The Bolshevik Revolution and the Socialist Calculation Debate

Lawrence H. White

doi:10.1017/CBO9780511998218.003

2 - The Bolshevik Revolution and the Socialist Calculation Debate

Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 June 2012

Lawrence H. White

Show author details

Lawrence H. White: Affiliation:
George Mason University, Virginia

Book contents

Get access

Summary

Vladmir Lenin sent warm greetings in April 1919 to the socialist revolutionaries who had just seized power in Munich and declared a Bavarian Soviet Republic. Drawing on his experience eighteen months earlier leading the Bolshevik Revolution that gave Russia a Soviet Socialist government, he asked them about a checklist of concrete measures they might take, urging their “most urgent and most extensive implementation”:

[H]ave councils of workers and servants been formed in the different sections of the city; have the workers been armed; have the bourgeoisie been disarmed; has use been made of the stocks of clothing and other items for immediate and extensive aid to the workers, and especially to the farm labourers and small peasants; have the capitalist factories and wealth in Munich and the capitalist farms in its environs been confiscated; have mortgage and rent payments by small peasants been cancelled; have the wages of farm labourers and unskilled workers been doubled or trebled; have all paper stocks and all printing-presses been confiscated so as to enable popular leaflets and newspapers to be printed for the masses; has the six-hour working day with two or three-hour instruction in state administration been introduced; have the bourgeoisie in Munich been made to give up surplus housing so that workers may be immediately moved into comfortable flats; have you taken over all the banks; have you taken hostages from the ranks of the bourgeoisie; have you introduced higher rations for the workers than for the bourgeoisie; have all the workers been mobilised for defence and for ideological propaganda in the neighbouring villages?

The list concisely summarizes Lenin’s immediate agenda for consolidating power by winning over the workers. The absence of any suggestions for longer-range economic strategy hints at the problem Lenin himself faced in Moscow: because there were no concrete guidelines from Marx and Engels, economic policy had to be improvised.

Information

Type: Chapter
Information: The Clash of Economic Ideas
The Great Policy Debates and Experiments of the Last Hundred Years
, pp. 32 - 67

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511998218.003 [Opens in a new window]

Publisher: Cambridge University Press

Print publication year: 2012

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Book purchase

Temporarily unavailable

References

Boettke, Peter J.The Political Economy of Soviet Socialism: The Formative Years, 1918–1928BostonKluwer Academic 1990CrossRef Google Scholar

Hirshliefer, JackEconomic Behavior in AdversityChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press 1987Google Scholar

Gregory, PaulBefore Command: An Economic History of Russia from Emancipation to the First Five-year PlanPrinceton, NJPrinceton University Press 1994CrossRef Google Scholar

Ball, Alan M.Russia’s Last Capitalists: The Nepmen, 1921–1929BerkeleyUniversity of California Press 1990Google Scholar

Polanyi-Levitt, KariMendell, MargueriteThe Origins of Market Fetishism – Critique of Friedrich Hayek’s Economic TheoryMonthly Review 41 1989 11Google Scholar

Caldwell, BruceHayek’s ChallengeChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press 2004Google Scholar

Mises, Ludwig vonCollectivist Economic PlanningLondonRoutledge 1935Google Scholar

Mises, SocialismIndianapolisLiberty Fund 1981Google Scholar

Hayek, Hayek on Hayek: An Autobiographical DialogueChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press 1994CrossRef Google Scholar

Hart, DavidLudwig von Mises, Money, and the Fall and Rise of Classical Liberalism in the 20th Century,Literature of Liberty 5 1982 3Google Scholar

Ebeling, Richard M.Globalization: Will Freedom or World Government Dominate the International Marketplace?Hillsdale, Mich.Hillsdale College Press 2002Google Scholar

Hülsmann, Jörg GuidoMises: The Last Knight of LiberalismAuburn, ALMises Institute 2007Google Scholar

Lavoie, DonRivalry and Central Planning: The Socialist Calculation Debate ReconsideredCambridgeCambridge University Press 1985Google Scholar

Levy, David M.Peart, Sandra J.New Palgrave Dictionary of EconomicsNew YorkPalgrave Macmillan 2008Google Scholar

Gwartney, JamesLawson, RobertEconomic Freedom of the World: 2009 Annual ReportEconomic Freedom Network 2009 http://www.freetheworld.com/release.htmlGoogle Scholar

Fitzpatrick, SheilaEveryday StalinismOxfordOxford University Press 1999Google Scholar

Levy, DavidThe Bias in Centrally Planned Prices,Public Choice 67, 1990 213CrossRef Google Scholar

Prychitko, David L.The Concise Encyclopedia of EconomicsIndianapolisLiberty Fund 2008Google Scholar

Smith, AdamAn Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of NationsCampbell, R. H.Skinner, A. S.Todd, W. B.IndianapolisLiberty 1981Google Scholar

Ricardo, DavidThe Principles of Political EconomyLondonJohn Murray 1817Google Scholar

Menger, CarlPrinciples of EconomicsNew YorkNew York University Press 1976Google Scholar

Lange, OskarOn the Economic Theory of Socialism: Part One,Review of Economic Studies 4 1936 53CrossRef Google Scholar

Taylor, Fred M.The Guidance of Production in a Socialist State,American Economic Review 19 1929 1Google Scholar

Dickinson, H. D.Price Formation in a Socialist Community,Economic Journal 43 1933 237CrossRef Google Scholar

Lerner, Abba P.Economic Theory and Socialist Economy,Review of Economic Studies 2 1934CrossRef Google Scholar

Lerner, The Economics of ControlNew YorkMacmillan 1940Google Scholar

Lippincott, Benjamin E.On the Economic Theory of SocialismMinneapolisUniversity of Minnesota Press 1938Google Scholar

1839

Dobb, MauriceOn Economic Theory and Socialism: Collected PapersLondonRoutledge 1953Google Scholar

Walras, LéonElements of Pure EconomicsLondonRoutledge 2003Google Scholar

Robbins, LionelThe Nature and Significance of Economic ScienceLondonMacmillan 1932Google Scholar

Mises, Ludwig vonHuman ActionChicagoHenry Regnery 1966Google Scholar

Hayek, F. A.Socialist Calculation: The Competitive Solution,Economica 7 1940 125CrossRef Google Scholar

Hayek, Individualism and Economic OrderChicagoGateway 1972Google Scholar

Hayek, Friedrich A. 1945

Phelps, Edmund S.Macroeconomics for a Modern Economy,American Economic Review 97 2007 543CrossRef Google Scholar

Lange, OskarEconomic Theory and Market Socialism: Selected Essays of Oskar LangeAldershot, UKEdward Elgar 1994Google Scholar

Lange, Oskar 1942

Kowalik, TadeuszWhy Market Socialism? Voices from DissentArmonk, NYM. E. Sharpe 1994Google Scholar

Schiff, Stacy 2006 http://www.newyorker.com/fact/content/articles/060731fa

Sowell, Thomas 2007 http://townhall.com/columnists/ThomasSowell/2007/05/16/presumptions

Caplan, BryanIs Socialism Really ‘Impossible’?Critical Review 16 2004 33CrossRef Google Scholar

Boettke, Peter J.Leeson, Peter T.Still Impossible after All These Years: Reply to Caplan,Critical Review 17 2005 155CrossRef Google Scholar

Bergson, AbramEssays in Normative EconomicsCambridge, MAHarvard University Press 1966CrossRef Google Scholar

Bergson, AbramMarket Socialism RevisitedJournal of Political Economy 75 1967 658CrossRef Google Scholar

Bergson, AbramThe Economics of Soviet PlanningNew Haven, CTYale University Press 1964Google Scholar

Levy, David M.Peart, Sandra J.Soviet Growth and American Textbooks: An Endogenous PastJournal of Economic Behavior & Organization 78 2011 110CrossRef Google Scholar

Samuelson, Paul A.Nordhaus, William D.EconomicsNew YorkMcGraw-Hill 1989Google Scholar

Skousen, MarkThe Perseverance of Paul Samuelson’s EconomicsJournal of Economic Perspectives 11 1997 148CrossRef Google Scholar

Smelev, NikolaiPopov, VladimirThe Turning PointNew YorkDoubleday 1989Google Scholar

DeLong, J. BradfordSeeing One’s Intellectual Roots: A Review Essay on James Scott’s ,Review of Austrian Economics 12 1999 257CrossRef Google Scholar

Roemer, JohnSocialism’s Future: An Interview with John Roemer,Imprints 3 1998 23Google Scholar

Schmidtz, DavidWhen Justice Matters,Ethics 117 2007 437CrossRef Google Scholar

Accessibility standard: Unknown

Accessibility compliance for the PDF of this book is currently unknown and may be updated in the future.