Hostname: page-component-89b8bd64d-n8gtw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-05-08T13:27:37.347Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Unintended Consequences of Conditional Cash Transfer Programs for Violence: Experimental and Survey Evidence from Mexico and the Americas

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 March 2023

Daniel Zizumbo-Colunga
Daniel Zizumbo-Colunga*
Affiliation:
Daniel Zizumbo-Colunga is an Assistant Professor in the Multidisciplinary Studies’ Division, CIDE-Región Centro, Aguascalientes, Mexico. daniel.zizumbo@cide.edu.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Because conditional cash transfer programs (CCTs) can address the deep roots of violence, many scholars and policymakers have assumed them to be an effective and innocuous tool to take on the issue. I argue that while CCTs may have positive economic effects, they can also trigger social discord, criminal predation, and political conflict and, in doing so, increase violence. To test this claim, I take advantage of the exogenous shock caused by the randomized expansion of Mexico’s flagship CCT, PROGRESA/Oportunidades. I find that the experimental introduction of the program increased rather than decreased violence. Then, I analyze all the data compiled by LAPOP on the issue over the years. I find that, other things constant, Latin Americans are more exposed to violence and insecurity when they participate in CCTs than when they do not. These findings urge us to reconsider the effects of social programs on violence.

Keywords

CCTsocial programshomicidesPROGRESAMexico

Information

Type
Research Article
Information
Latin American Politics and Society , Volume 65 , Issue 3 , August 2023 , pp. 47 - 71
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of the University of Miami

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

Footnotes

*

He is also a Researcher for Mexico at National Council of Science and Technology’s Drug Policy Program.

Conflict of interest: Daniel Zizumbo Colunga declares none.

References

Adato, Michelle, Coady, David, and Ruel, Marie. 2000. An Operations Evaluation of PROGRESA from the Perspective of Beneficiaries, Promotoras, School Directors, and Health Staff. Final Report. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.Google Scholar
Albarracín, Juan, and Barnes, Nicholas. 2020. Criminal Violence in Latin America. Latin American Research Review 55, 2: 397–406.10.25222/larr.975CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Araújo, Victor. 2021. Do Anti-Poverty Policies Sway Voters? Evidence from a Meta-Analysis of Conditional Cash Transfers. Research and Politics 8, 1:.10.1177/2053168021991715CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barrena, Guadalupe, Fernández, Alethia, and Morales, Agustín. 2019. Niñas, niños y adolescentes: víctimas del crimen organizado en México. Mexico City: Comisión Nacional de los Derechos Humanos.Google Scholar
Blattman, Christopher, Emeriau, Mathilde, and Fiala, Nathan. 2018. Do Anti-Poverty Programs Sway Voters? Experimental Evidence from Uganda. Review of Economics and Statistics 100, 5: 891–905.10.1162/rest_a_00737CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Borraz, Fernando, and Munyo, Ignacio. 2020. Conditional Cash Transfers and Crime: Higher Income but Also Better Loot. Economics Bulletin 40, 2: 1804–13.Google Scholar
Bueno de Mesquita, Ethan. 2020. Territorial Conflict Over Endogenous Rents. Journal of Politics 82, 1: 162–82.10.1086/705687CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Calderón, Laura Y., Heinle, Kimberly, Rodríguez Ferreira, Octavio and David. A, Shirk. 2019. Organized Crime and Violence in Mexico (Justice in Mexico). University of San Diego. https://justiceinmexico.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Organized-Crime-and-Violence-in-Mexico-2019.pdf.Google Scholar
Camacho, Adriana, and Mejía, Daniel. 2013. Las externalidades de los programas de transferencias condicionadas sobre el crimen: el caso de Familias en Acción en Bogotá. Documentos CEDE 010552. Universidad de los Andes/CEDE. https://ideas.repec.org/p/col/000089/010552.html.Google Scholar
Cameron, Lisa, and Shah, Manisha. 2013. Can Mistargeting Destroy Social Capital and Stimulate Crime? Evidence from a Cash Transfer Program in Indonesia. Economic Development and Cultural Change 62, 2: 381–415.10.1086/674102CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Casas, Agustín. 2018. Distributive Politics with Vote and Turnout Buying. American Political Science Review 112, 4: 1111–19.10.1017/S0003055418000291CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Chioda, Laura, De Mello, João M. P., and Soares, Rodrigo R.. 2016. Spillovers from Conditional Cash Transfer Programs: Bolsa Família and Crime in Urban Brazil. Economics of Education Review 54, 1: 306–20.10.1016/j.econedurev.2015.04.005CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Córdova, Abby. 2009. Measuring Relative Wealth Using Household Asset Indicators. Methodological Note 6. AmericasBarometer Insights. Nashville: Latin American Public Opinion Project (LAPOP), Vanderbilt University.Google Scholar
Corrêa, Diego Sanches, and Antonio Cheibub, José. 2016. The Anti-Incumbent Effects of Conditional Cash Transfer Programs. Latin American Politics and Society 58, 1: 49–71.10.1111/j.1548-2456.2016.00296.xCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Crost, Benjamin, Felter, Joseph, and Johnston, Patrick. 2014. Aid Under Fire: Development Projects and Civil Conflict. American Economic Review 104, 6: 1833–56.10.1257/aer.104.6.1833CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Crutchfield, Robert D., and Wadsworth, Tim. 2003. Poverty and Violence. In International Handbook of Violence Research, ed. Heitmeyer, Wilhelm and Hagan, John. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands. 67–82.10.1007/978-0-306-48039-3_4CrossRefGoogle Scholar
De La, O, Ana, L. 2013. Do Conditional Cash Transfers Affect Electoral Behavior? Evidence from a Randomized Experiment in Mexico. American Journal of Political Science 57, 1: 1–14.10.1111/j.1540-5907.2012.00617.xCrossRefGoogle Scholar
De la Roche, Roberta Senechal. 1996. Collective Violence as Social Control. Sociological Forum 11, 1: 97–128.10.1007/BF02408303CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dell, Melissa. 2015. Trafficking Networks and the Mexican Drug War. American Economic Review 105, 6: 1738–79. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20121637.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
De Micheli, David. 2018. The Racialized Effects of Social Programs in Brazil. Latin American Politics and Society 60, 1: 52–75.10.1017/lap.2017.6CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Díaz-Cayeros, Alberto. 2008. Electoral Risk and Redistributive Politics in Mexico and the United States. Studies in Comparative International Development 43, 2: 129–50.10.1007/s12116-008-9020-1CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Díaz-Cayeros, Alberto, Estévez, Federico, and Magaloni, Beatriz. 2016. The Political Logic of Poverty Relief: Electoral Strategies and Social Policy in Mexico. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9781316492710CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dirección General de Información en Salud (DGIS). 2001. Estadística de egresos hospitalarios de la Secretaría de Salud, 2000. Salud Pública de México 43, 5: 494–510.Google Scholar
Dubois, Pierre, de Janvry, Alain, and Sadoulet, Elisabeth. 2012. Effects on School Enrollment and Performance of a Conditional Cash Transfer Program in Mexico. Journal of Labor Economics 30, 3: 555–89.10.1086/664928CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ellis, Frank. 2012. “We Are All Poor Here”: Economic Difference, Social Divisiveness and Targeting Cash Transfers in Sub-Saharan Africa. Journal of Development Studies 48, 2: 201–14.10.1080/00220388.2011.625408CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Enamorado, Ted, López-Calva, Luis F., Rodríguez-Castelán, Carlos, and Winkler, Hernán. 2016. Income Inequality and Violent Crime: Evidence from Mexico’s Drug War. Journal of Development Economics 120: 128–43.10.1016/j.jdeveco.2015.12.004CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fajnzylber, Pablo, Lederman, Daniel, and Loayza, Norman. 2002. Inequality and Violent Crime. Journal of Law and Economics 45, 1: 1–40.10.1086/338347CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Geremia, Valeria, and Martín Pérez García, Juan. 2011. Infancia y conflicto armado en México: informe alternativo sobre el protocolo facultativo de la Convención Sobre los Derechos del niño relativo a la participación de niños en los conflictos armados. Red por los Derechos Infancia en México.Google Scholar
González, Lucas I., and Mamone, Ignacio. 2015. Distributive Politics in Developing Federal Democracies: Compensating Governors for Their Territorial Support. Latin American Politics and Society 57, 3: 50–76.10.1111/j.1548-2456.2015.00279.xCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hays, R. Allen. 1982. Social Welfare Programs and Political Conflict in Local Communities: The Mediating Function of the Implementing Agency. Policy Studies Journal 11, 2: 234–44.10.1111/j.1541-0072.1982.tb00249.xCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR). 2015. Violence, Children, and Organized Crime. OEA/Ser.L/V/II, Doc.40/15. Washington, DC: IACHR. https://www.oas.org/en/iachr/reports/pdfs/ViolenceChildren2016.pdf.Google Scholar
Imai, Kosuke, King, Gary, and Velasco Rivera, Carlos. 2020. Do Nonpartisan Programmatic Policies Have Partisan Electoral Effects? Evidence from Two Large Scale Experiments. Journal of Politics 81, 2: 714–30.10.1086/707059CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jacob, Brian A., and Lefgren, Lars. 2003. Are Idle Hands the Devil’s Workshop? Incapacitation, Concentration, and Juvenile Crime. American Economic Review 93, 5: 1560–77.10.1257/000282803322655446CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jenson, Jane, and Nagels, Nora. 2018. Social Policy Instruments in Motion: Conditional Cash Transfers from Mexico to Peru. Social Policy and Administration 52, 1: 323–42.10.1111/spol.12275CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kaufman, Robert R., and Trejo, Guillermo. 1997. Regionalism, Regime Transformation, and PRONASOL: The Politics of the National Solidarity Programme in Four Mexican States. Journal of Latin American Studies 29, 3: 717–45.10.1017/S0022216X97004835CrossRefGoogle Scholar
King, Ryan D., and Wheelock, Darren. 2007. Group Threat and Social Control: Race, Perceptions of Minorities and the Desire to Punish. Social Forces 85, 3: 1255–80.10.1353/sof.2007.0045CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kirk, Robin. 1994. Generation Under Fire: Children and Violence in Colombia. New York: Human Rights Watch.Google Scholar
Lagarde, Mylene, Haines, Andy, and Palmer, Natasha. 2009. The Impact of Conditional Cash Transfers on Health Outcomes and Use of Health Services in Low and Middle Income Countries. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews no. 4 (October). doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008137 Google Scholar
Lance, Justin Earl. 2014. Conditional Cash Transfers and the Effect on Recent Murder Rates in Brazil and Mexico. Latin American Politics and Society 56, 1: 55–72.10.1111/j.1548-2456.2014.00221.xCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Layton, Matthew L., Donaghy, Maureen M., and Rennó, Lucio R.. 2017. Does Welfare Provision Promote Democratic State Legitimacy? Evidence from Brazil’s Bolsa Família Program. Latin American Politics and Society 59, 4: 99–120.10.1111/laps.12035CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Levitt, Steven D. 1998. The Relationship Between Crime Reporting and Police: Implications for the Use of Uniform Crime Reports. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 14, 1: 61–81.10.1023/A:1023096425367CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ramírez, López, Rigoberto, Augusto. 2015. Pandillas en escuelas públicas de El Salvador. Revista Policía y Seguridad Pública 5, 1: 247–98.10.5377/rpsp.v5i1.1994CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Loureiro, Andre O. F. 2012. Can Conditional Cash Transfers Reduce Poverty and Crime? Evidence from Brazil. SSRN Scholarly Paper 2139541. Rochester: Social Science Research Network.Google Scholar
Luallen, Jeremy. 2006. School’s Out … Forever: A Study of Juvenile Crime, At-Risk Youths and Teacher Strikes. Journal of Urban Economics 59, 1: 75–103.10.1016/j.jue.2005.09.002CrossRefGoogle Scholar
MacAuslan, Ian, and Riemenschneider, Nils. 2011. Richer but Resented: What Do Cash Transfers Do to Social Relations? IDS Bulletin 42, 6: 60–66.10.1111/j.1759-5436.2011.00274.xCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Machado, Daiane Borges, Rodrigues, Laura C., Rasella, Davide, et al. 2018. Conditional Cash Transfer Programme: Impact on Homicide Rates and Hospitalisations from Violence in Brazil. PLOS ONE 13, 12. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0208925 CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Maldonado-Aranda, Salvador. 2012. Drogas, violencia y militarización en el México rural. El caso de Michoacán. Revista Mexicana de Sociologia 74, 1, Article 1. https://doi.org/10.22201/iis.01882503p.2012.1.29532 Google Scholar
Malone, Mary Fran T. 2012. The Rule of Law in Central America: Citizens’ Reactions to Crime and Punishment. New York: Bloomsbury Academic.Google Scholar
Martínez-Reyes, Alberto, and Javier Navarro-Pérez, José. 2018. ¿Atracción o reclutamiento? Causas que motivan el ingreso en las pandillas de los/as adolescentes salvadoreños/as. Prisma Social: Revista de Investigación Social no. 23: 18–45.Google Scholar
Molina-Millán, Teresa, Barham, Tania, Macours, Karen et al. 2019. Long-Term Impacts of Conditional Cash Transfers: Review of the Evidence. World Bank Research Observer 34, 1: 119–59.10.1093/wbro/lky005CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Molyneux, Maxine. 2006. Mothers at the Service of the New Poverty Agenda: Progresa/Oportunidades, Mexico’s Conditional Transfer Programme. Social Policy and Administration 40, 4: 425–49.10.1111/j.1467-9515.2006.00497.xCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Molyneux, Maxine, and Thomson, Marilyn. 2011. Cash Transfers, Gender Equity and Women’s Empowerment in Peru, Ecuador and Bolivia. Gender and Development 19, 2: 195–212.10.1080/13552074.2011.592631CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Molyneux, Maxine, Nicola Jones, With, and Samuels, Fiona. 2016. Can Cash Transfer Programmes Have “Transformative” Effects? Journal of Development Studies 52, 8: 1087–98.10.1080/00220388.2015.1134781CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morais de Sá e Silva, Michelle. 2017. Poverty Reduction, Education, and the Global Diffusion of Conditional Cash Transfers. 1st ed. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Google Scholar
El Economista. 2010. Campesinos acusan extorsiones de bandas delitivas. El Economista. https://www.eleconomista.com.mx/noticia/Campesinos-acusan-extorsiones-de-bandas-delitivas-20101029-0070.html Google Scholar
Palmeira, Poliana A., Salles-Costa, Rosana, and Pérez-Escamilla, Rafael. 2020. Effects of Family Income and Conditional Cash Transfers on Household Food Insecurity: Evidence from a Longitudinal Study in Northeast Brazil. Public Health Nutrition 23, 4: 756–67.10.1017/S1368980019003136CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Parker, Susan W., and Todd, Petra E.. 2017. Conditional Cash Transfers: The Case of Progresa/Oportunidades. Journal of Economic Literature 55, 3: 866–915.10.1257/jel.20151233CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pavão, Nara. 2016. Conditional Cash Transfer Programs and Electoral Accountability: Evidence from Latin America. Latin American Politics and Society 58, 2: 74–99.10.1111/j.1548-2456.2016.00311.xCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Penfold-Becerra, Michael. 2007. Clientelism and Social Funds: Evidence from Chávez’s Misiones. Latin American Politics and Society 49, 4: 63–84.10.1111/j.1548-2456.2007.tb00392.xCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Phillips, Brian J. 2015. How Does Leadership Decapitation Affect Violence? The Case of Drug Trafficking Organizations in Mexico. Journal of Politics 77, 2: 324–36.10.1086/680209CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Proceso. 2009. Ante el narco, los programas sociales revientan. December 6. https://www.proceso.com.mx/nacional/2009/12/8/ante-el-narco-los-programas-sociales-revientan-20995.html Google Scholar
Rios Salgado, Gustavo, and Jaramillo, María Llano. 2021. La incidencia del programa de Transferencias Condicionadas Familias en acción sobre los niveles de crimen en Colombia. Master’s thesis, Universidad EAFIT. íhttps://repository.eafit.edu.co/bitstream/handle/10784/29834/GustavoRiosSalgado_MaríaLlanoJaramillo.pdf?sequence=2&isAllowed=y Google Scholar
Robles, Marcos, Rubio, Marcela G., and Stampini, Marco. 2017. Have Cash Transfers Succeeded in Reaching the Poor in Latin America and the Caribbean? Development Policy Review 37, S2: 85–139.Google Scholar
Rudgard, W. E. 2019. Preventing Household Financial Hardship from Severe Illness: The Role of Cash Transfers. Ph.D. thesis, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. DOI: 10.17037/PUBS.0465600010.17037/PUBS.04656000CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Salomón, Josefina. 2019. Grupos criminales refuerzan tácticas de reclutamiento infantil en México. Blog post. InSightCrime, July 17. https://es.insightcrime.org/noticias/analisis/grupos-criminales-refuerzan-tacticas-de-reclutamiento-infantil-en-mexico Google Scholar
Schedler, Andreas. 2015. En la niebla de la guerra: Los ciudadanos ante la violencia criminal organizada. CIDE, Centro de Investigación y Docencia Económicas.Google Scholar
Schober, Gregory S. 2019. Conditional Cash Transfers, Resources, and Political Participation in Latin America. Latin American Research Review 54, 3: 591–607.10.25222/larr.143CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schultz, Paul T. 2004. School Subsidies for the Poor: Evaluating the Mexican Progresa Poverty Program. Journal of Development Economics 74, 1: 199–250.10.1016/j.jdeveco.2003.12.009CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Seligson, Mitchell A. 2002. The Renaissance of Political Culture or the Renaissance of the Ecological Fallacy. Comparative Politics 34: 273–92.10.2307/4146954CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Sesia, Paola. 2001. “Aquí la PROGRESA está muy dura”: estado, negociación e identidad entre familias indígenas rurales. Desacatos no. 8: 109–28.Google Scholar
Singer, Matthew. 2017. Crime, Violence, and the Police in the Americas. In The Political Culture of Democracy in the Americas, 2016/17: A Comparative Study of Democracy and Governance, ed. Mollie, J. Cohen, Lupu, Noam, and Elizabeth, J. Zechmeister. Nashville: Vanderbilt University. 69–99.Google Scholar
Skogan, Wesley G. 1976. Citizens Reporting of Crime: Some National Panel Data. Criminology 13, 4: 535–49.10.1111/j.1745-9125.1976.tb00685.xCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Skoufias, Emmanuel. 2006. PROGRESA y su efecto sobre el bienestar de las familias rurales de México. Informe de Investigación 139. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.Google Scholar
Skoufias, Emmanuel, Benjamin, Davis and Jere R, Behrman. 1999. An Evaluation of the Selection of Beneficiary Households in the Education, Health, and Nutrition Program (PROGRESA) of Mexico (p. 140). International Food Policy Research Institute. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/c097/adfd0a1402aaa85795d87a9d9bf27a4e6149.pdf Google Scholar
United Nations. 2015. Doha Declaration on Integrating Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice into the Wider United Nations Agenda to Address Social and Economic Challenges and to Promote the Rule of Law at the National and International Levels, and Public Participation. Thirteenth United Nations Congress on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, Doha, April 12–19. http://undocs.org/A/CONF.222/L.6 Google Scholar
Villarreal, Andrés. 2002. Political Competition and Violence in Mexico: Hierarchical Social Control in Local Patronage Structures. American Sociological Review 67, 4: 477–98.10.2307/3088942CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Visconti, Giancarlo. 2020. Policy Preferences After Crime Victimization: Panel and Survey Evidence from Latin America. British Journal of Political Science 50, 4: 1481–95.10.1017/S0007123418000297CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Watson, Brett, Guettabi, Mouhcine, and Reimer, Matthew. 2020. Universal Cash and Crime. Review of Economics and Statistics 102, 4: 678–89.10.1162/rest_a_00834CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Webster, Colin, and Kingston, Sarah. 2014. Anti-Poverty Strategies for the UK: Poverty and Crime Review. Project Report. York, UK: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.Google Scholar
Weintraub, Michael. 2016. Do All Good Things Go Together? Development Assistance and Insurgent Violence in Civil War. Journal of Politics 78, 4: 989–1002.10.1086/686026CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wood, Reed M., and Molfino, Emily. 2016. Aiding Victims, Abetting Violence: The Influence of Humanitarian Aid on Violence Patterns During Civil Conflict. Journal of Global Security Studies 1, 3: 186–203.10.1093/jogss/ogw007CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zürcher, Christoph. 2017. What Do We (Not) Know About Development Aid and Violence? A Systematic Review. World Development 98, 10: 506–22.10.1016/j.worlddev.2017.05.013CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Supplementary material: File

Zizumbo-Colunga supplementary material

Appendix
Download Zizumbo-Colunga supplementary material(File)
File 422.9 KB