Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa
  • Get access
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
  • Cited by 641
  • Cited by
    This article has been cited by the following publications. This list is generated based on data provided by CrossRef.

    Ambasciano, Leonardo 2016. Mind the (Unbridgeable) Gaps. Method & Theory in the Study of Religion, Vol. 28, Issue. 2, p. 141.


    Christensen, Peer Fusaroli, Riccardo and Tylén, Kristian 2016. Environmental constraints shaping constituent order in emerging communication systems: Structural iconicity, interactive alignment and conventionalization. Cognition, Vol. 146, p. 67.


    Corballis, Michael C. 2016. The evolution of language: Sharing our mental lives. Journal of Neurolinguistics,


    Corballis, Michael C. 2016. Precursors to Language. Topoi,


    de Boer, Bart 2016. Modeling Co-evolution of Speech and Biology. Topics in Cognitive Science, Vol. 8, Issue. 2, p. 459.


    Dediu, Dan and de Boer, Bart 2016. Language evolution needs its own journal. Journal of Language Evolution, Vol. 1, Issue. 1, p. 1.


    Lara, Graciela De Antonio, Angélica and Peña, Adriana 2016. Computerized spatial language generation for object location. Virtual Reality,


    Lian, Arild 2016. Language Evolution and Developmental Impairments.


    Luger, George F. and Chakrabarti, Chayan 2016. From Alan Turing to modern AI: practical solutions and an implicit epistemic stance. AI & SOCIETY,


    McMurray, Bob 2016. Language at Three Timescales: The Role of Real-Time Processes in Language Development and Evolution. Topics in Cognitive Science, Vol. 8, Issue. 2, p. 393.


    Okada, Kayoko Rogalsky, Corianne O'Grady, Lucinda Hanaumi, Leila Bellugi, Ursula Corina, David and Hickok, Gregory 2016. An fMRI study of perception and action in deaf signers. Neuropsychologia, Vol. 82, p. 179.


    Oller, D. Kimbrough Dale, Rick and Griebel, Ulrike 2016. New Frontiers in Language Evolution and Development. Topics in Cognitive Science, Vol. 8, Issue. 2, p. 353.


    Pisanski, Katarzyna Cartei, Valentina McGettigan, Carolyn Raine, Jordan and Reby, David 2016. Voice Modulation: A Window into the Origins of Human Vocal Control?. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, Vol. 20, Issue. 4, p. 304.


    Sindi, Suzanne S. and Dale, Rick 2016. Culturomics as a data playground for tests of selection: Mathematical approaches to detecting selection in word use. Journal of Theoretical Biology, Vol. 405, p. 140.


    Stout, Dietrich 2016. The modern era of research on language evolution: Moving forward. Physics of Life Reviews, Vol. 16, p. 99.


    Strickland, Brent 2016. Language Reflects “Core” Cognition: A New Theory About the Origin of Cross-Linguistic Regularities. Cognitive Science, p. n/a.


    Tattersall, Ian 2016. Language Origins: An Evolutionary Framework. Topoi,


    Tattersall, Ian 2016. How can we detect when language emerged?. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,


    Thompson, Bill Kirby, Simon and Smith, Kenny 2016. Culture shapes the evolution of cognition. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Vol. 113, Issue. 16, p. 4530.


    van Tiel, Bob and Schaeken, Walter 2016. Processing Conversational Implicatures: Alternatives and Counterfactual Reasoning. Cognitive Science, p. n/a.


    ×

Natural language and natural selection

  • Steven Pinker (a1) and Paul Bloom (a2)
  • DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X00081061
  • Published online: 01 May 2011
Abstract
Abstract

Many people have argued that the evolution of the human language faculty cannot be explained by Darwinian natural selection. Chomsky and Gould have suggested that language may have evolved as the by-product of selection for other abilities or as a consequence of as-yet unknown laws of growth and form. Others have argued that a biological specialization for grammar is incompatible with every tenet of Darwinian theory – that it shows no genetic variation, could not exist in any intermediate forms, confers no selective advantage, and would require more evolutionary time and genomic space than is available. We examine these arguments and show that they depend on inaccurate assumptions about biology or language or both. Evolutionary theory offers clear criteria for when a trait should be attributed to natural selection: complex design for some function, and the absence of alternative processes capable of explaining such complexity. Human language meets these criteria: Grammar is a complex mechanism tailored to the transmission of propositional structures through a serial interface. Autonomous and arbitrary grammatical phenomena have been offered as counterexamples to the position that language is an adaptation, but this reasoning is unsound: Communication protocols depend on arbitrary conventions that are adaptive as long as they are shared. Consequently, language acquisition in the child should systematically differ from language evolution in the species, and attempts to analogize them are misleading. Reviewing other arguments and data, we conclude that there is every reason to believe that a specialization for grammar evolved by a conventional neo-Darwinian process.

Copyright
Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

W. L. Abler (1989) On the particulate principle of self-diversifying systems. Journal of Social and Biological Structures 12:113. [MS-K]

R. Axelrod & W. D. Hamilton (1981) The evolution of cooperation. Science 211:1390–96. [aSP]

J. M. Baldwin (1896) A new factor in evolution. American Naturalist 30:441–51. [aSP]

J. M. Baldwin (1902) Development and evolution, including psychophysical evolution, evolution by orthoplasy, and the theory of genetic modes. Macmillan. [JL]

J. H. Barkow (1989) Broad training for social scientists (letter). Science 243:992. [rSP]

C Best , B. Morgeniello & R. Robson (1981) Perceptual equivalence of acoustic cues in speech and nonspeech perception. Perception and Psychophysics 29:191211. [JK]

P. Bloom (1989) Nominals in child language. Unpublished manuscript, Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences, Massachusetts Institute of Technology. [aSP]

J. Bybee (1985) Morphology: A study of the relation between meaning and form. Benjamins. [aSP]

A. C. Catania (1978) The psychology of learning: Some lessons from the Darwinian revolution. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 309:1828. [ACC]

M. C. Corballis (1989) Laterality and human evolution. Psychological Review 96:492505. [rSP]

L. Cosmides (1989) The logic of social exchange: Has natural selection shaped how humans reason? Studies with the Wason selection task. Cognition 31:187276; [arSP, JT, DP, MP-P]

(1989) Evolutionary psychology and the generation of culture, Part II. Case study: A computational theory of social exchange. Ethology and Sociobiology 10:5197. [arSP, MP-P, JT]

F. H. C. Crick (1968) The origin of the genetic code. Journal of Molecular Biology 38:367–79. [MR]

J. Crothers , & M. Shibatani (1975) Fundamental concepts of phonology. In: Essays on the sound pattern of English, ed. D. L. Goyvaerts & G. K. Pullum . E. Story-Scientia. [JJF]

J. Deese (1980) Pauses, prosody, and the demands of production in language. In: Temporal variables in speech: Studies in honor of Frieda Goldman-Eisler, ed. H. W. Dechert & M. Raupach . Mouton. [LF]

R. L. Diehl (1976) Feature analyzers for the phonetic distinction: Stop vs. continuant. Perception & Psychophysics 19(3):267–72. [KRK]

R. Diehl & K. Kluender (1989) On the objects of speech perception. Ecological Psychology 1(2):121–44. [JK, KRK]

J. Dodd & T. M. Jessell (1988) Axon guidance and the patterning of neuronal projections in vertebrates. Science 242:692–99. [aSP]

P. D. Eimas & J. D. Corbit (1973) Selective adaptation of linguistic feature detectors. Cognitive Psychology 4:99109. [KRK]

D. Falk (1980) A reanalysis of the South African australopithecine natural endocasts. American journal of Physical Anthropology 53:525–39. [WW]

(1983) Cerebral cortices of East African early hominids. Science 221:1072–74. [aSP, WW]

C. A. Ferguson & C. B. Farwell (1975) Words and sounds in early language acquisition: English initial consonants in the first fifty words. Language 51:419–30. [MS-K]

J. A. Fodor & Z. Pylyshyn (1988) Connectionism and cognitive architecture: a critical analysis. Cognition 28:371. [rSP]

C. A. Fowler (1983) Converging sources of evidence on spoken and perceived rhythms of speech: Cyclic production of vowels in sequences of monosyllablic stress feet. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 112:386412. [JK]

H. Franks , A. Crompton , & R. German . (1984) Mechanism of intraoral food transport in macaques. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 65:275–82. [JK]

L. Frazier , C. Clifton & J. Randall (1983) Filling gaps: decision principles and structure in sentence comprehension. Cognition 13:187222. [aSP]

J. J. Freyd (1983) Shareability: The social psychology of epistemology. Cognitive Science 7:191210. [aSP, JJF]

(1987) Dynamic mental representations. Psychological Review 94:427–38. [JJF]

B. G. Galef Jr. (1981). The ecology of weaning. In: Parental care in mammals, ed. D. J. Gubernick & P. Klopfer . Plenum Press. [DP]

(1988) The role of cross-fostering in sign language studies of chimpanzees. Human Evolution 3(1–2):6579. [IU]

W. Garstang (1922) The theory of recapitulation: A critical restatement of the biogenetic law. Journal of the Linnaean Society 35:81101. [MS-K]

N. Geschwind (1965) Disconnexion syndromes in animal and man, part 1. Brain 88:237–94. [WW]

M. Gopnik (1990) Feature blind grammar and dysphasia. Nature 344:715. [aSP, MG]

P. Gordon (1985) Level-ordering in lexical development. Cognition 21:7393. [rSP]

S. Green (1975) Communication by a graded vocal system in Japanese monkeys. In: Primate behavior 4, ed. L. Rosenblum . Academic Press. [JK]

A. L. Harrelson & C. S. Goodman (1988) Growth cone guidance in insects: Fasciclin II is a member of the immunoglobulin superfamily. Science 242:700–08. [aSP]

C. F. Hockett (1960) The origin of speech. Scientific American 203:88111. [rSP, KRK]

R. Holloway (1981) Revisiting the South African Taung australopithecine endocast: The position of the lunate sulcus as determined by the stereoplotting technique. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 56:4358. [WW]

J. R. Hurford (1989a) Biological evolution of the Saussurean sign as a component of the language acquisition device. Lingua 77:187222. [aSP]

F. Jacob (1977) Evolution and tinkering. Science 196:1161–66. [aSP]

M. King & A. Wilson (1975) Evolution at two levels in humans and chimpanzees. Science 188:107–16. [aSP]

J. G. Kingsolver & M. A. R. Koehl (1985) Aerodynamics, thermoregulation, and the evolution of insect wings: Differential scaling and evolutionary change. Evolution 39:488504. [aSP]

D. E. Kroodsma & E. H. Miller , eds. (1982) Acoustic communication in birds, vol. 2: Song learning and its consequences. Academic Press. [ACC]

P. Kuhl (1981) Discrimination of speech by nonhuman animals: Basic auditory sensitivities conducive to the perception of speech-sound categories. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 70:340–49. [JK, KRK]

P. Kuhl & J. Miller (1978) Speech perception by the chinchilla: Identification functions for synthetic VOT stimuli. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 63:905–17. [JK, KRK]

J. Lachter & T. G. Bever (1988) The relation between linguistic structure and associative theories of language learning: A constructive critique of some connectionist learning models. Cognition 28:195247. [aSP]

J. Laitman , R. Heimbuch & E. Crelin (1979) The basicranium of fossil hominids as an indicator of their upper respiratory systems. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 51:1534. [JK]

R. Lewin (1980a) Evolutionary theory under fire. Science 210:883–87. [rSP, CPO]

(1980b) Is your brain really necessary? Science 210:1232–34. [rSP]

R. C. Lewontin (1966) Review of G. C. Williams's “Adaptation and Natural Selection”. Science 152:338–39. [rSP]

(1989) A specialization for speech perception. Science 243:489–96. [arSP, KRK, JK]

A. M. Liberman , F. S. Cooper , D. P. Shankweiler & Studdert-M. Kennedy (1967) Perception of the speech code. Psychological Review 74:431–61. [arSP, JT, KRK]

(1985) On the evolution of human syntactic ability: Its pre-adaptive bases -motor control and speech. Journal of Human Evolution 14:657–68. [PL]

(1988) On human speech, syntax, and language. Human Evolution 3:318. [IU]

(1977) Language in child and chimp? American Psychologist 32:280–95. [JL]

B. Lindblom (1983) Economy of speech gestures. In: The production of speech, ed. P. F. MacNeilage . Springer-Verlag. [MS-K]

(1986) Phonetic universals in vowel systems. In: Experimental phonology, ed. J. J. Ohala & J. J. Jaeger . Academic Press. [BL]

(1989a) Some remarks on the origin of the phonetic code In: Brain and Reading, ed. C. von Euler , I. Lundberg & G. Lennerstrand . Stockton Press. [BL]

M. A. Macken (1979) Developmental reorganization of phonology: A hierarchy of basic units of a acquisition. Lingua 49:1149. [MS-K]

D. Marr (1982) Vision. W. H. Freeman. [rSP]

(1974) The theory of games and the evolution of animal conflicts. Journal of Theoretical Biology 47:209–21. [aSP]

(1978) Optimization theory in evolution. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 9:3156. [MR]

(1987) When learning guides evolution. Nature 329:762. [aSP]

(1983) How to carry out the adaptationist program? The American Naturalist 121:324–34. [aSP]

J. McCarthy (1988) Feature geometry and dependency: A review. Phonetica 45:84108. [RJ]

A. N. Meltzoff (1988) Imitation, objects, tools, and the rudiments of language in human ontogeny. Human Evolution. 3:4766. [PL]

L. Menn (1986) Language acquisition, aphasia and phonotactic universals. In: Markedness, ed. F. R. Eckman , E. A. Moravcsik & J. R. Wirth . Plenum Press. [MS-K]

L. H. Miles (1983) Apes and languages: The search for communicative competence. In Languages in primates, ed. J. de Luce and H. T. Wilder . Springer Verlag. [IU]

J. L. Miller & P. W. Jusczyk (1989) Seeking the neurological bases of speech perception. Cognition 33:111–37. [rSP]

M. M. Miyamoto , J. L. Slightom & M. Goodman (1987) Phylogenetic relations of humans and African apes from DNA sequences in the g[yh]-globin region]. Science 238:369–73. [aSP ]

K. Munhall (1985) An examination of intra-articulator timing. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 78:1548–53. [JK]

(1983) Cross-language use of pitch: An ethological view. Phonetica 40:118. [JK]

S. Ohman (1966) Coarticulation in VCV utterances: Spectrographic measurements. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 39:151–68. [JK]

IE Parker . (1988) Auditory constraints on the perception of stop voicing: The influence of lower-tone frequency on judgments of tone-onset simultaneity. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 83:15971607. [JK]

E. Parker , R. Diehl & K. Kluender (1986) Trading relations in speech and nonspeech. Perception and Psychophysics 39:129–42. [JK, KRK]

L. Petitto (1987) On the autonomy of language and gesture: Evidence from the acquisition of personal pronouns in American Sign Language. Cognition 27:152. [aSP]

M. Piattelli-Palmarini (1989) Evolution, selection, and cognition: From “learning” to parameter setting in biology and the study of language Cognition 31:144. [aSP, LF, PL, MP-P, MR, DS, WW]

K. L. Pike (1943) Phonetics. University of Michigan Press. [BL]

S. Pinker (1979) Formal models of language learning. Cognition 7:217–83. [arSP]

S. Pinker & A. Prince (1988) On language and connectionism: Analysis of a Parallel Distributed Processing model of language acquisition. Cognition 28:73193. [aSP]

D. Premack (1984) Pedagogy and aesthetics as sources of culture. In: Handbook of cognitive neuroscience, ed. M. Gazzaniga . Plenum Press. [DP]

(1985) ‘Gavagai!’ or the future history of the animal language controversy. Cognition 19:207–96. [aSP]

(1986) Pangloss to Cyrano de Bergerac: “Nonsense, it's perfect!” Cognition 23:8188. [arSP]

R. R. Provine (1986) Yawning as a stereotyped action pattern and releasing stimulus. Ethology 72:109–22. [ACC]

R. Remez (1979) Adaptation of the category boundary between speech and nonspeech: A case against feature detectors. Cognitive. Psychology 11:3857. [KRK]

B. Repp (1982) Phonetic trading relations and context effects: New experimental evidence for a speech mode of perception. Psychological Bulletin 92:129–32. [KRK]

M. Rose (1980) The mental arms race amplifier. Human Ecology 8:285–93. [aSP]

M. S. Seidenberg & L. A. Petitto (1979) Signing behavior in apes: A critical review. Cognition 7:177215. [aSP, EB]

(1987) Communication, symbolic communication, and language: Comment on Savage-Rumbaugh, McDonald, Sevcik, Hopkins, and Rupert (1986). Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 116:279–87. [aSP, EB]

E. Simons (1989) Human origins. Science 245:1343–50. [JK]

B. F. Skinner (1957) Verbal behavior. Appleton. [aSP]

G. L. Stebbins & F. J. Ayala (1981) Is a new evolutionary synthesis necessary? Science 213:967–71. [aSP]

C. B. Stringer & P. Andrews (1988) Genetic and fossil evidence for the origin of modern humans. Science 239:1263–68. [aSP]

M. Studdert-Kennedy , A. M. Liberman , K. S. Harris & F. S. Cooper (1970) Motor theory of speech perception: A reply to Lane's critical review. Psychological Review 77:234–49. [KRK]

(1989) A critique of Darwinian anthropology. Ethology and Sociohiology 10:131–44. [rSP]

L. Talmy (1983) How language structures space. In: Spatial orientation: Theory, research, and applicaiton, ed. H. Pick & L. Acredolo . Plenum. [aSP]

(1988) Force dynamics in language and cognition. Cognitive Science 12:49100. [aSP]

H. T. Terrace (1985) In the beginning was the “name.” American Psychologist 40:1011–28. [IU]

E. C. Tolman & E. Brunswik (1935) The organism and the causal texture of the environment. Psychological Review 42:4377. [rSP]

R. S. Tomlin , ed. (1987) Coherence and grounding in discourse. John Benjamins.

R. L. Trivers (1971) The evolution of reciprocal altruism. Quarterly Review of Biology 46:3557. [arSP]

(1974) Parent-offspring conflict. American Zoologist 14:249–64. [aSP]

A. Tversky &. D. Kahneman (1981) The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice. Science 211:453–58. [aSP]

A. C. Wilson (1985) The molecular basis of evolution. Scientific American 253:164–73. [CO]

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences
  • ISSN: 0140-525X
  • EISSN: 1469-1825
  • URL: /core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-sciences
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords: