Skip to main content Accessibility help

Evaluation of the impact of a Herd Health and Production Management programme in organic dairy cattle farms: a process evaluation approach

  • J. E. Duval (a1), N. Bareille (a1), A. Madouasse (a1), M. de Joybert (a1), K. Sjöström (a2), U. Emanuelson (a2), F. Bonnet-Beaugrand (a1) and C. Fourichon (a1)...


Animal health planning activities are not always providing a satisfactory positive impact on herd health and welfare. Moreover, evaluating the impact of advisory programmes is complex due to multiple interacting elements that influence its outcome. Therefore, measuring solely health outcomes is not sufficient: the whole process of the implementation and use of such programmes should be evaluated. In order to evaluate the impact of an intervention with a Herd Health and Production Management (HHPM) programme a process evaluation framework was designed and used. The intervention involved 20 organic dairy cattle farmers and their advisors, in both France and Sweden. In both countries 20 organic dairy farms were selected as control herds. The evaluation of the HHPM programme was based on: (a) the compliance to the programme; (b) the programme’s functions influencing herd health management practices and stimulating dialogue between farmers and advisors; (c) its effectiveness in terms of improving herd health compared with control farms. Complete compliance to the programme was fulfilled by 21 out of 40 farmers–advisors. Results from a questionnaire showed that the programme functioned as intended (e.g. by allowing early identification of herd health problems), stimulated change in farmers’ herd health management practices and farmer–advisor dialogue. Even though the majority of the users perceived that the programme contributed to herd health improvements, no significant differences in health outcomes were found when compared with control farms 12 months after the start of the intervention. The programme allowed creating an environment promoting the exchange of information between farmers and advisors, necessary to define pertinent advice in a farm-specific situation. Future research should aim at improving methods for the evaluation of the effect of advisory programmes, by identifying early indicators for effective advice and developing methods to evaluate the quality of advisory situations without interfering with them.


Corresponding author


Hide All
Anonymous 2007. Council regulation (EC) No 834/2007 on organic production and labelling of organic products and repealing Regulation (EEC) No 2092/91.
Beekhuis-Gibbon, L, Devitt, C, Whyte, P, O’Grady, L, More, SJ, Redmond, B and Doherty, ML 2011. A HACCP-based approach to mastitis control in dairy herds. Part 2: implementation and evaluation. Irish Veterinary Journal 64, 7.
Bell, NJ, Bell, MJ, Knowles, TG, Whay, HR, Main, DJ and Webster, AJF 2009. The development, implementation and testing of a lameness control programme based on HACCP principles and designed for heifers on dairy farms. The Veterinary Journal 180, 178188.
Brand, A, Noordhuizen, JPTM and Schukken, YH 2001. Herd Health and Production Management in dairy practice. Wageningen Academic Publishers, Wageningen, The Netherlands.
Cerf, M, Jeuffroy, MH, Prost, L and Meynard, JM 2012. Participatory design of agricultural decision support tools: taking account of the use situations. Agronomy for Sustainable Development 32, 899910.
Craig, P, Dieppe, P, Macintyre, S, Health, P, Unit, S, Michie, S and Petticrew, M 2008. Developing and evaluating complex interventions: the new Medical Research Council Guidance. British Medical Journal 337, 1655.
Duval, JE, Bareille, N, Fourichon, C, Madouasse, A and Vaarst, M 2016a. Perceptions of French private veterinary practitioners on their role in organic dairy farms and opportunities to improve their advisory services for organic dairy farmers. Preventive Veterinary Medicine 128, 1021.
Duval, JE, Fourichon, C, Madouasse, A, Sjöström, K, Emanuelson, U and Bareille, N 2016b. A participatory approach to design monitoring indicators of production diseases in organic dairy farms. Preventive Veterinary Medicine 133, 1222.
Garforth, C 2011. Effective communication to improve udder health: can social science help? In Udder health and communication (ed. H Hogeveen and TJGM Lam), pp. 5566. Wageningen Academic Publishers, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Green, MJ, Leach, KA, Breen, JE, Green, LE and Bradley, AJ 2007. National intervention study of mastitis control in dairy herds in England and Wales. Veterinary Record 160, 287293.
International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements 2005. Principles of organic agriculture. IFOAM. Retrieved on 13 February 2017 from
Ivemeyer, S, Smolders, G, Brinkmann, J, Gratzer, E, Hansen, B, Henriksen, BIF and Walkenhorst, M 2012. Impact of animal health and welfare planning on medicine use, herd health and production in European organic dairy farms. Livestock Science 145, 6372.
Ivemeyer, S, Walkenhorst, M, Heil, F, Notz, C, Maeschli, A, Butler, G and Klocke, P. 2009. Management factors affecting udder health and effects of a one year extension program in organic dairy herds. Animal 3, 15961604.
Janz, NK and Becker, MH 1984. The health belief model: a decade later. Health Education Quarterly 11, 147.
Klerkx, L and Jansen, J 2010. Building knowledge systems for sustainable agriculture: supporting private advisors to adequately address sustainable farm management in regular service contacts. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability 8, 148163.
Krieger, M, Sjöström, K, Blanco-Penedo, I, Madouasse, A, Duval, JE, Bareille, N, Fourichon, C, Sundrum, A and Emanuelson, U. 2017. Prevalences of production diseases in European organic dairy herds. Livestock Science 198, 104108.
Malterud, K 2001. The art and science of clinical knowledge: evidence beyond measures and numbers. The Lancet 358, 397400.
Moore, GF, Audrey, S, Barker, M, Bond, L, Bonell, C, Hardeman, W and Baird, J 2015. Process evaluation of complex interventions: Medical Research Council guidance. British Medical Journal 350, h1258.
Oakley, A, Strange, V, Bonell, C, Allen, E, Stephenson, J, and RIPPLE Study Team. 2006. Process evaluation in randomised controlled trials of complex interventions. British Medical Journal 332, 413416.
Vaarst, M, Bennedsgaard, TW, Klaas, I, Nissen, TB., Thamsborg, SM and Østergaard, S 2006. Development and daily management of an explicit strategy of nonuse of antimicrobial drugs in twelve Danish organic dairy herds. Journal of Dairy Science 89, 18421853.
Vaarst, M, Winckler, C, Roderick, S, Smolders, G, Ivemeyer, S, Brinkmann, J and Huber, J 2011. Animal health and welfare planning organic dairy cattle farms. The Open Veterinary Science Journal 5, 1925.
Waters, E, Hall, BJ, Armstrong, R, Doyle, J, Pettman, TL and De Silva-Sanigorski, A 2011. Essential components of public health evidence reviews: capturing intervention complexity, implementation, economics and equity. Journal of Public Health 33, 462465.


Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

Duval et al supplementary material 1
Duval et al supplementary material

 Word (637 KB)
637 KB

Evaluation of the impact of a Herd Health and Production Management programme in organic dairy cattle farms: a process evaluation approach

  • J. E. Duval (a1), N. Bareille (a1), A. Madouasse (a1), M. de Joybert (a1), K. Sjöström (a2), U. Emanuelson (a2), F. Bonnet-Beaugrand (a1) and C. Fourichon (a1)...


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.