Skip to main content
×
×
Home

Archaeology, symmetry and the ontology of things. A response to critics

  • Bjørnar Olsen and Christopher Witmore
Abstract

This article responds to recent critiques of ‘symmetrical archaeology’. It addresses three common claims: (1) that symmetrical archaeology fails to see a difference between living and non-living entities, (2) that symmetrical archaeology makes no room for humans and other living things, (3) that symmetrical archaeology lacks any sincere ethical concern for things. This article demonstrates how these claims are based on common misunderstandings or misreadings, and offers further clarifications as to its perspective on ontology, ethics and things.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Bjørnar Olsen, Department of Archaeology and Social Anthropology, UiT – the Arctic University of Norway. Email: bjornar.olsen@uit.no.
Christopher Witmore, Department of Classical and Modern Languages and Literatures, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, USA. Email: christopher.witmore@ttu.edu.
References
Hide All
Barrett, J., 2014: The material constitution of humanness, Archaeological dialogues 21 (1), 6574.
Bryant, L., 2011: The democracy of objects, Ann Arbor.
Clarke, B., 2012: Autopoiesis and the planet, in Sussman, H. (ed.), Impasses of the post-global. Theory in the era of climate change, Vol. 2, Ann Arbor, 5875.
Fowler, C., and Harris, O.J.T., 2015: Enduring relations. Exploring a paradox of new materialism, Journal of material culture 20 (2), 127–48.
Fowles, S., 2010: People without things, in Bille, M., Hastrup, F. and Sørensen, T.F. (eds), The anthropology of absence. Materializations of transcendence and loss, New York, 2341.
Graves-Brown, P., 2013: Review of In defense of things, Journal of the Royal Anthropology Institute 19, 183–84.
Hamilakis, Y., 2013: Archaeology and the senses. Human experience, memory, and affect, Cambridge.
Harman, G., 2009: Prince of networks. Bruno Latour and metaphysics, Melbourne.
Harman, G., 2012a: Weird realism. Lovecraft and philosophy, Winchester.
Harman, G., 2012b: The well-wrought broken hammer. Object-oriented literary criticism, New literary history 43, 183203.
Harman, G., 2013: Bells and whistles. More speculative realism, Winchester
Harman, G., 2014: Materialism is not the solution. On matter, form and mimesis, Nordic journal of aesthetics 47, 94110.
Hodder, I., 2012: Entangled. An archaeology of the relationships between humans and things, Malden, MA.
Ingold, T., 2012: Toward an ecology of materials, Annual review of anthropology 41, 427–42.
Latour, B., 2014: Agency in the time of the anthropocene, New literary history 45, 118.
Lingis, A., 1998: The imperative, Bloomington, IN.
Morton, T., 2013: Hyperobjects. Philosophy and ecology after the end of the world, Minneapolis.
Olsen, B., 2003: Material culture after text. Re-membering things, Norwegian archaeological review 36, 87104.
Olsen, B., 2007: Keeping things at arm's length. A genealogy of asymmetry, World archaeology 39, 579–88.
Olsen, B., 2010: In defense of things. Archaeology and the ontology of objects, Lanham, MD.
Olsen, B., 2012a: After interpretation. Remembering archaeology, Current Swedish archaeology 20, 1134.
Olsen, B., 2012b: Symmetrical archaeology, in Hodder, I. (ed.), Archaeological theory today, Cambridge, 208–28.
Olsen, B., 2013: Reclaiming things. An archaeology of matter, in Carlile, P.L., Nicolini, D., Langley, A. and Tsoukas, H. (eds), How matter matters. Objects, artifacts and materiality in organization studies, Oxford, 171–96.
Olsen, B., Shanks, M., Webmoor, T. and Witmore, C., 2012: Archaeology. The discipline of things, Berkeley, CA.
Pétursdóttir, Þ., 2012: Small things forgotten now included, or what else do things deserve? International journal of historical archaeology 16, 577603.
Pétursdóttir, Þ., 2014: Things out-of-hand. The aesthetics of abandonment, in Olsen, B. and Pétursdóttir, Þ. (eds) Ruin memories. Materiality, aesthetics and the archaeology of the recent past, London, 335–64.
Pluciennik, M., 2013: Escaping from the pen?, Archaeological dialogues 20 (2), 155–59.
Pollock, S., Bernbeck, R., Jauß, C., Greger, J., Rüden, C. von and Schreiber, S., 2014: Entangled discussions. Talking with Ian Hodder about his book Entangled, Forum kritische Archäologie 3, 151–61.
Smith, L., 2006: Uses of heritage, London.
Sørensen, T.F., 2013: We have never been Latorian. Archaeological ethics and the posthuman condition, Norwegian archaeological review 46, 118.
Thomas, J., 2015: Why ‘the death of archaeological theory’?, in Herschend, F., Hillerdal, C. and Siapkas, J. (eds), Debating archaeological empiricism, London, 11–37.
Webmoor, T., 2012: Symmetry, STS, archaeology, in Graves-Brown, P., Harrison, R. and Piccini, A. (eds.), The Oxford handbook of the archaeology of the contemporary world, Oxford, 105–20.
Webmoor, T., and Witmore, C., 2008: Things are us! A commentary on human/things relations under the banner of a ‘social’ archaeology, Norwegian archaeology review 41, 5370.
Witmore, C., 2004: On multiple fields. Between the material world and media. Two cases from the Peloponnesus, Greece, Archaeological dialogues 11 (2), 133–64.
Witmore, C., 2007: Symmetrical archaeology. Excerpts of a manifesto, World archaeology, 39, 546–62.
Witmore, C., 2011: Interview. Jonas Zakaitis talks with Christopher Witmore, The Federal 2, October, 1120.
Witmore, C., 2013: Which archaeology? A question of chronopolitics, in González-Ruibal, A. (ed.), Reclaiming archaeology. Beyond the tropes of modernity, London, 130–44.
Witmore, C., 2014: archaeology and the new materialisms, Journal of contemporary archaeology 1 (2), 122.
Witmore, C., 2015: Bovine urbanism. The ecological corpulence of Bos urbanus, in Clarke, B. (ed.), Earth, life and system. Interdisciplinary essays on environment and evolution, New York, 225–49.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Archaeological Dialogues
  • ISSN: 1380-2038
  • EISSN: 1478-2294
  • URL: /core/journals/archaeological-dialogues
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed