Skip to main content

How we know our own minds: The relationship between mindreading and metacognition

  • Peter Carruthers (a1)

Four different accounts of the relationship between third-person mindreading and first-person metacognition are compared and evaluated. While three of them endorse the existence of introspection for propositional attitudes, the fourth (defended here) claims that our knowledge of our own attitudes results from turning our mindreading capacities upon ourselves. Section 1 of this target article introduces the four accounts. Section 2 develops the “mindreading is prior” model in more detail, showing how it predicts introspection for perceptual and quasi-perceptual (e.g., imagistic) mental events while claiming that metacognitive access to our own attitudes always results from swift unconscious self-interpretation. This section also considers the model's relationship to the expression of attitudes in speech. Section 3 argues that the commonsense belief in the existence of introspection should be given no weight. Section 4 argues briefly that data from childhood development are of no help in resolving this debate. Section 5 considers the evolutionary claims to which the different accounts are committed, and argues that the three introspective views make predictions that are not borne out by the data. Section 6 examines the extensive evidence that people often confabulate when self-attributing attitudes. Section 7 considers “two systems” accounts of human thinking and reasoning, arguing that although there are introspectable events within System 2, there are no introspectable attitudes. Section 8 examines alleged evidence of “unsymbolized thinking”. Section 9 considers the claim that schizophrenia exhibits a dissociation between mindreading and metacognition. Finally, section 10 evaluates the claim that autism presents a dissociation in the opposite direction, of metacognition without mindreading.

Hide All
Aiello L. & Wheeler P. (1995) The expensive tissue hypothesis. Current Anthropology 36:199221.
Anderson J. (1995) Learning and memory: An integrated approach. Wiley.
Anderson M. L. & Perlis D. (2005a) Logic, self-awareness and self-improvement: The metacognitive loop and the problem of brittleness. Journal of Logic and Computation 15:2140.
Baars B. J. (1988) A cognitive theory of consciousness. Cambridge University Press.
Baars B. J. (1997) In the theatre of consciousness. Oxford University Press.
Baars B. J. (2002) The conscious access hypothesis: Origins and recent evidence. Trends in Cognitive Science 6:4752.
Baars B. J. (2003) How brain reveals mind: Neuroimaging supports the central role of conscious experience. Journal of Consciousness Studies 10:100–14.
Baars B. J., Ramsoy T. & Laureys S. (2003) Brain, consciousness, and the observing self. Trends in Neurosciences 26:671–75.
Baddeley A., Chincotta D. & Adlam A. (2001) Working memory and the control of action: Evidence from task switching. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 130:641–57.
Bayne T. & Pacherie E. (2007) Narrators and comparators: The architecture of agentive self-awareness. Synthese 159:475–91.
Begg I., Duft S., Lalonde P., Melnick R. & Sanvito J. (1989) Memory predictions are based on ease of processing. Journal of Memory and Language 28:610–32.
Bem D. (1967) Self-perception: An alternative interpretation of cognitive dissonance phenomena. Psychological Review 74:183200.
Bem D. (1972) Self-perception theory. In: Advances in experimental social psychology, vol. 6, ed. Berkowitz L.. Academic Press.
Benjamin A. & Bjork R. (1996) Retrieval fluency as a metacognitive index. In: Implicit memory and metacognition, ed. Reder L.. Erlbaum.
Beran M., Smith J., Redford J. & Washburn D. (2006) Rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta) monitor uncertainty during numerosity judgments. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes 32:111–19.
Birch S. A. J. & Bloom P. (2004) Understanding children's and adult's limitations in mental state reasoning. Trends in Cognitive Science 8:255–60.
Birch S. A. J. & Bloom P. (2007) The curse of knowledge in reasoning about false beliefs. Psychological Science 18:382–86.
Blakemore S., Wolpert D. & Frith C. (1998) Central cancellation of self-produced tickle sensation. Nature Neuroscience 1:635–40.
Block N. (1995) A confusion about the function of consciousness. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 18:227–47.
Bosco F., Friedman O. & Leslie A. (2006) Recognition of pretend and real actions in play by 1- and 2-year-olds: Early success and why they fail. Cognitive Development 21:310.
Brasil-Neto J., Pascual-Leone A., Valls-Solé J., Cohen L. & Hallett M. (1992) Focal transcranial magnetic stimulation and response bias in a forced choice task. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 55:964–66.
Bratman M. (1987) Intentions, plans, and practical reason. Harvard University Press.
Bratman M. (1999) Faces of intention: Selected essays on intention and agency. Cambridge University Press.
Briñol P. & Petty R. (2003) Overt head movements and persuasion: A self-validation analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 84:1123–39.
Byrne R. & Whiten A., eds. (1988) Machiavellian intelligence I: Social expertise and the evolution of intellect in monkeys, apes, and humans. Oxford University Press.
Byrne R. & Whiten A., eds. (1997) Machiavellian intelligence II: Extensions and evaluations. Cambridge University Press.
Call J. & Carpenter M. (2001) Do apes and children know what they have seen? Animal Cognition 4:207–20.
Call J. & Tomasello M. (2008) Does the chimpanzee have a theory of mind? 30 years later. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 12:187–92.
Carruthers P. (1996a) Autism as mind-blindness. In: Theories of Theories of Mind, ed. Carruthers P. & Smith P.. Cambridge University Press.
Carruthers P. (1996c) Simulation and self-knowledge. In: Theories of Theories of Mind, ed. Carruthers P. & Smith P.. Cambridge University Press.
Carruthers P. (2000) Phenomenal consciousness: A naturalistic theory. Cambridge University Press.
Carruthers P. (2002) The cognitive functions of language. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 25:657719.
Carruthers P. (2006) The architecture of the mind: Massive modularity and the flexibility of thought. Oxford University Press.
Carruthers P. (2008a) Cartesian epistemology: Is the theory of the self-transparent mind innate? Journal of Consciousness Studies 15(4):2853.
Carruthers P. (2008b) Metacognition in animals: A skeptical look. Mind and Language 23(1):5889.
Carruthers P. (2009) An architecture for dual reasoning. In: In two minds: Dual processes and beyond, ed. Evans J. St. B. T. & Frankish K., pp. 109–27. Oxford University Press.
Cheney D. & Seyfarth R. (2007) Baboon metaphysics: The evolution of a social mind. University of Chicago Press.
Clark A. (1998) Magic words: How language augments human computation. In: Language and thought, ed. Carruthers P. & Boucher J.. Cambridge University Press.
Cooper J. & Duncan B. (1971) Cognitive dissonance as a function of self-esteem and logical inconsistency. Journal of Personality 18:354–63.
Csibra G. (2007) Action mirroring and action interpretation: An alternative account. In: Sensorimotor foundations of higher cognition: Attention and performance XXII, ed. Haggard P., Rosetti Y. & Kawato M.. Oxford University Press.
Damasio A. (1994) Descartes' error: Emotion, reason and the human brain. Papermac.
Damasio A. (2003) Looking for Spinoza: Joy, sorrow, and the feeling brain. Harcourt.
Dehaene S. & Naccache L. (2001) Towards a cognitive neuroscience of consciousness: Basic evidence and a workspace framework. Cognition 79:137.
Dehaene S., Naccache L., Cohen L., Bihan D., Mangin J., Poline J. & Riviere D. (2001) Cerebral mechanisms of word priming and unconscious repetition masking. Nature Neuroscience 4:752–58.
Dehaene S., Sergent C. & Changeux J. (2003) A neuronal network model linking subjective reports and objective physiological data during conscious perception. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 100:8520–25.
Dennett D. C. (1991) Consciousness explained. Penguin.
Dennett D. C. (2000) Making tools for thinking. In: Metarepresentations, ed. Sperber D.. Oxford University Press.
Dunbar R. (2000) On the origin of the human mind. In: Evolution and the human mind, ed. Carruthers P. & Chamberlain A.. Cambridge University Press.
Eagly A. & Chaiken S. (1993) The psychology of attitudes. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
Edwards G. (1965) Post-hypnotic amnesia and post-hypnotic effect. British Journal of Psychiatry 111:316–25.
Evans G. (1982) The varieties of reference. Oxford University Press/Clarendon Press.
Evans J. St. B. T. & Over D. (1996) Rationality and reasoning. Psychology Press.
Farrant A., Boucher J. & Blades M. (1999) Metamemory in children with autism. Child Development 70:107–31.
Festinger L. (1957) A theory of cognitive dissonance. Stanford University Press.
Fodor J. (1992) A theory of the child's theory of mind. Cognition 44:283–96.
Frankish K. (2004) Mind and supermind. Cambridge University Press.
Frith C. D., Blakemore S. & Wolpert D. (2000a) Abnormalities in the awareness and control of action. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 355:1771–88.
Frith C. D., Blakemore S. & Wolpert D. (2000b) Explaining the symptoms of schizophrenia: Abnormalities in the awareness of action. Brain Research Reviews 31:357–63.
Frith U. & Happé F. (1999) Theory of mind and self-consciousness: What is it like to be autistic? Mind and Language 14:122.
Gallese V., Fadiga L., Fogassi L., Rizzolatti G. (1996) Action recognition in the premotor cortex. Brain 119:593609.
Gallese V. & Goldman A. (1998) Mirror neurons and the simulation theory of mindreading. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 12:493501.
Gazzaniga M. (1995) Consciousness and the cerebral hemispheres. In: The cognitive neurosciences, ed. Gazzaniga M.. MIT Press.
Gazzaniga M. (1998) The mind's past. California University Press.
Gazzaniga M. (2000) Cerebral specialization and inter-hemispheric communication: Does the corpus callosum enable the human condition? Brain 123:1293–326.
Gigerenzer G., Todd P. & the ABC Research Group. (1999) Simple heuristics that make us smart. Oxford University Press.
Goldman A. (1993) The psychology of folk psychology. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 16:1528.
Goldman A. (2006) Simulating minds: The philosophy, psychology, and neuroscience of mindreading. Oxford University Press.
Gomez J. (1998) Some thoughts about the evolution of LADS, with special reference to TOM and SAM. In: Language and thought, ed. Carruthers P. & Boucher J.. Cambridge University Press.
Gopnik A. (1993) The illusion of first-person knowledge of intentionality. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 16:114.
Gopnik A. & Meltzoff A. (1994) Minds, bodies, and persons: Young children's understanding of the self and others as reflected in imitation and theory of mind research. In: Self-awareness in animals and humans, ed. Parker S., Mitchell R. & Boccia M.. Cambridge University Press.
Gopnik A. & Meltzoff A. (1997) Words, thoughts, and theories. MIT Press.
Gordon R. (1986) Folk psychology as simulation. Mind and Language 1:158–70.
Gordon R. (1996) “Radical” simulationism. In: Theories of Theories of Mind, ed. Carruthers P. & Smith P.. Cambridge University Press.
Greenbaum C. & Zemach M. (1972) Role-playing and change of attitude toward the police after a campus riot: Effects of situational demand and justification. Human Relations 25:8799.
Grush R. (2004) The emulation theory of representation: Motor control, imagery, and perception. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 27:377442.
Hampton R. R. (2001) Rhesus monkeys know when they remember. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 98:5359–62.
Hampton R. R. (2005) Can Rhesus monkeys discriminate between remembering and forgetting? In: The Missing Link in Cognition: Origins of Self-reflective Consciousness, ed. Terrace H. & Metcalfe J.. Oxford University Press.
Hampton R. R., Zivin A. & Murray E. (2004) Rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) discriminate between knowing and not knowing and collect information as needed before acting. Animal Cognition 7:239–46.
Happé F. (2003) Theory of mind and the self. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1001:134–44.
Hare B. (2007) From nonhuman to human mind: What changed and why? Current Directions in Psychological Science 16:6064.
Hare B., Call J., Agnetta B. & Tomasello M. (2000) Chimpanzees know what conspecifics do and do not see. Animal Behavior 59:771–85.
Hare B., Call J. & Tomasello M. (2001) Do chimpanzees know what conspecifics know? Animal Behavior 61:139–51.
Harris P. L. (2002a) Checking our sources: The origins of trust in testimony. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 33:315–33.
Harris P. L. (2002b) What do children learn from testimony? In: The cognitive basis of science, ed. Carruthers P., Stich S. & Siegal M.. Cambridge University Press.
Hurlburt R. (1990) Sampling normal and schizophrenic inner experience. Plenum Press.
Hurlburt R. (1993) Sampling inner experience in disturbed affect. Plenum Press.
Hurlburt R. T. & Akhter S. A. (2008) Unsymbolized thinking. Consciousness and Cognition 17:1364–74.
Hurlburt R. T., Happé F. & Frith U. (1994) Sampling the form of inner experience in three adults with Asperger syndrome. Psychological Medicine 24:385–95.
Jeannerod M. (2006) Motor cognition. Oxford University Press.
Kahneman D. (2002) Maps of bounded rationality: A perspective on intuitive judgment and choice. Nobel laureate acceptance speech. Available at:
Kant I. (1781/1929) The critique of pure reason, trans. Kemp Smith N., Macmillan. (Original published in 1781.)
Kazak S., Collis G. & Lewis V. (1997) Can young people with autism refer to knowledge states? Evidence from their understanding of “know” and “guess.” Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 38:10011009.
Koriat A. (1993) How do we know that we know? The accessibility model of the feeling of knowing. Psychological Review 100:609–39.
Koriat A. (1997) Monitoring one's own knowledge during study: A cue-utilization approach to judgments of learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 126:349–70.
Koriat A., Ma'ayan H. & Nussinson R. (2006) The intricate relationships between monitoring and control in metacognition: Lessons for the cause-and-effect relation between subjective experience and behavior. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 135(1):3669.
Kornell N., Son L. & Terrace H. (2007) Transfer of metacognitive skills and hint seeking in monkeys. Psychological Science 18:6471.
Kosslyn S. (1994) Image and brain. MIT Press.
Kreiman G., Fried I. & Koch C. (2003) Single neuron correlates of subjective vision in the human medial temporal lobe. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 99:8378–83.
Kruglanski A., Alon W. & Lewis T. (1972) Retrospective misattribution and task enjoyment. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 8:493501.
Leslie A. M. & Polizzi P. (1998) Inhibitory processing in the false belief task: Two conjectures. Developmental Science 1:247–53.
Levelt W. (1989) Speaking: From intention to articulation. MIT Press.
Locke J. (1690/1961) An essay concerning human understanding, ed. Yolton J., Dent and Sons. (Original published in 1690.)
McCloskey M. (1983) Naive theories of motion. In: Mental models, ed. Gentner D. & Stevens A.. Erlbaum.
Metcalfe J. & Shimamura A., eds. (1994) Metacognition: Knowing about knowing. MIT Press.
Nelson T. O, ed. (1992) Metacognition: Core readings. Allyn and Bacon.
Nichols S. & Stich S. (2003) Mindreading: An integrated account of pretence, self-awareness, and understanding other minds. Oxford University Press.
Nisbett R. & Wilson T. (1977) Telling more than we can know: Verbal reports on mental processes. Psychological Review 84:231–95.
Onishi K. & Baillargeon R. (2005) Do 15-month-olds understand false beliefs? Science 5719:255–58.
Onishi K., Baillargeon R. & Leslie A. (2007) 15-month-old infants detect violations in pretend scenarios. Acta Psychologica 124:106–28.
Origgi G. & Sperber D. (2000) Evolution, communication, and the proper function of language. In: The evolution of the human mind, ed. Carruthers P. & Chamberlain A.. Cambridge University Press.
Paulescu E., Frith D. & Frackowiak R. (1993) The neural correlates of the verbal component of working memory. Nature 362:342–45.
Phillips W., Baron-Cohen S. & Rutter M. (1998) Understanding intention in normal development and in autism. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 16:337–48.
Rey G. (2008) (Even higher-order) intentionality without consciousness. Revue Internationale de Philosophie 62:5178.
Rizzolatti G., Fadiga L., Gallese V. & Fogassi L. (1996) Premotor cortex and the recognition of motor actions. Cognitive Brain Research 3:131–41.
Russell J. & Hill E. (2001) Action-monitoring and intention reporting in children with autism. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 42:317–28.
Schwartz B. L. & Smith S. (1997) The retrieval of related information influences tip-of-the-tongue states. Journal of Memory and Language 36:6886.
Searle J. (1992) The rediscovery of the mind. MIT Press.
Shallice T. (1988) From neuropsychology to mental structure. Cambridge University Press.
Sheehan P. & Orne M. (1968) Some comments on the nature of post-hypnotic behavior. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 146:209–20.
Shergill S., Brammer M., Fukuda R., Bullmore E., Amaro E., Murray R. & McGuire P. (2002) Modulation of activity in temporal cortex during generation of inner speech. Human Brain Mapping 16:219–27.
Shields W., Smith J. & Washburn D. (1997) Uncertain responses by humans and rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) in a psychophysical same–different task. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 126:147–64.
Shoemaker S. (1996) The first-person perspective and other essays. Cambridge University Press.
Sloman S. (1996) The empirical case for two systems of reasoning. Psychological Bulletin 119:322.
Skinner B. F. (2002) Two systems of reasoning. In: Heuristics and biases: The psychology of intuitive judgment, ed. Gilovich T., Griffin D. & Kahneman D.. Cambridge University Press.
Smith J. D. (2005) Studies of uncertainty monitoring and metacognition in animals and humans. In: The missing link in cognition: Origins of self-reflective consciousness, ed. Terrace H. & Metcalfe J.. Oxford University Press.
Smith J. D., Schull J., Strote J., McGee K., Egnor R. & Erb L. (1995) The uncertain response in the bottlenosed dolphin (Tursiops truncatus). Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 124:391408.
Smith J. D., Shields W., Schull J. & Washburn D. (1997) The uncertain response in humans and animals. Cognition 62:7597.
Smith J. D., Shields W. & Washburn D. (2003) The comparative psychology of uncertainty monitoring and metacognition. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 26:317–39; discussion pp. 339–73.
Son L. & Kornell N. (2005) Meta-confidence judgments in rhesus macaques: Explicit versus implicit mechanisms. In: The missing link in cognition: Origins of self-reflective consciousness, ed. Terrace H. & Metcalfe J.. Oxford University Press.
Song H. & Baillargeon R.(forthcoming) Infants' reasoning about others' false perceptions. Developmental Psychology.
Song H., Onishi K., Baillargeon R. & Fisher C.(forthcoming) Can an agent's false belief be corrected through an appropriate communication? Psychological reasoning in 18-month-old infants. Cognition.
Southgate V., Gergely G. & Csibra G. (2008) Does the mirror neuron system and its impairment explain human imitation and autism? In: The role of mirroring processes in social cognition, ed. Pineda J.. Humana Press.
Southgate V., Senju A. & Csibra G. (2007) Action anticipation through attribution of false belief by 2-year-olds. Psychological Science 18:587–92.
Sperber D. & Wilson D. (1995) Relevance: Communication and cognition, 2nd edition. Blackwell.
Stanovich K. (1999) Who is rational? Studies of individual differences in reasoning. Erlbaum.
Sternberg S. (2001) Separate modifiability, mental modules, and the use of pure and composite measures to reveal them. Acta Psychologica 106:147246.
Surian L., Caldi S. & Sperber D. (2007) Attribution of beliefs by 13-month old infants. Psychological Science 18:580–86.
Terrace H. & Metcalfe J., eds. (2005) The missing link in cognition: Origins of self-reflective consciousness. Oxford University Press.
Tomasello M., Call J. & Hare B. (2003a) Chimpanzees understand psychological states – the question is which ones and to what extent. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 7:153–56.
Tomasello M., Call J. & Hare B. (2003b) Chimpanzees versus humans: It's not that simple. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 7:239–40.
Washburn D., Smith J. & Shields W. (2006) Rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) immediately generalize the uncertain response. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes 32:185–89.
Wegner D. (2002) The illusion of conscious will. MIT Press.
Wegner D. & Wheatley T. (1999) Apparent mental causation: Sources of the experience of the will. American Psychologist 54:480–91.
Weiskrantz L., Elliot J. & Darlington C. (1971) Preliminary observations of tickling oneself. Nature 230:598–99.
Wellman H. (1990) The child's theory of mind. MIT Press.
Wellman H., Cross D. & Watson J. (2001) Meta-analysis of theory-of-mind development: The truth about false belief. Child Development 72:655–84.
Wells G. & Petty R. (1980) The effects of overt head movements on persuasion: Compatibility and incompatibility of responses. Basic and Applied Social Psychology 1:219–30.
Wicklund R. & Brehm J. (1976) Perspectives on cognitive dissonance. Erlbaum.
Wilson T. (2002) Strangers to ourselves. Harvard University Press.
Wolpert D. & Ghahramani Z. (2000) Computational principles of movement neuroscience. Nature Neuroscience 3:1212–17.
Wolpert D. & Kawato M. (1998) Multiple paired forward and inverse models for motor control. Neural Networks 11:1317–29.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • ISSN: 0140-525X
  • EISSN: 1469-1825
  • URL: /core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 74
Total number of PDF views: 347 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 1198 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 21st January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.