Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

Monument and material reuse at the National Memorial Arboretum

Abstract
Abstract

Exploring the relocation and reuse of fragments and whole artefacts, materials and monuments in contemporary commemorative memorials in the United Kingdom (UK), this paper focuses on the National Memorial Arboretum (Alrewas, Staffordshire, hereafter NMA). Within this unique assemblage of memorial gardens, reuse constitutes a distinctive range of material commemoration. Through a detailed investigation of the NMA's gardens, this paper shows how monument and material reuse, while used in very different memorial forms, tends to be reserved to commemorate specific historical subjects and themes. Monument and material reuse is identified as a form of commemorative rehabilitation for displaced memorials and provides powerful and direct mnemonic and emotional connections between past and present in the commemoration through peace memorials, of military disasters and defensive actions, the sufferings of prisoners of war, and atrocities inflicted upon civilian populations. In exploring monument and material reuse to create specific emotive and mnemonic fields and triggers, this paper engages with a hitherto neglected aspect of late 20th- and early 21st-century commemorative culture.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Howard Williams, Department of History and Archaeology, University of Chester, UK. Email: howard.williams@chester.ac.uk.
References
Hide All
Andreassen E., Bjerck H. and Olsen B., 2010: Persistent memories. Pyramiden – a Soviet mining town in the High Arctic, Trondheim.
Ashplant T.G., Dawson G. and Roper M., 2000: The politics of war memory and commemoration. Contexts, structures and dynamics, in Ashplant T.G., Dawson G. and Roper M. (eds), Commemorating war. The politics of memory, New Brunswick and London, 385.
Black J., 2004: Thanks for the memory. War memorials, spectatorship and the trajectories of commemoration 1919–2001, in Saunders N.J. (ed.), Matters of conflict. Material culture, memory and the First World War, London, 134–48.
Borić D. (ed.), 2010: Archaeology and memory, Oxford.
Bradley R., 2002: The past in prehistoric societies, London.
Bradley R.J., and Williams H. (eds), 1998: The past in the past. The reuse of ancient monuments, World archaeology 30 (1).
Brilliant R., and Kinney D. (eds), 2011: Reuse value. Spolia and appropriation in art and architecture from Constantine to Sherrie Levine, Farnham.
Buchli V., 2010: Memory, melancholy and materiality, in Borić D. (ed.), Archaeology and memory, Oxford, 204–10.
Childs D., 2008: Growing remembrance. The story of the National Memorial Arboretum, Barnsley.
Cornish P., 2004: ‘Sacred relics’: objects in the Imperial War Museum 1917–39, in Saunders N.J. (ed.), Matters of conflict. Material culture, memory and the First World War, London, 3550.
Doss E., 2007: War porn. Spectacle and seduction in contemporary American war memorials, in Schubart R., Virchow F., White-Stanley D. and Thomas T. (eds), War isn't hell, it's entertainment. Essays on visual media and the representation of conflict, London and Jefferson, NC, 1330.
Doss E., 2008: War, memory and the public mediation of affect. The National World War II Memorial and American imperialism, Memory studies 1, 227–50.
Doss E., 2010: Memory mania. Public feeling in America, Chicago.
Filippucci P., 2010: Archaeology and memory on the Western Front, in Borić D. (ed.), Archaeology and memory, Oxford, 171–82.
Gough P., 1998: Memorial gardens as dramaturgical space, International journal of heritage studies 3 (4), 119214.
Gough P., 2004: Corporations and commemoration. First World War remembrance, Lloyds TSB and the National Memorial Arboretum, International journal of heritage studies 10 (5), 435–55.
Gough P., 2009: ‘Garden of gratitude’. The National Memorial Arboretum and strategic remembering, in Ashton P. and Kean H. (eds), People and their pasts. Public history today. London, 95112.
Hamilakis Y., 2011: Archaeological ethnography. A multitemporal meeting ground for archaeology and anthropology, Annual review of anthropology 40, 399414.
Harris O., and Sørensen T.F., 2010: Rethinking emotion and material culture, Archaeological dialogues 17 (2), 145–63.
Harrison R., 2011: Surface assemblages. Towards an archaeology in and of the present, Archaeological dialogues 18 (2), 141–71.
Harrison R., and Schofield J., 2010: After modernity. Archaeological approaches to the contemporary past, Oxford.
Holtorf C., 1996: Towards a chronology of megaliths. Understanding monumental time and cultural memory, Journal of European archaeology 4, 119–52.
Holtorf C., 2003: Dyster star dösen, in Williams H. (ed.), Archaeologies of remembrance. Death and memory in past societies, Kluwer, pp. 281–99.
Holtorf C., 2005: From Stonehenge to Las Vegas. Archaeology as popular culture, Walnut Creek, CA.
Holtorf C., 2009: On the possibility of time travel, Lund archaeological review 15, 3141.
Holtorf C., 2010: The presence of pastness. Themed environments and beyond, in Schlehe J., Uike-Bormann M., Oesterle C. and Hochbruck W. (eds), Staging the past. Themed environments in transcultural perspectives, Bielefeld, 2340.
Holtorf C., and Williams H., 2006: Landscapes and memories, in Hicks D. and Beaudray M. (eds), Cambridge companion to historical archaeology, Cambridge, 235–54.
Legendre J.-P., 2001: Archaeology of World War I. The Lancaster bomber of Fléville (Meurthe-et-Moselle, France), in Buchli V. and Lucas G. (eds), Archaeologies of the contemporary past, London, 126–38.
Llillios K.T., and Tasamis V., 2010: Material mnemonics. Everyday memory in prehistoric Europe, Oxford.
Mills B., and Walker W.H. (eds), 2008: Archaeologies of material practices, Sante Fe.
Moriarty C., 1999: Review article. The material culture of Great War remembrance, Journal of contemporary history 34 (4), 653–62.
Moshenska G., 2008: A hard rain. Children's shrapnel collections in the Second World War, Journal of material culture 13 (1), 107–25.
Moshenska G., 2010: Working with memory in the field of modern conflict, Cambridge archaeological journal 20 (1), 3348.
National Memorial Arboretum (NMA), 2009: Remember. Their names will live for evermore . . . The National Memorial Arboretum. Your guide. Alrewas.
National Memorial Arboretum (NMA), 2012: National Memorial Arboretum guidebook, 4th edn, Alrewas.
Rowlands M., 1999: Remembering to forget. Sublimation as sacrifice in war memorials, in Forty A. and Küchler S. (eds), The art of forgetting, Oxford, 129–45.
Saunders N.J., 2003: Crucifix, calvary, and cross. Materiality and spirituality in Great War landscapes, World archaeology 35 (1), 721.
Saunders N.J., 2007: Killing time. The archaeology of the First World War, Stroud.
Sørensen T.F., 2010: A saturated void. Anticipating and preparing presence in contemporary Danish cemetery culture, in Bille M., Hastrup F. and Sørensen T.F. (eds), An anthropology of absence, New York, 115–30.
Thäte E.S., 2007: Monuments and minds. Monument re-use in Scandinavia in the second half of the first millennium AD, Lund (Acta Archaeologica Lundensia Series in 4° No 27).
Van Dyke R., and Alcock S. (eds), 2003: Archaeologies of memory, Oxford.
Walls S., and Williams H., 2010: Death and memory on the home front. Second World War commemoration in the South Hams, Devon, Cambridge archaeological journal 20 (1), 4966.
Williams H., 1997: Ancient landscapes and the dead. The reuse of prehistoric and Roman monuments as early Anglo-Saxon burial sites, Medieval archaeology 41, 131.
Williams H. (ed.), 2003: Archaoelogies of remembrance. Death and memory in past societies, New York.
Williams H., 2011: Archaeologists on contemporary death, Mortality 16 (2), 9197.
Williams H., 2012: Ash and antiquity. Archaeology and cremation in contemporary Sweden, in Jones A.M., Pollard J., Allen M.J. and Gardiner J. (eds), Image, memory and monumentality. Archaeological engagements with the material world, Oxford, 207–17.
Williams H., 2013: Antiquity at the National Memorial Arboretum, International journal of heritage studies 20 (4), DOI: 10.1080/13527258.2012.757556.
Young J.E., 1993: The texture of memory, New Haven.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Archaeological Dialogues
  • ISSN: 1380-2038
  • EISSN: 1478-2294
  • URL: /core/journals/archaeological-dialogues
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords:

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 10
Total number of PDF views: 36 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 212 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 19th October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.