Bishops and the Politics of Lithomania in Early Byzantium

Daniel F. Caner

doi:10.1017/9781108895859.012

Chapter 11 - Bishops and the Politics of Lithomania in Early Byzantium

from Part V - The Decline and Fall of Euergetism?

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 21 January 2021

Daniel F. Caner

Edited by

Marc Domingo Gygax and

Arjan Zuiderhoek

Show author details

Marc Domingo Gygax: Affiliation:
Princeton University, New Jersey
Arjan Zuiderhoek: Affiliation:
Universiteit Gent, Belgium

Book contents

Get access

Summary

Contrary to common belief, Christian bishops did not simply continue practicing traditional euergetism in Christianized form in cities of the late Roman Near East. From the late fourth century onwards, they had to answer for their use of church resources to an ideologically significant special interest group known as the ptōchoi. Entitled to church resources called the poor fund (ptōchika), this constituency was often comprised not only of the urban poor but of local monastic leaders who had close connections with influential lay donors. This chapter examines the details of three early fifth-century allegations of episcopal lithomania (excessive construction of church buildings) to date the historical emergence of this urban constituency and show how it pressured bishops to spend funds in their interest. It argues that the pressure exerted by this group was crucial in ensuring that episcopal budgets would be spent not just on monumental vanity projects but on philanthropic institutions and services. Hence these ptōchoi were actively involved in the politics that changed the urban landscape of the Roman Near East.

Keywords

church poor fund deserving poor Christian patronage monasticism bishop lithomania ptōchoi ptōchika

Type: Chapter
Information: Benefactors and the Polis
The Public Gift in the Greek Cities from the Homeric World to Late Antiquity
, pp. 267 - 296

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108895859.012 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2021

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Primary Sources

Anon. Vita Iohanni Eleēmosyni, in Delehaye, H. (ed.), Une vie inédite de S. Jean l’Aumónier, Brussels (1927), 19–25. Trans. E. Dawes and N. H. Baynes, Three Byzantine Saints. Crestwood, NY (1996), 199–206.Google Scholar

Athanasius, Pseudo- [Ps.-Ath.]. Canons, in Riedel, W. and Crum, W. (ed. and trans.), The Canons of Athanasius. Text and Translation Society 9. Amsterdam (1973).Google Scholar

Barsanuphius, [Bars.]. Questiones et responses [qu. et resp.], in Neyt, F. and de Angelis-Noah, P. (ed. and trans.), Barsanuphe et Jean de Gaza: correspondance, vol. 3: lettres 617–848 (aux laïcs et aux évêques). Sources chrétiennes 468. Paris (2002).Google Scholar

Choricius of Gaza [Chor.]. Orationes, in Foerster, R. and Richtsteig, E. (eds.), Choricii Gazaei opera, Leipzig (1929). Trans. F. K. Litsas, ‘Choricius of Gaza: an approach to his work. Introduction, translation, commentary,’ PhD dissertation, University of Chicago (1980).Google Scholar

Council of Chalcedon. Acta [ACO]. In Schwartz, E. (ed.), Acta Conciliorum Oecumenicorum, vol. 2: Concilium universale Chalcedonense. Berlin (1924–35). Trans. R. Price and M. Gaddis, The Acts of the Council of Chalcedon, 3 vols. Translated Texts for Historians 45. Liverpool (2005).Google Scholar

Ephesus, Second Council. Acta. Trans. Doran, R., Stewards of the Poor: The Man of God, Rabbula, and Hiba in Fifth-Century Edessa. Cistercian Studies Series 208. Kalamazoo, MI (2006), 133–88.Google Scholar

Gerontius, [Geront.]. Vita Melaniae graeca, in Gorce, D. (ed.), Gérontius: vie de Sainte Mélanie. Sources Chrétiennes 90. Paris (1962).Google Scholar

Gregory the Great [Greg]. Registrum epistularum [reg.], in Norberg, D. (ed.), S. Gregorii Magni Registrum epistularum, 2 vols. (Libri I–VII and Libri VIII–XIV). Corpus Christianorum Series Latina 140 and 140A. Turnhout (1982).Google Scholar

Gregory of Nazianzus. Funebris oratio in patrem [Or. 18]. PG 35: 985–1044. Trans. C. G. Browne, A Select Library of Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, vol. 7: S. Cyril of Jerusalem, S. Gregory Nazianzen. Grand Rapids, MI (1989).Google Scholar

Isidore of Pelusium [Isid. Pel.]. Epistulae, in Évieux, P. (ed.), Isidore de Péluse: lettres, 2 vols. Sources Chrétiennes 422 and 454. Paris (1997, 2000); also PG 78: 177A–1645D.Google Scholar

John of Tella, Pseudo-. Canons, in Vööbus, A. (ed. and trans.), The Synodicon in West Syrian Tradition. Corpus Scriptorum Christianorum Orientalium 367/368, Script. syri 161. Louvain (1975).Google Scholar

Justinian, [Just.]. Codex Iustinianus, in Krueger, P. and Schoell, R. (eds.), Corpus Iuris Civilis, vol. 2. Berlin (1895).Google Scholar

Justinian, [Just.]. Novellae, in Krueger, P. and Schoell, R. (eds.), Corpus Iuris Civilis, vol. 3. Berlin (1895).Google Scholar

Leontius of Neapolis [Leont. N.]. Vita Iohannis Eleemosynarii, in Festugière, A.-J. (ed.), Léontios de Néapolis, vie de Syméon le Fou et vie de Jean de Chypre. Paris (1974). Trans. E. Dawes and N. H. Baynes, Three Byzantine Saints. Crestwood, NY (1996), 207–62.Google Scholar

Lydus, John. De magistribus, in Bandy, A. C. (ed. and trans.), Ioannes Lydus: On Powers or the Magistracies of the Roman State. Philadelphia (1983).Google Scholar

Man of God of Edessa, in Amiaud, A. (ed.), La légende syriaque de Saint Alexis, l’homme de Dieu. Paris (1889). Trans. R. Doran, Stewards of the Poor: The Man of God, Rabbula, and Hiba in Fifth-Century Edessa. Cistercian Studies Series 208. Kalamazoo, MI (2006), 17–25.Google Scholar

Mar Jesuyahb, Synod. Canons, in Chabot, J.-B. (ed. and trans.), Synodicon Orientale de recueil de Synodes Nestorians. Paris (1911).Google Scholar

Mark the Deacon [Marc. Diac.]. Vita Porphyrii Gazensis, in Grégoire, H. and Kugener, M.-A. (ed.), Marc le Diacre: Vie de Porphyre, Évêque de Gaza. Paris (1930).Google Scholar

Martyrius, Pseudo-, of Antioch. [Ps.-Martyr.]. Oratio funebris, in Wallraff, M. (ed.), Oratio funebris in laudem sancti Iohannis Chrysostomi: Epitaffio attribuito a Martirio di Antiochia (BHG 871, CPG 6517). Quaderni della Rivista di Bizantinistica 12. Spoleto (2007).Google Scholar

Moschus, John [Mosch.]. Pratum spirituale [prat.]. PG 87 [III].2852A–3112B.Google Scholar

Palladius [Pall.]. Dialogus de vita Iohannis Chrysostomis [v.Chrys.], in Malingrey, A.-M. (ed.), Palladios: dialogue sur la vie de S. Jean Chrysostome. Sources Chretiennes 341. Paris (1988).Google Scholar

Palladius [Pall.]. Historia Lausiaca [Hist. Laus.], in Butler, C. (ed.), The Lausiac History of Palladius. Cambridge (1904).Google Scholar

Procopius of Caesarea. De aedificiis, in Hury, J. (ed.), Procopii Caesariensis opera omnia, vol. 3.2. Leipzig (1906).Google Scholar

Rabbula of Edessa [Rabb.]. Canons for Priests, in Vööbus, A. (ed. and trans.), Syriac and Arabic Documents Regarding Legislation Relative to Syrian Asceticism. Stockholm (1960), 34–50.Google Scholar

Rabbula Panegyric [Pan. Rabb.], in Overbeck, J. J. (ed.), S. Ephraemi Syri, Rabulae Episcopi Edesseni, Balaei aliorumque opera selecta. Oxford (1865). Trans. R. Doran, Stewards of the Poor: The Man of God, Rabbula, and Hiba in Fifth-Century Edessa. Cistercian Studies Series 208. Kalamazoo, MI (2006), 65–108.Google Scholar

Severus of Antioch [Sev. Ant.]. Cathedral homilies 100 and 101, in Guidi, I. (ed. and trans.), Les homiliae cathedrales de Sévère d’Antioche: homélies XCIX à CIII. Patrologia Orientalis 22. Paris (1930), 230–73.Google Scholar

Theodoret of Cyrrhus. Epistulae, in Azéma, Y. (ed. and trans.), Théodoret de Cyr: correspondence II (Epist. Sirm. 1–95). Sources Chrétiennes 98. Paris (1964).Google Scholar

Secondary Sources

Abd el-Samie, M. (1993) ‘Tell El-Makhzan’, Monde de la Bible 82: 21.Google Scholar

Allen, P. (2011) ‘Episcopal succession in Antioch in the sixth century’, in Leemans, J., Van Nuffelen, P., Keough, S. W. J. and Nicolaye, C. (eds.), Episcopal Elections in Late Antiquity. Berlin, 23–38.Google Scholar

Alston, R. (2002) The City in Roman and Byzantine Egypt. London.Google Scholar

Avraméa, A. (1989) ‘Les constructions profanes de l’évêque d’après l’épigraphie et les textes d’Orient’, in Duval, N. (ed.), Actes du XIe Congrès International d’Archéologie Chrétienne: Lyon, Vienne, Grenoble, Genève et Aoste, (21–28 sept 1986), vol. 1, Collection de l’École française du Rome 123. Rome, 829–35.Google Scholar

Batiffol, P. (1911) ‘L’epitaphe d’Eugène, Evêque de Laodiceé’, Bulletin d’Ancienne Litterature et d’Archéologie Chrétienne 1: 25–34.Google Scholar

Baumstark, A. (1904) ‘Vorjustinianische kirchliche Bauten in Edessa’, Oriens Christianus 4: 164–83.Google Scholar

Brown, P. (1992) Power and Persuasion in Late Antiquity: Towards a Christian Empire. Madison, WI.Google Scholar

Brown, P. (2002) Poverty and Leadership in the Later Roman Empire. Hanover, NH.Google Scholar

Brown, P. (2012) Through the Eye of a Needle: Wealth, the Fall of Rome, and the Making of Christianity in the West, 350–550 AD. Princeton.Google Scholar

Caillet, J.-P. (2003) ‘L’évergétisme monumental chrétien dans la Jordanie de la fin de l’antiquité’, in Duval, N. (ed.), Les églises de Jordanie et leurs mosaïques. Bibliothèque archéologique et historique 168. Beirut, 297–301.Google Scholar

Caillet, J.-P. (2012) ‘L’évolution de la notion d’évergétisme dans l’Antiquité chrétienne’, in Spieser, J.-M. and Yota, É. (eds.), Donation et donateurs dans le monde byzantin: actes du colloque internationale de l’Université de Fribourg, 13–15 mars 2008. Réalités Byzantines 14. Paris, 11–24.Google Scholar

Caner, D. F. (2002) Wandering Begging Monks: Spiritual Authority and the Promotion of Monasticism in Late Antiquity. Transformation of the Classical Heritage 33. Berkeley.Google Scholar

Caner, D. F. (2018) ‘Not a hospital but a leprosarium: Basil’s Basilias and an early Byzantine concept of the deserving Poor’, Dumbarton Oaks Papers 72: 25–48.Google Scholar

Caseau, B. (2001) ‘Πολεμειν λιθοіς: la désacralisation des espaces et des objets religieux païens durant l’Antiquité tardive’, in Kaplan, M. (ed.), Le sacré et son inscription dans l’espace à Byzance et en Occident. Byzantina Sorbonensia 18. Paris, 61–123.Google Scholar

Dagron, G. (1989) ‘Constantinople: les sanctuaries et l’organisation de la vie religeuse: topographie chrétienne’, in Duval, N., Baritel, F. and Pergola, P. (eds.), Actes du XIe congrès international d’archéologie chrétienne. Lyon, Vienne, Grenoble, Genève et Aoste (21–28 Septembre 1986). Rome, 1069–85.Google Scholar

Deliyannis, D. (2015) ‘Church-building in rhetoric and reality in the 5th–7th centuries’, in Radtki, C., Danner, M. and Boschung, D. (eds.), Politische Fragmentierung und kulturelle Kohärenz in der Spätantike. Munich, 159–82.Google Scholar

Déroche, V. (1995) Études sur Léontios de Néapolis. Studia Byzantina Upsaliensia 3. Uppsala.Google Scholar

Destephen, S. (2008) Prosopographie chrétienne du Bas-Empire, vol. 3: Prosopographie du Diocése d’Asie (325–641). Paris.Google Scholar

Di Segni, L. (1999) ‘Epigraphic documentation on building in the provinces of Palaestina and Arabia, 4th–7th c.’, in Humphrey, J. H. (ed.), Roman and Byzantine Near East, 2: Some Recent Archaeological Research. Journal of Roman Archaeology Suppl. 31. Portsmouth, RI, 149–78.Google Scholar

Donceel-Voûte, P. (1988) Les pavements des églises byzantines de Syrie et du Liban: décor, archéologie et liturge. Publications d’Histoire de l’art et d’archéologie de l’Université Catholique de Louvain 69. Louvain-la-neuve.Google Scholar

Doran, R. (2006) Stewards of the Poor: The Man of God, Rabbula, and Hiba in Fifth-Century Edessa. Cistercian Studies Series 208. Kalamazoo, MI.Google Scholar

Downey, G. (1961) A History of Antioch in Syria from Seleucus to the Arab Conquest. Princeton.Google Scholar

Drijvers, H. J. W. (1996) ‘The man of God of Edessa, bishop Rabbula and the urban poor: church and society in the fifth century’, Journal of Early Christian Studies 4: 235–48.CrossRef Google Scholar

Elm, S. K. (1998) ‘The dog that did not bark: doctrine and patriarchal authority in the conflict between Theophilus of Alexandria and John Chrysostom of Constantinople’, in Ayres, L. and Jones, G. (eds.), Christian Origins: Theology, Rhetoric, and Community. London, 68–93.Google Scholar

Évieux, P. (1995) Isidore de Péluse. Théologie historique 99. Paris.Google Scholar

Feissel, D., and Philippides-Braat, A. (1985) ‘Inventaires en vue d’un recueil des inscriptions historiques de Byzance. III: inscriptions du Péloponnèse (à l’exception de Mistra)’, Travaux et Memoires 9: 268–398.Google Scholar

Finn, R. (2006) Almsgiving in the Later Roman Empire: Christian Promotion and Practice (313–450). Oxford.Google Scholar

Gaddis, M. (2005) There Is No Crime for Those Who Have Christ: Religious Violence in the Christian Roman Empire. Transformation of the Classical Heritage 39. Berkeley.Google Scholar

Haensch, R. (2006) ‘Le financement de la constructions des églises pendant l’Antiquité tardive et l’évergétisme antique’, Antiquité Tardive 14: 47–58.Google Scholar

Haensch, R. (2011) ‘Christlicher Euergetismus ob honorem? Die Einsetzung von Klerikern in ihre Ämter und die von diesen vorangetriebenen Bauprojekte’, in Leemans, J., Van Nuffelen, P., Keough, S. W. J. and Nicolaye, C. (eds.), Episcopal Elections in Late Antiquity. Berlin, 167–82.Google Scholar

Haldon, J. (2009) ‘Introduction: Greater Syria in the seventh-century: context and background’, in Haldon, J. (ed.), Money, Power and Politics in Early Islamic Syria: A Review of Current Debates. Farnham, 1–20.Google Scholar

Hevelone-Harper, J. (2005) Disciples of the Desert: Monks, Laity and Spiritual Authority in Sixth-Century Gaza. Baltimore.Google Scholar

Holum, K. G. (1982) Theodosian Empresses: Women and Imperial Dominion in Late Antiquity. Transformation of the Classical Heritage 3. Berkeley.Google Scholar

Jäggi, C., and Meier, H.-R. (1997) ‘“… this great appetite for church building still needs adequate explanation”. Zum Kirchenbauboom am Ende der Spätantike’, in Colella, R. L. (ed.), Pratum Romanum. Richard Krautheimer zu seinem 100. Geburtstag. Wiesbaden, 181–98.Google Scholar

Jones, A. H. M. (1992) The Later Roman Empire, 284–602: A Social, Economic and Administrative Survey, 2 vols. Baltimore.Google Scholar

Kotz, D. (2010) ‘Triphis in the White Monastery: reused temple blocks from Sohag,’ Ancient Society 40: 197–213.Google Scholar

Kraeling, C. H. (1938) Gerasa: City of the Decapolis. New Haven.Google Scholar

Lassus, J. (1947) Sanctuaires chrétiens de Syrie: essai sur la genèse, la forme et l’usage liturgique des édifices du culte chrétien en Syrie, du III^e siècle à la conquête musulmane. Institut Français d’Archéologie de Beyrouth, Bibliothèque Archéologique et Historique 42. Paris.Google Scholar

Liebeschutz, J. H. W. G. (2001) The Decline and Fall of the Roman City. Oxford.CrossRef Google Scholar

López, A. G. (2013) Shenoute of Atripe and the Uses of Poverty: Rural Patronage, Religious Conflict and Monasticism in Late Antique Egypt. Transformation of the Classical Heritage 50. Berkeley.Google Scholar

Magdalino, P. (1990) ‘Church, baths, and diakonia in medieval Constantinople’, in Morris, R. (ed.), Church and People in Byzantium. Birmingham, 165–88.Google Scholar

Markus, R. A. (1990) The End of Ancient Christianity. Cambridge.Google Scholar

Markus, R. A. (1997) Gregory the Great and His World. Cambridge.Google Scholar

Martin, A. 1979. ‘L’église et la khôra égyptienne au IVe siècle’, Institut d’Études Augustiniennes 25: 3–26.Google Scholar

Martin, A. (1984) ‘Les premiers siècles du christianisme à Alexandrie: essai de topographie religieuse (III^e–IV^e siècles)’, Revue des Etudes Augustiniennes 30: 211–25.Google Scholar

Matthews, J. F. (1975) Western Aristocracies and Imperial Court, AD 364–425. Oxford.Google Scholar

Maxwell, J. L. (2006) Christianization and Communication in Late Antiquity. Cambridge.Google Scholar

Mayer, W. (2008) ‘Poverty and generosity towards the poor in the time of John Chrysostom’, in Holman, S. R. (ed.), Wealth and Poverty in Early Church and Society. Grand Rapids, MI, 140–58.Google Scholar

Mayer, W. (2009) ‘John Chrysostom on Poverty’, in Allen, P., Neil, B. and Mayer, W. (eds.), Preaching Poverty in Late Antiquity: Perceptions and Realities. Leipzig, 69–111.Google Scholar

Mentzou-Meimari, C. (1982) ‘Eparchiaka euage idrymata mechri tou telous tes eikonomachias’, Vyzantina 11: 243–308.Google Scholar

Natali, A. (1982) ‘Église et évergétisme à Antioche à la fin du IVe siècle d’après Jean Chrysostome’, Studia Patristica 17: 1176–84.Google Scholar

Norton, P. (2007) Episcopal Elections 250–600: Hierarchy and Popular Will in Late Antiquity. Oxford.Google Scholar

Patlagean, É. (1977) Pauvreté économique et pauvreté sociale à Byzance, 4^e–7^e siècles. Paris.CrossRef Google Scholar

Piccirillo, M. (1993) The Mosaics of Jordan. Amman.Google Scholar

Rapp, C. (2005) Holy Bishops in Late Antiquity: The Nature of Christian Leadership in an Age of Transition. Transformation of the Classical Heritage 37. Berkeley.CrossRef Google Scholar

Roueché, C. (1997) ‘Benefactors in the late Roman period: the eastern Empire’, in Christol, M. and Masson, O. (eds.), Actes du X^e Congrès international d’épigraphie grecque et latine, Nîmes, 4–9 octobre 1992. Paris, 353–68.Google Scholar

Saller, S. J., and Bagatti, B. (1949) The Town of Nebo (Khirbet El-Mekhayyat) with a Brief Survey of Other Ancient Christian Monuments in Transjordan. Publications of the Studium Biblicum Franciscanum 7. Jerusalem.Google Scholar

Sandwell, I. (2004) ‘Christian self-definition in the fourth century AD: John Chrysostom on Christianity, imperial rule, and the city’, in Sandwell, I. and Huskinson, J. (eds.), Culture and Society in Later Roman Antioch. Oxford, 35–58.Google Scholar

Sandwell, I. (2007) Religious Identity in Late Antiquity: Greeks, Jews and Christians in Antioch. Cambridge.Google Scholar

Saradi, H. G. (2006) The Byzantine City in the Sixth Century: Literary Images and Historical Reality. Athens.Google Scholar

Segal, J. B. (1970) Edessa, ‘the Blessed City’. Oxford.Google Scholar

Thomas, J. P. (1987) Private Religious Foundations in the Byzantine Empire. Dumbarton Oaks Studies 24. Washington, DC.Google Scholar

Wipszycka, E. (1972) Les ressources et les activités économiques des églises en Égypte du IV^e au VIII^e siècle. Papyrologica Bruxellensia 10. Brussels.Google Scholar

Wipszycka, E. (1996) Études sur le christianisme dans l’Égypte de l’Antiquité Tardive. Rome.Google Scholar

Zeisel, W. N. (1975) ‘An economic survey of the early Byzantine church’, PhD dissertation, Rutgers University.Google Scholar

Zuiderhoek, A. (2009) The Politics of Munificence in the Roman Empire: Citizens, Elites and Benefactors in Asia Minor. Cambridge.Google Scholar