Hostname: page-component-6766d58669-bp2c4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-05-18T21:29:41.416Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Becoming Modern and Secular: A Review Essay on Recent Work on Islam and South Asia

Review products

Discussed: Defending Muḥammad in Modernity. By TareenSherAli. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 2020. Pp. 506. $125.00 (cloth); $35.00 (paper); $27.99 (digital). ISBN: 9780268106706.
Governance of Islam in Pakistan: An Institutional Study of the Council of Islamic Ideology. By HolzSarah. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press, 2022. Pp. 240. $70.00 (paper). ISBN: 9781789761665.
Hurt Sentiments: Secularism and Belonging in South Asia. By NairNeeti. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2023. Pp. 352. $45.00 (cloth); $45.00 (digital). ISBN: 9780674238275.

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 August 2024

Carimo Mohomed Open the ORCID record for Carimo Mohomed [Opens in a new window]
Carimo Mohomed*
Affiliation:
Researcher, Centre of Religious History Studies, Catholic University (Portugal); Professor of State, Society, Religion, International Islamic University for Sciences (Spain); Research Fellow, University of Religions and Denominations, Qom (Iran)
*
mohomed.carimo@gmail.com
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The Muslims of South Asia are more than five hundred million people, distributed between Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh, and there are more Muslims in South Asia than in any other region in the world. After Indonesia, which is the largest Muslim country in the world, India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh are the second, third, and fourth largest Muslim countries, respectively. Although the prevalent approach in the study of Islam is to consider its so-called Arab character as central, the Muslims in pre-Partition India constituted the largest body of Muslims in the world, and the vast political and intellectual influence exerted by South Asian Muslims on the wider Muslim world is often neglected. Many of the most important political, intellectual, and spiritual developments within Islam have had their origins, or have flourished, in South Asia, and Muslims from the region have played important roles in the global history of Islam, including during the colonial period, in resistance to colonial rule, and in intellectual responses to and dialogue with Western thought. Pakistan was specifically created to provide a homeland for South Asia’s Muslim population and its trials and tribulations over the past seventy-five years have been carefully watched by Muslims and non-Muslims alike. Muslims constitute India’s largest minority, with an often uneasy—to say the least—relationship to the majority. In the context of the three books under discussion, I explore issues, such as secularism, modernity, and religion, and their impacts on the conception of the nation-state that was promoted during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries as an expression of political modernity.

Keywords

secularismmodernityPakistanIndiaBangladeshIslamHinduism

Information

Type
Review Essay
Information
Journal of Law and Religion , Volume 39 , Issue 2 , May 2024 , pp. 270 - 284
Check for updates
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2024. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Center for the Study of Law and Religion at Emory University

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

1 For a detailed account on the origins, causes, and consequences of the revolt, see Dalrymple, William, The Last Mughal: The Fall of a Dynasty, Delhi, 1857 (London: Bloomsbury, 2007).Google Scholar

2 For example, Malik, Salahuddin, 1857: War of Independence or a Clash of Civilizations? British Public Reactions (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008)Google Scholar.

3 For further details, Saikal, Amin, “Afghanistan and Pakistan: The Question of Pashtun Nationalism?,” Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs 30, no. 1 (2010): 5–17 CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

4 Anderson, Clare, Indian Uprising of 1857–8: Prisons, Prisoners and Rebellion (London: Anthem Press, 2007)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Biswamoy Pati, ed., The 1857 Rebellion (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007).

5 Aryn Baker, “Beyond Faith,” Time, August 13, 2007, 22–29 (Asia and South Pacific editions).

6 Iqbal Singh Sevea, “Islam, State and Modernity: Muslim Political Discourse in Late 19th and Early 20th Century India,” IDSS Working Paper Series, no. 115, Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies, Singapore, 2006.

7 Sen, Amartya, The Argumentative Indian: Writings on Indian History, Culture and Identity (New York: Picador, 2006).Google Scholar

8 “Book Symposium on Defending Muḥammad in Modernity,” Contending Modernities, March 9, 2021, https://contendingmodernities.nd.edu/series/book-symposium-on-defending-muḥammad-in-modernity/; “A Forum on SherAli Tareen’s Defending Muhammad in Modernity,” Marginalia Review of Books, August 19, 2022, https://www.marginaliareviewofbooks.com/post/a-forum-on-sherali-tareen-s-defending-muhammad-in-modernity; SherAli Tareen, “The Politics of Prophetic Love in South Asia,” Canopy Forum, March 8, 2022, https://canopyforum.org/2022/03/08/the-politics-of-prophetic-love-in-south-asia-sherali-tareen/; S. Akbar Zaidi, “Review of Tareen, SherAli K. Defending Muḥammad in Modernity,” H-Asia, H-Net Reviews, April 2021, https://www.h-net.org/reviews/showpdf.php?id=56091.

9 For decades, scholars such as Seyyed Hossein Nasr, Taha Abdurrahman, Henry Corbin (1903–1978), and others, have been drawing people’s attention to the nonsensical nature of these dichotomies.

10 For further details, see Mohomed, Carimo, “Religion as Nation: The Muslims of India and the Debates on qaum, millat, and umma in the 1930s,” Social Sciences 10, no. 6 (2021): 286–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

11 Muhammad Iqbal, “Sir Muhammad Iqbal’s 1930 Presidential Address to the 25th Session of the All-India Muslim League. Allahabad, 29 December,” in Speeches, Writings, and Statements of Iqbal, ed. Latif Ahmed Sherwani, 2nd rev. ed. (1944; rpt. Lahore: Iqbal Academy, 1977), 3–26.

12 Iqbal, Muhammad, The Reconstruction of Religious Thought in Islam, ed. Saeed Sheikh, M. (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2013 [1934]), 123 Google Scholar.

13 Skinner, Quentin, “From the State of Princes to the Person of the State,” in Visions of Politics, volume 2, Renaissance Virtues (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004), 368–413 Google Scholar.

14 Mikhail Bakunin, “The Political Theology of Mazzini and the International,” accessed May 7, 2024, https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/mikhail-bakunin-the-political-theology-of-mazzini-and-the-international; Mikhail Bakunin, “To the Comrades of the International Workingmen’s Association of Locle and Chaux-De-Fonds” (letter), May 7, 2024, https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/bakunin/works/1869/program-letters.htm.

15 Laski, Harold, Studies in the Problem of Sovereignty (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1917), 6.Google Scholar

16 For a brief introduction to Sayyid Ahmad Khan and his work, see The Cambridge Companion to Sayyid Ahmad Khan, ed. Yasmin Saikia and M. Raisur Rahman (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2019).

17 Pakistan Const. (1956); see also Pakistan Const. (1973).

18 Muslim Family Law Ordinance, Ordinance 8 of 1961, Pakistani Code, https://pakistancode.gov.pk/english/UY2FqaJw1-apaUY2Fqa-apaUY2Npa5po-sg-jjjjjjjjjjjjj; Carroll, Lucy, “The Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, 1961: Provisions and Procedures—A Reference Paper for Current Research,” Contributions to Indian Sociology 13, no. 1 (1979): 117–43CrossRefGoogle Scholar. The Hudood Ordinances include three laws: The Prohibition (Enforcement of Hadd) Order, President’s Order No. 4 of 1979; The Offence of Zina (Enforcement of Hudood) Ordinance, Ordinance No. 7 of 1979; The Offence of Qazf (Enforcement of Hadd) Ordinance, Ordinance No. 8 of 1979, https://pakistani.org/pakistan/legislation/hudood.html. See also Charles H. Kennedy, “Islamization in Pakistan: Implementation of the Hudood Ordinances,” Asian Survey 28, no. 3 (1988): 307–16.

19 Nair, Neeti, Changing Homelands: Hindu Politics and the Partition of India (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2011).CrossRefGoogle Scholar

20 Nair, Neeti, “Beyond the ‘Communal’ 1920s: The Problem of Intention, Legislative Pragmatism, and the Making of Section 295A of the Indian Penal Code,” Indian Economic and Social History Review 50, no 3 (2013): 317–40CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

21 Brutal Assassination of Salman Taseer Is Call to Abolish Pakistan’s Blasphemy Laws, Amnesty International, accessed April 21, 2024, https://www.amnestyusa.org/updates/brutal-assassination-of-salman-taseer-is-call-to-abolish-pakistans-blasphemy-laws/; Rafiq, Aayesha, “Section 295-C of Pakistan Penal Code: Controversy and Criticism,” Academic Research International 6, no. 3 (2015): 384–90Google Scholar.

22 The Indian Penal Code, https://lddashboard.legislative.gov.in/sites/default/files/A1860-45.pdf; Adcock, C. S., “Violence, Passion, and the Law: A Brief History of Section 295A and Its Antecedents,” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 84, no. 2 (2016): 337–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

23 Marshall, Heather, “‘We Don’t Have Blasphemy Laws in England’: What Does This Mean for RE?,” Journal of Religious Education, no. 72 (2024): 109–28CrossRefGoogle Scholar.

24 For an example of a flawed description and conception of secularism, see Bhargava, Rajeev, “Political Secularism,” in The Oxford Handbook of Political Theory (New York: Oxford University Press, 2006): 636–55Google Scholar. In addition, the author praises the Indian model of Secularism, completely detached from what was really happening in India, a reality that only got worse with time. For a more accurate analysis of secularism, see Asad, Talal, Formations of the Secular: Christianity, Islam, Modernity (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2003)Google Scholar.

25 For more on this, see Mann, Michael, “State and Society, 1130–1815: An Analysis of English State Finances,” in Political Power and Social Theory, ed. Zeitlin, Maurice (Greenwich: JAI Press, 1979): 1:165–208 Google Scholar; Ertman, Thomas, Birth of the Leviathan: Building States and Regimes in Medieval and Early Modern Europe (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1997): 35–89 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Fischer, Wolfram and Lundgreen, Peter, “The Recruitment and Training of Administrative and Technical Personnel,” in The Formation of National States in Western Europe, ed. Charles Tilly (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1975): 456–561 Google Scholar; Reza Nasr, Seyyed Vali, The Islamic Leviathan: Islam and the Making of State Power (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gorski, Philip S., “The Protestant Ethic Revisited: Disciplinary Revolution and State Formation in Holland and Prussia,” American Journal of Sociology 99, no. 2 (1993): 265–316 CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Wuthnow, Robert, Communities of Discourse: Ideology and Social Structure in the Reformation, the Enlightenment, and European Socialism (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1989)Google Scholar.

26 Kropotkin, Pëtr, Words of a Rebel, trans. Woodcock, George (Montréal: Black Rose Books, 1992), 25.Google Scholar

27 Unless, of course, you are part of the elite, in which case, you are free among equals. For Schmitt’s critique of liberal democracy, see generally Carl Schmitt, The Crisis of Parliamentary Democracy, trans. Ellen Kennedy (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1985). For discussions of Schmitt’s critique, see Richard Bellamy and Peter Baehr, “Carl Schmitt and the Contradictions of Liberal Democracy,” European Journal of Political Research 23, no. 2 (1993) 163–85; Chantal Mouffe, “Carl Schmitt and the Paradox of Liberal Democracy,” Canadian Journal of Law & Jurisprudence 10, no. 1 (1997): 21–33. For a more recent critique, see Xiong, Wanling, “Protecting Democracy from Liberalism: Defending Carl Schmitt’s Critiques of Liberal Democracy” (master’s thesis, University of Leiden, 2019)Google Scholar, https://studenttheses.universiteitleiden.nl/access/item%3A2607914/view.

28 See “Denmark Adopts Law Banning Quran Burnings,” Le Monde, December 7, 2023, https://www.lemonde.fr/en/europe/article/2023/12/07/denmark-adopts-law-banning-quran-burnings_6322184_143.html; Jaroslav Lukiv, “Denmark Passes Law to Ban Quran Burnings,” BBC News, December 7, 2023, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-67651580.

29 H. M. Cole, “Origins of the French Protectorate Over Catholic Missions in China,” American Journal of International Law 34, no. 3 (1940): 473–91; Young, Ernest P., “The Emergence of the French Religious Protectorate in China,” in Ecclesiastical Colony: China’s Catholic Church and the French Religious Protectorate (New York: Oxford Academic, 2013): 11–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

30 See, for example, Costello, Róisín Áine and Ahmed, Sahar, “Citizenship, Identity, and Veiling: Interrogating the Limits of Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights in Cases Involving the Religious Dress of Muslim Women,” Journal of Law and Religion 38, no. 1 (2023): 81–107 CrossRefGoogle Scholar. The prohibitions or the regulations are never about, say, the length of the beard or how trimmed and shaped it should be.

31 For further details, see Basaran, Betül, Selim III Social Control and Policing in Istanbul at the End of the Eighteenth Century: Between Crisis and Order (Leiden: Brill, 2014)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Zarinebaf-Shahr, Fariba, “Women and the Public Eye in Eighteenth-Century Istanbul,” in Women in the Medieval Islamic World: Power, Patronage, and Piety, ed. Hambly, Gavin R. G. (New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1998): 301–24Google Scholar.

32 National Register of Citizens, Government of Assam, Cachar District, accessed April 21, 2024, https://cachar.gov.in/frontimpotentdata/national-register-of-citizens-nrc; Uma Menon, “India’s National Register of Citizens Threatens Mass Statelessness,” Journal of Public and International Affairs, June 2, 2023, https://jpia.princeton.edu/news/indias-national-register-citizens-threatens-mass-statelessness; Vatsal Raj, “The National Register of Citizens and India’s Commitment Deficit to International Law,” LSE Human Rights (blog), August 10, 2020, https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/humanrights/2020/08/10/the-national-register-of-citizens-and-indias-commitment-deficit-to-international-law/;

33 Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019, https://indiancitizenshiponline.nic.in/Documents/UserGuide/E-gazette_2019_20122019.pdf; https://indiancitizenshiponline.nic.in/.

34 Orwell, George, Nineteen Eighty-Four (New York: Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1949); 154.Google Scholar

35 See Barash, Jeffrey Andrew, Martin Heidegger and the Problem of Historical Meaning (New York: Fordham University Press, 2004).Google Scholar