Skip to main content

Broad Bills or Particularistic Policy? Historical Patterns in American State Legislatures

  • GERALD GAMM (a1) and THAD KOUSSER (a2)

When do lawmakers craft broad policies, and when do they focus on narrow legislation tailored to a local interest? We investigate this question by exploring historical variation in the types of bills produced by American state legislatures. Drawing on a new database of 165,000 bills—covering sessions over 120 years in thirteen different states—we demonstrate the surprising prominence of particularistic bills affecting a specific legislator's district. We then develop and test a theory linking the goals of legislators to their propensity to introduce district bills rather than broad legislation. We find that, consistent with our predictions, politicians are more likely to craft policies targeted to a particular local interest when a legislature is dominated by one party or when it pays its members relatively high salaries. These findings provide empirical support for Key's (1949) thesis that one-party politics descends into factionalism and undermines the making of broad public policy.

Corresponding author
Gerald Gamm is Associate Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Rochester, Harkness Hall 331, Rochester, NY 14627-0146 (
Thad Kousser is Associate Professor, Department of Political Science, University of California at San Diego, 9500 Gilman Drive, La Jolla, CA 92093 ( During the 2009–2010 academic year, Thad Kousser is a Campbell National Fellow at the Hoover Institution and a Visiting Associate Professor at Bill Lane Center for the American West, Stanford University.
Hide All
Ansolabehere Stephen, and Snyder James M. Jr., 2008. The End of Inequality: One Person, One Vote and the Transformation of American Politics. New York: Norton.
Baker v. Carr. 1962. 369 U.S. 186.
Banfield Edward C., and Wilson James Q.. 1963. City Politics. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Battaglini Marco, and Coate Stephen. 2005. “Inefficiency in Legislative Policy-Making: A Dynamic Analysis.” Unpublished manuscript, Princeton University.
Berry William D., Berkman Michael B., and Schneiderman Stuart, 2000. “Legislative Professionalism and Incumbent Reelection: The Development of Institutional Boundaries.” American Political Science Review 94: 859–74.
Bureau of Economic Analysis. 2006. “State Annual Personal Income.” (Accessed November 12, 2009).
Burnham Walter Dean. 1970. Critical Elections and the Mainsprings of American Politics. New York: W.W. Norton.
Burns Nancy, Evans Laura, Gamm Gerald, and McConnaughy Corrine. 2008. “Pockets of Expertise: Institutional Capacity in 20th-Century State Legislatures.” Studies in American Political Development 22: 229–48.
Burns Nancy, Evans Laura, Gamm Gerald, and McConnaughy Corrine. 2009. “Urban Politics in the State Arena.” Studies in American Political Development 23: 122.
Burns Nancy, and Gamm Gerald. 1997. “Creatures of the State: State Politics and Local Government, 1871–1921.” Urban Affairs Review 33: 5996.
Carey John M., Niemi Richard G., Powell Lynda W., and Moncrief Gary F.. 2006. “The Effects of Term Limits on State Legislatures: A New Survey of the 50 States.” Legislative Studies Quarterly 31: 105–34.
Carmines Edward. 1974. “The Mediating Influence of State Legislatures on the Linkage Between Interparty Competition and Welfare Policies.” American Political Science Review 68: 1118–24.
Cohen Jacob. 1960. “A Coefficient of Agreement for Nominal Scales,” Educational and Psychological Measurement 20 (1): 3746.
Cox Gary W., and McCubbins Mathew D.. 1993. Legislative Leviathan: Party Government in the House. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Crisp Brian F., Escobar-Lemmon Maria C., Jones Bradford S., Jones Mark P., and Taylor-Robinson Michelle M.. 2004. “Vote-Seeking Incentives and Legislative Representation in Six Presidential Democracies.” Journal of Politics 66: 823–46.
Dauer Manning J., and Kelsay Robert G.. 1955. “Unrepresentative States.” National Municipal Review 46: 571–5.
Dawson Richard E., and Robinson James. 1963. “Inter-Party Competition, Economic Variables, and Welfare Policies in the American States.” Journal of Politics 25: 265–89.
Desposato Scott W. 2001. Institutional Theories, Social Realities, and Party Politics in Brazil. Ph.D. diss., University of California–Los Angeles.
Dubin Michael J. 2007. Party Affiliations in the State Legislatures: A Year by Year Summary, 1796–2006. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
Dye Thomas R. 1966. Politics, Economics, and the Public: Policy Outcomes in the American States. Chicago: Rand McNally.
Easterlin Richard A. 1957. “State Income Estimates.” In Population Redistribution and Economic Growth: United States, 1870–1950, Vol. 1, eds. Kuznets Simon and Thomas Dorothy Swaine. Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society, 703–59.
Elazar Daniel J., Gray Virginia, and Spano Wyman. 1999. Minnesota Politics and Government. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
Erie Steven P. 1988. Rainbow's End: Irish-Americans and the Dilemmas of Urban Machine Politics, 1840–1985. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Evans Diana. 1994. “Policy and Pork: The Use of Pork Barrel Projects To Build Policy Coalitions in the House of Representatives.” American Journal of Political Science 38: 894917.
Fenno Richard F. Jr. 1973. Congressmen in Committees. Boston: Little, Brown.
Fenno Richard F. Jr. 1978. Home Style: House Members in Their Districts. Boston: Little, Brown.
Frug Gerald E. 1980. “The City as a Legal Concept.” Harvard Law Review 93: 10571154.
Frug Gerald E. 1999. City Making: Building Communities without Building Walls. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Gamm Gerald, and Kousser Thad. 2007a. “Broad Bills or Particularistic Policy: Historical Patterns in American State Legislatures.” Presented at the annual meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago.
Gamm Gerald, and Kousser Thad. 2007b. “Diversity and the Breakdown of Deference: Evidence from District Bills in State Legislatures.” Presented at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Chicago.
Gibson Campbell, and Jung Kay. 2005. “Historical Census Statistics on Population Totals by Race, 1790 to 1990, and by Hispanic Origin, 1790 to 1990, for Large Cities and Other Urban Places in the United States.” Population Division Working Paper No. 76. Washington, DC: U.S. Census Bureau. (Accessed November 12, 2009).
Griffith Ernest S. 1974. A History of American City Government: The Conspicuous Failure, 1870–1900. New York: Praeger.
Haines Michael R. 2006. “State Populations.” In Historical Statistics of the United States, Earliest Times to the Present, Millennial Edition. Vol. 1, eds. Carter Susan B., Gartner Scott Sigmund, Haines Michael R., Olmstead Alan L., Sutch Richard, and Wright Gavin. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1-180–1-379.
Hanson Russell L., ed. 1998. Governing Partners: State–Local Relations in the United States. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Herron Michael C., and Shotts Kenneth W.. 2006. “Term Limits and Pork.” Legislative Studies Quarterly 31 (3): 383403.
Hofferbert Richard I. 1966. “The Relation between Public Policy and Some Structural and Environmental Variables in the American States.” American Political Science Review 60: 7382.
Hogan Robert E., and Hamm Keith. 1998. “Variations in District-Level Campaign Spending in State Legislatures.” In Campaign Finance in State Legislative Elections, eds. Thompson Joel A. and Moncrief Gary F.. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly Press, 5979.
Jacoby William G., and Schneider Saundra K.. 2001. “Variability in State Policy Priorities: An Empirical Analysis.” Journal of Politics 63: 544–68.
Karnig Albert K., and Sigelman Lee. 1975. “State Legislative Reform and Public Policy: Another Look.” Western Political Quarterly 28: 548–53.
Key V. O. Jr. 1949. Southern Politics in State and Nation. New York: Knopf.
King James D. 2000. “Changes in Professionalism in U.S. State Legislatures.” Legislative Studies Quarterly 25: 327–43.
Kousser Thad. 2005. Term Limits and the Dismantling of State Legislative Professionalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Krane Dale, Rigos Platon N., and Hill Melvin B. Jr., 2001. Home Rule in America: A Fifty-State Handbook. Washington, DC: CQ Press.
Landis J. Richard, and Koch Gary G.. 1977. “The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data.” Biometrics 33: 159–74.
Leblanc William, Snyder James M. Jr., and Tripathi Micky. 2000. “Majority-Rule Bargaining and the Under Provision of Public Investment Goods.” Journal of Public Economics 75: 2147.
LeLoup Lance T. 1978. “Reassessing the Mediating Impact of Legislative Capability.” American Political Science Review 72: 616–21.
Lizzeri Alessandro, and Persico Nicola. 2001. “The Provision of Public Goods under Alternative Electoral Incentives.” American Economic Review 91: 225–39.
Lombard Matthew, Snyder-Duch Jennifer, and Bracken Cheryl Campanella. 2002. “Content Analysis in Mass Communication: Assessment and Reporting of Intercoder Reliability.” Human Communication Research 28: 587604.
Lowi Theodore J. 1964. “American Business, Public Policy, Case-Studies, and Political Theory.” World Politics 16: 677715.
Mayhew David R. 1974. Congress: The Electoral Connection. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
McBain Howard L. 1916. The Law and the Practice of Municipal Home Rule. New York: Columbia University Press.
Moncrief Gary F., Niemi Richard G., and Powell Lynda W.. 2004. “Time, Term Limits, and Turnover: Trends in Membership Stability in U.S. State Legislatures.” Legislative Studies Quarterly 29: 357–81.
Moncrief Gary, Thompson Joel A., and Cassie William. 1996. “Revisiting the State of U.S. State Legislative Research.” Legislative Studies Quarterly 21: 301–35.
Niemi Richard G., and Winsky Laura R.. 1987. “Membership Turnover in U.S. State Legislatures: Trends and Effects of Districting.” Legislative Studies Quarterly 12: 115–23.
Ogg Frederic A., and Ray P. Orman. 1922. Introduction to American Government. New York: Century.
Polsby Nelson W. 1968. “The Institutionalization of the U.S. House of Representatives.” American Political Science Review 62: 144–68.
Ritt Leonard. 1973. “State Legislative Reform: Does It Matter?American Politics Quarterly 1: 499510.
Ritt Leonard. 1977. “The Policy Impact of Legislative Reform: A 50-State Analysis.” In Legislative Reform and Public Policy, eds. Welch Susan and Peters John G.. New York: Praeger, 189200.
Roeder Phillip W. 1979. “State Legislative Reform: Determinants and Policy Consequences.” American Politics Quarterly 7: 5170.
Schattschneider E. E. 1956. “United States: The Functional Approach to Party Government.” In Modern Political Parties: Approaches to Comparative Politics, ed. Neumann Sigmund. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 194215.
Sensenbrenner F. James Jr., “The History of the Private Calendar and the Consideration of Private Bills.” Extensions of Remarks by the Honorable F. James Sensenbrenner, Jr., of Wisconsin in the House of Representatives, Wednesday, April 21, 1999. (Accessed November 12, 2009).
Squire Peverill. 1992. “The Theory of Legislative Institutionalization and the California Assembly.”Journal of Politics 54: 1026–54.
Squire Peverill. 1993. “Professionalization and Public Opinion of State Legislatures.” Journal of Politics 55: 479–91.
Squire Peverill, and Hamm Keith E.. 2005. 101 Chambers: Congress, State Legislatures, and the Future of Legislative Studies. Columbus: Ohio State University Press.
Teaford Jon C. 1984. The Unheralded Triumph: City Government in America, 1870–1900. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Teaford Jon C. 2002. The Rise of the States: Evolution of American State Government. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Thompson Joel A. 1986. “State Legislative Reform: Another Look, One More Time, Again.” Polity 19: 2741.
Trochim William, and Donnelly James P.. 2007. The Research Methods Knowledge Base. 3rd ed.Cincinnati, OH: Atomic Dog.
U.S. Department of Labor. 2006. Consumer Price Index, All Urban Consumers—(CPI-U), U.S. City Average, All Items. (Accessed August 2006).
Volden Craig, and Wiseman Alan E.. 2007. “Bargaining in Legislatures over Particularistic and Collective Goods.” American Political Science Review 101: 7992.
Weingast Barry R. 1979. “A Rational Choice Perspective on Congressional Norms.” American Journal of Political Science 23: 245–62.
Weingast Barry R. 1994. “Reflections on Distributive Politics and Universalism.” Political Research Quarterly 47: 319–27.
Wilson James Q. 1980. The Politics of Regulation. New York: Basic Books.
Wiltsee Herbert. 1956. “Recent Trends in Strengthening State Legislatures.” In Streamlining State Legislatures: Report of a Conference Held at the University of California, Berkeley, October 27–29, 1955, ed. Scott Stanley. Berkeley, CA: Howell-North Press, 1525.
Winters Richard F. 1976. “Party Control and Policy Change.” American Journal of Political Science 20: 597636.
Wright Gerald C., and Schaffner Brian F.. 2002. “The Influence of Party: Evidence from the State Legislatures.” American Political Science Review 96: 367–79.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 9
Total number of PDF views: 86 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 301 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.