To save content items to your account,
please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies.
If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account.
Find out more about saving content to .
To save content items to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org
is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings
on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part
of your Kindle email address below.
Find out more about saving to your Kindle.
Note you can select to save to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations.
‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi.
‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.
Galactic magnetic fields are widely thought to be the product of a turbulent mean field dynamo. We find, however, that kinematic mean field theory is inapplicable for galactic parameters because there is no effective way to destroy the small-scale fluctuating magnetic fields. We find that this ‘magnetic noise’ grows exponentially with a time constant of 104 years, while the dynamo grows with a 2 × 108 year time scale. The dynamo field quickly becomes unobservable under such conditions and the kinematic approximation fails before the mean field grows significantly.
INTRODUCTION
Our galaxy and others are permeated by magnetic fields. They play an important role in star formation, in the support of molecular clouds against collapse, and in cosmic ray confinement. With a field strength of a few microgauss, they are comparable in in energy density to thermal energy, radiation, and cosmic rays. These fields are widely assumed to be the result of a dynamo operating on an initial seed field.
Dynamos work by folding magnetic field lines back on themselves constructively more often than destructively. Mean field theory assumes that the many folds in the field with no net contribution are destroyed, usually by resistivity. What would happen if these small disordered fields were not destroyed? They would obscure the growing large-scale field and might dominate the total magnetic energy. This is indeed a concern for galactic dynamo theory as magnetic loops 0.1 pc across need 1022 years to decay ohmically.
The helioseismological results about the Solar law of rotation pose some serious problems for dynamo theory. However, if the magnetic flux is bounded in the lower part of the convection zone and the α-effect is concentrated at the equator, it is possible to obtain correct butterfly diagrams. This model seems to be a natural combination of the new law of rotation, the suggested storage of the magnetic flux at the bottom of the convection zone, the trapping of flux tubes at low latitudes and the induction effect of magnetos trophic waves.
THE DYNAMO IN THE CONVECTION ZONE
In 1969, Steenbeck & Krause presented results of the first hydrodynamic dynamo model acting in the turbulent convection zone (CZ) and based on the idea of mean field electrodynamics. They introduced two spherical shells for the induction effects: in the inner, there is the differential rotation (Ω ∼ r) and in the outer, one has the turbulent rotating matter (α ∼ Cos v). This simple model is in agreement with most of the observed magnetic patterns, such as the butterfly diagram (Figure 1), H ale's polarity rule and the 22 year period of the Solar cycle.
During half a cycle, i.e. eleven years, the activity belts, as a measure of the toroidal field, move from about ±30° latitude towards the equator. In the vicinity of the pole, there are no active regions. But observations of torsional oscillations (Howard & LaBonte 1982) and Solar wind (Legrand & Simon 1991) suggest that the toroidal field starts the reversal of its polarity there (Schussler 1981).
Convection in a compressible fluid with an imposed vertical magnetic field is studied numerically in a three-dimensional Cartesian geometry, restricting attention to the weakly nonlinear regime. Steady convection occurs in the form of two-dimensional rolls when the field is weak but three-dimensional squares when the magnetic field is sufficiently strong. In the regime where convection is oscillatory, the preferred planform for moderate fields is found to be ‘alternating rolls’ – standing waves in both horizontal directions which are out of phase. For stronger fields, oscillatory convection takes the form of a two-dimensional travelling wave.
INTRODUCTION
This paper is concerned with the effect of an imposed magnetic field on thermal convection. Although this is not directly relevant to dynamo theory, the question of the interaction of convection with magnetic fields is important for a full understanding of a convectively driven dynamo. The motivation for this work is to understand some aspects of convection in the Sun, particularly in regions of high magnetic field, such as sunspots, where the strong, predominantly vertical field inhibits thermal convection, causing the spot to appear dark. This work is part of an ongoing collaboration with Michael Proctor and Nigel Weiss. This brief report summarises some of the main results of this work; further details will be published in a future paper (Matthews, Proctor & Weiss 1993).
Linear theory for the onset of magnetoconvection in an incompressible fluid was discussed extensively by Chandrasekhar (1961).
My objective in these five lectures was to introduce the fundamental physical ideas underlying cosmological models of an isotropic hot Big-Bang and the development of large-scale structure in such an expanding universe. My instructions from the Organizing Committee were to assume that the audience had not studied cosmology before, and that is what I have tried to do. My final lecture reviewed a number of results in infrared observational cosmology, but constraints of time and space have not permitted inclusion of that material here.
Much of the material on isotropic cosmological models is developed very well in any number of existing sources (although this is less so for the theory of galaxy formation) and it is with some diffidence that I offer my version. The references list a number of other developments of these topics, and I have borrowed from most of them. Perhaps the best recent text which covers these and many other topics in modern cosmology very thoroughly, and yet very readably, is that by Kolb and Turner (1990). My own research in infrared observational cosmology received an important stimulus from a series of similar lectures presented by Malcolm Longair (1977) over 15 years ago. I hope these lectures might, in a similar way, give young astronomers an introduction which will generate enthusiasm for inventing new infrared observing programs bearing on fundamental cosmological problems.
THE ISOTROPIC UNIVERSE
Introduction
We begin by taking a very large-scale view of the universe, and make a simplicity approximation that the universe is smooth, with no structure. In this approximation we can think of the universe as a fluid (of galaxies) of density ρ, pressure p.
One theory for the origin of the galactic field is that it grows from a very weak seed field by fast dynamo action associated with turbulent motions. However, the dynamo also amplifies small scale fields faster than the large scale. In this paper we calculate the time evolution of the spectrum of small scale fields. We show that the magnetic turbulence reaches the resistive scale in a reasonably short time where some damping occurs. We also show that the damping is not strong enough to stop the exponential growth of the random turbulence which grows to equipartition with the turbulent power in a time short compared to the dynamo growth time for the large scale fields. Our conclusion is that a dynamo origin from a weak seed field is not plausible.
A hotly debated topic is the origin of the large scale galactic magnetic field. Originally, it was supposed by Fermi and others that the field had a primordial origin and was maintained against Ohmic decay by the large inductance of the galactic disk. (The time scale for Ohmic decay by ordinary Spitzer resistivity is extremely long, of order 1026 years.) However, there have been several objections to the primordial theory (Parker 1979). One objection is that turbulent resistivity is sufficiently large to destroy the field in a Hubble time. A second objection is that if it is not destroyed by turbulent resistivity, it can escape from the galactic disc by ambipolar diffusion. Probably the strongest objection has been that there seems no known way to produce a magnetic field in the early universe on a large enough scale and of sufficient strength to provide a primordial origin.
By
C.A. Jones, Department of Mathematics, University of Exeter, Exeter, EX4 4QE UK,
D.J. Galloway, School of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW 2006 Australia
By
A.D. Gilbert, Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, University of Cambridge, Silver St., Cambridge, CB3 9EW UK,
N.F. Otani, School of Electrical Engineering, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853 USA,
S. Childress, Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences, New York University, New York, NY 10012 USA
Fast dynamo saturation is explored numerically using a simplified model. The magnetic field has many degrees of freedom and allows the generation of fine structure at large Rm. The velocity field is constrained, containing two Fourier modes and so eight degrees of freedom; the Lorentz force is projected onto these modes. Numerical simulations at varying Rm are discussed.
Fast dynamo instabilities are the subject of intense research (reviewed in Childress 1992), through numerical simulations and analytical studies of simple models. However little is known about how a fast dynamo instability might saturate and what the resulting spatial structure and temporal behaviour of the field might be. Does a fast dynamo saturate by suppressing the flow field until the effective magnetic Reynolds number is reduced to a value of order unity or by modifying transport effects of the flow (Vainshtein et al. 1993)? Is the saturated magnetic energy in equipartition with the kinetic energy and how is the magnetic energy distributed; in particular how much energy is stored in large-scale field components (Vainshtein & Cattaneo 1992)? Does the field contain the fine structure typical of kinematic fast dynamo instabilities and is it intermittent in time? The difficulty in answering these questions is that dynamo action only allows growth of 3-d magnetic fields and through the Lorentz force this leads to all the complexities of 3-d MHD turbulence. Numerical studies are computationally expensive and only moderate values of Rm have been achieved (see, for example, Gilman 1983, Glatzmaier 1985, Meneguzzi & Pouquet 1989, Nordlund et al 1991 and Galanti et al 1992).
By
P.A. Fox, High Altitude Observatory, National Center for Atmospheric Research Boulder, CO 80307-3000 USA,
M.L. Theobald, Center for Solar and Space Research, Yale University New Haven, CT 06511-6666 USA,
S. Sofia, Center for Solar and Space Research, Yale University New Haven, CT 06511-6666 USA
The detailed dynamics of the Solar dynamo presents a significant challenge to our understanding of the interaction of convection and magnetic fields in the Solar interior. In this paper we discuss certain aspects of this interaction, such as modification of convective energy transport, and turbulent dissipation of magnetic fields. The latter controls the spatial distribution of the magnetic field and its time dependence. We also discuss how these results may influence current Solar dynamo calculations.
MOTIVATION
Solar activity manifests itself in many forms but perhaps most importantly through the presence of a magnetic field. The topic of this meeting is that of dynamos, in Solar and planetary contexts. In the case of the Sun the dynamo, which seems likely to be responsible for at least part of the Solar activity we observe, acts on a global scale. That is, the period of the dynamo is 22 years (a timescale distinct from those usually encountered on the Sun), sunspots appear within latitude bands and their numbers (in terms of monthly or yearly running means) increase and decrease over one cycle. There is however, a strong asymmetry of the Solar cycle in time, i.e. the growth phase is shorter (and dependent of the amount of activity) than the decay, or descending phase. In addition, the polar field of the Sun is observed to reverse around Solar maximum, again with a distinct asymmetry between hemispheres. Despite these global-scale features, the Solar magnetic field has many spatial components (Stenflo 1991) and the majority of the magnetic flux appears in small elements.
The outer fluid core of the Earth can be considered as a fluid between two hard spheres (the internal core and the rock mantle) rotating with different but close angular velocities. In the incompressible, nonconducting almost inviscid limit a singular cylindrical surface having the radius of the internal sphere appears (the Proudman solution). A shear layer forming around this surface in the non-ideal fluid may have important implications for the geodynamo.
INTRODUCTION
The aim of this short paper is to attract attention to one feature in the Earth's fluid core. The feature is an internal shear layer induced by a relative rotation of the inner core. Large gradients of the velocity around this layer may be important for the geodynamo. Note, in particular, that in the geodynamo model-Z without an account of the inner core rotation one of the basic sources (the α-effect) is assumed to be concentrated near the core-mantle boundary (Braginsky 1993).
The inner core of the Earth can be considered as a hard iron ball of radius approximately 0.2R, where R is the Earth's radius. The rest of the planet is occupied by the outer liquid core and the rock mantle in the form of spherical shells of almost equal width, 0.4R. The other iron-rock planets (Mercury, Mars), except probably Venus, also have inner cores (Stevenson 1983). As the source of compositional convection (Loper & Roberts 1983) the inner core is apparently a necessary part of the planetary dynamo.
Turbulence plays a crucial role in dynamo processes. For example, turbulent difFusion is important for the existence of the Solar dynamo. Some turbulent phenomena may be studied with presentday measurement equipment. A number of relevant diagnostics are based on the interaction of an electromagnetic beam with plasma. Here we discuss the situation in which information on plasma properties is obtained by probing plasma with a plane polarized electromagnetic beam. It is shown that the problem of recovering statistical properties of turbulence from the line integrated data can be solved uniquely using a realistic model of plasma. Analytical expressions relating structure functions of both the random density field and random magnetic field to measured structure functions have been found. This information is of importance in studies of MHD turbulence.
STATISTICAL PROPERTIES OF PLASMA TURBULENCE
Recent measurements have shown the existence of fine-scale density structures in Tokamak plasmas (Cripwell & Costley 1991). There is also experimental evidence that the anomalous (i.e. greater than collisional) particle and energy transport may be in some circumstances due to particle drift motion caused by microturbulence. These facts make the investigation of the turbulence in Tokamaks very important. To describe the phenomena, it is useful to know statistics of random magnetic and density fields.
In this paper we discuss the statistical properties of plasma which can be studied with the so-called refractometry technique probing plasma with a plane polarized electromagnetic laser or microwave beam (Gill & Magyar 1987; Weisen et al. 1988.
In order to discuss the observations in a meaningful way, it is useful to first discuss the theory, because only then does one have a meaningful context in which to place the observations. One must note that this does not imply that the theory is well understood, because this is not necessarily the case. But this approach gives some insight as to what the key observations are, and by comparing the observations with the theory one can find the weakness in the theory which can be more thoroughly studied.
Review of the early evolution
The main sequence star transforms hydrogen into helium in the central regions of the star as its source of energy. This stage is usually referred to as hydrogen burning. As the hydrogen burns, the core gradually contracts and heats up, which produces an increase in the rate at which the hydrogen is burned. The increased burning rate closely offsets the diminished fuel supply, and the luminosity of the star does not change substantially. For the first 90% of its lifetime the star remains close to the main sequence, and may double its luminosity in this time. This is shown schematically in the H-R diagram, Fig. 1, as the motion from points A to B. The initial position on the main sequence is determined only by the mass of the star, as long as it consists mainly of hydrogen. Evolutionary tracks are shown for stars of 1.1 M⊙ and 5 M⊙. The former represent the ‘low’ mass stars and the latter represent ‘intermediate’ mass stars which will be presently more completely defined.
The Childress–Soward dynamo, which uses rotating Benard convection to maintain a magnetic field against Ohmic decay, is investigated numerically. A converged three-dimensional solution of the strong field branch is presented for very small Ekman number. For strong rotation, the system is able sustain convection and act as a dynamo even for a Rayleigh number substantially less than critical. It is found that the dominant forces tend to cancel, and that the magnitudes of the curls of the Lorentz and Coriolis forces remain virtually identical.
INTRODUCTION
Numerical computations comprise an increasingly important tool in the understanding of the Earth's dynamo, and, with the increased accessibility of supercomputers, direct, realistic simulations of the geodynamo are not far off. Any such simulation must solve the equations governing a three dimensional, rapidly rotating, dynamically consistent dynamo with Lorentz force J × B present in the dominant balance of forces. The simplest dynamo with these characteristics, first proposed by Childress & Soward (1972), uses the convective motions of rapidly rotating Benard convection to drive a dynamically consistent MHD dynamo. Computationally, the Childress–Soward dynamo has the advantage of permitting the expansion of the unknown fields in Fourier series in all directions, allowing three dimensional fast Fourier transforms (FFT's) to be used in calculating the nonlinear terms. Since no fast Legendre transform exists at the moment, the resulting programs will be faster than more realistic spherical dynamo simulations, while at the same time reflecting the important features of these models.
In this paper, the strong field branch of the Childress–Soward dynamo is investigated using direct numerical simulations.
In a report of the current status of the observational studies of star formation published in 1982, Wynn-Williams introduced the subject by boldly stating “Protostars are the Holy Grail of infrared astronomy”, one of the most (ab)used astronomical quotations ever. At the time of the review, searches had been made at IR wavelengths towards a restricted sample of objects, guided by the theoretical expectation that protostars would undergo a phase of high IR luminosity during the main accretion phase (Larson 1969). The aim of these studies, and of those that followed, was to get an unambiguous example of Spitzer's definition (1948) of a protostar as “an isolated interstellar cloud undergoing inexorable gravitational contraction to form a single star”.
This definition appears now rather restrictive, since observations have shown that the structure of star forming regions is highly complex, rarely revealing well isolated, noninteracting interstellar clouds. In addition, observations in the near infrared at high spatial resolution have shown that many young stars are not single, but do have companions (Zinnecker & Wilking 1992). However, despite great effort, resulting from improvements in instrumentation and progress in the theoretical models, the same discouraging conclusion reached by Winn-Williams in 1982 still holds true: no conclusive identification of a genuine protostar has yet been made. Nevertheless, the motivation for continuing the search using the IR band remains still unquestionable.
In these lectures I will present an overview of the main properties of the star formation process with a special emphasis on stars of low- and intermediate-mass, for which observations are the most detailed and a consistent theoretical framework has been developed and tested.
Early measurements of the interstellar extinction curve at visual wavelengths (Stebbins et al., 1939) established a broad result which has survived unchanged, namely that the amount of the extinction on a magnitude scale has an approximately linear dependence on wavenumber, i.e. Aλ ∝ 1/λ. This result was later refined (Nandy 1964a, b, 1965) to show that in a second order of approximation Aλ could be represented in a plot against 1/λ, by two straight line segments intersecting at 1/λ ≅ 2.4 (μm−1), with the segment corresponding to blue wavelengths being somewhat shallower in slope than the segment corresponding to red wavelengths. The shape of the interstellar extinction curve over the waveband 1 < λ−1 λ 3μm−1 remained more or less invariant from star to star. Grain models were thus constrained to possess a wavelength dependence of extinction that accorded with this general result.
Another observational criterion that was available from the 1930's related to the amount of the interstellar extinction per unit path length. For instance at the visual wavelength, corresponding to 1/λ = 1.8 (μm)−1, the mean extinction of starlight in directions close to the galactic plane is about 2 mag/kpc.
A further result of relevance is the so-called Oort limit for the total mass density of interstellar material – gas and dust – which amounts to ˜ 3 × 10−24 g cm−3 (Oort, 1932, 1952). The dust grain density had certainly to be less than this value, probably considerably less, in view of the fact that the bulk of cosmic material is made up of H which cannot by itself condense into solid grains at a temperature above that of the cosmic microwave background, ˜ 2.7°K.