Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-vvkck Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-27T23:52:15.041Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Commerce and Industry in Nineteenth Century Paraguay: The Example of Yerba Mate*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 December 2015

Vera Blinn Reber
Vera Blinn Reber*
Affiliation:
Shippensburg University of Pennsylvania, Shippensburg, Pennsylvania
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Yerba mate, a primitive forest industry, demonstrates the interaction of private and state enterprise in nineteenth century Paraguay. A low capital investment industry based upon utilizing seasonal and unskilled labor, yerba mate was financed, collected, and sold by the private entrepreneur and the state. Demand for yerba in both internal and external markets assured satisfactory profits for businessmen, above average wages for laborers, and necessary revenues for government. As a major export of Paraguay from the end of the seventeenth century until the War of the Triple Alliance, The Great War of 1864-1870, yerba mate provides insight into government regulations, taxation, price controls, and foreign trade policies. Because of the significance of yerba mate for the Paraguayan economy, the state was involved in both production and trade, although government interest primarily assured revenues rather than state control. A description of the organization of the yerba mate industry and an analysis of government policies supports revisionist studies that the governments of José Gaspar de Francia, 1811-1840, Carlos Antonio López, 1844-1862, and Francisco Solano López, 1862-1870 were pragmatic and rational rather than dictatorial and monopolistic.

Type
Research Article
Information
The Americas , Volume 42 , Issue 1 , July 1985 , pp. 29 - 53
Copyright
Copyright © Academy of American Franciscan History 1985

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

The author wishes to thank the Tinker Foundation, which made possible research in Brasília, Corrientes, and Asunción, Shirley Mellinger for typing and aid in statistical analysis and Daniel Papiernik and the Media Service of Shippensburg University for preparation of the map.

References

1 For the traditional view of Paraguay’s nineteenth century governments see George Mulhall, Michael, Handbook of the River Plate comprising the Argentine Republic, Uruguay and Paraguay (London, 1885), p. 629 Google Scholar; Robertson, John Parish and Robertson, William Parish, Francia’s Reign of Terror, being a sequel to Letters on Paraguay (Philadelphia, 1839q), 1, 182 Google Scholar; Creydt, Oscar A., Formación historica de la nación paraguay ([n.p.], 1963), pp. 41–43 Google Scholar; Pastore, Carlos, La Lucha por la tierra en el Paraguay (Montevideo, 1972), pp. 98–9.Google Scholar The revisionist works are best illustrated by White, Richard, Paraguay’s Autonomous Revolution (Albuquerque, 1978),Google Scholar Williams, John H., The Rise and Fall of the Paraguayan Republic, 1800–1870 (Austin, 1979),Google Scholar and García Mellid, Atilio, Proceso a los falsificadores de la historia del Paraguay (Buenos Aires, 1964).Google Scholar

2 Plate, Enrique, Notes on Paraguay (Buenos Aires, 1899), p. 18 Google Scholar; Martínez, Benigno T., El Paraguay: memoria bajo el punto de vista industrial y comercial en relación con los países del Plata (Asunción, 1885), p. 41 Google Scholar; Library of Congress, Washington (hereafter LC), Manuscript Division (hereafter MD), Ac 6431, Diary of Charles T. Fahs, 11 February 1859, p. 104; Raine, Philip, Paraguay (New Brunswick, N.J., 1956), p. 363.Google Scholar

3 Demersay, L. M., Étude economique sur la maté thé du Paraguay (Paris, 1867), p. 12.Google Scholar Archives du Ministère des Affaires Entrangères, Paris (hereafter AMAE), Correspondence consulaire et commerciale (hereafter ccc), Buenos Aires (hereafter B.A.), vol. 3, B.A. 30 April 1853, St. Georges to Drouyn de Lhuys.

4 The map was based on the following sources: Demersay, Étude economique sur la maté; Du Graty, Alfredo, La República del Paraguay, trans, from the French by Carlos Calvo (Besanzon, 1862), pp. 143–154 Google Scholar; Mulhall, M. G., Handbook, 1875, p. 385 Google Scholar; Peña Villamil, Manuel, “Breve Historia de la Granaderia Paraguaya,” Historia Paraguaya, 13 (1969–80), 83–97 Google Scholar; Silva, Raul de Andrada e, Ensato sobre a Ditadura do Paraguai, 1814–1840 (São Paulo, 1978), pp. 57 Google Scholar, 207, 209. de Arad, Irene Szumsztjn, “La Granaderia en el Paraguay: Período 1870–1900,” Revista Paraguaya de Sociologia, 10, no. 28 (Sept.-Dec. 1973), 187 Google Scholar; AMAE, ccc B.A. 3, 30 April 1853; Mapa de la República del Paraguay, 1860 by Coronel D. Alfredo Du Graty. For a visual image of the economy of Paraguay during the Francia years simply contrast the agricultural area, and decrease the cattle area particularly in the north.

5 Fischer-Treuenfeld, R. von, Le Paraguay (Bruxelles, 1906), 25–26.Google Scholar That would mean 810 trees could be planted on one cuerda or 1.25 acres.

6 López, Adalberto, “The Economics of Yerba Mate in Seventeenth Century South America,” Agricultural History, IIL, 4 (1974), 499–507.Google Scholar

7 Archivo Nacional, Asunción (hereafter ANA), Sección Historia (hereafter SH) 279, Razón de Yerbales, Villa Rica, 23 January 1846.

8 ANA, Sección Nueva Encuademación (hereafter NE) 2801, Informe sobre Beneficio, Asunción 8 June 1863, 14 October 1863, 10 December 1863. Great Britain, Parliament, Parliamentary Papers (House of Commons & Command), 1883, Vol. LXXI, Cmnd. 3472, “Report on the manufactures, commerce, &c, of Paraguay,” p. 151.

9 ANA, NE 829 Autorizaciones otorgades para beneficio de yerba, 1862; Public Record Office, London (hereafter PRO), Foreign Office Section (hereafter FO) 6/135, 18 Feb. 1847 Joseph Graham to Felipe Arana.

10 John, P. and Robertson, William P., Four Years in Paraguay comprising an account of that Republic under the government of Dictator Francia (Philadelphia, 1838), 2, 100–101 Google Scholar; ANA, NE 2736, 1854; PRO, FO 12/202 29 April 1843 Gordon to Earl of Aberdeen.

11 Du Graty, La República p. 41. The exchange rate was approximately one peso to five francs.

12 la Dardye, E. de Bourgade, Paraguay: The Land and the People, natural wealth and commercial capabilities, edited by Ravenstein, E. G. (London, 1892), pp. 200–201.Google Scholar

13 Silva, , Ensato, p. 209.Google Scholar

14 Cooney, Jerry, “An Ignored Aspect of the Viceroyalty of the Rio de la Plata” (Unpublished paper), pp. 2–3 Google Scholar; White, Richard Alan, “America’s First Radical Revolution; The Political Economy of Popular Paraguay, 1810–1840” (Ph.D. thesis, University of California Los Angeles, 1976), p. 30.Google Scholar

15 de Aguirre, Juan Francisco, “Diario de Aguirre,” Anales de la Biblioteca, 7 (1910), 434–439.Google Scholar

16 Cooney, , “An Ignored Aspect, pp. 2–3 Google Scholar; Archivo y Museo Histórico del Banco de la Provincia de Buenos Aires (hereafter AMB), Archivo Particular Juan Pedro de Aguirre (hereafter Aguirre Papers) 031-2-1 no. 16, Paraguay 19 August 1794 Juan Carci to Christoval Aguirre.

17 AMB, Aguirre Papers 031-6-9 no. 1, Cuenta, 18 Sept. 1813. The Robertson Brothers in partnership with an Argentine merchant report a profit of 3,000 percent on one speculation in 1818. This profit was far higher than those indicated for the colonial era. This was extremely unusual, most likely exaggerated as the Robertson Brothers tended to figure their profits without clearly indicating their expenses and at best a one time occurrence. See Robertson, , Francia’s Reign of Terror, 2, 57–91.Google Scholar

18 Robertson, , Four years in Paraguay, 2, 93 Google Scholar; Page, Thomas J., La Plata, the Argentine Confederation and Paraguay, Being a narrative of the exploration of the tributaries of the RiberLa Plata and adjacent countries during the years 1853, 1854, 1855, and 1856 (New York, 1859), p. 37.Google Scholar

19 White, , Paraguay’s Autonomous Revolution, p. 141 Google Scholar; Table II, DuGraty, La República, p. 341.

20 ANA, NE 2582 Correspondance y Comprobantes del rama de Hacienda 19 Jan. 1849. Page, La Piata, Argentine Confederation and Paraguay, p. 137.

21 Du Graty, La República, p. 341.

22 la Dardye, Bourgade, Paraguay, pp. 219–220.Google Scholar

23 Mulhall, , Handbook 1885, p. 629 Google Scholar; la Dardye, Bourgade, Paraguay, pp. 219–221.Google Scholar

24 White, , Paraguay’s Autonomous Revolution, p. 141.Google Scholar

25 ANA, SH 307 Rosario 5 March 18.63, Pedro L. Ramayo to Mariano Gonzalez.

26 Williams, , Rise and Fall, p. 33 Google Scholar Demersay, , Étude economique sur la maté, p. 21.Google Scholar

27 ANA, NE 1294 Registro de guias y aforas 1822, No. 72.

28 Chaves, Julio C., El Supremo dictador: biografía de José Gaspar de Francia (3rd ed., Buenos Aires, 1958), p. 276 Google Scholar; ANA, NE 1875 Libro de la recaudación de yerba de la contribución fructuaria de Concepción, 1834. White, , Paraguay’s Autonomous Revolution, p. 108.Google Scholar

29 Silva, , Ensaio, p. 226 Google Scholar; ANA, NE 1849 Cuaderno para la recauderno del derecho de alcabala en la receptoría de San Estanislao, 1827; White, , Paraguay’s Autonomous Revolution, p. 141,Google Scholar and p. 276, footnote 19.

30 López, Carlos Antonio, Documentos del Archivo de Asuncion (Asunción, n.d.), 2, 339.Google Scholar

31 ANA, SH 254, Licenses para beneficios de yerba.

32 ANA, NE 1693, Registro de Libranzas de yerba, 1865.

33 Du Graty, La República, p. 339; Alfred, Demersay, Histoire physique economique et politique de Paraguay et des établissements des Jésuites (Paris, 1864), 2, 44.Google Scholar ANA, NE 3007, Cuaderno de conocimiento de venta de yerba correspondiente a los años 1849 y 1850, Villa del Pilar.

34 ANA, NE 648; ANA, NE 2679 Cuaderno de conocimientos de las rentos de yerba 1848; ANA, NE 1374, Libro Registro de Patentes, 1844.

35 ANA, NE 1693, Registro de Libranzas de yerba, 1864.

36 ANA, NE 2708, Razon de la yerba entregó en el Puerto de la Capital para su venta al Estado, 31 August 1852; AMAE, ccc, Vol. 3, Β.A. 30 April 1853, St. Georges to Drouyn de Lhuys.

37 AMAE, Correspondence Politique (hereafter cp), Paraguay, Vol. 1, 10 June 1855, Lucien de Brayer to Monsieur Drouyn de Lhuys.

38 ANA, NE 1110, Registro de guias otorgades 1850; ANA, NE 2023, Registro de guia 1851; ANA, NE 1488, Registro de guia 1851; ANA, NE 2579, Secundo cuaderno de conocimientos de las rentas de yerba, 1848.

39 There is some disagreement between the sources PRO, FO 6/13, Asunción 15 January 1855 Henderson to Earl of Clarendon, “Report on the Commerce, Agriculture, and Industry of the Republic of Paraguay,” p. 22 and the tax records. Arquivo Histórico do Ministerio de Relações Exteriores, Itamaratí, Rio de Janeiro (hereafter AHI), Repartiçoes Consulares Brasileiras (hereafter CB), 238.3.2, Asunción 23 January 1859, Amaro José dos Santos Barbosa to José María de Silva Parantes. ANA, NE 2057, Pasaporte otorgadas para el interno 1854: the latter clearly shows that private individuals continue to export on their own account.

40 PRO, FO 59/113, Asunción 15 January 1855 Henderson to Earl of Clarendon, “Report on the Commerce, Agriculture, and Industry of the Republic of Paraguay,” p. 22, suggests that the annual export in former years was 320,000 arrobas and was reduced to 80,000 arrobas. This amount is somewhat exaggerated for the “former” years, but still supports the downward decline of exports. However, profits of private entrepreneurs seemed reasonable even with complaints that government regulation discouraged incentive.

41 AMAE, ccc Asunción, vol. 1, 10 June 1855 Cte Lucien de Brayer to Drouyn de Lhuys.

42 Biblioteca Nacional do Rio de Janeiro (hereafter BN), Coleção Visconde do Rio Branco (hereafter CRB), 1–30,30,23, no. 2, “President López and the Policy of Paraguay,” clipping from Daily News, 7 Sept. 1857.

43 AHI, 238.3.2, Asunción 12 Jan. 1860, Amaro José Santos Barbaro to José Luis Viera Cassnasancas de Liminbu.

44 AMAE, ccc, Asunción 10 June 1855, Lucien de Brayer to Drouyn de Lhuys, p. 32.

45 Great Britain, Parliamentary Papers (House of Commons & Command, 1883, Vol. LXXI, Cmnd. 3472, p. 148.

46 la Dardye, Bourgade, Paraguay, pp. 219–221.Google Scholar Silva, , Ensaio, p. 226.Google Scholar Warren, Harris Gaylord, Paraguay, and the Triple Alliance: The Postwar Decade, 1869–1878 (Austin, 1978), p. 223.Google Scholar

47 Viola, Alfredo, Reseña del desarrollo cultural del Paraguay (Asunción, 1979), p. 107.Google Scholar

48 ANA, NE 2679 Secundo Cuaderno de conocimientos de las rentas de yerba, cuero, y tablos del estado en el año 1848, Villa Rica.

49 ANA, NE 1863, Cuaderno del Derecho de Villa del Pilar, 1832.

50 ANA, NE 1850, Cuaderno de alcabala, San Ysidro 1828.

51 Williams, , The Rise and Fall of Paraguay, pp. 69–74.Google Scholar

52 Archivo General de la Provincia Corrientes (hereafter AGPC), Correspondencia Official (hereafter CO), Legajo 18, San Roque 7 Feb. 1825 and 8 Feb. 1825. AMAE, ccc, Asunción, Vol. 1, 22 January 1859.

53 la Dardye, Bourgade, Paraguay, pp. 219–221 Google Scholar; Découd, Jose Segundo, Paraguay, with a chapter on the native races by J. Hampden Porter (Washington, D.C., 1902), pp. 166–167 Google Scholar; Robertson, , Four Years in Paraguay, pp. 100–101 Google Scholar; PRO, FO 6/135, 18 Feb. 1847 Joseph Graham to Felipe Arana; Archives Nationales, Paris (hereafter ANP), Ministère de la Marine (hereafter MM), Serie BB4.420 (1821.6), Amérique du Sud, 4 Nov. 1820.

54 Mellet, Jullien, Voyages dan l’interior de L’Amerique Meridionale Paris, 1824), p. 28.Google Scholar PRO, FO 6/24, Buenos Aires 29 July 1824.

55 Wilcocke, Samuel Hull, History of the Viceroyalty of Buenos Aires (London, 1807), p. 530.Google Scholar

56 This is based on a total export of 216,000 arrobas; see Table 5.

57 Paraguay: A Concise History of its rise and progress, and the causes of the present war with Brazil (London, 1867), p. 36.

58 BN, CRB, 1–24,35,56, no. 25, Limehouse, London 8 Sept. 1857 J. A. Blythe to F. S. López.

59 BN, CRB, 1–30,3,70, Berlin 5 October 1864 Alfred Du Graty to José Berges; Ibid., Brussels 31 October 1864.

60 BN, CRB, 1–30,22,44, nos. 1–7, January 1865.

61 Cardozo, Efraín, Hace cien años: Crónicas d la Guerra de 1864–70 (Asunción, 1966–1972), 5, 302 Google Scholar; one bale is assumed to weigh seven and one half arrobas.

62 BN, CRB, 1–30,11,44.

63 Warren, Carlos A., Emancipación Economica Americana, Vol. XVIII: Paraguay (Montevideo, 1946), p. 157.Google Scholar

64 PRO,FO 6/285, 8 October 1869 Stuart to Earl of Clarendon.

65 The best discussion on the problems of forming a government after the Great War and Argentine and Brazilian efforts to control Paraguay can be found in H. G. Warren, Paraguay and the Triple Alliance.