Hostname: page-component-6766d58669-7cz98 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-05-15T18:15:05.179Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Autonomy-Representation Dilemma: Indigenous Groups and Distributive Benefits in the Americas

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 November 2021

Christopher L. Carter Open the ORCID record for Christopher L. Carter [Opens in a new window]
Christopher L. Carter*
Affiliation:
Harvard Academy for International and Area Studies, Cambridge, MA, USA
*
*Corresponding author. E-mail: christopher.carter@berkeley.edu
Get access

Abstract

Autonomy carries the promise of resolving longstanding distributive inequalities between indigenous and non-indigenous groups. Yet, contemporary autonomy arrangements have often been associated instead with a reduction in native communities' access to needed public goods and services. I situate these negative effects within a broader autonomy-representation dilemma: autonomy provides indigenous groups with more responsive coethnic leaders, but these leaders frequently face difficulties in collecting and deploying revenue. These capacity constraints often arise from the way national governments have recognized autonomy. As such, pursuing coethnic representation within the state might—under certain conditions—be more likely to provide indigenous groups with needed goods and services. Drawing on natural experimental evidence and an original survey of indigenous community presidents from Peru, I first demonstrate that achieving coethnic political representation within the state can expand indigenous groups' access to the public good they most need: water. I then illustrate how capacity constraints that arise from autonomy have prevented native groups in Bolivia's autonomous municipalities from achieving similar distributive gains. Ultimately, the findings provide insights for understanding the sources of—and potential institutional remedies for—indigenous groups' unequal access to local public goods in the Americas and beyond.

Keywords

indigenous politicsautonomydistributive politicsinterethnic inequalitydescriptive representation

Information

Type
Research Article
Information
Journal of Race, Ethnicity, and Politics , Volume 7 , Issue 2 , July 2022 , pp. 294 - 315
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of The Race, Ethnicity, and Politics Section of the American Political Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Acemoglu, D and Robinson, JA (2012) Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty. New York: Crown Publishing Group.Google Scholar
Albó, X (1991) El Retorno del Indio. Revista Andina 9, 299–366.Google Scholar
Albó, X (2008) Movimientos y Poder Indígena en Bolivia, Ecuador y Perú. CIPCA.Google Scholar
Alchon, SA (2002) Native Society and Disease in Colonial Ecuador. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Alesina, A, Baqir, R and Easterly, W (1999) Public goods and ethnic divisions. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 114, 1243–1284.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aliaga, C (2018) Autogobierno Indígena Originario Campesino Uru Chipaya priorizará el turismo.Google Scholar
Andolina, R (2003) The sovereign and its shadow: constituent assembly and indigenous movement in Ecuador. Journal of Latin American Studies 35, 721–750.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Aragón, F and Casas, C (2009) Local governments’ capacity and performance: evidence from Peruvian municipalities. Perspectivas 7, 89–113.Google Scholar
Augsburger, A and Haber, P (2018) Visions in conflict: state hegemony versus plurinationality in the construction of indigenous autonomy in Bolivia. Latin American and Caribbean Ethnic Studies 13, 135–156.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baldwin, K (2013) Why vote with the chief? Political connections and public goods provision in Zambia. American Journal of Political Science 57, 794–809.Google Scholar
Baldwin, K (2015) The Paradox of Traditional Chiefs in Democratic Africa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Benton, AL (2017) Configuring authority over electoral manipulation in electoral authoritarian regimes: evidence from Mexico. Democratization 24, 521–543.Google Scholar
Cameron, CM, Kelton, P and Swedlund, AC (2015) Beyond Germs: Native Depopulation in North America. Tucson: University of Arizona Press.Google Scholar
Carter, CL (2020) States of Extraction: The Emergence and Effects of Indigenous Autonomy in the Americas (Dissertation). UC Berkeley, Berkeley, CA.Google Scholar
Carter, CL (Forthcoming) The representational effects of communal property: evidence from Peru's indigenous groups. Comparative Political Studies.Google Scholar
Chandra, K (2006) What is ethnic identity and does it matter? Annual Review of Political Science 9, 397–424.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chattopadhyay, R and Duflo, E (2004) Women as policy makers: evidence from a randomized policy experiment in India. Econometrica 72, 1409–1443.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cibils, VF and Ter-Minassian, T (2015) Decentralizing Revenue in Latin America: Why and How. Washington, DC: Inter-American Development Bank.Google Scholar
Clow, RL (1987) The Indian reorganization act and the loss of tribal sovereignty: constitutions of the Rosebud and Pine Ridge reservations. Great Plains Quarterly 7, 125–134.Google Scholar
Collier, RB and Collier, D (2002) Shaping the Political Arena: Critical Junctures, the Labor Movement, and Regime Dynamics in Latin America. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.Google Scholar
Cook, ND (1998) Born to Die: Disease and New World Conquest, 1492–1650. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Cramb, RA and Wills, IR (1990) The role of traditional institutions in rural development: community-based land tenure and government land policy in Sarawak, Malaysia. World Development 18, 347–360.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dahl, RA (1982) Dilemmas of Pluralist Democracy: Autonomy Vs. Control. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Degregori, CI (1998) Ethnicity and democratic governability in Latin America: reflections from two central Andean countries. In Agüero, F and Stark, J (eds), Fault Lines of Democracy in Post-Transition Latin America. Coral Gables: North-South Center Press/University of Miami, pp. 203–227.Google Scholar
de Kadt, D and Larreguy, HA (2018) Agents of the regime? Traditional leaders and electoral politics in South Africa. The Journal of Politics 80, 382–399.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dell, M (2010) The persistent effects of Peru's mining mita. Econometrica 78, 1863–1903.Google Scholar
Díaz-Cayeros, A, Magaloni, B and Ruiz-Euler, A (2014) Traditional governance, citizen engagement, and local public goods: evidence from Mexico. World Development 53, 80–93.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Díaz-Polanco, H (1998) La Autonomía, Demanda Central de los Pueblos Indígenas: Significado e Implicaciones. In Alta, V, Iturralde, D and López Bassola, M (eds), Pueblos Indígenas y Estado En América Latina. Quito: Editorial Abya Yala, pp. 213–220.Google Scholar
Dippel, C (2016) Forced coexistence and economic development: evidence from native American reservations. In Anderson, TL (ed.), Unlocking the Wealth of Indian Nations. Lanham: Lexington Books, pp. 160–195.Google Scholar
Dubertret, F and Alden Wily, L (2015) Percent of indigenous and community lands. Data file from LandMark: The Global Platform of Indigenous and Community Lands. Available at: www.landmarkmap.org.Google Scholar
Dunning, T and Nilekani, J (2013) Ethnic quotas and political mobilization: caste, parties, and distribution in Indian village councils. American Political Science Review 107, 35–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eisenstadt, TA (2007) Usos y Costumbres and Postelectoral conflicts in Oaxaca, Mexico, 1995–2004: an empirical and normative assessment. Latin American Research Review 42, 52–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Eisenstadt, TA (2011) Politics, Identity, and Mexico's Indigenous Rights Movements. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Engerman, SL and Sokoloff, KL (2012) Economic Development in the Americas Since 1500: Endowments and Institutions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Evans, LE (2011) Expertise and scale of conflict: governments as advocates in American Indian politics. American Political Science Review 105, 663–682.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Faguet, J-P (2011) Decentralization and Governance. SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 1892149, Social Science Research Network, Rochester, NY.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Falleti, TG (2005) A sequential theory of decentralization: Latin American cases in comparative perspective. American Political Science Review 99, 327–346.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frye, D and Parker, DP (2016) Paternalism versus sovereignty: the long-run economic effects of the Indian reorganization Act. In Anderson, TL (ed.), Unlocking the Wealth of Indian Nations. Lanham: Lexington Books, pp. 224–244.Google Scholar
Fuentes Cordoba, G (2019) Does the recognition of indigenous territories impact household economic situations? Evidence from western Panama. Journal of Comparative Economics 47, 225–237.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
González, M (2015) Indigenous territorial autonomy in Latin America: an overview. Latin American and Caribbean Ethnic Studies 10, 10–36.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grieshaber, EP (1980) Survival of Indian communities in nineteenth-century Bolivia: a regional comparison. Journal of Latin American Studies 12, 223–269.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Grossman, G, Gazal-Ayal, O, Pimentel, SD and Weinstein, JM (2016) Descriptive representation and judicial outcomes in multiethnic societies. American Journal of Political Science 60, 44–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Guarachi Huanca, P (2016) ¿Por qué perdió el “Sí” en Totora Marka? Andamios 1(1), 81–94.Google Scholar
Habyarimana, J, Humphreys, M, Posner, DN and Weinstein, JM (2009) Coethnicity: Diversity and the Dilemmas of Collective Action. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.Google Scholar
Huenchulaf Cayuqueo, M (1998) La Temática Indígena en el Concierto Internacional. In Alta, V, Iturralde, DA and López-Bassols, MA (eds), Pueblos Indígenas Y Estado En América Latina. Quito: Editorial Abya-Yala, pp. 147–159.Google Scholar
Instituto Nacional de Estadística e Informática (2011) Encuesta Nacional de Hogares. Dataset downloaded from http://iinei.inei.gob.pe/microdatos/ on August 14, 2018.Google Scholar
Instituto Nacional de Estadística e Informática (2014) IV Censo Nacional Agropecuario. Dataset downloaded from http://iinei.inei.gob.pe/microdatos/ on September 13, 2018.Google Scholar
Jackson, JE and Warren, KB (2005) Indigenous movements in Latin America, 1992–2004: controversies, ironies, New directions. Annual Review of Anthropology 34, 549–573.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Koter, D (2013) King makers: local leaders and ethnic politics in Africa. World Politics 65, 187–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Magaloni, B, Díaz-Cayeros, A and Ruiz Euler, A (2019) Public good provision and traditional governance in indigenous communities in Oaxaca, Mexico. Comparative Political Studies, 1841–1880.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mahoney, J (2010) Colonialism and Postcolonial Development: Spanish America in Comparative Perspective. Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mendoza, RR (2002) Legislación Peruana sobre Comunidades Campesinas. Lima: UNMSM.Google Scholar
Miller, N (1968) The political survival of traditional leadership. Journal of Modern African Studies 6, 183–198.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas Públicas (2020) Presupuesto General del Estado. Data accessed from https://jubileobolivia.com/presupuestos/ on December 5, 2018.Google Scholar
Mollinedo, S and Miguel, M (2017) Análisis del estatuto autonómico indígena originario de la nación Uru Chipaya*. Revista Jurídica Derecho 6, 137–152.Google Scholar
Morell i Torra, P (2015) La (difícil) construcción de autonomías indígenas en el Estado plurinacional de Bolivia: consideraciones generales y una aproximación al caso de la autonomia Guaraní Charagua Iyambae. Revista d'estudis autonòmics i federals, Num. 22, 94–135.Google Scholar
OECD (2018) OECD Development Pathways Multi-Dimensional Review of Panama Volume 2: In-Depth Analysis and Recommendations. Paris: OECD Publishing.Google Scholar
Postero, N (2017) The Indigenous State: Race, Politics, and Performance in Plurinational Bolivia. Oakland: Univ of California Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Postero, N and Tockman, J (2020) Self-governance in Bolivia's first indigenous autonomy: Charagua. Latin American Research Review 55, 1–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Postero, NG and Zamosc, L (2004) The Struggle for Indigenous Rights in Latin America. Brighton: Sussex Academic Press.Google Scholar
Puerta, JM, Maciel, O, Soriano, A, García, JF, Maqueda, S, Mortara, A and Soares, T (2020) Evaluación del Programa de País: Panamá 2015–2019. Technical report, Inter-American Development Bank.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rice, R (2012) The New Politics of Protest: Indigenous Mobilization in Latin America's Neoliberal Era. Tucson: University of Arizona Press.Google Scholar
Rojas Paz, L (2018) El municipio Uru Chipaya adopta condición de autonomía indígena. Página Siete.Google Scholar
Rousseau, S and Manrique, H (2019) La autonomía indígena “tutelada” en Bolivia. Bulletin de l'Institut français d’études andines 48, 1–19.Google Scholar
Shotts, KW (2003) Does racial redistricting cause conservative policy outcomes? Policy preferences of southern representatives in the 1980s and 1990s. The Journal of Politics 65, 216–226.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Stauffer, C (2018) Native peoples sour on Morales, Bolivia's first indigenous president. Reuters.Google Scholar
Stavenhagen, R (2000) Towards the right to autonomy in Mexico. In Burguete Cal y Mayor, , Aracely (ed.), Indigenous Autonomy in Mexico. Copenhagen: IWGIA, pp. 10–23.Google Scholar
Stern, SJ (1993) Peru's Indian Peoples and the Challenge of Spanish Conquest: Huamanga to 1640. Madison: Univ of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
Tajfel, H and Turner, J (2001) An integrative theory of intergroup conflict. In Hogg, MA and Abrams, D (eds), Intergroup Relations: Essential Readings, Key Readings in Social Psychology. New York, NY, USA: Psychology Press, pp. 94–109.Google Scholar
Taylor, GD (1980) The New Deal and American Indian Tribalism: The Administration of the Indian Reorganization Act, 1934–45. Lincoln: U of Nebraska Press.Google Scholar
Tockman, J (2017) The hegemony of representation: democracy and indigenous self-government in Bolivia. Journal of Politics in Latin America 9, 121–138.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tockman, J and Cameron, J (2014) Indigenous autonomy and the contradictions of plurinationalism in Bolivia. Latin American Politics and Society 56, 46–69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tockman, J, Cameron, J and Plata, W (2015) New institutions of indigenous self-governance in Bolivia: between autonomy and self-discipline. Latin American and Caribbean Ethnic Studies 10, 37–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vakis, R and Lindert, K (2000) Poverty in indigenous populations in Panama: a study using LSMS data. In The World Bank Panama Poverty Assessment: Priorities and Strategies for Poverty Reduction. Washington, DC: World Bank Publications, pp. 1–44.Google Scholar
Van Cott, DL (2001) Explaining ethnic autonomy regimes in Latin America. Studies in Comparative International Development 35, 30–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Van der Windt, P, Humphreys, M, Medina, L, Timmons, JF and Voors, M (2018) Citizen attitudes toward traditional and state authorities: substitutes or complements? Comparative Political Studies, 1810–1840.Google Scholar
World Bank Group (2015) Indigenous Latin America in the Twenty-First Century: The First Decade. Technical Report 98544, The World Bank.Google Scholar
Yashar, DJ (1998) Contesting citizenship: indigenous movements and democracy in Latin America. Comparative Politics 31, 23–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yashar, DJ (2005) Contesting Citizenship in Latin America: The Rise of Indigenous Movements and the Postliberal Challenge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Supplementary material: PDF

Carter supplementary material

Carter supplementary material

Download Carter supplementary material(PDF)
PDF 388.8 KB