Skip to main content
×
×
Home

The Power of the Multitude: Answering Epistemic Challenges to Democracy

  • SAMUEL BAGG (a1)
Abstract

Recent years have witnessed growing controversy over the “wisdom of the multitude.” As epistemic critics drawing on vast empirical evidence have cast doubt on the political competence of ordinary citizens, epistemic democrats have offered a defense of democracy grounded largely in analogies and formal results. So far, I argue, the critics have been more convincing. Nevertheless, democracy can be defended on instrumental grounds, and this article demonstrates an alternative approach. Instead of implausibly upholding the epistemic reliability of average voters, I observe that competitive elections, universal suffrage, and discretionary state power disable certain potent mechanisms of elite entrenchment. By reserving particular forms of power for the multitude of ordinary citizens, they make democratic states more resistant to dangerous forms of capture than non-democratic alternatives. My approach thus offers a robust defense of electoral democracy, yet cautions against expecting too much from it—motivating a thicker conception of democracy, writ large.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Samuel Bagg is a Postdoctoral Fellow with the Research Group on Constitutional Studies and the Department of Political Science at McGill University, 855 Sherbrooke St. West, Montréal, QC, Canada, H3A 2T7 (samuel.bagg@gmail.com).
Footnotes
Hide All

For valuable feedback and discussion on the themes of this article, I am very grateful to Arash Abizadeh, Aaron Ancell, Pablo Beramendi, Kevin Elliot, Michael Gillespie, Kelly Gordon, Ruth Grant, Jeffrey Green, Ewan Kingston, Jack Knight, Elizabeth Landesberg, Catherine Lu, Victor Muñiz-Fraticelli, Wayne Norman, Will Roberts, Amit Ron, Christa Scholtz, Melissa Schwartzberg, Lucas Swaine, Daniel Weinstock, and Yves Winter, as well as Leigh Jenco and several anonymous reviewers at the APSR.

Footnotes
References
Hide All
Acemoglu, Daron, and Robinson, James. 2012. Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty. New York: Crown Business.
Ancell, Aaron. 2017. “Democracy Isn't That Smart (but We Can Make It Smarter): On Landemore's Democratic Reason.” Episteme 14 (2): 161–75.
Achen, Christopher H., and Bartels, Larry M.. 2016. Democracy for Realists: Why Elections Do Not Produce Responsive Government. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Anderson, Elizabeth. 2007. “The Epistemology of Democracy.” Episteme: A Journal of Social Epistemology 3 (1): 822.
Anderson, Elizabeth. 2008. “An Epistemic Defense of Democracy: David Estlund's Democratic Authority.” Episteme: A Journal of Social Epistemology 5 (1): 129–39.
Anderson, Elizabeth. 2010. The Imperative of Integration. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Arneson, Richard. 1993. “Democratic Rights at National and Workplace Levels.” In The Idea of Democracy, eds. Copp, David, Hampton, Jean, and Roemer, John. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 118–48.
Arneson, Richard. 2004. “Democracy Is Not Intrinsically Just.” In Justice and Democracy: Essays for Brian Barry, eds. Dowding, Keith, Goodin, Robert, and Pateman, Carole. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 4058.
Bagg, Samuel. 2016. “Between Critical and Normative Theory: Predictive Political Theory as a Deweyan Realism.” Political Research Quarterly 69 (2): 233–44.
Bagg, Samuel. 2017. “What Makes a Political Theory Political? A Comment on Waldron.” Political Studies Review. https://doi.org/10.1177/1478929917704815 (December 18, 2017).
Bagg, Samuel. 2018a. “Beyond the Search for the Subject: An Anti-Essentialist Ontology for Liberal Democracy.” European Journal of Political Theory OnlineFirst. https://doi.org/10.1177/1474885118763881 (March 29, 2018).
Bagg, Samuel. 2018b. “Can Deliberation Neutralise Power?European Journal of Political Theory 17 (3): 257–79.
Beitz, Charles R. 1989. Political Equality: An Essay in Democratic Theory. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Bell, Daniel A. 2015. The China Model: Political Meritocracy and the Limits of Democracy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Bohman, James. 2006. “Deliberative Democracy and the Epistemic Benefits of Diversity.” Episteme: A Journal of Social Epistemology 3 (3): 175–91.
Brennan, Jason. 2016. Against Democracy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Campbell, Angus, Converse, Philip E., Miller, Warren E., and Stokes, Donald E.. 1960. The American Voter. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Caplan, Bryan. 2007. The Myth of the Rational Voter: Why Democracies Choose Bad Policies. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Christiano, Thomas. 1996. The Rule of the Many: Fundamental Issues in Democratic Theory. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Coulthard, Glen Sean. 2014. Red Skin, White Masks: Rejecting the Colonial Politics of Recognition. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Crouch, Colin. 2004. Post-Democracy. Malden, MA: Polity.
Davis, Angela Y. 2012. The Meaning of Freedom: And Other Difficult Dialogues. San Francisco: City Lights Publishers.
Dietrich, Franz. 2008. “The Premises of Condorcet's Jury Theorem Are Not Simultaneously Justified.” Episteme: A Journal of Social Epistemology 5 (1): 5673.
Disch, Lisa. 2011. “Toward a Mobilization Conception of Democratic Representation.” American Political Science Review 105 (1): 100–14.
Dresden, Jennifer Raymond, and Howard, Marc Morjé. 2016. “Authoritarian Backsliding and the Concentration of Political Power.” Democratization 23 (7): 1122–43.
Dworkin, Ronald. 1996. Freedom's Law: The Moral Reading of the American Constitution. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
El Amine, Loubna. 2016. “Beyond East and West: Reorienting Political Theory through the Prism of Modernity.” Perspectives on Politics 14 (1): 102–20.
Estlund, David. 1994. “Opinion Leaders, Independence, and Condorcet's Jury Theorem.” Theory and Decision 36 (2): 131–62.
Estlund, David. 2008. Democratic Authority: A Philosophical Framework. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Foa, Roberto Stefan, and Mounk, Yascha. 2016. “The Democratic Disconnect.” Journal of Democracy 27 (3): 517.
Fricker, Miranda. 2009. Epistemic Injustice: Power and the Ethics of Knowing. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Fuerstein, Michael. 2008. “Epistemic Democracy and the Social Character of Justification.” Episteme 5 (1): 7493.
Fukuyama, Francis. 2014. Political Order and Political Decay: From the Industrial Revolution to the Globalization of Democracy. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Galston, William. 2010. “Realism in Political Theory.” European Journal of Political Theory 9 (4): 385411.
Gaus, Gerald. 1997. “Does Democracy Reveal the Voice of the People? Four Takes on Rousseau.” Australasian Journal of Philosophy 75 (2): 141–62.
Gaus, Gerald. 2011. “On Seeking the Truth (Whatever That Is) through Democracy: Estlund's Case for the Qualified Epistemic Claim.” Ethics 121 (2): 270300.
Gramsci, Antonio. 1971. Selections from the Prison Notebooks, eds. Hoare, Quintin and Smith, Geoffrey Nowell. New York: International Publishers.
Green, Jeffrey Edward. 2009. The Eyes of the People: Democracy in an Age of Spectatorship. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Green, Jeffrey Edward. 2016. The Shadow of Unfairness: A Plebeian Theory of Liberal Democracy. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Griffin, Christopher G. 2003. “Democracy as a Non–Instrumentally Just Procedure.” Journal of Political Philosophy 11 (1): 111–21.
Grofman, Bernard, and Feld, Scott L.. 1988. “Rousseau's General Will: A Condorcetian Perspective.” The American Political Science Review 82 (2): 567–76.
Guerrero, Alexander A. 2014. “Against Elections: The Lottocratic Alternative.” Philosophy & Public Affairs 42 (2): 135–78.
Hayward, Clarissa Rile. 2013. How Americans Make Race: Stories, Institutions, Spaces. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Healy, Andrew, and Malhotra, Neil. 2013. “Retrospective Voting Reconsidered.” Annual Review of Political Science 16 (1): 285306.
Hong, Lu, and Page, Scott E.. 2004. “Groups of Diverse Problem Solvers Can Outperform Groups of High-Ability Problem Solvers.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 101 (46): 16385–9.
Hualing, Fu. 2015. “Wielding the Sword: President Xi's New Anti-Corruption Campaign.” In Greed, Corruption and the Modern State: Essays in Political Economy, eds. Rose-Ackerman, Susan and Lagunes, Paul. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing, 134–59.
Hui, Victoria Tin-bor. 2015. “The Protests and Beyond.” Journal of Democracy 26 (2): 111–21.
Hui, Victoria Tin-bor. 2016. “Contribution to Symposium on Bell's China Model.” Perspectives on Politics 14 (1): 150–1.
Humphrey, Mathew. 2007. Ecological Politics and Democratic Theory: The Challenge to the Deliberative Ideal. New York: Routledge.
Ingham, Sean. 2013. “Disagreement and Epistemic Arguments for Democracy.” Politics, Philosophy & Economics 12 (2): 136–55.
Issacharoff, Samuel, and Pildes, Richard H.. 1998. “Politics as Markets: Partisan Lockups of the Democratic Process.” Stanford Law Review 50 (3): 643717.
Jenco, Leigh. 2016. “Contribution to Symposium on Bell's China Model.” Perspectives on Politics 14 (1): 152–3.
Kirshner, Alexander S. 2014. A Theory of Militant Democracy: The Ethics of Combatting Political Extremism. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Knight, Jack, and Johnson, James. 2011. The Priority of Democracy: Political Consequences of Pragmatism. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Kolodny, Niko. 2014. “Rule Over None I: What Justifies Democracy?Philosophy & Public Affairs 42 (3): 195229.
Landemore, Hélène. 2012. Democratic Reason: Politics, Collective Intelligence, and the Rule of the Many. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Landemore, Hélène, and Elster, Jon, eds. 2012. Collective Wisdom: Principles and Mechanisms. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Levinson, Daryl J., and Pildes, Richard H.. 2006. “Separation of Parties, Not Powers.” Harvard Law Review 119 (8): 2311–86.
Levitsky, Steven, and Way, Lucan A.. 2010. Competitive Authoritarianism: Hybrid Regimes after the Cold War. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Levitsky, Steven, and Ziblatt, Daniel. 2018. How Democracies Die. New York: Crown.
Lindsey, Brink, and Teles, Steven. 2017. The Captured Economy: How the Powerful Enrich Themselves, Slow Down Growth, and Increase Inequality. New York: Oxford University Press.
List, Christian, and Goodin, Robert E.. 2001. “Epistemic Democracy: Generalizing the Condorcet Jury Theorem.” Journal of Political Philosophy 9 (3): 277306.
Lodge, Milton, and Charles, S. Taber. 2013. The Rationalizing Voter. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Longino, Helen E. 2013. Studying Human Behavior: How Scientists Investigate Aggression and Sexuality. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Mantena, Karuna. 2012. “Another Realism: The Politics of Gandhian Nonviolence.” American Political Science Review 106 (02): 455–70.
Marks, Jonathan. 2009. Why I Am Not a Scientist: Anthropology and Modern Knowledge. Berkeley: University of California Press.
McNamee, Stephen J., and Miller, Robert K.. 2013. The Meritocracy Myth (3rd ed.). Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Medearis, John. 2015. Why Democracy Is Oppositional. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Medina, José. 2012. The Epistemology of Resistance: Gender and Racial Oppression, Epistemic Injustice, and Resistant Imaginations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Misak, Cheryl. 2008. “A Culture of Justification: The Pragmatist's Epistemic Argument for Democracy.” Episteme: A Journal of Social Epistemology 5 (1): 94105.
Nathan, Andrew. 2016. “Contribution to Symposium on Bell's China Model.” Perspectives on Politics 14 (1): 154–5.
North, Douglass C., Wallis, John Joseph, and Weingast, Barry R.. 2009. Violence and Social Orders: A Conceptual Framework for Interpreting Recorded Human History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ober, Josiah. 2008. Democracy and Knowledge: Innovation and Learning in Classical Athens. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Ong, Lynette. 2016. “Contribution to Symposium on Bell's China Model.” Perspectives on Politics 14 (1): 156–7.
Oppenheimer, Danny, and Edwards, Mike. 2012. Democracy Despite Itself: Why a System That Shouldn't Work at All Works So Well. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Pettit, Philip. 2013. On the People's Terms: A Republican Theory and Model of Democracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Phulwani, Vijay. 2016. “The Poor Man's Machiavelli: Saul Alinsky and the Morality of Power.” American Political Science Review 110 (4): 863–75.
Przeworski, Adam. 1991. Democracy and the Market: Political and Economic Reforms in Eastern Europe and Latin America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Przeworski, Adam. 1999. “Minimalist Conception of Democracy: A Defense.” In Democracy's Value, eds. Shapiro, Ian and Hacker-Cordon, Casiano. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Przeworski, Adam. 2005. “Democracy as an Equilibrium.” Public Choice 123 (3–4): 253–73.
Przeworski, Adam. 2010. Democracy and the Limits of Self-Government. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Rahman, K. Sabeel. 2016. Democracy against Domination. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Schwartzberg, Melissa. 2015. “Epistemic Democracy and Its Challenges.” Annual Review of Political Science 18 (1): 187203.
Sen, Amartya. 1999. “Democracy as a Universal Value.” Journal of Democracy 10 (3): 3–17.
Shapiro, Ian. 2003. The State of Democratic Theory. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Shapiro, Ian. 2016. Politics against Domination. Cambridge: Belknap.
Somin, Ilya. 2013. Democracy and Political Ignorance: Why Smaller Government Is Smarter (1st ed.). Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Somin, Ilya. 2015. The Grasping Hand: “Kelo v. City of New London” and the Limits of Eminent Domain. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Stout, Jeffrey. 2012. Blessed Are the Organized: Grassroots Democracy in America. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Sunstein, Cass R. 1987. “Lochner's Legacy.” Columbia Law Review 87 (5): 873919.
Svolik, Milan. n.d. “When Polarization Trumps Civic Virtue: Partisan Conflict and the Subversion of Democracy by Incumbents.” Working Paper, Yale University.
Tan, Kenneth Paul. 2008. “Meritocracy and Elitism in a Global City: Ideological Shifts in Singapore.” International Political Science Review 29 (1): 727.
Thompson, Abigail. 2014. “Does Diversity Trump Ability? An Example of the Misuse of Mathematics in the Social Sciences.” Notices of the American Mathematical Society 61 (9): 1024–30.
Tilly, Charles. 2007. Democracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Van Hees, Martin. 2007. “The Limits of Epistemic Democracy.” Social Choice and Welfare 28 (4): 649–66.
Viehoff, Daniel. 2014. “Democratic Equality and Political Authority.” Philosophy & Public Affairs 42 (4): 337–75.
Waldron, Jeremy. 1995. “The Wisdom of the Multitude: Some Reflections on Book 3, Chapter 11 of Aristotle's Politics.” Political Theory 23 (4): 563–84.
Wall, Steven. 2007. “Democracy and Equality.” The Philosophical Quarterly 57 (228): 416–38.
Warren, Mark. 2011. “Voting with Your Feet: Exit-Based Empowerment in Democratic Theory.” The American Political Science Review 105 (4): 683701.
Williams, Bernard. 2005. In the Beginning Was the Deed: Realism and Moralism in Political Argument, ed. Hawthorn, G.. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
X, Malcolm. 1964. The Ballot or the Bullet. Speech, Cory Methodist Church in Cleveland, OH. April 3, 1964.
Yuen, Samson. 2014. “Disciplining the Party: Xi Jinping's Anti-Corruption Campaign and Its Limits.” China Perspectives 2014 (2014/3): 41–7.
Zaller, John. 1992. The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed