Skip to main content Accesibility Help

Where Did All The Baby Bottles Go? Risk Perception, Interest Groups, Media Coverage and Institutional Imperatives in Canada's Regulation of Bisphenol A

  • Simon Kiss (a1)

As part of a multi-year, $816 million initiative to assess the risks posed by thousands of commonly used chemicals and compounds, Canada became the first country in the world to declare that bisphenol A (BPA) was toxic and justified regulation in April 2008. The process set up to conduct this risk assessment differed from the previous Canadian experience with the regulation of hazardous substances in that it was more formal, systematic and more pluralistic with much greater participation from interest groups. This case study explores the politics and process behind this decision and argues that the government's decision went beyond what scientific evidence could justify. The decision resulted from long-term institutional factors such as the incentive structure of Canadian federalism and values embedded in legislation as well as short-term factors such as media coverage, public opinion and interest group pressure.

Grâce à une initiative pluriannuelle de 816 millions de dollars pour examiner les risques posés par l'utilisation courante de milliers de produits et de composés chimiques, le Canada est devenu le premier pays dans le monde à déclarer que le bisphenol A (BPA) est un produit toxique et que de ce fait devrait s'en suivre des régulations quant à son utilisation à partir d'avril 2008.

De part le fait que le processus d'évaluation des risques suivi s'est fait sur une base plus formelle, systématique et pluraliste avec davantage de participation de groupes d'intérêt, il diffère de ce que le Canada avait l'habitude en matière de régulation de substances dangereuses. Cette étude de cas examine les politiques et processus qui ont servi à la prise de cette décision et met en avant l'argument qu' en fait le gouvernement ne disposait pas de suffisament de preuves scientifiques pour la justifier. La prise de décision résulterait de l'influence de facteurs institutionnels à long terme tels que des mesures d'incitation du fédéralisme canadien et des valeurs ancrées dans la législation, ainsi que de facteurs à court terme tels que la couverture médiatique, l'opinion publique et la pression des groupes d'intérêt.

Corresponding author
Journalism, Wilfrid Laurier University, 73 George Street, Brantford ON, N3T 2Y3, email:
Hide All
Ashby, J., Tinwell, H, and Haseman, J.. 1999. “Lack of effects for low dose levels of bisphenol A and diethylstilbestrol on the prostate gland of CF1 mice exposed in utero.” Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology 30 (2): 156–66.
Bell, David. 2012. “Nature of an effect: adverse or non-adverse.” EFSA Scientific Colloquium no. 17 on low dose response in toxicology and risk assessment. Parma, Italy. (June 13, 2013).
Brewer, P.R. and Ley, B.L.. 2011. “Multiple Exposures: Scientific Controversy, the Media, and Public Responses to Bisphenol A.” Science Communication 33 (1): 7697.
Canada. Bureau of Chemical Safety. 2008. Health Risk Assessment of Bisphenol A from Food Packaging Applications. Ottawa: Health Canada. (June 30, 2013).
Canada. Environment Canada. 2010. Domestic Substances List. (June 6, 2013).
Canada. Health Canada and Environment Canada. 2008. Screening Assessment for the Challenge Phenol, 4,4' -(1-methylethylidene)bis(Bisphenol A). Ottawa. (June 13, 2013).
Canada. Health Canada. 2008. Proposed Risk Management Approach for Phenol, 4,4'-(1-Methylethylidene) Bis (Bisphenol A). Ottawa: Queen's Printer.
Canada. House of Commons. Standing Committee on the Environment and Sustainable Development. 1995. It's About Our Health: Towards Pollution Prevention. Ottawa: Queen's Printer.
Canada. Privy Council Office. 2003. A Framework for the Application of Precaution in Science-Based Decision Making About Risk. Ottawa: Privy Council Office.
Colborn, T., Dumanoski, D. and Myers, J.P.. 1997. Our Stolen Future: Are We Threatening Our Fertility, Intelligence, and Survival? A Scientific Detective Story. New York: Plume.
Conrad, James W. Jr., and Becker, Richard. 2011. “Enhancing Credibility of Chemical Safety Studies.” Environmental Health Perspectives 119 (6): 757–64.
Conway, E. M. and Oreskes, N.. 2011. Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming. New York: Bloomsbury.
Chapin, Robert E., Adams, J., Boekelheide, K., Gray, L.E. Jr., Hayward, S.W., Lees, P.S., McIntyre, B.S., Portier, K.M., Schnorr, T.M., Selevan, S.G., Vandenbergh, J.G. and Woskie, S.R.. 2008. “NTP-CERHR Expert Panel Report on the Reproductive and Developmental Toxicity of Bisphenol A.” Birth Defects Research Part B: Developmental and Reproductive Toxicology 83 (3): 157395.
Delclos, K. Barry, Camacho, L., Lewis, S.M., Vanlandingham, Michelle M., Lattendresse, John R., Olson, Greg R., Davis, Kelly J., Patton, Ralph E., Gonçalo Gamboa da Costa, Woodling, Kellie A., Bryant, Matthew S., Chidambaram, Mani, Trbojevich, Raul, Juliar, Beth E., Felton, Robert P., Thorn, Brett T.. 2014. “Toxicity evaluation of bisphenol A administered by gavage to Sprague-Dawley rats from gestation day 6 through postnatal day 90”, Toxicological Sciences 139 (1): 174197.
Douglas, M. and Wildavsky, A.. 1983. Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technical and Environmental Dangers. Berkeley CA: University of California Press.
Edge, S. and Eyles, J.. 2013. “Message in a bottle: claims disputes and the reconciliation of precaution and weight-of-evidence in the regulation of risks from Bisphenol A in Canada.” Health, Risk & Society 15 (5): 432–48.
Ema, M., Fujii, S., Furukawa, M., Kiguchi, M., Ikka, T. and Harazono, A.. 2001. “Rat two-generation reproductive toxicity study of bisphenol A.” Reproductive toxicology 15 (5): 505–23.
Entine, Jon. 2011. Scared to Death: How Chemophobia Threatens Public Health. New York: American Council on Science and Health.
Environmental Defence. 2008. Toxic Baby Bottles in Canada. Toronto.
Environics. Environics Focus Canada 1985–2007. (July 18, 2014).
Gardner, D. 2009. Risk: The Science and Politics of Fear. Toronto: McClelland & Stewart.
Gioiosa, Laura, Fissore, E., Ghirardelli, G., Parmigiani, S. and Palanza, P.. 2007. “Developmental exposure to low-dose estrogenic endocrine disruptors alters sex differences in exploration and emotional responses in mice.” Hormones and behavior 52 (3): 307–16.
Haneke, Karen and Carson, Bonnie. 2001. Toxicological Summary for Sodium Hexafluorosilicate [16893-85-9] and Fluorosilicic Acid [16961-83-4]. Washington: National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences
Harrison, K. 2011. Racing to the Bottom? Provincial Interdependence in the Canadian Federation. Vancouver: UBC Press.
Harrison, K. and Hoberg, G.. 1994. Risk, Science, and Politics: Regulating Toxic Substances in Canada and the United States. Montreal and Kingtson: McGill-Queen's University Press.
Harrison, Kathryn. 1996. Passing the Buck: Federalism and Canadian Environmental Policy. Vancouver: UBC Press.
Hartings, M.R. and Fahy, D.. 2011. “Communicating chemistry for public engagement.” Nature Chemistry 3: 674–77.
Hengstler, J. G., Foth, H., Gebel, T., Kramer, P.J., Lilienblum, W., Schweinfurth, H., Völkel, W., Wollin, K.M. and Gundert-Remy, U., 2011. “Critical evaluation of key evidence on the human health hazards of exposure to bisphenol A.” Critical Reviews in Toxicology 41 (4): 263–91.
Ho, S.M., Tang, W.Y., de Frausto, J. Belmonte and Prins, G.S.. 2006. “Developmental exposure to estradiol and bisphenol A increases susceptibility to prostate carcinogenesis and epigenetically regulates phosphodiesterase type 4 variant 4.” Cancer research 66 (11): 5624.
Ioannidis, John P.A. 2005. “Contradicted and Initially Stronger Effects in Highly Cited Clinical Research.” Journal of the American Medical Association 294 (2): 218–28.
Kahan, Dan M., Breman, Donald, Slovic, Paul, Gastil, John and Cohan, Geoffrey L.. 2007. “The Second National Risk and Culture Study: Making Sense of and Making Progress in the American Culture War of Fact.” (July 24, 2014).
Kahan, Dan M., Braman, Donald, Cohen, Geoffrey L., Gastil, John and Slovic, Paul. 2010. “Who fears the HPV vaccine, who doesn't, and why? An experimental study of the mechanisms of cultural cognition.” Law and human behavior 34 (6): 501–16.
Kawai, Keisuke, Nozaki, Takehiro, Nishikata, Hiroaki, Aou, Shuji, Takii, Masato and Kubo, Chiharu. 2003. “Aggressive behavior and serum testosterone concentration during the maturation process of male mice: the effects of fetal exposure to bisphenol A.” Environmental Health Perspectives 111 (2): 175.
Kiss, Simon. 2013. “Legislation by agenda-setting: Assessing the media's role in the regulation of BPA in the US states.” Mass Communication and Society 16 (5): 687712.
Kraus, Nancy, Malmfors, Torbjorn and Slovic, Paul. 1992. “Intuitive Toxicology: Expert and Lay Judgments of Chemical Risks.” Risk analysis. 12 (2): 215–32.
Laszlo, P. 2007. “On the self-image of chemists, 1950–2000.” The Public Image of Chemistry, ed. Schummer, Joachim, Vincent, Bernadette Bensaude and Van Tiggelen, Brigitte. London: World Scientific Publishing.
Laviola, Giovanni, Adriani, W. and Palanza, P.. 2005. “D-amphetamine-related reinforcing effects are reduced in mice exposed prenatally to estrogenic endocrine disruptors.” Brain research bulletin 65 (3): 235–40.
Leiss, W. 2001. In the Chamber of Risks: Understanding Risk Controversies. Montreal, Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press.
Linkov, I., Loney, D., Cormier, S., Satterstrom, S.K. and Bridges, T... 2009. “Weight-of-evidence evaluation in environmental assessment: Review of qualitative and quantitative approaches.” Science of the Total Environment 407 (19): 51995205.
McGarity, Thomas O. and Wagner, Wendy Elizabeth. 2008. Bending Science: How Special Interests Corrupt Public Health Research. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.
Nagel, S.C., vom Saal, F.S., Thayer, K.A., Dhar, M.G., Boechler, M. and Welshons, W.V.. 1997. “Relative binding affinity-serum modified access (RBA-SMA) assay predicts the relative in vivo bioactivity of the xenoestrogens bisphenol A and octylphenol.” Environmental Health Perspectives 105 (1): 7076.
Nishizawa, Hanako, Manabe, Noboru, Morita, M., Sugimoto, M., Imanishi, S. and Miyamoto, H..2003. “Effects of in utero exposure to bisphenol A on expression of RARalpha and RXRalpha mRNAs in murine embryos.” The Journal of Reproduction and Development 49 (6): 539–45.
Nishizawa, Hanako, Imanishi, Satoshi and Manabe, Noboru. 2005a. “Effects of exposure in utero to bisphenol a on the expression of aryl hydrocarbon receptor, related factors, and xenobiotic metabolizing enzymes in murine embryos.” The Journal of Reproduction and Development 51 (5): 593605.
Nishizawa, Hanako, Morita, Maki, Sugimoto, M. Imanishi, S. and Manabe, N.. 2005b. “Effects of in utero exposure to bisphenol A on mRNA expression of arylhydrocarbon and retinoid receptors in murine embryos.” The Journal of Reproduction and Development 51 (3): 315–24.
Nosek, Brian A., Spies, Jeffrey R. and Motyl, Matt. 2012. “Scientific Utopia II. Restructuring Incentives and Practices to Promote Truth over PublishabilityPerspectives on Psychological Science 7 (6): 615–31.
Palanza, Paola, Howdeshell, Kembra L., Parmigiani, Stefano and vom Saal, Frederick. 2002. “Exposure to a low dose of bisphenol A during fetal life or in adulthood alters maternal behavior in mice.” Environmental Health Perspectives 110 (suppl 3): 415.
Pralle, S. 2006. “The ‘mouse that roared’: Agenda setting in Canadian pesticides politics.” Policy Studies Journal 34 (2): 781–99.
Purchase, Iain F.H. 2004. “Fraud, errors and gamesmanship in experimental toxicology.” Toxicology 202 (1-2): 120.
Ropeik, David. 2010. How Risky Is It, Really? McGraw-Hill Professional.
Roy, Jeffrey. 2013. From Machinery to Mobility: Government and Democracy in a Participative Age. New York: Springer.
Ryan, Bryce C., Hotchkiess, Andrew K., Crofton, Kevin M. and Gray, L. Earl Jr. 2010. “In utero and lactational exposure to bisphenol A, in contrast to ethinyl estradiol, does not alter sexually dimorphic behavior, puberty, fertility, and anatomy of female LE rats.” Toxicological sciences: An official journal of the Society of Toxicology 114 (1): 133–48.
Rowe, Sylvia, Alexander, Nick, Clydesdale, Fergus M., Applebaum, Rhona S., Atkinson, Stephanie, Black, Richard M., Dwyer, Johanna T., Hentges, Eric, Higley, Nancy A., Lefevre, Michael, Lupton, Joanne R., Miller, Sanford A., Tancredi, Doris L., Weaver, Connie M., Woteki, Catherine E. and Wedral, Elaine. 2009. “Funding Food Science and Nutrition Research: Financial Conflicts and Scientific Integrity.” The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 89 (5): 1285–91.
Scott, Dayna Nadine. 2009. “Testing Toxicity: Proof and Precaution in Canada's Chemicals Management Plan.” Review of European Community & International Environmental Law 18 (1): 5976.
Sharpe, Richard M. 2010. “Is it time to end concerns over the estrogenic effects of bisphenol A?Toxicological sciences: An official journal of the Society of Toxicology 114 (1): 14.
Shelby, M. 2008. Potential Human Reproductive and Development Effects of Bisphenol A. NIH Publication no. 08-5994. Washington: Department of Health and Human Services.
Slovic, P., Malmfors, T., Krewski, Daniel, Mertz, C.K., Neil, Nancy and Bartlett, Sheryl. 1995. “Intuitive toxicology. II. Expert and lay judgments of chemical risks in Canada.” Risk Analysis 15 (6): 661–75.
Slovic, Paul, Finucane, Melissa, Peters, Ellen and MacGregor, Donald G.. 2002. “The Affect Heuristic.” In Heuristics and Biases: Intuitive Judgment, ed. Gilovich, Thomas, Kahneman, Daniel, and Griffin, Dale. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Slovic, Paul, Fischhoff, Baruch and Lichtenstein, Sarah. 1982. “Why Study Risk Perception?Risk analysis 2 (2): 8393.
Smith, R. and Daifallah, A.. 2006. “It's in Tory genes to go green”. Globe and Mail (Toronto). February 6, 2006.
Smith, R. and Lourie, B.. 2010. Slow Death by Rubber Duck: How the Toxic Chemistry of Everyday Life Affects Our Health. Toronto: Random House.
Sunstein, Cass. 2004. Risk and Reason: Safety, Law, and the Environment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sutton, P., Woodruff, T.J. and Vogel, S.. 2011. “Conrad and Becker's ‘10 Criteria’ Fall Short of Addressing Conflicts of Interest in Chemical Safety Studies.” Environmental Health Perspectives 119 (12): 506–09.
Teeguarden, Justin G. and Hanson-Drury, Sesha. 2013. “A Systematic Review of Bisphenol A ‘Low Dose’ Studies in the Context of Human Exposure: A Case for Establishing Standards for Reporting ‘LowDose’ Effects of Chemicals.” Food and Chemical Toxicology 62: 935–48.
Tyl, R.W., Myers, C.B., Marr, M.C., Thomas, B.F., Keimowitz, A.R., Brine, D.R., Veselica, M.M., Fail, P.A., Chang, T.Y., Seely, J.C., Joiner, R.L., Butala, J.H., Dimond, S S., Cagen, S.Z., Shiotsuka, R.N., Stropp, G.D. and Waechter, J.M.. 2002. “Three-generation reproductive toxicity study of dietary bisphenol A in CD Sprague Dawley rats.” Toxicological Sciences: An official journal of the Society of Toxicology 68 (1): 121–46.
Tyl, R., Myers, C., Marr, M. and Sloan, C.. 2008. “Two-generation reproductive toxicity study of dietary bisphenol A (BPA) in CD-1 (Swiss) mice.” Toxicological Sciences 104.(2): 362–84.
United States. Environmental Protection Agency. 1990. Reducing Risk: Setting priorities and strategies for environmental protection. Washington DC.
United States. National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences. 2010. Bisphenol A (BPA): Expanding Research to Impact Human Health. (July 18, 2014).
Vandenberg, L.N., Colborn, T., Hayes, T.B., Heindel, J.J., Jacobs, D.R. Jr., Lee, D.H., Shioda, T., Soto, A.M., vom Saal, F.S., Welshons, W.V., Zoeller, R.T. and Myers, J.P. 2012. “Hormones and endocrine-disrupting chemicals: low-dose effects and nonmonotonic dose responses.” Endocrine Reviews (33) 1: 175.
Vandenberg, L.N., Maffini, M.V. and Sonnenschein, C.. 2009. Bisphenol-A and the great divide: A review of controversies in the field of endocrine disruption. Endocrine Reviews 30 (1): 7595.
Völkel, W., Colnot, T., Csanády, G.A., Filser, J.G. and Dekant, W.. 2002. “Metabolism and kinetics of bisphenol A in humans at low doses following oral administration.” Chemical research in toxicology 15(10): 1281–87.
Vogel, D. 2012. The Politics of Precaution: Regulating Health, Safety, and Environmental Risks in Europe and the United States. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Vom Saal, F., Timms, B., and Montano, M.. 1997. “Prostate enlargement in mice due to fetal exposure to low doses of estradiol or diethylstilbestrol and opposite effects at high doses.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 94: 2056–61.
Vom Saal, F. and Welshons, W.. 2006. “Large effects from small exposures II. The importance of positive controls in low-dose research on bisphenol A”. Environmental research. 100: 5076.
Vom Saal, F. Cooke, Paul S., Buchanan, D.L., Palanza, P., Thayer, K.A., Nagel, S.C., Parmigiani, S. and Welshons, W.V.. 1998. “A physiologically based approach to the study of bisphenol A and other estrogenic chemicals on the size of reproductive organs, daily sperm production, and behavior.” Toxicology and Industrial Health 14 (1–2): 239–60.
Vom Saal, Frederick S. et al. 2007. “Chapel Hill Bisphenol A Expert Panel Consensus Statement: Integration of Mechanisms, Effects in Animals and Potential to Impact Human Health at Current Levels of Exposure.” Reproductive toxicology 24(2): 131–38.
Waterloo Watch. 2010. “Fluoridation: It's just not worth the risk.” (July 20, 2014).
Welshons, W.V., Thayer, K.A. and Judy, B.M.. 2003. “Large Effects from Small Exposures. I. Mechanisms for Endocrine-Disrupting Chemicals with Estrogenic Activity.” Environmental Health Perspectives 111 (8): 9941006.
Welshons, W., and Nagel, S.. 2006. “Large Effects from Small Exposures. III. Endocrine Mechanisms Mediating Effects of Bisphenol A at Levels of Human Exposure.” Endocrinology 147 (6): S56S59.
Wildavsky, Aaron. 1997. But Is It True? A Citizen's Guide to Environmental Health and Safety Issues. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Young, S. Stanley and Karr, Alan. 2011. “Deming, data and observational studies.” Significance 8 (3): 116–20.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique
  • ISSN: 0008-4239
  • EISSN: 1744-9324
  • URL: /core/journals/canadian-journal-of-political-science-revue-canadienne-de-science-politique
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed