The Charlie Maier Scare and the Historiography of American Foreign Relations, 1959–1980

doi:10.1017/CBO9781139021760.003

2 - The Charlie Maier Scare and the Historiography of American Foreign Relations, 1959–1980

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 June 2014

Mark Philip Bradley

Edited by

Frank Costigliola and

Michael J. Hogan

Show author details

Mark Philip Bradley: Affiliation:
University of Chicago
Frank Costigliola: Affiliation:
University of Connecticut
Michael J. Hogan: Affiliation:
University of Illinois, Springfield

Book contents

Get access

Summary

The Charlie Maier Scare began in 1980. In many ways its grip on the historiography of American foreign relations persists to the present day. In an essay for the Past Before Us, a panoramic assessment of contemporary American historical scholarship, Harvard historian Charles S. Maier wrote:

The history of international relations (including here American diplomatic history as well as that of other countries) cannot, alas, be counted among the pioneering fields of the discipline in the 1970s. At universities and among the educated public that reads and helps to produce serious historical scholarship, diplomatic history has become a stepchild. Promising graduate students are tempted by the methodological excitement attending social history. The output of mature scholars has been intermittent. Seminal and rich works indeed have appeared. Still, there has been no wave of transforming research during the 1970s comparable to the sustained output on American slavery or labor or the prenational American experience…. For historians of American foreign relations there was no catalytic book comparable, for example, to E. P. Thompson’s Making of the English Working Class.

The reverberations of Maier’s comments unleashed what can only be considered a thirty-year panic among historians of American diplomacy.Maier tapped into an escalating unease and dread about the future of the field. The social history train, the new trinity of race, class and gender, and, soon, the cultural turn seemed to leave diplomatic historians in the dust. Replacement lines were no longer a sure thing. Opportunities to publish were drying up, as were book prizes. The “best” graduate students, as Maier suggested, were looking elsewhere. Or so go the dominant memories of those dark decades.

Information

Type: Chapter
Information: America in the World
The Historiography of American Foreign Relations since 1941
, pp. 9 - 29

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139021760.003 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2013

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Maier, Charles S., “Marking Time: The Historiography of International Relations” in The Past Before Us: Contemporary Historical Writing in the United States, edited by Kammen, Michael G. (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1980): 355, 361

May, Ernest R., “The Decline of Diplomatic History,” in Billias, George Athan and Grob, Gerald N. (eds.), American History: Retrospect and Prospect (New York, 1971), 399–430

McCormick, Thomas J., “The State of American Diplomatic History,” in Bass, Herbert J. (ed.) The State of American History (Chicago, 1970), 119–41

Williams, William A., The Tragedy of American Diplomacy (New York, 1959), 39–40, 64

Williams, Tragedy (1972): 45. I draw here on Bradford Perkins’s careful reading of Williams in his “The Tragedy of American Diplomacy: Twenty-Five Years After,”Reviews in American History 12 (March 1984): 1–18Google Scholar

LaFeber, Walter, The New Empire: An Interpretation of American Expansion, 1860–1898 (Ithaca, NY, 1963)

McCormick, Thomas J., China Market: America’s Quest for Informal Empire, 1893–1901 (Chicago, 1967)

Young, Marilyn Blatt, The Rhetoric of Empire: American China Policy, 1895–1901 (Cambridge, 1968)

Gardner, Lloyd C., Economic Aspects of New Deal Diplomacy (Madison, WI, 1964)

Levin, N. Gordon, Jr., Woodrow Wilson and World Politics (New York: Oxford University Press, 1968): vii

Beisner, Robert L., Twelve Against Empire: the Anti-Imperialists, 1898–1900 (New York, 1968) and From the Old Diplomacy to the New, 1865–1900 (New York, 1975)

Feis, Herbert, Roosevelt-Churchill-Stalin: The War They Waged and the Peace They Sought (Princeton, NJ, 1957) and Between War and Peace: The Potsdam Conference (Princeton, NJ, 1960)

Alperovitz, Gar, Atomic Diplomacy: Hiroshima and Potsdam (New York, 1965)

Kolko, Gabriel, The Politics of War: The World and United States Foreign Policy, 1943–1945 (New York, 1968)

Joyce, and Kolko, Gabriel, The Limits of Power: The World and United States Foreign Policy, 1945–54 (New York, 1972)

Gardner, Lloyd C., Architects of Illusion: Men and Ideas in American Foreign Policy, 1941–49 (Chicago, 1970)

LaFeber, Walter, America, Russia and the Cold War, 1945–1966 (New York: 1967)

Patterson, Thomas G., Soviet-American Confrontation: Postwar Reconstruction and the Origins of the Cold War (Baltimore, 1973): 260

Tucker, Robert W., The Radical Left and American Foreign Policy (Baltimore, 1971)

Thompson, J. A., “William Appleman Williams and the ‘American Empire’,”American Studies 7 (April 1973): 91–104Google Scholar

Schlesinger, Arthur, Jr., “Origins of the Cold War,”Foreign Affairs 46 (October 1967): 24Google Scholar

Novick, Peter, That Noble Dream: The “Objectivity Question” and the American Historical Profession (Cambridge, 1988), 450

Maddox, Robert, The New Left and the Origins of the Cold War (Princeton, NJ, 1973)

Handlin, Oscar, “Introduction to Robert J. Maddox, “Cold War Revisionism: Abusing History,”Freedom at Issue 15 (September–October 1972): 2Google Scholar

Pratt, Julius, A History of United States Foreign Policy (New York, 1954), 780

Bemis, Samuel Flag, “American Foreign Policy and the Blessings of Liberty,”American Historical Review 67 (1962): 305Google Scholar

Rodgers, Daniel T., The Age of Fracture (Cambridge, 2011), 40

Gaddis, John Lewis, The United States and the Origins of the Cold War, 1941–1947 (New York, 1972), 134, 355

Bernstein, Barton J., “Cold War Orthodoxy Restated,”Reviews in American History 1 (December 1973): 460Google Scholar

Sherwin, Martin J., A World Destroyed: The Atomic Bomb and the Grand Alliance (New York, 1975)

Herring, George C., Aid to Russia, 1941–1946: Strategy, Diplomacy, the Origins of the Cold War (New York, 1973)

Yergin, Daniel, Shattered Peace: The Origins of the Cold War and the National Security State (Boston, 1977)

Kuniholm, Bruce, The Origins of the Cold War in the Near East: Great Power Conflict and Diplomacy in Iran, Turkey and Greece (Princeton, NJ, 1980)

Lundestad, Geir, The American Non-Policy towards Eastern Europe, 1943–1947 (Tromsö, 1978)

Kauffman, Burton, Efficiency and Expansion: Foreign Trade Organization in the Wilson Administration, 1913–1921 (Westport, CT, 1973)

Hoff-Wilson, Joan, Ideology and Economics: U.S. Relations With the Soviet Union, 1918–1933 (Columbia, MO, 1974)

Hogan, Michael J., Informal Entente: The Private Structure of Cooperation in Anglo-American Economic Diplomacy. 1918–1928 (Columbia, MO, 1977)

Leffler, Melvyn P., The Elusive Quest: America’s Pursuit of European Stability and French Security, I919–1933 (Chapel Hill, NC, 1979)

Maier, Charles S., Recasting Bourgeois Europe: Stabilization in France, Germany, and Italy in the Decade After World War I (Princeton, NJ, 1975)

DeBenedetti, Charles, Origins of the Modern American Peace Movement, 1915–1929 (Millwood, NY, 1978)

Herman, Sondra R., Eleven Against War: Studies in American Internationalist Thought, 1989–1921 (Stanford, CA, 1969)

Fairbank, John K. (ed.), The Missionary Enterprise in China and America, (Cambridge, 1974)

Schulzinger, Robert D., The Making of the Diplomatic Mind: The Training, Outlook and Style of United States Foreign Service Officers, 1908–1931 (Middletown, CT, 1975)

De Santis, Hugh, The Diplomacy of Silence: The American Foreign Service, the Soviet Union, and the Cold War, 1933–1947 (Chicago, 1980)

Challener, Richard D., Admirals, Generals, and American Foreign Policy, 1898–1914 (Princeton, NJ, 1973)

Sherry, Michael S., Preparing for the Next War: American Plans for Postwar Defense, 1941–45 (New Haven, CT, 1977)

Ulam, Adam, Expansion and Coexistence: The History of Soviet Foreign Policy, 1917–1967 (New York, 1968)

Mastny, Vojtech, Russia’s Road to the Cold War: Diplomacy, Warfare and the Politics of Communism, 1941–45 (New York, 1978)

May, Ernest R., World War I and American Isolationism, 1914–1917 (Cambridge, 1959)

Imperial Democracy: The Emergence of America as a Great Power (New York, 1961)

Mayer, Arno J., Political Origins of the New Diplomacy, 1917–1918 (New Haven, CT, 1959)

Politics and Diplomacy of Peacemaking: Containment and Counterrevolution at Versailles, 1918–1919 (New York, 1967)

Louis, William Roger, Imperialism at Bay: The United States and the Decolonization of the British Empire, 1941–1945 (New York, 1978)

Perkins, Bradford, Castlereagh and Adams: England and the United States, 1812–1923 (Berkeley, CA, 1964)

Iriye, Akira, After Imperialism: The Search for a New Order in the Far East, 1921–1931 (Cambridge, 1965)

Pacific Estrangement: Japanese and American Expansionism, 1897–1911 (Cambridge, 1972)

Hunt, Michael H., Frontier Defense and the Open Door: Manchuria in Chinese-American Relations, 1895–1911 (New Haven, CT, 1973)

Thorne, Christopher, Allies of a Kind: The United States, Britain, and the War against Japan, 1941–1945 (New York, 1978)

Borg, Dorothy and Okomoto, Shumpei (eds.), Pearl Harbor as History: Japanese-American Relations, 1931–1941 (New York, 1973)

Perkins, Bradford, The First Rapprochement: England and the United States, 1795–1805 (Philadelphia, 1955), Castlereagh and Adams, and The Great Rapprochement: England and the United States, 1895–1914 (New York, 1968)

May, Ernest R., The Making of the Monroe Doctrine (Cambridge, 1975)

Gilbert, Felix, To the Farewell Address: Ideas of Early American Foreign Policy (Princeton, NJ, 1961)

De Conde, Alexander, The Quasi-War: The Politics and Diplomacy of the Undeclared War with France (New York, 1966)

Morris, Richard B., The Peacemakers: The Great Powers and American Independence (New York, 1965)

Williams, William A., The Roots of Modern American Empire: A Study of the Growth and Shaping of Social Consciousness in a Marketplace Society (New York, 1969)

Bailyn, Bernard, The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution (Cambridge, 1967)

Wood, Gordon S., The Creation of the American Republic, 1776–1787 (Chapel Hill, NC, 1969)

Pocock, J. G. A., The Machiavellian Moment: Florentine Political and the Atlantic Republic Tradition (Princeton, NJ, 1975)

Herring, George C., “The Truman Administration and the Restoration of French Sovereignty in Indochina,”Diplomatic History 1 (Spring 1977): 97–117Google Scholar

Hess, Gary R., “Franklin Roosevelt and Indochina,”Journal of American History 59 (September 1972): 353–68Google Scholar

LaFeber, Walter, “Roosevelt, Churchill and Indochina, 1942–1945,”American Historical Review 80 (December 1975): 1277–95Google Scholar

Gleijeses, Piero, The Dominican Crisis: The 1965 Constitutional Revolution and American Intervention (Baltimore, MD, 1978)

Borg, Dorothy, The United States and the Far Eastern Crisis of 1933–1938: From the Manchurian Incident through the Initial State of the Undeclared Sino-Japanese War (Cambridge, 1964)

Cohen, Warren I., America’s Response to China: An Interpretative History of Sino-American Relations (New York, 1971)

The Chinese Connection: Roger S. Greene, Thomas W. Lamont, George E. Sokolsky and American-East Asian Relations (New York, 1978)

Schaller, Michael, The U.S. Crusade in China, 1938–1945 (New York, 1979)

LaFeber, Walter F., “Responses to Charles S. Maier, ‘Marking Time: The Historiography of International Relations’”Diplomatic History 5 (October 1981): 362.Google Scholar

Connelly, Matthew, A Diplomatic Revolution: Algeria’s Fight for Independence and the Origins of the Post-Cold War Era (New York, 2002)

Schurmann, Franz’s The Logic of World Power: An Inquiry into the Origins, Currents, and Contradictions of World Politics (New York, 1974)

Zeiler, Thomas W., “The Diplomatic History Bandwagon: A State of the Field,”Journal of American History 95 (March 2009): 1053, 1054Google Scholar

Manela, Erez’s “The United States in the World” in Foner, Eric and McGirr, Lisa (eds.), American History Now (Philadelphia, 2011), 203–22

Pérez, Louis A., “We Are the World: Internationalizing the National, Nationalizing the International,”Journal of American History 89 (September 2002): 558–66Google Scholar

Chaplin, Joyce E., “Expansionism and Exceptionalism in Early American History,”Journal of American History 89 (March 2003): 1431–55Google Scholar

Connelly, Matthew, “SHAFR in the World,”Passport 42 (September 2011): 4–7Google Scholar

Logevall, Frederick, “Politics and Foreign Relations,”Journal of American History 95 (March 2009): 1076Google Scholar

Craig, Campbell and Logevall, Fredrik, America’s Cold War: the Politics of Domestic Insecurity (Cambridge, 2009)

Wendt, Alexander, “Anarchy is What States Make of It: The Social Construction of Power Politics,”International Organization 46 (Spring 1992): 391–425; and his Social Theory of International Politics (Cambridge, 1999)Google Scholar

Hansen, Thomas Blom and Stepputat, Finn, Sovereign Bodies: Citizens, Migrants, and States in the Postcolonial World (Princeton, NJ, 2005)

Agamben, Giorgio, Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life (Stanford, CA, 1988)

Butler, Judith, Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity, 2nd ed. (New York, 2006)

Scott, James C., Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts (New Haven, CT, 1990)

Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Form of Peasant Resistance (New Haven, CT, 1985)

Sewell, William, Logics of History: Social Theory and Social Transformation (Chicago, 2005)

Werner, Michael and Zimmermann, Bénédicte, “Beyond Comparison: Histoire Croisée and the Challenge of Reflexivity,”History and Theory 45 (2006): 30–50Google Scholar

Stoler, Ann Laura and Cooper, Frederick, “Between Metropole and Colony: Toward a Research Agenda” in Cooper, Frederick and Stoler, Ann Laura (eds.), Tensions of Empire: Colonial Cultures in a Bourgeois World (Berkeley, CA, 1997 1–56

Burbank, Jane and Cooper, Frederick, Empires in World History: Power and Politics of Difference (Princeton, NJ, 2010)

Gardner, Lloyd C. and Young, Marilyn B. (eds.), The New American Empire: A 21st Century Teach-In on U.S. Foreign Policy (New York, 2005), 253–75

Manifest Destiny: American Expansion and the Age of Right (New York, 1996)

Kramer, Paul A. in his “Power and Connection: Imperial Histories of the United States in the World,”American Historical Review 116 (December 2011): 1348–91Google Scholar

Mitchell, Timothy, Rule of Experts: Egypt, Techno-Politics and Modernity (Berkeley, CA, 2002)

Scott, James C., Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed (New Haven, CT, 1999)

Dudziak, Mary L., War Time: An Idea, Its History, Its Consequences (New York, 2012)

Meaney, Thomas and Wertheim, Stephen, “Grand Flattery,”Nation, 28 May 2012, 27–31Google Scholar

Accessibility standard: Unknown

Accessibility compliance for the PDF of this book is currently unknown and may be updated in the future.