From assimilationist jurisprudence to legal nationalism

Colin Kidd

doi:10.1017/CBO9780511756009.006

5 - From assimilationist jurisprudence to legal nationalism

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 06 July 2010

Colin Kidd

Show author details

Colin Kidd: Affiliation:
University of Glasgow

Book contents

Get access

Summary

Jurisprudence constitutes one of the most important branches of unionist political thought in Scotland over the past three centuries. In chapter 3 we have already examined how Scots jurists parsed the particular problem of sovereignty within the field of constitutional law. This chapter takes a broader approach to Scots juridical thought within the Union, not only exploring constitutional questions regarding the status of Scots law, but also investigating the depth of commitment felt by Scots lawyers to the preservation of Scottish legal distinctiveness, attitudes to legal reform, including programmes to anglicise Scots law, interpretations of Scottish and British legal history, and the relationship of Scottish legal culture more generally to the politics of Union.

Although jurisprudence might seem at first sight to be a somewhat arcane branch of political thought, the unusual status of Scots law within the Union of 1707 means that the subject deserves special treatment. Articles XVIII, XIX and XX of Union appeared to guarantee the preservation of a Scottish legal system within the Union. Yet this was no more than a fragile semi-autonomy. Public law was a matter for the new British state, but Scots private law was to be preserved in its entirety. There was no attempt to define public or private law or to clarify the grey areas between them. The Union agreement was also silent on the question of whether Scots legal appeals might be brought to the British House of Lords from the supreme courts of Scotland, whether from the Court of Session in civil cases or the High Court of Justiciary in criminal trials.

Information

Type: Chapter
Information: Union and Unionisms
Political Thought in Scotland, 1500–2000
, pp. 173 - 210

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511756009.006 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2008

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Willock, I. D., ‘The Scottish legal heritage revisited’, in Grant, J. P. (ed.), Independence and devolution: the legal implications for Scotland (Edinburgh, 1976), pp. 1–14Google Scholar

MacCormick, N., ‘Stair as analytical jurist’, in Walker, D. (ed.), Stair tercentenary studies (Stair Society, Edinburgh, 1981), pp. 187–99Google Scholar

Minute book of the Faculty of Advocates I 1661–1712 ed. Pinkerton, J. A. (Stair Society, Edinburgh, 1976), pp. 115–16

Minute book of the Faculty of Advocates II 1713–1750 ed. J. A. Pinkerton (Stair Society, Edinburgh, 1980), pp. 72–5, 77, 79, 85, 115–16, 232, 239, 241

Dalrymple, James, The institutions of the law of Scotland deduced from its originals and collated with the civil, canon and feudal laws; and with the customs of neighbouring nations (Edinburgh, 1681)Google Scholar

Grant, Francis, Law, religion and education considered (1715), i, ‘Law’, p. 97Google Scholar

Maclean, A. J., ‘The 1707 Union: Scots law and the House of Lords’, in Kiralfy, A. and MacQueen, H. (eds.), New perspectives in Scottish legal history (London, 1984), pp. 50–75Google Scholar

MacLean, A. J., ‘The House of Lords and appeals from the High Court of Justiciary, 1707–1887’, Juridical Review (1985), 192–226Google Scholar

Kidd, C., Subverting Scotland's past (Cambridge, 1993)CrossRef Google Scholar

Home, Henry, Kames, Lord, Essays upon several subjects concerning British antiquities (Edinburgh, 1747), p. 4Google Scholar

Home, Henry, Kames, Lord, Historical law tracts (2 vols., Edinburgh, 1758), i, pp. xiii–xivGoogle Scholar

Dalrymple, John, Essay towards a general history of feudal property in Great Britain (1757), p. v

Lieberman, D., ‘The legal needs of a commercial society: the jurisprudence of Lord Kames’, in Hont, L. and Ignatieff, M. (eds.), Wealth and virtue: the shaping of political economy in the Scottish Enlightenment (Cambridge, 1983), pp. 203–34CrossRef Google Scholar

Haakonssen, K., The science of a legislator: the natural jurisprudence of David Hume and Adam Smith (Cambridge, 1981)CrossRef Google Scholar

Kidd, Subverting, pp. 158–60

Wallace, George, A system of the principles of the law of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1760), p. xixGoogle Scholar

Smollett, Tobias, Humphry Clinker (1771: Harmondsworth, 1967), p. 292Google Scholar

Phillipson, N. T., ‘Nationalism and ideology’, in Wolfe, J. N. (ed.), Government and nationalism in Scotland (Edinburgh, 1969)Google Scholar

Phillipson, N. T., The Scottish whigs and the reform of the Court of Session 1785–1830 (Stair Society, Edinburgh, 1990)Google Scholar

Simpson, A. W. B., ‘Entails and perpetuities’, Juridical Review (1979), 1–20Google Scholar

Bell, G. J., Commentaries on the law of Scotland and on the principles of mercantile jurisprudence (Edinburgh, 1810)Google Scholar

Cairns, J., ‘The influence of the German historical school in nineteenth-century Edinburgh’, Syracuse Journal of International Law and Commerce 20 (1994), 191–203Google Scholar

Harvie, C., ‘Legalism, myth and national identity in Scotland in the imperial epoch’, Cencrastus no. 26 (1987), 35–41Google Scholar

Reddie, John, Historical notices of the Roman law, and of the recent progress of its study in Germany (Edinburgh, 1826)Google Scholar

Savigny, C., The history of the Roman law during the middle ages, i (transl. Cathcart, E., Edinburgh, 1829)Google Scholar

Gardiner, W. (transl.), Survey of the Roman, or civil law; an extract from Gibbon's Decline and Fall, with notes, by Professor Hugo of Gottingen (Edinburgh, 1823)

Rodger, A., ‘Scottish advocates in the nineteenth century: the German connection’, Law Quarterly Review 110 (1994), 563–91Google Scholar

Guthrie, William, ‘Introduction’, Savigny, , Private international law: a treatise on the conflict of laws (transl. Guthrie, W., Edinburgh, 1869), pp. xxxv–xxxviGoogle Scholar

[Moir, George], The appellate jurisdiction: Scotch appeals (Edinburgh, 1851), pp. 3–4, 8Google Scholar

Hutchison, I. G. C., A political history of Scotland 1832–1924 (Edinburgh, 1986), pp. 93–5Google Scholar

Rodger, A., ‘The codification of commercial law in Victorian Britain’, Law Quarterly Review 108 (1992), 570–90Google Scholar

Roberton, James, Introductory lecture delivered on 7th November, 1867 (Glasgow, [1867]), pp. 17–18Google Scholar

Roberton, James, Proposed abolition of the feudal system: an address delivered to the Glasgow Legal and Speculative Society, on 11th February, 1870 (Glasgow, 1870), pp. 18, 27–8Google Scholar

Mackay, Aeneas, A sketch of the history of Scots law ([Edinburgh?], 1882), pp. 17, 22–3Google Scholar

Brodie-Innes, J. W., Comparative principles of the laws of England and Scotland (Edinburgh and London, 1903), p. 4Google Scholar

Walton, F. P., ‘The civil law and the common law in Canada’, Juridical Review (1899), 282–301Google Scholar

Reid, K. G. C., ‘The idea of mixed legal systems’, Tulane Law Review 78 (2003), 5–40Google Scholar

Levy-Ullmann, H. (transl. Walton, F. P.), ‘The law of Scotland’, Juridical Review (1925), 370–91Google Scholar

Inglis, John, Glencorse, Lord (1810–91), The historical study of law (Edinburgh, 1863)Google Scholar

Gloag, W. M. and Henderson, R. C., Introduction to the Law of Scotland (2nd edn, Edinburgh, 1933), pp. 1–2Google Scholar

Walker, D. M., ‘Legal studies in the Scottish universities’, Juridical Review (1957), 21–41 and 151–79Google Scholar

MacQueen, H., ‘Two Toms and an ideology for Scots law: T. B. Smith and Lord Cooper of Culross’, in Reid, E. and Miller, D. L. Carey (eds.), A mixed legal system in transition: T. B. Smith and the progress of Scots law (Edinburgh, 2005)Google Scholar

Gretton, G. L., ‘The rational and the national: Thomas Brown Smith’, in Reid and Carey Miller (eds.), A mixed legal system, pp. 32–3

Farmer, L., ‘Under the shadow of Parliament House’, in Farmer, L. and Veitch, S. (eds.), The state of Scots law (Edinburgh, 2001), pp. 151–64Google Scholar

Gibb, Andrew Dewar, The shadow on Parliament House: has Scots law a future? (Edinburgh, 1932)Google Scholar

Gibb, Andrew Dewar, Law from over the border (Edinburgh, 1950)Google Scholar

Gibb, Andrew Dewar, Scottish Empire (London, 1937), p. 312Google Scholar

Whitty, N. R., ‘The civilian tradition and debates on Scots Law: part II’, Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg (1996), 442–57Google Scholar

Cooper, T. M., Selected papers 1922–1954 (Edinburgh and London, 1957)Google Scholar

Smith, T. B., ‘Severalty of administration of justice in the United Kingdom’, Juridical Review 56 (1949), 151–71Google Scholar

Smith, T. B., British justice: the Scottish contribution (London, 1961), p. 203Google Scholar

Smith, T. B., ‘British justice: a Jacobean phantasma’, Scots Law Times (4 June 1982), 157–64

Smith, British Justice, p. 25

Smith, T. B., ‘Pretensions of English law as “imperial law”’, ‘Constitutional Law’, Stair Memorial Encyclopedia, v (Edinburgh, 1987)Google Scholar

Smith, T. B., A short commentary on the law of Scotland (Edinburgh, 1962), p. 61Google Scholar

Smith, T. B., ‘Legal imperialism and legal parochialism’, Juridical Review (1965), 39–57Google Scholar

Smith, T. B., ‘Unification of law in Britain: problems of coordination’, Juridical Review (1967), 97–126Google Scholar

Mulligan, G. A., ‘Bellum Juridicum (3): Purists, pollutionists and pragmatists’, South African Law Journal 69 (1952), 25–32Google Scholar

‘Bellum Juridicum: two approaches to South African Law, South African Law Journal 68 (1951), 306–13

Smith, T. B., ‘The common law cuckoo’, in Smith, , Studies critical and comparative (Edinburgh, 1962)Google Scholar

Smith, T. B., ‘Strange gods: the crisis of Scots law as a civilian system’, in Smith, Studies

Accessibility standard: Unknown

Why this information is here

This section outlines the accessibility features of this content - including support for screen readers, full keyboard navigation and high-contrast display options. This may not be relevant for you.

Accessibility Information

Accessibility compliance for the PDF of this chapter is currently unknown and may be updated in the future.