Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

A critical review of predefined diet quality scores

  • Patricia M. C. M. Waijers (a1), Edith J. M. Feskens (a1) and Marga C. Ocké (a1)

Abstract

The literature on predefined indexes of overall diet quality is reviewed. Their association with nutrient adequacy and health outcome is considered, but our primary interest is in the make-up of the scores. In total, twenty different indexes have been reviewed, four of which have gained most attention, and many others were based on those four. The various scores differ in many respects, such as the items included, the cut-off values used, and the exact method of scoring, indicating that many arbitrary choices have been made. Correlations in intake between dietary components may not be adequately addressed. In general, diet quality scores show an association with mortality or disease risk, but these relations are generally modest. Existing indexes do not predict morbidity or mortality significantly better than individual dietary factors. Although conclusions from the review may provide guidance in the construction of a diet quality score, it is questionable whether a dietary score can be obtained that is a much better predictor of health outcome.

  • View HTML
    • Send article to Kindle

      To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure no-reply@cambridge.org is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.

      Note you can select to send to either the @free.kindle.com or @kindle.com variations. ‘@free.kindle.com’ emails are free but can only be sent to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘@kindle.com’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

      Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

      A critical review of predefined diet quality scores
      Available formats
      ×

      Send article to Dropbox

      To send this article to your Dropbox account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Dropbox.

      A critical review of predefined diet quality scores
      Available formats
      ×

      Send article to Google Drive

      To send this article to your Google Drive account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Google Drive.

      A critical review of predefined diet quality scores
      Available formats
      ×

Copyright

Corresponding author

*Marga Ocké, fax +31 30 2744466; MC.Ocke@rivm.nl

References

Hide All
Bernstein, MA, Tucker, KL, Ryan, ND, O'Neill, EF, Clements, KM, Nelson, ME, Evans, WJ & Fiatarone Singh, MA (2002) Higher dietary variety is associated with better nutritional status in frail elderly people. J Am Diet Assoc 102, 10961104.
Bosetti, C, Gallus, S, Trichopoulou, A, Talamini, R, Franceschi, S, Negri, E & La Vecchia, C (2003) Influence of the Mediterranean diet on the risk of cancers of the upper aerodigestive tract. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 12, 10911094.
Brennan, CS (2005) Dietary fibre, glycaemic response, and diabetes. Mol Nutr Food Res 49, 560570.
Chan, JK, McDonald, BE, Gerrard, JM, Bruce, VM, Weaver, BJ & Holub, BJ (1993) Effect of dietary alpha-linolenic acid and its ratio to linoleic acid on platelet and plasma fatty acids and thrombogenesis. Lipids 28, 811817.
Choi, HK, Willett, WC, Stampfer, MJ, Rimm, E & Hu, FB (2005) Dairy consumption and risk of type 2 diabetes mellitus in men: a prospective study. Arch Intern Med 165, 9971003.
de Lorgeril, M, Salen, P, Martin, JL, Monjaud, I, Boucher, P & Mamelle, N (1998) Mediterranean dietary pattern in a randomized trial: prolonged survival and possible reduced cancer rate. Arch Intern Med 158, 11811187.
de Lorgeril, M, Salen, P, Martin, JL, Monjaud, I, Delaye, J & Mamelle, N (1999) Mediterranean diet, traditional risk factors, and the rate of cardiovascular complications after myocardial infarction: final report of the Lyon Diet Heart Study. Circulation 99, 779785.
Drewnowski, A, Henderson, SA, Driscoll, A & Rolls, BJ (1997) The Dietary Variety Score: assessing diet quality in healthy young and older adults. J Am Diet Assoc 97, 266271.
Drewnowski, A, Henderson, SA, Shore, AB, Fischler, C, Preziosi, P & Hercberg, S (1996) Diet quality and dietary diversity in France: implications for the French paradox. J Am Diet Assoc 96, 663669.
Dubois, L, Girard, M & Bergeron, N (2000) The choice of a diet quality indicator to evaluate the nutritional health of populations. Public Health Nutr 3, 357365.
Fanelli, MT & Stevenhagen, KJ (1985) Characterizing consumption patterns by food frequency methods: core foods and variety of foods in diets of older Americans. J Am Diet Assoc 85, 15701576.
Fernandez, E, D'Avanzo, B, Negri, E, Franceschi, S & La Vecchia, C (1996) Diet diversity and the risk of colorectal cancer in northern Italy. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 5, 433436.
Fernandez, E, Negri, E, La Vecchia, C & Franceschi, S (2000) Diet diversity and colorectal cancer. Prev Med 31, 1114.
Food Guide Pyramid (1992) A guide to daily food choices. Washington, DC: US Department of Agriculture, Human Nutrition Information service, 1992. Home and Garden Bulletin No. 252.
Fung, TT, Hu, FB, Pereira, MA, Liu, S, Stampfer, MJ, Colditz, GA & Willett, WC (2002) Whole-grain intake and the risk of type 2 diabetes: a prospective study in men. Am J Clin Nutr 76, 535540.
Fung, TT, McCullough, ML, Newby, PK, Manson, JE, Meigs, JB, Rifai, N, Willett, WC & Hu, FB (2005) Diet-quality scores and plasma concentrations of markers of inflammation and endothelial dysfunction. Am J Clin Nutr 82, 163173.
Gerber, MJ, Scali, JD, Michaud, A, Durand, MD, Astre, CM, Dallongeville, J & Romon, MM (2000) Profiles of a healthful diet and its relationship to biomarkers in a population sample from Mediterranean southern France. J Am Diet Assoc 100, 11641171.
Haines, PS, Siega-Riz, AM & Popkin, BM (1999) The Diet Quality Index revised: a measurement instrument for populations. J Am Diet Assoc 99, 697704.
Hann, CS, Rock, CL, King, I & Drewnowski, A (2001) Validation of the Healthy Eating Index with use of plasma biomarkers in a clinical sample of women. Am J Clin Nutr 74, 479486.
Harnack, L, Nicodemus, K, Jacobs, DR Jr & Folsom, AR (2002) An evaluation of the Dietary Guidelines for Americans in relation to cancer occurrence. Am J Clin Nutr 76, 889896.
Haveman-Nies, A, de Groot, LP, Burema, J, Cruz, JA, Osler, M & van Staveren, WA (2002) Dietary quality and lifestyle factors in relation to 10-year mortality in older Europeans: the SENECA study. Am J Epidemiol 156, 962968.
Haveman-Nies, A, Tucker, KL, de Groot, LC, Wilson, PW & van Staveren, WA (2001) Evaluation of dietary quality in relationship to nutritional and lifestyle factors in elderly people of the US Framingham Heart Study and the European SENECA study. Eur J Clin Nutr 55, 870880.
Hu, FB (2002) Dietary pattern analysis: a new direction in nutritional epidemiology. Curr Opin Lipidol 13, 39.
Hu, FB, Manson, JE & Willett, WC (2001) Types of dietary fat and risk of coronary heart disease: a critical review. J Am Coll Nutr 20, 519.
Hu, FB, Stampfer, MJ, Manson, JE, Rimm, EB, Wolk, A, Colditz, GA, Hennekens, CH & Willett, WC (1999) Dietary intake of alpha-linolenic acid and risk of fatal ischemic heart disease among women. Am J Clin Nutr 69, 890897.
Huijbregts, P, Feskens, E, Rasanen, L, Fidanza, F, Nissinen, A, Menotti, A & Kromhout, D (1997a) Dietary pattern and 20 year mortality in elderly men in Finland, Italy, and The Netherlands: longitudinal cohort study. BMJ 315, 1317.
Huijbregts, PP, Feskens, EJ, Rasanen, L, Fidanza, F, Alberti-Fidanza, A, Nissinen, A, Giampaoli, S & Kromhout, D (1998) Dietary patterns and cognitive function in elderly men in Finland, Italy and The Netherlands. Eur J Clin Nutr 52, 826831.
Huijbregts, PPCW, Vegt de, F, Feskens, EJM, Bowles, CH & Kromhout, D (1997b) Dietary patterns and mortality in an elderly population in the Netherlands. A comparison between cluster analysis and the healthy diet indicator. In Dietary Patterns and Health in the Elderly, pp. 3342 [Huijbregts, PPCW, editor]. The Netherlands: Wageningen University.
International Agency for Research on Cancer (2003) IARC Handbooks of Cancer Prevention. vol. 8: Fruits and Vegetables. Lyon: IARC Press.
Jensen, MK, Koh-Banerjee, P, Hu, FB, Franz, M, Sampson, L, Gronbaek, M & Rimm, EB (2004) Intakes of whole grains, bran, and germ and the risk of coronary heart disease in men. Am J Clin Nutr 80, 14921499.
Joshipura, KJ, Ascherio, A, Manson, JE, Stampfer, MJ, Rimm, EB, Speizer, FE, Hennekens, CH, Spiegelman, D & Willett, WC (1999) Fruit and vegetable intake in relation to risk of ischemic stroke. JAMA 282, 12331239.
Joshipura, KJ, Hu, FB, Manson, JE, et al. (2001) The effect of fruit and vegetable intake on risk for coronary heart disease. Ann Intern Med 134, 11061114.
Kant, AK (1996) Indexes of overall diet quality: a review. J Am Diet Assoc 96, 785791.
Kant, AK (2004) Dietary patterns and health outcomes. J Am Diet Assoc 104, 615635.
Kant, AK, Schatzkin, A, Graubard, BI & Schairer, C (2000) A prospective study of diet quality and mortality in women. JAMA 283, 21092115.
Kant, AK, Schatzkin, A, Harris, TB, Ziegler, RG & Block, G (1993) Dietary diversity and subsequent mortality in the first national health and nutrition examination survey epidemiologic follow-up study. Am J Clin Nutr 57, 434440.
Kant, AK & Thompson, FE (1997) Measures of overall diet quality from a food frequency questionnaire: National Health Interview Survey, 1992. Nutr Res 17, 14431456.
Kennedy, ET, Bowman, SA, Spence, JT, Freedman, M & King, J (2001) Popular diets: correlation to health, nutrition, and obesity. J Am Diet Assoc 101, 411420.
Kennedy, ET, Ohls, J, Carlson, S & Fleming, K (1995) The Healthy Eating Index: design and applications. J Am Diet Assoc 95, 11031108.
Kim, S, Haines, PS, Siega-Riz, AM & Popkin, BM (2003) The Diet Quality Index-International (DQI-I) provides an effective tool for cross-national comparison of diet quality as illustrated by China and the United States. J Nutr 133, 34763484.
King, DE (2005) Dietary fiber, inflammation, and cardiovascular disease. Mol Nutr Food Res 49, 594600.
Knoops, KT, de Groot, LC, Kromhout, D, Perrin, AE, Moreiras-Varela, O, Menotti, A & van Staveren, WA (2004) Mediterranean diet, lifestyle factors, and 10-year mortality in elderly European men and women: the HALE project. JAMA 292, 14331439.
Kouris-Blazos, A, Gnardellis, C, Wahlqvist, ML, Trichopoulos, D, Lukito, W & Trichopoulou, A (1999) Are the advantages of the Mediterranean diet transferable to other populations? A cohort study in Melbourne. Australia. Br J Nutr 82, 5761.
Kushi, L, Lenart, E & Willett, W (1995) Health implications of Mediterranean diets in light of contemporary knowledge. 2. Meat, wine, fats, and oils. Am J Clin Nutr 61, 1416S1427S.
La Vecchia, C, Munoz, SE, Braga, C, Fernandez, E & Decarli, A (1997) Diet diversity and gastric cancer. Int J Cancer 72, 255257.
Lasheras, C, Fernandez, S & Patterson, AM (2000) Mediterranean diet and age with respect to overall survival in institutionalized, nonsmoking elderly people. Am J Clin Nutr 71, 987992.
Liu, S (2003) Whole-grain foods, dietary fiber, and type 2 diabetes: searching for a kernel of truth. Am J Clin Nutr 77, 527529.
Lowik, MRH, Hulshof, KFAM & Brussaard, JH (1999) Food-based dietary guidelines: some assumptions tested for the Netherlands. Br J Nutr 81, s143s149.
Madden, JP & Yoder, MD (1972) Program evaluation: food stamps and commodity distribution in rural areas of central Pennsylvania. Penn Agr Exp Sta Bull 78, 1119.
Massari, M, Freeman, KM, Seccareccia, F, Menotti, A & Farchi, G (2004) An index to measure the association between dietary patterns and coronary heart disease risk factors: findings from two Italian studies. Prev Med 39, 841847.
McCullough, ML, Feskanich, D, Rimm, EB, Giovannucci, EL, Ascherio, A, Variyam, JN, Spiegelman, D, Stampfer, MJ & Willett, WC (2000a) Adherence to the Dietary Guidelines for Americans and risk of major chronic disease in men. Am J Clin Nutr 72, 12231231.
McCullough, ML, Feskanich, D, Stampfer, MJ, et al. (2002) Diet quality and major chronic disease risk in men and women: moving toward improved dietary guidance. Am J Clin Nutr 76, 12611271.
McCullough, ML, Feskanich, D, Stampfer, MJ, Rosner, BA, Hu, FB, Hunter, DJ, Variyam, JN, Colditz, GA & Willett, WC (2000b) Adherence to the Dietary Guidelines for Americans and risk of major chronic disease in women. Am J Clin Nutr 72, 12141222.
McKeown, NM, Meigs, JB, Liu, S, Wilson, PW & Jacques, PF (2002) Whole-grain intake is favorably associated with metabolic risk factors for type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease in the Framingham Offspring Study. Am J Clin Nutr 76, 390398.
Michels, KB & Wolk, A (2002) A prospective study of variety of healthy foods and mortality in women. Int J Epidemiol 31, 847854.
National Research Council. Committee on Diet and Health, FaNB (1989) Diet and Health. Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences.
Newby, PK, Hu, FB, Rimm, EB, Smith-Warner, SA, Feskanich, D, Sampson, L & Willett, WC (2003) Reproducibility and validity of the Diet Quality Index Revised as assessed by use of a food-frequency questionnaire. Am J Clin Nutr 78, 941949.
Newby, PK & Tucker, KL (2004) Empirically derived eating patterns using factor or cluster analysis: a review. Nutr Rev 62, 177203.
Oh, K, Hu, FB, Manson, JE, Stampfer, MJ & Willett, WC (2005) Dietary fat intake and risk of coronary heart disease in women: 20 years of follow-up of the nurses' health study. Am J Epidemiol 161, 672679.
Osler, M, Heitmann, BL, Gerdes, LU, Jorgensen, LM & Schroll, M (2001) Dietary patterns and mortality in Danish men and women: a prospective observational study. Br J Nutr 85, 219225.
Osler, M, Helms Andreasen, A, Heitmann, B, Hoidrup, S, Gerdes, U, Morch Jorgensen, L & Schroll, M (2002) Food intake patterns and risk of coronary heart disease: a prospective cohort study examining the use of traditional scoring techniques. Eur J Clin Nutr 56, 568574.
Osler, M & Schroll, M (1997) Diet and mortality in a cohort of elderly people in a north European community. Int J Epidemiol 26, 155159.
Patterson, RE, Haines, PS & Popkin, BM (1994) Diet quality index: capturing a multidimensional behavior. J Am Diet Assoc 94, 5764.
Pereira, MA, Jacobs, DR Jr, Van Horn, L, Slattery, ML, Kartashov, AI & Ludwig, DS (2002) Dairy consumption, obesity, and the insulin resistance syndrome in young adults: the CARDIA Study. JAMA 287, 20812209.
Pitsavos, C, Panagiotakos, DB, Tzima, N, Chrysohoou, C, Economou, M, Zampelas, A & Stefanadis, C (2005) Adherence to the Mediterranean diet is associated with total antioxidant capacity in healthy adults: the ATTICA study. Am J Clin Nutr 82, 694699.
Roche, HM, Zampelas, A, Knapper, JM, et al. (1998) Effect of long-term olive oil dietary intervention on postprandial triacylglycerol and factor VII metabolism. Am J Clin Nutr 68, 552560.
Scali, J, Richard, A & Gerber, M (2001) Diet profiles in a population sample from Mediterranean southern France. Public Health Nutr 4, 173182.
Schroder, H, Marrugat, J, Vila, J, Covas, MI & Elosua, R (2004) Adherence to the traditional Mediterranean diet is inversely associated with body mass index and obesity in a Spanish population. J Nutr 134, 33553361.
Seymour, JD, Calle, EE, Flagg, EW, Coates, RJ, Ford, ES & Thun, MJ (2003) Diet Quality Index as a predictor of short-term mortality in the American Cancer Society Cancer Prevention Study II Nutrition Cohort. Am J Epidemiol 157, 980988.
Slattery, ML, Berry, TD, Potter, J & Caan, B (1997) Diet diversity, diet composition, and risk of colon cancer (United States). Cancer Causes Control 8, 872882.
Solfrizzi, V, D'Introno, A, Colacicco, AM, Capurso, C, Palasciano, R, Capurso, S, Torres, F, Capurso, A & Panza, F (2005) Unsaturated fatty acids intake and all-causes mortality: a 8·5-year follow-up of the Italian Longitudinal Study on Aging. Exp Gerontol 40, 335343.
Trichopoulos, D & Lagious, P (2004) Mediterranean diet and cardiovascular epidemiology. Eur J Epidemiol 19, 78.
Trichopoulou, A, Bamia, C & Trichopoulos, D (2005a) Mediterranean diet and survival among patients with coronary heart disease in Greece. Arch Intern Med 165, 929935.
Trichopoulou, A, Costacou, T, Bamia, C & Trichopoulos, D (2003) Adherence to a Mediterranean diet and survival in a Greek population. N Engl J Med 348, 25992608.
Trichopoulou, A, Kouris-Blazos, A, Wahlqvist, ML, Gnardellis, C, Lagiou, P, Polychronopoulos, E, Vassilakou, T, Lipworth, L & Trichopoulos, D (1995) Diet and overall survival in elderly people. BMJ 311, 14571460.
Trichopoulou, A, Lagiou, P, Kuper, H & Trichopoulos, D (2000) Cancer and Mediterranean dietary traditions. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 9, 869873.
Trichopoulou, A, Orfanos, P, Norat, T, et al. (2005b) Modified Mediterranean diet and survival: EPIC-elderly prospective cohort study. BMJ 330, 991996.
Weinstein, SJ, Vogt, TM & Gerrior, SA (2004) Healthy Eating Index scores are associated with blood nutrient concentrations in the third National Health And Nutrition Examination Survey. J Am Diet Assoc 104, 576584.
Willett, W (1998) Nutritional Epidemiology, 2nd ed. New York: Oxford University Press.
Woo, J, Woo, KS, Leung, SS, et al. (2001) The Mediterranean score of dietary habits in Chinese populations in four different geographical areas. Eur J Clin Nutr 55, 215220.
Zemel, MB & Miller, SL (2004) Dietary calcium and dairy modulation of adiposity and obesity risk. Nutr Rev 62, 125131.

Keywords

A critical review of predefined diet quality scores

  • Patricia M. C. M. Waijers (a1), Edith J. M. Feskens (a1) and Marga C. Ocké (a1)

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed