Skip to main content

Regulation of “Religion” and the “Religious”: The Politics of Judicialization and Bureaucratization in India and Indonesia

  • Yüksel Sezgin (a1) and Mirjam Künkler (a2)

This article compares the strategies through which Hindu-majority India and Muslim-majority Indonesia have regulated religion and addressed questions of what constitutes “the religious” in the post-independence period. We show that the dominant approach pursued by the Indian state has been one of judicialization—the delegation of religious questions to the high courts—while in Indonesia it has predominantly been one of bureaucratization—the regulation of religious issues by the Ministry of Religious Affairs. Contrary to the expectation that judicialization devitalizes normative conflicts while bureaucratization, more frequently associated with authoritarian politics, “locks” these conflicts “in,” we show that these expectations have not materialized, and at times, the effects have been reverse. Engaging the literatures on judicialization and on bureaucratization, we argue that what determines the consequences of the policy toward religion is less the choice of the implementing institution (i.e., the judiciary or bureaucracy) than the mode of delegation (vertical versus horizontal) which shapes the relationship between the policy-maker and the institution implementing it. Bureaucrats, judges, and elected politicians in multicultural societies around the world encounter questions of religious nature very similar to those that authorities in India and Indonesia have faced. How they address the challenge of religious heterogeneity has a profound impact on prospects of nation-building and democratization. It is therefore imperative that the consequences of the policy toward religion, and even more so the consequences of political delegation, be studied more systematically.

Corresponding author
Hide All
Abalahin A. J. 2005. A Sixth Religion? Confucianism and the Negotiation of Indonesian Chinese Identity under the Pancasila State. In Willford A. C. and George K. M., eds., Spirited Politics: Religion and Public Life in Contemporary Southeast Asia. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 119–42.
Agnes F. 2007. The Supreme Court, the Media, and the Uniform Civil Code Debate in India. In Needham A. D. and Rajan R. Sunder, eds., The Crisis of Secularism in India. Durham: Duke University Press, 294315.
Aragon L. V. 2000. Fields of the Lord: Animism, Christian Minorities, and State Development in Indonesia. Honolulu: University of Hawai`i Press.
Atkinson J. M. 1987. Religions in Dialogue: The Construction of an Indonesian Minority Religion. In Kipp R. S. and Rodgers S., eds., Indonesian Religions in Transition. Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 171–86.
Benda H. J. 1958. The Crescent and the Rising Sun; Indonesian Islam under the Japanese Occupation, 1942–1945. The Hague: W. van Hoeve. Distributed by the Institute of Pacific Relations.
Bhargava R. 2002. What Is Indian Secularism and What Is It For? Indian Review 1, 1: 132.
Bowen J. 2013. Contours of Shari'a in Indonesia. In Künkler M. and Stepan A. C., eds., Democratization and Islam in Indonesia. New York: Columbia University Press, 149–67.
Butt S. 2008. Polygamy and Mixed Marriage in Indonesia: Islam and Marriage Law in the Courts. In Lindsey T., ed., Indonesia: Law and Society. Singapore: ISEAS, 266–87.
Butt S. 2010. Islam, the State and the Constitutional Court in Indonesia. Pacific Rim Law and Policy Journal 19, 2: 279301.
Cammack M., Young L. A., and Heaton T.. 2008. Indonesia's Marriage Law. In Lindsey T., ed., Indonesia: Law and Society. Singapore: ISEAS, 288312.
Casanova J. 2006. Rethinking Secularism: A Global Comparative Perspective. Hedgehog Review, 8, 1–2: 722.
Chakrabarty B. 2008. Indian Politics and Society since Independence: Events, Processes and Ideology. London: Routledge.
Chalmers I. 2006. Indonesia: An Introduction to Contemporary Traditions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Chandra B., Mukherjee A., and Mukherjee M.. 1999. India after Independence. New Delhi and London: Penguin Books.
Cossman B. and Kapur R.. 2001. Secularism's Last Sigh?: Hindutva and the (Mis)rule of Law. Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Crouch M. A. 2012. Law and Religion in Indonesia: The Constitutional Court and the Blasphemy Law. Asian Journal of Comparative Law 7, 1: 146.
Das G. 2000. The Supreme Court: An Overview. In Kirpal B. N., Desai A. H., and Subramanium G., eds., Supreme but Not Infallible: Essays in Honour of the Supreme Court of India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 1647.
De Bary W. T., Gluck C., Tiedemann A. E., Boot W. J. J., and Bodiford W. M.. 2006. Sources of Japanese Tradition, Part II (1868–2000). 2d ed.New York: Columbia University Press.
Derrett J. D. M. 1999. Religion, Law and the State in India. Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Dhavan R. 2001. The Road to Xanadu: India's Quest for Secularism. In Larson G. J., ed., Religion and Personal Law in Secular India: A Call to Judgment. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 301–29.
Dhavan R. 2007. Governance by Judiciary: Into the Next Millennium. In Dua B. D., Singh M. P., and Saxena R., eds., Indian Judiciary and Politics. New Delhi: Manohar, 73106.
Dhavan R. and Nariman F. S.. 2000. The Supreme Court and Group Life: Religious Freedom, Minority Groups, and Disadvantaged Communities. In Kirpal B. N., Desai A. H., and Subramanium G., eds., Supreme but Not Infallible: Essays in Honour of the Supreme Court of India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 256–87.
Eisgruber C. L. and Sager L. G.. 2007. Religious Freedom and the Constitution. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Emmerson D. K. 1978. The Bureaucracy in Political Context: Weakness in Strength. In Jackson K. D. and Pye L. W., eds., Political Power and Communications in Indonesia. Berkeley: University of California Press, 82136.
Federspiel H. M. 1998. Islamic Values, Law, and Expectations in Contemporary Indonesia. Islamic Law and Society 5, 1: 90117.
Fox J. 2006. World Separation of Religion and State into the Twenty First Century. Comparative Political Studies 39, 5: 537–69.
Freston P. 2001. Evangelicals and Politics in Asia, Africa, and Latin America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Galanter M. 1989. Law and Society in Modern India. Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Geertz C. 1960. The Religion of Java. Glencoe, Ill.: The Free Press.
Ginsburg T. and Moustafa T.. 2008. Rule by Law: The Politics of Courts in Authoritarian Regimes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ginting J. T. 2004. The Position of Hinduism in Karo Society (North Sumatra). In Ramstedt M., ed., Hinduism in Modern Indonesia: A Minority Religion between Local, National, and Global Interests. London: RoutledgeCurzon, 226–41.
Handberg R. 1999. Judicialization across Societies: The Spread of Judicial Power and Societal Change. International Journal of Public Administration 22, 8: 1269–92.
Hansen T. B. 1999. The Saffron Wave: Democracy and Hindu Nationalism in Modern India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Hardacre H. 1989. Shinto and the State, 1868–1988. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Hasan Z. 1994. Minority Identity, State Policy and the Political Process. In Hasan Z., ed., Forging Identities: Gender, Communities and the State. New Delhi: Kali for Women, 5973.
Hefner R. W. 2004. Hindu Reform in an Islamizing Java: Pluralism and Peril. In Ramstedt M., ed., Hinduism in Modern Indonesia: A Minority Religion between Local, National, and Global Interests. New York: RoutledgeCurzon, 93108.
Heriyanto Yang Y. 2005. The History and Legal Position of Confucianism in Postindependence Indonesia. Marburg Journal of Religion 10, 1: 18.
Hirschl R. 2004. Towards Juristocracy: The Origins and Consequences of the New Constitutionalism. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Hirschl R. 2008. The Theocratic Challenge to Constitution Drafting in Post-Conflict States. William and Mary Law Review 49, 4: 1179–211.
Howell J. D. 1982. Indonesia: Searching for Consensus. In Caldarola C., ed., Religions and Societies, Asia and the Middle East. New York: Mouton, 497548.
Intan B. F. 2006. “Public Religion” and the Pancasila-Based State of Indonesia: An Ethical and Sociological Analysis. New York: Peter Lang.
Irianto S. 2005. Race and Gender Discrimination in a Socio-Legal Perspective: The Experience of Chinese Indonesian Women in Indonesia. In Lindholt L. and Schaumburg-Müller S., eds., Human Rights in Development Yearbook: Human Rights and Local/Living Law. Oslo: Martinus Nijhoff, 235–63.
Jacobsohn G. J. 2003. The Wheel of Law: India's Secularism in Comparative Constitutional Context. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Jones S. 2013. Indonesian Government Approaches to Radical Islam since 1998. In Künkler M. and Stepan A. C., eds., Democratization and Islam in Indonesia. New York: Columbia University Press, 109–25.
Kipp R. S. 1993. Dissociated Identities: Ethnicity, Religion, and Class in an Indonesian Society. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Kipp R. S. and Rodgers S.. 1987. Indonesian Religions in Transition. Tucson: University of Arizona Press.
Kopf D. 1979. The Brahmo Samaj and the Shaping of the Modern Indian Mind. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Kusuma A. B. and Elson R. E.. 2011. A Note on the Sources for the 1945 Constitutional Debates in Indonesia. Bijdragen tot de Taal-, Land- en Volkenkunde 167, 2/3: 196209.
Lev D. S. 1972. Islamic Courts in Indonesia: A Study in the Political Bases of Legal Institutions. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Lev D. S. 2000. Legal Evolution and Political Authority in Indonesia: Selected Essays. The Hague: Kluwer Law International.
Lukito R. 2003. Law and Politics in Post-Independence Indonesia: A Case Study of Religious and Adat Courts. In Salim A. and Azra A., eds., Shari‘a and Politics in Modern Indonesia. Singapore: ISEAS, 1732.
Mahajan G. 2002. Secularism as Religious Non-Discrimination: The Universal and the Particular in the Indian Context. Indian Review 1, 1: 3351.
Mahmood S. T. 1995. Uniform Civil Code: Fictions and Facts. New Delhi: India and Islam Research Council.
Mawardi A. I. 1998. Socio-Political Background of the Enactment of Kompilasi Hukum Islam Di Indonesia. MA thesis, McGill University, Montreal.
McDaniel J. 2010. Agama Hindu Dharma Indonesia as a New Religious Movement: Hinduism Recreated in the Image of Islam. Nova Religio: The Journal of Alternative and Emergent Religions 14, 1: 93111.
Menski W. 2003. Hindu Law: Beyond Tradition and Modernity. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Minor R. N. 1982. Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan on the Nature of “Hindu” Tolerance. Journal of the American Academy of Religion 50, 2: 275–90.
Minor R. N. 1999. The Religious, the Spiritual, and the Secular: Auroville and Secular India. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Mitra S. K. and Fischer A.. 2002. Sacred Laws and the Secular State: An Analytical Narrative of the Controversy over Personal Laws in India. Indian Review 1, 3: 99130.
Moog R. S. 1998. Elite-Court Relations in India: An Unsatisfactory Arrangement. Asian Survey 38, 4: 410–23.
Mulder N. 1978. Mysticism and Everyday Life in Contemporary Java: Cultural Persistence and Change. Singapore: Singapore University Press.
Nehru J. 1989. Jawaharlal Nehru on Minorities and Secularism. Trivandrum: Institute of Management in Government.
Nurlaelawati E. 2010. Modernization, Tradition and Identity: The Kompilasi Hukum Islam and Legal Practice in the Indonesian Religious Courts. Amsterdam: University of Amsterdam Press.
O'Shaughnessy K. 2009. Gender, State and Social Power in Contemporary Indonesia: Divorce and Marriage Law. London: Routledge.
Pantham T. 1997. Indian Secularism and Its Critics: Some Reflections. Review of Politics 59, 3: 523–40.
Parsons N. and Mietzner M.. 2009. Sharia by-Laws in Indonesia. A Legal and Political Analysis. Australian Journal of Asian Law 11, 12: 190217.
Pausacker H. 2012. Playboy, the Islamic Defenders’ Front and the Law: Enforcing Islamic Norms in Post-Soeharto Indonesia? Australian Journal of Asian Law 13, 1: 120.
Pennington B. K. 2005. Was Hinduism Invented? Britons, Indians, and Colonial Construction of Religion. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ramstedt M. 2004a. The Hinduization of Local Traditions in South Sulawesi. In Ramstedt M., ed., Hinduism in Modern Indonesia: A Minority Religion between Local, National, and Global Interests. London: RoutledgeCurzon, 184225.
Ramstedt M. 2004b. Introduction: Negotiating Identities—Indonesian ‘Hindus’ between Local, National, and Global Interests. In Ramstedt M., ed., Hinduism in Modern Indonesia: A Minority Religion between Local, National, and Global Interests. New York: RoutledgeCurzon, 134.
Rana M. S. 2006. India Votes: Lok Sabha and Vidhan Sabha Elections 2001–2005. New Delhi: Sarup and Sons.
Rao A. and Rao B. G.. 1974. Six Thousand Days: Jawaharlal Nehru, Prime Minister. New Delhi: Sterling Publishers.
Rao B. 2004. Religion, Law, and Minorities in India: Problems with Judicial Regulation. In Richardson J. T., ed., Regulating Religion: Case Studies from around the Globe. New York: Kluwer, 381413.
Rocher R. 2010. The Creation of Anglo-Hindu Law. In Lubin T., Davis D. R., and Krishnan J., eds., Hinduism and Law: An Introduction. New York: Cambridge University Press, 7888.
Sachar R. 2006. Social, Economic and Educational Status of the Muslim Community of India. New Delhi: Prime Minister's High Level Committee.
Salim A. 2008. Challenging the Secular State: The Islamization of Law in Modern Indonesia. Honolulu: University of Hawai`i Press.
Sathe S. P. 2003. Judicial Activism in India. 2d ed.Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Scheingold S. A. 2004. The Politics of Rights: Lawyers, Public Policy, and Political Change. 2d ed.Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Schiller A. 1996. An “Old” Religion in “New Order” Indonesia: Notes on Ethnicity and Religious Affiliation. Sociology of Religion 57, 4: 409–17.
Schrauwers A. 2000. Colonial ‘Reformation’ in the Highlands of Central Sulawesi, Indonesia, 1892–1995. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Sen R. 2010. Articles of Faith: Religion, Secularism, and the Indian Supreme Court. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Sezgin Y. 2013. Human Rights under State-Enforced Religious Family Laws in Israel, Egypt and India. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Smith D. E. 1963. India as a Secular State. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Smith J. Z. 1998. Religion, Religions, Religious. In Taylor M. C., ed., Critical Terms for Religious Studies. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 269–84.
Stump R. W. 2000. Boundaries of Faith: Geographical Perspectives on Religious Fundamentalism. Lanham, Md.: Rowman and Littlefield.
Surbakti R. A. 1991. Interrelation between Religious and Political Power under New Order Indonesia. PhD diss., Northern Illinois University, DeKalb.
Sweet A. S. 2003. Constitutional Courts and Parliamentary Democracy. In Thatcher M. and Sweet A. Stone, eds., The Politics of Delegation. London: Frank Cass, 6989.
Tallberg J. 2003. Delegation to Supranational Institutions: Why, How, and with What Consequences? In Thatcher M. and Sweet A. Stone, eds., The Politics of Delegation. London: Frank Cass, 2346.
Tate C. N. 1993. Courts and Crisis Regimes: A Theory Sketch with Asian Case Studies. Political Research Quarterly 46, 2: 311–38.
Tate C. N. 1995. Why the Expansion of Judicial Power. In Tate C. N. and Vallinder T., eds., The Global Expansion of Judicial Power. New York: New York University Press, 2737.
Thatcher M. and Sweet A. S.. 2003. Theory and Practice of Delegation to Non-Majoritarian Institutions. In Thatcher M. and Sweet A. Stone, eds., The Politics of Delegation. London: Frank Cass, 122.
Williams R. V. 2006. Postcolonial Politics and Personal Laws: Colonial Legal Legacies and the Indian State. New Delhi and Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Zavos J. 2002. The Emergence of Hindu Nationalism in India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Comparative Studies in Society and History
  • ISSN: 0010-4175
  • EISSN: 1475-2999
  • URL: /core/journals/comparative-studies-in-society-and-history
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 22
Total number of PDF views: 110 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 391 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 16th January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.