Hostname: page-component-77f85d65b8-6c7dr Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-04-19T09:24:55.076Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Maybe He's Depressed: Mental Illness as a Mitigating Factor for Drug Offender Accountability

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  27 December 2018

Leslie Paik
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Given the often perplexing relationship between mental illness and substance abuse among offenders, this article looks at how a juvenile drug court staff's presumptions of a youth's mental illness affect its decision‐making process. Based on thirteen months of ethnographic fieldwork at a Southern California juvenile drug court, this article uses Manzo and Travers's “law in action” approach to analyze how the staff readjusts its application of normal remedies (a concept developed by Robert Emerson) designed to respond to a youth's noncompliance when it suspects mental illness may be influencing the youth's actions. In doing so, it highlights how court staff's considerations of youth mental disorders arise out of its everyday work practices. Furthermore, the article discusses how staff negotiations around a youth's mental illness create tensions for the juvenile drug court's accountability‐based model of therapeutic jurisprudence, because assessments of mental illness tend to mitigate responsibility for a youth's behavior.

Information

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Social Inquiry , Volume 34 , Issue 3 , Summer 2009 , pp. 569 - 602
Copyright
Copyright © American Bar Foundation, 2009 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Article purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

References

Aos, Steven, Phipps, Polly, Barnoski, Robert, and Lieb, Roxanne. 2001. The Comparative Costs and Benefits of Programs to Reduce Recidivism. Olympia: Washington State Institute for Public Policy.Google Scholar
Atkins, D. Lanette, Pumariega, Andres J., Rogers, Kenneth, Montgomery, Larry, Nybro, Cheryl, Jeffers, Gary, and Sease, Franklin. 1999. Mental Health and Incarcerated Youth I: Prevalence and Nature of Psychopathology. Journal of Child and Family Studies 8:193–204.Google Scholar
Atkinson, J. M., and Paul, Drew. 1979. Order in Court: The Organisation of Verbal Interaction in Judicial Settings. London: Macmillan Press.Google Scholar
Baar, Carl. 2002. What the Data Shows. Fordham Urban Law Journal 29:1827–57.Google Scholar
Bavon, A. 2001. The Effect of the Tarrant County Drug Court Project on Recidivism. Evaluation and Program Planning 24:13–22.Google Scholar
Belenko, Steven. 2001. Research on Drug Courts: A Critical Review: 2001 Update. New York: National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse.Google Scholar
Berman, Greg, and Feinblatt, John. 2005. Good Courts. New York and London: New Press.Google Scholar
Bortner, M.A. 1982. Inside a Juvenile Court: The Tarnished Ideal of Individualized Justice. New York: New York University Press.Google Scholar
Braithwaite, John, and Mugford, Steven. 1994. Conditions of Successful Reintegration Ceremonies: Dealing with Juvenile Offenders. British Journal of Criminology 34:139–56.Google Scholar
Bridges, George, and Steen, Sara. 1998. Racial Disparities in Official Assessments of Juvenile Offenders: Attributional Stereotypes as Mediating Mechanisms. American Sociological Review 63:554–70.Google Scholar
Burns, Stacy, and Peyrot, Mark. 2003. Tough Love: Nurturing and Coercing Responsibility and Recovery in California Drug Courts. Social Problems 50:416–38.Google Scholar
Butts, Jeffrey, and Roman, John, eds. 2004. Juvenile Drug Courts and Teen Substance Abuse. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.Google Scholar
Butzin, Clifford, Saum, Christine, and Scarpitti, Frank. 2002. Factors Associated with Completion of a Drug User Treatment Court Diversion Program. Substance Use and Misuse 37:1615–33.Google Scholar
Carey, Shannon, and Finnigan, Michael W. 2004. A Detailed Cost Analysis in a Mature Drug Court Setting: A Cost‐Benefit Evaluation of the Multnomah County Drug Court. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 20:315–38.Google Scholar
Cavender, Gray, and Knepper, Paul. 1992. Strange Interlude: An Analysis of Juvenile Parole Revocation Decision Making. Social Problems 39:387–99.Google Scholar
Charmaz, Kathy. 1983. The Grounded Theory Model: An Explication and Interpretation. In Contemporary Field Research: A Collection of Readings, 1st ed., ed. Emerson, Robert M., 109–26. Prospect Heights, IL: Waveland Press, Inc.Google Scholar
Cook, Kimberly. 2006. Doing Difference and Accountability in Restorative Justice Conferences. Theoretical Criminology 10:107–24.Google Scholar
Cooper, Caroline S. 2002. Juvenile Drug Treatment Courts in the United States: Initial Lessons Learned and Issues Being Addressed. Substance Use and Misuse 37:1689–722.Google Scholar
Daly, Kathleen. 2002. Restorative Justice: The Real Story. Punishment and Society 4:55–79.Google Scholar
Dorf, Michael, and Sabel, Charles F. 2000. Drug Treatment Courts and Emergent Experimentalist Government. Vanderbilt Law Review 53:829–83.Google Scholar
Drew, Paul. 1992. Contested Evidence in Courtroom Cross‐Examination: The Case of a Trial for Rape. In Talk at Work: Interaction in Institutional Settings, ed. Drew, Paul and Heritage, John, 470–520. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Emerson, Robert M. 1969. Judging Delinquents: Context and Process in Juvenile Court. Chicago: Aldine.Google Scholar
Emerson, Robert M. 1974. Role Determinants in Juvenile Court. In Handbook of Criminology, ed. Glaser, Daniel, 621–50. Chicago: Rand McNally College Publishing Co.Google Scholar
Emerson, Robert M. 1981. On Last Resorts. American Journal of Sociology 87:1–22.Google Scholar
Emerson, Robert M., and Paley, Blair. 1992. Organizational Horizons and Compliant‐Filing. In Official Uses of Discretion, ed. Hawkins, Keith, 232–47. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
Goldkamp, John, White, Michael, and Robinson, Jennifer. 2001. Do Drug Courts Work? Getting Inside the Drug Court Black Box. Journal of Drug Issues 31:27–72.Google Scholar
Goodwin, Charles. 1994. Professional Vision. American Anthropologist 96:606–33.Google Scholar
Gottfredson, Denise C., Najaka, Stacy S., and Kearley, Brook. 2003. Effectiveness of Drug Treatment Courts: Evidence from a Randomized Trial. Criminology and Public Policy 2 (2):171–96.Google Scholar
Granfield, Robert, Eby, Cynthia, and Brewster, Thomas. 1998. An Examination of the Denver Drug Court: The Impact of a Treatment‐Oriented Drug Offender System. Law and Policy 20 (2): 183–202.Google Scholar
Grisso, Thomas, and Underwood, Lee A. 2004. Screening and Assessing Mental Health and Substance Use Disorders among Youth in the Juvenile Justice System. Washington, DC: US Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.Google Scholar
Harrell, Adele, and Roman, Mark. 2001. Reducing Drug Use and Crime among Offenders: The Impact of Graduated Sanctions. Journal of Drug Issues 31:207–32.Google Scholar
Hepburn, John, and Harvey, Angela N. 2007. The Effect of the Threat of Legal Sanction on Program Retention and Completion: Is that Why They Stay in Drug Court? Crime & Delinquency 53:255–80.Google Scholar
Hirschfield, Paul, Maschi, Tina, White, Helene R., Traub, Leah G., and Loeber, Rolf. 2006. Mental Health and Juvenile Arrests: Criminality, Criminalization, or Compassion? Criminology 44:593–630.Google Scholar
Hoffman, Morris. 2002. The Denver Drug Court and Its Unintended Consequences. In Drug Courts in Theory and in Practice, ed. Nolan, James L. Jr., 67–88. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Hora, Peggy Fulton, Schma, William G., and Rosenthal, John T. A. 1999. Therapeutic Jurisprudence and the Drug Treatment Court Movement: Revolutionizing the Criminal Justice System's Response to Drug Abuse and Crime in America. Notre Dame Law Review 74:439–537.Google Scholar
Jacobs, Mark D. 1990. Screwing the System and Making It Work: Juvenile Justice in the No Fault Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
Lewis, Dorothy. 1980. Race Bias in the Diagnosis and Disposition of Violent Adolescents. The American Journal of Psychiatry 137:1211–16.Google Scholar
Lewis, Dorothy, Balla, David, and Shanok, Shelly. 1979. Some Evidence of Race Bias in the Diagnosis and Treatment of the Juvenile Offender. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 49:53–61.Google Scholar
Lewis, Dorothy, Shanok, Shelly, and Pincus, Jonathan. 1982. A Comparison of the Neuropsychiatric Status of Female and Male Incarcerated Delinquents: Some Evidence of Sex and Race Bias. Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry 21:190–96.Google Scholar
Longshore, Douglas, Turner, Susan, Wenzel, Suzanne, Morral, Andrew, Harrell, Adele, McBride, Duane, Deschenes, Elizabeth, and Iguchi, Martin. 2001. Drug Courts: A Conceptual Framework. Journal of Drug Issues 31:7–26.Google Scholar
Mackinem, Mitchell B., and Higgins, Paul. 2007. Tell Me about the Test: The Construction of Truth and Lies in Drug Court. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 36:223–51.Google Scholar
Manzo, John F., and Max, Travers, eds. 1998. Law in Action: Ethnomethodological and Conversation Analytic Approaches to Law. London: Dartmouth Press.Google Scholar
Maynard, Douglas. 1982. Offender Attributes in Plea Bargaining. Social Problems 29:347–60.Google Scholar
Maynard, Douglas. 1984. Inside Plea Bargaining: the Language of Negotiation. New York: Plenum Press.Google Scholar
Miethe, Terance D., Lu, Hong, and Reese, Erin. 2000. Reintegrative Shaming and Recidivism Risks in Drug Court: Explanations for Some Unexpected Findings. Crime and Delinquency 46:522–41.Google Scholar
Mirchandani, Rekha. 2005. What's So Special about Specialized Courts? The State and Social Change in Salt Lake City's Domestic Violence Court. Law and Society 39:379–417.Google Scholar
Nolan, James L. Jr. 2001. Reinventing Justice: The American Drug Court Movement. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
Nolan, James L. Jr. 2002. Drug Courts in Theory and in Practice. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Otto, Randy, Greenstein, Jonathan, Johnson, M. K., and Friedman, Joseph. 1992. Prevalence of Mental Disorders among Youth in the Juvenile Justice System. In Responding to the Mental Health Needs of Youth in the Juvenile Justice System, ed. Cocozza, Joseph J. Seattle, WA: National Coalition for the Mentally Ill in the Criminal Justice System.Google Scholar
Peters, Roger H., and Murrin, Mary R. 2000. Effectiveness of Treatment‐Based Drug Courts in Reducing Criminal Recidivism. Criminal Justice and Behavior 27:72–96.Google Scholar
Pranis, Kay. 2001. Restorative Justice, Social Justice, and the Empowerment of Marginalized Populations. In Restorative Community Justice: Repairing Harm and Transforming Community, ed. Bazemore, S. Gordon and Schiff, Maria, 287–306. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson Publishing Co.Google Scholar
Quinn, Mae C. 2000-2001. Whose Team Am I on Anyway? Musings of a Public Defender about Drug Treatment Court Practice. New York University Review of Law and Social Change 26:37–75.Google Scholar
Rempel, Michael, Fox‐Kralstein, Dana, Cissner, Amanda, Cohen, Robyn, Labriola, Melissa, Farole, Donald, Bader, Ann, and Magnani, Michael. 2003. The New York State Adult Drug Court Evaluation: Policies, Participants and Impacts. New York: Center for Court Innovation.Google Scholar
Rosenfield, Sarah, Phillips, Julie, and White, Helene. 2006. Gender, Race, and the Self in Mental Health and Crime. Social Problems 53:161–85.Google Scholar
Spohn, Cassie, Piper, R. K., Martin, Tom, Frenzel, Erika Davis. 2001. Drug Courts and Recidivism: The Results of an Evaluation Using Two Comparison Groups and Multiple Indicators of Recidivism. Journal of Drug Issues 31 (1): 149–76.Google Scholar
Steen, Sara. 2002. West Coast Drug Courts: Getting Offenders Morally Involved in the Criminal Justice Process. In Drug Courts in Theory and in Practice Social Problems and Social Issues, ed. Nolan, James L. Jr., 51–66. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.Google Scholar
Sudnow, David. 1965. Normal Crimes: Sociological Features of the Penal Code in a Public Defender's Office. Social Problems 12:255–76.Google Scholar
Taxman, Faye, and Bouffard, Jeffrey. 2002. Treatment Inside the Drug Treatment Court: The Who, What, Where, and How of Treatment Services. In Drug Courts: Current Issues and Future Perspectives, ed. Harrison, Lana D., Scarpitti, Frank, Amir, Menachem, and Einstein, Stanley, 193–211. Huntsville, TX: Office of International Criminal Justice.Google Scholar
Teplin, Linda. 1990. The Prevalence of Severe Mental Disorder among Male Urban Jail Detainees: Comparison with the Epidemiological Catchment Area Program. American Journal of Public Health 80:663–69.Google Scholar
Teplin, Linda. 1994. Psychiatric and Substance Abuse Disorders among Male Urban Jail Detainees. American Journal of Public Health 84:290–93.Google Scholar
Teplin, Linda, Abram, Karen, McClelland, Gary M., Mericle, Amy, Dulcan, Mina, and Washburn, Jason. 2006. Psychiatric Disorders of Youth in Detention. Washington, DC: US Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.Google Scholar
Thomas, John W., Stubbe, Dorothy E., and Pearson, Geraldine. 1999. Race, Juvenile Justice and Mental Health: New Dimensions in Measuring Racial Bias. The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 89:615–70.Google Scholar
Turner, Susan, and Petersilia, Joan. 1992. Focusing on High Risk Parolees: An Experiment to Reduce Commitments to the Texas Department of Corrections. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 29:34–61.Google Scholar
Wasserman, Gail, Ko, Susan J., and McReynolds, Larkin S. 2004. Assessing the Mental Health Status of Youth in Juvenile Justice Settings. Bulletin. Washington, DC: US Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.Google Scholar
Weinberg, Darin. 1997. The Social Construction of Non‐Human Agency: The Case of Mental Disorder. Social Problems 44:217–35.Google Scholar
Wexler, David B., and Winick, Bruce J. 1991. Essays in Therapeutic Jurisprudence. Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press.Google Scholar
Winick, Bruce J., and Wexler, David B., eds. 2003. Judging in a Therapeutic Key: Therapeutic Jurisprudence and the Courts. Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press.Google Scholar
Wolf, Elaine, and Colyer, Corey. 2001. Everyday Hassles: Barriers to Recovery in Drug Court. Journal of Drug Issues 31:233–58.Google Scholar
Wolfe, Ellen, Guydish, Joseph, and Termondt, Jenna. 2002. A Drug Court Outcome Evaluation Comparing Arrests in a Two Year Follow‐Up Period. Journal of Drug Issues 32:1155–72.Google Scholar

Cases Cited

In Re Gault. 387 U.S. 1 (1967)Google Scholar