Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Evaluating mountain goat dairy systems for conversion to the organic model, using a multicriteria method

  • Y. Mena (a1), J. Nahed (a2), F. A. Ruiz (a3), J. B. Sánchez-Muñoz (a4), J. L. Ruiz-Rojas (a4) and J. M. Castel (a1)...

Abstract

Organic farming conserves natural resources, promotes biodiversity, guarantees animal welfare and obtains healthy products from raw materials through natural processes. In order to evaluate possibilities of increasing organic animal production, this study proposes a farm-scale multicriteria method for assessing the conversion of dairy goat systems to the organic model. In addition, a case study in the Northern Sierra of Seville, southern Spain, is analysed. A consensus of expert opinions and a field survey are used to validate a list of potential indicators and issues for assessing the conversion, which consider not only the European Community regulations for organic livestock farming, but also agroecological principles. As a result, the method includes 56 variables integrated in nine indicators: Nutritional management, Sustainable pasture management, Soil fertility and contamination, Weed and pest control, Disease prevention, Breeds and reproduction, Animal welfare, Food safety and Marketing and management. The nine indicators are finally integrated in a global index named OLPI (Organic Livestock Proximity Index). Application of the method to a case study with 24 goat farms reveals an OLPI value of 46.5% for dairy goat farms located in mountain areas of southern Spain. The aspects that differ most from the agroecological model include soil management, animal nutrition and product marketing. Results of the case study indicate that the proposed method is easy to implement and is useful for quantifying the approximation of conventional farms to an organic model.

Copyright

Corresponding author

E-mail: yomena@us.es

References

Hide All
Bellon, S, Lamine, C 2009. Conversion to organic farming: a multidimensional research project at the crossroads of agricultural and social sciences – a review. In Sustainable agriculture (ed. E Lichtfouse, M Navarrete, P Debaeke, V Souchère and C Alberola), pp. 653663. Springer Publishing, Heidelberg, Germany.
Benoit, M, Laignel, G 2009. Performances techniques et économiques en élevage biologique d'ovins viande: observations en réseaux d’élevage et fermes expérimentales. INRA Productions Animales 22, 197206.
Benoit, M, Tournadre, H, Dulphy, JP, Laignel, G, Prache, S, Cabaret, J 2009. Comparaison de deux systèmes d’élevage biologique d'ovins allaitants différant par le rythme de reproduction: une approche expérimentale pluridisciplinaire. INRA Productions Animales 22, 207220.
Bernués, A, Ruiz, R, Olaizola, A, Villalba, D, Casasús, I 2011. Sustainability of pasture-based livestock farming systems in the European Mediterranean context: synergies and trade-offs. Livestock Science 139, 4457.
Bockstaller, C, Guichard, L, Makowski, D, Aveline, A, Girardin, P, Plantureux, S 2009. Agri-environmental indicators to assess cropping and farming system: a review. In Sustainable agriculture (ed. E Lichtfouse, M Navarrete, P Debaeke, V Souchère and C Alberola), pp. 725739. Springer Publishing, Heidelberg, Germany.
Boongoen, T, Shen, Q 2009. Semi-supervised OWA aggregation for link-based similarity evaluation and alias detection. FUZZ-IEEE (Korea) 20, 288293.
Castel, JM, Ruiz, FA, Mena, Y, Sánchez Rodríguez, M 2010. Present situation and perspectives of goat production systems in Spain. Small Ruminant Research 85, 4249.
Castel, JM, Mena, Y, Ruiz, FA, Camúñez-Ruiz, J, Sánchez-Rodríguez, M 2011. Changes occurring in dairy goat production systems in less favoured areas of Spain. Small Ruminant Research 93, 8392.
Coffey, L, Reynolds, J, Hale, M 2004. Small ruminant sustainability checksheet. Livestock Production Guide, 1-800-346-9140, ATTRA. Retrieved May 5, 2010, from http://www.attra.ncat.org
Commission Regulation (EC) No. 889/2008 of 5 September 2008 laying down detailed rules for implementation of Council Regulation (EC) No. 834/2007 on organic production and labeling of organic products with regards to organic production, labelling and control.
Council Regulation (EC) No. 834/2007 of 28 June 2007 on organic production and labelling of organic products and repealing Regulation (ECC) No. 2092/91.
Cuchillo, M, Delgadillo, C, Navarro, A, Pérez-Gil, F 2009. Antioxidant activity, bioactive polyphenols in Mexican goats’ milk cheeses on summer grazing. Journal of Dairy Research 76, 17.
Darnhofer, I, Lindenthal, T, Bartel-Kratocvhvil, R, Zollitsch, W 2010. Conventionalisation of organic farming practices: from structural criteria towards an assessment based on organic principles: a review. Agronomy for Sustainable Development 30, 6781.
De Rancourt, M, Fois, N, Lavín, MP, Tchakérian, E, Vallerand, F 2006. Mediterranean sheep and goat production: an uncertain future. Small Ruminant Research 62, 167179.
Dubeuf, JP, Ruiz Morales, FA, Castel Genís, JM 2010. Initiatives and projects to promote the Mediterranean local cheeses and their relations to the development of livestock systems and activities. Small Ruminant Research 93, 6775.
Falconi, F, Burbano, R 2004. Instrumentos económicos para la gestión ambiental: decisiones monocriteriales versus decisiones multicriteriales. Revista Iberoamericana de Economía Ecológica 1, 1120.
Galán, MB, Peschard, D, Boizard, H 2007. ISO 14001 at the farm level: analysis of five methods for evaluating the environmental impact of agricultural practices. Journal of Environmental Management 82, 341352.
Gallopín, GC 1997. Indicators and their use: information for decision making. In Sustainability indicators: report of the project on indicators of sustainable development (ed. B Moldan and S Billhartz), pp. 1327. SCOPE Wiley and Sons Ltd, Chichester, UK.
García, A, Perea, JM, Acero, R, Valerio, D, Ramos, JA 2008. Producción ecológica de caprino de leche. In Producción Ecológica: influencia en el desarrollo rural (ed. G Guzmán, A García, A Alonso and JM Perea), pp. 467498. Ministry of the Environment and Rural and Marine Affairs Publishing, Madrid, Spain.
García-Martínez, A, Olaizola, A, Bernués, A 2009. Trajectories of evolution and drivers of change in European mountain cattle farming systems. Animal 3, 152165.
Grabisch, M 1995. Fuzzy integral in multicriteria decision making. Fuzzy Sets and Systems 69, 279298.
Gray, D, Hovi, M 2001. Sanidad y bienestar de los animales en las explotaciones ecológicas. In Ganadería ecológica (ed. D Younie and JM Wilkinson), pp. 3555. Acribia Publishing, Zaragoza, Spain.
Grimm, JW, Wozniak, PR 1990. Basic social statistics and quantitative research methods. Wadsworth Publishing Co., Belmont, CA, USA.
Guzmán, CGI, Alonso, MA 2001. Diseño del proceso de transición a agricultura ecológica. In La práctica de la agricultura y ganadería ecológica (ed. Comité Andaluz de Agricultura Ecologica), pp. 341348. Comité Andaluz de Agricultura Ecológica Publishing, Seville, Spain.
Hadjigeorgiou, I, Osoro, K, Fragoso de Almeida, JP, Molle, G 2005. Southern European grazing lands: production, environmental and landscape management aspects. Livestock Production Science 96, 5159.
International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements (IFOAM) 2009. The principles of organic agriculture. Retrieved January 13, 2011, from http://www.ifoam.org/about_ifoam/principles/index.html
Labrador, J, Sarandon, S 2001. Aproximación a las bases del pensamiento agroecológico. In Agroecología y desarrollo: aproximación a los fundamentos agroecológicos para la gestión sustentable de agrosistemas mediterráneos (ed. J Labrador and MA Altieri), pp. 2148. Mundiprensa Publishing, Madrid, Spain.
LaSalle, T, Happerly, P, Diop, A 2008. The Organic Green Revolution. Rodale Institute Publishing, Pennsylvania, USA.
Lu, CD, Gangyi, X, Kawas, JR 2010. Organic goat production, processing, and marketing: opportunities, challenges and outlook. Small Ruminant Research 89, 102109.
Manly, BFJ 2004. Multivariate statistical methods a primer. Chapman & Hall/CRC, Florida, USA.
Ministry of the Environment and Rural and Marine Affairs (MARM) 2009. Organic production statistics. Retrieved January 3, 2011, from http://www.marm.es
Mata, MC 2001. Bases técnicas de la ganadería ecológica. In La práctica de la agricultura y ganadería ecológica (ed. Comité Andaluz de Agricultura Ecologica), pp. 163177. Comité Andaluz de Agricultura Ecológica, Seville, Spain.
Mena, Y, Nahed, J, Ruíz, FA, Castel, JM, Ligero, M 2009a. Proximity to the organic model of dairy goat systems in the Andalusian mountains (Spain). Tropical and Subtropical Agroecosystem 11, 6973.
Mena, Y, Ligero, M, Ruíz, FA, Nahed, J, Castel, JM, Acosta, JM, Guzman, JL 2009b. Organic and conventional dairy goat production systems in Andalusian mountains areas. Options Méditerranéennes Série A 91, 253256.
Müller-Lindenlauf, M, Deittert, Ch, Köpke, U 2010. Assessment of environmental effects, animal welfare and milk quality among organic dairy farms. Livestock Science 128, 140148.
Munda, G 2004. Multicriteria methods and multicriteria processes for social evaluation of public policy. Revista Iberoamericana de Economía Ecológica 1, 3145.
Munda, G, Nijkamp, P, Rietveld, P 1994. Fuzzy multigroup conflict resolution for environmental management. In The economic of project appraisal and the environment (ed. J Weiss), pp. 161183. Edward Elgar Publishing, Aldershot, UK.
Nahed, TJ, Castel, JM, Mena, Y, Caravaca, F 2006. Appraisal of the sustainability of dairy goat systems in Southern Spain according to their degree of intensification. Livestock Science 101, 1023.
Napolitano, F, De Rosa, G, Ferrante, V, Grasso, F, Braghieri, A 2009. Monitoring the welfare of sheep in organic and conventional farms using an ANI 35 L derived method. Small Ruminant Research 83, 4957.
Nardone, A, Zervas, G, Ronchi, B 2004. Sustainability of small ruminant organic of production. Livestock Production Science 90, 2739.
Nauta, WJ, Baars, T, Bovenhuis, H 2006. Converting to organic dairy farming: consequences of production, somatic cells scores and calving interval of first parity Holstein cows. Livestock Production Science 99, 185195.
Olivares, PR, Gómez, CMA, Meraz, AM 2005. Potential for conversion of conventional livestock farms to organic production systems in the State of Tabasco. Técnicas Pecuarias Mexicanas 43, 361370.
Peacock, C, Sherman, DM 2010. Sustainable goat production – some global perspectives. Small Ruminant Research 89, 225238.
Phythian, CJ, Michalopoulou, E, Jones, PH, Winter, AC, Clarkson, MJ, Stubbings, LA, Grove-White, D, Cripps, PJ, Duncan, JS 2011. Validating indicators of sheep welfare through a consensus of expert opinion. Animal 5, 943952.
Pimentel, D, Hepperli, P, Hanson, J, Douds, D, Seidel, R 2005. Environmental, energetic, and economic comparisons of organic and conventional farming systems. BioSience 55, 573582.
Pingali, P, Raney, T 2005. From the green revolution to the gene revolution: how will the poor fare? ESA Working paper No. 05-09. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome, Italy.
Ronchi, B, Nardone, A 2003. Contribution of organic farming to increase sustainability of Mediterranean small ruminants systems. Livestock Production Science 80, 1731.
Rozzi, P, Miglior, F, Hands, J 2007. A total Merit Selection Index for Ontario Organic Dairy Farmers. Journal Dairy Science 90, 15841593.
Ruiz, FA, Castel, JM, Mena, Y, Camúñez, J, González-Redondo, P 2008. Application of the technico-economic analysis for characterizing, making diagnoses and improving pastoral dairy goat systems in Andalusia (Spain). Small Ruminant Research 77, 208220.
Ruiz, FA, Mena, Y, Castel, JM, Guinamard, C, Bossis, N, Caramelle-Holtz, E, Contu, M, Sitzia, M, Fois, N 2009. Dairy goat grazing systems in Mediterranean regions: a comparative analysis in Spain, France and Italy. Small Ruminant Research 85, 4249.
SPSS Inc . 2006. SPSS users manual base 15.0. SPSS Inc., Chicago, USA.
Statistical Institute of Andalusia-Andalusian Government (SIA-AG) 2008. Official statistics. Retrieved January 3, 2011, from http://www.juntadeandalucia.es:9002/
Vaarst, M, Padel, S, Hovi, M, Younie, D, Sundrum, A 2005. Sustaining animal health and food safety in European organic livestock farming. Livestock Production Science 94, 6169.
Yager, RR 1991. Connectives and quantifiers in fuzzy sets. Fuzzy Sets and Systems 40, 3975.
Zar, JH 1984. Biostatistical analysis, 2nd edition. Prentice-Hall, New Jersey, USA.

Keywords

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed