Published online by Cambridge University Press: 31 August 2012
This essay follows recent work in environmental history to explore the history of recycling in physical sciences in Britain and North America since the seventeenth century. The term ‘recycling’ is here used broadly to refer to a variety of practices that extended the life of material resources for doing science in the early modern period. These included practices associated with maintenance, repair, exchange and the adaptation or reuse of material culture. The essay argues that such practices were common in early modern science, and informed experimental spaces and techniques and the ideas that they generated. The essay considers some of the varied motivations that led to such practices, and concludes by examining the endurance of recycling in science since the end of the eighteenth century, particularly in recent efforts to create sustainable scientific research practices.
1 Strasser, Susan, Waste and Want: A Social History of Trash, New York: Metropolitan Books, 1999Google Scholar.
2 Melosi, Martin V., Garbage in the Cities: Refuse, Reform, and the Environment, Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 2004Google Scholar; Barles, Sabine, L'invention des déchets urbains: France 1790–1970, Seyssel: Champ Vallon, 2005Google Scholar.
3 Cooper, Tim, ‘Rags, bones and recycling bins’, History Today (2006) 56, pp. 17–18Google Scholar; Goddard, Nicholas, ‘19th-century recycling: the Victorians and the agricultural use of sewage’, History Today (1981) 31, pp. 32–36Google Scholar; Gille, Zsuzsa, From the Cult of Waste to the Trash Heap of History: The Politics of Waste in Socialist and Postsocialist Hungary, Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 2007Google Scholar; see also Mårald, Erland, ‘Everything circulates: agricultural chemistry and recycling theories in the second half of the nineteenth century’, Environment and History (2002) 8, pp. 65–84Google Scholar.
4 But see Woodward, Donald, ‘Swords into ploughshares: recycling in pre-industrial England’, Economic History Review (1985) 38, pp. 175–191CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lemire, Beverly, ‘Consumerism in pre-industrial and early industrial England: the trade in second-hand clothes’, Journal of British Studies (1988) 27, pp. 1–24Google Scholar; Fontaine, Laurence (ed.), Alternative Exchanges: Second-Hand Circulations from the Sixteenth Century to Today, Oxford: Berghahn Books, 2008Google Scholar.
5 On circulation see Secord, James, ‘Knowledge in transit’, Isis (2004) 95, pp. 654–672Google Scholar; Livingstone, David, Putting Science in Its Place: Geographies of Scientific Knowledge, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2003, pp. 135–178CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
6 Edgerton, David, The Shock of the Old: Technology and Global History since 1900, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007Google Scholar; Oudshoorn, Nelly and Pinch, Trevor (eds.), How Users Matter: The Co-construction of Users and Technology, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2003Google Scholar.
7 Strasser, op. cit. (1). The use of the term ‘stewardship’ has been criticized in environmental studies, but here it is only meant to designate a form of careful management intended to preserve and make good use of materials.
8 Strasser, op. cit. (1), p. 22; see also Rogers, Heather, Gone Tomorrow: The Hidden Life of Garbage, New York: New Press, 2005, pp. 29–32Google Scholar.
9 Strasser, op. cit. (1), pp. 22–23.
10 On early modern waste disposal, see Cockayne, Emily, Hubbub: Filth, Noise and Stench in England, 1600–1770, New Haven: Yale University Press, 2007, pp. 183–191Google Scholar.
11 Quoted in Woodward, op. cit. (4), p. 178; ‘Scavengers’, A New and Complete Dictionary of Arts and Sciences … The Second Edition, vol. 4, London, 1764, p. 2879.
12 The examples are taken from Woodward, op. cit. (4), pp. 186, 188–189.
13 Shapin, Steven, ‘The house of experiment in 17th-century England’, Isis (1988) 79, pp. 373–404Google Scholar, 378.
14 Pamela H. Smith, ‘Laboratories’, in Lorraine Daston and Katharine Park (eds.), The Cambridge History of Science, vol. 3: Early Modern Europe, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 290–305; Crosland, Maurice, ‘Early laboratories c.1600–1800 and the location of experimental science’, Annals of Science (2005) 62, pp. 233–253Google Scholar.
15 Harkness writes, ‘for a relatively brief time the household bridged the gap between monastery and laboratory as a site for the practice of natural philosophy’. Harkness, Deborah E., ‘Managing an experimental household: the Dees of Mortlake and the practice of natural philosophy’, Isis (1997) 88, pp. 247–262CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 249.
16 Boyle, Robert, New Experiments and Observations Touching Cold, or, An Experimental History of Cold, London, 1665, pp. 109–132Google Scholar.
17 Boyle, Robert, Experiments and Considerations about the Porosity of Bodies in Two Essays, London, 1684, p. 63Google Scholar.
18 Robert Boyle, ‘Memoirs for an experimental history of cold’, in Philosophical Works of the Honorable Robert Boyle, ed. Peter Shaw, 3 vols., London, 1738, vol. 1, pp. 573–730, 652.
19 Boyle, Robert, ‘The usefulness of experimental philosophy; by way of extortion to study it’, in Philosophical Works of the Honorable Robert Boyle, op. cit. (18), vol. 1, pp. 3–181, 109Google Scholar.
20 Boyle, Robert, Certain Physiological Essays and Other Tracts Written at Distant Times, and on Several Occasions, London, 1669, p. 189Google Scholar.
21 Boyle, Robert, Memoirs for the Natural History of Humane Blood, Especially the Spirit of that Liquor, London, 1683, p. 76Google Scholar.
22 Boyle, Robert, New Experiments Physico-mechanical, Touching the Air, London, 1682, pp. 63–64Google Scholar.
23 Sir Digby, Kenelm, A Discourse Concerning the Vegetation of Plants Spoken by Sir Kenelme Digby at Gresham College on the 23 of January, 1660, London, 1661, pp. 76–77Google Scholar. On Digby's laboratory see Feingold, Mordechai, The Mathematicians’ Apprenticeship: Science, Universities and Society in England, 1560–1640, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984, pp. 181–182Google Scholar.
24 Francis Bacon, The Philosophical Works of Francis Bacon, Baron of Verulam, ed. Peter Shaw, 3 vols., London, 1733, vol. 3, p. 121.
25 Bacon, op. cit. (24), vol. 1, p. 291.
26 Bacon, op. cit. (24), vol. 3, p. 12.
27 On the Bruegel image see Principe, Lawrence M. and DeWitt, Lloyd, Transmutations: Alchemy in Art: Selected Works from the Eddleman and Fisher Collections at the Chemical Heritage Foundation, Philadelphia: Chemical Heritage Foundation, 2002, pp. 11–12Google Scholar.
28 Newman, William R., Promethean Ambitions: Alchemy and the Quest to Perfect Nature, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2004, pp. 73–74Google Scholar.
29 Moran, Bruce, Distilling Knowledge: Alchemy, Chemistry, and the Scientific Revolution, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2005, p. 53Google Scholar.
30 Moran, op. cit. (29), pp. 62–64; Kavey, Allison, Books of Secrets: Natural Philosophy in England, 1550–1600, Champaign: University of Illinois Press, 2007, pp. 95–125Google Scholar.
31 Quoted in Woodward, op. cit. (4), pp. 177–178.
32 Woodward, op. cit. (4), pp. 185–186; Strano, Giorgio, ‘Galileo's telescope: history, scientific analysis, and replicated observations’, Experimental Astronomy (2009) 25, pp. 17–31Google Scholar, 22.
33 Owen Gingerich, ‘Astronomical paper instruments with moving parts’, in Robert Anderson, James A. Bennett and W.F. Ryan (eds.), Making Instruments Count: Essays on Historical Scientific Instruments presented to Gerard L'Estrange Turner, Aldershot: Variorum, 1993, pp. 63–74.
34 Elaine Leong has highlighted the use of cooking and household implements in the making of medicaments in early modern households. See her ‘Making medicines in the early modern household’, Bulletin of the History of Medicine (2008) 82, pp. 145–168, 162; see also Enoch, J.M., ‘Nicholas de Cusa (1401–1464): a description of fine grained and polished wooden spoons employed as mirrors; concave, convex, flat and cylindrical (1450 AD)’, Hindsight (2003) 34, pp. 1–3Google Scholar.
35 Crosland, Maurice, ‘Priestley Memorial Lecture: a practical perspective on Joseph Priestley as a pneumatic chemist’, BJHS (1983) 16, pp. 223–238Google Scholar, 233; on Watt see Hills, Richard L., James Watt, vol. 1: His Time in Scotland, 1736–1774, Ashbourne: Landmark Publishing, 2002Google Scholar.
36 Priestley, Joseph, Experiments and Observations on Different Kinds of Air, 3 vols., Birmingham, 1790Google Scholar; Kraus reprint, 1970, vol. 1, pp. 16, 20, 51. Tobacco pipes were also used as stirrers. See Dossie, Robert, The Elaboratory Laid Open: Or the Secrets of Modern Chemistry and Pharmacy Revealed, London, 1758, p. 273Google Scholar.
37 General Collection of the University of Pennsylvania, 1740–1820. UPA 3. Matriculation and Lecture Ticket Collection 1620. Morgan, John. Materia. Medica and Practice of Physick: incomplete, 1765. Thanks for this reference to Karen Reeds.
38 Bergeret, Jean-Pierre, Phytonomatotechnie universelle, Paris, 1783, p. 158Google Scholar. Thanks for this reference to Sara T. Scharf.
39 See Friedlander, Eli, J.J. Rousseau: An Afterlife of Words, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2004, pp. 74, 163Google Scholar.
40 British Library Add Mss 34716; Keynes, Geoffrey, ed., The Library of Edward Gibbon, 2nd edn, Godalming: St Paul's Bibliographies, 1980Google Scholar.
41 Arden, James, Analysis of Mr. Arden's Course of Lectures on Natural and Experimental Philosophy, London, 1782, p. 10Google Scholar.
42 Bradley, Richard, A Course of Lectures, upon the Materia Medica, Antient and Modern, London, 1730, p. 33Google Scholar.
43 Peter, Charles, New Observations on the Venereal Disease, with the True Way of Curing the Same. The Third Edition, London, 1709, pp. 22–23Google Scholar, 22.
44 Knight, Thomas, A Vindication of a Late Essay on the Transmutation of Blood, Containing The True Manner of Digestion of our Aliments, and the Aetiology, London, 1731, p. 220Google Scholar.
45 Watson, Richard, Chemical Essays, 2 vols., London, 1782, vol. 1, pp. 225–226Google Scholar.
46 Watson, op. cit. (45), vol. 1, p. 237.
47 Numerous instances are to be found in e.g. Hall, A. Rupert and Boas Hall, Marie (eds.), The Correspondence of Henry Oldenburg, 10 vols., Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1965–1975Google Scholar; see also Smith, Pamela H. and Findlen, Paula (eds.), Merchants and Marvels: Commerce, Science, and Art in Early Modern Europe, London: Routledge, 2001Google Scholar; Biagioli, Mario, ‘Galileo's system of patronage’, History of Science (1990) 28, pp. 1–50CrossRefGoogle Scholar, 18–25; Paula Findlen, ‘The economy of scientific exchange in early modern Italy’, in Bruce T. Moran (ed.), Patronage and Institutions: Science, Technology, and Medicine at the European Court, 1500–1750, Rochester: Boydell Press, 1991, pp. 5–24.
48 Fara, Patricia, ‘“A treasure of hidden vertues”: the attraction of magnetic marketing’, BJHS (1995) 28, pp. 5–35Google Scholar, 16; Robert Boyle, ‘An exact copy of the last will and testament of the honourable Robert Boyle’, in The Works of the Honourable Robert Boyle. In Six Volumes. To Which is Prefixed the Life of the Author, ed. Thomas Birch, London, 1772, vol. 1, pp. clviii–clxxi, clx.
49 Gordon, Alexander, ‘John Horsley (1685–1732)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, vol. 9, pp. 1276–1277Google Scholar; Schofield, Robert, The Enlightenment of Joseph Priestley: A Study of His Life and Work from 1733 to 1773, University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 1997, p. 142Google Scholar.
50 Folkes, Martin, ‘Some account of Mr. Leeuwenhoek's curious microscopes, lately presented to the Royal Society’, Philosophical Transactions 32 (1722–1723), pp. 446–453Google Scholar, 447.
51 Stewart, Larry, ‘Other centres of calculation, or, where the Royal Society didn't count: commerce, coffee-houses and natural philosophy in early modern London’, BJHS (1999) 32, pp. 133–153Google Scholar; Giles Mandelbrote, ‘The organization of book auctions in late seventeenth-century London’, in Robin Myers, Michael Harris and Giles Mandelbrote (eds.), Under the Hammer: Book Auctions since the Seventeenth Century, New Castle: Oak Knoll Press, 2001, pp. 15–36. For scientific auctions see de Clercq, Peter, ‘Private instrument collections sold at auction in London in the late 18th Century’, Bulletin of the Scientific Instrument Society (2007) 95, pp. 28–36Google Scholar, and (2009) 100, pp. 27–35; Millburn, John R., Retailer of the Sciences: Benjamin Martin's Scientific Instrument Catalogues, 1756–1782, London: Vade-Mecum Press, 1986, pp. 72–88Google Scholar; Chalmers-Hunt, J.M., Natural Historical Auctions 1700–1972: A Register of Sales in the British Isles, London: Sotheby Parke Bernet, 1976Google Scholar.
52 Robert Hooke, The Diary of Robert Hooke, 1672–1680, ed. Henry W. Robinson and Walter Adams, London: Wykeham Publications Ltd, 1968, pp. 360–361, 414; Rostenberg, Leona, The Library of Robert Hooke: The Scientific Book Trade of Restoration England, Santa Monica: Modoc Press, 1989, pp. 66–81Google Scholar.
53 Wall, Cynthia, ‘The English auction: narratives of dismantlings’, Eighteenth-Century Studies (1997) 31, pp. 1–25Google Scholar.
54 Robert Boyle, ‘A physico-chemical essay, containing an experiment with some considerations touching the differing parts and redintegration of salt-petre’, in Boyle, op. cit. (20), pp. 129–158, 130.
55 Robert Boyle, ‘An essay of the intestine motions of the particles of quiescent solids. Where the absolute rest of bodies is called in question’, in Boyle, op. cit. (20), pp. 1–30, 24.
56 Berg, Maxine, Luxury and Pleasure in Eighteenth-Century Britain, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005, p. 123Google Scholar; see also Newcomb, Sally, The World in a Crucible: Laboratory Practice and Geological Theory at the Beginning of Geology, Boulder: Geological Society of America, 2009, p. 80CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
57 Wheler quoted in Schaffer, Simon, ‘Experimenters' techniques, dyers' hands and the Electric Planetarium’, Isis (1997) 88, pp. 456–483Google Scholar, 471.
58 Boyle, Robert, A continuation of New Experiments Physico-mechanical, Touching the Spring and Weight of the Air and their Effects, London, 1669, p. 13Google Scholar. Boyle heated the air with hot iron or tongs held near the receiver of the air-pump, but ‘without making it touch the Instrument, for fear of breaking it’. Boyle, Robert, Animadversions upon Mr. Hobbes's Problemata de vacuo, London, 1674, p. 72Google Scholar. Investigating the claim that mixtures of water and nitre froze the water, Boyle used a weather-glass, removing it from cold water ‘to avoid injuring the instrument’. Boyle, op. cit. (16), p. 595.
59 Dossie, op. cit. (36), p. 282.
60 Macquer, Pierre Joseph, Elements of the Theory and Practice of Chymistry, 3 vols., London, 1758, vol. 2, p. 137Google Scholar.
61 Dunn, Richard, ‘Touching and cleaning: the routine work of an East London instrument supplier’, Bulletin of the Scientific Instrument Society (2006) 89, pp. 21–26Google Scholar, 22.
62 British Museum, Sarah Banks collection of trade cards, Banks 66.35.
63 On Galileo see Valeriani, Matteo, Galileo: Engineer, Dordrecht: Springer, 2010, pp. 23, 221Google Scholar. Watt adapted a flute as the handle for an auger; see Wright, Michael, ‘James Watt: musical instrument maker’, Galpin Society Journal (2002), 55, pp. 104–129Google Scholar, 114.
64 See, for example, Dossie, op. cit. (36), pp. 49–52; Sara Pennell, ‘For a crack and a flaw despis'd’: thinking about ceramic semi-durability and the “everyday” in early modern England’, in Tara Hamling and Catherine Richardson (eds.), Everyday Things: Medieval and Early Modern Material Culture, Farnham: Ashgate, 2010, pp. 27–40, 36.
65 Boyle, Robert, ‘Essay X. Of men's great ignorance of the uses of natural things: or, that there is scarce any one thing in Nature, wherof the uses to human life are yet thoroughly understood’, in The Works of the Honourable Robert Boyle, op. cit. (48), vol. 3, pp. 470–494Google Scholar.
66 Morrison-Low, Alison D., Making Scientific Instruments in the Industrial Revolution, Aldershot: Ashgate, 2007Google Scholar, pp. 75, 122, 170, 204, 266–267.
67 On colonial instrument-makers and repairs see Bedini, Silvio A., Thinkers and Tinkers: Early American Men of Science, New York: Scribners, 1975, pp. 184–204Google Scholar.
68 Schaffer, Simon, ‘Easily cracked: scientific instruments in states of disrepair’, Isis (December 2011) 102(4), pp. 706–717CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed.
69 Hooke, op. cit. (52), pp. 17, 144, 164, 239, 355.
70 Berg, op. cit. (56), pp. 125–126.
71 See, for example, Wilson, Benjamin, ‘New experiments upon the Leyden phial, respecting the termination of conductors’, Philosophical Transactions (1778) 68, pp. 999–1012Google Scholar, 1011–1012.
72 Morgan, George Cadogan, Lectures on Electricity, 2 vols., Norwich, 1794Google Scholar, vol. 2, p. 460; see also Adams, George, An Essay on Electricity, Explaining the Principles of that Useful Science, London, 1799, p. 271Google Scholar.
73 Cavallo, Tiberius, A Complete Treatise of Electricity in Theory and Practice, London: E. & C. Dilly, 1777, p. 145Google Scholar.
74 Antoine-Laurent Lavoisier, Elements of Chemistry (tr. Robert Kerr), London, 1790, p. 377.
75 Lavoisier, op. cit. (74), p. 377.
76 Priestley, op. cit. (36), p. 22.
77 Vaquelin, Nicolas-Louis, ‘On the use of the new metal called chrome, the oxyd of chrome, and the chromic acid’, Philosophical Magazine (1798) 2, pp. 74–77Google Scholar, 76.
78 Pallas, quoted in Vaquelin, op. cit. (77), p. 77.
79 Torbern Bergman, Physical and Chemical Essays (tr. Edward Cullen), London, 1788, vol. 2, p. 87.
80 Marshall, William, ‘Experiments and Observations concerning Agriculture and the Weather’, Critical Review: or, Annals of Literature (1779) 48, pp. 444–453Google Scholar, 451.
81 Quoted in Crosland, op. cit. (35), p. 232; see also Lavoisier, op. cit. (74), p. 377.
82 Cavallo, op. cit. (73), p. 144.
83 Boyle, Robert, Advertisements about the Experiments and Notes Relating to Chymical Qualities, London, 1675, p. 6Google Scholar.
84 Johann Sigismund Elsholtz, The Curious Distillatory, or, The Art of Distilling Coloured Liquors, Spirits, Oyls, &c. from Vegitables, Animals, Minerals and Metals (tr. Thomas Sherley), London, 1677, ‘To the Reader’.
85 Priestley, Joseph, Experiments and Observations Relating to Various Branches of Natural Philosophy; with a Continuation of the Observations on Air, London, 1779, pp. 202–203Google Scholar.
86 For the Boyle quotations see Boyle, op. cit. (65), pp. 486, 488–489. For the history of meanings of thrift see Peggy A. Knapp, ‘Thrift’, in Robert Edwards (ed.), Art and Context in Late Medieval English Narrative: Essays in Honor of Robert Worth Frank, Jr, Woodbridge: Boydell & Brewer Ltd, 1994, pp. 193–205; Yates, Joshua and Hunter, James Davison (eds.), Thrift and Thriving in America: Capitalism and Moral Order from the Puritans to the Present, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011Google Scholar; Max Weber, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (ed. Richard Swedberg), New York: Norton, 2008.
87 On Puritan notions of thrift see James Calvin Davis and Charles Mathewes, ‘Saving grace and moral striving: thrift in Puritan theology’, in Yates and Hunter, op. cit. (86), pp. 88–116; Weintraub, Karl. J., ‘The Puritan ethic and Benjamin Franklin’, Journal of Religion (1976) 56, pp. 223–237Google Scholar.
88 Robert Boyle, ‘An account of Philaretus during his minority’, in The Works of the Honourable Robert Boyle, op. cit. (48), vol. 1, pp. xii–xxvi.
89 On thrift among New England Puritans in Franklin's time see Stephen Innes, ‘Thrift and prosperity’, in Yates and Hunter, op. cit. (86), pp. 117–138.
90 Innes, op. cit. (89), p. 133.
91 Bass, Edward, The Character of the Beloved Disciple. A Sermon Preached before the Ancient and Honorable Society of Free and Accepted Masons at St. Paul's, Newbury, MA, 1780, p. 30Google Scholar.
92 Franklin, Benjamin, Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin, New York: Modern Library, 1944Google Scholar, pp. 10, 17, 50.
93 Franklin, op. cit. (92), pp. 87–89.
94 Franklin, op. cit. (92), pp. 140–142, 145.
95 Franklin, op. cit. (92), p. 94; Fiering, Norman S., ‘Benjamin Franklin and the way to virtue’, American Quarterly (1978) 30, pp. 199–223Google Scholar.
96 Franklin, op. cit. (92), p. 209.
97 Franklin, op. cit. (92), p. 90.
98 H. Otto Sibum, ‘Nature's bookkeeper: Benjamin Franklin's electrical research and the development of experimental natural philosophy in the 18th Century’, in J.A. Leo Lemay (ed.), Reappraising Benjamin Franklin: A Bicentennial Perspective, Newark: University of Delaware Press, 1993, pp. 221–246.
99 Pennell, op. cit. (64), pp. 31–32.
100 Babbage, Charles, Economy of Machines & Manufactures, 3rd edn, London, 1846Google Scholar, pp. 6, 11–12, 393–396.
101 Faraday, Michael, Chemical Manipulation, 3rd edn, London, 1842Google Scholar.
102 Faraday, op. cit. (101), p. 371.
103 Faraday, op. cit. (101), p. 865.
104 Faraday, op. cit. (101), p. 863.
105 Wood, Alexander, The Cavendish Laboratory, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1946, p. 18Google Scholar; Stuart Blume, ‘Whatever happened to the string and sealing wax?’, in Robert Bud, Susan E. Cozzens and Roy F. Porter (eds.), Invisible Connections: Instruments, Institutions and Science, Bellingham: SPIE Optical Engineering Press, 1992, pp. 87–101.
106 Quoted in Fawcett, Ruth, Nuclear Pursuits: The Scientific Biography of Wilfrid Bennett Lewis, Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1994, pp. 7, 26Google Scholar.
107 Spufford, Francis, Backroom Boys: The Secret Return of the British Boffin, London: Faber and Faber, 2004Google Scholar.
108 US Environmental Protection Agency/US Department of Energy, Laboratories for the 21st Century: An Introduction to Low-Energy Design, Golden: National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 2008, p. 1Google Scholar.
109 See the website of the University of California at Santa Barbara Laboratory Research and Technical Staff, http://sustainability.ucsb.edu/LARS, accessed 28 June 2011.
110 UCSB, op. cit. (109), http://sustainability.ucsb.edu/LARS/best_practices/electronics_apparatus/electronic_repairs.php, accessed 28 June 2011.
