Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

Dominance: The baby and the bathwater

  • Irwin S. Bernstein (a1)

The concept of dominance is used in the behavioral and biological sciences to describe outcomes in a variety of competitive interactions. In some taxa, a history of agonistic encounters among individuals modifies the course of future agonistic encounters such that the existence of a certain type of relationship can be inferred. If one is to characterize such relationships as dominance, however, then they must be distinguished from other kinds of interaction patterns for which the term tends to be used, as well as from factors such as territoriality and "trained" winners and losers, which may also influence the expression of agonistic behavior. Operational definitions based on causal, functional, evolutionary, and ontogenetic considerations have been proposed. Reliability and validity problems have been discussed, but the dominance concept has proved useful despite methodological difficulties. The confusion of dominance relationships (which involve two or more individuals) with dominance ranks (which are assigned to a single individual) has obscured the possible evolutionary basis of dominance relationships. If benefits accrue to dominant members of pairs, then those attributes which allow an animal to establish dominance can be selected. Dominance per se and dominance ranks, on the other hand, cannot be genetically transmitted since they constitute relationships with other individuals rather than absolute attributes. Dominance rankings in particular may be useful for describing behavioral patterns within a group, but they may reflect our own ability to count rather than any important variable in social organization.

Hide All
V. Abernethy (1978) Feminists' heterosexual relationships. Archives of General Psychiatry 35:435–38. [VA]

S. A. Altmann (1962a) A field study of the sociobiology of rhesus monkeys, Macaca mulatta. Annals of New York Academy of Science 102:338435. [PEM]

C. O. Anderson & W. A. Mason (1978) Competitive social strategies in groups of deprived and experienced rhesus monkeys. Developmental Psychobiology 11:289–99. [ISB]

D. Benton ; J. F. Goldsmith ; L. Gamal-el-Din ; P. F. Brain ; & F. H. Hucklebridge (1978) Adrenal activity in isolated mice and mice of different social status. Physiology and Behaviour 20:459–64. [PFB]

D. Benton ; J. C. Dalrymple-Alford ; & P. F. Brain (1980) Comparisons of measures of dominance in the laboratory mouse. Animal Behaviour 28:1274–79. [PFB]

I. S. Bernstein (1964) Role of the dominant male rhesus in response to external challenges to the group. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 57:404–6. [ISB]

R. J. Blanchard & D. C. Blanchard (1980) The colony model: Experience counts. Behavioral and Neural Biology 30:109–12. [KJF]

R. J. Blanchard ; D. C. Blanchard ; T. Takahashi ; & M. J. Kelley (1977) Attack and defensive behavior in the albino rat. Animal Behaviour 25:622–34. [PFB, KJF]

R. C. Boelkins (1967) Determination of dominance hierarchies in monkeys. Psychonomic Science 7:317–18. [ISB]

P. F. Brain (1981b) Hormones and aggression in infra-human vertebrates. In: The Biology of aggression, ed. P. F. Brain & D. Benton . Alphen aan der Rijn: Noordhoff/Sijthoff. [PFB]

P. F. Brain & S. Al-Maliki (1978) A comparison of "intermale fighting" in "standard opponent" tests and attack directed towards locusts by "TO" strain mice: Effects of simple experimental manipulations. Animal Behaviour 26:723–37. [PFB]

P. F. Brain & S. Al-Maliki (1979) A comparison of effects of simple experimental manipulations on fighting generated by breeding activity and predatory aggresion in "TO" strain mice. Behaviour 69:183200. [PFB]

P. Buirski ; H. Kellerman ; R. Plutchik ; R. Weininger ; & N. Buirski (1973) A field study of emotions, dominance and social behavior in a group of baboons (Papio anubis). Primates 14:6778. [ISB]

B. N. Bunnell ; D. R. Kenshalo Jr; J. D. Allen ; F. J. Manning ; & F. J. Sodetz (1979) Performance correlates of social behavior and organization: Social rank and omission of reinforcement in rhesus monkeys (M. mulatto). Primates 20:7786. [ISB]

D. Candland ; L. Dresdale ; J. Leiphart ; D. Bryan ; C. Johnson ; & B. Nazar (1973) Social structure of the squirrel monkey (Saimiri sciureus iquitos): Relationships among behavior, heartrate, and physical distance. Folia Primatological 20:211–40. [JRK]

C. R. Carpenter (1942) Characteristics of social behavior in nonhuman primates. Transactions of the New York Academy of Sciences 4:248–58. [ISB]

A. S. Chamove & R. E. Bowman (1976) Rank, rhesus social behavior, and stress. Folia Primatologica 26:5766. [JRK]

M. R. A. Chance (1956) Social structure of a colony of Macaca mulatto. British Journal of Animal Behavior 4:113. [PEM]

I. D. Chase (1974) Models of hierarchy formation in animal societies. Behavioral Science 19:374–82. [RP]

D. L. Cheney (1977) The acquisition of rank and the development of reciprocal alliances among free-ranging immature baboons. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 2:303–18. [DKC]

D. L. Cheney (1978b) The play partners of immature baboons. Animal Behaviour 26:1038–50. [RMS]

S. B. Christopher (1972) Social validation of an objective measure of dominance in captive monkeys. Behavior Research Methods and Instrumentation 4:1920. [ISB]

M. M. Clark & B. G. Galef Jr. (1977) Patterns of agonistic interaction and space utilization by agoutis (Dasyproeta punctata): A brief report. Behavioral Biology 20:135–40. [PFB]

N. E. Collias (1944) Aggressive behavior among vertebrate animals. Physiological Zoology 17:83123. [DSS]

J. G. Corrigan & K. J. Flannelly (1979) Ultrasonic vocalizations of defeated male rats. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology 93:105–15. [KJF]

C. Darwin (1872) The expression of the emotions in man and the animals. London: John Murray. [DSS]

J. C. DeFries & G. F. McClearn (1970) Social dominance and Darwinian fitness in the laboratory mouse. American Naturalist 104:408–11. [PFB]

L. C. Drickamer (1974) Social rank, observability, and sexual behavior of rhesus monkeys (Macaco mulatto). Journal of Reproductive Fertility 37:117–20. [ISB]

R. I. M. Dunbar & E. P. Dunbar (1977) Dominance and reproductive success among female gelada baboons. Nature (London) 266:351–52. [ISB]

S. W. Duvall ; I. S. Bernstein ; & T. P. Gordon (1976) Paternity and status in a rhesus monkey group. Journal of Reproduction and Fertility 47:2531. [JRK]

G. G. Eaton (1974) Male dominance and aggression in Japanese macaque reproduction. In: Reproductive behavior, ed. W. Montagna & W. A. Sadler , pp. 287–97. New York: Plenum Press. [GGE]

G. G. Eaton & J. A. Resko (1974) Plasma testosterone and male dominance in a Japanese macaque (Macaco fuscata) troop compared with repeated measures of testosterone in laboratory males. Hormones and Behavior 5:251–59. [ISB]

P. W. Ewald & S. Rohwer (1980) Age, coloration and dominance in non-breeding hummingbirds: A test of the asymmetry hypothesis. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology 7:273–79. [SAG]

R. Ewer (1968) Ethology of mammals. London: Logos Press Limited. [JRK]

L. Fairbanks (1980) Relationships among adult females in captive vervet monkeys: Testing a model of rank-related attractiveness. Animal Behaviour 28:853–59. [RMS]

F. H. Gage (1978) A multivariate approach to the analysis of social dominance. Behavioral Biology 23:3851. [FHG]

F. H. Gage & A. F. Lieberman (1978) A multivariate analysis of social dominance in children. Aggressive Behavior 4:219–29. [FHG]

J. S. Gartlan (1968) Structure and function in primate society. Folia Primatologica 8:89120. [ISB]

S. A. Gauthreaux Jr. (1978) The ecological significance of behavioral dominance. In: Perspectives in ethology, ed. P. P. G. Bateson and P. H. Klopfer , pp. 1754. New York: Plenum Press. [ISB, SAG]

H. Gouzoules (1974) Harrassment of sexual behavior in the stumptail macaque, Macaca arctoides. Folia Primatologica 22:208–17. [RMS]

R. Green ; R. E. Whalen ; B. Rutley ; & C. Battie (1972) Dominance hierarchy in squirrel monkeys (Saimiri sciureus). Role of the gonads and androgen on genital display and feeding order. Folia Primatologica 18:185–95. [ISB]

R. S. O. Harding (1980) Agonism, ranking, and the social behavior of adult male baboons. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 53:203–16. [BS]

R. A. Hinde (1978) Dominance and role: Two concepts with dual meanings. Journal of Social Biology Structure 1:2738. [ISB, GGE, RAH]

P. Jay (1965) Field studies. In: Behavior of nonhuman primates, ed. A. M. Schrier , H. F. Harlow & F. Stollnitz , pp. 525–92. New York: Academic Press. [ISB]

E. B. Keverne ; R. A. Leonard ; D. M. Scruton ; & S. K. Young (1978) Visual monitoring in social groups of talapoin monkeys (Miopithecus talapoin). Animal Behaviour 26:933–44. [ISB]

H. G. Landau (1951) On dominance relations and the structure of animal societies: I. Effect of inherent characteristics. Bulletin of Mathematical Biophysics 13:119. [DKC]

A. I. Leshner & D. K. Candland (1972) Endocrine effects of grouping and dominance rank in squirrel monkeys. Physiology and Behavior 8:441–45. [JRK]

G. Lindzey ; H. Winston ; & M. Manosevitz (1961) Social dominance in inbred mouse strains. Nature (London) 191:474–76. [PFB]

D. F. Lott (1979) Dominance relations and breeding rate in mature male American bison. Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie 49:418–32. [DFL]

K. Manogue ; A. I. Leshner ; & D. K. Candland (1975) Dominance status and adrenocortical reactivity to stress in squirrel monkeys (Saimiri sciureus). Primates 16:457–63. [JRK]

R. Maroney & R. Leary (1957) A failure to condition submission in monkeys. Psychological Reports 3:472. [KJF]

A. H. Maslow (1940) Dominance quality and social behavior in infrahuman primates. Journal of Social Psychology 11:313–24. [ISB]

P. E. Maxim (1972) Behavioral Effects of telestimulating hypothalamic reinforcement sites in freely moving rhesus monkeys. Brain Research 42:243–62. [PEM]

P. E. Maxim (1977) Self-stimulation of a hypothalamic site in response to tension or fear. Physiology and Behavior 18:197201. [PEM]

P. E. Maxim (1978b) Quantitative analysis of small group interaction in rhesus monkeys. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 48:283–95. [ISB, KJF, PEM]

R. M. May (1971) Some mathematical remarks on the paradox of voting. Behavioral Science 16:143–51. [PSP]

A. Mazur (1973) A cross-species comparison of status in small established groups. American Sociological Review 38:513–30. [ISB, KJF]

A. Mazur (1976) Effects of testosterone on status in primate groups. Folia Primatologica 26:214–26. [ISB]

M. D. Morris & C. A. McMahan (1980) A note on the dominance hierarchy index. Bulletin of Mathematical Biology. 42:739–46. [CAB]

R. G. Niemi & W. H. Riker (1976) The choice of voting systems. Scientific American 234(6):2127. [PSP]

G. A. Parker (1974) Assessment strategy and the evolution of fighting behaviour. Journal of Theoretical Biology 47:223–43. [SAG]

J. D. Paterson (1973) Ecologically different patterns of aggressive and sexual behavior in two troops of Ugandan baboons, Papio anubis. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 38:641–47. [ISB, SAG]

P. S. Petraitis (1979) Competitive networks and measures of intransitivity. American Naturalist 114:921–25. (GGE]

R. Plutchik (1980b) A general psychoevolutionary theory of emotion. In: Theories of Emotion, ed. R. Plutchik & H. Kellerman . New York: Academic Press. [RP]

V. Reinhardt (1973) Beiträge zur sozialen Rangordnung und Melkordnung bei Kühen. Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie 32:281–92. [DKC]

M. W. Schein & M. H. Fohrman (1955) Social dominance relationships in a herd of dairy cattle. British Journal of Animal Behaviour 3:4555. [CAB]

J. P. Scott (1948) Dominance and the frustration-aggression hypothesis. Physiological Zoology 21:31 -39. [ DKC]

J. P. Scott (1971) Theoretical issues concerning the origin and causes of fighting. In: The physiology of aggression and defeat, ed. B. E. Eleftheriou & J. P. Scott , pp. 1141. New York: Plenum Press. [SHV]

R. M. Seyfarth (1976) Social relationships among adult female baboons. Animal Behaviour 24:917–38. [ISB, GGE, RMS]

R. M. Seyfarth (1980) The distribution of grooming and related behaviors among adult female vervet monkeys. Animal Behaviour 28:798813. [GGE, RMS]

H. H. Swanson & M. R. Lockley (1978) Population growth and social structure in confined colonies of Mongolian gerbils: Scent gland size and marking behaviour as indices of social status. Aggressive Behavior 4:5789. [PFB]

G. C. Wagner ; L. G. Beauving ; & R. Hutchinson (1979) Androgen dependency of aggressive target-biting and paired fighting in male mice. Physiology and Behavior 22:4346. [PFB]

R. Haven Wiley & S. A. Hartnett (1980) Mechanisms of spacing in groups of juncos: Measurement of behavioral tendencies in social situations. Animal Behaviour 28:1005–16. [RMS]

R. M. Yerkes (1940) Social behavior of chimpanzees. Dominance between mates, in relation to sex status. Journal of Comparative Psychology 30:147–86. [ISB]

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • ISSN: 0140-525X
  • EISSN: 1469-1825
  • URL: /core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 40 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 995 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.