Skip to main content
×
×
Home

Choice, consumerism and devolution: growing old in the welfare state(s) of Scotland, Wales and England

  • SUZANNE MOFFATT (a1), PAUL HIGGS (a2), KIRSTEIN RUMMERY (a3) and IAN REES JONES (a4)
Abstract
ABSTRACT

The introduction of choice and consumer mechanisms in public services has been identified as a fundamental shift in welfare service provision internationally. Within the United Kingdom (UK), such mechanisms developed and integrated into English services have not been replicated in their entirety in Scotland and Wales. For the first time since the inception of the UK welfare state, there are now formal differences in entitlement for older people as a result of devolution. This paper uses comparative policy analysis to review a range of sources not hitherto brought together in order to explore how these concurrent developments – choice and devolution – impact on people over state retirement age. We also consider the extent to which a more consumerist approach to public services might redress or increase later-life inequalities. Drawing on theoretical research and policy evidence, we argue that for many people over state retirement age, the prospect of becoming a consumer in these varied contexts is difficult and unwelcome. We suggest that although it is too early in the devolutionary process for any significant impact of these divergent policies to materialise, continued policy divergence will lead to different experiences and outcomes for older people in Scotland, Wales and England. We conclude that these divergent social policies offer significant research opportunities, particularly concerning their impact on later-life inequalities.

  • View HTML
    • Send article to Kindle

      To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.

      Note you can select to send to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be sent to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

      Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

      Choice, consumerism and devolution: growing old in the welfare state(s) of Scotland, Wales and England
      Available formats
      ×
      Send article to Dropbox

      To send this article to your Dropbox account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your Dropbox account. Find out more about sending content to Dropbox.

      Choice, consumerism and devolution: growing old in the welfare state(s) of Scotland, Wales and England
      Available formats
      ×
      Send article to Google Drive

      To send this article to your Google Drive account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your Google Drive account. Find out more about sending content to Google Drive.

      Choice, consumerism and devolution: growing old in the welfare state(s) of Scotland, Wales and England
      Available formats
      ×
Copyright
Corresponding author
Address for correspondence: Suzanne Moffatt, Institute of Health & Society, Newcastle University, Baddiley-Clarke Building, Richardson Road, Newcastle upon Tyne NE2 4AX, UK. E-mail: s.m.moffatt@ncl.ac.uk
References
Hide All
Age Concern England 2006. Benefits of Direct Payments Revealed. Available online at http://www.ageconcern.org.uk [accessed 6 May 2007].
Appleby J., Harrison A. and Devlin N. 2003. What is the Real Cost of More Patient Choice? King's Fund, London.
Argyle E. 2001. Poverty, disability and the role of older carers. Disability and Society, 16, 4, 585–95.
Baldock J. 2003. On being a welfare consumer in a consumer society. Social Policy and Society, 2, 1, 6571.
Baldock J. and Ungerson C. 1994. Becoming Consumers of Community Care: Households Within the Mixed Economy of Welfare. Community Care into Practice Series, Joseph Rowntree Foundation, York, UK, 156.
Bardasi E., Jenkins S. and Rigg J. 2002. Retirement and the income of older people: a British perspective. Ageing & Society, 22, 2, 131–59.
Barnes M. and Walker A. 1996. Consumerism versus empowerment: a principled approach to the involvement of older service users. Policy and Politics, 24, 4, 375–93.
Barr D. A., Fenton L. and Blane D. 2008. The claim for patient choice and equity. Journal of Medical Ethics, 34, 271–4.
Bell D. 2010. The Impact of Devolution. Long-term Care Provision in the UK. Joseph Rowntree Foundation, York, UK.
Bell D. and Bowes A. 2006. Financial Care Models in Scotland and the UK. Joseph Rowntree Foundation, York, UK.
Birrell D. 2009. The Impact of Devolution on Social Policy. Policy Press, Bristol, UK.
Blomqvist P. 2004. Privatisation of Swedish welfare services. Social Policy and Adminstration, 38, 3, 139–55.
Bourdieu P. 1990. The Logic of Practice. Polity Press, Cambridge.
Brewer M., Browne J., Emmerson C., Goodman A., Muriel A. and Tetlow G. 2007. Pensioner Poverty Over the Next Decade: What Role for Tax and Benefit Reform? Institute for Fiscal Studies, London.
Byers S. 2006. A new deal for older people must become a top political priority. The Guardian, 6 September.
Cavaye J. 2006. The care of older people. In Mooney G., Sweeney T. and Law A. (eds), Social Care. Health and Welfare in Contemporary Scotland. Kynoch & Blaney, Paisley, UK, 239–70.
Chandola T., Ferrie J., Sacker A. and Marmot M. 2007. Social inequalities in self reported health in early old age: follow-up of prospective cohort study. BMJ Online First. doi:10.1136/bmj.39167.439792.55 [accessed 8 May 2007].
Clark H., Gough H. and Macfarlane A. 2004. ‘It Pays Dividends.’ Direct Payments and Older People. Policy Press, Bristol, UK.
Clarke J. and Newman J. 2007. What's in a name? New Labour's citizen-consumers and the remaking of public services. Cultural Studies, 21, 4/5, 738–57.
Clarke J., Newman J., Smith N., Vidler E. and Westmarland L. 2007. Creating Citizen-consumers: Changing Publics and Changing Public Services. Sage, London.
Clasen J. 1998. Comparative Social Policy. Blackwell, Oxford.
Commission for Social Care Inspection 2009. The State of Social Care in England 2007/8. Care Quality Commission, London.
Cooper Z. and Le Grand J. 2007. Choice, competition and the political left. Eurohealth, 13, 4, 1820.
Corden A., Sainsbury R., Irvine A. and Clarke S. 2010. The Impact of Disability Allowance and Attendance Allowance. Department for Work and Pensions Research Report, No. 649, HMSO, Norwich.
Department for Work and Pensions 2004. Income Related Benefits Estimates of Take-up in 2001/2002. Office of National Statistics, London.
Department for Work and Pensions 2009. Building a Society for All Ages. Available online at http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk or http://www.hmg.gov.uk/buildingasocietyforallages.aspx [accessed 26 July 2010].
Department of Health 2003 a. Building on the Best. Choice, Responsiveness and Equity in the NHS. Department of Health, London.
Department of Health 2003 b. The National Service Framework for Older People. The Stationery Office, London.
Department of Health 2006. Our Health, Our Care, Our Say: A New Direction for Community Services. Department of Health, London.
Department of Health 2007 a. Next Steps Review: Interim Report. Department of Health, London.
Department of Health 2007 b. Putting People First: A Shared Vision and Commitment to the Transformation of Social Care for Adults in England. Cm6499, Department of Health, London.
Dolowitz D. and Marsh D. 2000. Learning from abroad: the role of policy transfer in contemporary policy-making. Governance, 13, 1, 524.
Esping Andersen G. 1996. Welfare States in Transition. National Adaptations in Global Economies. Sage, London.
Ferguson I. 2005. Social work and social care in the ‘new’ Scotland. In Mooney G. and Scott G. (eds), Exploring Social Policy in the ‘New’ Scotland. Policy Press, Bristol, UK, 221–38.
Fotaki M. 2009. Are all consumers the same? Choice in health, social care and education in England and elsewhere. Public Money and Management, 29, 2, 8794.
Gilleard C. 2004. Cohorts and generations in the study of social change. Social Theory & Health, 2, 106–19.
Gilleard C. and Higgs P. 2005. Contexts of Ageing: Class, Cohort and Community. Polity Press, Cambridge.
Gilleard C., Higgs P., Hyde M., Wiggins R. and Blane D. 2005. Class, cohort, and consumption: the British experience of the Third Age. Journal of Gerontology, 60B, 6, S30510.
Glendinning C. 2009. The consumer in social care. In Simmons R., Powell M. and Greener I. (eds), The Consumer in Public Services. Choice, Values and Difference. Policy Press, Bristol, UK, 177–96.
Greener I. 2002. Agency, social theory and social policy. Critical Social Policy, 22, 4, 688705.
Greener I. and Powell M. 2008. The evolution of choice policies in UK housing, education and health policy. Journal of Social Policy, 38, 6381.
Greer S. 2003. Policy divergence: will it change something in Greenock? In Hazell R. (ed.), The State of the Nations 2003: The Third Year of Devolution in the United Kingdom. Constitution Unit, University College London, London, 195214.
Greer S. 2004. Territorial Politics and Health Policy. Manchester University Press, Manchester, UK.
Greer S. (ed.) 2007. Devolving Policies, Diverging Values. Nuffield Trust, London.
Greve B. 2009. Can choice in welfare states be equitable? Social Policy and Adminstration, 43, 6, 543–56.
Harris J. 1999. State social work and social citizenship in Britain: from clientelism to consumerism. British Journal of Social Work, 29, 6, 915–37.
Hill M. 2006. Social Policy in the Modern World: A Comparative Text. Blackwell Publishing, Oxford.
Jeffery C. 2008. The challenge of territorial politics. Policy and Politics, 36, 4, 545–57.
House of Commons 2011. Health and Social Care Bill 2010–2011. Stationery Office, London.
Hunter D. J. 2009. The case against choice and competition. Health Economics, Policy and Law, 4, 489501.
Individual Budgets Evaluation Network 2008. Evaluation of the Individual Budgets Pilot Programme. Final Report, Social Policy Unit, University of York, UK. Available online at www.york.ac.uk/spru [accessed 3 November 2008].
Jervis P. 2008. Devolution and Health. Nuffield Trust, London.
Jones I. R., Hyde M., Victor C., Wiggins R. D., Gilleard C. and Higgs P. 2008. Ageing in a Consumer Society. From Passive to Active Consumption in Britain. Policy Press, Bristol, UK.
Keating M. 2003. Social inclusion, devolution and policy divergence. The Political Quarterly, 74, 4, 429–38.
Kingdon J. 2002. Agendas, Alternatives and Public Policies. Longman, London.
Le Grand J. 1989. Markets, welfare and equality. In Le Grand J. and Estrin S. (eds), Market Socialism. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 124.
Le Grand J. (ed.) 2007 a. The Other Invisible Hand: Delivering Public Services Through Choice and Competition. Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey.
Le Grand J. 2007 b. The politics of choice and competition in public services. The Political Quarterly, 78, 2, 207–13.
Mannheim K. 1952. The problem of generation. In Kecskesmeti P. (ed.), Essays on the Sociology of Knowledge. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 280322.
Manthorpe J., Clough R., Cornes M., Bright L., Iliffe S. and (OPRSI) Older People Researching Social Issues 2007. Four years on: the impact of the National Service Framework for Older People on the experiences, expectations and views of older people. Age and Ageing, 36, 5, 501–7.
McCormick J., McDowell E. and Harris A. 2009. Policies for Peace of Mind? Devolution and Older Age in the UK. Institute for Public Policy Research, London.
Milburn A. 2001. Shifting the Balance of Power in the NHS. Launch of the NHS Modernisation Agency. Department of Health, London.
Moffatt S. and Higgs P. 2007. Charity or entitlement? Generational habitus and the welfare state among older people in North East England. Social Policy and Administration, 41, 5, 449–64.
Moffatt S. and Scambler G. 2008. Can welfare-rights advice targeted at older people reduce social exclusion? Ageing & Society, 28, 6, 875–99.
Mooney G. and Poole L. 2004. ‘A land of milk and honey?’ Social policy in Scotland after devolution. Critical Social Policy, 24, 4, 458–83.
Peillon M. 1998. Bourdieu's field and the sociology of welfare. Journal Social Policy, 27, 2, 213–29.
Phillipson C. 2002. Ageism and globalisation: citizenship and social rights in transnational settings. In Andersson L. (ed.), Cultural Gerontology. Auburn House, Westport, Connecticut, 4558.
Phillipson C. and Scharf T. 2004. The Impact of Government Policy on Social Exclusion Among Older People. Social Exclusion Unit, London.
Pollock A. M. 1999. Devolution and health: challenges for Scotland and Wales. British Medical Journal, 318, 1195–8.
Pollock A. M. and Price D. 2011. How the Secretary of State for Health proposes to abolish the NHS in England. British Medical Journal, 342, 800–3.
Powell M., Doheny S., Greener I. and Mills N. 2009. Introduction: managing the ‘unmanageable consumer’. In Simmons R., Powell M. and Greener I. (eds), The Consumer in Public Services. Choice, Values and Difference. Policy Press, Bristol, UK, 117.
Priestley M., Jolly D., Pearson C., Riddell S., Barnes C. and Mercer G. 2007. Direct payments and disabled people in the UK: supply, demand and devolution. British Journal of Social Work, 37, 1189–204.
Puttick H. 2010. What now for free personal care? Herald Scotland, 30 July. Available online at http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/health/what-now-for-free-personal-care-1.1034147 [accessed 30 July 2010].
Rummery K. 2002. Disability, Citizenship and Community Care: A Case for Welfare Rights? Ashgate, Aldershot, UK.
Rummery K. 2006. Disabled citizens and social exclusion: the role of direct payments. Policy and Politics, 34, 4, 633–50.
Rummery K. 2009. A comparative discussion of the gendered implications of cash-for-care schemes: markets, independence and social citizenship in crisis? Social Policy and Administration, 43, 6, 634–48.
Scottish Executive 2006. Direct Payments Scotland 2006. Available online at http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2006/09/25160444/13 [accessed 6 May 2008].
Scottish Executive 2007. All Our Futures. Available online at www.scotland.gov.uk/publications/2007 [accessed 23 July 2010].
Scottish Government 2007. National Guidance on Self Directed Support. Available online at http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2007/07/04093127/5 [accessed 2 March 2009].
Shaw M., Davey-Smith G. and Dorling D. 2005. Health inequalities and New Labour: how the promises compare with real progress. British Medical Journal, 330, 1016–21.
Simmons R. and Powell M. 2009. Conclusion: the consumer in public services. In Simmons R., Powell M. and Greener I. (eds), The Consumer in Public Services. Choice, Values and Difference. Policy Press, Bristol, UK, 255–79.
Simmons R., Powell M. and Greener I. (eds) 2009. The Consumer in Public Services. Choice, Values and Difference. Policy Press, Bristol, UK.
Social Interface 2007. A Survey on the Implementation of the Current Direct Payments Scheme in Wales. Available online at http://wales.gov.uk/dhss/publications/socialcare/reports/directpayments/surveye.pdf?1ang=en [accessed 21 October 2008].
Spandler H. 2004. Friend or foe? Towards a critical assessment of direct payments. Critical Social Policy, 24, 2, 187209.
Stewart J. 2004. Taking Stock. Scottish Social Welfare After Devolution. Policy Press, Bristol, UK.
Sullivan M. 2002. Health policy: differentiation and devolution. In Adams J. and Robinson P. (eds), Devolution in Practice. Public Policy Differences in the UK. IPPR/ESRC, London, 60–6.
Tannahill C. 2005. Health and health policy. In Mooney G. and Scott G. (eds), Exploring Social Policy in the ‘New’ Scotland. Policy Press, Bristol, UK, 199220.
Taylor-Gooby P. (ed.) 2000. Risk, Trust and Welfare. Macmillan, Basingstoke, UK.
Taylor-Gooby P. (ed.) 2001. Welfare States Under Pressure. Sage, London.
Welsh Assembly Government 2008. The Strategy for Older People in Wales, 2008–13. Available online at http://wales.gov.uk/topics/olderpeople/publications/strategy2008-2013/?lang=en [accessed 16 May 2009].
Williams C. and Mooney G. 2008. Decentring social policy? Devolution and the discipline of social policy: a commentary. Journal of Social Policy, 37, 3, 489507.
Woods K. J. 2002. Health policy and the NHS in the UK 1997–2002. In Adams J. and Robinson P. (eds), Devolution in Practice. Public Policy Differences in the UK. IPPR/ESRC, London, 2559.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Ageing & Society
  • ISSN: 0144-686X
  • EISSN: 1469-1779
  • URL: /core/journals/ageing-and-society
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 16
Total number of PDF views: 109 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 389 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 20th January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.