Skip to main content

The impact of vehicle silhouettes on perceptions of car environmental friendliness and safety in 2009 and 2016: a comparative study

  • Youyi Bi (a1), Sixuan Li (a1), David Wagner (a2) and Tahira Reid (a1)

Automakers are interested in creating optimal car shapes that can visually convey environmental friendliness and safety to customers. This research examined the influence of vehicle form on perceptions based on two subjective inference measures: safety and perceived environmental friendliness (PEF). A within-subjects study was conducted in 2009 (Study 1) to study how people would evaluate 20 different vehicle silhouettes created by designers in industry. Participants were asked to evaluate forms on several scales, including PEF, safety, inspired by nature, familiarity, and overall preference. The same study was repeated in 2016 (Study 2). The results from the first study showed an inverse relationship between PEF and perceptions of safety. That is, vehicles that appeared to be safe were perceived to be less environmentally friendly, and vice versa. Participants in the second study showed a similar trend, but not as strongly as the 2009 participants. Several shape variables were identified to be correlated with participants’ PEF and safety ratings. The changes in the trend of participants’ evaluations over seven years were also discussed. These results can provide designers with insights into how to create car shapes with balanced PEF and safety in the early design stage.

  • View HTML
    • Send article to Kindle

      To send this article to your Kindle, first ensure is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings on the Manage Your Content and Devices page of your Amazon account. Then enter the ‘name’ part of your Kindle email address below. Find out more about sending to your Kindle. Find out more about sending to your Kindle.

      Note you can select to send to either the or variations. ‘’ emails are free but can only be sent to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. ‘’ emails can be delivered even when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees apply.

      Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service.

      The impact of vehicle silhouettes on perceptions of car environmental friendliness and safety in 2009 and 2016: a comparative study
      Available formats
      Send article to Dropbox

      To send this article to your Dropbox account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Dropbox.

      The impact of vehicle silhouettes on perceptions of car environmental friendliness and safety in 2009 and 2016: a comparative study
      Available formats
      Send article to Google Drive

      To send this article to your Google Drive account, please select one or more formats and confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your <service> account. Find out more about sending content to Google Drive.

      The impact of vehicle silhouettes on perceptions of car environmental friendliness and safety in 2009 and 2016: a comparative study
      Available formats
Distributed as Open Access under a CC-BY 4.0 license (
Corresponding author
Email address for correspondence:
Hide All
Abbasi, S. M. 2013 The fashion cycle and theories of fashion. Paripex – Indian Journal of Research 2 (9), 117119.
Anstey, K. J., Horswill, M. S., Wood, J. M. & Hatherly, C. 2012 The role of cognitive and visual abilities as predictors in the multifactorial model of driving safety. Accident Analysis & Prevention 45, 766774.
Artacho-Ramirez, M. A., Diego-Mas, J. A. & AlcaideMarzal, J. 2008 Influence of the mode of graphical representation on the perception of product aesthetic and emotional features: an exploratory study. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 38 (11), 942952.
Ayres, T., Wood, C., Schmidt, R., Young, D. & Murray, J. 2000 Affordance perception and safety intervention. In Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, vol. 44, No. 32, pp. 651. SAGE Publications.
Bates-Brkljac, N. 2009 Assessing perceived credibility of traditional and computer generated architectural representations. Design Studies 30 (4), 415437.
Beverland, M. & Lockshin, L. 2003 A longitudinal study of customers’ desired value change in business-to-business markets. Industrial Marketing Management 32 (8), 653666.
Bishop, P. & Bloomfield, R. 2000 A methodology for safety case development. Safety and Reliability 20 (1), 3442.
Bloch, P. H. 1995 Seeking the ideal form: product design and consumer response. The Journal of Marketing 59 (3), 1629.
Bolduc, D., Boucher, N. & Alvarez-Daziano, R. 2008 Hybrid choice modeling of new technologies for car choice in Canada. Journal of the Transportation Research Record 2082, 6371.
Bolton, R. N. & Drew, J. H. 1991 A longitudinal analysis of the impact of service changes on customer attitudes. The Journal of Marketing 55 (1), 19.
Boyd, J. & Mellman, R. 1980 The effect of fuel economy standards on the US automotive market: an Hedonic demand analysis. Transportation Research Part A: General 14 (5–6), 367378.
Boztepe, S. 2007 User value: competing theories and models. International Journal of Design 1 (2), 5563.
Brannan, D., Heeter, J. & Bird, L.2012 Made with renewable energy: how and why companies are labeling consumer products, National Renewable Energy Lab, Report No. TP-6A20-53764.
Brooker, G. 1976 The self-actualizing socially conscious consumer. Journal of Consumer Research (3), 107112.
Buhrmester, M., Kwang, T. & Gosling, S. D. 2011 Amazon’s Mechanical Turk: a new source of inexpensive, yet high-quality, data? Perspectives on Psychological Science 6 (1), 35.
Bump, P.2014 Here is when each generation begins and ends, according to facts. The Atlantic, published on March 25, 2014.
Burnap, A., Hartley, J., Pan, Y., Gonzalez, R. & Papalambros, P. Y. 2016 Balancing design freedom and brand recognition in the evolution of automotive brand styling. Design Science Journal 2 (e9), doi:10.1017/dsj.2016.9.
Cagan, J. & Vogel, C. 2013 Creating Breakthrough Products. Financial Times Press.
Chen, C. 2001 Design for the environment: a quality-based model for green product development. Management Science 47 (2), 250263.
Chase, D. & Smith, T. K. 1992 Consumers keen on green but marketers don’t deliver. Advertising Age 63 (29), 24.
Chen, W. & Wassenaar, H. J. 2003 An approach to decision-based design with discrete choice analysis for demand modeling. Journal of Mechanical Design 125 (3), 490497.
Coad, A., De Haan, P. & Woersdorfer, J. S. 2009 Consumer support for environmental policies: an application to purchases of green cars. Ecological Economics 68 (7), 20782086.
Crandall, R. & Graham, J. 1989 The effect of fuel economy standards on automobile safety. The Journal of Law and Economics 32 (1), 97118.
Creusen, M. E. & Schoormans, J. P. 2005 The different roles of product appearance in consumer choice. Journal of Product Innovation Management 22 (1), 6381.
Dagnoli, J. 1991 Consciously green. Advertising Age 14 (9), 14.
D’Souza, C. 2004 Ecolabel programmes: a stakeholder (consumer) perspective. Corporate Communications: An International Journal 9 (3), 179188.
Du, P. & MacDonald, E. F. 2014 Eye-tracking data predict importance of product features and saliency of size change. Journal of Mechanical Design 136 (8), 081005.
Duchowski, A. T. 2007 Eye Tracking Methodology: Theory and Practice. Springer.
Du Preez, J. P., Diamantopoulos, A. & Schlegelmilch, B. 1994 Product standardization and attribute saliency: a three country empirical comparison. Journal of International Marketing 2 (1), 728.
El-Basyouny, K. & El-Bassiouni, M. Y. 2013 Modeling and analyzing traffic safety perceptions: an application to the speed limit reduction pilot project in Edmonton, Alberta. Accident Analysis & Prevention 51, 156167.
Evans, L. 2004 Traffic Safety, Science Serving Society. Bloomfield Hills.
Flint, D. J. & Woodruff, R. B. 2001 The initiators of changes in customers’ desired value: results from a theory building study. Industrial Marketing Management 30 (4), 321337.
Goodwin, A.2016 Take a look back four generations of Toyota Prius (pictures),, April 30, 2016.
Goucher-Lambert, K. & Cagan, J. 2015 The impact of sustainability on consumer preference judgments of product attributes. Journal of Mechanical Design 137 (8), 081401.
Hahnel, U. J., Gölz, S. & Spada, H. 2014 How does green suit me? Consumers mentally match perceived product attributes with their domainspecific motives when making green purchase decisions. Journal of Consumer Behaviour 13 (5), 317327.
Haugen, A. S., Søfteland, E., Eide, G. E., Nortvedt, M. W., Aase, K. & Harthug, S. 2010 Patient safety in surgical environments: cross-countries comparison of psychometric properties and results of the Norwegian version of the Hospital Survey on Patient Safety. BMC Health Services Research 10 (1), 1.
Heffner, R., Kurani, K. S. & Turrentine, T. S.2007 Symbolism in early markets for hybrid electric vehicles. Technical Report No. UCD-ITS-RR-07-01, Institute of Transportation Studies, University of California, Davis, CA.
Hoffenson, S., Frischknecht, B. D. & Papalambros, P. Y. 2013 A market systems analysis of the US sport utility vehicle market considering frontal crash safety technology and policy. Accident Analysis & Prevention 50, 943954.
Holbrook, M. B. 1999 Consumer Value: a Framework for Analysis and Research. Psychology Press.
Hoyer, W. D. 1984 An examination of consumer decision making for a common repeat purchase product. Journal of Consumer Research 11 (3), 822829.
Isa, M. H. M., Ariffin, A. H., Jawi, Z. M. & Kassim, K. A. A. 2012 Purchasing behavior and perception on safety among car drivers: a study in Klang Valley. In Technology, Science, Social Sciences and Humanities Conference 2012, Langkawi, Kedah, Malaysia.
Jian-you, Z., Xiao-fen, S., Liang, Z., Shuang-xi, Z. & Xi-yang, N. 2013 Driving behavior theory and computer simulation system of driver’s risk perception based on 3D. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences 96, 16861695.
von Kaenel, C.Auto sales hit new record as Americans buy more gas-guzzling cars. Scientific American, - last accessed June 1, 2017.
Kassarjian, H. 1971 Incorporating ecology into marketing strategy: the case of air pollution. Journal of Marketing 35, 6165.
Kaul, V., Singh, S., Rajagopalan, K. & Coury, M.2010 Consumer attitudes and perceptions about safety and their preferences and willingness to pay for safety. SAE Technical Paper, No. 2010-01-2336.
Kelly, J., Papalambros, P. Y. & Seifert, C. M. 2008 Interactive genetic algorithms for use as creativity enhancement tools. In 2008 AAAI Spring Symposium: Creative Intelligent Systems, pp. 3439.
Kelly, J. C., Maheut, P., Petiot, J. F. & Papalambros, P. Y. 2011 Incorporating user shape preference in engineering design optimisation. Journal of Engineering Design 22 (9), 627650.
Klier, T. & Linn, J. 2010 The price of gasoline and new vehicle fuel economy: evidence from monthly sales data. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 2 (3), 134153.
Krupa, J. S., Rizzo, D. M., Eppstein, M. J., Lanute, D. B., Gaalema, D. E., Lakkaraju, K. & Warrender, C. E. 2014 Analysis of a consumer survey on plug-in hybrid electric vehicles. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 64, 1431.
Kudrowitz, B. M. & Wallace, D. Assessing the quality of ideas from prolific, early-stage product ideation. Journal of Engineering Design 24 (2), 120139.
Kumar, M. & Garg, N. 2010 Aesthetic principles and cognitive emotion appraisals: How much of the beauty lies in the eye of the beholder? Journal of Consumer Psychology 20 (4), 485494.
Lai, H. H., Chang, Y. M. & Chang, H. C. 2005 A robust design approach for enhancing the feeling quality of a product: a car profile case study. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 35 (5), 445460.
Lapierre, J., Tran-Khanh, A. & Skelling, J. 2008 Antecedents of customers’ desired value change in a business-to-business context: theoretical model and empirical assessment. Services Marketing Quarterly 29 (3), 114148.
Laufer, W. S. 2003 Social accountability and corporate greenwashing. Journal of Business Ethics 43 (3), 253261.
Lugo, J. E., Schmiedeler, J. P., Batill, S. M. & Carlson, L. 2015 Quantification of classical gestalt principles in two-dimensional product representations. Journal of Mechanical Design 137 (9), 094502.
MacDonald, E. F., Gonzalez, R. & Papalambros, P. 2009a The construction of preferences for crux and sentinel product attributes. Journal of Engineering Design 20 (6), 609626.
MacDonald, E. F., Gonzalez, R. & Papalambros, P. Y. 2009b Preference inconsistency in multidisciplinary design decision making. Journal of Mechanical Design 131 (3), 031009.
MacDonald, E. F., Lubensky, A., Sohns, B. & Papalambros, P. Y. 2008 Product semantics and wine portfolio optimisation. International Journal of Product Development 7 (1–2), 7398.
Maniatis, P. 2016 Investigating factors influencing consumer decision-making while choosing green products. Journal of Cleaner Production 132, 215228.
Miller, C., McIntyre, S. & Mantrala, M. Journal of Marketing Research 30 (2), 142157.
Nagamachi, M. 1995 Kansei engineering: a new ergonomic consumer-oriented technology for product development. International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 15 (1), 311.
Nass, C., Jonsson, I. M., Harris, H., Reaves, B., Endo, J., Brave, S. & Takayama, L. 2005 Improving automotive safety by pairing driver emotion and car voice emotion. In CHI’05 Extended Abstracts on Human Factors in Computing Systems, pp. 19731976. ACM.
Noort, G. V., Kerkhof, P. & Fennis, B. M. 2008 The persuasiveness of online safety cues: the impact of prevention focus compatibility of Web content on consumers’ risk perceptions, attitudes, and intentions. Journal of Interactive Marketing 22 (4), 5872.
Oblinger, D. 2003 Boomers, gen-xers, and millennials: understanding the ‘new students’. Educause Review 38 (4), 3645.
Orbay, G., Fu, L. & Kara, L. B. 2015 Deciphering the influence of product shape on consumer judgments through geometric abstraction. Journal of Mechanical Design 137 (8), 081103081104.
Orsborn, S., Cagan, J. & Boatwright, P. 2009 Quantifying aesthetic form preference in a utility function. Journal of Mechanical Design 131 (6), 061001.
Orsborn, S., Cagan, J. & Boatwright, P. 2015 Visual conjoint from discrete to continuous. In Proceedings of the 20th International Conference on Engineering Design (ICED 15), Milan, Italy, July 27–30, vol. 10, pp. 155164.
Orth, U. R. & Malkewitz, K. 2008 Holistic package design and consumer brand impressions. Journal of Marketing 72 (3), 6481.
Parra, P. A., Kim, H., Shapiro, M. A., Gravani, R. B. & Bradley, S. D. 2014 Home food safety knowledge, risk perception, and practices among Mexican–Americans. Food Control 37, 115125.
Rand, D. G. 2012 The promise of Mechanical Turk: How online labor markets can help theorists run behavioral experiments. Journal of Theoretical Biology 299, 172179.
Reid, T. N., Frischknecht, B. D. & Papalambros, P. Y. 2012a Perceptual attributes in product design: fuel economy and silhouette-based perceived environmental friendliness tradeoffs in automotive vehicle design. Journal of Mechanical Design 134 (4), 041006.
Reid, T. N., Gonzalez, R. D. & Papalambros, P. Y. 2010 Quantification of perceived environmental friendliness for vehicle silhouette design. Journal of Mechanical Design 132 (10), 101010.
Reid, T. N., MacDonald, E. F. & Du, P. 2013 Impact of product design representation on customer judgment. Journal of Mechanical Design 135 (9), 091008.
Reisenwitz, T. H. & Iyer, R. 2009 Differences in generation X and generation Y: implications for the organization and marketers. The Marketing Management Journal 19 (2), 91103.
Roosen, J., Hansen, K. & Thiele, S. 2004 Food safety and risk perception in a changing world. In 44th Annual Meeting of the Gesellchaft für Wirtschafts- und Sozialwissenschaften des Landbaues, Faculty of Agriculture and Horticulture, pp. 2729. Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin.
Saleh, A. M., Darawad, M. W. & Al-Hussami, M. 2015 The perception of hospital safety culture and selected outcomes among nurses: an exploratory study. Nursing & Health Sciences 17 (3), 339346.
Schmitt, R., Köhler, M., Durá, J. V. & Diaz-Pineda, J. 2013 Objectifying user attention and emotion evoked by relevant perceived product components. Journal of Sensors and Sensor Systems 3 (2), 315324.
Shanker, A. 2012 Q&A. What is customer value and how do you deliver it? Technology Innovation Management Review 2 (2), 3233.
She, J. & MacDonald, E. 2014 Priming designers to communicate sustainability. Journal of Mechanical Design 136 (1), 011001.
Sheller, M. 2004 Automotive emotions feeling the car. Theory, Culture & Society 21 (4–5), 221242.
Shende, V. 2014 Analysis of research in consumer behavior of automobile passenger car customer. International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications 4 (2), 18.
Smith, K. T. & Brower, T. R. 2012 Longitudinal study of green marketing strategies that influence millennials. Journal of Strategic Marketing 20 (6), 535551.
Stisser, P. 1994 A deeper shade of green. American Demographics 16 (3), 2429.
Sullivan, G. L. & Burger, K. J. 1987 An investigation of the determinants of cue utilization. Psychology and Marketing 4 (1), 6374.
Swamy, S., Orsborn, S., Michalek, J. & Cagan, J. 2007 Measurement of headlight form preference using a choice based conjoint analysis. In 2007 Proceedings of the ASME International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference, vol. 6, pp. 197206.
Sylcott, B., Cagan, J. & Tabibnia, G. 2014 Understanding consumer tradeoffs between form and function through metaconjoint and cognitive neuroscience analyses. Journal of Mechanical Design 135 (10), 101002.
Sylcott, B., Michalek, J., Cagan, J. & Tabibnia, G. 2015 Exploring the role of interaction effects in visual conjoint analysis. Journal of Mechanical Design 137 (9), 094503.
Sylcott, B., Orsborn, S. & Cagan, J. 2014 The effect of product representation in visual conjoint analysis. In ASME 2014 International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference, pp. V02AT03A014V02AT03A014.
Thomas, J. & Walton, D. 2007 Is bigger better? Vehicle size and driver perceptions of safety. International Journal of Sustainable Transportation 2 (4), 260273.
Tovey, M. 1992 Intuitive and objective processes in automotive design. Design Studies 13 (1), 2341.
Tseng, I., Cagan, J. & Kotovsky, K. 2012 Concurrent optimization of computationally learned stylistic form and functional goals. Journal of Mechanical Design 134 (11), 111006.
Tseng, I., Cagan, J., Kotovsky, K. & Wood, M. 2013 Form function fidelity. Journal of Mechanical Design 135 (1), 011006.
Turrentine, T. S. & Kurani, K. S. 2007 Car buyers and fuel economy. Energy Policy 35 (2), 12131223.
Tversky, A. & Kahneman, D. 1974 Judgment under uncertainty: heuristics and biases. Science 185 (4157), 11241131.
U.S. Department of Energy2016 U.S. HEV Sales by Model,, Last updated on January 2016.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency2013 Light-Duty Automotive Technology, Carbon Dioxide Emissions, and Fuel Economy Trends: 1975 Through 2013. https://, Technical Report, December 2013.
Valencia-Romero, A. & Lugo, J. E. 2016 Part-worth utilities of gestalt principles for product esthetics: a case study of a bottle silhouette. Journal of Mechanical Design 138 (8), 081102.
Vrkljan, B. H. & Anaby, D. 2011 What vehicle features are considered important when buying an automobile: an examination of driver preferences by age and gender. Journal of Safety Research 42 (1), 6165.
Wenzel, T. & Ross, M. 2008 The relationship between vehicle weight/size and safety. In Physics of Sustainable Energy: Using Energy Efficiently and Producing It Renewably (ed. Hafemeister, D., Levi, B., Levine, M. & Schwartz, P.), pp. 251265. Melville.
White, J.2014 One thing isn’t new in car design: clay prototypes. The Wall Street Journal, published on June 1, 2014.
Woodruff, R. B. 1997 Customer value: the next source for competitive advantage. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 25 (2), 139153.
Yumer, M. E., Chaudhuri, S., Hodgins, J. K. & Kara, L. B. 2015 Semantic shape editing using deformation handles. ACM Transactions on Graphics (TOG) 34 (4), 8697.
Yusof, J. M., Singh, G. K. B. & Razak, R. A. 2013 Purchase intention of environment-friendly automobile. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences 85, 400410.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Design Science
  • ISSN: -
  • EISSN: 2053-4701
  • URL: /core/journals/design-science
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed