Skip to main content

The Dog That Hasn't Barked: The Political Economy of Contemporary Debates on Canadian Foreign Investment Policies

  • Geoffrey Hale (a1)

Abstract. This article examines the responses of Canadian business leaders, national newspapers, and governments to record numbers of foreign takeovers of Canadian-based firms in 2004–2007. It assesses the political, economic, financial market, and regulatory contexts for takeover activity in historical, macro-economic, and micro-economic contexts in light of Canada's historically firm-centred business culture. It summarizes five dimensions of policy and media discourse on the interrelated issues of foreign investment and corporate consolidation, including debates on “hollowing out” and “national champions.” It concludes that the limited influence of nationalist and related business interests on recent Canadian government policies reflects Canada's growing economic interdependence with other countries, particularly the growing role played by Canadian-based multinationals in foreign markets.

Résumé. Le présent article examine la réaction des leaders du monde des affaires canadien, des journaux nationaux et des gouvernements devant le nombre record de prises de contrôle étrangères de sociétés exerçant leur activités au Canada entre 2004 et 2007. Il évalue l'activité de prise de contrôle selon les données de la politique, de l'économie, des marchés financiers et de la réglementation, dans des contextes historique, macroéconomique et microéconomique, compte tenu de la culture des affaires canadienne, traditionnellement axée sur l'entreprise. Il présente un sommaire des cinq dimensions des politiques et du discours des médias sur des questions liées : l'investissement étranger et la consolidation des sociétés, dont le débat sur l'«évidement» et les «champions nationaux». Il conclut que le peu d'influence des intérêts commerciaux nationalistes ou apparentés sur les politiques récentes du gouvernement du Canada reflète l'interdépendance croissante entre le Canada et d'autres pays et, notamment, le rôle croissant sur les marchés étrangers des multinationales établies au Canada.

Corresponding author
Geoffrey Hale, University of Lethbridge, 4401 University Drive West, Lethbridge, Alberta T1K 3M4, Canada,
Hide All
Atkinson Michael M. and Coleman William D.. 1989. The State, Business and Industrial Change in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Baldwin John R. and Gellatly Guy. 2005. Global Links: Long-Term Trends in Foreign Investment and Foreign Control in Canada: 1960–2005. Cat. #11-622-MIE, no. 008. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
Baldwin John R. and Gu Wulong. 2005. Multinationals, Foreign Ownership and Productivity Growth in Canada. Cat. #11-622, #9. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
Baldwin John R. and Hanel Peter. 2000. “Multinationals and the Canadian Innovation Process.” Working Paper #151. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
Barnes Angela. 2007. “Brazil exchange hits big time.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), June 7.
Beckstead Desmond and Brown W. Mark. 2006. Head Office Employment in Canada: 1999—2005. Cat. #11-624-MIE #014. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
Bradford Neil. 1998. Commissioning Ideas. Toronto: Oxford University Press.
Canada. Advisory Panel on Efficiencies. 2005. “Treatment of efficiencies under the Competition Act: History and current practice.” Report. Ottawa: Competition Bureau.
Canada. Department of Finance. 2006. Fiscal Reference Tables. Ottawa.
Canada. Department of Finance. 2007. The Budget Plan: 2007. Ottawa.
Canada. Royal Commission on the Economic Union and Development Prospects for Canada. 1985. Report. 3 vol.Ottawa: Supply and Services Canada.
Canada. Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Trade. 2002. Partners in North America: Advancing Canada's Relations with the United States and Mexico. 3rd report. 37th Parliament, 2nd Session. Ottawa: House of Commons.
Canadian Council of Chief Executives (CCCE). 2007. “Competitive Offence is Best Defence against Hollowing Out, Business Leaders Say.” Press release. Ottawa, October 10.
Carmichael Kevin. 2008. “Prentice defends decision to kill takeover.” The Globe and Mail (Toronto), May 9.
Chase Steven. 2007a. “Trust tax under fire as drain on revenue.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), April 9.
Chase Steven. 2007b. “Liberals aim to reduce foreign takeovers.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), May 28.
Chernow Ron. 1990. The House of Morgan. New York: Grove Press.
Clancy Peter. 2004. Micropolitics and Canadian Business: Paper, Steel, and the Airlines. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press.
Clark Campbell. 2008. “The death knell of a deal.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), April 12.
Competition Bureau. 2006. “Proposed Acquisition of Arcelor by Mittal.” Ottawa.
Competition Policy Review Panel. 2007. Sharpening Canada's Competitive Edge. Ottawa: Industry Canada.
Competition Policy Review Panel. 2008. Compete to Win—Final Report. Ottawa: Industry Canada.
Crane David. 2007. “Why we should worry about the economy.” The Toronto Star, 5 November.
D'Alessandro Dominic. 2007. “Ownership rules for other sectors?” National Post. (Toronto), May 4, FP15.
DeCloet Derek. 2007. “Protectionism isn't the cure for the hollowing out of Corporate Canada.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), May 5, B2.
Estey Willard Z. 1999. “The quiet hijacking of corporate Canada.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), December 16.
Financial Post Crosbie. 2004–2008. M&A Quarterly Reports. (June 26, 2008).
Foster Peter. 2007. “Champions are fat, slow, political.” National Post (Toronto), May 26, FP19.
Foster Peter. 2008. “A model of naive interventionism.” National Post (Toronto), June 27, A1.
Gellatly G., Sabourin D. and Baldwin J.. 2006. “Changes in Foreign Control under Different Regulatory Climates: Multinationals in Canada.” Canadian Economic Observer. Cat. #11-010. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
Gera Surendra, Gu Wulong and Lee Frank C.. 1999. Foreign Direct Investment and Productivity Growth: The Canadian Host-Country Experience. Working Paper #30. Ottawa: Industry Canada.
Go Erwin. 2007. Year 2006 in Review. Toronto: Investment Funds Institute of Canada. (October 2, 2007).
Guillemette Yvan and Mintz Jack M.. 2004. A Capital Story: Exploding the Myths around Foreign Investment in Canada. Commentary #201. Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute.
Hale Geoffrey. 2006. Uneasy Partnership: The Politics of Business and Government. Peterborough, ON: Broadview Press.
Harris Richard G., ed. 2003. North American Linkages: Opportunities and Challenges for Canada. Calgary: University of Calgary Press.
Hart Michael. 2002. A Nation of Traders. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.
Haskayne Dick, with Grescoe Paul. 2007. Northern Tigers: Building Ethical Canadian Corporate Champions. Toronto: Key Porter.
Hoffman Andy. 2007. “As rivals merge, Alcan wants to go it alone.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), March 14.
Hurtig Mel. 2002. The Vanishing Country: Is It Too Late to Save Canada? Toronto: McClelland and Stewart.
Hutton Susan M. 2007. “Canada and the EU: Cooperation and Convergence.” The European Antitrust Review 2007.
Keenan Greg. 2007. “Ipsco swept up in tide of consolidation.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), July 17.
Lavoie Francois. 2003. Canadian Direct Investment in Offshore Financial Centres, Cat. #11-621, #021. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
MacIntosh Jeffrey. 2008. “The People's corporate law: Unsafe at any speed.” National Post (Toronto), June 10, FP17.
Mandel-Campbell Andrea. 2007. Why Canadians Don't Drink Molson's: Rescuing Canadian Business from the Suds of Global Obscurity. Vancouver: Douglas & McIntyre.
Marotte Bertrand. 2007. “Beaudoin joins call for takeover protection.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), May 30, B1.
Martin Roger and Nixon Gordon. 2007. “Whoa Canada.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), July 2, B1.
McCallum John. 2007. “Level field for takeovers.” National Post (Toronto), June 5, FP15.
McLean Catherine. 2007. “Scrap foreign ownership limits, OECD study urges.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), Feb. 14.
Milne David. 1986. Tug of War: Trudeau, Mulroney and the Provinces. Toronto: Lorimer.
Morgan Gwyn. 2007. “Head offices can locate anywhere, so make Canada competitive.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), May 14, B2.
Partridge John. 2007. “Foreign takeover fears played down.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), August 22.
Pitts Gordon et al. 2006. “Hollow Fears? For Sale: Corporate Canada.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), September 9–18.
Prentice Hon. Jim. 2007. “Speaking points to Vancouver Board of Trade, October 9, 2007.” Ottawa: Industry Canada.
Prentice Hon. Jim. 2008. “Ottawa must control own technology.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), April 12, A17.
Rousseau Stéphane. 2008. “A case to be heard.” National Post (Toronto), May 30, FP15.
Rubin Jeff, Buchanan Peter and Shenfeld Avery. 2007. “A Merger-Driven Market.” Toronto: CIBC World Markets. (May 17, 2007).
Schwartz Gerald. 2007. “Ottawa should step up for the home team.” The Globe and Mail, May 14, B2.
Silcoff Sean. 2007. “A speed bump in the big steel era.” National Post (Toronto), June 2, FP6.
Silcoff Sean. 2008. “Xenophobia to blame if deal dies.” National Post (Toronto), May 9, FP3.
Simeon Richard and Robinson Ian. 1990. State, Society and the Development of Canadian Federalism. Background Paper. Royal Commission on the Economic Union and Development Prospects for Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Smythe Elizabeth. 2007. “Canada and the Negotiation over Investment Rules at the WTO.” In Readings in Canadian Foreign Policy: Classic Debates and New Ideas, ed. Bratt Duane and Kukucha Christopher J.. Toronto: Oxford University Press.
Statistics Canada. 2001, 2008. Canada's International Investment Position. Cat. #67-202. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
Statistics Canada. 2006. Canada's International Investment Position. Cat. #67-202. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
Statistics Canada. 2007a. “Employer pension plans (trusteed pension plans).” The Daily (Ottawa), March 15.
Statistics Canada. 2007b. “Foreign control in the Canadian economy: 2005.” The Daily (Ottawa), June 14.
Stueck Wendy. 2008. “Veto leaves MDA stuck with unwanted division.” The Globe and Mail (Toronto), April 11, B1.
Supreme Court of Canada. 2008. “BCE Inc. et al. v. A Group of 1976 Debentureholders, et al.—and—Director Appointed Pursuant to the CBCA, Catalyst Asset Management Inc. and Matthew Stuart.” National Post online, June 20.
Tait Carrie. 2007. “Buyers get more aggressive.” Financial Post, 16 May.
Tang Jianmin and Rao Someshwar. 2001. R&D Propensity and R&D Performance of Foreign Controlled Firms in Canada. Working Paper #33. Ottawa: Industry Canada.
Thorpe Jacqueline. 2008. “What business wants.” National Post (Toronto), June 23, FP3.
Verbeke Alain, Huebner Jefferson and Yuan Wenlong. 2006. The NAFTA Effect: Multinational Enterprises in Canada. Ottawa: Conference Board of Canada.
Vieira Paul. 2007a. “No market meddling, PM vows.” National Post (Toronto), June 2, FP7.
Vieira Paul. 2007b. “Panel to eye competition, ownership.” National Post (Toronto), July 13, FP2.
Waverman Leonard, ed. 1991. Corporate Globalization through Mergers and Acquisitions. Calgary: University of Calgary Press.
Wells Jennifer. 2007. “PM fiddles while Alcan sale looms.” Toronto Star, May 30.
Whittington Les. 1999. The Banks. Toronto: Stoddart.
Whittington Les and Brennan Richard. 2008. “Massive overhaul urged on foreign investment.” Toronto Star, June 27.
Willis Andrew. 2007. “Savvy acquirers like to strike while the iron is cold.” Globe and Mail (Toronto), Sept. 7.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique
  • ISSN: 0008-4239
  • EISSN: 1744-9324
  • URL: /core/journals/canadian-journal-of-political-science-revue-canadienne-de-science-politique
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 2
Total number of PDF views: 22 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 397 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 21st February 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.