Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
×
Home

James Madison's Principle of Religious Liberty

  • VINCENT PHILLIP MUÑOZ (a1)

Abstract

Although James Madison has been invoked by justices and judicial scholars for over 100 years, Madison's principle of religious liberty has never been fully grasped or adopted by the Supreme Court. Judges and scholars have failed to understand Madison's radical but simple teaching that religion is not part of the social compact and, therefore, that the state may not take religion within its cognizance. In this article I set forth Madison's principle of “noncognizance” in light of the social compact theory he articulates in the “Memorial and Remonstrance.” I then attempt to show how it consistently explains Madison's political actions and writings on religious liberty. I conclude by explaining how a “Madisonian” approach, properly understood, would adjudicate the First Amendment's religion clauses.The author would like to thank Mark Blitz, Charles R. Kesler, Nicholas May, Ralph A. Rossum, and Michael Uhlmann for their comments on drafts of this article.

Copyright

References

Hide All
Abington v. Schempp 1963 374 U.S. 203
Agostini v. Felton 1997 521 U.S. 203
Aguilar v. Felton 1985 473 U.S. 402
American State Papers 10. Miscellaneous 1834 Vol. 2 Washington, DC Gales and Seaton
Annals of the Congress of the United States, 1789–1834 1834–56 42 vols Washington, DC Gales and Seaton
Ash John 1775 The New and Complete Dictionary of the English Language London Printed for Edward and Charles Dilly in the Poultry and R. Baldwin in Pater-Noster Row
Braun Eva 1997 Madison's ‘Memorial and Remonstrance’ The Past Present: Selected Writings of Eva Braun Pamela Kraus Annapolis, MD St. John's College Press
Brant Irving 1951 Madison: On the Separation of Church and State William and Mary Quarterly 3rd Series 8 January 3 24
Buckley Thomas 1977 Church and State in Revolutionary Virginia Charlottesville University of Virginia Press
Cantwell v. Connecticut 1940 310 U.S. 296
City of Boerne v. P.F. Flores 1997 521 U.S. 507
Cobb Sanford H. 1902 The Rise of Religious Liberty in America New York Macmillan
Cord Robert 1982 Separation of Church and State: Historical Fact and Current Fiction New York Lambeth Press
Cord Robert 1987 Original Intent Jurisprudence and Madison's ‘Detached Memoranda’ Benchmark 3 1–2 79 85
Drakeman Donald L. 1983 Religion and the Republic: James Madison and the First Amendment Journal of Church and State 25 Autumn 427-45
Drakeman Donald L. 2000 James Madison and the First Amendment Establishment of Religion Clause” Religion and Political Culture in Jefferson's Virginia Garrett Ward Sheldon Daniel L. Dreisbach Lanham, MD Rowman & Littlefield 219–33
Dreisbach Daniel L. 2000 George Mason's Pursuit of Religious Liberty in Revolutionary Virginia Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 108 5 44
Elliot Jonathan 1836 Debates in the Several State Conventions on the Adoption of the Federal Constitution Washington, DC
Employment Division, Department of Human Resources of Oregon v. Smith 1990 485 U.S. 660
Engel v. Vitale 1962 370 U.S. 421
Everson v. Board of Education 1947 330 U.S. 1
Farrand Max 1966 The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787 Rev. ed. 4 vols New Haven, CT Yale University Press
Fleet Elizabeth 1946 Madison's ‘Detached Memoranda’ William and Mary Quarterly 3rd Series 3 October 534-68
Goldwin Robert A. 1997 From Parchment to Power: How James Madison Used the Bill of Rights to Save the Constitution Washington, DC AEI Press
Hamburger Philip A. 1992 A Constitutional Right of Religious Exemptions: An Historical Perspective George Washington Law Review 60 April 915-48
Hamburger Philip A. 1993 Equality and Diversity: The Eighteenth-Century Debate about Equal Protection and Equal Civil Rights 1992 The Supreme Court Review Dennis J. Hutchinson David A. Strauss Geoffrey R. Stone Chicago University of Chicago Press 295–392
Hunt Gaillard 1902 James Madison and Religious Liberty Annual Report of the American Historical Association for the Year 1901 Washington, DC Government Printing Offices 165–71
Hutson James 2001 James Madison and the Social Utility of Religion: Risks vs. Rewards Presented at the symposium, James Madison: Philosopher and Practitioner of Liberal Democracy, Library of Congress Washington, DC
Ivers Gregg 1995 To Build A Wall: American Jews and the Separation of Church and State Charlottesville University of Virginia Press
Jefferson Thomas 1904 The Writings of Thomas Jefferson Andrew A. Lipscomb Washington. DC Thomas Jefferson Memorial Association
Johnson Samuel 1755 A Dictionary of the English Language London W. Strahan
Kurland Philip B. 1961 Of Church and State and the Supreme Court University of Chicago Law Review 29 Autumn 1 96
Laycock Douglas 1986 ‘Nonpreferential’ Aid to Religion: A False Claim about Original Intent William and Mary Law Review 27 Summer 875 923
Lee v. Weisman 1992 505 U.S. 577
Levy Leonard 1986 The Establishment Clause: Religion and the First Amendment New York Macmillan
Locke John [1689a] 1960 Two Treatises on Government Peter Laslett Cambridge Cambridge University Press
Locke John [1689] 1983 A Letter Concerning Toleration James H. Tully Indianapolis Hackett
Madison James 1884 Letters and Other Writings of James Madison. 4 vols New York R. Worthington
Madison James 1900 The Writings of James Madison Gaillard Hunt 9 vols New York G.P. Putnam's Sons
Madison James 1962–91 The Papers of James Madison Congressional Series William T. Hutchinson et al 17 vols Chicago University of Chicago Press; Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press
Madison James 1981 The Mind of the Founder: Sources of the Political Thought of James Madison Marvin Meyers Rev. ed. Hanover and London Brandeis University Press
Madison James 1984 The Papers of James Madison Presidential Series J.C.A. Stagg et al 4 vols Charlottesville University of Virginia Press
Madison James Alexander Hamilton John Jay [1788] 1961 The Federalist Papers Clinton Rossiter New York Mentor
Marsh v. Chambers 1983 463 U.S. 783
McCollum v. Board of Education 1948 333 U.S. 203
McConnell Michael W. 1990 The Origins and Historical Understanding of Free Exercise of Religion Harvard Law Review 103 May 1409 1517
McConnell Michael W. 2000 Believes as Equal Citizens Obligations of Citizenship and Demands of Faith Nancy L. Rosenblum Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press 90–110
Mitchell v. Helms 2000 530 U.S. 793
Mueller v. Allen 1983 463 U.S. 388
Muñoz Vincent Phillip 2003 George Washington and Religious Liberty Review of Politics 65 Winter
Palm Daniel 1997 Religious Toleration and Religious Liberty at the Founding On Faith and Free Government Daniel Palm Lanham, MD Rowman & Littlefield 29–42
Pfeffer Leo 1958 The Case for Separation Religion in America: Original Essays on Religion in a Free Society John Cogley New York Meridian Book 52–94
Reynolds v. United States 1879 98 U.S. 145
Richardson James D. 1896 A Compilation of the Messages and the Papers of the Presidents 1798–1897. 10 Vols Washington, DC Government Printing Office
Rosen Gary 1999 American Compact: James Madison and the Problem of Founding Lawrence University of Kansas Press
Rosenberger v. University of Virginia 1995 515 U.S. 819
Sherbert v. Verner 1963 374 U.S. 398
Smith Steven D. 2000 Blooming Confusion: Madison's Mixed Legacy Indiana Law Journal 75 Winter 61 75
Soifer Aviam 2000 The Fullness of Time Obligations of Citizenship Nancy Rosenblum Princeton, NJ Princeton University Press 245–79
Stokes Anson Phelps 1950 Church and State in the United States New York Harper & Brothers
Strout Cushing 1988 Jeffersonian Religious Liberty and American Pluralism The Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom: Its Evolution and Consequence in American History Merrill D. Peterson Robert C. Vaughn Cambridge Cambridge University Press 201–35
Texas Monthly Inc. v. Bullock 1989 489 U.S. 1
Wallace v. Jaffree 1985 472 U.S. 38
Walz v. Tax Commissioners of New York City 1970 397 U.S. 664
Weber Paul 1982 James Madison and Religious Equality: The Perfect Separation Review of Politics 44 April 163-86
Wisconsin v. Yoder 1972 406 U.S. 205
Zobrest v. Catalina Foothills School District 1993 509 U.S. 1
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed