Skip to main content
×
×
Home

The Politics of Isolation: Refused Relation as an Emerging Regime of Indigenous Biolegitimacy

  • Lucas Bessire (a1)
Abstract
Abstract

This essay describes the politics of voluntary isolation, an emerging category of indigeneity predicated on a form of human life that exists outside of history, the market, and wider networks of social connection. It traces a recent controversy around one such “isolated” population—Ayoreo-speaking people in the Paraguayan Gran Chaco—to suggest how these politics of isolation may represent a new regime of what Didier Fassin has called “biolegitimacy,” or the uneven political parsing and authorization of valid human life, within global formations of indigeneity. Here, I identify how international human rights law, multiculturalist state policies, humanitarian NGO programs, and genetic science all share an investment in the moral defense of isolated life. I explore how this investment may divide the kind of humanity authorized or claimed as “indigenous” into opposing legitimacies that are set against one another and vertically ranked. The essay argues that what is at stake in this process is not merely a new technique of the self or the enduring romance of the primitive, but the redistribution of the meaning and value assigned to those domains of human life imagined in opposition to social relation itself.

Copyright
Corresponding author
lucas@nyu.edu
References
Hide All
Abercrombie Tom. 1998. Pathways of Memory and Power. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Albró Robert. 2006. The Indigenous in the Plural in Bolivian Oppositional Politics. Bulletin of Latin American Research 24, 4: 433–53.
Amnesty International. 2010. Paraguay: Raid on NGO May Be in Reprisal for Its Public Criticism of Scientific Expedition. Public Pronouncement AMR 45/007/2010, 6 Dec. At: http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/asset/AMR45/007/2010/en/cecfdc6d-7f76-44e-afa8-860cf868340b/amr450072010en.pdf.
Appadurai Arjun. 2002. Diversity and Sustainable Development. In Cultural Diversity and Biodiversity for Sustainable Development. Nairobi: United Nations Environment Programme, 1620. At: http://www.unep.org/civil_society/PDF_docs/Cultural_Diversity_and_Biodiversity.pdf.
Arendt Hannah. 1968. Totalitarianism, Part Three of The Origins of Totalitarianism. San Diego: Harvest.
Bartolomé Miguel. 2000. El Encuentro de la Gente con los Insensatos: La Sedentarizacion de los Cazadores Ayoreo en el Chaco Paraguayo. Asuncion: Centro de Estudios Antropólogicos de la Universidad Católica (CEADUC).
Bedoya Silva-Santisteban Alvaro and Garland Eduardo Bedoya. 2005. Servidumbre por Deudas y Marginación en el Chaco de Paraguay. International Labour Organization Declaration 45/2005. At: http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/@ed_norm/@declaration/documents/publication/wcms_081941.pdf.
Benjamin Walter. 1999 [1921]. Critique of Violence. In Bullock Marcus and Jennings Michael, eds., Selected Writings, Vol. 1. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 277300.
Bessire Lucas. 2010. Behold the Black Caiman: Politics, Desire and Becoming Ayoreo. PhD diss., New YorkUniversity Department of Anthropology.
Bessire Lucas. 2011. Apocalyptic Futures: The Violent Transformation of Moral Human Life among Ayoreo-Speaking People of the Paraguayan Gran Chaco. American Ethnologist 38, 4: 743–57.
Blaser Mario. 2004. ‘Way of Life’ or ‘Who Decides’: Development, Paraguayan Indigenism and the Yshiro People's Life Projects.” In Blaser Mario, Feit Harvey A., and McRae Glenn, eds., In the Way of Development: Indigenous Peoples, Life Projects, and Globalization. London: Zed Books, 5271.
Boecher Nickolas M. 2009. Third Party Petitions as a Means of Protecting Voluntarily Isolated Indigenous Peoples. Sustainable Development Law & Policy 10, 1: 58, 89.
Bórmida Marcelo. 1984. Cómo una cultura arcaica concibe su propio mundo. Scripta Ethnologica 8: 5161.
Brackelaire Vincent. 2006. Diagnostico del Pueblos Aislados. Washington, D.C.: InterAmerican Development Bank.
Bruyere Jean de la. 1885 [1688]. The Characters of Jean de la Bruyere. van Laun Henri, trans. London: John Nimmo.
Brysk Alison. 2000. From Tribal Village to Global Village: Indian Rights and International Relations in Latin America. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Butler Judith. 2006. Critique, Coercion and Sacred Life in Benjamin's Critique of Violence. In de Vries Hent and Sullivan Lawrence E., eds., Political Theologies: Public Religions in a Post-Secular World. New York: Fordham University Press, 201–19.
Canova Paola. 2011. Del Monte a la Ciudad: La Producción Cultural de los Ayoreode en los Espacios Urbanos del Chaco Central. Suplemento Antropologico 46, 1: n.p.
Carlyle Thomas. 1843. Past and Present. London: Chapman and Hall.
Chodoff Paul. 1970. The German Concentration Camp as a Psychological Stress. Archives of General Psychiatry 22, 1: 7887.
Clifford James. 1988. The Predicament of Culture: Twentieth-Century Ethnography, Literature and Art. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Comaroff Jean and Comaroff John. 2003. Ethnography on an Awkward Scale: Postcolonial Anthropology and the Violence of Abstraction. Ethnography 4, 2: 147–79.
Combés Isabelle. 2009. Zamucos. Cochabamba: Ediciónes Nómadas.
de Wilde Marc. 2006. Violence in the State of Exception: Reflections on Theologico-Political Motifs in Benjamin and Schmitt. In de Vries Hent and Sullivan Lawrence E., eds., Political Theologies: Public Religions in a Post-Secular World. New York: Fordham University Press, 188200.
Diderot Denis and D'Alembert Jean le Rond, eds. 1772. Encyclopédie, ou dictionnaire raisonné des sciences, des arts et des métiers, etc. University of Chicago: ARTFL Encyclopédie Project (Spring 2011 edition, Robert Morrissey, ed.). At: http://encyclopedie.uchicago.edu/.
Dornelles C., Battilana J., Fagundes N., Freitas L., Bonatto S., and Salzano F.. 2004. Mitochondrial DNA and Alu Insertions in a Genetically Peculiar Population: The Ayoreo Indians of Bolivia and Paraguay. American Journal of Human Biology 16, 4: 479–88.
Dos Santos Sidney, Ribero-Rodrigues Elezemar, Ribero-dos-Santos Andrea, and Hutz Mara. 2009. Autosomal STR Analyses in Native Amazonian Tribes Suggest a Population Structure Driven by Isolation by Distance. Human Biology 81, 1: 7188.
Duerksen Marvin. 2010a. Allanamiento de ONG se basa en denuncias. ABC Color, 4 Dec.
Duerksen Marvin. 2010b. Maniobran para retirar denuncia contra ONG Iniciativa Amotocodie. ABC Color, 16 Dec.
Duerksen Marvin. 2011a. Imputan a los directivos de Iniciativa Amotocodie por Lesion de Confianza. ABC Color 20 May.
Duerksen Marvin. 2011b. Ayoreos exigen que una ONG devuelva mas de G. 2.000 milliones. ABC Color, 7 June.
Eissler K. R. 1959. On Isolation. Pyschoanlytic Study of the Child 14: 2960.
Escobar Ticio. 1988. Mision: Etnocidio. Asuncion: Editora Liticolor.
Fabian Johannes. 1983. Time and the Other: How Anthropology Makes Its Object. New York: Columbia University Press.
Fassin Didier. 2009. Another Politics of Life Is Possible. Theory, Culture, and Society 26, 5: 4460.
Fisher William. 1997. Doing Good? The Politics and Antipolitics of NGO Practices. Annual Review of Anthropology 26: 439–64.
Fortun Mike. 2008. Promising Genomics: Iceland and deCODE Genetics in a World of Speculation. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Fowler Alan. 1997. Striking a Balance: A Guide to Enhancing the Effectiveness of NGOs in International Development. London: Earthscan.
Franklin Sarah and Lock Margaret, eds. 2003. Remaking Life and Death: Toward an Anthropology of the Biosciences. Santa Fe: School of American Research Press.
Freud Sigmund. 1926. Inhibitions, Symptoms and Anxiety. Standard Edition 20: 77172.
Gill Victoria. 2010. Conservation Expedition Poses Risk to Tribes. BBC News, 9 Nov.
Glauser Benno. 2004. Paraguay: The Last Ayoreo in Voluntary Isolation. World Rainforest Movement Bulletin 87: 1213.
Glauser Benno. 2006. Paraguay: Pueblos Indigenas Aislados. Suplemento Antropológico 41, 2: 187200.
Glauser Benno. 2007. Su Presencia Protege el Corazon del Chaco Seco. In Parellada A., ed., Pueblos Indigenas en Aislamiento Voluntario y Contacto Inicial en la Amazonia y el Gran Chaco. Copenhagen: International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs, 220–34.
Goicoechea A. S., Carnese F. R., Dejean C., and Avena S. A.. 2001. New Genetic Data on Amerindians from the Paraguayan Chaco. American Journal of Human Biology 13: 660–67.
Gordillo Gaston. 2004. Landscapes of Devils: Tensions of Place and Memory in the Argentinean Chaco. Durham: Duke University Press.
Gordillo Gaston. 2006. En el gran chaco: anthropologias e historias. Buenos Aires: Prometeo.
Gordon Avery. 1997. Ghostly Matters: Haunting and the Sociological Imagination. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Goulart S., Demarchi D. A., Raimann P. E., Salzano F. M., Huts S. H., and Callegari S. M.. 2008. Autosomal STR Genetic Variability in the Gran Chaco Native Population: Homogeneity or Heterogeneity? American Journal of Human Biology 20: 704–11.
Grassian Stuart. 1983. Psychopathological Effects of Solitary Confinement. American Journal of Psychiatry 140: 1450–54.
Gupta Akhil and Ferguson James. 1997. Beyond Culture: Space, Identity, and the Politics of Difference. In Gupta Akhil and Ferguson James, eds., Culture, Power, Place: Explorations in Critical Anthropology. Durham: Duke University Press, 3352.
Hale Charles. 2006. Mas que un Indio: Racial Ambivalence and Neoliberal Multiculturalism in Guatemala. Santa Fe: School of American Research Press.
Hein David. 1990. Los Ayoreo Nuestros Vecinos: La mission del norte chaqueno. Asunción: El Lector.
Hogle Linda. 2003. Life/Time Warranty: Rechargeable Cells and Extendable Lives. In Franklin Sarah and Lock Margaret, eds., Remaking Life and Death: Toward an Anthropology of the Biosciences. Santa Fe: School of American Research Press, 6197.
Holland Luke. 1980. Indians, Missionaries and the Promised Land: Photographs from Paraguay. London: Survival International.
Horst Rene H. 2003. Consciousness and Contradiction: Indigenous People and Paraguay's Transition to Democracy. In Langer Erick D. and Muñoz Elena, eds., Contemporary Indigenous Movements in Latin America. Wilmington, Del.: Scholarly Resources, 103–34.
Horst Rene H. 2007. The Stroessner Regime and Indigenous Resistance in Paraguay. Gainesville: University Press of Florida.
Hudock A. C. 2000. NGOs’ Seat at the Donor Table: Enjoying the Food or Serving the Dinner?IDS Bulletin 31, 3: 1418.
Huertas-Castillo Beatriz. 2002. Los Pueblos Indigenas en Aislamiento: Su lucha por la sobrevivencia y la libertad. Copenhagen: International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs.
Hulme David and Edwards Michael, eds. 1997. NGOs, States and Donors: Too Close for Comfort? New York: St. Martin's Press.
IWGIA (International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs). 2010. The Case of the Ayoreo. Report 4. Copenhagen: IWGIA.
Jackson Jean. 1995. Culture, Genuine and Spurious: The Politics of Indianness in the Vaupes, Colombia. American Ethnologist 22, 1: 327.
Jackson Jean and Warren Kay. 2005. Indigenous Movements in Latin America, 1992–2004: Controversies, Ironies and New Directions. Annual Review of Anthropology 34: 549–73.
Janzen A. E. 1962. The Moro's Spear. Hillboro, Kans: Board Missions of the Mennonite Brethren Church.
Johnson Jean Dye. 1966. God Planted Five Seeds. New York: Harper and Row.
Johnston Kenneth J. 1985. The Story of the New Tribes Mission. Sanford, Fl.: New Tribes Mission Press.
Kaul Inge, Grunberg Isabelle, and Stern Marc. 1999. Introduction. In Kaul Inge, Grunberg Isabelle, and Stern Marc, eds., Global Public Goods: International Cooperation in the 21st Century. Oxford: Oxford University Press, xix–xxxviii.
Keate George. 1779. Sketches from Nature: Taken and Coloured in a Journey to Margate. London: J. Dodsley.
Keck Margaret and Sikkink Kathryn. 1998. Activists Beyond Borders: Advocacy Networks in International Politics. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Kidd Stephen. 1997. The Working Conditions of Indigenous Peoples of the Gran Chaco. Copenhagen: International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs.
Killeen T., Guerra A., Calzada M., Correa L., Calderon V., Soria L., Quezada B., and Steininger M.. 2008. Total Historical Land-Use Change in Eastern Bolivia: Who, Where, When and How Much? Ecology and Society 13, 1: 36. At: http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol13/iss1/art36/.
Kroeber Theodora. 1961. Ishi in Two Worlds: A Biography of the Last Wild Indian in North America. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Kymlicka Will. 1996. Multicultural Citizenship. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Latour Bruno. 2005. Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor-Network Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Law John. 1999. After ANT: Complexity, Naming and Topology. In Law John and Hassard John, eds., Actor Network Theory and After. Oxford: Blackwell, 114.
Maffi Luisa. 2005. Linguistic, Cultural and Biological Diversity. Annual Review of Anthropology 34: 599617.
Maybury-Lewis David and Howe James. 1980. The Indian Peoples of Paraguay: Their Plight and Their Prospects. Cambridge: Cultural Survival Special Report 2.
Mbembe Achille. 2001. On the Postcolony. Berkeley: University of California Press.
McFalls Laurence. 2010. Benevolent Dictatorship: The Formal Logic of Humanitarian Government. In Fassin Didier and Pandolfi Mariella, eds., Contemporary States of Emergency. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 317–34.
Muehlmann Shaylih. 2009. How Do Real Indians Fish? Neoliberal Multiculturalism and Contested Indigeneities in the Colorado Delta. American Anthropologist 111, 4: 468–79.
Myers Fred. 1988. Locating Ethnographic Practice: Romance, Reality and Politics in the Outback. American Ethnologist 15, 4: 609–24.
Myers Fred. 2004. Ontologies of the Image and Economies of Exchange. American Ethnologist 31, 1: 520.
Napolitano Dora and Ryan Aliya. 2007. The Dilemma of Contact: Voluntary Isolation and the Impacts of Gas Exploitation on Health and Rights in the Kugapakori Nahua Reserve, Peruvian Amazon. Environmental Research Letters 2, 4: 112.
Nickson Andrew and Lambert Peter. 2002. State Reform and the ‘Privatized State’ in Paraguay. Public Administration and Development 22, 2: 163–74.
Niederland William. 1968. Clinical Observations on the Survivor Syndrome. International Journal of Psychoanalysis 49: 313–15.
Pagden Anthony. 1982. The Fall of Natural Man: The American Indian and the Origins of Comparative Ethnology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Parellada Alejandro, ed. 2007. Pueblos Indigenas en Aislamiento Voluntario y Contacto Inicial en la Amazonia y el Gran Chaco. Copenhagen: International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs.
Pelleschi Giovanni. 1886. Eight Months on the Gran Chaco of the Argentine Republic. London: Sampson Low, Marston, Searle and Rivington.
Perasso Jose. 1987. Cronicas de Cacerias Humanas: la tragedia Ayorea. El Lector: Asuncion.
Perez-Diez A. A. and Salzano F. M.. 1978. Evolutionary Implications of the Ethnography and Demography of Ayoreo Indians. Journal of Human Evolution 7: 253–68.
Picanerai Aquino. 2007. De los Dirigentes de la Union de Nativos Ayoreo de Paraguay,” In Parrellada A., ed., Pueblos Indigenas en Aislamiento Voluntario y Contacto Inicial en la Amazonia y el Gran Chaco. Copenhagen: International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs, 234–36.
POJOAJU (Asociación de ONGs del Paraguay). 2010. Caso de Allanamiento de la Oficina de la ONG Iniciativa Amotocodie. Press Release, 3 Dec.
Postero Nancy. 2006. Now We Are Citizens: Indigenous Politics in Post-Multicultural Bolivia. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Ramos Alcida. 1998. Indigenism: Ethnic Politics in Brazil. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Rivas Alex. 2007. Los Pueblos Indigenas en Aislamiento: Emergencia, Vulnerabilidad y Necesidad de Proteccion. Cultura y Representaciones Sociales 1, 2: 7390.
Rosaldo Renato. 1989. Culture and Truth: The Remaking of Cultural Analysis. Boston: Beacon Press.
Sahlins Marshall. 1993. Goodbye Tristes Tropes: Ethnography in the Context of the Modern World System. Journal of Modern History 65: 125.
Salzano F. M., Pages F., Neel J. V., Gershowitz H., Tanis R. J., Moreno R., and Franco M.. 1978. Unusual Blood Genetic Characteristics among the Ayoreo Indians of Bolivia and Paraguay. Human Biology 50, 2: 121–36.
Santos Ricardo Ventura. 2002. Indigenous Peoples, Postcolonial Contexts and Genomic Research in the Late 20th Century: A View from Amazonia (1960–2000). Critique of Anthropology 22, 1: 81104.
Santos Ricardo Ventura and Maio Marcos Chor. 2004. Race, Genomics, Identities and Politics in Contemporary Brazil. Critique of Anthropology 24, 4: 347–78.
Serageldin Ismail. 1999. Cultural Heritage as Public Good: Economic Analysis Appplied to Historic Cities. In Kaul Inge, Grunberg Isabelle, and Stern Marc, eds., Global Public Goods: International Cooperation in the 21st Century. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 240–63.
Sieder Rachel. 2002. Introduction. In Sieder Rachel, ed., Multiculturalism in Latin America: Indigenous Rights, Diversity and Democracy. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Stoler Ann Laura. 2002. Carnal Knowledge and Imperial Power: Race and the Intimate in Colonial Rule. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Stoler Ann Laura. 2008. Imperial Debris: Reflections on Ruins and Ruination. Cultural Anthropology 23, 2: 191219.
Swain Mike. 2010. The Lost Tribe of Green Hell: Cultures Clash in a Battle for the Future of the Planet. Daily Mirror, 31 Dec. At: http://akastg.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/the-lost-tribe-of-green-hell-cultures-272319.
Taussig Michael. 1987. Shamanism, Colonialism and the Wild Man: A Study in Terror and Healing. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Taussig Michael. 1993. Mimesis and Alterity: A Particular History of the Senses. New York: Routledge.
Trouillot Michel-Rolph. 1995. Silencing the Past: Power and the Production of History. Boston: Beacon.
Tsing Anna. 2005. Friction: An Ethnography of Global Connections. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Tucker Robert, ed. 1978. The Marx-Engels Reader. New York: W.W. Norton & Co.
Turner Terence. 1999. Indigenous and Culturalist Movements in the Contemporary Global Conjuncture. In Del Riego Francisco F., Portasany Marcial G., Turner Terence, Llobera Josep R., Moreno Isodoro, and Fernandez James W., eds., Las identidades y las tensiones culturales de modernidad. Santiago de Compostela: Federacion de Asociaciones de antropologia del Estado Espanol.
Turner Terence. 2009. The Crisis of Late Structuralism, Perspectivism and Animism: Rethinking Culture, Nature, Spirit, and Bodiliness. Tipiti 7, 1: 342.
United Nations Human Rights Council. 2009. Draft Guidelines on the Protection of Indigenous Peoples in Voluntary Isolation and in Initial Contact of the Amazon Basin and El Chaco. Geneva: United Nations Document.
Vidal John. 2010a. Natural History Museum Expedition Poses Genocide Threat to Paraguay Tribes. Guardian, 8 Nov. At: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/nov/08/natural-history-museum-paraguay-tribes.
Vidal John. 2010b. Natural History Museum's Gran Expedition to Arid Chaco Halted. Guardian, 15 Nov. At: http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2010/nov/15/natural-history-museum-chaco-expedition-halted.
Vidal John. 2010c. Paraguayan Government Raids Offices of NGO Opposing Chaco Research Trip. Guardian 15 Dec. At: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/dec/15/ngo-raided-paraguay-expedition.
Wacquant Loïc. 2010. Class, Race & Hyperincarceration in Revanchist America. Daedalus 139, 3: 7490.
Warren Kay. 1998. Indigenous Movements and Their Critics: Pan-Maya Activism in Guatemala. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
White Hayden. 1972. Forms of Wildness: Archaeology of an Idea. In Dudley Edward and Novak Maximilian, eds., The Wild Man Within. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 338.
Williams Raymond. 1977. Structures of Feeling. In Marxism and Literature. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 128–35.
Wilmsen Edwin. 1989. Land Filled with Flies: A Political Economy of the Kalahari. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Wolf Eric. 1982. Europe and the People without History. Berkeley: University California Press.
Yashar Deborah. 2005. Contesting Citizenship in Latin America: The Rise of Indigenous Movements and the Postliberal Challenge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Comparative Studies in Society and History
  • ISSN: 0010-4175
  • EISSN: 1475-2999
  • URL: /core/journals/comparative-studies-in-society-and-history
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 17
Total number of PDF views: 73 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 343 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 16th January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.