Skip to main content
×
×
Home

The Astronomical Tradition Of Maragha: A Historical Survey And Prospects for Future Research

  • George Saliba (a1)
Abstract

This paper surveys the results established so far by the on-going research on the planetary theories in Arabic astronomy. The most important results of the Maragha astronomers are gathered here for the first time, and new areas for future research are delineated. The conclusions reached demonstrate that the Arabic astronomical works mentioned here not only elaborate the connection between Arabic astronomy and Copernicus, but also that such activities, namely the continuous reformulation of Greek astronomy, were not limited to a specific group of astronomers or to a specific geographical area. It is shown that such activities were spread over a period of more than seven hundred years, from the early eleventh till the sixteenth century, and over an area stretching from the Andalusian peninsula in the west to the farthest reaches of Central Asia in the east.

L'auteur expose, dans cet article, les résultats établis jusqu'ici par les recherches en cours concernant les théories planétaires de l'astronomie arabe. Les résultats les plus importants relatifs aux astronomes de Maragha sont rassemblés ici pour la première fois et le contour de nouveaux domaines pour la recherche future s'y trouve délimité. Les conclusions auxquelles on parvient dans cet article montrent d'une part que les oeuvres en astronomie mentionnées nous permettent de mieux saisir la liaison entre l'astronomie arabe et celle de Copernic, d'autre part que l'activité de reformulation continue de l'astronomie grecque ne fut limitée ni à un groupe spécifique d'astronomes, ni à une aire géographique déterminée. On montre ici qu'une telle activité s'est en fait étendue sur une période de plus de sept siécles, depuis le début du Xle siècle jusqu'au XVIe siècle, et sur une aire allant de la péninsule andalouse à l'Ouest jusqu'aux confins les plus éloignés de l'Asie centrale à l'Est.

    • Send article to Kindle

      To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.

      Note you can select to send to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be sent to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

      Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

      The Astronomical Tradition Of Maragha: A Historical Survey And Prospects for Future Research
      Available formats
      ×
      Send article to Dropbox

      To send this article to your Dropbox account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Dropbox.

      The Astronomical Tradition Of Maragha: A Historical Survey And Prospects for Future Research
      Available formats
      ×
      Send article to Google Drive

      To send this article to your Google Drive account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Google Drive.

      The Astronomical Tradition Of Maragha: A Historical Survey And Prospects for Future Research
      Available formats
      ×
Copyright
References
Hide All

1 The Ultimate Quest regarding the Rectification of [Astronomical] Principles. A critical edition of this text using all the extant manuscripts is now completed by the present author. There exists an English translation based on one manuscript, completed by Victor Roberts more than twenty years ago but never published. A new comprehensive translation of the critically edited text and a commentary on the whole work are now in preparation by the present author.

2 Neugebauer, O., Exact Sciences in Antiquity (Providence, RI, 1957), Appendix, pp. 197, 203–204. Neugebauer was already working on the Maragha results from a French translation of a text by Naṣīr al-Dīn al-Ṭūsī (d. 1274) describing the “Ṭsī Device” and Ṭūsī lunar model. It was Baron Carra De Vaux who first made that text available in French as Appendix VI to Tannery's, P.Recherche sur l'histoire de l'astronomie ancienne (Paris, 1893), pp. 337361.

3 Neugebauer, O., Exact Sciences, note 2.

4 All these articles are now gathered together in Kennedy, E.S. et al. , Studies in the Islamic Exact Sciences (American University of Beirut, Beirut, 1983), Pp. 50107.

5 The important chapter in Ṭūsī's work, where the description of his lunar model is to be found, was already published in translation by Carra De Vaux, see note 2 above.

6 See for example, Saliba, G., “The Original Source of Quṭb al-Dīn al-Shīrāzī's Planetary Model,” Journal for the History of Arabic Science (1979) 3: 318.

7 Urḍī's text, Kitāb al-Hay'a, was first used by Swerdlow, Noel in his unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, “Ptolemy's Theory of the Distances and Sizes of the Planets: A Study of the Scientific Foundation of Medieval Cosmology” (Yale, 1968), and identified simply as the “Anonymous Astronomical Treatise in Bodleian Arabic Ms March 621.” Later, the same manuscript was used by Goldstein, B. and Swerdlow, N. in “Planetary Distances and Sizes in an Anonymous Arabic Treatise Preserved in Bodleian Ms March 621,” Centaurus (19701971) 15: 135170. The present author finally identified this Bodleian MS as being the work of 'Urḍī, in The First non-Ptolemaic Astronomy at the Maragha School,” ISIS (1979) 70: 571576.

8 In reality it was Carra De Vaux who first published Ṭūsī's lunar model, see note 2 above.

9 See note 6.

10 Saliba, G., “A Medieval Arabic Reform of the Ptolemaic Lunar Model,” Journal for the History of Astronomy (1989) 20: 157164.

11 Parts of the Tadhkira were edited, translated into English, and supplied with a commentary by Ragep, F. Jamil as a Ph.D. dissertation at Harvard University, 1982. Since then, I understand that the same author has undertaken to edit the whole work and to translate it into English and comment upon it.

12 See al-Haytham, Ibn, Al-Shukūk 'ala Baṭlamyūs, edited by Sabra, A. and Shehaby, N. (Dubitationes in Ptolemæum) (Cairo, 1971).

13 The present author is aware of the facsimile edition produced by Goldstein, B., “The Arabic Version of Ptolemy's Planetary Hypothesis,” Transactions of the American Philosophical Society (1967) 57, and of an on-going project, conducted by Régis Morelon, the aim of which is to produce a critical edition of the Planetary Hypothesis.

14 Goldstein, B., Al-Biṭrūjī: On the Principles of Astronomy (New Haven and London, 1971).

15 Koyré's statement, in Taton, R., Histoire générale des sciences, vol. 2, p. 64, was also quoted in Neugebauer, O., “On the Planetary Theory of Copernicus,” Vistas in Astronomy (1968) vol. 10, p. 89, reprinted in Neugebauer, O., Astronomy and History: Selected Essays (New York, Berlin, Heidelberg, Tokyo, 1983), pp. 491505. See also infra.

16 Swerdlow, N. and Neugebauer, O., Mathematical Astronomy in Copernicus's De Revolutionibus (New York, Berlin, Heidelberg, Tokyo, 1984), p. 295.

17 Neugebauer, O., “On the Planetary Theory of Copernicus,” p. 90, note 15.

18 See, for example, Hartner, W., “Naṣīr al-Dīn al-Ṭūsī's Lunar Theory,” Physis (1969) 11: 287304;La science dans le monde de l'Islam après la chute du califat,” Studia Islamica (1970) 31: 135151;Copernicus, the Man, the Work, and its History,” Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society (1973) 117: 413422;“The Islamic Astronomical Background to Nicholas Copernicus,” Ossolineum 1975, Colloquia Copernica III, Nadbitka, 716 [all now reprinted in W. Hartner, Oriens-Occidens II (1984)];Swerdlow, N., “The Derivation and First Draft of Copernicus's Planetary Theory: A Translation of the Commentariolus with Commentary,” Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society (1973) 117: 423512.

19 See, Hartner, W., “Copernicus, the Man,” note 18.

20 Hartner, continued to explore this connection between Copernicus and the Maragha astronomers till the last years of his life. Just before he died, he published, for example, “Ptolemaische Astronomie im Islam und zur Zeit des Regiomontanus,” Regiomontanus-Studien, Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Philosophisch-Historische Klasse, Sitzungberichte, 364. Band (1980), Heraugegeben von Günther Hamann, 109124.

21 Swerdlow, N., “Derivation,” note 18.

22 For a detailed analysis of the use of 'Urḍī's Lemma by the Maragha astronomers and its eventual use by Copernicus, see Saliba, G.Arabic Astronomy and Copernicus,” Zeitschrift für Geschichte der Arabisch-Islamischen Wissenschaften (1984) 1: 7387, esp. pp. 78–79.

23 See A History of Ancient Mathematical Astronomy (New York, Heidelberg, Berlin, 1975), p. 1456 for plate IX of Vat. Gracec. 211, fol. 116r.

22 Swerdlow, Noel and Neugebauer, Otto, note 16, figs. 5 and 6.

24 See for example, Saliba, G., “The Role of the Almagest Commentaries in Medieval Arabic Astronomy,” Archives Internationales d'Histoire des Sciences (1987) 37: 320.

25 Most of these interpretations are now grouped together for the reader's convenience in one article by Gingerich, Owen, “Islamic Astronomy,” Scientific American (1986) 254: 7483. This article was later translated into Arabic with many gross mistakes in the Arabic and published in the Arabic version of the Scientific American Majallat al-'Ulūm, 1.1: 8–19.

26 Saliba, G., “Theory and Observation in Islamic Astronomy: The Work of Ibn al-Shāṭir of Damascus (d. 1375),” Journal for the History of Astronomy (1987) 18: 3543.

27 Saliba, , “The Role of the Almagest Commentaries,” note 25.

28 See Roberts, note 4.

29 See note 10.

30 Roberts, Victor, note 4, p. 430.

31 For a more detailed treatment of the problem of periodization in Arabic astronomy, see Saliba, G., “The Role of Maragha in the Development of Islamic Astronomy: A Scientific Revolution Before the Renaissance,” Revue de Synthèse (1987) 3.4: 361373.

32 For a short survey of Tāj al-Sharīcas models, see G. Saliba, “Islamic Planetary Theories After the Eleventh Century,” to appear in a book devoted to the history of Arabic science edited by R. Rashed. See also the edition, translation, and commentary on Tāj al-Sharīca's works in the Ph.D. dissertation of Ahmad al-Dallāl, Department of Middle East Languages and Cultures, Columbia University (1990).

34 The only reference we have to this book comes from an elementary treatise called Kitāb al-Hay'a (A Book on Astronomy), by the same anonymous Spanish author, now preserved at the Osmania University Library, Hyderabad, MS N° 520RH.

35 Cf. Arabic manuscript Ahmad III 3338, fol. 4v, in the Topkapi Library, Istanbul.

36 The latest of these studies is Sabra, A.I., “The Andalusian Revolt against Ptolemaic Astronomy,” in Transformation and Tradition in the Sciences, edited by Everett, Mendelsohn (Cambridge, 1984).

37 The last study of Swerdlow, N., “Jābir Ibn Aflah's Interesting Method for Finding Eccentricities and Direction of the Apsidal Line of a Superior Planet,” in From Deferent to Equant, edited by King, D. and Saliba, G., Annals, New York Academy of Sciences (1987) 500: 501512, explains the methodological sophistication of Jābir, but does not touch directly upon the issues raised here.

38 I have noted the importance of these texts and their interrelationship in the preliminary survey of the Tahrĭr. See Saliba, G., “The Role of the Almagest Commentaries,” note 25.

39 Cf. Shīrāzī's text, Majlis Shūra-i Milli MS 3944, Teheran, fol. 7r.

40 Se ISIS (1983) 74: 388401 and Centaurus (1986) 29: 249271.

41 This treatise was mentioned by the biographer Zādeh, Taşköprü (d. 1561), al-Shaqā 'iq al-Nu'mānīya fi al-Dawla al-'Uthmānīya, edited by Ahmad, S. Furāt, Istanbul Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Yayinlari N°: 3353 (Istanbul 1985), p. 159.

42 The existence of this treatise was first brought to my attention, in 1981, by A.I. Sabra, of Harvard University, who has kindly sent me a copy of his own handwritten selections from it. I gladly acknowledge his kind gesture.

43 See Suter, H., Die Mathematiker und Astronomen Der Araber und Ihre Werke (Leipzig, 1900), p. 188.

44 See Sédillot, L.P.E.A., Prolégomènes des Tables Astronomiques d'Ouloug-Beg (Paris, 1853).

45 Süleymaniye, Hüsrev Paşa MS 246.

46 Ibid., fol. 46v.

47 Ibid., fol. 50v.

48 See, for example, Suter, , Die Mathematiker und Astronomen, p. 189, note 43 and Brockelman, C., Geschichte der Arabischen Literatur (Berlin, 1902), II, p. 414.

49 MS Arabic Revan 1996.

50 Ibid., fol. 90r.

52 Ibid., fol. 92v.

53 lstanbul University MS Arabçe 2466.

54 See, Suter, Die Mathematiker und Astronomen, p. 190, note 43, where he gives a variant of the name as Chalīl b. Ahmed el-Naqīb, Gars ed-dīn Ḥalebī, but does not mention the work discussed here.

55 MS Arabçe Yeni Cami 1181.

56 Ibid., fol. 174v.

57 More on this author in Suter, Die Mathematiker und Astronomen, p. 194, note 43.

58 Süleymaniye Library, Istanbul, Laleli Arabic MS 2126, fols. 64r-116v.

59 lstanbul University, MS Arabçe 2466.

60 Ibid., fol. 6v.

61 See, Saliba, G., “Ibn Sīna and Abū 'Ubayd al-Jūzjāni: The Problem of the Ptolemaic EquantJournal for the History of Arabic Science (1980) 4: 376403.

62 lstanbul University, MS Arabçe 2466, fol. 6v.

63 Ibid., fol. 7r.

64 In this context I am thinking of the work of the Ḥanbalite theologian Ibn Taymīya al-Harrānī (d. 1328) who did make such statements in his Dar' al-Ta'āruḍ Bayn al-'Aql wa-l-Naql, but this is the subject of another article.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Arabic Sciences and Philosophy
  • ISSN: 0957-4239
  • EISSN: 1474-0524
  • URL: /core/journals/arabic-sciences-and-philosophy
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed