Introduction
Globally, reduction of maternal mortality is recognized as a critical public health priority (Say et al., Reference Say, Chou, Gemmill, Tunçalp and Moller2014). In 2015, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimated that about 830 women die each day from pregnancy- and childbirth-related complications around the world, and that 99% of these maternal deaths occur in developing countries (Alkema et al., Reference Alkema, Chou, Hogan, Zhang and Moller2016). Despite encouraging strides against maternal mortality, Afghanistan still bears a high burden of maternal mortality, estimated at 1291 per 100,000 live births (CSO et al., 2016). Given this statistic, there is a growing need to promote interventions to reverse the current trend of maternal deaths. One such intervention is encouraging active male involvement in their pregnant partners’ utilization of reproductive health care services, which is critical, owing to the well-known positive effects of women’s health-seeking behaviours on maternal and neonatal health outcomes.
According to a joint report by UNICEF and WHO in 2015, the median coverage rate of at least four ANC visits during a previous pregnancy was 55%, with the lowest baseline coverage being in Afghanistan, at only 15% (Requejo et al., Reference Requejo, Bryce and Victora2015). Other key reproductive health care utilization variables were also reported to be low in the country; only 30% of women received ANC during the first trimester of pregnancy, and only 40% and 30% of pregnant women received urine and blood testing during pregnancy, respectively. Furthermore, only 48% of women delivered at a health facility and 40% attended a postnatal check-up within the first 2 days after delivery. Antenatal care visits serve as an ideal entry point for reducing preventable maternal and neonatal morbidity and mortality, where pregnant women and families receive essential consultations and services for safe pregnancy and delivery. Male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners could improve their access to, and knowledge of, maternal and neonatal health issues, which are conducive to favourable reproductive health outcomes (Yargawa & Leonardi-Bee, Reference Yargawa and Leonardi-Bee2015).
Research from other countries has highlighted the positive effect of involving male partners in maternal health on women’s utilization of reproductive health care services during pregnancy, delivery and in the postpartum period (Dudgeon & Inhorn, Reference Dudgeon and Inhorn2004), including enhanced maternal access to antenatal and postnatal services (Redshaw & Henderson, Reference Redshaw and Henderson2013; Tokhi et al., Reference Tokhi, Comrie-Thomson, Davis, Portela, Chersich and Luchters2018; Van der Gaag et al., Reference Van der Gaag, Heilman, Gupta, Nembhard and Barker2019), increased utilization of adequate ANC (Assaf & Davis, Reference Assaf and Davis2018) and ANC during the first trimester (Mohammed et al., Reference Mohammed, Johnston, Vackova, Hassen and Yi2019). In addition, it has been observed that the participation of the male partner in ANC is associated with an increase in the number of deliveries taking place at a health facility (Chattopadhyay, Reference Chattopadhyay2012; Mangeni et al., Reference Mangeni, Nwangi, Mbugua and Mukthar2012). Several systemic reviews have also reported that encouraging male partners to become involved in ANC is a promising intervention for obtaining improved maternal health outcomes, including improved utilization of prenatal and postnatal care (Aguiar & Jennings, Reference Aguiar and Jennings2015; Tokhi et al., Reference Tokhi, Comrie-Thomson, Davis, Portela, Chersich and Luchters2018).
Given the patriarchal and conservative social structure of Afghan society, with pre-defined responsibilities for men and women – including women being unable to act independently or needing a male companion to access health care services (Byrd & Betron, Reference Byrd and Betron2015) – it is of fundamental importance to encourage male involvement in ANC to improve the access of women to maternal health care services. Involving male partners in their pregnant partners’ utilization of reproductive health care services is, in fact, a new idea in developing countries, including Afghanistan, where traditionally maternal health is considered exclusively a woman’s issue. Limited knowledge about ANC among women and their families, lack of financial support and transport problems have been highlighted as potential obstacles to the use of ANC services in Afghanistan (Rahmani & Brekke, Reference Rahmani and Brekke2013). The involvement of male partners in maternal health issues can provide their pregnant partners with informational, financial, instrumental and emotional support (Story et al., Reference Story, Burgard, Lori, Taleb, Ali and Hoque2012; Tokhi et al., Reference Tokhi, Comrie-Thomson, Davis, Portela, Chersich and Luchters2018) and help them improve their health-seeking behaviours to tackle the demand-side barriers to accessing health services. Interventions that involve male partners have been linked to improved couple communication and shared decision-making (Hartmann et al., Reference Hartmann, Gilles, Shattuck, Kerner and Guest2012), which are known to influence maternal health and care-seeking outcomes (Richards et al., Reference Richards, Tolhurst and Theobald2011). Male partners have a crucial role to play in making decisions about health care in the family, which affects their pregnant partners’ access to maternal health services (Dudgeon & Inhorn, Reference Dudgeon and Inhorn2004). Men’s potential influence on maternal health can be better conceptualized through the ‘model of three delays’ that lead to maternal deaths: delay in making the decision to seek care at a health facility, delay in reaching care and delay in the provision of care at the facility (Mahmood et al., Reference Mahmood, Mufidah, Scroggs, Siddiqui and Raheel2018). Male participation, among other factors, can influence the first two delays. In some Afghan families, decisions about referring women to a health facility and arranging transport to it are made by the men of the family, or at least require their approval, since as a cultural norm most women depend on their husbands’ permission as well as their income for accessing and/or receiving health care services.
International communities have put forward important strategies for decreasing maternal mortality, including improved pregnancy, delivery and postpartum care; better health facility services; greater education and heightened awareness levels (Shrestha et al., Reference Shrestha, Bell and Marais2014). However, in addition, the involvement of male partners in reproductive health care is recommended as an essential intervention to improve maternal health outcomes (Varkey et al., Reference Varkey, Mishra, Das, Ottolenghi and Huntington2004; WHO, 2015). Recognizing the dynamic role of male partners, the International Conference on Population and Development (ICPD) (United Nations, 2012) in Cairo and the 4th World Conference on Women (United Nations, 1995) in Beijing formally acknowledged the importance of men’s involvement in improving the sexual and reproductive health and rights of women, and countries were mandated to engage male partners in the implementation of sexual and reproductive health programmes. Particularly, in the ICPD, countries made a commitment to developing effective plans and strategies to involve men in all components of reproductive health care, including family planning, sexual health and maternal health care, which mainly include care during the antenatal, delivery and postnatal periods.
The 2015 WHO Recommendations on Health Promotion Interventions for Maternal and Newborn Health focused on interventions to promote active participation of men during pregnancy, childbirth and after birth, to facilitate and support improved maternal and newborn health outcomes. The interventions are recommended on the condition that women’s choices and their autonomy in making decisions are respected (WHO, 2015).
The Afghanistan health sector stresses the need for the active involvement of men in reproductive health care to improve maternal and child health outcomes. The National Health Strategy 2016–2020 and National Reproductive, Maternal, Newborn, Child, and Adolescent Health Strategy 2017–2021 highlight the role of men in supporting women to increase their demand for, and their access to, quality health services (MoPH, 2016, 2017). Despite the potential benefit of involving men for improving maternal health outcomes, this has been neglected. Using data from the 2015 Afghanistan Demographic and Health Survey (AfDHS), the objective of this study was to examine the association between male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners and the utilization of reproductive health care services by pregnant partners, with the aim of informing maternal health policy recommendations and intervention strategies in Afghanistan.
Methods
Data
The study was based on secondary data from the 2015 AfDHS. This was a nationally representative survey of the Afghan population that employed a two-stage stratified sampling design. The first stage involved selecting 950 clusters: 260 from urban and 690 from rural areas. The second stage involved systematic sampling of households within the clusters.
Study sample
Figure 1 shows the derivation of the study sample. Initially, men re-code and individual re-code datasets from the AfDHS were merged using key variables. The unit of analysis was a couple who met the inclusion criteria of being married and having at least one live birth in the previous 5 years. This allowed the selection of participants with recent experience of ANC and reduced the chances of recall bias. To make sure that the couples were reporting on the same child, only those who gave the same age for their last child and who had completed individual interviews, being questioned about childbirth and ANC for their last child, were included. Eligibility for inclusion also required that the women gave a history of at least one ANC visit during their last pregnancy. The final weighted sample size was 2660 couples. To reduce the categories and simplify interpretation of the variables, the data were re-coded.
Flow chart of study data selection.
Study variables
Dependent variables
Six variables were developed as dependent variables to assess reproductive health care utilization: adequate utilization of ANC services (at least 4 visits), ANC utilization during the first trimester of pregnancy, urine testing during pregnancy, blood testing during pregnancy, institutional delivery and utilization of postnatal care. The number of ANC visits was assessed as a dichotomous categorical variable, created from continuous measurement of the frequency of ANC visits during pregnancy, as follows: ‘adequate ANC’ (four or more ANC visits) and ‘inadequate ANC’ (fewer than 4 visits), in line with the WHO gold standard definition (WHO, 2002, 2007). It is worth noting that the 2016 WHO Guidelines on Antenatal Care for a Positive Pregnancy Experience recommended at least eight ANC visits to reduce perinatal mortality and improve women’s experience of care (WHO, 2016). As the study used 2015 AfDHS data, the previously recommended 4 visits was taken to define ‘adequate ANC’.
‘Utilization of ANC during the first trimester’ was a binary variable constructed from the combined responses to the question on timing of the first ANC check-up. To assess rates of urine and blood testing during pregnancy, binary variables were constructed from the responses to the questions on whether the pregnant partners had undergone the tests. Place of delivery was assessed as a dichotomous variable: home delivery (when the pregnant partner gave birth to the baby in their home or another’s home) and hospital (institutional) delivery (when the delivery took place at a public, private, non-governmental or other type of health facility). To assess the rate of attendance at postnatal check-ups, a binary variable was constructed from the combined responses to a question on health check-up visits after delivery.
Explanatory variable
The major explanatory variable was ‘male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners’. The variable ‘men’s participation during any ANC check-up’ from the men’s questionnaire was used to measure this. This variable was measured by the response to the question ‘were you ever present during any of those antenatal check-ups?’ and was coded ‘yes’ if the male partner accompanied his pregnant partner to the ANC facility, and ‘no’ if he did not. The AfDHS did not inquire if the male partner also participated in ANC consultations, and it is possible that some escorted their pregnant partners to the clinic but then went elsewhere and joined them again after the ANC visit.
Covariates
The covariates included in the study were linked to male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners and reproductive health care service utilization in a theoretical and empirical manner. Male partner’s age was classified into three age groups: 17–28, 29–35 and 36–49 years. Pregnant partner’s age was categorized into: 16–24, 25–34 and 35–49 years. Both partners’ education levels were classified in terms of the formal education system of Afghanistan: no education (0 years), primary education (1–6 years) and secondary education or higher (7 years or more). Male partner’s occupation was categorized into six groups: professional/technical/managerial, clerical, agricultural, self-employed/employee, services/sales, skilled manual and unskilled manual. Pregnant partner’s employment status was ranked according to whether she was working or not. Place of residence was categorized as rural or urban. The AfDHS wealth index was used as a proxy for the socioeconomic status of the household and was designated as ‘poorest’, ‘middle’ and ‘richest’ tertiles. The size of the household was classified based on the number of household members: 3–7, 8–10 or 11+. Decision-making autonomy of pregnant partners was measured using four questions on these topics: who usually made family decisions about the pregnant partner’s health care; large household purchases; visits to the pregnant partner’s family and relatives; and the spending of the male partner’s earnings. Response options included the pregnant partner alone, the pregnant partner jointly with her male partner, her male partner alone, and someone else. A composite score was generated giving a score of 1 to each decision that the pregnant partner made alone or jointly (and 0 otherwise) that yielded a score range of 0–4, with 0 for having no decision-making autonomy in the family (i.e. decisions made solely by the male partner or someone else), 1 for participating in at least one of the four decisions, 2 for participating in two of the four decisions, 3 for participating in three of the four decisions and 4 for participating in all four decisions. The sex of the delivered child was categorized as female or male. A dichotomous variable was created to measure the pregnancy intentions for the last birth (intended: live birth wanted at time of conception; unintended: live birth wanted after conception or not wanted at all). Attitude towards wife beating was based on the question on whether ‘wife beating’ was considered acceptable under the following circumstances: if the wife goes out without telling her male partner; if she neglects the children; if she argues with the male partner; if she refuses to have sex with the male partner; or if she serves burnt food. It was categorized into the dichotomous responses ‘yes’ (if the respondent answered in the affirmative to at least one of these) indicating that wife beating was acceptable and ‘no’ if they answering in the negative to all of these.
Statistical analysis
Data were analysed using Stata software, version 15.1 (Stata Corp). Descriptive statistics were used to summarize the characteristics of the study participants. Several approaches were used to examine whether male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners was associated with the outcome variables. First, bivariate associations were analysed of the rate of male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners with the socio-demographic characteristics and outcome measures of reproductive health. Next, multivariate logistic regression analysis was performed to investigate the effects of the demographic and socioeconomic variables, maternal autonomy, pregnancy intention and male and pregnant partners’ attitudes towards wife beating on the relationship between male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners and utilization of reproductive health care by their pregnant partners. The model was applied with adjustment for demographic and socioeconomic factors. All analyses included survey sampling weights (N=2660). Statistical testing was performed at a 95% level of significance, and a p-value of 0.05 was used as the cut-off point for significant association.
Results
Description of study sample
Figure 2 shows the rates of utilization of reproductive health care services by the pregnant partners. Only 30.5% received adequate ANC, 48.8% commenced ANC during the first trimester, 41.3% and 33.4%, respectively, received urine and blood tests during pregnancy, 70.8% gave birth in an institution and 31.3% utilized postnatal care.
Utilization rate of reproductive health care services by pregnant partners.
Table 1 describes the socio-demographic characteristics of the sample couples. The majority of male partners (36.9%) were aged 17–28 years, and 39.9% had no formal education. Almost half of the pregnant partners (48.6%) were aged 25–34 years, 79.2% had no education and 91% were unemployed. Nearly two-thirds of the couples (70.9%) resided in rural areas, 37.7% were in the poorest wealth tertile and 36% lived in households with eleven or more household members. About one-third of the pregnant partners (34.7%) had no decision-making autonomy, more than half of their delivered children (54.4%) were male and 90% of their births were intended. The majority of male partners (75.4%) and 86.9% of pregnant partners thought that wife beating was acceptable under at least one of the listed circumstances (see Table 1).
Characteristics of couples selected for analysis, Afghanistan DHS 2015, N=2660
a Number of family decisions pregnant partners made alone or jointly with male partners regarding: the pregnant partner’s health care; large household purchases; visits to the female partner’s family and relatives; and the spending of the male partner’s earnings. 0 indicates having no decision-making autonomy in the family (i.e. decisions made solely by male partner or someone else), 1 indicates participating in at least one of the four decisions, 2 indicates participating in two of the four decisions, 3 indicates participating in three of the four decisions and 4 indicates participating in all four decisions.
b Intended: live birth wanted at the time of conception; unintended: live birth wanted after conception or not wanted at all.
c Beating justified if wife goes out without telling male partner; neglects the children; argues with male partner; refuses to have sex with male partner; or serves burnt food. ‘No’ indicates that wife beating is not acceptable under any of these circumstances.
Male attendance at ANC by socio-demographic characteristics of couples
Table 2 shows the percentages of male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners by demographic, socioeconomic, maternal autonomy, pregnancy intention and the couples’ attitude related characteristics. Compared with male partners who did not accompany their pregnant partners to ANC facilities, those who attended at least one ANC visit with their pregnant partners were more educated, more likely to live in an urban area and more likely to have a professional job (clerk or higher). A higher rate of ANC attendance by pregnant partners was also identified among the unemployed pregnant partners and those who had more decision-making autonomy (involved in all four decisions compared with their counterparts).
Percentage male attendance at ANC with pregnant partners by selected socio-demographic characteristics, Afghanistan DHS 2015, N=2660
a Number of family decisions pregnant partners made alone or jointly with male partners regarding: the pregnant partner’s health care; large household purchases; visits to the female partner’s family and relatives; and the spending of the male partner’s earnings. 0 indicates having no decision-making autonomy in the family (i.e. decisions made solely by male partner or someone else), 1 indicates participating in at least one of the four decisions, 2 indicates participating in two of the four decisions, 3 indicates participating in three of the four decisions and 4 indicates participating in all four decisions.
b Intended: live birth wanted at the time of conception; unintended: live birth wanted after conception or not wanted at all.
c Beating justified if wife goes out without telling male partner; neglects the children; argues with male partner; refuses to have sex with male partner; or serves burnt food. ‘No’ indicates that wife beating is not acceptable under any of these circumstances.
p<0.05 indicates a significant difference; ‘ns’ indicates not significant.
Trends in associations of male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners and other variables were also observed, including age of the male partner, number of household members, wealth status, pregnancy intention, sex of the child and attitude towards wife beating, although these were not statistically significant.
Male attendance at ANC and utilization of reproductive health care services
The percentage of male attendance at ANC at least once with their pregnant partners in relation to components of ANC utilized, as well as the tendency for institutional delivery and attendance at postnatal care, are presented in Table 3. A higher proportion of pregnant partners whose male partners accompanied them to at least one ANC visit had adequate ANC, received ANC during the first trimester, underwent urine and blood testing during pregnancy, gave birth in an institution and presented for postnatal care compared with those whose male partners never accompanied them to ANC visits.
Percentage male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners by utilization of reproductive health care services, Afghanistan DHS 2015, N=2660
p<0.05 indicates a significant difference; ‘ns’ indicates not significant.
Table 4 shows the factors associated with male attendance at ANC. Being an urban resident increased the likelihood of men’s attendance at ANC by 1.49 times. On the other hand, it was lower for pregnant partners who were employed and for male partners with non-professional occupations (services/sales, skilled and unskilled manual).
Association between male attendance at ANC with pregnant partners and selected socio-demographic variables, Afghanistan DHS 2015, N=2660
a Intended: live birth wanted at the time of conception; unintended: live birth wanted after conception or not wanted at all.
b Beating justified if wife goes out without telling male partner; neglects the children; argues with male partner; refuses to have sex with male partner; or serves burnt food. ‘No’ indicates that wife beating is not acceptable under any of these circumstances.
OR=Odds Ratio; CI=Confidence Interval.
p<0.05 indicates a significant difference; ‘ns’ indicates not significant.
Results of logistic regression analysis
Table 5 shows the results of multivariate analyses. After adjustments for socio-demographic factors, the odds of utilizing adequate ANC were 1.42 times higher for pregnant partners whose male partners attended at least one ANC visit than for those whose male partners did not attend any ANC visits with them (AOR=1.42, 95% CI: 1.18–1.71). Several of the factors, such as the pregnant partner’s education level, place of residence and decision-making autonomy, positively influenced the rate of fulfilment of the criteria for adequate ANC. Pregnant partners who had higher education levels, resided in urban areas and had strong decision-making autonomy were more likely to have ‘adequate ANC’. On the other hand, pregnant partners aged 25–34 years, living in households with eight or more members, who were rich, currently working and who said that wife beating was acceptable under at least one of the circumstances listed were less likely to receive adequate ANC.
Association between reproductive health care utilization and male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners adjusted by other variables, Afghanistan DHS 2015, N=2660
a Number of family decisions pregnant partners made alone or jointly with male partners regarding: the pregnant partner’s health care; large household purchases; visits to the female partner’s family and relatives; and the spending of the male partner’s earnings. 0 indicates having no decision-making autonomy in the family (i.e. decisions made solely by male partner or someone else), 1 indicates participating in at least one of the four decisions, 2 indicates participating in two of the four decisions, 3 indicates participating in three of the four decisions and 4 indicates participating in all four decisions.
b Intended: live birth wanted at the time of conception; unintended: live birth wanted after conception or not wanted at all.
c Beating justified if wife goes out without telling male partner; neglects the children; argues with male partner; refuses to have sex with male partner; or serves burnt food. ‘No’ indicates that wife beating is not acceptable at all of these circumstances.
***p<0.001; **p<0.01; *p<0.05.
Male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners was significantly associated with the commencement of ANC during the first trimester of pregnancy. The odds of this were 1.21 times higher for pregnant partners whose male partners attended at least one ANC visit with them than for those whose male partners never accompanied them for any ANC visit (AOR=1.21, 95% CI: 1.03–1.42). Pregnant partners aged 25 years or over and who resided in urban areas were more likely to commence ANC in the first trimester than those in other categories. On the other hand, pregnant partners who were currently working, lived in households with 8–10 members and whose male partners were above 29 years old were less likely to commence ANC in the first trimester than their counterparts.
The multivariate analysis revealed no association between the rate of urine and blood testing performed during pregnancy and male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners.
Male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners markedly increased the rate of institutional delivery (AOR=1.23, 95% CI: 1.03–1.47). Pregnant partners who were educated, resided in urban areas and who lived in households with eight or more members were more likely to give birth at a health facility. On the other hand, pregnant partners saying wife beating was acceptable under at least one of the circumstances listed were less likely to give birth at a hospital.
Male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners was associated with a higher rate of utilization of postnatal care services (AOR=1.24, 95% CI: 1.04–1.47). The likelihood of utilizing postnatal care was higher in pregnant partners who were currently working and who resided in urban areas compared with other groups. On the other hand, pregnant partners with a secondary level of education and who had weak decision-making autonomy were less likely to receive postnatal care than their counterparts.
Discussion
This study provides evidence on the influence of male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners on health care measures for pregnancy, delivery and postpartum care in Afghanistan. The findings show that male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners significantly increased pregnant partners’ utilization of ANC services, commencing ANC during the first trimester, utilization of institutional delivery and postnatal check-up attendance.
The overall rate of male attendance at ANC in the study sample was high. Seven out of ten male partners whose pregnant partners needed ANC accompanied their partners to ANC services, which is comparable to figures reported in similar studies in Kenya (Mangeni et al., Reference Mangeni, Nwangi, Mbugua and Mukthar2012), Myanmar (Wai et al., Reference Wai, Shibanuma, Oo, Fillman, Saw and Jimba2015) and Uganda (Tweheyo et al., Reference Tweheyo, Konde-Lule, Tumwesigye and Sekandi2010) of 68.4%, 64.8% and 65.4%, respectively. However, it was higher than the rates reported in studies conducted in Nepal (39.3%) (Bhatta, Reference Bhatta2013), Ethiopia (19.7%) (Asefa et al., Reference Asefa, Geleto and Dessie2014), Malawi (13.7%) (Kalembo et al., Reference Kalembo, Zgambo, Mulaga, Yukai and Ahmed2013) and Nigeria (24%) (Akinpelu & Oluwaseyi, Reference Akinpelu and Oluwaseyi2014), but lower than the rates reported in India (90.5%) (Varkey et al., Reference Varkey, Mishra, Das, Ottolenghi and Huntington2004) and Rwanda (86.8%) (NISR, 2010). These discrepant rates could be attributable to socio-cultural differences across countries and differences in the periods when the studies were conducted. Thus, the findings of this study indicate that an encouraging platform is already in place for male partners’ attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners in Afghanistan, which could serve as a catalyst to achieve full-scale male involvement in reproductive health care.
The study found independent associations between male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners and reproductive health service utilization not only in terms of ANC visits, but also rate of institutional deliveries and postnatal check-ups. Among the reproductive health care utilization outcomes, that which was most influenced by men’s attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners was adequate utilization (four or more visits) of ANC facilities. Male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners increased the likelihood of pregnant partners receiving adequate ANC, in compliance with WHO guidelines; pregnant partners whose partners accompanied them for at least one ANC visit were more likely to sufficiently utilize ANC services than those whose male partners did not accompany them. This could imply that men who accompanied their pregnant partners for their ANC visits had greater knowledge about the importance of ANC. Similar findings have been reported in a previous study based on data obtained from the most recent DHS survey conducted in 33 countries (Assaf & Davis, Reference Assaf and Davis2018), which showed that pregnant partners whose male partners were present during at least one ANC visit had a higher likelihood of attending at least four ANC visits compared with those whose male partners were not present during any of their ANC visits. However, a study conducted in Vietnam found no correlation between male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners and satisfactory utilization (four or more visits) of ANC services (Ha et al., Reference Ha, Tac, Duc, Duong and Thi2015).
Consistent with the results of a community-based couple study conducted in Ethiopia (Mohammed et al., Reference Mohammed, Johnston, Vackova, Hassen and Yi2019), the current study also found that pregnant partners who attended ANC with their spouses were more likely to commence their ANC visits in the first trimester of pregnancy. It is important for pregnant partners to seek care from an early stage of pregnancy to ensure care of their own health and that of their babies, and that any potential risks are identified in a timely manner. Pregnant partner’s age and area of residence were significant factors influencing early seeking of ANC: pregnant partners aged 25 years or over and those residing in urban areas commenced care earlier than those who were younger and who lived in rural areas. This could be because older women have greater awareness of the need for care during pregnancy and understand the importance of receiving health consultations for reproductive health concerns early so as to prevent/reduce possible risks, even at an early stage.
No significant association was found between male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners and the rate of performance of blood and urine tests during pregnancy. However, a study conducted in Ethiopia demonstrated a positive association and revealed that pregnant partners who attended ANC with their male partners were more likely to receive such tests during pregnancy than those who attended ANC without their male partners (Forbes et al., Reference Forbes, Wynter, Wade, Zeleke and Fisher2018). Therefore, further studies are needed to investigate this association in Afghanistan.
The study also showed that male partners’ presence during ANC consultations improved institutional delivery rates. Improved rates of these care-seeking behaviours could have resulted from the pregnant partners having felt more empowered by their partner’s support to make decisions to meet their own health care needs and those of their infants. These findings are consistent with reports from prior studies that showed increased rates of health facility births in couples with higher overall involvement of their male partners (Chattopadhyay, Reference Chattopadhyay2012; Mangeni et al., Reference Mangeni, Nwangi, Mbugua and Mukthar2012; Kalembo et al., Reference Kalembo, Zgambo, Mulaga, Yukai and Ahmed2013; Mohammed et al., Reference Mohammed, Johnston, Vackova, Hassen and Yi2019). In contrast, a study conducted in Nepal found that pregnant partners receiving ANC education along with their male partners had no effect on their place of delivery (Mullany et al., Reference Mullany, Becker and Hindin2007).
Pregnant partners who were accompanied by their male partners to ANC were more likely to utilize PNC services. A randomized controlled trial on the impact of the male partner’s involvement in ANC in Nepal reported a similar finding (Mullany et al., Reference Mullany, Becker and Hindin2007), as did prior studies conducted in other developing countries (Mon et al., Reference Mon, Phyu, Thinkhamrop and Thinkhamrop2018; Rahman et al., Reference Rahman, Perkins, Islam, Siddique and Moinuddin2018). Given such positive effects, encouraging male involvement in ANC programmes may be an effective strategy for improving pregnant partners’ utilization of reproductive health care services.
The concept of male involvement in reproductive health care is broad and multifaceted and could include a wide range of ideas, from the male partners physically attending a health facility-based activity with their pregnant partners to provision of emotional and instrumental support for pregnant partners’ health from the start of pregnancy to the end of the postnatal period. In a nutshell, there is no specific operational definition of what might constitute ‘male involvement’ or any uniform method/standardized indicator to measure it. Some studies use the terms ‘male involvement’, ‘men’s attendance’, ‘men’s accompaniment’, ‘male participation’ and ‘male engagement’ interchangeably when it comes to reproductive health, depending on the settings. In the context of Afghanistan, male participation in ANC denotes male partners accompanying their pregnant partners to ANC facilities. Some of the male partners could have escorted their pregnant partners to the clinic and then gone elsewhere to then return again to fetch their partners after the ANC visit. Some studies used certain proxy indicators to rate male involvement, including accompanying the pregnant partner to the ANC visit at least two times, having knowledge of the danger signs of pregnancy, having knowledge about the number of ANC visits representing adequate ANC, being present during childbirth, giving financial support, identifying the health facility for delivery and arranging transport (Matiang’i et al., Reference Matiang’i, Mojola and Githae2014). The term ‘male involvement’ is typically used to indicate that male partners have knowledge about, and participate in, ANC. It can be directed towards participatory roles such as acting as partners and making joint decisions that will improve the health outcomes of women and children. Involvement of men is also linked with being accessible, supportive, patient and kind to their pregnant partners and understanding pregnancy-related issues (Alio et al., Reference Alio, Lewis, Scarborough, Harris and Fiscella2013). It may be concluded that more sophisticated measures of ‘male involvement’ are required that can fit various research contexts.
The findings of this study suggest that education has a crucial role to play in ensuring ANC attendance by male partners in maternal health care in Afghanistan. Male partners with higher levels of education were found to be more likely to accompany their pregnant partners to ANC than their peers with lower levels of, or no, education. In Afghanistan, educated men benefit more from health promotion programmes that cover awareness-raising and behavioural change interventions to foster improved maternal and neonatal health. These programmes can help with a variety of interventions – from better understanding of maternal health care services to recognizing the need for the involvement of male partners in their pregnant partners’ reproductive health, including ANC visits. It is also likely that educated men make informed decisions about seeking care, while discarding negative attitudes and harmful cultural beliefs and practices. It is also worth noting that men with higher levels of education may have formal employment with better salaries, which enable them to bear the health care-related costs of their pregnant partners. On the other hand, uneducated men or those who have little education are perceived to hold onto outdated cultural traditions/beliefs and put more constraints on their pregnant partners’ mobility and decision-making, which can negatively affect male attendance at ANC. This finding is in line with studies conducted in different countries that showed increased likelihood of involvement of the male partner in maternal health care in association with obtaining formal education (Byamugisha et al., Reference Byamugisha, Tumwine, Semiyaga and Tylleskär2010; Shahjahan et al., Reference Shahjahan, Mumu, Afroz, Chowdhury, Kabir and Ahmed2013). In this context, it is noteworthy that studies conducted in Nepal and Bangladesh have revealed that no education or low level of education increased the odds of active involvement of men in reproductive health issues (Bhatta, Reference Bhatta2013; Bishwajit et al., Reference Bishwajit, Tang, Yaya, Ide and Fu2017).
Men’s occupation was found to influence their attendance at ANC. Those with formal occupations (professional, technical, managerial or clerical) have higher levels of education and better information about maternal health issues. Given the prevailing situation in Afghanistan, men who are informally employed, particularly self-employed or daily-wage employees, spend most of their time at their workplaces and lack the time to attend ANC activities with their spouses during the working hours of health facilities. This is concordant with a study conducted in Nepal, which reported that men with formal occupations were more likely to accompany their pregnant partners to ANC visits (Bhatta, Reference Bhatta2013). The findings of the current study are in contrast to those of a study conducted in Kenya, which reported that the majority of employed men who escorted their spouses to ANC did not have formal jobs (Ongeso & Okoth, Reference Ongeso and Okoth2018). As for pregnant partners’ employment, it was found that pregnant partners who were not employed were more likely to get their male partners involved in ANC compared with those who were employed. However, a study conducted in Ethiopia indicated that housewives were less likely to be escorted by their spouses to ANC visits (Asefa et al., Reference Asefa, Geleto and Dessie2014). Within the context of Afghanistan, where the majority of men have informal employment, there is a critical need for important strategies to engage informal employees in maternal health care services.
A higher proportion of male partners living in urban areas escorted their pregnant partners to ANC visits than those living in rural areas. Urban residents in Afghanistan were more likely to utilize maternal health services (MoPH & KIT, 2018). This could be because people residing in urban areas have more knowledge about the importance of pregnant partners’ reproductive health care, have a higher socioeconomic status, have greater exposure to the media and enjoy access to well-equipped health care services, all of which are likely to improve health care utilization.
Although males in urban areas are pre-occupied with formal jobs, they can take some time off work to accompany their wives for ANC visits. Consistently, higher levels of education and raised awareness of health issues among urban dwellers could enable men to recognize their responsibilities towards supporting their partners in accessing health care and shed the misconception that reproductive health care is only a concern of women. Urban males are less likely to feel ashamed to be involved in the utilization of health care services for their pregnant partners than rural men, who often think it is below their dignity to walk alongside their pregnant partners. This result is in line with studies conducted in Ethiopia, which reported a higher likelihood of male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners in urban areas (Asefa et al., Reference Asefa, Geleto and Dessie2014; Kassahun et al., Reference Kassahun, Worku, Nigussie and Ganfurie2018). In contrast, a study in Bangladesh showed opposite results – that men residing in urban areas had lower odds of accompanying their pregnant partners for ANC visits compared with those living in rural areas (Bishwajit et al., Reference Bishwajit, Tang, Yaya, Ide and Fu2017). This suggests that programmes on male involvement should focus on rural residents to improve male attendance at ANC in Afghanistan.
Women’s empowerment was also a factor that significantly increased a women’s likelihood of being accompanied by their male partners to receive ANC. Thus empowering women could be a promising strategy for enhancing their male partners’ involvement in their ANC. The findings of this study are consistent with evidence from a study conducted in selected African countries, which reported that women with higher empowerment were more likely to have their male partners accompany them to ANC compared with women with lower degrees of empowerment in Burkina Faso and Uganda, but the opposite was reported in Malawi (Jennings et al., Reference Jennings, Na, Cherewick, Hindin, Mullany and Ahmed2014). Conversely, studies conducted in Nepal have revealed that higher decision-making autonomy of women is associated with lower rates of male participation in maternal health issues (Mullany et al., Reference Mullany, Hindin and Becker2005; Thapa & Niehof, Reference Thapa and Niehof2013).
In conclusion, the study findings provide evidence that, in Afghanistan, male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners is associated with those partners receiving not only adequate and timely antenatal care – four or more ANC visits and ANC during the first trimester – but also increases their likelihood of giving birth at a health facility and utilizing postnatal care. Therefore, it is recommended that the Ministry of Public Health design policies and behaviour change strategies that influence the involvement of male partners in ANC to improve reproductive health outcomes and ultimately contribute to a reduction in maternal and childhood mortality and morbidity in Afghanistan, where pregnant mothers and children are still dying at alarming rates. On balance, the findings demonstrated a good proportion of male attendance at ANC in Afghanistan. Public health managers should put effort into designing programmes that target wider inclusion of male partners in ANC consultations to support the existing encouraging platform and increase reproductive health care utilization. The findings could be applied to implement community-wide awareness and education programmes for male partners to further sensitize them to the benefits of their involvement in ensuring and supporting their pregnant partners in health seeking behaviours. Additional qualitative research is needed to obtain a more in-depth understanding of the attitudes and perceptions of men, women, and health care providers towards male involvement in reproductive health issues in Afghanistan. Qualitative measures could also assist in identifying the cultural dimensions, potential barriers/facilitators and contributory factors to effect changes in what is traditionally viewed as a woman’s concern alone.
Study strengths and limitations
The study had some limitations. The cross-sectional nature of the DHS data could have introduced reporting bias arising from socially desirable responses of the study participants, particularly regarding male attendance at ANC with their pregnant partners. It also did not allow collection of information about why many males did not attend ANC with their pregnant partners; a male partner’s absence from home may be the reason, rather than that he was unwilling to attend or was uninterested. The AfDHS did not explicitly inquire whether male partners also participated in ANC consultations along with their pregnant partners. This would help provide clear understanding of male partners present during ANC consultations and male partners only escorting their pregnant partners to the clinic for the ANC visits and did not attend the consultations. Reverse causation may be also a possible alternative explanation for associations between the exposure and outcome measures. Ultimately, this study only targeted attendees of ANC clinics and excluded pregnant partners who had never visited an ANC clinic; thus, the data did not represent all pregnant partners in the Afghanistan Demographic and Health Survey.
Funding
This work was partly supported by a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Study of Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (17H02164).
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that they had no conflicts of interest.
Ethical Approval
This study used microdata from the 2015 Afghanistan Demographic and Health Survey (DHS 2015/AfDHS 2015), which was conducted with ethical approval from the Central Statistics Organization (CSO) and the Ministry of Public Health (MoPH) of Government of Islamic Republic of Afghanistan. The authors obtained the microdata without personal identification information on 31st October 2018.
Open access
