Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa

The evolution of misbelief

  • Ryan T. McKay (a1) and Daniel C. Dennett (a2)

From an evolutionary standpoint, a default presumption is that true beliefs are adaptive and misbeliefs maladaptive. But if humans are biologically engineered to appraise the world accurately and to form true beliefs, how are we to explain the routine exceptions to this rule? How can we account for mistaken beliefs, bizarre delusions, and instances of self-deception? We explore this question in some detail. We begin by articulating a distinction between two general types of misbelief: those resulting from a breakdown in the normal functioning of the belief formation system (e.g., delusions) and those arising in the normal course of that system's operations (e.g., beliefs based on incomplete or inaccurate information). The former are instances of biological dysfunction or pathology, reflecting “culpable” limitations of evolutionary design. Although the latter category includes undesirable (but tolerable) by-products of “forgivably” limited design, our quarry is a contentious subclass of this category: misbeliefs best conceived as design features. Such misbeliefs, unlike occasional lucky falsehoods, would have been systematically adaptive in the evolutionary past. Such misbeliefs, furthermore, would not be reducible to judicious – but doxastically1 noncommittal – action policies. Finally, such misbeliefs would have been adaptive in themselves, constituting more than mere by-products of adaptively biased misbelief-producing systems. We explore a range of potential candidates for evolved misbelief, and conclude that, of those surveyed, only positive illusions meet our criteria.

Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

A. Abbey (1982) Sex differences in attributions for friendly behavior: Do males misperceive females' friendliness? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 42:830–38.

K. Akins (1996) Of sensory systems and the “aboutness” of mental states. The Journal of Philosophy 93(7):337–72.

M. D. Alicke (1985) Global self-evaluation as determined by the desirability and controllability of trait adjectives. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 49:1621–30.

S. Atran & A. Norenzayan (2004) Religion's evolutionary landscape: Counterintuition, commitment, compassion, communion. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 27:713–70.

A. Bandura (1989) Human agency in social cognitive theory. American Psychologist 44:1175–84.

J. A. Bargh , M. Chen & L. Burrows (1996) Automaticity of social behavior: Direct effects of trait construct and stereotype activation on action. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 71:230–44.

J. L. Barrett (2000) Exploring the natural foundations of religion. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 4(1):2934.

R. F. Baumeister (1989) The optimal margin of illusion. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology 8:176–89.

T. R. Bayes (1763) An essay towards solving a problem in the doctrine of chances. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 53:370418.

T. Bayne & E. Pacherie (2005) In defence of the doxastic conception of delusions. Mind and Language 20(2):163–88.

A. Beja-Pereira , G. Luikart , P. R. England , D. G. Bradley , O. C. Jann , G. Bertorelle , A. T. Chamberlain , T. P. Nunes , S. Metodiev , N. Ferrand & G. Erhardt (2003) Gene-culture coevolution between cattle milk protein genes and human lactase genes. Nature Genetics 35:311–13.

R. Benabou & J. Tirole (2002) Self-confidence and personal motivation. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 117(3):871915.

J. M. Bering (2002) The existential theory of mind. Review of General Psychology 6:324.

J. M. Bering (2006) The folk psychology of souls. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 29:453–98.

J. M. Bering & D. D. P. Johnson (2005) “O Lord … you perceive my thoughts from afar”: Recursiveness and the evolution of supernatural agency. Journal of Cognition and Culture 5(1/2):118–42.

J. M. Bering , K. A. McLeod & T. K. Shackelford (2005) Reasoning about dead agents reveals possible adaptive trends. Human Nature 16:360–81.

F. Binkofski , G. Buccino , C. Dohle , R. J. Seitz & H.-J. Freund (1999) Mirror agnosia and mirror ataxia constitute different parietal lobe disorders. Annals of Neurology 46:5161.

L. Blackwell , K. Trzesniewski & C. S. Dweck (2007) Implicit theories of intelligence predict achievement across an adolescent transition: A longitudinal study and an intervention. Child Development 78:246–63.

P. Bloom (2007) Religion is natural. Developmental Science 10(1):147–51.

S. Bowles , J.-K. Choi & A. Hopfensitz (2003) The co-evolution of individual behaviours and social institutions. Journal of Theoretical Biology 223(2):135–47.

R. Boyd , H. Gintis , S. Bowles & P. J. Richerson (2003) The evolution of altruistic punishment. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 100(6):3531–35.

P. Boyer (2003) Religious thought and behaviour as by-products of brain function. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 7(3):119–24.

P. Boyer (2008b) Religion: Bound to believe? Nature 455(23):1038–39.

M. E. Bratman (1992) Practical reasoning and acceptance in a context. Mind 101(401):115.

N. Breen , D. Caine & M. Coltheart (2001) Mirrored-self misidentification: Two cases of focal onset dementia. Neurocase 7:239–54.

N. Breen , D. Caine , M. Coltheart , J. Hendy & C. Roberts (2000) Towards an understanding of delusions of misidentification: Four case studies. Mind and Language 15(1):74110.

M. Brüne (2001) De Clerambault's syndrome (erotomania) in an evolutionary perspective. Evolution and Human Behavior 22(6):409–15.

M. Brüne (2003b) Erotomanic stalking in evolutionary perspective. Behavioral Sciences and the Law 21(1):8388.

J. Bulbulia (2004b) The cognitive and evolutionary psychology of religion. Biology and Philosophy 19:655–86.

B. J. Bushman , R. D. Ridge , E. Das , C. W. Key & G. L. Busath (2007) When God sanctions killing: Effect of scriptural violence on aggression. Psychological Science 18(3):204207.

D. M. Buss & M. G. Haselton (2005) The evolution of jealousy: A response to Buller. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 9(11):506507.

M. Coltheart (1996) Are dyslexics different? Dyslexia 2:7981.

C. R. Colvin & J. Block (1994) Do positive illusions foster mental health? An examination of the Taylor and Brown formulation. Psychological Bulletin 116(1):320.

G. Currie (2000) Imagination, delusion and hallucinations. Mind and Language 15:168–83.

G. Currie & J. Jureidini (2001) Delusion, rationality, empathy: Commentary on Davies et al. Philosophy, Psychiatry, and Psychology 8(2–3):159–62.

D. Davidson (1994) Radical interpretation interpreted. In: Philosophical perspectives, vol. 8: Logic and Language, ed. J. E. Tomberlin , pp. 121–28. Ridgeview.

D. Davidson (2001) Inquiries into truth and interpretation, 2nd edition.Clarendon Press.

M. Davies , M. Coltheart , R. Langdon & N. Breen (2001) Monothematic delusions: Towards a two-factor account. Philosophy, Psychiatry, and Psychology 8(2–3): 133–58.

C. Dean & P. G. Surtees (1989) Do psychological factors predict survival in breast cancer? Journal of Psychosomatic Research 33(5):561–69.

D. C. Dennett (1971) Intentional systems. Journal of Philosophy 68(2):87106.

D. C. Dennett (1990b) The interpretation of texts, people and other artifacts. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 50(Supplement):177–94.

D. C. Dennett (2008) Fun and games in Fantasyland. Mind and Language 23(1):2531.

J. A. Easton , L. D. Schipper & T. K. Shackelford (2007) Morbid jealousy from an evolutionary psychological perspective. Evolution and Human Behavior 28:399402.

E. Fehr & U. Fischbacher (2003) The nature of human altruism. Nature 425:785–91.

E. Fehr & U. Fischbacher (2004) Social norms and human cooperation. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 8(4):185–90.

E. Fehr , U. Fischbacher & S. Gaechter (2002) Strong reciprocity, human cooperation, and the enforcement of social norms. Human Nature 13:125.

E. Fehr & S. Gaechter (2002) Altruistic punishment in humans. Nature 415:137–40.

B. J. Fowers , E. M. Lyons & K. H. Montel (1996) Positive marital illusions: Self-enhancement or relationship enhancement? Journal of Family Psychology 10:192208.

B. J. Fowers , E. Lyons , K. H. Montel & N. Shaked (2001) Positive illusions about marriage among the married, engaged, and single. Journal of Family Psychology 15:95109.

J. Friedrich (1996) On seeing oneself as less self-serving than others: The ultimate self-serving bias? Teaching of Psychology 23(2):107109.

F. M. Gagné & J. E. Lydon (2004) Bias and accuracy in close relationships: An integrative review. Personality and Social Psychology Review 8(4):322–38.

T. S. Gendler (2008) Alief and belief. Journal of Philosophy 105(10):634–63.

G. Gigerenzer & D. G. Goldstein (1996) Reasoning the fast and frugal way: Models of bounded rationality Psychological Review 103(4):650–69.

H. Gintis (2000) Strong reciprocity and human sociality. Journal of Theoretical Biology 206:169–79.

H. Gintis (2003) The hitchhiker's guide to altruism: Gene-culture co-evolution and the internalization of norms. Journal of Theoretical Biology 220:407–18.

H. Gintis , S. Bowles , R. Boyd & E. Fehr (2003) Explaining altruistic behavior in humans. Evolution and Human Behavior 24(3):153–72.

H. Gintis , E. Smith & S. Bowles (2001) Costly signalling and cooperation. Journal of Theoretical Biology 213:103–19.

D. G. Goldstein & G. Gigerenzer (2002) Models of ecological rationality: The recognition heuristic. Psychological Review 109(1):7590.

S. J. Gould & R. C. Lewontin (1979) The spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian paradigm: A critique of the adaptationist programme. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B 205(1161):581–98.

W. D. Hamilton (1964) Genetical evolution of social behavior, I and II. Journal of Theoretical Biology 7:152.

M. G. Haselton (2003) The sexual overperception bias: Evidence of a systematic bias in men from a survey of naturally occurring events. Journal of Research in Personality 37(1):3447.

M. G. Haselton & D. M. Buss (2000) Error Management Theory: A new perspective on biases in cross-sex mind reading. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 78(1):8191.

M. G. Haselton & D. Nettle (2006) The paranoid optimist: An integrative evolutionary model of cognitive biases. Personality and Social Psychology Review 10(1):4766.

J. Henrich & R. Boyd (2001) Why people punish defectors – weak conformist transmission can stabilize costly enforcement of norms in cooperative dilemmas. Journal of Theoretical Biology 208:7989.

S. F. Huq , P. A. Garety & D. R. Hemsley (1988) Probabilistic judgements in deluded and non-deluded subjects. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology A 40(4):801–12.

M. Jahoda (1958) Current concepts of positive mental health. Basic Books.

D. D. P. Johnson (2005) God's punishment and public goods: A test of the supernatural punishment hypothesis in 186 world cultures. Human Nature 16(4):410–46.

D. D. P. Johnson & J. M. Bering (2006) Hand of God, mind of man: Punishment and cognition in the evolution of cooperation. Evolutionary Psychology 4:219–33.

D. D. P. Johnson & O. Krüger (2004) The good of wrath: Supernatural punishment and the evolution of cooperation. Political Theology 5(2):159–76.

D. D. P. Johnson , P. Stopka & S. Knights (2003) The puzzle of human cooperation. Nature 421:911–12.

G. Katzir & H. C. Howland (2003) Corneal power and underwater accommodation in great cormorants (Phalacrocorax carbo sinensis). The Journal of Experimental Biology 206:833–41.

G. Katzir & N. Intrator (1987) Striking of underwater prey by a reef heron, Egretta gularis schistacea. Journal of Comparative Physiology A 160:517–23.

D. Kelemen (2004) Are children “intuitive theists”? Psychological Science 15:295301.

P. Kinderman & R. P. Bentall (1996) Self-discrepancies and persecutory delusions: Evidence for a model of paranoid ideation. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 105(1):106–13.

P. Kinderman & R. P. Bentall (1997) Causal attributions in paranoia and depression: Internal, personal, and situational attributions for negative events. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 106(2):341–45.

R. Langdon & M. Coltheart (2000) The cognitive neuropsychology of delusions. Mind and Language 15(1):183216.

R. Langdon , R. McKay & M. Coltheart (2008) The cognitive neuropsychological understanding of persecutory delusions. In: Persecutory delusions: Assessment, theory, and treatment, ed. D. Freeman , R. Bentall & P. Garety , pp. 221–36. Oxford University Press.

A. Lotem , E. Schechtman & G. Katzir (1991) Capture of submerged prey by little egrets, Egretta garzetta garzetta: Strike depth, strike angle and the problem of light refraction. Animal Behaviour 42:341–46.

R. McKay , R. Langdon & M. Coltheart (2007a) Models of misbelief: Integrating motivational and deficit theories of delusions. Consciousness and Cognition 16:932–41.

R. McKay , R. Langdon & M. Coltheart (2007b) The defensive function of persecutory delusions: An investigation using the Implicit Association Test. Cognitive Neuropsychiatry 12(1):124.

F. P. McKenna , R. A. Stanier & C. Lewis (1991) Factors underlying illusory self-assessment of driving skill in males and females. Accident Analysis and Prevention 23(1):4552.

S. Moritz , R. Werner & G. von Collani (2006) The inferiority complex in paranoia readdressed: A study with the Implicit Association Test. Cognitive Neuropsychiatry 11(4):402–15.

G. P. Murdock & D. R. White (1969) Standard cross-cultural sample. Ethnology 8:329–69.

S. L. Murray , J. G. Holmes & D. W. Griffin (1996) The benefits of positive illusions: Idealization and the construction of satisfaction in close relationships. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 70:7998.

D. Myers (2002) Social psychology, 7th edition.McGraw-Hill.

D. Nettle (2004) Adaptive illusions: Optimism, control and human rationality. In: Emotion, evolution and rationality, ed. D. Evans & P. Cruse , pp. 193208. Oxford University Press.

J. G. Neuhoff (2001) An adaptive bias in the perception of looming auditory motion. Ecological Psychology 13:87110.

A. Norenzayan & A. F. Shariff (2008) The origin and evolution of religious prosociality. Science 322:5862.

I. Pichon , G. Boccato & V. Saroglou (2007) Nonconscious influences of religion on prosociality: A priming study. European Journal of Social Psychology 37:1032–45.

D. J. Povinelli & J. M. Bering (2002) The mentality of apes revisited. Current Directions in Psychological Science 11:115–19.

E. Pronin , T. Gilovich & L. Ross (2004) Objectivity in the eye of the beholder: Divergent perceptions of bias in self versus others. Psychological Review 111(3):781–99.

E. Pronin , D. Y. Lin & L. Ross (2002) The bias blind spot: Perceptions of bias in self versus others. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 28(3):369–81.

L. Quillian & D. Pager (2001) Black neighbors, higher crime? The role of racial stereotypes in evaluations of neighborhood crime. American Journal of Sociology 107(3):717–67.

V. S. Ramachandran (1994a) Phantom limbs, neglect syndromes, repressed memories, and Freudian psychology. International Review of Neurobiology 37:291333.

V. S. Ramachandran (1995) Anosognosia in parietal lobe syndrome. Consciousness and Cognition 4(1):2251.

V. S. Ramachandran (1996a) The evolutionary biology of self-deception, laughter, dreaming and depression: Some clues from anosognosia. Medical Hypotheses 47(5):347–62.

V. S. Ramachandran , E. L. Altschuler & S. Hillyer (1997) Mirror agnosia. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences 264:645–47.

V. S. Ramachandran & S. Blakeslee (1998) Phantoms in the brain: Human nature and the architecture of the mind. Fourth Estate.

B. Randolph-Seng & M. E. Nielsen (2007) Honesty: One effect of primed religious representations. The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 17(4):303–15.

B. Randolph-Seng & M. E. Nielsen (2008) Is God really watching you? A response to Shariff and Norenzayan (2007). The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 18(2):119–22.

G. M. Reed , M. E. Kemeny , S. E. Taylor & B. R. Visscher (1999) Negative HIV-specific expectancies and AIDS-related bereavement as predictors of symptom onset in asymptomatic HIV-positive gay men. Health Psychology 18:354–63.

G. M. Reed , M. E. Kemeny , S. E. Taylor , H.-Y. J. Wang & B. R. Visscher (1994) “Realistic acceptance” as a predictor of decreased survival time in gay men with AIDS. Health Psychology 13:299307.

F. L. Roes & M. Raymond (2003) Belief in moralizing gods. Evolution and Human Behavior 24(2):126–35.

M. J. Rossano (2007) Supernaturalizing social life: Religion and the evolution of human cooperation. Human Nature 18:272–94.

P. Rozin & A. E. Fallon (1987) A perspective on disgust. Psychological Review 94:2341.

P. Rozin , M. Markwith & B. Ross (1990) The sympathetic magical law of similarity, nominal realism, and neglect of negatives in response to negative labels. Psychological Science 1(6):383–84.

P. Rozin , L. Millman & C. Nemeroff (1986) Operation of the laws of systematic magic in disgust and other domains. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 50(4):703–12.

B. J. Ruffle & R. Sosis (2007) Does it pay to pray? Costly ritual and cooperation. The B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis and Policy 7(1) (Contributions):Article 18.

A. F. Shariff & A. Norenzayan (2007) God is watching you: Priming God concepts increases prosocial behavior in an anonymous economic game. Psychological Science 18(9):803809.

H. A. Simon (1990) A mechanism for social selection and successful altruism. Science 250(4988):1665–68.

R. Sosis (2004) The adaptive value of religious ritual. American Scientist 92:166–72.

K. B. Spangenberg , M. T. Wagner & D. L. Bachman (1998) Neuropsychological analysis of a case of abrupt onset mirror sign following a hypotensive crisis in a patient with vascular dementia. Neurocase 4:149154.

G. L. Stephens & G. Graham (2004) Reconceiving delusion. International Review of Psychiatry 16(3):236–41.

T. Stone & A. W. Young (1997) Delusions and brain injury: The philosophy and psychology of belief. Mind and Language 12:327–64.

S. E. Taylor & J. D. Brown (1988) Illusion and well-being: A social psychological perspective on mental health. Psychological Bulletin 103(2):193210.

S. E. Taylor & J. D. Brown (1994b) Positive illusions and well-being revisited: Separating fact from fiction. Psychological Bulletin 116(1):2127.

S. E. Taylor , M. E. Kemeny , G. M. Reed , J. E. Bower & T. L. Gruenewald (2000) Psychological resources, positive illusions, and health. American Psychologist 55:99109.

S. E. Taylor , J. S. Lerner , D. K. Sherman , R. M. Sage & N. K. McDowell (2003) Are self-enhancing cognitions associated with healthy or unhealthy biological profiles? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 85(4):605–15.

R. L. Trivers (1971) The evolution of reciprocal altruism. The Quarterly Review of Biology 46:3557.

R. L. Trivers (1974) Parent-offspring conflict. American Zoologist 14:249–64.

D. S. N. Van Leeuwen (2007) The spandrels of self-deception: Prospects for a biological theory of a mental phenomenon. Philosophical Psychology 20(3):329–48.

C. Vazquez , C. Diez-Alegria , M. J. Hernandez-Lloreda & M. N. Moreno (2008) Implicit and explicit self-schema in active deluded, remitted deluded, and depressed patients. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 39:587–99.

E. Voland & R. Voland (1995) Parent-offspring conflict, the extended phenotype, and the evolution of conscience. Journal of Social and Evolutionary Systems 18(4):397412.

B. Wallace (1973) Misinformation, fitness and selection. American Naturalist 107:17.

A. Wenger & B. J. Fowers (2008) Positive illusions in parenting: Every child is above average. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 38(3):611–34.

A. F. Williams (2003) Views of U.S. drivers about driving safety. Journal of Safety Research 34(5):491–94.

D. S. Wilson (2002) Darwin's cathedral: Evolution, religion and the nature of society. University of Chicago Press.

T. Yamagishi , S. Terai , T. Kiyonari , N. Mifune & S. Kanazawa (2007) The social exchange heuristic: Managing errors in social exchange. Rationality and Society 19(3):259–91.

A. W. Young (1999) Delusions. The Monist 82(4):571–89.

A. W. Young (2000) Wondrous strange: The neuropsychology of abnormal beliefs. Mind and Language 15(1):4773.

A. Zahavi (1995) Altruism as a handicap – the limitations of kin selection and reciprocity. Journal of Avian Biology 26:13.

J. Zolotova & M. Brüne (2006) Persecutory delusions: Reminiscence of ancestral hostile threats? Evolution and Human Behavior 27(3):185–92.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • ISSN: 0140-525X
  • EISSN: 1469-1825
  • URL: /core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 26
Total number of PDF views: 183 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 669 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 18th August 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.