Progress in reducing global malaria incidence has slowed in recent years, demonstrating the need for new vector control tools to complement existing interventions in reaching global malaria control targets. Spatial repellents (SRs) can reduce pathogen transmission by altering the behaviors of Anopheles spp. mosquito vectors. A recent cluster-randomized control trial in western Kenya found that SRs reduced first-time infections by 33.4% in a highly-endemic setting with substantial insecticide resistance and high coverage of insecticide treated nets. We modeled the likely impact of the SR intervention in this setting under different deployment strategies, with the goal of identifying the best overall and per-product strategies. Continuous monthly SR deployment with 100% coverage caused the greatest (45.1%) reduction in infections versus no SR, although some seasonal approaches averted more infections per SR product. Six months of SR use starting in October caused a 36.4% reduction in infections and eight months starting in September reduced infections by 44.7%. This study identified optimum and efficient SR use strategies and highlights the importance of SR protection during periods of low and increasing transmission. When resources are limited, the coverage, deployment strategy, and timing of SR deployment all play a key role in maximizing product impact.