Hostname: page-component-5db58dd55d-d6ndz Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-06-04T14:13:40.281Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes do not predict survival in human papillomavirus-associated oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma: a single institution retrospective review

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 February 2026

Michael Fitzsimons Open the ORCID record for Michael Fitzsimons [Opens in a new window] ,
Grace O'Flanagan ,
Shane Brennan ,
Hannah O'Driscoll ,
Susan Kennedy ,
Conrad Timon  and
Robbie Seton Rowan Woods
Michael Fitzsimons*
Affiliation:
Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Ireland Royal Victoria Eye and Ear Hospital, Dublin, Ireland
Grace O'Flanagan
Affiliation:
Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Ireland Royal Victoria Eye and Ear Hospital, Dublin, Ireland
Shane Brennan
Affiliation:
St. James’ Hospital, Dublin, Ireland
Hannah O'Driscoll
Affiliation:
Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Ireland St. Luke’s Radiation Oncology Network, Dublin, Ireland
Susan Kennedy
Affiliation:
Royal Victoria Eye and Ear Hospital, Dublin, Ireland
Conrad Timon
Affiliation:
Royal Victoria Eye and Ear Hospital, Dublin, Ireland St. James’ Hospital, Dublin, Ireland
Robbie Seton Rowan Woods
Affiliation:
Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, Ireland Department of Otolaryngology, Beaumont Hospital, Dublin, Ireland
*
Corresponding author: Michael Fitzsimons; Email: michael.fitzsimons31@gmail.com
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Objective

Human papillomavirus (HPV) associated oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma (OPSCC) exhibits a favourable prognosis compared to non-HPV OPCSCC. Tumour infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) may predict better survival outcomes for patients with HPV+OPSCC.

Methods

A retrospective review of patients treated for HPV+OPSCC between 2003-2018. TIL density scores for each patient’s tumour specimen were determined. Patients were categorised as TIL-Hi or TIL-Lo. Survival outcomes for the two TIL groups were compared.

Results

Fifty-seven patients, 33 in the TIL-Hi group, were included. 5-year overall survival was 81.8% in the TIL-Hi and 75% in the TIL-Lo groups. 5-year disease specific survival was 87.9% and 87.5%, respectively. There was no statistically significant difference in survival outcomes between TIL-Hi and TIL-Lo.

Conclusion

TIL density in HPV+OPSCC has been reported to predict survival outcomes. This is not supported by the findings of this study. Further prospective evaluation with a standardised scoring technique may fully elicit the prognostic value of TILs in HPV+OPSCC.

Keywords

oropharyngeal neoplasmslymphocytestumor-infiltratingpapillomavirus infectionsprognosis

Information

Type
Main Article
Information
The Journal of Laryngology & Otology , Volume 140 , Issue 5 , May 2026 , pp. 495 - 500
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of J.L.O. (1984) LIMITED.

Introduction

Oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) associated with human papillomavirus (HPV) carries a favourable prognosis when compared with non-HPV oropharyngeal SCC. It is well established that oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV exhibits greater treatment response and survival versus non-HPV oropharyngeal SCC.Reference Ang, Harris, Wheeler, Weber, Rosenthal and Nguyen-Tan1–Reference O’Rorke, Ellison, Murray, Moran, James and Anderson3 This has been reflected in the most recent (eighth) edition of the American Joint Committee on Cancer cancer staging manualReference Lydiatt, Patel, O’Sullivan, Brandwein, Ridge and Migliacci4, Reference Amin, Greene, Edge, Compton, Gershenwald and Brookland5 wherein oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV has a distinct tumour–node–metastasis (TNM) classification. With that in mind, there exists potential for less intense treatment regimens for oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV that have the potential to reduce morbidity while preserving efficacy.

A subgroup of patients with oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV still has a poor prognosis, with up to 36 per cent of patients experiencing recurrence within 8 yearsReference Nguyen-Tan, Zhang, Ang, Weber, Rosenthal and Soulieres6 and up to 19 per cent not surviving beyond 3 years.Reference Ang, Harris, Wheeler, Weber, Rosenthal and Nguyen-Tan1 Attempts to substitute concurrent cisplatin chemotherapy with cetuximab, an epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) inhibitor, in patients treated with primary chemoradiotherapy demonstrated no benefit in terms of toxicity reduction and in fact was detrimental to overall survival and tumour control.Reference Gillison, Trotti, Harris, Eisbruch, Harari and Adelstein7, Reference Mehanna, Robinson, Hartley, Kong, Foran and Fulton-Lieuw8 Hence, there is a need to identify predictors of a positive prognosis for patients with oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV to enable appropriate selection for de-intensified treatment protocols and ensure optimal outcomes.Reference Mensour, Alam, Mawani, Bahig, Lang and Nichols9

Tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes specific to HPV within the tumour microenvironment may infer a greater immune response, improved treatment response and favourable survival outcomes in patients with oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV.Reference Welters, Ma, Santegoets, Goedemans, Ehsan and Jordanova10 Several studies have identified a positive relationship between the density of tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes in the tumour microenvironment and patient outcomes in oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV.Reference de Ruiter, Ooft, Devriese and Willems11–Reference Ward, Thirdborough, Mellows, Riley, Harris and Suchak13 Further validation of the prognostic role of tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes in oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV is needed if it is to be routinely utilised in treatment decisions. To that end, we retrospectively investigated the prognostic value of tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes for patients diagnosed with oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV in a single institution in Dublin, Ireland.

Methods

A list of patients diagnosed with oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV in the Royal Victoria Eye and Ear Hospital, Dublin between 2003 and 2018 was retrospectively compiled. This study was approved by the Hospital Research Ethics Committee and is in compliance with the Helsinki Declaration. Human papillomavirus status was determined at the time of diagnosis with p16 overexpression of more than 70 per cent used as a surrogate for HPV positivity. In some cases, DNA in situ hybridisation or polymerase chain reaction had already been carried out and so this information was included. A retrospective chart review was undertaken and a database populated from clinical notes, histopathology and radiology reports. Clinical data including age, sex, smoking status and pack year history, TNM stage, recurrence, survival and follow-up duration (to a maximum of five years) were extracted from the records. Patients who declined conventional treatment or who were treated with palliative intent were excluded from the study.

Tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte scoring

For each patient, tumour-infiltrating lymphocyte density was scored by two pathologists (SK, SB) using archived whole-tumour haematoxylin and eosin-stained slides. Each haematoxylin and eosin slide was assessed and reported independently by each examiner. The scoring algorithm utilised was described by Marsh et al.Reference Marsh, Suchak, Moutasim, Vallath, Hopper and Jerjes14 and utilised in subsequent studies.Reference Ruangritchankul, Sandison, Warburton, Guerrero-Urbano, Reis Ferreira and Lei12, Reference Ward, Thirdborough, Mellows, Riley, Harris and Suchak13 The characteristics of tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes include that they are located at the invasive tumour front. Lymphocytes counted include those located between isolated single tumour cells or between islands and/or nests of tumour cells. In addition, as squamous cells are characteristically cohesive, lymphocytes within islands and/or nests of tumour cells were included. Scoring was conducted on a 10× magnification and 2.5 objective lens on the same microscope (Nikon Eclipse 50i, Tokyo, Japan).

Tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes were categorised into two groups: high and low. High tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes was defined as having a diffuse infiltrate present in more than 20 per cent of tumour and stroma. Low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes was defined as having a weak or absent infiltrate present in less than 20 per cent of tumour and stroma. Cases with discrepancies were reviewed together by both pathologists and an agreed score was provided before submitting to statistical analysis.

Statistical analysis

Patients were grouped according to tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte score (high or low). Clinical characteristics between the two groups were compared using chi-square, Fisher’s exact test and t-test, where appropriate.

Survival analysis was conducted to compare five-year overall survival, disease-free survival and disease-specific survival between the two groups. Kaplan–Meier survival curves were plotted for disease-free survival, disease-specific survival and overall survival. Log-rank test was employed to compare survival functions. Statistical significance was considered as p less than 0.05. Statistical analysis was performed using Stata/SE 16.0 for Mac (StataCorp, Texas, USA).

Results

Seventy-four patients diagnosed with HPV-positive oropharyngeal SCC (oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV) during the study period of July 2003 to December 2018 were identified. There was insufficient remaining archived tissue sample for tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte analysis for 15 patients, and 2 patients were treated with palliative intent (1 due to metastatic disease at presentation and 1 due to co-morbidities). Thus 57 patients were included in the final review. HPV DNA polymerase chain reaction and/or in situ hybridisation was performed on 27 of 57 cases which confirmed HPV positivity.

The mean age at diagnosis was 58 years (standard deviation, 8.6 years) with a male-to-female ratio of 5.3:1. The median follow-up duration was 60 months (interquartile range, 57–60 months). There were 12 deaths observed in the 5-year follow-up period. For the remaining 45 patients, complete 5-year follow up was available for 42 (i.e. complete 5-year survival data were recorded for 54 of 57 patients (94.7 per cent).

There were 33 of 57 patients (57.9 per cent) in the high tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte group. There was no statistically significant difference between the high and low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes groups with regards to gender, follow up, smoking history, T stage, N stage or overall stage (Table 1). There was a trend towards older age in the low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes group, but this was not statistically significant (p = 0.12).

Table 1.

Overview characteristics

Patients with high tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes are younger and predominantly male, with similar follow-up and smoking history compared to those with low infiltration; no significant differences in stages or N stage were found. See long description.

SD = standard deviation; IQR = interquartile range.

There were 6 deaths (6 of 33, 18.2 per cent) observed in the high tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes group during 5-year follow up, of which 4 (4 of 33, 12.1 per cent) were due to oropharyngeal SCC. Six deaths (6 of 24, 25 per cent) occurred in the low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes group. Three (3 od 24, 12.5 per cent) deaths in the low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes group were due to oropharyngeal SCC. There was no statistically significant difference in 5-year overall survival (logrank, p = 0.46) or 5-year disease-specific survival (logrank, p = 0.88) between the two tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte groups. Disease-free survival at 5 years was similar between the two groups (logrank, p = 0.73).

Discussion

It is well established that oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV exhibits better survival outcomes when compared with non-HPV oropharyngeal SCC.Reference Ang, Harris, Wheeler, Weber, Rosenthal and Nguyen-Tan1–Reference O’Rorke, Ellison, Murray, Moran, James and Anderson3 While this raises the prospect of less intense treatment regimens for oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV, it is important to remain mindful of the fact that a small subgroup within the oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV cohort still has a poor prognosis. As such, a greater understanding of prognostic indicators in oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV is required.

Several studies have reported the prognostic value of tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes in oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV, with a higher density of tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte on haematoxylin and eosin-stained sections correlated with improved survival.Reference Ruangritchankul, Sandison, Warburton, Guerrero-Urbano, Reis Ferreira and Lei12, Reference Ward, Thirdborough, Mellows, Riley, Harris and Suchak13, Reference Yin, Rivera, Garcia, Bartemes, Lewis and Lohse15–Reference Faraji, Fung, Zaidi, Gourin, Eisele and Rooper19 A recent meta-analysis of 11 studies found tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes in oropharyngeal SCC to be a reliable prognostic indicator with improved disease-free, disease-specific and overall survival (hazard ration (HR) = 0.39, HR = 0.32, HR = 0.38).Reference Almangush, Alabi, De Keukeleire, Makitie, Pirinen and Leivo20 It was concluded that assessment of tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes could become part of routine practice ‘for better risk stratification and treatment planning in oropharyngeal SCC’.

The findings from our study do not support the utility of tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes alone as a prognostic marker in oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV. We found similar outcomes for high and low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes groups in terms of 5-year overall survival (p = 0.46) (Figure 1), 5-year disease-specific survival (p = 0.88) (Figure 2) and 5-year disease-free survival (p = 0.73) (Figure 3), although there was a slight trend towards improved survival in the high tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes group.

There are a number of reasons as to why the observed outcomes in our review may be in contrast to the findings of other published studies. These include the small sample size, retrospective study design and use of archived tissue samples, lack of lymphocyte subtype analysis and interobserver variability in tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte scoring. Nonetheless, the published literature on this topic to date is based on similar study designs. Several studies include both oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV and non-HPV oropharyngeal SCC cases in their analysis. This study benefits from solely focusing on oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV as this is an entity distinct from non-HPV oropharyngeal SCC.

Figure 1.

Five-year overall survival.

A survival graph comparing high and low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes groups over 60 months. See long description.
Figure 2.

Five-year disease-specific survival.

A survival graph showing cumulative survival over 60 months for high and low groups with logrank p equals 0.88. See long description.
Figure 3.

Five-year disease-free survival.

A survival graph showing cumulative survival over 60 months for high and low groups with logrank p equals 0.73. See long description.

The 5-year overall survival for oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV is typically greater than 80 per cent.Reference Ang, Harris, Wheeler, Weber, Rosenthal and Nguyen-Tan1, Reference O’Sullivan, Huang, Su, Garden, Sturgis and Dahlstrom21, Reference Yamashita, Ikegami, Hirakawa, Uehara, Deng and Agena22 Overall 5-year survival was 79 per cent in our cohort. This comprised 5-year overall survival of 81.8 and 75 per cent for the high and low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes groups, respectively. Ruangritchankul et al.Reference Ruangritchankul, Sandison, Warburton, Guerrero-Urbano, Reis Ferreira and Lei12 (n = 232) reported 5-year overall survival greater than 80 per cent for all patients, which comprised approximately 88 and 46 per cent 5-year overall survival for the high and low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes groups, respectively. Disease-specific survival at 3 years for 148 cases of oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV reported by Ward et al.Reference Ward, Thirdborough, Mellows, Riley, Harris and Suchak13 was 96, 76 and 59 per cent for high, moderate and low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes. By comparison, 3-year disease-specific survival in our study was 90.9 per cent for the high tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes group and 87.5 per cent for the low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes group. This demonstrates that the observed mortality rate in our low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes cohort was lower than expected compared with rates reported in the literature.

The utility of using tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte density to stratify survival outcomes in oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV lies in using a simple, reproducible, inexpensive test. Hence, several authors,Reference Ruangritchankul, Sandison, Warburton, Guerrero-Urbano, Reis Ferreira and Lei12, Reference Yin, Rivera, Garcia, Bartemes, Lewis and Lohse15, Reference De Keukeleire, Vermassen, De Meulenaere, Deron, Huvenne and Duprez17 including ourselves, have examined tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte scoring performed on haematoxylin and eosin staining without investigating lymphocyte subtype analysis. That said, T-cell subtype analysis has identified that, for example, CD8Reference Ward, Thirdborough, Mellows, Riley, Harris and Suchak13,, Reference Atipas, Laokulrath, Petsuksiri, Ratanaprasert and Pongsapich23 and CD3Reference Ljokjel, Haave, Lybak, Vintermyr, Helgeland and Aarstad24, Reference Haave, Ljokjel, Lybak, Moe, Berge and Vintermyr25 cells in the tumour and stroma predict better survival. Conversely, the density of FOXP3, related to regulatory T-cells, can predict better survival in some cancers, while indicating worse prognosis in others.Reference Wang, Gong, Zhao, Lei, Sun and Ren26

The value and prognostic direction of FOXP3 in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) is also subject to conflicting reports.Reference Ljokjel, Haave, Lybak, Vintermyr, Helgeland and Aarstad24, Reference Haave, Ljokjel, Lybak, Moe, Berge and Vintermyr25, Reference Wansom, Light, Thomas, Worden, Prince and Urba27–Reference Oguejiofor, Hall, Slater, Betts, Hall and Slevin30 Acknowledging that the proportion of FOXP3 in the total tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte may be low,Reference Ward, Thirdborough, Mellows, Riley, Harris and Suchak13, Reference Oguejiofor, Hall, Slater, Betts, Hall and Slevin30 it could be the case that tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte subtype analysis of our cohort might shed light on why we did not see a survival benefit similar to that reported in the literature. Furthermore, there exists a risk of publication bias, as noted by de Ruiter et al.,Reference de Ruiter, Ooft, Devriese and Willems11 wherein statistically non-significant results for specific T-cell subtypes (e.g. CD4+) are not reported. Hence, while our results do not align with previous studies, it is important to publish these findings.

Interobserver reliability of tumour-infiltrating lymphocyte scoring is often reported as good to excellent,Reference Ruangritchankul, Sandison, Warburton, Guerrero-Urbano, Reis Ferreira and Lei12, Reference Almangush, Alabi, De Keukeleire, Makitie, Pirinen and Leivo20 but this finding is not universal.Reference Yin, Rivera, Garcia, Bartemes, Lewis and Lohse15, Reference De Keukeleire, Vermassen, De Meulenaere, Deron, Huvenne and Duprez17, Reference Kazemi, Gharib, Mohamadian Roshan, Taraz Jamshidi, Stogbauer and Eslami31, Reference Ly, Garcia, Blenman, Ehinger, Elfer and Hanna32 De Keukeleire et al.Reference De Keukeleire, Vermassen, De Meulenaere, Deron, Huvenne and Duprez17 reported moderate agreement (Fleiss’ k = 0.31–0.48) in interobserver tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte scores, as did Yin et al.Reference Yin, Rivera, Garcia, Bartemes, Lewis and Lohse15 Furthermore, tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte scoring from oropharyngeal specimens is ostensibly more challenging given the background lymphoid tissue.Reference Yin, Rivera, Garcia, Bartemes, Lewis and Lohse15, Reference Hendry, Salgado, Gevaert, Russell, John and Thapa33 The use of artificial intelligence (AI)Reference Ly, Garcia, Blenman, Ehinger, Elfer and Hanna32, Reference Xirou, Moutafi, Bai, Nwe Aung, Burela and Liu34–Reference Choi, Cho, Jung, Lee, Choi and Song36 and machine learning methodsReference Corredor, Toro, Koyuncu, Lu, Buzzy and Bera16 to improve reliability and reproducibility of tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte scoring has been reported. Future studies or the adoption of tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte scoring in routine clinical practice may benefit from the assistance of AI and standardised methods.Reference Hendry, Salgado, Gevaert, Russell, John and Thapa33

The variable nature of manual tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte scoring and inherent interobserver variability may be contributory factors to the proportion of cases categorised as low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes in our cohort, which was 42.1 per cent. This is comparatively high with respect to other reports in which the low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes proportion ranged from 9 to 34 per cent among patients with oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV.Reference Ruangritchankul, Sandison, Warburton, Guerrero-Urbano, Reis Ferreira and Lei12, Reference Ward, Thirdborough, Mellows, Riley, Harris and Suchak13, Reference De Keukeleire, Vermassen, De Meulenaere, Deron, Huvenne and Duprez17, Reference Kreinbrink, Li, Parajuli, Wise-Draper, Choi and Tang18, Reference Almangush, Jouhi, Haglund, Hagstrom, Makitie and Leivo37 While other clinicopathological characteristics may influence tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte density, there was no difference in terms of smoking (p = 0.61), N stage (p = 0.57) and overall stage (p = 0.26) between the high and low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes groups in our study. Previous studies have similarly reported that tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte score is independent of smoking history.Reference Ward, Thirdborough, Mellows, Riley, Harris and Suchak13, Reference Almangush, Jouhi, Haglund, Hagstrom, Makitie and Leivo37 Almangush et al.Reference Almangush, Jouhi, Haglund, Hagstrom, Makitie and Leivo37 found higher tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte density to be associated with lower T stage. This trend was observed in our cohort without reaching statistical significance (p = 0.17). The large proportion of low tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes cases in our cohort might have skewed survival outcomes.

Fifteen cases were excluded from our analysis because of lack of sufficient archived material. Other retrospective studies examining tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes in oropharyngeal SCC have had to discount cases for the same reason.Reference Ward, Thirdborough, Mellows, Riley, Harris and Suchak13, Reference Kreinbrink, Li, Parajuli, Wise-Draper, Choi and Tang18, Reference Almangush, Jouhi, Haglund, Hagstrom, Makitie and Leivo37 This is, of course, a limitation of the retrospective design but calls into question the generalisability of results from incomplete biological datasets. Previous studies have identified the use of archived biological material as a potential source of bias.Reference Hoppin, Tolbert, Taylor, Schroeder and Holly38, Reference Porta, Malats, Corominas, Rifa, Pinol and Real39 Thus, the use of archived material to inform the prognostic value of specific biomarkers should be approached with caution, with some authors suggesting adherence to certain criteria to do so.Reference Simon, Paik and Hayes40 Insufficient archived material in 20 per cent of our cohort (15 of 74) may have influenced the outcomes observed.

Overexpression of p16 by more than 70 per cent is the accepted surrogate for HPV positivity in clinical practice.Reference Lydiatt, Patel, O’Sullivan, Brandwein, Ridge and Migliacci4, 41 However, it is recognised that between 7 and 19 per cent of p16 positive cases are HPV DNA negative.Reference Ang, Harris, Wheeler, Weber, Rosenthal and Nguyen-Tan1, Reference Albers, Qian, Kaufmann and Coordes42–Reference Craig, Anderson, Moran, Graham, Currie and Rooney44 HPV DNA polymerase chain reaction and/or in situ hybridisation was additionally conducted on 27 patients in this study cohort who showed HPV positivity concordant with p16 positivity. Of the 30 patients who had p16 testing only, there is a risk that these could, in fact, be HPV negative. That said, this risk is estimated to be low because of the high prevalence of oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV in Ireland,Reference Cleere, Murphy, Crotty, Hintze, Timon and Kinsella45, Reference Gallus, Nauta, Marklund, Rizzo, Crescio and Mureddu46 and therefore unlikely to affect the overall results of this study.

In summary, five-year survival data did not differ based on tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte stratification in this study. This finding is in contrast to that in the published literature. Potential reasons for this are outlined above. Nevertheless, tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte scoring based on haematoxylin and eosin-stained slides, in general, shows promise of prognostic value in oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV and may be particularly relevant as immunotherapy becomes more widely used in this disease. The findings of this study suggest further research is warranted. Prospective studies, adopting a standardised tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocyte assessment, should be undertaken to confirm its utility in oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV prognosis before it can be implemented in routine clinical practice.

  • • Human papillomavirus (HPV)-associated squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) compared with non-HPV oropharyngeal SCC typically carries a better prognosis

  • • A subset of patients with oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV experience poor outcomes

  • • Previous studies have suggested tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes can predict survival in oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV

  • • The predictive value of tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes in oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV is not upheld in this study

  • • Further evaluation of the prognostic utility of tumour-infiltrating T-lymphocytes in oropharyngeal SCC associated with HPV is required before it can be incorporated into routine practice

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the Royal Victoria Eye and Ear Hospital Research Foundation (Annual Grant Scheme 2020).

Competing interests

None declared

Footnotes

Michael Fitzsimons takes responsibility for the integrity of the content of the paper

References

Ang, KK, Harris, J, Wheeler, R, Weber, R, Rosenthal, DI, Nguyen-Tan, PF et al. Human papillomavirus and survival of patients with oropharyngeal cancer. N Engl J Med 2010;363:24–35CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dayyani, F, Etzel, CJ, Liu, M, Ho, CH, Lippman, SM, Tsao, AS. Meta-analysis of the impact of human papillomavirus (HPV) on cancer risk and overall survival in head and neck squamous cell carcinomas (HNSCC). Head Neck Oncol 2010;2:15CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
O’Rorke, MA, Ellison, MV, Murray, LJ, Moran, M, James, J, Anderson, LA. Human papillomavirus related head and neck cancer survival: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Oral Oncol 2012;48:1191–201CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lydiatt, WM, Patel, SG, O’Sullivan, B, Brandwein, MS, Ridge, JA, Migliacci, JC et al. Head and neck cancers – major changes in the American Joint Committee on cancer eighth edition cancer staging manual. CA Cancer J Clin 2017;67:122–37Google ScholarPubMed
Amin, MB, Greene, FL, Edge, SB, Compton, CC, Gershenwald, JE, Brookland, RK et al. The Eighth Edition AJCC Cancer Staging Manual: continuing to build a bridge from a population-based to a more ‘personalized’ approach to cancer staging. CA Cancer J Clin 2017;67:93–9Google ScholarPubMed
Nguyen-Tan, PF, Zhang, Q, Ang, KK, Weber, RS, Rosenthal, DI, Soulieres, D et al. Randomized phase III trial to test accelerated versus standard fractionation in combination with concurrent cisplatin for head and neck carcinomas in the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group 0129 trial: long-term report of efficacy and toxicity. J Clin Oncol 2014;32:3858–66CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Gillison, ML, Trotti, AM, Harris, J, Eisbruch, A, Harari, PM, Adelstein, DJ et al. Radiotherapy plus cetuximab or cisplatin in human papillomavirus-positive oropharyngeal cancer (NRG Oncology RTOG 1016): a randomised, multicentre, non-inferiority trial. Lancet 2019;393:40–50CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Mehanna, H, Robinson, M, Hartley, A, Kong, A, Foran, B, Fulton-Lieuw, T et al. Radiotherapy plus cisplatin or cetuximab in low-risk human papillomavirus-positive oropharyngeal cancer (De-ESCALaTE HPV): an open-label randomised controlled phase 3 trial. Lancet 2019;393:51–60CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Mensour, EA, Alam, S, Mawani, S, Bahig, H, Lang, P, Nichols, A et al. What is the future of treatment de-escalation for HPV-positive oropharyngeal cancer? A review of ongoing clinical trials. Front Oncol 2022;12:1067321CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Welters, MJP, Ma, W, Santegoets, S, Goedemans, R, Ehsan, I, Jordanova, ES et al. Intratumoral HPV16-specific T cells constitute a type I-oriented tumor microenvironment to improve survival in HPV16-driven oropharyngeal cancer. Clin Cancer Res 2018;24:634–47CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
de Ruiter, EJ, Ooft, ML, Devriese, LA, Willems, SM. The prognostic role of tumor infiltrating T-lymphocytes in squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Oncoimmunology 2017;6 e1356148CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Ruangritchankul, K, Sandison, A, Warburton, F, Guerrero-Urbano, T, Reis Ferreira, M, Lei, M et al. Clinical evaluation of tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes as a prognostic factor in patients with human papillomavirus-associated oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma. Histopathology 2019;75:146–50CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Ward, MJ, Thirdborough, SM, Mellows, T, Riley, C, Harris, S, Suchak, K et al. Tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes predict for outcome in HPV-positive oropharyngeal cancer. Br J Cancer 2014;110:489–500CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Marsh, D, Suchak, K, Moutasim, KA, Vallath, S, Hopper, C, Jerjes, W et al. Stromal features are predictive of disease mortality in oral cancer patients. J Pathol 2011;223:470–81CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Yin, LX, Rivera, M, Garcia, JJ, Bartemes, KR, Lewis, DB, Lohse, CM et al. Impact of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes on disease progression in human papillomavirus-related oropharyngeal carcinoma. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2023;169:539–47CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Corredor, G, Toro, P, Koyuncu, C, Lu, C, Buzzy, C, Bera, K et al. An imaging biomarker of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes to risk-stratify patients with HPV-associated oropharyngeal cancer. J Natl Cancer Inst 2022;114:609–17CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
De Keukeleire, SJ, Vermassen, T, De Meulenaere, A, Deron, P, Huvenne, W, Duprez, F et al. Tumour infiltrating lymphocytes in oropharyngeal carcinoma: prognostic value and evaluation of a standardised method. Pathology 2021;53:836–43CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kreinbrink, PJ, Li, J, Parajuli, S, Wise-Draper, TM, Choi, DL, Tang, AL et al. Pre-treatment absolute lymphocyte count predicts for improved survival in human papillomavirus (HPV)-driven oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma. Oral Oncol 2021;116:105245CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Faraji, F, Fung, N, Zaidi, M, Gourin, CC, Eisele, DW, Rooper, LM et al. Tumor-infiltrating lymphocyte quantification stratifies early-stage human papillomavirus oropharynx cancer prognosis. Laryngoscope 2020;130:930–8CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Almangush, A, Alabi, RO, De Keukeleire, S, Makitie, AA, Pirinen, M, Leivo, I. Clinical significance of overall assessment of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in oropharyngeal cancer: a meta-analysis. Pathol Res Pract 2023;243:154342CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
O’Sullivan, B, Huang, SH, Su, J, Garden, AS, Sturgis, EM, Dahlstrom, K et al. Development and validation of a staging system for HPV-related oropharyngeal cancer by the International Collaboration on Oropharyngeal cancer Network for Staging (ICON-S): a multicentre cohort study. Lancet Oncol 2016;17:440–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Yamashita, Y, Ikegami, T, Hirakawa, H, Uehara, T, Deng, Z, Agena, S et al. Staging and prognosis of oropharyngeal carcinoma according to the 8th Edition of the American Joint Committee on Cancer Staging Manual in human papillomavirus infection. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 2019;276:827–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Atipas, K, Laokulrath, N, Petsuksiri, J, Ratanaprasert, N, Pongsapich, W. CD8+ T cells and PD-L1 expression as prognostic indicators in a low prevalence of HPV-associated oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma. Curr Oncol 2023;30:1450–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ljokjel, B, Haave, H, Lybak, S, Vintermyr, OK, Helgeland, L, Aarstad, HJ. Tumor infiltration levels of CD3, Foxp3 (+) lymphocytes and CD68 macrophages at diagnosis predict 5-year disease-specific survival in patients with oropharynx squamous cell carcinoma. Cancers (Basel) 2022;14:1508CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Haave, H, Ljokjel, B, Lybak, H, Moe, SE, Berge, JE, Vintermyr, OK et al. Tumor HPV status, level of regulatory T cells and macrophage infiltration predict up to 20-year non-disease-specific survival in oropharynx squamous cell carcinoma patients. Biomedicines 2022;10:2484CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wang, J, Gong, R, Zhao, C, Lei, K, Sun, X, Ren, H. Human FOXP3 and tumour microenvironment. Immunology 2023;168:248–55CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wansom, D, Light, E, Thomas, D, Worden, F, Prince, M, Urba, S et al. Infiltrating lymphocytes and human papillomavirus-16–associated oropharyngeal cancer. Laryngoscope 2012;122:121–7CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Weller, P, Bankfalvi, A, Gu, X, Dominas, N, Lehnerdt, GF, Zeidler, R et al. The role of tumour FoxP3 as prognostic marker in different subtypes of head and neck cancer. Eur J Cancer 2014;50:1291–300CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
De Meulenaere, A, Vermassen, T, Aspeslagh, S, Zwaenepoel, K, Deron, P, Duprez, F et al. Prognostic markers in oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma: focus on CD70 and tumour infiltrating lymphocytes. Pathology 2017;49:397–404CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Oguejiofor, K, Hall, J, Slater, C, Betts, G, Hall, G, Slevin, N et al. Stromal infiltration of CD8 T cells is associated with improved clinical outcome in HPV-positive oropharyngeal squamous carcinoma. Br J Cancer 2015;113:886–93CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kazemi, A, Gharib, M, Mohamadian Roshan, N, Taraz Jamshidi, S, Stogbauer, F, Eslami, S et al. Assessment of the tumor-stroma ratio and tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in colorectal cancer: inter-observer agreement evaluation. Diagnostics (Basel) 2023;13:2339CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Ly, A, Garcia, V, Blenman, KRM, Ehinger, A, Elfer, K, Hanna, MG et al. Training pathologists to assess stromal tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes in breast cancer synergises efforts in clinical care and scientific research. Histopathology 2024;84:915–23CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hendry, S, Salgado, R, Gevaert, T, Russell, PA, John, T, Thapa, B et al. Assessing tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in solid tumors: a practical review for pathologists and proposal for a standardized method from the International Immunooncology Biomarkers Working Group: Part 1: Assessing the host immune response, TILs in invasive breast carcinoma and ductal carcinoma in situ, metastatic tumor deposits and areas for further research. Adv Anat Pathol 2017;24:235–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Xirou, V, Moutafi, M, Bai, Y, Nwe Aung, T, Burela, S, Liu, M et al. An algorithm for standardization of tumor Infiltrating lymphocyte evaluation in head and neck cancers. Oral Oncol 2024;152:106750CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Rakaee, M, Adib, E, Ricciuti, B, Sholl, LM, Shi, W, Alessi, JV et al. Association of machine learning-based assessment of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes on standard histologic images with outcomes of immunotherapy in patients with NSCLC. JAMA Oncol 2023;9:51–60CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Choi, S, Cho, SI, Jung, W, Lee, T, Choi, SJ, Song, S et al. Deep learning model improves tumor-infiltrating lymphocyte evaluation and therapeutic response prediction in breast cancer. NPJ Breast Cancer 2023;9:71CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Almangush, A, Jouhi, L, Haglund, C, Hagstrom, J, Makitie, AA, Leivo, I. Tumor microenvironment-based risk stratification of oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma. Head Neck 2025;47:599–605CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Hoppin, JA, Tolbert, PE, Taylor, JA, Schroeder, JC, Holly, EA. Potential for selection bias with tumor tissue retrieval in molecular epidemiology studies. Ann Epidemiol 2002;12:1–6CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Porta, M, Malats, N, Corominas, JM, Rifa, J, Pinol, JL, Real, FX et al. Generalizing molecular results arising from incomplete biological samples: expected bias and unexpected findings. Ann Epidemiol 2002;12:7–14CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Simon, RM, Paik, S, Hayes, DF. Use of archived specimens in evaluation of prognostic and predictive biomarkers. J Natl Cancer Inst 2009;101:1446–52CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
National Comprehensive Cancer Network. NCCN Clinical Practice Guidelines in Oncology (NCCN Guidelines®) Head and Neck Cancers. Version 1.2024 ed. Plymouth Meeting, PA2024Google Scholar
Albers, AE, Qian, X, Kaufmann, AM, Coordes, A. Meta analysis: HPV and p16 pattern determines survival in patients with HNSCC and identifies potential new biologic subtype. Sci Rep 2017;7:16715CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Mehanna, H, Taberna, M, von Buchwald, C, Tous, S, Brooks, J, Mena, M et al. Prognostic implications of p16 and HPV discordance in oropharyngeal cancer (HNCIG-EPIC-OPC): a multicentre, multinational, individual patient data analysis. Lancet Oncol 2023;3:239–51CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Craig, SG, Anderson, LA, Moran, M, Graham, L, Currie, K, Rooney, K et al. Comparison of molecular assays for HPV testing in oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinomas: a population-based study in Northern Ireland. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 2020;29:31–8CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Cleere, EF, Murphy, J, Crotty, TJ, Hintze, JM, Timon, CVI, Kinsella, J et al. HPV overtakes smoking as the leading cause of oropharyngeal cancer in Ireland: experience of a head and neck surgery tertiary referral centre. Ir J Med Sci 2024;193:2161–9CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gallus, R, Nauta, IH, Marklund, L, Rizzo, D, Crescio, C, Mureddu, L et al. Accuracy of p16 IHC in classifying HPV-driven OPSCC in different populations. Cancers (Basel) 2023;15:656CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Figure 0

Table 1. Overview characteristicsTable 1 long description.

Figure 1

Figure 1. Five-year overall survival.Figure 1 long description.

Figure 2

Figure 2. Five-year disease-specific survival.Figure 2 long description.

Figure 3

Figure 3. Five-year disease-free survival.Figure 3 long description.