The virus responsible for Middle Eastern respiratory syndrome (MERS), MERS-coronavirus (CoV) is a lineage C β-coronavirus similar to the lineage A murine β-coronavirus, mouse hepatitis virus, strain A59 (MHV-A59). Coronaviruses were first identified as the causative agent of the severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) in 2002 in China, and the Middle Eastern respiratory syndrome (MERS) in the Middle East in 2012.Reference Nie, Luo and Hui 1 – Reference Zumla, Hui and Perlman 3 The first reported case of MERS occurred in Saudi Arabia in 2012 and resulted in 76 deaths.Reference Zaki, van Boheemen, Bestebroer, Osterhaus and Fouchier 4 Since that time, cases of MERS have continued to occur in both the Middle East as well as in other countries in Europe, Asia, Africa, and North America. A recent outbreak, involving more than 180 patients, occurred in South Korea.Reference Khan, Farooqui, Guan and Kelvin 5 MERS has a reported mortality rate of approximately 36%;Reference de Groot, Baker and Baric 2 , Reference Zumla, Hui and Perlman 3 , Reference Memish, Al-Tawfiq and Alhakeem 6 it is thought to be transmitted from camels to humans through direct contact; however, obvious camel-to-human interaction has not been documented in all cases. Human-to-human transmission has also been identified in hospital and household transmission during MERS outbreaks. The ability of coronaviruses to rapidly mutate increases the risk of a large-scale outbreak or epidemic in the future.Reference de Groot, Baker and Baric 2 MHV-A59 is structurally similar to the MERS-CoV but causes hepatic and neuronal disease in mice. The MHV-A59 virus is an ideal model virus with which to study the effects of UV-C against MERS-CoV because it has many similarities to the human virus but can be handled at the biosafety level 2 (BSL2) laboratory. Along with studies of MHV-A59, the Surfacide multiple-emitter system (Surfacide, Naperville, IL) was also tested against the MERS-CoV virus.
METHODS
The Surfacide multiple-emitter automated UV-C disinfection system consists of 3 ultraviolet C (UV-C) emitters with a diameter of 59 cm and a height of 195 cm. All systems include both a touch screen control tablet and a motion sensor that double as jointers to connect the emitters together for transport. The system utilizes a laser to identify the size of the disinfection space and to identify near-field objects. Based on these measurements the system then calculates the disinfection cycle time accordingly while rotating 360°.
Triplicate 10-µL aliquots of MHV-A59 were loaded onto sterile glass coverslips at a concentration of 1.6e8 pfu/mL and allowed to dry. Coverslips containing dried virus were then placed in a UV transparent Petri dish and either left untreated or exposed to UV-C radiation from the Surfacide system placed 4 feet (1.22 m) from the samples for predetermined times between 0 and 60 minutes. The coverslips containing dried virus were then placed in Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle’s Medium (DMEM) media on ice to resuspend the virus. Serial 1:10 dilutions were inoculated onto Hela cells expressing the MHV receptorReference Williams, Jiang and Holmes 7 and allowed to incubate for 45 minutes at 37°C. Medium containing virus was removed and the cells were allowed to incubate overnight in D10 media. Plaque counts were determined the following day by combining 1% neutral red with 2× media plus agarose and incubating the cells for approximately 3 hours. All studies were conducted in triplicate with replicate experiments.
Testing MERS-CoV sensitivity to UV-C was conducted under strict containment BSL3 laboratory protocols due to the infective nature of the virus, and all steps were carried out above bleach-soaked pads to prevent virus spread. The moist environment created by the bleach soaked pads in the biosafety cabinet prevented drying of the virus onto glass coverslips. MERS-CoV was therefore loaded onto glass coverslips as small droplets at a concentration of 8.9e5 pfu/mL in UV-C permeable dishes and exposed to UV-C energy from the Surfacide emitter placed 4 feet (1.22 m) from the dishes. Samples were removed at several time points between 0 and 30 minutes. Virus resuspension and dilution were carried out as described above. Virus dilutions were placed onto 90% confluent African green monkey kidney cell-line (Vero81) cells at 37°C for 40 minutes. Following a 40-minute incubation, medium containing virus was removed and replaced with 2×medium plus 1.2% agarose and allowed to solidify. DMEM was then layered on top to prevent drying, and the plates were incubated at 37°C for 3 days to allow plaque formation. On day 3, formalin was added to fix the cells for 20 minutes. Formalin, media, and agarose were then removed and replaced with 0.1% crystal violet for a 5-minute incubation. This procedure was followed by a phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) wash prior to counting plaques. Again, all samples were prepared in triplicate.
RESULTS
MHV-A59 dried and MERS-CoV droplets were stable on glass coverslips for at least 60 and 30 minutes, 0.09 and 0.22 log reduction, respectively. Plaque counts indicated that the UV-C energy emitted from the Surfacide disinfection system was able to reduce the viral titers of MHV-A59 by an average of 2.71 log10 in 5 minutes and 6.11 log10 in 10 minutes of exposure, resulting in undetectable levels of MHV-A59 virus (Figure 1). For MERS-CoV, a UV-C exposure time of only 5 minutes resulted in undetectable virus levels that remained undetectable following 30 minutes of total exposure for a 5.9 log10 reduction (Figure 2).
Log reduction of MHV-A59 following Surfacide UV-C exposure at a 4-foot distance (1.22 m). Virus was reduced by 2.71 log10 in 5 minutes and by 6.11 log10 in 10 minutes to undetectable levels. Results are the means of triplicate samples.
Log reduction of MERS-CoV during exposure to Surfacide UV-C at 4 feet (1.22 m). Log reduction of MERS-CoV on glass coverslips following Surfacide UV-C exposure at a 4-foot distance. Virus was reduced to 5.91 log10 in 5 minutes to undetectable levels. Results are the means of triplicate samples.
DISCUSSION
The multiple-emitter continuous UV-C disinfection system was >99.999% effective against MHV-A59, a mouse analog of MERS-CoV, and SARS-CoV in 10 minutes. Applying those same studies to droplets of MERS-CoV resulted in undetectable levels of MERS-CoV virus after only 5 minutes of exposure to the UV-C emitter or a percent reduction of >99.999%. Notably, UV-C disinfection is most effective when used as an adjunct to standard terminal cleaning of hard surfaces and should not be used to replace good cleaning practices.Reference Anderson, Gergen and Smathers 8 This study is the first to document the effectiveness of a multiple-emitter, automated, whole-room UV-C system or any whole-room disinfection system against RNA viruses like MHV-A59, MERS-CoV, and SARS-CoV. The use of the Surfacide whole-room UV-C disinfection system during MERS outbreaks may prevent the nosocomial spread of the virus and protect staff in the process.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Adam Buchaklian, PhD, is the Director of Research for Surfacide, LLC, and provided the UV-C disinfection system as well as recommendations on study design. All studies were conducted independently in the laboratory of Dr. Stanley Perlman at the University of Iowa. All other authors report no conflict of interest.
