Skip to main content

Talk about the passion


We would like to thank the five commentators for their thorough and stimulating reflections on, and criticism of, our article. The different comments raise various issues, and we appreciate their diversity of perspectives and their analysis of problems in our attempt at a rethinking of emotion in archaeology. The comments are each in their own way highly rewarding for us, and they certainly bring concerns to the fore that we have left out. Here we identify several issues that the commentators address in different voices and with varying intensities, and would like to examine these in turn. First, we consider the question of ritual at Mount Pleasant and the absence of the quotidian from our account. Second, we engage with the worry expressed over the lack of specificity of emotions in our given scenarios. Third, the phenomenological perspective in our article is given some critical thought. Fourth, we address the important point on which several of the commentators agree: that we leave out how emotions unfold in historically specific and context-dependent situations. Finally we turn back to the issue of our vocabulary to see how it stands the test of both application and critique.

Hide All
Abdi K., 2001: Nationalism, politics, and the development of archaeology in Iran, American journal of archaeology 105, 5176.
Ahmed S., 2004: The cultural politics of emotion, London.
Armstrong R.P., 1971: The affecting presence. An essay in humanistic anthropology, Urbana, IL.
Barber M., 2004: Mount Pleasant from the air, Proceedings of the Dorset Natural History and Archaeology Society 126, 714.
Barber M., 2005: Mount Pleasant, Dorchester. Cropmarks old and new, Past. The newsletter of the Prehistoric Society 49, 57.
Barkan L., 1999: Unearthing the past. Archaeology and aesthetics in the making of Renaissance culture, New Haven.
Barrett J., 1994: Fragments from antiquity. An archaeology of social life in Britain, 2900–1200 BC, Oxford.
Barrett J.C., 2001: Agency, the duality of structure, and the problem of the archaeological record, in Hodder I. (ed.), Archaeological theory today, Cambridge, 141–64.
Bateson G., 1986: Naven, Stanford.
Battaglia D., 1990: On the bones of the serpent. Person, memory and mortality in Sabarl Island society, Chicago.
Bell C., 1992: Ritual theory, ritual practice, Oxford.
Bell C., 1997: Ritual. Perspectives and dimensions, Oxford.
Bender B. and Winer M. (eds), 2001: Contested landscapes. Movement, exile and place, Oxford.
Bennett T. and Joyce P. (eds), 2010: Material powers. Cultural studies, history and the material turn, London.
Berggren Å., forthcoming. Med kärret som källa. Om begreppen offer och ritual inom arkeologin, Lund: Nordic Academic Press (Vägar till Midgård 13).
Bille M., Hastrup F. and Sørensen T.F., 2010: Introduction, in Bille M., Hastrup F. and Sørensen T.F. (eds), An anthropology of absence. Materializations of transcendence and loss, New York.
Bock P., 1999: Psychological anthropology. Continuity and change in the study of human action, Prospect Heights, IL.
Böhme G., 1992: Atmosphere as the fundamental concept of a new aesthetics, Thesis eleven 36, 113–26.
Bollnow O.F., 1963: Mensch und Raum, Stuttgart.
Bourdieu P., 1973: The Berber house, in Douglas M. (ed.), Rules and meanings, Harmondsworth, 98110.
Bourdieu P., 1993: The field of cultural production. Essays on art and literature, New York.
Bradley R., 1975: Maumbury Rings, Dorchester. The excavations of 1908–13, Archaeologia 105, 197.
Bradley R., 2000: An archaeology of natural places, London.
Bradley R., 2003: A life less ordinary. The ritualization of the domestic sphere in Later Prehistoric Europe, Cambridge archaeological journal 13 (1), 523.
Bradley R., 2005: Ritual and domestic life in Prehistoric Europe, New York.
Brown B., 2003: A sense of things. The object matter of American literature, Chicago.
Brück J., 1998: In the footsteps of the ancestors, a review of Christopher Tilley's ‘A phenomenology of landscape: places, paths, monuments’, Archaeological review from Cambridge 15, 2336.
Brück J., 1999: Ritual and rationality. Some problems of interpretation in European archaeology, European journal of archaeology 2, 313–44.
Brück J., 2001: Monuments, power and personhood in the British Neolithic. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 7 (4), 649–67.
Brück J., 2005. Experiencing the past? The development of a phenomenological archaeology in British prehistory, Archaeological dialogues 12 (1), 4572.
Case H., 1993: Beakers. Deconstruction and after, Proceeding of the Prehistoric Society 59, 241–68.
Classen C., 1993: Worlds of sense. Exploring senses in history and across cultures. London.
Cleal R.M.J., 1999: Introduction. The what, where, when and why of grooved ware, in Cleal R.M.J. and MacSween A. (eds), Grooved ware in Britain and Ireland, Oxford, 18.
Clough A.T. and Halley J. (eds), 2007: The affective turn. Theorizing the social, London.
Comaroff J. and Comaroff J., 1991: Of revelation and revolution, Volume 1, Chicago.
Damasio A.R., 1996: Descartes’ error. Emotion, reason and the human brain, London.
Damasio A.R., 1999: The feeling of what happens. Body and emotion in the making of consciousness, Berkeley, CA.
Davidson J., Bondi L. and Smith M. (eds), 2005: Emotional geographies, Aldershot.
Davies S.M., Bellamy P.S., Heaton M.J. and Woodward P.J., 2002: Excavations at Alington Avenue, Fordington, Dorchester, Dorset, 1984–7, Dorchester.
De Certeau M., 1988: The practice of everyday life, Berkeley, CA.
Deleuze G., 1983: Cinema 1. The movement image, London.
Dietler M., 1994: ‘Our ancestors the Gauls’. Archaeology, ethnic nationalism, and the manipulation of Celtic identity in modern Europe, American anthropologist 96 (3), 584605.
Dolan R.J., 2002: Emotion, cognition, and behavior, Science new series 298 (5596), 1191–94.
Durkheim E., 1965 (1915): The elementary forms of religious life, New York.
Ekman P., 1980: The face of Man. Expressions of universal emotions in a New Guinea village, New York.
Fernandez J., 1965: Symbolic consensus in a Fang reformative cult, American anthropologist 67, 902–29.
Fernandez J., 1986: Persuasions and performances. The play of tropes in culture, Bloomington.
Fogelin L., 2007: The archaeology of religious ritual, Annual review of anthropology 36, 5571.
Fogelin L., 2008: Delegitimizing religion. The archaeology of religion as . . . archaeology?, in Whitley D.S. and Hays-Gilpin K. (eds), Belief in the past. Theoretical approaches to the archaeology of religion, Walnut Creek, CA, 129–42.
Forty A., 1995: Objects of desire. Design and society since 1750, London.
Fowler C., 2000: The individual, the subject, and archaeological interpretation. Reading Luce Irigaray and Judith Butler, in Holtorf C. and Karlsson H. (eds), Philosophy and archaeological practice. Perspectives for the 21st century, Gothenburg, 107–33.
Gell A., 1998: Art and agency. An anthropological theory, Oxford.
Gerholm T., 1988: On ritual. A postmodernist view, Ethnos 53, 190203.
Gibson A., 2004: Round in circles. Timber circles, henges and stone circles: some possible relations and transformation, in Cleal R.M.J. and Pollard J. (eds), Monuments and material culture. Papers in honour of an Avebury archaeologist: Isobel Smith, Salisbury, 7882.
Goody J., 1977: Against ritual. Loosely structured thoughts on a loosely defined topic, in Moore S.F. and Myerhoff B.G. (eds), Secular ritual, New York, 2535.
Goody J., 1988: The interface between the written and the oral, Cambridge.
Goody J., 1989: The logic of writing and the organization of society, Cambridge.
Gosden C., 2004: Aesthetics, intelligence, and emotions. Implications for archaeology, in Demarrais E., Gosden C. and Renfrew C. (eds), Rethinking materiality. The engagement of mind with the material world, 3340, Cambridge (McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research Vols.).
Gosden C., 2005: What do objects want? Journal of archaeological method and theory 12 (3), 193211.
Handelman D. and Lindquist G. (eds), 2004: Ritual in its own right, New York.
Harré R. (ed.), 1986: The social construction of emotions, Oxford.
Harris O.J.T., 2006: Identity, memory and emotion in Neolithic Dorset, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, School of History and Archaeology, Cardiff University.
Harris O.J.T., 2009: Making places matter in Early Neolithic Dorset, Oxford journal of archaeology 28 (2), 111–23.
Harris O.J.T., in press: Emotional and mnemonic geographies at Hambledon Hill. Texturing Neolithic places with bodies and bones. Cambridge archaeological journal 20 (3).
Hawkes C., 1954: Archaeological theory and method. Some suggestions from the Old World, American anthropologist 56 (2),155–68.
Heidegger M., 1962: Being and time, New York.
Henare A.,Holbraad M. and Wastell S., 2007: Thinking through things, in Henare A., Holbraad M. and Wastell S. (eds), Thinking through things. Theorising artefacts ethnographically. London, 131.
Hinton A., 1993: Prolegomenon to a processual approach to the emotions, Ethos 21 (4), 417–51.
Hodder I. and Hutson S., 2003: Reading the past. Current approaches to interpretation in archaeology, Cambridge.
Holbraad M., 2007: The power of powder. Multiplicity and motion in the divinatory cosmology of Cuban Ifá (or mana, again), in Henare A., Holbraad M. and Wastell S. (eds), Thinking through things. Theorising artefacts ethnographically. London, 189225.
Holland D.,Lachicotte W. Jr., Skinner D. and Cain C., 1998: Identity and agency in cultural worlds, Cambridge, MA.
Houseman M. and Severi C., 1998: Naven or the other self. A relational approach to ritual action, Leiden.
Howe D. (ed.) 1991: The varieties of sensory experience. A sourcebook in the anthropology of the senses, Toronto.
Humphrey C. and Laidlaw J., 1994: The archetypical actions of ritual. A theory of ritual illustrated by the Jain rite of worship, Oxford.
Inomata T. and Coben L.S. (eds), 2006: Archaeology of performance. Theaters of power, community, and politics, New York.
James W., 1884: What is an emotion?, Mind 9 (34), 188205.
James W., 1890: Principles of psychology, Vols. 1 and 2, New York.
Johnson M., 2006: On the nature of theoretical archaeology and archaeological theory, Archaeological dialogues 13 (2), 117–82.
Jones A., 2002: Archaeological theory and scientific practice, Cambridge.
Jones A., 2007: Memory and material culture, Cambridge.
Kertzer D.I., 1988: Ritual, politics, and power, New Haven.
Khatchadourian L., 2008: Making nations from the ground up. Traditions of classical archaeology in the South Caucasus, American journal of archaeology 112 (2), 247–78.
Kinnes I.A.,Gibson A.M., Ambers J., Bowman S., Leese M. and Boast R., 1991: Radiocarbon dating and British beakers. The British Museum programme. Scottish archaeological review 8, 3568.
Köepping K-P., 1997: The ludic as creative disorder. Framing, de-framing, and boundary crossing, in Köepping K-P. (ed.), The games of god and man. Essays in play and performance, Hamburg.
Kohl P.L. and Fawcett C.P., 1995: Nationalism, politics, and the practice of archaeology, Cambridge.
Kus S., 1992: Towards an archaeology of body and soul, in Gardin J.-C. and Peebles C. (eds), Representations in archaeology, Bloomington, 168–77.
Kus S., 2006: In the midst of the moving waters. Material, metaphor and feminist archaeology, in Stockett M. and Geller P. (eds), Feminist anthropology. Present, past, and future, University Park, PA, 105–19.
Kus S. and Raharijaona V., 1998: Between Earth and Sky there are only a few large boulders. Sovereignty and monumentality in Central Madagascar, Journal of anthropological archaeology 17, 5379.
Kyriakidis E. (ed.), 2007: The archaeology of ritual, Los Angeles.
Latour B., 1993: We have never been modern, New York.
Leavitt J., 1996: Meaning and feeling in the anthropology of emotions, American ethnologist 23 (3), 514–39.
Leder D., 1990: The absent body, Chicago.
Leroi-Gourhan A., 1964–65: Le Geste et la parole, 2 vols., Paris.
Levine R., 1999: An agenda for psychological anthropology, Ethos 27 (2), 1524.
Levi-Strauss C., 1962: La Pensée sauvage, Paris.
Levy R., 1973: Tahitians. Mind and experience in the Society Islands, Chicago.
Lewis G., 1980: Day of shining red. An essay on understanding ritual, Cambridge.
Löfgren O., 2008: Motion and emotion. Learning to be a railway traveller, Mobilities 3 (3), 331–51.
Longworth I.H., 1979: The Neolithic and Bronze Age pottery, in Wainwright G.J. (ed.), Mount Pleasant, Dorset. Excavations 1970–1971, London, 75124.
Lupton D., 1998: The emotional self, London.
Lutz C., 1988: Unnatural emotions. Everyday sentiments on a Micronesian atoll and their challenge to Western theory, Chicago.
Lutz C. and Abu-Lughod L. (eds), 1990: Language and the politics of emotions, Cambridge.
Lutz C. and White G.M., 1986: The anthropology of emotions, Annual review of anthropology 15, 405–36.
Maschio T., 1998: The narrative and counter-narrative of the gift. Emotional dimensions of ceremonial exchange in southwestern New Britain, Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 4 (1), 83100.
Massumi B., 2002: Parables for the virtual. Movement, affect, sensation, London.
Mauss M., 2002 (1923): The gift. The form and reason for exchange in archaic societies, London.
Meskell L., 1996. The somatization of archaeology. Institutions, discourses, corporality. Norwegian archaeological review 29 (1), 116.
Meskell L., 1998. Intimate archaeologies. The case of Kha and Merit. World archaeology 29 (3), 363–79.
Meskell L., 1999: Archaeologies of social life. Age, sex, et cetera in ancient Egypt, Oxford.
Meskell L., 2004: Object worlds in ancient Egypt. Material biographies past and present. London: Berg.
Middleton D., 1989: Emotional style. The cultural ordering of emotions, Ethos, 17 (2), 187201.
Miller D., 2005: Materiality. An introduction, in Miller D. (ed.), Materiality, Durham, 150.
Milton K. and Svašek M. (eds), 2007: Mixed emotions. Anthropological studies of feeling, Oxford.
Needham S., 2005: Transforming Beaker culture in north-west Europe. Processes of fusion and fission, Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 71, 171217.
Ngai S., 2005: Ugly feelings, Cambridge, MA.
Nilsson Stutz L., 2003. Embodied rituals & ritualized bodies. Tracing ritual practices in late Mesolithic burials, Stockholm (Acta Archaeologica Lundensia, No. 46).
Noble G., 2006: Neolithic Scotland. Timber, stone, earth and fire, Edinburgh.
Ong W., 1982: Orality and literacy. Technologizing the word, London.
Ong W., 1991: The shifting sensorium, in Howe D. (ed.), The varieties of sensory experience. A sourcebook in the anthropology of the senses, Toronto, 2530.
Overing J. and Passes A. (eds), 2000: The anthropology of love and anger. The aesthetics of conviviality in native Amazonia, London.
Panksepp J., 1998: Affective neuroscience. The foundations of human and animal emotions, Oxford (Series in Affective Science).
Parker Pearson M., 2007: The Stonehenge riverside project. Excavations at the east entrance of Durrington Walls, in Larsson M. and Pearson M. Parker (eds), From Stonehenge to the Baltic. Living with cultural diversity in the third millennium BC, Oxford, 125–44.
Parrott F.R., 2005: ‘It's not forever’. The material culture of hope, Journal of material culture 10 (3), 245–62.
Pitts M., 2001: Excavating the Sanctuary. New investigations on Overton Hill, Avebury, Wiltshire archaeological and natural history magazine 94, 123.
Pollard J. and Robinson D.E., 2007: A return to Woodhenge, in Larsson M. and Pearson M. Parker (eds), From Stonehenge to the Baltic. Living with cultural diversity in the third millennium BC, Oxford, 159–68.
Pollard J., 1992: The Sanctuary, Overton Hill, Wiltshire. A re-examination. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 58, 213–26.
Pollard J., 2001: The aesthetics of depositional practice, World archaeology 33, 315–33.
Probyn E., 2005: Blush. Faces of shame. Minneapolis, MN.
Pryor F., 1998: Etton. Excavations at a Neolithic causewayed enclosure near Maxey, Cambridgeshire, 1982–7, London.
Radin P., 1957: Primitive man as philosopher, New York.
Raharijaona V. and Kus S., 2000: Where to begin a house foundation. Betsileo ‘mpanandro’ and the (re)creation of tradition, in Allibert C. and Rajaonarimanana N. (eds.), L'Extraordinaire et le quotidien. Variations anthropologiques, Paris, 135–44.
Ratcliffe M., 2002: Heidegger's attunement and the neuropsychology of emotion, Phenomenology and the cognitive sciences 1 (3), 287312.
Ratcliffe M., 2008: Feelings of being. Phenomenology, psychiatry and the sense of reality, Oxford.
Reddy W.M., 2001: Navigation of feeling. A framework for the history of emotions, Cambridge.
Renfrew C., 1973: Monuments, mobilization, and social organization in Neolithic Wessex, in Renfrew C. (ed.), The explanation of culture change. Models in prehistory, London, 539–58.
Renfrew C., 1994: The archaeology of religion, in Renfrew C. (ed.), The ancient mind, Cambridge, 4754.
Richard A. and Rudnyckyj D., 2009: Economies of affect, Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 15 (1), 5777.
Rosaldo M.Z., 1984: Toward an anthropology of self and feeling, in Shweder R.A. and LeVine R.A. (eds), Culture theory. Essays on mind, self, and emotion, Cambridge, 137–57.
Runia E., 2006: Presence. History and theory 45 (February), 129.
Seremetakis C.N., 1991: The last word. Women, death, and divination in Inner Mani, Chicago.
Sheets-Johnstone M., 1999: Emotion and movement. A beginning empirical–phenomenological analysis of their relationship, Journal of consciousness studies 6 (11–12), 259–77.
Sheller M., 2004: Automotive emotions. Feeling the car. Theory, culture & society 21 (4–5), 221–42.
Shore B., 1993: Emotion: Culture, psychology, biology, Ethos 21 (3), 357–63.
Shweder R., 1999: Why cultural psychology? Ethos 27 (1), 6273.
Simonsen K., 2007: Practice, spatiality and embodied emotions. An outline of a geography of practice, Human affairs 17, 168–81.
Smith J.Z., 1982: Imagining religion from Babylon to Jonestown, Chicago.
Smith R.J.C.,Healy F., Allen M.J., Morris E.L., Barnes I. and Woodward P.J., 1997: Excavations along the route of the Dorchester by-pass, Dorset, 1986–8, Salisbury.
Sørensen T.F., 2009: The presence of the dead. Cemeteries, cremation and the staging of non-place, Journal of social archaeology 9 (1), 110–35.
Sørensen T.F., 2010. An archaeology of movement. Materiality, affects and cemeteries in prehistoric and contemporary Odsherred, Denmark, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Aarhus.
Stets J.E. and Turner J.H. (eds), 2006: Handbook of the sociology of emotions, New York.
Stewart K., 2007: Ordinary affects, Durham, NC.
Swenson E., 2008: The disjunctive approach to the archaeological analysis of ritual politics, in Fogelin L., Religion, archaeology, and the material world, Carbdondale, IL, 237–60.
Tambiah S.J., 1979: A performative approach to ritual, Proceedings of the British Academy 65, 113–69.
Tarlow S., 1999: Bereavement and commemoration. An archaeology of mortality, Oxford.
Tarlow S., 2000: Emotion in archaeology, Current anthropology 41 (5), 713–46.
Thoits P.A., 1989: The sociology of emotions, Annual review of sociology 15, 317–42.
Thomas J., 1996: Time, culture and identity. An interpretive archaeology, London.
Thomas J., 1999: Understanding the Neolithic, London.
Thomas J., 2000: The identity of place in Neolithic Britain. Examples from Southwest Scotland, in Ritchie A. (ed.), Neolithic Orkney in its European context, Cambridge.
Thomas J., 2002: Archaeology's humanism and the materiality of the body, in Hamilakis Y., Pluciennik M. and Tarlow S. (eds), Thinking through the body. Archaeologies of corporeality. London, 2945.
Thomas J., 2007: The internal features at Durrington Walls. Investigations in the southern and western enclosures 2005–6, in Larsson M. and Parker M. Pearson (eds), From Stonehenge to the Baltic. Living with cultural diversity in the third millennium BC, Oxford, 145–57.
Thomas J., 2010: The return of the Rinyo-Clacton folk? The cultural significance of the Grooved Ware complex in later Neolithic Britain. Cambridge archaeological journal 20 (1), 115.
Treherne P., 1995: The warrior's beauty. The masculine body and self-identity in Bronze-Age Europe, Journal of European archaeology 3, 105–44.
Tuan Y.-F., 1974: Topophilia. A study of environmental perception, attitudes, and values, Englewood.
Turnbull C., 1978: The politics of non-aggression (Zaire), in Montague A. (ed.), Learning non-aggression. The experience of non-literate societies, New York, 161221.
Turner V., 1967: The forest of symbols. Aspects of Ndembu ritual, Ithaca, NY.
Turner V., 1982: From ritual to theatre. The human seriousness of play, New York.
Van Dyke R.M., 2009: Chaco reloaded. Discursive social memory on the post-Chacoan landscape, Journal of social archaeology, 9 (2), 220–48.
Wainwright G.J., 1979: Mount Pleasant, Dorset. Excavations 1970–1971, London.
Webmoor T. and Witmore C.L., 2008: Things are us! A commentary on human/things relations under the banner of a ‘social archaeology’. Norwegian archaeological review 41 (1), 118.
Whittle A., 2005: Lived experience in the Early Neolithic of the Great Hungarian Plain, in Bailey D., Whittle A. and Cummings V. (eds), (Un)Settling the Neolithic, Oxford, 6470.
Wierzbicka A., 2003: Emotion and culture. Arguing with Martha Nussbaum, Ethos 31 (4), 577600.
Woodward A., 2002: Beads and beakers. Heirlooms and relics in the British Early Bronze Age, Antiquity 76, 1040–47.
Woodward P.J., Davies S.M. and Graham A.H., 1993: Excavations at the old Methodist chapel and Greyhound Yard, Dorchester 1981–1984, Dorchester.
Zumthor P., 2006: Atmospheres. Architectural environments, surrounding objects, Basel.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Archaeological Dialogues
  • ISSN: 1380-2038
  • EISSN: 1478-2294
  • URL: /core/journals/archaeological-dialogues
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 2
Total number of PDF views: 24 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 88 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 20th November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.