Skip to main content

Constitutional Power and Competing Risks: Monarchs, Presidents, Prime Ministers, and the Termination of East and West European Cabinets


Some European constitutions give cabinets great discretion to manage their own demise, whereas others limit their choices and insert the head of state into decisions about government termination. In this article, we map the tremendous variation in the constitutional rules that govern cabinet termination and test existing expectations about its effects on a government's survival and mode of termination. In doing so, we use the most extensive government survival data set available to date, the first to include East and West European governments. Our results demonstrate that constitutional constraints on governments and presidential influence on cabinet termination are much more common than has previously been understood and have powerful effects on the hazard profiles of governments. These results alter and improve the discipline's understanding of government termination and durability, and have implications for comparative work in a range of areas, including the survival and performance of democracies, electoral accountability, opportunistic election calling, and political business cycles.

Corresponding author
Petra Schleiter is University Lecturer, Department of Politics and International Relations, University of Oxford; Tutorial Fellow. St. Hilda's College, Oxford, UKOX1 3UQ Oxford, UKOX4 1DY (
Edward Morgan-Jones is Research Fellow and Tutor in Politics, Keble College, and Department of Politics and International Relations, University of Oxford, Manor Road, Oxford, UKOX1 3UQ (
Hide All
Alesina A., Cohen G. D., and Roubini N.. 1993. “Electoral Business Cycle in Industrial Democracies.European Journal of Political Economy 9 (1): 123.
Amorim Neto O., and Lobo M. C.. 2009. “Portugal's Semi-Presidentialism (Re)considered: An Assessment of the President's Role in the Policy Process, 1976–2006.European Journal of Political Research 48 (2): 234–55.
Amorim Neto O., and Strøm K.. 2006. “Breaking the Parliamentary Chain of Delegation: Presidents and Non-Partisan Cabinet Members in European Democracies.British Journal of Political Science 36 (4): 619–43.
Bagehot W. 1872. The English Constitution. London: Thomas Nelson & Sons.
Balke N. S. 1990. “The Rational Timing of Parliamentary Elections.Public Choice 65 (3): 201–16.
Baron D. P. 1998. “Comparative Dynamics of Parliamentary Governments.American Political Science Review 92 (3): 593609.
Blais A., Gidengil E., Nadeau R., and Nevitte N.. 2004. “Do (Some) Canadian Voters Punish a Prime Minister for Calling a Snap Election?Political Studies 52 (6): 307–23.
Box-Steffensmeier J. M., and Jones B. S.. 2004. Event History Modeling: A Guide for Social Scientists. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Browne E. C., Frendreis J., and Gleiber D. W.. 1986. “The Process of Cabinet Dissolution: An Exponential Model of Duration and Stability in Western Democracies.American Journal of Political Science 30 (3): 628–50.
Bull M., and Newell J.. 2005. Italian Politics: Adjustment under Duress. Cambridge, UK: Polity.
Bundesverfassungsgericht. 2005. BVerfG. 2 BvE 4/05 vom 25.8. 2005. Leitsätze zum Urteil des Zweiten Senats vom 25. August 2005.
Diermeier D., and Stevenson R. T.. 1999. “Cabinet Survival and Competing Risks.American Journal of Political Science 43 (4): 1051–68.
Diermeier D., and Stevenson R. T.. 2000. “Cabinet Termination and Critical Events.American Political Science Review 94 (3): 627–40.
Drazen A. 2000. “The Political Business Cycle after 25 Years.NBER Macroeconomics Annual 15: 75117.
Druckman J., and Thies M. F.. 2002. “The Importance of Concurrence: The Impact of Bicameralism on Government Formation and Duration.American Journal of Political Science 46 (4): 760–71.
Duverger M. 1959. La Cinquième République. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
Elgie R. 1999. “The Politics of Semi-Presidentialism,” In Semi-Presidentialism in Europe, ed. Elgie R.. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 121.
Franzese R. J. Jr. 2002. “Electoral and Partisan Cycles in Economic Policies and Outcomes.Annual Review of Political Science 5: 369421.
Freire A., and Lobo M. C.. 2006. “The Portuguese 2005 Legislative Election: Return to the Left.West European Politics 29 (3): 581–88.
Goldey D. B. 1998. “The French General Election of 25 May–1 June 1997.Electoral Studies 17 (4): 536–55.
Hainsworth P. 1998. “The Return of the Left: The 1997 French Parliamentary Election.Parliamentary Affairs 51 (1): 7183.
Huber J. D. 1998. “How Does Cabinet Instability Affect Political Performance? Portfolio Volatility and Health Care Cost Containment in Parliamentary Democracies.American Political Science Review 92 (3): 577–91.
Ito T., and Park J. H.. 1988. “Political Business Cycles in the Parliamentary System.Economics Letters 27 (3): 233–38.
Kayser M. A. 2005. “Who Surfs, Who Manipulates? The Determinants of Opportunistic Election Timing and Electorally Motivated Economic Intervention.American Political Science Review 99 (1): 1727.
King G., Alt J. E., Burns N. E., and Laver M.. 1990. “A Unified Model of Cabinet Dissolution in Parliamentary Democracies.American Journal of Political Science 34 (3): 846–71.
Kysela J., and Kuhn Z.. 2007. “The Czech Republic.European Constitutional Law Review 3 (1): 91113.
Laver M. 2006. “Legislatures and Parliaments in Comparative Context.” In Oxford Handbook of Political Economy, eds. Weingast B. and Wittman D.. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 121–38.
Laver M., and Schofield N.. 1990. Multiparty Government: The Politics of Coalition in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Laver M., and Shepsle K. A.. 1996. Making and Breaking Governments: Cabinets and Legislatures in Parliamentary Democracies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Linz J. 1994. “Presidential versus Parliamentary Democracy: Does It Make a Difference?” In The Failure of Presidential Democracy, eds. Linz J. and Valenzuela A.. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 387.
Lobo M. 2001. The Emergence of a Prime Ministerial Model: Portuguese Government Co-ordination, 1976–1995. Ph.D. diss.University of Oxford.
Lupia A., and Strøm K.. 1995. “Coalition Termination and the Strategic Timing of Parliamentary Elections.American Political Science Review 89 (3): 648–65.
Moestrup S. 2007. “Semi-Presidentialism in Young Democracies: Help or Hindrance?” In Semi-Presidentialism Outside Europe, eds. Elgie R. and Moestrup S.. Abingdon: Routledge, 3055.
Morgan-Jones E., and Schleiter P.. 2004. “Government Change in a President-Parliamentary Regime.Post-Soviet Affairs 20 (2): 132–64.
Müller W. C., Bergman T., and Strøm K.. 2003. “Parliamentary Democracy: Promise and Problems.” In Delegation and Accountability in Parliamentary Democracies, eds. Strøm K., Müller W. C., and Bergman T.. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 332.
Müller W. C., and Strøm K., eds. 2000. Coalition Governments in Western Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pasquino G. 1999. “The Election of the Tenth President of the Italian Republic.Journal of Modern Italian Studies 4 (3): 405–15.
Protsyk O. 2003. “Troubled Semi-Presidentialism: Stability of the Constitutional System and Cabinet in Ukraine.Europe-Asia Studies 55 (7): 1077–95.
Protsyk O. 2006. “Cabinet Decision-Making in Ukraine: The Dual Executive and The Diffusion of Policy-Making Authority.” In Democratic Governance in Central and East European Countries: Challenges and Responses for the 21st Century, eds. Rosenbaum A. and Nemec J.. Bratislava: NISPAcee.
Pulzer P. 2006. “Germany Votes for Deadlock: The Federal Elections of 2005.West European Politics 29 (3): 560–72.
Roper S. D. 2002. “Are All Semipresidential Regimes the Same? A Comparison of Premier-Presidential Regimes.Comparative Politics 34 (3): 253–72.
Saalfeld T. 2003. “Germany: Multiple Veto Points, Informal Co-ordination, and Problems of Hidden Action.” In Delegation and Accountability in Parliamentary Democracies, eds. Strøm K., Müller W. C., and Bergman T.. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 347–75.
Saalfeld T. 2008. “Institutions, Chance and Choices: The Dynamics of Cabinet Survival in the Parliamentary Democracies of Western Europe (1945–99).” In Cabinets and Coalition Bargaining: The Democratic Life Cycle in Western Europe, eds. Müller W. C., Strøm K., and Bergman T.. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 327–68.
Shugart M. S. 2006. “Comparative Executive-Legislative Relations.” In The Oxford Handbook of Political Institutions, eds. Rhodes R. A., Binder S., and Rockman B.. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 344–65.
Shugart M. S., and Carey J. M.. 1992. Presidents and Assemblies: Constitutional Design and Electoral Dynamics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Smith A. 2004. Election Timing. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Strøm K., Müller W. C., and Bergman T., eds. 2003. Delegation and Accountability in Parliamentary Democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Strøm K., and Swindle S. M.. 2002. “Strategic Parliamentary Dissolution.American Political Science Review 96 (3): 575–91.
Szarka J. 1997. “Snatching Defeat from the Jaws of Victory: The French Parliamentary Elections of May 25 and June 1 1997.West European Politics 20 (4): 192–99.
Tanasescu E. S. 2008. “The President of Romania, Or: The Slippery Slope of a Political System.European Constitutional Law Review 4 (1): 6497.
Warwick P. V. 1994. Government Survival in Parliamentary Democracies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Woldendorp J., Keman H., and Budge I.. 2000. Party Government in 48 Democracies (1945–1998): Composition–Duration–Personnel. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 12
Total number of PDF views: 160 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 743 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 19th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.