Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Hostname: page-component-77f85d65b8-t6st2 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-04-17T15:05:21.538Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Index

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 September 2023

Elizabeth Anderson
Affiliation:
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

Information

Index

abolition, 6566, 192194, 289290
absolutism, 40, 41, 4344, 4850
accumulation, of wealth, xvii, –1718, 20, 2122, 3536, 5152, 5354, 6566, 128129, 170, 171173, 295, see also competitive acquisition
Agreement of the People, 38, 4043
agricultural workers, 91, 100101, 107, 110, 147148, 170, 182, 192, 289290
agriculture, 2728, 56, 91, 95, 107, 182, 238, see also collectivized farming
alienation, 206212
altruism, effective, 1619
anarchists, 2122, 235
Andover Union workhouse, scandal over administration of, 106, 189
Anglican Church, 56, 15, 24, 6566
antitrust doctrine, weakening of, xxi, 254255
apprenticeship, 60, 61, 143144, 147, 148, 155156, 210, 289290
appropriation, 28, 29, 3031, 3435
consent and, 3233, 5455
just, 2728, 29, 3132
aristocratic paternalism, 9199
Arminianism, 1314, 17
artisans. See craftsmen
asceticism, xvii, 17, 6465, 88, 128129, 271272, 295
autonomy, 128129, 181182, 186187, 206207, 219220, 242243, 248249, 250, 288
Babeuf, François-Noël, 213224, 227, 229, 232
distributive justice and, 246
Bakunin, Mikhail, 224
banking system, 254255, 277, 278, see also financialization
bankruptcy laws, xxi, 254255
bargaining power, 275, see also collective bargaining
Baxter, Richard, 67, 1314, 15, 17, 26, 4546, 60, 67, 69, 88, 97, 98, 251252, 258259, 260261, 275, 277278, 281
business ethics and, 34, 46, 276277, 281282
Christian Directory, 89, 10, 11, 1213, 1516, 1718, 19, 65
condemnation of exploitation of poor, 13
dignity of labor and, 71
dual nature of work ethic and, 1516
good works and, 2627
idle rich and, 71, 85
justified inequality and, 275, 276277
progressive work ethic and
shareholder capitalism and, 272273
slavery and, 1011, 1213, 51
unpaid domestic labor and, 71, 296297
utilitarianism and, 1819, 169170
begging, 1, 2, 59, 60, 62, 111
Bengal famine, East India Company and, 146147, 201202
Bentham, Jeremy, xiv, xv, 63, 7381, 102, 105, 109, 123124, 127128, 179180, 264, 272
government outsourcing and, 199, 258259, 264272
interest rates and, 46, 149
panopticon and, 7375, 7677, 7879, 8081, 271
Pauper Management Improved, 7374, 7579, 8081
the poor and, 6399
Puritanism and, 66, 7374, 7677, 91
Smith and, 7576, 79
utilitarianism and, 7374, 7677, 78, 79, 8081, 105
utopian fanaticism and, 125, 128129
Bernstein, Eduard, xiv, 127, 213, 225226, 235237, 238, 240, 244245, 293294
Evolutionary Socialism, 225226, 236
Marx/Marxism and, 236237, 243244
social democracy and, 234242, 243244, 292293
“workers” cooperatives and, 238, 240
Beveridge, William, 252
Bible, 1, 45, 1415, 65
Bismarck, Otto von, 232, 234, 252
Blacks
Black activists, 258
civil and political rights of, 259
stereotypes of, 259, 260261
subjection of, 257258
Blum, Léon, 250
bourgeoisie, 62, 7381, 123, 167, 210211
Bray, John Francis, 163, 164, 165167, 174, 244
bullshit jobs, 290291, 295296
Bunyan, Paul, Pilgrim’s Progress, 7778
Buonarroti, Philippe, 214, 215
Burke, Edmund, xv, 63, 87, 9199, 115116, 127128
aristocracy and, 9199
commodification of labor and, 247248
free markets and, 9395
in Rockinghamite faction of Whigs, 93
Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790), 93
Smith and, 130, 146, 154
Speenhamland system and, 9295
“Thoughts and Details on Scarcity” (1795), 113, 150151
business ethics, 276, 277
business executives, xi, 255256, 272275, 276
calling, 5, 8, 1112, 1516, 67, 8889, 168169
Calvin, John, 56
Calvinism, 37, 1314, 17, 204205
capitalism, xvii, 2, 9, 53, 212, 237, see also laissez-faire capitalism
alienation and, 206212
anarchist, 163164
critical analyses of, 289
democracy and, 236
Marx’s critique of, 206212
Puritanism and, 254
shareholder capitalism, xiixiii, 255, 258259, 272283
stakeholder capitalism, 255
work and, 203, 206212
capitalist class, xiii, 20, 6365, 122, 172
carceral state, 264272, see also prisons
care work, 296297
Carlyle, Thomas, 193194, 195196
Catholic Church, xviixviii, 1, 233
Chadwick, Edwin, 102, 104105, 119120
charity, 11, 2526, 4546, 69, 94, 120121, see also poverty relief
Christian, 1619
discouraged by conservative work ethic, 126
duty of, 18, 19, 5758, 67, 83
effective altruism and, 1617
Locke and, 67, 68, 69
Malthus and, 83, 86
natural law and, 57
punishment of, 126
right to, 57, 58
vs. workhouses, 111
Charles I, 15, 3839, 4850
Charles II, 24, 3839, 4951, 176177
Chartism, 170171, 186, 234
chastity, xiv, 6768, 8187, 122, 179180
child care, 60, 71, 259261, 296297
child labor, 7576, 78, 102, 182, 235, 260261
child poverty, 7576, 78, 102, 260261, 296297
children, 57, 60, 61, 260261
apprenticeship and, 60, 61
child development, 187188
deprived of care, 121122
education of, 191192
poverty and, 57, 60, 61, 8485, 259261
in workhouses, 7576, 7778, 102
China, 200201, 213, 215216, 285286
Church of England. See Anglican Church
citizenship, 243, 244245, 250251
civil servants, 264265, 266, 267
class conflict, xvxvi, 123124, 162, 167, 230231, 232, 243, 244246
class differences, 6364, 128129, 166167, 179180, 238239, 240241, 243, 250253
Malthus and, 8586, 9697, 128129
social democracy and, 244245, 253
work ethic and, 6465, 243
classes, 161, 162, 185186, 209, see also class conflict; class differences; specific classes
classical economic thought, xvii, 284, 286288, 289290
classical liberalism, xiii, 127128, 226, 227234, 256257, 292293
codetermination, 187, 24041, 243, 249, 297
collective bargaining, 243, 24849, 296
colonialism, 199, 200201, see also imperialism
colonies, 4950, 140141, 145147
commercial society, rise of, 138140, 142143
Commission for Inquiring into the Condition of the Poorer Classes of Ireland, 109110
commodification of labor, xixiii, 248, 256, 269270, 274275
commodity, meaning of, 248
commons, 3436, 5455
communes, 165, 238, 292293
communism, x, 178179, 204, 213224, 227, 237, 287288
institutional structure of, 213, 214, 215, 221223
institutions eliminated by, 213
luck egalitarianism and, 216, 217
totalitarianism and, 213, 214216, 224, 225226
competitive acquisition, 128129, 170, 172173, 182, 245, 247, 258259, 284285, 295
Condorcet, Nicolas de Caritat Marquis de, 63, 7172, 96, 127, 226234, 247, 275, 276
conservative, use of the term, xv
conservative relief policies, poverty-promoting features of, 120122, 123
conservative work ethic, xixii, xivxv, xvi, 14, 2425, 62, 6399, 172173, 233, 254259, 292293
aggregative utilitarianism and, 169170
attitudes toward working poor and, 130
Bentham and, 264, 272
child care and, 261
class and, xvxvi, 120, 123124, 132, 179180
consumption and, 170, 172173, 182
contradiction inherent in, 123, 170171, 179180
definition of, ixx
English welfare reform and, 100108
harshness toward workers and, 120
hijacking of work ethic by, xivxv
ideas of moral desert and, 129, 133135, 136137
ideology and, xvi, 100126
imperialism and, 257258, 259
Industrial Revolution and, 292293
inegalitarian and antidemocratic sentiment fueled by, 253
Irish famine policy and, 108119
Malthus and, 190191, 257258
Mill and, 192, 195196, 202, 293
neoclassical welfare economics and, 285
neoliberalism and, xii, 253, 254283
nonutilitarian normative attitudes of, 85
poverty policies and, 6768, 6970, 71, 101, 120122, 123
progress and, 169170
secularization and, 6667
shareholder capitalism and, xiixiii
taxation and, 120, 121122
United States and, 250, 254255, 257258
Weber and, 292293
welfare reform and, 100108
Whately and, 108109, 257258, 259264, 273
conspicuous consumption, 1516, 1718, 66, 170, 172173, 182, 284285
Constitution (English), 3844, 90
contract(s), xixii, xiiixiv, 5153, 149150, 192193, see also social contract
freedom of, xiiixiv, 22, 46, 183184
regulation of, 3738, 45, 48, 183184
copyholders, 54, 5556, 6364, 108109
Corn Laws, 107, 110, 152, 173181
cottier system of renting land, 174175, 177178, 180, 181
craftsmen, 64, 210211
factory system and, 6364, 234
Marx’s romanticized view of, 210211
radical artisans, 210, 221222, 235
replaced by factory system and wage workers, 6364, 170
decommodification of labor, 247249, 250253
democracy, 243, 293294, 297298, see also social democracy
backsliding of, x, 290, 297
capitalism and, 236
constraining of, xi, 293
distributive justice and, 247
in the workplace, 297298
deregulation, xiixiii, 254255, 277, 285286, 287
desert, 216, 217, 232, 245246, 247, 261262
Diggers, 31, 42, 43, 54
dignity of labor, 71, 242243
disability insurance, 230, 231, 243
discipline, xvii, xviii, 67, 1314, 6465, 88, 122, 129130, 136137, 291292
ascetic, 8, 9, 14, 8889, 114, 137, 180, 249, 271272, see also asceticism
in the workplace, 65, 125, 170171, 178, 179, 188, 189, 209, 218219, 248249
distributive justice, 164, 245246, 247, 285, 286287, 288
democratic perspective on, 245247
desert and, 245246, 247
Equals and, 219220
Ricardian socialists and, 162, 164, 165, 245246
division of labor, 1516, 168169, 172, 181187, 208, 211, 235, 249, 273
European progress attributed to, 168169
Mill and, 172, 182, 184185, 273
Smith and, 147148, 184185, 273
women and, 184
drudgery, xvii, 9, 61, 62, 73, 128129, 137, 154155, 169, 170, 173, 182, 191192, 208, 248249
Du Bois, W. E. B., 258
duty to work, ixx, 1112, 2324, 26, 59, 68
East India Company, 146147
economic growth, x, 285286
education, 61, 147148, 191192, 248250
expansion of access to, 251252, 257
inequality of, 228, 251252
publicly funded, 233234, 243, 248249, 250251
radicalizing effects of, 248
rights to, 243, 250
schooling provided by factory owners, 182
social stratification and, 251252
universal, 147148, 228, 242243
of workers, 186, 192
efficiency, criterion of, 285, 286
egalitarianism, 11, 1415
luck egalitarianism, 216, 217
enclosure(s), 13, 3031, 3435, 5556, 6364, 139, 161
Locke and, 3233, 53, 5455, 56, 279
Mill and, 177, 192
Parliamentary, 5556, 8990, 91, 273, 279
vulture private equity as new, 279281
Engels, Friedrich, 214, 222, 223, 224, 236, 237
Communist Manifesto, 204, 221222
“dictatorship of the proletariat” and, 221
freedom and, 219220, 223224
institutional structure of communism and, 213
Engels’s Pause, 6465, 170, 234235, 254, 256
England. See also United Kingdom
classical liberalism in, xiii
land tenure, 173181
Poor Law and, 8182
English Civil War, 15, 38, 4043, 4849
Enlightenment, 96, 153154, 227
entails, 140142, 176177, 289290
equality, x, 4344, 242243
attempts to create strict, 229
of citizenship, as basis for shared normative perspective, 244245
distributive justice and, 247
Equals’ radical principle of, 216, 217218
under the law, 42, 43
of status, 250251
Equals, 214, 217, 229
distributive justice and, 219220
Marx and, 218220
material equality and, 216, 217218
military-style central planning and, 223
Paine and, 229, 230231
estate taxes, 7173, 230
evictions, 13, 5556
as death sentence, 126
Irish famine policy, 112113, 115116, 117118
in United States, 281282
executive compensation, 255256, 272275
Fabian socialists, 246, 247, 273
Factory Acts, 182, 183
factory system, 6364, 122, 170, 182, 234, 235
faith, 37, 1314
famine, 100126, 151, 189190
Bengal, 146147, 201202
British policy toward, 100
Irish, 100, 111112, 129, 151, 177178, 189190
Mill and, 177178
state intervention to prevent, 94, 95
feudalism, 4850, 54, 137138, 142145, 147, 159
finance, 254255, 277279, 293
financial aid, 263264
firm, the, 266267, 269, 284285, 288, 295296
forced labor, 188189, 259, 270272, see also slavery
France, 87, 8990, 100101, 214, 233234, 250, 252, 296297, see also French Revolution
franchise
expansion of, xiii, 24, 90, 155156
propertyless men and, 4344
restricted, xiii, 20, 2122, 3839, 43
universal male, 38, 170171
women and, 4344
Franklin, Benjamin, secularization of work ethic and, 6566
freedom, 206, 223224, 242243, 289
freedom of contract, xiiixiv, 22, 46, 183184
free labor, xviixviii, 140141, 142145, 258
free markets, xiii, 9395, 122, 123124, 129, 135148, 155156, 182, 256257
French Revolution, 81, 87, 9192, 100101, 124, 140141, 150, 153154, 159, 214215, 218, 221222, 226227
Friedman, Milton, 255, 278279
frugality, xiv, xviii, 89, 6465, 6768, 122, 129130, 136137, 174, 179180, 276, see also asceticism
Germany, xviixviii, 225226, 234, 235236, 241242, 252
Gilbert’s Act (1782), 93, 104
government outsourcing, x, –264272
grace, 57, 1314, 2627
Great Famine. See Irish famine
Gregory Clause, 117, 262263
guild system, 210, 234
Hansson, Per Albin, 244245, 247
Hayek, Friedrich, Road to Serfdom (1944), 225226
Hazlitt, William, 72, 89, 189190
health care, x, 232, 243, 250251, 269270, 296, 298
Hegel, G. W. F., 96, 206207, 219220
historical progress, 96, 9798, 206, 236
history, xvii, 96, 9798, 168, 206, see also historical progress
Hodgskin, Thomas, 163164, 166167, 176177, 248
Hone, William, 8990
Hooker, Richard, 2526
House of Commons, 38, 40, 106
House of Lords, 38, 43
human capabilities, 171173, 181182, 204, 208209, 242243, 249250, 288, 291
human flourishing, 203204, 248249, 250, 289
ideologies, xvi, 125
critique of, 119120
epistemic functioning of, xvi, 123124
historical origins of, xvi
idleness, 8, 12, 4445, 47, 5162, 65, 6970, 111
idle poor, 2425, 5262, 65, 6970
idle rich, 2425, 26, 3032, 34, 42, 4445, 47, 5152, 65, 71, 85, 8889, 101, 243, 245, 247, 295, see also leisure class
imperialism, 98, 187202, 254, 257258, 259, 293
indentured servitude, 51, 5254
independence, 72, 186187
cult of, 6873
independent contractors, xi, 256, 274275
India, 200201
individualism, 6667, 71, 231, 258259
individuality, 205206, 210, 214215
Industrial Revolution, 57, 6364, 65, 101, 122, 168, 170, 211212, 234235, 265266, 288, 292293
commodification of labor and, 248
labor productivity and, 189190
industry, xiv, 6768, 122, 128130, 136137, 174, 179180, 191192
idleness and, 4445, 47, 5162
micro-division of labor in, 182
inequality, 228, 230231, 250253, 290
decommodification of labor and, 250253
justified, 9, 230231, 275, 276277
malign cultural effect of, 289
private property and, 217218
social democracy and, 250253
inheritance, 4849, 120, 141142, 143, 173181, 254255
intellectual property, xxi, 47, 48, 254255, 279
interest, 46, 47, 176177, 245246, 247248
International Working Men’s Association, 210, 224, 235236
Ireland, 99, 108, 181
agricultural system in, 111112, 118
birth rates in, 118
cottier system of renting land in, 174175, 177178, 180, 181
division of labor in, 108109
inheritance in, 173181
land reform in, 177179
land tenure in, 173181
poverty relief in, 111112, 177178, see also Irish famine policy
unemployment in, 109
workhouses in, 111112, 124125
Irish famine, 112119, 129, 151, 177178, see also Irish famine policy
Irish famine policy, 100, 112120, 181
British government and, 120121, 124125, 153, 177178, 181, 261262, 263
evictions, 112113, 115116, 117118
exacerbation of famine and, 112113, 118, 189190
Gregory Clause, 117
public works, 112114
punishment of charity and, 126
temporary soup kitchens, 112113, 115
workhouses and, 112113, 115118
Irish landlords, 112113, 115116, 117, 177178, 181
Irish peasantry, 99, 289290
conversion into wage laborers, 111112, 117, 118, 177178
Irish poor law, 100, 108112, 119120
Jacobins, 214, 218, 229
Jesus, 1415
justice, 22, 2526, 3132, 186187, see also distributive justice
Kaldor, Nicholas, 285
Kant, Immanuel, 96
Keynes, John Maynard, 2, 247248, 278, 290, 291, 292293
King, Martin Luther, Jr., 258
Knatchbull’s Act, 62, 93. See also Workhouse Test Act (1723).
labor, 21, 47, 107, 157, 163, 207, 208, 221, 252253
alienated, 206212
commodification of, xixiii, 94, 126, 245246, 248, 256, 269270, 274275
decommodification of, 247248, 250253
dignity of, 11, 71
as expression of individuality, 205206, 208
forced, 188189, 259, 270272, see also slavery
labor supply, 123, 170171, 191, 284285
professional, 269270
property rights and, 47
unalienated, 203206, 207, 219220, 223, 235
unfree, 140141, 142145
unpaid domestic, 71, 289, 296297
laboring poor, 103, 130, 228, see also working poor
labor theory of property, 174175, 180, 230
labor theory of value, 2931, 70, 162, 165166, 231232, 236237
labor unions. See unions
laissez-faire capitalism, 46, 112113, 114, 127128, 148, 150, 151155, 182, 183184, 241, 257258
land, 47, 54, 122, 174, 177, see also enclosure(s); property rights; labor value of property
landlords, xiii, 13, 24, 30, 4445, 56, 64, 65, 91, 95, 110, 125, 147148, 172, 243, 254, 273, 279, 281282 see also landowners
authority of, xiii, 95, 105, 107, 108, 110
Irish, 111113, 115116, 117, 125, 177178, 181
landowners, 24, 2931, 3839, 4445, 47, 4950, 6364, 156158, 161
land reform, 177179, 181
Land Tenure Reform Association, 176177
land tenure system, 173181, 289290
leisure, 1, 169170, 249250, 290, 291292
vs. luxury, 182183
Mill and, 183184, 249250
progressive work ethic and, 66, 137, 296
Puritan attitudes toward, 7374
Smith and, 137, 249250
work and, 2
workers and, 66, 182, 186, 192, 242243
Lenin, Vladimir, 213, 221, 227
“less eligibility,” principle of, 104, 111, 120121, 188
Leveller movement, 2324, 3839, 4043, 48, 5253, 5455, 87, 90, 170171, 210
liberalism, 57, 127128, 239, 240
liberal Toryism, 91, 105, 108, 110, 118. See also Tories
libertarianism, xiii, 2126, 2729, 3132, 33, 3637, 40, 4546, 127128, 152153, 256257
liberty, 247, See also freedom
Locke, John, xiv, 26, 3233, 3940, 4344, 4546, 5051, 53, 57, 67, 138, 169170, 187188, 209, 236237, 293294
on begging, 59, 60
business ethics and, 276277
charity and, 67, 68, 69
class analysis and, 3940, 179180
constitutional remedies of, 4044, 5253, 170171
on contracts, 3738, 45, 48, 5153
on copyright, 47, 48, 279
distributive justice and, 164, 247
on enclosures, 3233, 53, 5455, 279
franchise and, 2324, 4344
Fundamental Constitution of Carolina, the, 5354
head of Board of Trade under King William III, 41, 49, 51
idleness and, 2425, 26, 3132, 42, 4445, 47, 5162, 65, 71, 85, 279
on indentured servitude, 51, 5254
on inheritance, 4849, 5253, 141, 175176
justified inequality and, 275, 276277
labor-mixing provision and, 27, 29
labor theory of value and, 2931, 70
Leveller movement and, 2324, 4043, 48, 5253, 5455
libertarian reading of, 2025, 2729, 33, 3637, 40, 4546
Mill and, 173181, 190191
on monarchy, 3940, 4344, 49
on monopolies, 5253, 277
moral theory of, 2526, 27
natural law and, 57
need for state and, 3438
on children, 60, 61, 187188, 260261
poverty and, 5759, 60, 62, 6465, 68, 187188, 260261
property regimes and, 2425, 3436, 47, 48, 4950, 5153, 54, 55, 163164, 172
pro-worker orientation of, 2425, 44, 4950, 5253, 54, 57, 60, 63
Reasonableness of Christianity (1695), 2627
rejection of libertarian historical entitlement theory, 3132
scarcity and, 3437
Second Treatise, 2627, 3233, 42, 43, 55, 5960, 65
secularization of work ethic and, 65
on slavery, 49, 50, 53, 54
Smith and, 149
social contract and, 3638, 4344, 229
Some Thoughts Concerning Education (1693), 61
spoilage proviso and, 27, 3031, 33
sufficiency proviso and, 2729, 30, 3233, 3435, 4950, 5455, 5859, 174
Two Treatises, 2324, 41
on wage labor, 5354, 143
Whig party and, 2324, 3839, 110, 265266
work ethic and, xv, 2062, 6364, 65, 190191, 203204, 258259, 275, 277278
London Corresponding Society, 87, 89
Luther, Martin, 36, 15
Lutheranism, 37
Luxemburg, Rosa, 213
luxury, 89, 1718, 69, 88, 170, 182, 245
vs. leisure, 182183
luxury consumption, 89, 1718, 66, 88, 170, 245
Macpherson, C. B., 20, 52, 5354
Malthus, Thomas Robert, xiv, xv, 63, 66, 8187, 89, 91, 94, 105, 111, 118, 129, 146, 160161, 179180, 190191, 199, 256259
charity and, 83, 86
chastity and, 6768, 8384
class and, 8587, 9697, 128129
influence of, 102, 108109, 123124, 156158, 189191, 257258, 259264
Mill and, 188, 189, 190191
Poor Law and, 8183, 84, 189
population theory of, 8283, 96, 155158, 172173, 188, 189, 190
poverty relief and, 6768, 72, 8183, 84, 89, 102, 189
Ricardo and, 155156, 158159, 160
theory of rent and, 155156, 157158
utilitarianism and, 84, 85
welfare policy and, 259264
Mao Zedong, 213, 215216, 218
Maréchal, Sylvain, 214
Marshall, T. H., 243, 250251
Marx, Karl, 63, 96, 122, 127128, 163, 203, 204, 206212, 213224, 226, 235, 236237, 238239, 249, 291292, 293, 295
Capital, 207, 226, 235
Civil War in France, 222
“Comments on James Mill, Élémens d’Économie Politique (1844),” 2056
commitment to autonomy of revolutionary workers, 223224
Communist Manifesto, 204, 210211, 221222
Critique of the Gotha Program, 204, 218
“dictatorship of the proletariat” and, 221
distributive justice and, 246, 247
Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts of 1844, 204
Equals and, 218220
freedom and, 219220, 223224, 291
human flourishing and, 203204
ideal of unalienated labor and, 203206, 235
institutional structure of communism and, 213
labor theory of value and, 165166, 236237
launches democratic path for “workers” emancipation, 224
Mill (John Stuart) and, 127128, 204, 210212, 224, 226
progressive work ethic and, xiv, 127128, 203224, 226, 244, 292293
radical artisans and, 221222, 235
social democracy and, 226, 292293
stress on work as central meaningful activity, 204206
totalitarianism and, 225226
on work as expression of individuality, 205206
Marxism, 213, 214, 225227, 234, 243244, 287288, 289
mercantilist policies, 143, 145147
meritocracy, 251252, 256257, 293
Methodism, 17, 77
micro-division of labor, 147148, 168169, 182, 186187, 248, 256, 287288
Mill, James, 155, 159, 176177, 178179, 204, 205206, 208, 246
Mill, John Stuart, xv, 63, 127128, 155, 167, 168202, 204, 212, 225226, 238, 239, 249, 293
abolition and, 192193
classical liberalism and, xiii, 127128
colonialism and, 199, 200201
competitive conspicuous consumption and, 172, 257, 295
cottier system and, 174175, 177178, 180, 181
on despotism, 195, 196, 197, 198
division of labor and, 172, 182, 184185, 273
domestic imperialism and, 187192
foreign imperialism and, 192202
Irish famine policy and, 177178, 181
laissez-faire economics and, 182, 183184
land reform and, 177, 178179, 181
laws of inheritance and, 174176
leisure and, 183184, 249250
Locke and, 173181, 190191
Malthus and, 188, 189, 190191
Marx and, 204, 210212, 224, 226
New Poor Law of 1834 and, 188189, 190191, 192
non-white peoples and, 195198, 202
as officer of British East India Company, 198199, 202
Petition of the East India Company, 198199
poverty policy and, 188189, 190191
on primogeniture, 176177
progressive work ethic and, xiv, 173, 187188, 190191, 193195, 236237, 289290, 293294
promotion of leisure, 182183
property rights and, 172, 186187
rejection of hierarchy, 172, 185186, 198
Ricardian socialists and, 173, 176177
slavery and, 192194, 195198, 200201
Smith and, 173, 184185
support for forced labor, 188189
sympathy and, 172
unions and, 184185
utilitarianism and, 173174
women’s rights and, 183, 191192, 198, 289
workers’ cooperatives and, 184185, 186187, 238, 244
Milton, John, 2
minimum wage, 9495, 150151, 256, 272
monarchy, 3940, 41, 4344, 4950
money, 2829, 30, 3233, 3536, 53, 148149
monopolies, xi, xiii, 45, 46, 47, 48, 254, 264265, 277, see also antitrust doctrine
natural law, 2122, 2534, 3536, 49, 57, 108
natural liberties, 4344, 149
natural rights, 2122, 2324, 3637, 163164
neoclassical economics, xviixviii, 245246, 272273, 287, 288
neoliberalism, xii, 22, 253, 254283, 285
consequences of, xi
definition of, xiixiii, 272273
origins of, xiv, xvi
policymaking and, 285286
Poor Laws and, 264
Protestant work ethic and, xiv
racism and, xviixviii
rise of, x, 254259, 285
social democracy and, xiiixiv, 254255, 293
in United States, xviixviii, 258264
welfare policy and, 259264, 288
New Poor Law of 1834, 100, 105, 107, 109, 115116, 119120, 124125, 188189, 190191, 192, 258264
Nicholls, George, 111112, 115
Noetics, 95, 96, 98, 99, 105, 109, 122, 243
Nozick, Robert, 2526, 27
Old Poor Law. See Poor Law
original sin, doctrine of, 2627, 97, 98
outdoor relief, 102103, 109, 111112, 115116
outsourcing, x, 256, 258259, 264272, 274275, 288
Owen, Robert, 165
Owenites, 172173
Paine, Thomas, 63, 127, 226234
Babeuf and, 227, 229, 232
Equals and, 229, 230231
labor theory of value and, 231232
Poor Law regime and, 230
progressive work ethic and, xiv, 289290
Rights of Man, 87
social insurance and, 7172, 289290
Paley, William, 63, 66, 6768, 8790, 91
Parliament (UK), 38, 39, 56, 181, 183, 198, 199
peasant proprietors, 180181, 186, 192
peasantry, 5556, 99, 289290, see also peasant proprietors
conversion into wage laborers, 111112, 117, 118, 122, 177178
Irish, 99, 108109, 111112, 117, 118, 125, 177178
social democrats and, 240241
Peel, Robert, 95, 113
Perkins, William, 8, 910
personal responsibility, 8187
philanthropy, 295, see also charity
Piketty, Thomas, 217, 289, 290, 293
Pitt, William, 9495, 150151
Pol Pot, 213, 215216, 218
poor, the, 57, 58, 6399, 120, 135, see also idle poor; poverty relief
able-bodied, 58, 59, 60, 62, 102103, 104105, 116118
criminalization of, 270272
distinction between “deserving” and “undeserving,” 9, 11, 5859, 83, 103, 121, 124, 261262, 264
duty of charity to, 18, 19
Malthus and, 8187, 89
right to poverty relief and, 188
Poor Law, 58, 6768, 70, 7172, 74, 8182, 93, 95, 100, 101, 105, 107, 153, 160, 188, 189, 228, 230, 258259, 264, see also New Poor Law of 1834; poor law reforms
Locke and, 5859, 60, 62, 6465
Malthus and, 8183, 84, 102, 189
neoliberal welfare policy and, 264
Poor Law Commissioners’ Report of 1834, 106, 107, 118120, 129, 188
poor law reforms, 5758, 102103, 104105, 106, 108, 111112, 115, 187188, 189, 190191, 259260
population theory, 8283, 96, 155158, 172173, 188, 189, 190
positive rights, 2324, 3438, 57
poverty, 6768, 170171, 179180, 233234, 285286, see also poor, the; Poor Law; poverty relief
children and, 57, 60, 61, 8485, 259261, 296297
criminalization of, 270272
stigmatization of, 83
vice and, 122, 123124, 129, 133135, 136137, 228
workers and, 242243, 245, 247, 296
poverty relief, 6399, 100101, 103, 115116, 120122, 123, 150151, 153, 188, 229
abolishment of, 72, 105
conservative relief policies, 120122, 123
for-profit outsourcing of, 120122
humiliating forms of, 120121, 123124
Locke and, 5859
Malthus and, 8183, 123124, 189
Mill and, 188, 190191
right to, 5859, 116, 188
in Speenhamland, Berkshire (English county), 102
workhouses and, 104105, 109, 111112, 188
work requirements and, 104105, 120122
precarity, 121122, 126, 170171, 179180, 228, 242243, 245246, 247248, 275
Priestley, Joseph, 63, 66, 6773, 91, 9293, 123, 127129, 179180, 230, 231, 256257
competitive acquisition and, 9798, 170, 257, 258259, 284285
idea of life as competitive race, 167
individualism and, 71, 72, 231
mandated savings and, 69, 70, 72
Poor Law and, 70, 71
secularization of work ethic and, 69, 70, 7273
shareholder capitalism and, 258259
primogeniture, 49, 5253, 140142, 175177, 289290
prisons, xi, 267268, 269, 270272
private equity, vulture, 279281
private property, 229, 240241, 288
abolition of, 217, 292293
classical liberalism and, xiii
distribution of, 178179
inequality and, 217218
labor theory of, 174175, 180
Locke’s theory of, 44, 173181
Marx and, 208, 212, 213
Mill’s Lockean theory of, 173181
property laws, 8990, 120, 288, 289
redistribution of, 43, 8990
regulation of, xiiixiv, 34, 3738, 45
workers and, 182, 192
productivity, xxi, 21, 27, 47, 5152, 56, 107, 186, 189190, 249, 256, 273
professionals, 210, 269
profits, 156158
maximization of, xixii, 255256, 272273, 295296, 297
as unearned income, 245246
wages and, 156158, 163
progress, 236
conservative view of, 169170, 171172
Eurocentric view of, 168169
historical, 96, 9798, 236
human history as, 206
imperialism seen as engine of, 293
Mill’s conception of, 172173
Smith’s account of, 137140, 142
theory of historical progress, 96, 9798
progressive, use of the term, xvxvi
progressive work ethic, xiv, 13, 14, 127167, 172173, 181182, 236237, 239, 242243, 289, 293296
common roots of economic liberalism and social democracy in, 240
definition of, ixx
Industrial Revolution and, 292293
leisure and, 137, 296
Locke and, xiv, 2062, 187188, 236237, 293294
Marx and, xiv, 203224, 226, 244, 292293
Mill and, xiv, 168202, 236237, 289290, 293294
Paine and, xiv, 289290
Puritan work ethic and, xivxv
Ricardian socialists and, xiv, 167, 236237
secularization and, 66
Smith and, xiv, 154155, 182, 236237, 289290, 293295
social democracy and, x, xiv, 225253, 292293
social insurance and, 7172
virtues of, 128129
vision for workers offered by, xvii
vision of duties to fellow human beings, xivxv
“workers” agenda afforded by, 294, 296297
property. See private property; property rights
property rights, xiiixiv, 20, 22, 43, 57, 8990, 163164, 227, 229, 240241
of copyholders, 54, 5556
feudal, 45, 4850, 54
natural, 163164
state and, 2122, 5859
in state of nature, 5354
Protestant work ethic, 2
Baxter and, 67
dual nature of, 119
influence of, 2025
as revaluation of values, 13
pro-worker work ethic. See progressive work ethic
Puritanism, xviixviii, 34, 67, 910, 17, 8889, see also Puritan work ethic
calling and, 8, 1112, 168169
exaltation of workers and, 1112
idle rich and, 85
moral egalitarianism and, 1011
sanctification of work and, 11, 14
utilitarianism and, 16, 169170
Puritan work ethic, xivxv, 816, 6364, 65, 8889, 203204, 257258, 265266
Putney debates, 4344
racism, xviixviii, 118, 257264, 286
Rawls, John, 275, 276
Reformation, 2, 34, 15
Reign of Terror, 218, 221, 223224, 228
rent(s), 13, 156158, 161
distribution of, 245246, 273
economic function of, 176177
Fabian socialists and, 273
in Ireland, 181
landlords and, 156158, 176177, 178, 230
Malthus’s theory of, 155156, 157158
Ricardo and, 176177, 178, 246, 273
as unearned income, 245246
Ricardian socialists, xiv, 63, 72, 127, 155, 161167, 173, 178, 236237, 245246, 258, 296297
Ricardo, David, 100101, 155156, 158161, 173, 175, 245246
on classes, 161, 162
labor theory of value and, 165166
Malthus and, 155159, 160
rents and, 176177, 246, 273
theory of inverse relation of profits and wages, 163
workers’ rights and, 155156
Robespierre, Maximilien, 218, 221, 223224, 229
Russell, John, 111113, 124125
salvation, 2, 45, 67, 8, 1011, 1315, 17, 2627, 42, 6667, 7778, 204205
Sanderson, Robert, 8, 11, 1213, 67, 85, 8889, 172, 203, 236237, 273
Scandinavia, xiii, 247248, 252
Scrope, G. Poulett, 116, 118, 188189
self-employment, xiixiii, xviixviii, 122, 147148, 186, 210, 258
Senior, Nassau, 63, 98, 102, 104105, 118120, 124125, 129, 188
servants, 53, 91, 92, 9495, 107
settler colonialism, xviixviii, 258259
Shaftesbury (Anthony Ashley Cooper, first Earl of Shaftesbury), 24, 5051
shareholder capitalism, 255, 258259, 272273, 275, 276, 277, 281
sin, 8, 14, 2627, 97, 98
Singer, Peter, 1617, 18
slavery, xviixviii, 1011, 1213, 45, 5354, 257258. See also abolition
advocates of, 259
Locke on, 5051, 5254, 192193
Mill and, 192194, 195198, 200201
slaveholders, 124, 254
slave trade, 50
Smith on, 143144, 197, 289290
in United States, 192193, 257258
Smith, Adam, xv, 63, 7576, 79, 90, 96, 98, 107, 127, 130135, 146, 154, 178179, 180, 186187, 210, 225226, 281, 289
on bargaining power, 275
biases in sentiment and, 130131, 132
critique of conservative work ethic, 130135
“Digression Concerning the Corn Trade and Corn Laws,” 151152
division of labor and, 184185, 273
East India Company and, 79, 201202
free markets and, 142143, 150, 151, 152155
human progress and, 90, 137141, 142, 154155
“laboring poor” and, 103
laissez-faire and, 148, 150, 151, 152155
on leisure, 137, 249, 250
libertarian reading of, 147, 152153
Locke and, 149
Malthus and, 146
Marx and, 208, 209, 226
micro-division of labor and, 168169, 182, 186187, 287288
Mill and, 173, 184185
poverty relief and, 150151
pragmatism vs. dogmatism, 148155
progressive work ethic and, xiv, 182, 236237, 289290, 293295
pro-worker economic policies and, 130135, 149151, 182
reforms proposed by, 140148
slavery and, 154155, 197, 289290
supply curve of labor and, 284285
Theory of Moral Sentiments, 130131, 132, 135136
tradeoff of prosperity against human capabilities, 182, 184
on virtues, 135137
wage labor and, 143, 273, 275
Wealth of Nations, 137141, 150, 152153, 154
social contract, 2122, 3637, 4344, 173174, 229
social democracy, xiiixiv, xviixviii, 127128, 186187, 213, 225227, 243244, 249, 253, 292293
classical liberal tradition and, 227234
codetermination and, 240, 297298
decommodification of labor and, 247248, 250253
market economies and, 252253, 295296
neoliberalism and, xiiixiv, 254255, 293
origins of, 226, 234242
persistence of class inequality and, 250253
pre-Marxist origins of, 226234
progressive work ethic and, x, xiv, 225253, 292293
Social Democratic Party (SAP) (Sweden), 225, 243245
Social Democratic Party (SPD) (Germany), 225226, 234, 235236, 241242
social democratic political parties, xiv, 225226, 240241, 243244, 257, 293
Social Democratic Workers’ Party of Germany, 235236
social insurance, x, xixii, 64, 70, 7172, 84, 226227, 232, 243, 247248, 252, 262263, 289290, see also means-testing
origins of, 227234
socialist parties and, 233
universal, 233234
in United States, 227, 233234
socialist tradition, xviixviii, 127128, 232, 240, 292293, see also Ricardian socialists
Soviet Union, 213, 221
Speenhamland system, 9295, 102, 106, 107, 189190
Spencer, Herbert, 96
spoilage proviso, 21, 27, 3031, 33, 34
stakeholder grants, 230, 231232, 233234, 289290
Stalin, Joseph, 213, 215216, 218
state of nature, 21, 22, 29, 33, 34, 3537, 5354, 173175
stationary state, 156158, 160161, 172173, 182
sufficiency proviso, 21, 2729
enclosure and, 3233
failure of, 3436, 3738, 5455, 58, 174, 229
Locke and, 30, 3233, 34, 4950, 5455, 5859, 174
suffrage, 191192, 214, 222
Sweden, 225, 242, 243245
sympathy, 172, 181182, 186187, 204, 288, 298
Tarnow, Fritz, 242
taxes/taxation, xiiixiv, 20, 22, 3738, 47, 4849, 57, 70, 71, 74, 246, 257, 297, 298
capital income and, 120, 254255
conservative work ethic and, 120, 121122
cutting, x
distributive justice and, 246
estate, 7173, 230
income, 120, 247, 254255
inheritance, 254255
labor and, 120, 252253
landowners and, 47
local, 121122
poverty relief and, 111
progressive, 254255
redistributive, xiiixiv
regressive, 120
rents and, 159160, 176177
social insurance and, 7173
tax deductions, 259
tax farmers, 79
war, 101
wealth, 231, 247
welfare policy and, 252253
Tenures Abolition Act, 4849, 55
Test Act, 265266
Thatcher, Margaret, 254255
Thompson, William, 126, 164, 165, 166167, 172173, 232, 244, 246, 289, 296297
Tocqueville, Alexis de, 118119
Tories, 24, 3132, 4344, 91, 175
totalitarianism, xiiixiv, 213, 214216, 224, 225227
trade agreements, x, 254255, 257, 285286
trade unions. See unions
Trevelyan, Charles, 112113, 119120, 129, 151
unemployment, 59, 62, 100101, 109
unemployment insurance, 106, 107, 243, 256
unions, xixii, xiiixiv, 64, 181187, 192, 234235, 240, 243, 247248, 254255, 257, 258
assault on, xxi, 255256, 287
Mill and, 184185
social democracy and, 297298
United Kingdom, 108, 250251, 254255
United States, xviixviii, 250, 254255, 257258
abolitionism in, 6566
Black activists in, 258
changes in business model in, 255256
conservative work ethic in, 250, 254255, 257258
ideal of self-employment in, xviixviii
individualism in, 258259
means-tested welfare programs in, 259
neoliberalism in, xviixviii, 258264
progressive movements in, 6566, 254255
progressive work ethic in, 257258
Puritanism in, 6566
racism in, 258259
shareholder capitalism in, 277
slavery in, 6566, 192193, 257258
social democracy in, 254255
social insurance in, 227, 233234
welfare policy in, 257264
utilitarianism, 7, 1617, 37, 66, 155, 285
aggregative view of, 169170
ascetic theology and, 17
Baxter and, 169170
Bentham and, 7374, 7677, 78, 79, 8081, 105
birth of, 119
classical, 169170
duty of universal benevolence and, 1819
Locke and, 169170
Malthus and, 84, 85
Mill and, 173174
natural rights and, 173174
Puritanism and, 16, 169170
social contract and, 173174
theological derivation of, 19
utility, interpersonal comparisons of, 285
utopianism, 122, 125, 126, 258, 292293
Veblen, Thorstein, 284285
virtue(s), xiv, 8790, 122, 123124, 129, 133135, 136137, 181182, 186187, 215, 223224, 288, 294295
wage labor, 5354, 6364, 9495, 108109, 111, 117, 118, 121, 122, 123, 143, 170, 171172, 177178, 180
wages, 21, 156158
ceiling on, 9495
grain prices and, 100101
growth of, 234235
labor supply and, 191
low, 182, 245, 248, 296
minimum wage, 9495, 150151, 256, 272
profits and, 156158, 163
stagnating, xxi, 6465, 254, 256
subsistence, 160161
unions and, 184185
wage rates, 275
wages-fund theory, 188
wealth
accumulation of, xvii, 1718, 20, 2122, 3536, 5152, 5354, 170, 295, see also competitive acquisition
distribution of, 173
dynastic, 176
inequality of, 228
redistribution of, 20, 21, 22
virtue and, 122, 123124, 129, 133135, 136137
wealth extraction, 281282, 283, 296
Weber, Max, xvii, 2, 34, 5, 7, 910, 6566, 7778, 290, 292293
Weimar Republic, 241242
welfare policy, xixii, 20, 57, 112113, 187192, 257, 259264, 288, 289
arbitrary limits and, 263
bureaucratic requirements and, 123124, 263264
Poor Laws and, 264
racism and, xviixviii, 257264
taxation and, 252253
in United States, 257264
welfare reform, 100108, 119121, 257, 260261. See also specific legislation
welfare state, xxi, xiv, 82, 243, 252253, 258
Wesley, John, 17, 77
Whately, Richard, 63, 66, 9199, 102, 105, 115116, 125, 128129, 146, 166, 179180, 195196, 256257, 258264
commodification of labor and, 247248
competitive acquisition and, 170, 284285
conservative work ethic and, 108109, 257258, 259264, 273
doctrine of original sin and, 97, 98
imperialism and, 98
Irish famine policy and, 115116, 118
land appropriation and, 122
landlords and, 95, 273
poverty and, 6768, 123
theory of historical progress and, 9798
welfare policy and, 187192, 259264
Whig government, 112119
Whig party, 2324, 3132, 3839, 4344, 93, 110, 111112, 114, 125, 265266
William III, King, 41, 4950, 51
women
childbearing and, 188
child care and, 260261
division of labor and, 184
economic roles of, 296297
franchise and, 4344
freedom of contract and, 183
limits on labor of, 235
in Locke’s political philosophy, 4344
subordination of, 2122, 289
as teachers, 12
unpaid domestic labor of, 71, 289, 296297
work, 211212, see also labor
as ascetic discipline, 271272
as expression of individuality, 205206, 208, 210
Baxter’s definition of, 211212
calling to, 5, 8, 11
degradation of, 286288
ideal, 203, 204, 205206
legitimate, 1213
Marx’s romanticized view of artisanal, 210211
Puritan attitudes toward, 2, 7374, see also Puritan work ethic
sacralization of, 34, 7, 11
workers, 224, See also labor; specific kinds of workers
agency of, 128129, 181187
autonomy and, 242243, 248249
capitalists and, 6365, 172
deskilling of, 274275
dignity of, 11, 13, 242243
education of, 147148, 186, 192
emancipation of, 127128, 138140, 147148, 224
entitled to fruits of labor, 128129, 192
free markets for, 135148
harshness of conservative work ethic toward, 120
leisure and, 182, 192, 242243
precarity and, 228, 242243, 245246, 247248
property ownership and, 192
self-employed, 147148
self-governing, 291, 295296
subordination of, 2122, 53
workers’ compensation, 232
workers’ cooperatives, 64, 184185, 186187, 192, 238, 240, 244245, 258, 297298
workers’ organizations, 120. See also unions
work ethic, xv, xviii, 63, 6873, 93, 168169, 186187, 217, 258259, 26061, 275, 277278, 281, 290291, 292293, see also conservative work ethic; progressive work ethic; Protestant work ethic; Puritan work ethic; specific theorists and approaches
as contested ideal, 2
developments in the late eighteenth century, 6368
European progress attributed to, 97, 98, 168, 194, 196
hijacking of, xivxv, xvii, 6399, 127, 256257
workfare, 259261
workhouses, 62, 74, 102, 104, 105, 121122, 124125, 153, 189190, 192, see also workhouse test
abuses in, 189
as both test and punishment, 123124
child labor in, 75, 260261
Gilbert’s Act and, 93
incarceration in, 189
in Ireland, 111113, 115116, 117118, 124125
poverty relief and, 109, 111112, 188
privately run, 7479, 8081, 265
scandal over administration of, 106
workhouse test, 104, 116118, 262263, 264
Workhouse Test Act (Knatchbull’s Act), 62, 93, 104
working classes, 81, 82, 8788, 89, 90, 91, 125, 289290
“civilization” of, 125
in rich countries, 285286
rising radicalism among, 81, 100101, 124, 170171, 237238
working day, length of, 182, 183184, 234235, 250
working poor, 130131, 187192, 227, 296
workplace
democratization of, 289, 290, 297298
fissured, 256
workplace conditions, 235, see also working conditions
works, 37, 2627, see also charity
Woytinsky, Wladimir, 241242
yeoman class, 5253, 55, 56, 6364, 139, 141142, 143, 181
Young, Arthur, 136137, 140

Save book to Kindle

To save this book to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about saving to your Kindle.

Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

  • Index
  • Elizabeth Anderson, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
  • Book: Hijacked
  • Online publication: 21 September 2023
  • Chapter DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009275422.015
Available formats
×

Save book to Dropbox

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Dropbox.

  • Index
  • Elizabeth Anderson, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
  • Book: Hijacked
  • Online publication: 21 September 2023
  • Chapter DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009275422.015
Available formats
×

Save book to Google Drive

To save content items to your account, please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Find out more about saving content to Google Drive.

  • Index
  • Elizabeth Anderson, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
  • Book: Hijacked
  • Online publication: 21 September 2023
  • Chapter DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009275422.015
Available formats
×