Skip to main content

Making Outsiders' Votes Count: Detecting Electoral Fraud through a Natural Experiment


Weak electoral registration requirements are commonly thought to encourage electoral participation, but may also promote electoral fraud. As one possibility, candidates and their supporters can more easily mobilize voters who do not reside within the district to register there fraudulently and vote for that district's candidates. We statistically detect this classic type of electoral fraud for the first time, by taking advantage of a natural experimental setting in Japanese municipal elections. We argue that whether or not a municipal election was held in April 2003 can be regarded as an “as-if” randomly assigned treatment. A differences-in-differences analysis of municipality–month panel data shows that the increase in the new population just prior to April 2003 is significantly larger in treatment municipalities (with an election) than in control ones (without an election). The estimated effects are decisive enough to change the electoral results when the election is competitive. We argue that our approach—“election timing as treatment”—can be applied to investigate not only this type of electoral fraud but also electoral connections in other countries.

Corresponding author
Kentaro Fukumoto is Professor, Department of Political Science, Gakushuin University, 1-5-1 Mejiro, Toshima, Tokyo 171-8588, Japan (
Yusaku Horiuchi is Associate Professor, Crawford School of Economics and Government, College of Asia and the Pacific, Australian National University, J.G. Crawford Building, No. 132, Canberra, ACT 0200, Australia (
Hide All
Alvarez R. Michael, Hall Thad E., and Hyde Susan D.. 2008. Election Fraud: Detecting and Deterring Electoral Manipulation. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
Alvarez R. Michael, and Katz Jonathan N.. 2008. “The Case of the 2002 General Election.” In Election Fraud: Detecting and Deterring Electoral Manipulation, eds. Michael Alvarez R., Hall Thad E., and Hyde Susan D.. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press, 149–61.
Birch Sarah. 2007. “Electoral Systems and Election Misconduct.” Comparative Political Studies 40 (12): 1533–56.
Campbell Angus, Converse Philip E., Miller Warren E., and Stokes Donald E.. 1960. The American Voter. New York: Wiley.
Campbell Tracy. 2005. Deliver the Vote: A History of Election Fraud, an American Political Tradition–1742–2004. New York: Carroll and Graf.
Chang Eric, and Golden Miriam. 2006. “Electoral Systems, District Magnitude and Corruption.” British Journal of Political Science 37 (1): 115–37.
Christensen Ray, and Colvin Kyle. 2009. “Stealing Elections: A Comparison of Election-night Corruption in Japan, Canada, and the United States.” In Political Change in Japan: Electoral Behavior, Party Realignment, and the Koizumi Reforms, eds. Reed Steven R., Mori McElwain Kenneth, and Shimizu Kay. Stanford, CA: Shorenstein Asia–Pacific Research Center, 199218.
Converse Philip E. 1972. “Change in American Electorate.” In The Human Meaning of Social Change, eds. Campbell Angus and Converse Philip E.. New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 263337.
Cox Gray W., and Morgan Kousser J.. 1981. “Turnout and Rural Corruption: New York as a Test Case.” American Journal of Political Science 25 (4): 646–63.
Dai 4 Ji Senkyo Seido Shingikai. 1966. Senkyo no Tetsuzuki ni Kansuru Shôiinkai Iinchô Chûkan Hôkoku Yôshi [Chairman's Interim Report Outline of Subcommittee on Electoral Procedures]. February 15.
Dubin Michael J. 2007. Party Affiliations in the State Legislatures: A Year by Year Summary, 1976–2006. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
Dunning Thad. 2008. “Improving Causal Inference: Strengths and Limitations of Natural Experiments.” Political Research Quarterly 61 (2): 282–93.
Fisher J. A. 1999. “The Probability of Being Decisive.” Public Choice 101: 267–83.
Fukumoto Kentaro, and Horiuchi Yusaku. 2009. “Mobilization and Participation: A Natural Experiment.” Presented at the Annual Summer Meeting of the Society for Political Methodology, New Haven, CT.
Fukumoto Kentaro, Horiuchi Yusaku, and Tanaka Shoichiro. 2011. “Treated Politicians, Treated Voters: A Natural Experiment to Estimate Electoral Effects on Fiscal Expenditure.” Presented at the Annual Meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago.
Fukumoto Kentaro, and Ueki Futoshi. 2011. “Shichôson Senkyo ga Tôitsu Chihô Senkyo kara Itsudatsu Shita Jiki to Riyû.” [“When and Why Did Municipalities Drop from the Simultaneous Local Elections?”] Gakushuin University. Unpublished Manuscript.
Horiuchi Yusaku. 2005. Institutions, Incentives and Electoral Participation in Japan: Cross-level and Cross-national Perspectives. London: Routledge Curzon.
Horiuchi Yusaku. 2009. “Understanding Japanese Politics from a Local Perspective.” International Political Science Review 30 (5): 565–73.
Hutcheson John A., Jr. 1997. “Elections and the Franchise.” In Britain in the Hanoverian Age, 1714–1837: An Encyclopedia, eds. Newman Gerald and Ellen Brown Leslie. New York: Garland Publishing, 222–24.
Hyde Susan D. 2007. “The Observer Effect in International Politics: Evidence from a Natural Experiment.” World Politics 60 (1): 3763.
Hyde Susan D. 2008. “How International Election Observers Detect and Deter Fraud.” In Election Fraud: Detective and Deterring Electoral Manipulation, eds. Alvarez R. Michael, Hall Thad E., and Hyde Susan D.. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press, 201–15.
Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters, the Parliament of Australia. 2001. User Friendly, Not Abuser Friendly: Report of the Inquiry into the Integrity of the Electoral Roll. (accessed June 10, 2011).
Keisatsuchô . 2003. Hanzai Tôkeisho [Criminal Statistics].
Lehoucq Fabrice. 2003. “Electoral Fraud: Causes, Types and Consequences.” Annual Review of Political Science 6: 233–56.
Lehoucq Fabrice E., and Molina Ivan. 2002. Stuffing the Ballot Box: Fraud, Electoral Reform, and Democratization in Costa Rica. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
MacManus Susan. 1999. “The Resurgent City Councils.” In American State and Local Politics: Directions for the 21st Century, eds. Weber Ronald E. and Brace Paul. New York: Seven Bridges, 166–93.
Mayhew David R. 1974. Congress: The Electoral Connection. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Mebane Walter R. 2008. “Election Forensics: The Second-digit Benford's Law Test and Recent American Presidential Elections.” In Election Fraud: Detecting and Deterring Electoral Manipulation, eds. Alvarez R. Michael, Hall Thad E., and Hyde Susan D.. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press, 162–81.
Minnite Lorraine C. 2010. The Myth of Voter Fraud. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Moore John L., Preimesberger Jon P., and Tarr David R., eds. 2001. Congressional Quarterly's Guide to U.S. Elections. Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly.
Myagkov Mikhail, Ordeshook Peter C., and Shakin Dimitri. 2009. The Forensics of Election Fraud: Russia and Ukraine. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Nyblade Benjamin, and Reed Steven R.. 2008. “Who Cheats? Who Loots? Political Competition and Corruption in Japan, 1947–1993.” American Journal of Political Science 52 (4): 926–41.
Persson Torsten, Tabellini Guido, and Trebbi Francesco. 2003. “Electoral Rules and Corruption.” Journal of the European Economic Association 1 (4): 958–89.
Piven Frances Fox, and Cloward Richard A.. 2000. Why Americans Still Don't Vote: And Why Politicians Want It That Way. Rev. and updated ed. Boston: Beacon.
Riker William H., and Ordeshook Peter C.. 1968. “A Theory of the Calculus of Voting.” American Political Science Review 62 (1): 2542.
Rosenstone Steven J., and Mark Hansen John. 1993. Mobilization, Participation, and Democracy in America. New York: Macmillan.
Sadiq Kamal. 2005. “When States Prefer Non-citizens over Citizens: Conflict over Illegal Immigration into Malaysia.”International Studies Quarterly 49 (1): 101–22.
Senate, Parliament of the Czech Republic. 2011. “How Are Senators Elected?” (accessed February 18, 2011).
Shepsle Kenneth A., Van Houweling Robert P., Abrams Samuel J., and Hanson Peter C.. 2009. “The Senate Electoral Cycle and Bicameral Appropriations Politics.” American Journal of Political Science 53 (2): 343–59.
Sômushô Jichigyôsei Kyoku Senkyo Bu. 2003. Chihô Senkyo Kekka Shirabe [Survey of the Local Election Results].
Sômushô Tôkei Kyoku. 2001–2004. Jûmin Kihon Daichô Jinkô Idô Hôkoku [Report of Population Migration in Residential Basic Book]. (accessed June 12, 2009).
Wand Jonathan N., Shotts Kenneth W., Sekhon Jasjeet S., Mebane Walter R. Jr., Herron Michel C., and Brady Henry E.. 2001. “The Butterfly Did It: The Aberrant Vote for Buchanan in Palm Beach County, Florida.” American Political Science Review 95 (4): 793810.
Wolfinger Raymond E., and Rosenstone Steven J.. 1980. Who Votes? New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 7
Total number of PDF views: 150 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 766 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 22nd January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.