Introduction
Adversity in childhood, such as parental divorce and sexual abuse, predicts increased risk of affective disorders, suicidal ideation and completed suicide in adolescence and early adulthood (Fergusson et al. Reference Fergusson, Woodward and Horwood2000; Agerbo et al. Reference Agerbo, Nordentoft and Mortensen2002). Exposure to adversity can interact with genetic factors and result in altered hormonal responses to subsequent stressful life events and may have long-term consequences across the lifecourse (Bradley et al. Reference Bradley, Binder, Epstein, Tang, Nair, Liu, Gillespie, Berg, Evces, Newport, Stowe, Heim, Nemeroff, Schwartz, Cubells and Ressler2008; McGowan et al. Reference McGowan, Sasaki, D'Alessio, Dymov, Labonté, Szyf, Turecki and Meaney2009; Hornung & Heim, Reference Hornung and Heim2014). It is unknown whether the association of childhood adversity and suicidal ideation extends into midlife although cross-sectional studies show associations of retrospectively recalled childhood adversity and suicide in adulthood (Dube et al. Reference Dube, Anda, Felitti, Chapman, Williamson and Giles2001; Bifulco et al. Reference Bifulco, Moran, Baines, Bunn and Stanford2002; Fanous et al. Reference Fanous, Prescott and Kendler2004; Corcoran et al. Reference Corcoran, Gallagher, Keeley, Arensman and Perry2006; Enns et al. Reference Enns, Cox, Afifi, de Graaf, Ten Have and Sareen2006; Fairweather et al. Reference Fairweather, Anstey, Rodgers, Jorm and Christensen2007; Heider et al. Reference Heider, Bernert, Matschinger, Haro, Alonso and Angermeyer2007; Afifi et al. Reference Afifi, Enns, Cox, Asmundson, Stein and Sareen2008) and sexual and physical abuse in childhood (Fanous et al. Reference Fanous, Prescott and Kendler2004; Ystgaard et al. Reference Ystgaard, Hestetun, Loeb and Mehlum2004). In this context, retrospective recall of childhood adversity has been found to be biased by contemporaneous adult mental ill-health (Colman et al. Reference Colman, Kingsbury, Garad, Zeng, Naicker, Patten, Jones, Wild and Thompson2016).
Little is known of potential pathways between childhood adversity and adult suicidal ideation but pathways via adult affective disorders may be relevant. The association of childhood adversity with adult suicidal ideation may be mediated through early onset of psychopathology (Fanous et al. Reference Fanous, Prescott and Kendler2004). Early-onset psychopathology is associated with increased risk of psychopathology in adulthood (Clark et al. Reference Clark, Rodgers, Caldwell, Power and Stansfeld2007) and repeated internalizing disorders in childhood are associated with greatly increased risk of further psychopathology across the lifecourse and hence with suicidal ideation (Colman et al. Reference Colman, Wadsworth, Croudace and Jones2007). Alternatively, the association of childhood adversity with adult suicidal ideation may be mediated through increased exposure to life events in adulthood (Fergusson et al. Reference Fergusson, Woodward and Horwood2000), where early adversity exposure predicts adulthood adversity exposure either through trajectories of social disadvantage (Graham & Power, Reference Graham and Power2004) or through selection of adverse environments (Kendler & Eaves, Reference Kendler and Eaves1986).
Kendler's developmental model for major depression in women (Kendler et al. Reference Kendler, Gardner and Prescott2002) and men (Kendler et al. Reference Kendler, Gardner and Prescott2006) includes three broad pathways: through the development of internalizing disorders, externalizing disorders, and adult interpersonal difficulties (adult adversity). This developmental model tested on twin samples has been innovative, integrating the multifactorial aetiology of adult depression, incorporating both genetic and environmental influences. The model explains a large proportion of the variance in the liability for adult depressive episodes in women (52%) and men (49%). The final model was very similar in women and men. In all, 18 predictor variables were organized across five tiers: childhood (genetic risk, disturbed family environment, sexual abuse, parental loss); early adolescence (neuroticism, self-esteem, anxiety and conduct disorder); late adolescence (educational attainment, lifetime traumas, social support, substance misuse); adulthood (divorce, history of major depression); and last year (marital problems, independent/dependent life events) (Kendler et al. Reference Kendler, Gardner and Prescott2002). Neuroticism and early-onset anxiety disorders were the most powerful influences in the internalizing pathway, with conduct disorder and substance misuse being most powerful in the externalizing pathway. The adult interpersonal difficulty pathway was more complex: childhood adversity influenced low educational attainment, lifetime trauma and low social support. The authors comment that ‘many of the depressogenic consequences of the earlier adversities appear to be in the realm of troubled interpersonal relationships’ (Kendler et al. Reference Kendler, Gardner and Prescott2002).
We examined these three pathways for the associations between childhood adversity at 7, 11 and 16 years and suicidal ideation at 45 years in participants from the British National Childhood Development Study (1958 Birth Cohort). We hypothesized that: (1) childhood adversity predicts suicidal ideation at midlife; and (2) the association of childhood adversity and suicidal ideation is partially mediated through (a) internalizing disorders in childhood, (b) externalizing disorders in childhood and (c) increased exposure to life events and interpersonal difficulties in adulthood.
Method
Setting
Data were from the 1958 British Birth Cohort, a study of 98% of births in England, Scotland and Wales during 1 week in 1958 (n = 17 416). Analyses were based on 9377 participants in a clinical survey at 45 years. The response rate for the clinical survey was 78% of those invited, representing 54% of the surviving population (Power & Elliott, Reference Power and Elliott2006). Information was available from parents and schools at ages 7, 11 and 16 years and by participant interviews at ages 7, 11, 16, 23, 33 and 42 years. Ethical approval for the survey was given by the South East Multi-Centre Research Ethics Committee: informed consent was obtained. The authors assert that all procedures contributing to this work comply with the ethical standards of the relevant national and international committees on human experimentation and with the Helsinki Declaration of 1975, as revised in 2008.
Measures
Midlife suicidal ideation
Two measures captured suicidal ideation in midlife: depressive ideas and a single-item measure on whether life is worth living. Depressive ideas were assessed using the Revised Clinical Interview Schedule (CIS-R) (Lewis et al. Reference Lewis, Pelosi, Araya and Dunn1992), administered by a trained research nurse using computer-assisted personal interviewing in the home-based clinical examination at 45 years. The CIS-R measures International Classification of Diseases, tenth edition (ICD-10) affective and anxiety diagnoses in the past week. Two measures of suicidal ideation were derived from CIS-R data. A ‘depressive ideas’ scale in the past 7 days was formed by summing affirmative answers to the following questions: ‘Have you on at least one occasion felt guilty or blamed yourself when it hasn't been your fault?’; ‘During the past week have you been feeling you are not as good as other people?’; ‘During the past week have you felt hopeless about your future?’; ‘In the past week have you felt that life isn't worth living?’; In the past week have you thought of killing yourself?’. This five-point scale is dichotomized at ⩾2 to indicate a clinically significant level of depressive ideas based on CIS-R scoring protocols (Lewis et al. Reference Lewis, Pelosi, Araya and Dunn1992). A single item from this scale was also examined as an outcome: ‘In the past week have you felt that life is not worth living?’ – analysed as a dichotomous outcome.
Childhood adversity
Childhood adversity was defined as exposure to traumatic events or chronic stressors (Tiet et al. Reference Tiet, Bird, Davies, Hoven, Cohen, Jensen and Goodman1998). Prospectively assessed measures of childhood adversity were available from data collected at 7, 11 and 16 years from the cohort member, their parent (usually the mother), the interviewer, the school/teacher and medical examination. These items are detailed elsewhere (Clark et al. Reference Clark, Caldwell, Power and Stansfeld2010), but in brief:
-
Illness relates to any mental or physical illness within the child's household at 7, 11 or 16 years;
-
Neglected appearance: medical report of the child having an underfed/neglected appearance at 7 and/or 11 years;
-
Maternal absence: any report of the child not living with their natural mother at 7, 11 and/or 16 years, through death, divorce, separation, illegitimacy or being in institutional care;
-
Paternal absence similarly reported the father's absence;
-
In care: the child having been in care at 7, 11 and/or 16 years;
-
Parental divorce: at 33 years participants reported parental divorce by 16 years;
-
Physical abuse by a parent (‘I was physically abused by a parent – punched, kicked, hit, or beaten with an object or needed medical treatment’);
-
Sexual abuse by a parent (‘I was sexually abused by a parent’).
Physical abuse and sexual abuse were ascertained from retrospective report at 45 years (Rosenman & Rodgers, Reference Rosenman and Rodgers2004) as these data were not collected prospectively. These types of adversity are difficult to assess prospectively because children often do not report abuse at the time because of shame and adult coercion. A measure of cumulative adversity counted the reports of neglected appearance, in care, parental divorce, parental physical abuse, parental sexual abuse, and maternal and paternal absence (0, 1, 2, 3 or more): the latter two adversities were only included if parental divorce and being in care were not reported (see Clark et al. Reference Clark, Caldwell, Power and Stansfeld2010). This cumulative measure attempts to account for exposure to multiple adversities across childhood.
Childhood internalizing and externalizing disorders
Internalizing and externalizing problems at 16 years were measured using the teacher version of the Rutter scales (Rutter, Reference Rutter1967; Elander & Rutter, Reference Elander and Rutter1996). Two scales were formed by summing and square root transforming the items ‘worries’, ‘solitary’, ‘miserable’, ‘fearful’ and ‘fussy’ for internalizing problems and ‘destructive’, ‘fights’, ‘not much liked by other children’, irritable’, ‘disobedient’, ‘lies’, ‘steals’, ‘resentful/aggressive’ and ‘bullies’ for externalizing problems. A score in the top 13% was defined as internalizing and externalizing disorders, the lowest 50% were not a case, and the remainder were borderline based on earlier studies (Ghodsian, Reference Ghodsian and Fogelman1983; Clark et al. Reference Clark, Rodgers, Caldwell, Power and Stansfeld2007). These scales have demonstrated reliability in this cohort (Cronbach's α for internalizing problems scale = 0.66, n = 7225; Cronbach's α for externalizing problems scale = 0.88, n = 7179) (Clark et al. Reference Clark, Rodgers, Caldwell, Power and Stansfeld2007).
Adult stressors and interpersonal difficulties
Recent life events
At 45 years 13 questions from the Australian Personality and Total Health (PATH) Study (Windsor et al. Reference Windsor, Anstey, Butterworth and Rodgers2008) measured serious illnesses and death within the family, relationship problems, work problems, unemployment, financial problems and legal/police problems. Responses were ‘yes’ or ‘no’. A sum of the number of life events in the past 6 months was coded as 0 or ⩾1. More detailed classification of life events in the last 6 months was not possible because of the small numbers of events. Social support was assessed by a question at 42 years where participants indicated whether they had someone they could turn to for advice/support (yes/no).
Lifecourse unemployment
A count of times the participant had been unemployed (having no employment as opposed to undertaking other non-working activities such as homemaking) from 16 to 42 years was calculated from the activity histories available from 1974 to 2009 (Hancock et al. Reference Hancock, Elliott, Johnson and Bukodi2011a ). This variable was coded as 0, 1, 2 or 3 or more periods of unemployment.
Lifecourse partnerships
A count of the number of separations from a cohabiting partnership from 16 to 42 years was derived from the partnership histories for the period 1974–2008 available for the cohort (Hancock et al. Reference Hancock, Elliott, Johnson and Bukodi2011b ). This variable was coded as 0 or 1 v. 2 or more separations.
Problem drinking
Problem drinking was included as an indicator of adult externalizing behaviours. A dichotomous variable was derived indicating problem drinking in the past year at 33 or 42 years as indicated by affirmative responses to two or more of the CAGE items (Cutting down, Annoyance by criticism, Guilty feeling, and Eye-openers) (Mayfield et al. Reference Mayfield, McLeod and Hall1974): ‘They felt they should cut down’; ‘People annoyed them by criticizing their drinking’; ‘They felt bad or guilty about their drinking’; and ‘They drank in the morning to get rid of a hangover’.
Long-standing illness
At 42 years participants indicated if they had ‘any long-standing illness, disability or infirmity’, coded as yes v. no.
Socio-economic position and educational qualifications
Adult social position was based on current/most recent occupation at 42 years and categorized using the British Registrar General classification (Office of Population Censuses and Surveys, 1980) as: ‘I and II’, professional/managerial/technical; ‘IIINM’, other non-manual; ‘IIIM’, skilled manual; and ‘IV and V’, unskilled manual. The same measure was available for the participant's father at birth: children with an absent father at birth were coded as ‘IV and V’. This classification was also available for the participant's father at birth (Stansfeld et al. Reference Stansfeld, Clark, Rodgers, Caldwell and Power2008). Qualifications were reported at 33 years, categorized as none, ‘O’ levels, and ‘A’ levels or higher.
Statistical analysis
Analyses were carried out using STATA (version 13; StataCorp LP, USA).
Imputation
Multiple imputation, under the ‘missing at random’ assumption, was used to address the issue of missing data, using the ICE program in STATA. The measures described above were included in the imputation equations. Employment status at 45 years, and social class at 7 and 42 years were also included as they were significantly associated with attrition (Atherton et al. Reference Atherton, Fuller, Shepherd, Strachan and Power2008). Missing data on the variables ranged from 0 to 20%, except for externalizing disorders at 16 years (22.9%), illness in the family (26.2%), in care (38.9%) and neglect (56.1%) (Table 1). All participants except 1245 who had died by 45 years were included in the imputation, but analyses in this paper are restricted to participants in the 45-year study (n = 9377). A total of 30 datasets of the imputation were run and analyses indicated that the measures were stable across the imputations. Parameter estimates from the 30 imputations were estimated using the MIM function in STATA. Imputed analyses are presented with unimputed prevalence figures.
Unimputed frequencies and percentages for the key variables in the analyses
CAGE, Cutting down, Annoyance by criticism, Guilty feeling, and Eye-openers; nm, non-manual; m, manual.
a The percentages are given out of 9377 for each variable: this will underestimate the prevalence for variables with large amounts of missing data, as missing data are included in the total percentage out of 9377.
b Retrospectively reported at 45 years.
Modelling
Initial logistic regression analyses, adjusting for gender, qualifications at 33 years and social position at 42 years, examined the strength of the associations between each childhood adversity measure and suicidal ideation at 45 years.
A series of logistic regression analyses were then run to test the hypothesized pathways between each of the childhood adversity measures and suicidal ideation. First, to establish whether the associations of the childhood adversity with suicidal ideation were partially mediated through internalizing and externalizing disorders, we conducted logistic regression analyses of the associations of the childhood adversities on internalizing and externalizing disorders at 16 years adjusted for gender and social class at birth. We conducted logistic regression analyses to establish whether the association of childhood adversity with suicidal ideation is through increased exposure to life events. In order to do this we examined the associations of each childhood adversity measure with recent life events at 45 years, adjusting for gender, qualifications at 33 years, and social position at 42 years.
Further logistic regression analyses assessed the associations of: (i) interpersonal difficulties (the number of partnerships, number of periods unemployed, lack of emotional support at 42 years, long-standing illness at 42 years); and (ii) adult drinking problems (at 33 or 42 years) with midlife suicidal ideation, adjusting for gender, social class at 42 years and qualifications at 33 years. Finally, the associations between childhood adversities and suicidal ideation were re-run, additionally adjusting for (a) internalizing and externalizing disorders at 16 years and (b) the adulthood life events and interpersonal difficulties.
Estimated causal mediation of the associations between each childhood adversity measure and midlife suicidal ideation by: (i) internalizing disorders; (ii) externalizing disorders; or (iii) interpersonal difficulties and problem drinking was investigated using the medeff package (Hicks & Tingley, Reference Hicks and Tingley2011). We applied 200 bootstrapping replications, to each imputed dataset separately using 2000 simulations in each to approximate the quasi-Bayesian uncertainty parameter estimate; causal mediation estimates were then combined using Rubin's rules (Rubin, Reference Rubin1987). At present mediation can only be examined easily for binary and continuous variables, so mediation analyses are not presented for the multinomial cumulative childhood adversity measure.
All analyses tested for interactions between childhood adversity and gender: analyses were stratified by gender if the interaction was significant (p < 0.05) and adjusted for gender where not significant (p ⩾ 0.05).
Results
Descriptives
Table 1 shows the unimputed frequencies for the key variables. At 45 years, 2.0% had felt that life was not worth living in the past week and 7.2% scored 2 or more on the depressive ideas scale.
Childhood adversities association with suicidal ideation
Table 2 shows the odds ratios (ORs) for suicidal ideation at 45 years, for each childhood adversity adjusted for gender, qualifications at 33 years and social class at 42 years. All the childhood adversities, except maternal absence, were significantly associated with increased odds of depressive ideas. Physical abuse by a parent and sexual abuse by a parent were associated with a 3-fold increased odds of reporting depressive ideas. All of the childhood adversities were significantly associated with increased odds of feeling life is not worth living in the past week, except maternal absence and neglected appearance. There was an interaction by gender for the effect of divorce of parents on having felt life not worth living in the past week, with an association for males [adjusted OR (AOR) 2.94, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.68–5.13] but not females. The odds of suicidal ideation increased with the number of childhood adversities reported.
Increase in risk for (a) suicidal ideation and depressive ideas at 45 years, (b) recent life events and (c) psychological ill health at 16 years, for the presence of each individual adversity/maltreatment a
Data are given as adjusted odds ratio (95% confidence interval).
a Suicidal ideation and recent life events models adjusted for social class at 42 years, qualifications at 33 years, and gender. Psychological ill health at 16 years model adjusted for gender and social class at 7 years.
b Reported at 33 years.
c Reported at 45 years.
d Measure of adversity only counts absent mother and absent father if being in care and divorce are not present; also does not include illness as this is too frequent. All measures are prospective (measured in childhood) except divorce of parents by age 16 years, parental physical abuse and parental sexual abuse. In all analyses the reference group is no exposure to the adversity or 0 for the cumulative adversity measure.
* p ⩽ 0.05, ** p ⩽ 0.01, *** p ⩽ 0.001.
No significant gender interactions were observed with the following exceptions: † p = 0.032; †† p = 0.004.
Childhood adversities and recent life events at 45 years
Table 2 shows the AORs of reporting any recent life event at 45 years for each childhood adversity measure. Associations were observed between illness in the household, being in care, divorce by age 16 years, physical abuse and sexual abuse on recent life events at 45 years. The cumulative number of childhood adversities reported was only associated with recent life events for females, with two adversities or three or more adversities significantly increasing the odds for recent life events (AOR 1.31, 95% CI 1.03–1.66; AOR 1.80 95% CI 1.42–2.28, respectively).
Childhood adversities and psychological distress at 16 years
After adjustment for gender and social class at birth, all the childhood adversities were associated with externalizing and internalizing problems at 16 years (Table 2). As associations were similar for the two measures at 16 years, further analyses combined ‘any externalizing or internalizing problems at 16 years’ (yes/no). All childhood adversities were associated with psychological distress at 16 years, the strength of the association increasing as the number of adversities increased.
Adulthood stressors and midlife suicidal ideation
Table 3 shows that all the adulthood stressors were significantly associated with suicidal ideation at 45 years; cohabiting partnership separations, periods of unemployment, problem drinking and long-standing illness increased the odds of depressive ideas around 1.5- to 2-fold. Low emotional support only increased the odds of depressive ideas for females.
Increase in odds for suicidal ideation and depressive ideas at 45 years, for no. of partnerships, no. of periods unemployed, drinking problems at 33 or 42 years, lack of emotional support at 42 years, long-standing illness at 42 years, internalizing problems and externalizing problems at 16 years a
Data are given as adjusted odds ratio (95% confidence interval).
CAGE, Cutting down, Annoyance by criticism, Guilty feeling, and Eye-openers.
a Adult stressors model adjusted for gender, social class at 42 years, and qualifications at 33 years. Psychological ill health at 16 years model adjusted for gender and social class at 7 years.
* p ⩽ 0.05, **p ⩽ 0.01, ***p ⩽ 0.001.
†b Gender interaction p = 0.042, †c gender interaction p = 0.034, †d gender interaction p = 0.018.
Internalizing and externalizing disorders as mediating factors
Table 4 shows that after adjustment for any internalizing or externalizing disorder at 16 years and the adulthood stressors, illness in the household, paternal absence, divorce by 16 years, physical abuse, sexual abuse and the cumulative number of adversities remained significantly associated with suicidal ideation. Psychological distress at 16 years mediated these associations by 1.80 to 5.57%. Adulthood problem drinking mediated these associations by 1.75 to 9.22%. Table 4 also shows that after adjustment for the adulthood stressors and psychological distress at 16 years, physical abuse, sexual abuse and the cumulative number of adversities remained significantly associated with depressive ideas at 45 years. Psychological distress at 16 years mediated these associations by 3.41% for physical abuse and 4.99% for sexual abuse. Problem drinking mediated these associations by 2.80% for physical abuse and 6.37% for sexual abuse.
Adjusted odds ratios (AORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) with supporting mediation effect showing the increase in odds for suicidal ideation and depressive ideas at 45 years, for each increase in the number of reports of the adversities a
a Adjusted for gender, social class at 42 years, qualifications at 33 years, life events at 45 years, number of partnerships in adulthood, number of periods of unemployment in adulthood, emotional support at 42 years, problem drinking at either 33 or 42 years, and long-standing illness at 42 years and psychological distress at 16 years (any internalizing or externalizing at 16 years).
b Reported at 33 years.
c Reported at 45 years.
* p ⩽ 0.05, ** p ⩽ 0.01, *** p ⩽ 0.001.
Adult life events and interpersonal difficulties as mediating factors
Table 5 shows the indirect percentage of the total mediation effect of the associations by life events: the associations of childhood adversities with depressive ideas were mediated by 5.59% for illness in the household, 11.79% for physical abuse, and 8.16% for sexual abuse. Cohabiting partnership separations mediated these associations by 2.97% for physical abuse and 2.73% for sexual abuse: the association between illness in the household and depressive ideas was suppressed by cohabiting partnership separations, but only marginally (−0.88%). The total percentage of mediation of the associations with feeling that life is not worth living by life events ranged from 1.55% for illness in the household to 9.59% for physical abuse. The indirect percentage of the mediation effect of these associations by cohabiting partnership separations ranged from 1.27 for paternal absence to 5.22% for physical abuse. Again, the association between illness in the household and suicidal ideation was marginally suppressed by cohabiting partnership separations (−0.50%).
Adjusted odds ratios (AORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) with supporting mediation effect showing the increase in odds for suicidal ideation and depressive ideas at 45 years, for each childhood adversity a
a Adjusted for gender, social class at 42 years, qualifications at 33 years, life events at 45 years, number of partnerships in adulthood, number of periods of unemployment in adulthood, emotional support at 42 years, problem drinking at 33 or 42 years, long-standing illness at 42 years and psychological distress at 16 years (any internalizing or externalizing at 16 years).
b Reported at 33 years.
c Reported at 45 years.
* p ⩽ 0.05, ** p ⩽ 0.01, *** p ⩽ 0.001.
We created a combined score describing overall adversity in adulthood. The sum of the dichotomous adversity measures included: number of partnerships, number of periods unemployed, drinking problems at 33 or 42 years, lack of emotional support at 42 years and long-standing illness at 42 years. We adjusted analyses for gender, social class at 42 years and qualifications at 33 years (AOR for life not worth living: cumulative adversity, one adversity AOR 1.75, 95% CI 1.08–2.84; two adversities AOR 2.39, 95% CI 1.42–4.02; three or more adversities AOR 3.79, 95% CI 2.33–6.15; AOR for depressive thoughts: one adversity AOR 1.36, 95% CI 1.05–1.76; two adversities AOR 1.44, 95% CI 1.08–1.92; three or more adversities AOR 1.94, 95% CI 1.47–2.56).
We carried out analyses to examine how much this adult adversity score might mediate the association between childhood adversity and suicidal ideation. The indirect percentage of the total mediation effect was between 3.28 and 8.63 for feeling that life was not worth living and between 7.86 and 8.67 for depressive ideas. The percentage of mediation explained was of little greater magnitude than the individual life events and interpersonal difficulties (see Supplementary Table).
Discussion
The aims of our study were to assess whether the effects of childhood adversity on suicidal ideation extended beyond adolescence to midlife and whether this was partially mediated by adolescent internalizing disorders, externalizing disorders and adult exposure to life events and interpersonal difficulties. We confirmed that specific childhood adversities which included illness in the household, paternal absence and divorce prospectively predict suicidal ideation at 45 years even after adjustment for confounding and mediating factors. Retrospectively recalled parental sexual and physical abuse also show strong associations with suicidal ideation at 45 years. Childhood adversity predicts adult life events, supporting continuity of exposure to adversity across the lifecourse. Adulthood interpersonal difficulties predicted suicidal ideation.
In terms of investigation of mediation, psychological ill-health in childhood partially mediated the association of illness in the household, paternal absence and physical and sexual abuse. Adult life events partially mediated the association of paternal absence, divorce and physical and sexual abuse, while partnerships in adulthood and problem drinking partially mediated the association of sexual and physical abuse. We have confirmed our hypotheses that some childhood adversities are associated with midlife suicidal ideation and that this is partly mediated by subsequent life events, internalizing and externalizing disorders, although the variance explained in mediation is small. Our findings support Kendler's aetiological framework for affective disorders (Kendler et al. Reference Kendler, Gardner and Prescott2002, Reference Kendler, Gardner and Prescott2006).
Studies of youth suicide have demonstrated the importance of parent-related events in the family such as parental hospital admission with mental illness, parental divorce and marital disruption (Fergusson et al. Reference Fergusson, Woodward and Horwood2000) as risk factors. We found that these risks persist into adulthood in our study, as in other studies (Agerbo et al. Reference Agerbo, Nordentoft and Mortensen2002). The predictive power of parental illness in the household may partially represent genetic transmission of mental illness susceptibility from parent to child as well as the environmental influence of having a sick parent on the child. Early onset of psychopathology, possibly brought forward by adversity, may develop into clinical psychiatric disorder (Clark et al. Reference Clark, Rodgers, Caldwell, Power and Stansfeld2007) that persists into adult life perpetuating suicidal risk (Fergusson et al. Reference Fergusson, Woodward and Horwood2000; Dube et al. Reference Dube, Anda, Felitti, Chapman, Williamson and Giles2001; Fanous et al. Reference Fanous, Prescott and Kendler2004). Adolescent internalizing disorder and adult suicidal ideation have also been linked in another British cohort study (Colman et al. Reference Colman, Wadsworth, Croudace and Jones2007) and adolescent depression and adult psychopathology have been found to be mediating factors for childhood adversity and adult suicidal ideation in the follow-up of the Isle of Wight Study (Pickles et al. Reference Pickles, Aglan, Collishaw, Messer, Rutter and Maughan2010). Anxiousness and disruptiveness are also mediating factors for childhood adversity and suicidal attempts in young adults (Wanner et al. Reference Wanner, Vitaro, Tremblay and Turecki2012). Altogether, lifecourse persistent psychopathology beginning in adolescence seems a key pathway for midlife suicidal ideation.
In terms of other types of childhood adversity sexual (Fergusson et al. Reference Fergusson, Woodward and Horwood2000; Fanous et al. Reference Fanous, Prescott and Kendler2004; Ystgaard et al. Reference Ystgaard, Hestetun, Loeb and Mehlum2004; Afifi et al. Reference Afifi, Enns, Cox, Asmundson, Stein and Sareen2008) and physical abuse (Ystgaard et al. Reference Ystgaard, Hestetun, Loeb and Mehlum2004; Enns et al. Reference Enns, Cox, Afifi, de Graaf, Ten Have and Sareen2006; Bruwer et al. Reference Bruwer, Govender, Bishop, Williams, Stein and Seedat2014; Harford et al. Reference Harford, Yia and Grant2014) have been associated with suicidal ideation, attempts and completed suicide (Séguin et al. Reference Séguin, Lesage, Turecki, Bouchard, Chawky, Tremblay, Daigle and Guy2007). Life events in childhood (Fergusson et al. Reference Fergusson, Woodward and Horwood2000) and adulthood, including divorce in adulthood (Dennis et al. Reference Dennis, Baillon, Brugha, Lindesay, Stewart and Meltzer2007), are associated with increased risk of suicidal ideation. Interpersonal difficulties in adolescence predict suicidal attempts in young adulthood (Johnson et al. Reference Johnson, Cohen, Gould, Kasen, Brown and Brook2002). Exposure to childhood adversity is related to increased exposure to midlife events. And, as in our study, there is evidence that self-reported alcohol dependence, an example of externalizing behaviour, partially mediates the effect of sexual and physical abuse (Dube et al. Reference Dube, Anda, Felitti, Chapman, Williamson and Giles2001).
Lack of maternal and paternal care has been linked to adult suicidal ideation (Enns et al. Reference Enns, Cox, Afifi, de Graaf, Ten Have and Sareen2006; Heider et al. Reference Heider, Bernert, Matschinger, Haro, Alonso and Angermeyer2007), although we found only an unexpected association with paternal absence, as other studies have found associations with maternal absence, although maternal absence was rare in our population. In this instance the CIs around the estimate will be wide because of the rarity of maternal absence rather than the nature of the effect itself. Despite adjustment for social class and educational attainment some of the effects of paternal absence and divorce on midlife suicidal ideation might relate to financial disadvantage as a consequence of these events in childhood. Bifulco et al. (Reference Bifulco, Moran, Baines, Bunn and Stanford2002) state that all types of childhood adversity increase the risk of adult affective disorder and suicidal ideation noting dose–response relationships and the importance of psychological abuse. In this context the number of adversities experienced may be important for future risk of suicidal ideation (Enns et al. Reference Enns, Cox, Afifi, de Graaf, Ten Have and Sareen2006), although sexual and physical abuse, as severe adversities, carry greater risk.
The magnitude of the effects of the mediating factors of internalizing, externalizing and interpersonal disorders may have been small due to methodological limitations: risk factor exposure misclassification, lack of key variables at different stages of the lifecourse and lack of coverage of all relevant risk factors within the three groups of mediators. Additionally we needed to dichotomize the mediating variables, rather than use continuous scores because of the skewed nature of their distribution. Thus we may have underestimated the effect of the mediators. Moreover, as the models are fully adjusted we only expected to see small levels of mediation as the other covariates in the model also contribute to the outcome. Looking at individual possible mediators on top of the effects of other covariates means that individual mediators are unlikely to explain a large percentage of the associations. However, in our study we may also be missing some key variables that are shaped by childhood adversity and transmit the risk of suicidal ideation across the lifecourse. One of these may be how the experience of adversity influences feelings of self-worth, mastery and the ability to develop positive and trusting relationships. In turn this may influence coping capacities and the ability to ask for help in a crisis (Gunnell et al. Reference Gunnell, Harbord, Singleton, Jenkins and Lewis2004). Mastery has been linked to lower levels of suicidal ideation (Fairweather et al. Reference Fairweather, Anstey, Rodgers, Jorm and Christensen2007). Childhood adversity and abuse have been linked to coping methods for stressors in adulthood linked to disengagement (problem avoidance, social withdrawal and self-criticism), although, surprisingly in this study, not to less social support (Leitenberg et al. Reference Leitenberg, Gibson and Novy2004). This pattern of behavior may result from stress sensitization following childhood adversity which may hinder emotional processing of adult adverse events. Moreover, difficulties in dealing with adult adversity may accumulate in terms of perceived burden and severe interpersonal difficulties perpetuating and increasing suicidal ideas (Heikkinen et al. Reference Heikkinen, Aro and Lonnqvist1993).
A common theme across studies of risk factors for suicidal ideation and suicide is low social support and social isolation (Heikkinen et al. Reference Heikkinen, Aro and Lonnqvist1993; Johnson et al. Reference Johnson, Cohen, Gould, Kasen, Brown and Brook2002; Gunnell et al. Reference Gunnell, Harbord, Singleton, Jenkins and Lewis2004; Dennis et al. Reference Dennis, Baillon, Brugha, Lindesay, Stewart and Meltzer2007). Our measures of social support were limited across the lifecourse and did not fully capture this dimension. Interpersonal skills deficits as one of the features of cluster B personality disorders with emotional dysregulation, disinhibition and ‘thwarted belonginess’ may be reasons for increased suicidal attempts in this patient group (May et al. Reference May, Klonsky and Klein2012). Future lifecourse studies should attempt to capture the ways people cope with stressors, develop interpersonal relationships and ask for help in relation to suicidal ideation.
It is a strength that we had prospective measurements of childhood adversities and mediating factors at different life stages. To our knowledge this is the first study to examine the role of mediators of prospectively measured childhood adversity and its association with midlife suicidal ideation. It is a limitation that childhood sexual and physical abuse were reported retrospectively (Colman et al. Reference Colman, Kingsbury, Garad, Zeng, Naicker, Patten, Jones, Wild and Thompson2016). Also our adversities were measured long before standard scales like the Parental Bonding Instrument had been developed and they were not designed to capture current conceptualizations of adversity. The main limitation of longitudinal cohort study analysis is sample attrition and missing data but we anticipate that multiple imputation has addressed this. Also, at present it is only possible computationally to perform relatively simple mediation analyses.
Conclusions
Suicidal ideation and completed suicide are not equivalent, and less than 1 in 200 of those with suicidal ideation proceed to suicide (Gunnell et al. Reference Gunnell, Harbord, Singleton, Jenkins and Lewis2004). However, in the National Comorbidity Study the conditional probability of making a suicidal attempt among those with suicidal ideation was 57.9% with a suicide plan and 25.2% without a plan (Kessler et al. Reference Kessler, Borges and Walters1999) so that suicidal ideation should be considered an indicator of clinically significant risk both of suicidal attempt and major depressive disorder (Kessler et al. Reference Kessler, Borges and Walters1999).
Some elements of childhood adversity have an impact on midlife suicidal ideation after adjustment for mediating factors. This is in keeping with effects of adversity in critical periods in childhood having long-term consequences for mental health that may reflect effects on the developing brain and neuroendocrine responses to stress.
Understanding the pathways from adversity to suicidal ideation can inform suicide prevention (Gunnell et al. Reference Gunnell, Harbord, Singleton, Jenkins and Lewis2004). Interventions focused on parenting may be most effective in preventing childhood affective disorders and hence the transmission to adulthood (Shonkoff & Fisher, Reference Shonkoff and Fisher2013). Additionally, interventions establishing mentors or significant others as alternative points of support and attachment during childhood would be a viable intervention pathway. Our results indicate that there are both childhood and adulthood factors that increase the risk of suicidal ideation and that interventions with internalizing, externalizing disorders and preventing relationship breakdown in adulthood may be relevant in prevention of the long-term consequences of childhood adversity.
Supplementary material
The supplementary material for this article can be found at http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0033291716002336
Acknowledgements
We thank the data providers: Centre for Longitudinal Studies, Institute of Education and National Birthday Trust Fund, National Children's Bureau, City University Social Statistics Research Unit (original data producers).
The biomedical examination and related statistical analyses were funded by the Medical Research Council (grant no. G0000934), awarded under the Health of the Public initiative. B.R. was supported by Research Fellowship no. 471429 from the National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia. Research at the UCL Institute of Child Health and Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children is supported by the Department of Health's National Institute of Health Research (NIHR) Biomedical Research Centre.
Declaration of Interest
None.
Open access
