Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
×
Home

Sources of Bias in Retrospective Decision Making: Experimental Evidence on Voters’ Limitations in Controlling Incumbents

  • GREGORY A. HUBER (a1), SETH J. HILL (a2) and GABRIEL S. LENZ (a3)
Abstract

Are citizens competent to assess the performance of incumbent politicians? Observational studies cast doubt on voter competence by documenting several biases in retrospective assessments of performance. However, these studies are open to alternative interpretations because of the complexity of the real world. In this article, we show that these biases in retrospective evaluations occur even in the simplified setting of experimental games. In three experiments, our participants (1) overweighted recent relative to overall incumbent performance when made aware of an election closer rather than more distant from that event, (2) allowed an unrelated lottery that affected their welfare to influence their choices, and (3) were influenced by rhetoric to give more weight to recent rather than overall incumbent performance. These biases were apparent even though we informed and incentivized respondents to weight all performance equally. Our findings point to key limitations in voters’ ability to use a retrospective decision rule.

Copyright
Corresponding author
Gregory A. Huber is Professor, Department of Political Science and Institution for Social and Policy Studies, Yale University, 77 Prospect Street, P.O. Box 208209, New Haven, CT 06520 (gregory.huber@yale.edu).
Seth J. Hill is Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, University of California at San Diego, 9500 Gilman Drive, La Jolla, CA 92093 (sjhill@ucsd.edu).
Gabriel S. Lenz is Assistant Professor, Charles and Louise Travers Department of Political Science, University of California at Berkeley, 210 Barrows Hall #1950, Berkeley, CA 94720 (glenz@berkeley.edu).
References
Hide All
Achen, Christopher H., and Bartels, Larry M.. 2004a. “Blind Retrospection: Electoral Responses to Drought, Flu, and Shark Attacks.” Princeton University. Unpublished manuscript.
Achen, Christopher H., and Bartels, Larry M.. 2004b. “Musical Chairs: Pocketbook Voting and the Limits of Democratic Accountability.” Princeton University. Unpublished manuscript.
Alter, Adam L., Oppenheimer, Daniel M., and Zemla, Jeffrey C.. 2010. “Missing the Trees for the Forest: A Construal Level Account of the Illusion of Explanatory Depth.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 99 (3): 436–51.
Ariely, Dan. 1998. “Combining Experiences over Time: The Effects of Duration, Intensity Changes, and On-line Measurements on Retrospective Pain Evaluations.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 11: 1945.
Ariely, Dan, and Carmon, Ziv. 2000. “Gestalt Characteristics of Experienced Profiles: The Defining Features of Summarized Events.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 13: 191201.
Ariely, Dan, and Zauberman, Gal. 2000. “On the Making of an Experience: The Effects of Breaking and Combining Experiences on Their Overall Evaluation.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 13: 219–32.
Baddeley, Alan. 1992. “Working Memory.” Science 255 (5044): 556–59.
Barro, Robert J. 1973. “The Control of Politicians: An Economic Model.” Public Choice 14 (1): 1942.
Bartels, Larry M. 2011. “Ideology and Retrospection in Electoral Responses to the Great Recession.” Vanderbilt University. Unpublished manuscript.
Baumgartner, Hans, Sujan, Mita, and Padgett, Dan. 1997. “Patterns of Affective Reactions to Advertisements: The Integration of Moment-to-Moment Responses into Overall Judgments.” Journal of Marketing Research 34 (2): 219–32.
Berinsky, Adam J., Huber, Gregory A., and Lenz, Gabriel S.. 2012. “Evaluating Online Labor Markets for Experimental Research: Amazon.com's Mechanical Turk.” Political Analysis 20 (3): 351–68.
Brady, Timothy F., and Alvarez, George A.. 2011. “Hierarchical Encoding in Visual Working Memory: Ensemble Statistics Bias Memory for Individual Items.” Psychological Science 22 (3): 384–92.
Buhrmester, Michael D., Kwang, Tracy, and Gosling, Samuel D.. 2011. “Amazon's Mechanical Turk: A New Source of Inexpensive, yet High-quality, Data?Perspectives on Psychological Science 6 (1): 35.
Callander, Steven. 2011. “Searching for Good Policies.” American Political Science Review 105 (4): 643–62.
Carmon, Ziv, and Kahneman, Daniel. 1996. “The Experienced Utility of Queuing.” Duke University. Unpublished manuscript.
Chapman, Gretchen B. 2000. “Preferences for Improving and Declining Sequences of Health Outcomes.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 13 (2): 203–18.
Cole, Shawn A., Healy, Andrew, and Werker, Eric. 2011. “Do Voters Appreciate Responsive Governments? Evidence from Indian Disaster Relief.” Journal of Development Economics 97 (2): 167–81.
Collier, Kenneth E., McKelvey, Richard D., Ordeshook, Peter C., and Williams, Kenneth C.. 1987. “Retrospective Voting: An Experimental Study.” Public Choice 53 (2): 101–30.
Collier, Kenneth, Ordeshook, Peter C., and Williams, Kenneth. 1989. “The Rationally Uninformed Electorate: Some Experimental Evidence.” Public Choice 60 (1): 329.
Delli Carpini, Michael X., and Keeter, Scott. 1996. What Americans Know about Politics and Why It Matters. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Downs, Anthony. 1957. An Economic Theory of Democracy. New York: Harper and Row.
Duch, Raymond M., and Stevenson, Randy. 2010. “The Global Economy, Competency, and the Economic Vote.” Journal of Politics 72 (1): 105–23.
Ebeid, Michael, and Rodden, Jonathan. 2006. “Economic Geography and Economic Voting: Evidence from the US States.” British Journal of Political Science 36 (3): 527–47.
Fair, Ray C. 1978. “The Effect of Economic Events on Votes for President.” Review of Economics and Statistics 60 (2): 159–73.
Fausey, Caitlin M., and Matlock, Teenie. 2011. “Can Grammar Win Elections?Political Psychology 32 (4): 563–74.
Ferejohn, John A. 1986. “Incumbent Performance and Electoral Control.” Public Choice 50 (1): 525.
Fiorina, Morris P. 1981. Retrospective Voting in American National Elections. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Forgas, Joseph P. 2000. “Feeling Is Believing? The Role of Processing Strategies in Mediating Effective Influences on Beliefs.” In Emotions and Beliefs: How Feelings Influence Thoughts, eds. Frijda, Nico H., Manstead, A.S.R., and Bem, Sacha. New York: Cambridge University Press, 108–44.
Forgas, Joseph P., and Bower, Gordon H.. 1987. “Mood Effects on Person-perception Judgments.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 53 (1): 5360.
Fredrickson, Barbara L., and Kahneman, Daniel. 1993. “Duration Neglect in Retrospective Evaluations of Affective Episodes.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 65 (1): 4555.
Friedman, Daniel, and Sunder, Shyam. 1994. Experimental Methods: A Primer for Economists. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Gasper, John T., and Reeves, Andrew. 2011. “Make It Rain? Retrospection and the Attentive Electorate in the Context of Natural Disasters.” American Journal of Political Science 55 (2): 340–55.
Gómez, Ángel, Brooks, Matthew L., Buhrmester, Michael D., Vázquez, Alexandra, Jetten, Jolanda, and Swann, William B. Jr. 2011. “On the Nature of Identity Fusion: Insights into the Construct and a New Measure.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 100 (5): 918–33.
Healy, Andrew, and Lenz, Gabriel S. 2012. “Substituting the End for the Whole: Why Voters Respond Primarily to the Election-year Economy.” University of California, Berkeley. Unpublished manuscript.
Healy, Andrew, and Malhotra, Neil. 2010. “Random Events, Economic Losses, and Retrospective Voting: Implications for Democratic Competence.” Quarterly Journal of Political Science 5 (2): 193208.
Healy, Andrew J., Malhotra, Neil A., and Mo, Cecilia H.. 2010. “Irrelevant Events Affect Voters’ Evaluations of Government Performance.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 107 (29): 12,804–9.
Hetherington, Marc J. 1996. “The Media's Role in Forming Voters’ National Economic Evaluations in 1992.” American Journal of Political Science 40 (2): 372–95.
Horton, John J., Rand, David G., and Zeckhauser, Richard J.. 2010. “The Online Laboratory: Conducting Experiments in a Real Labor Market.” Experimental Economics 14 (3): 399425.
Hsee, Christopher K., Abelson, Robert P., and Salovey, Peter. 1991. “The Relative Weighting of Position and Velocity in Satisfaction.” Psychological Science 2 (4): 263.
Iyengar, Shanto, and Kinder, Donald. 1987. News That Matters: Television and American Opinion. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kahneman, Daniel, Fredrickson, Barbara L., Schreiber, Charles A., and Redelmeier, Donald A.. 1993. “When More Pain Is Preferred to Less: Adding a Better End.” Psychological Science 4: 401–5.
Kahneman, Daniel, Wakker, Peter P., and Sarin, Rakesh. 1997. “Back to Bentham? Explorations of Experienced Utility.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 112 (2): 375405.
Kayser, Mark Andreas, and Peress, Michael. 2012. “Benchmarking across Borders: Electoral Accountability and the Necessity of Comparison.” American Political Science Review 106 (3): 661–84.
Kramer, Gerald H. 1971. “Short-term Fluctuations in U.S. Voting Behavior, 1896–1964.” American Political Science Review 65 (1): 131–43.
Lawson, Chappell, Lenz, Gabriel S., Myers, Michael, and Baker, Andy. 2010. “Looking Like a Winner: Candidate Appearance and Electoral Success in New Democracies.” World Politics 62 (4): 561–93.
Lenz, Gabriel S. 2012. Follow the Leader. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Levitt, Steven D., and List, John A.. 2007. “What Do Laboratory Experiments Measuring Social Preferences Reveal About the Real World?Journal of Economic Perspectives 21 (2): 153–74.
Loewenstein, George F., and Prelec, Dražen. 1991. “Negative Time Preference.” American Economic Review 81 (2): 347–52.
Loewenstein, George F., and Sicherman, Nachum. 1991. “Do Workers Prefer Increasing Wage Profiles?Journal of Labor Economics 9: 6784.
Loewenstein, George F., and Prelec, Dražen. 1993. “Preferences for Sequences of Outcomes.” Psychological Review 100 (1): 91108.
Mackuen, Michael B., Erikson, Robert S., and Stimson, James A.. 1992. “Peasants or Bankers? The American Electorate and the U.S. Economy.” American Political Science Review 86 (3): 597611.
Mason, Winter, and Watts, Duncan J.. 2012. “Collaborative Learning in Networks.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109 (3): 764–69.
Morton, Rebecca B., and Williams, Kenneth C.. 2010. Experimental Political Science and the Study of Causality. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Palmer, Harvey D., and Whitten, Guy D.. 2000. “Government Competence, Economic Performance, and Endogenous Election Dates.” Electoral Studies 19 (2): 41326
Paolacci, Gabriele, Chandler, Jesse, and Ipeirotis, Panagiotis G.. 2010. “Running Experiments on Amazon Mechanical Turk.” Judgment and Decision Making 5 (5): 411–19.
Rand, David G., Arbesman, Samuel, and Christakis, Nicholas A.. 2011. “Dynamic Social Networks Promote Cooperation in Experiments with Humans.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 108 (48): 19193–98.
Redelmeier, Donald A., and Kahneman, Daniel. 1996. “Patients’ Memories of Painful Medical Treatments.” Pain 66 (1): 38.
Ross, William T., and Simonson, Itamar. 1991. “Evaluations of Pairs of Experiences: A Preference for Happy Endings.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 4 (4): 273–82.
Schreiber, Charles A., and Kahneman, Daniel. 2000. “Determinants of the Remembered Utility of Aversive Sounds.” Journal of Experimental Psychology 129 (1): 2742.
Schwarz, Norbert, and Clore, Gerald L.. 1983. “Mood, Misattribution, and Judgments of Well-being: Informative and Directive Functions of Affective States.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 45 (3): 513–23.
Smith, Vernon L. 1976. “Experimental Economics: Induced Value Theory.” American Economic Review 66 (2): 274–79.
Sobolev, Anton, Lazarev, Yegor, Soboleva, Irina, and Boris, Sokolov. 2012. “Trial by Fire: The Impact of Natural Disaster on Attitudes toward the Government in Rural Russia.” Research Paper No. BRP 04/PS/2012. Higher School of Economics. http://ssrn.com/abstract=2011975 (accessed July 12, 2012).
Tufte, Edward R. 1978. Political Control of the Economy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Valentino, Nicholas A., and Sears, David O.. 1998. “Event-driven Political Communication and the Preadult Socialization of Partisanship.” Political Behavior 20 (2): 127–54.
Varey, C., and Kahneman, D.. 1992. “Experiences Extended across Time: Evaluation of Moments and Episodes.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 5 (3): 169–85.
Vavreck, Lynn. 2009. The Message Matters: The Economy and Presidential Campaigns. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Williams, Kenneth C. 1994. “Sequential Elections and Retrospective Voting.” Journal of Theoretical Politics 6 (2): 239–55.
Wolfers, Justin. 2002. “Are Voters Rational? Evidence from Gubernatorial Elections.” University of Pennsylvania. Unpublished manuscript.
Woon, Jonathan. 2010. “Democratic Accountability and Retrospective Voting in the Lab.” University of Pittsburgh. Unpublished manuscript.
Zaller, John. 1992. The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Zauberman, Gal, Diehl, Kristin, and Ariely, Dan. 2006. “Hedonic versus Informational Evaluations: Task Dependent Preferences for Sequences of Outcomes.” Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 19 (3): 191211.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

American Political Science Review
  • ISSN: 0003-0554
  • EISSN: 1537-5943
  • URL: /core/journals/american-political-science-review
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×
Type Description Title
PDF
Supplementary materials

Huber Supplementary Material
Appendix

 PDF (265 KB)
265 KB

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed