Skip to main content
    • Aa
    • Aa


  • Matthew D. Adler (a1)

This paper builds upon, but substantially revises, John Harsanyi's concept of ‘extended preferences’. An individual ‘history’ is a possible life that some person (a subject) might lead. Harsanyi supposes that a given spectator, formulating her ethical preferences, can rank histories by empathetic projection: putting herself ‘in the shoes’ of various subjects. Harsanyi then suggests that interpersonal comparisons be derived from the utility function representing spectators’ (supposedly common) ranking of history lotteries. Unfortunately, Harsanyi's proposal has various flaws, including some that have hitherto escaped scholarly attention. In particular, it ignores the limits of personal identity. If the subject has welfare-relevant attributes that the spectator cannot acquire without changing who she is, full empathetic identification of the latter with the former becomes impossible. This paper proposes instead to use sympathy as the attitude on a spectator's part that allows us to make sense of her extended preferences. Sympathy – an attitude of care and concern – is a psychological state quite different from empathy. We should also allow for hetereogeneity in spectators’ extended preferences. Interpersonal comparisons emerge from a plurality of sympathetic spectators, not (as per Harsanyi) from a common empathetic ranking.

Linked references
Hide All

This list contains references from the content that can be linked to their source. For a full set of references and notes please see the PDF or HTML where available.

M. Abdellaoui , C. Barrios and P. P. Wakker . 2007. Reconciling introspective utility with revealed preference: experimental arguments based on prospect theory. Journal of Econometrics 138: 356378.

R. J. Arneson 1999. Human flourishing versus desire satisfaction. In Human Flourishing, ed. E. F. Paul , F. D. Miller and J. Paul , 113142. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

M. Brown 2003. The elimination of personal identity. Southwest Philosophy Review 19: 239247.

S. L. Darwall 1998. Empathy, sympathy, care. Philosophical Studies 89: 261282.

S. L. Darwall 2002. Welfare and Rational Care. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

S. L. Darwall , A. Gibbard and P. Railton . 1992. Toward fin de siècle ethics: some trends. Philosophical Review 101: 115189.

D. Donaldson and J. A. Weymark . 1998. A quasiordering is the intersection of orderings. Journal of Economic Theory 78: 382387.

Ö. Evren and E. A. Ok . 2011. On the multi-utility representation of preference relations. Journal of Mathematical Economics 47: 554563.

N. Feit 2008. Belief about the Self: A Defense of the Property Theory of Content. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

M. Fleurbaey and D. Blanchet . 2013. Beyond GDP: Measuring Welfare and Assessing Sustainability. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

T. Gajdos and F. Kandil . 2008. The ignorant observer. Social Choice and Welfare 31: 193232.

R. M. Gordon 1995. Sympathy, simulation, and the impartial spectator. Ethics 105: 727742.

S. Grant , A. Kajii, B. Polak and Z. Safra. 2012a. Equally-distributed equivalent utility, ex post egalitarianism and utilitarianism. Journal of Economic Theory 147: 15451571.

S. Grant , A. Kajii, B. Polak and Z. Safra. 2012b. A generalized representation theorem for Harsanyi's (‘impartial’) observer. Social Choice and Welfare 39: 833846.

J. C. Harsanyi 1953. Cardinal utility in welfare economics and in the theory of risk-taking. Journal of Political Economy 61: 434435.

J. C. Harsanyi 1955. Cardinal welfare, individualistic ethics, and interpersonal comparisons of utility. Journal of Political Economy 63: 309321.

J. C. Harsanyi 1977. Rational Behavior and Bargaining Equilibrium in Games and Social Situations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

A. Kind 2011. The puzzle of imaginative desire. Australasian Journal of Philosophy 89: 421439.

V. Köbberling 2006. Strength of preference and cardinal utility. Economic Theory 27: 375391.

D. Lewis 1979. Attitudes de dicto and de se. Philosophical Review 88: 513543.

P. Mackie 2006. How Things Might Have Been: Individuals, Kinds, and Essential Properties. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

P. Mongin 2001. The impartial observer theorem of social ethics. Economics and Philosophy 17: 147179.

S. Nichols 2008. Imagination and the I. Mind and Language 23: 518535.

D. Ninan 2009. Persistence and the first-person perspective. Philosophical Review 118: 425464.

E. Ooghe and L. Lauwers . 2005. Non-dictatorial extensive social choice. Economic Theory 25: 721743.

M. C. Overvold 1980. Self-interest and the concept of self-sacrifice. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 10: 105118.

M. C. Overvold 1984. Morality, self-interest, and reasons for being moral. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 44: 493507.

J. Perry 1979. The problem of the essential indexical. Noûs 13: 321.

F. Recanati 2007. Perspectival Thought: A Plea for (Moderate) Relativism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

S. L. Reynolds 1989. Imagining oneself to be another. Noûs 23: 615633.

M. Risse 2002. Harsanyi's ‘utilitarian theorem’ and utilitarianism. Noûs 36: 550577.

K Roberts . 1997. Objective interpersonal comparisons of utility. Social Choice and Welfare 14: 7996.

S. Roca-Royes 2011. Essential properties and individual essences. Philosophy Compass 6: 6577.

J. E. Roemer 2008. Harsanyi's impartial observer is not a utilitarian. In Justice, Political Liberalism, and Utilitarianism: Themes from Harsanyi and Rawls, ed. M. Fleurbaey , M. Salles and J. A. Weymark , 129135. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

A. Sen 1976. Welfare inequalities and Rawlsian axiomatics. Theory and Decision 7: 243262.

A. Sen 1986. Social choice theory. In Handbook of Mathematical Economics, Vol. 3, ed. K. J. Arrow and M. D. Intriligator , 10731181. Amsterdam: North-Holland.

M. Smith , D. Lewis and M. Johnston . 1989. Dispositional theories of value. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society (Supplementary vols.) 63: 89174.

J. D. Velleman 1996. Self to self. Philosophical Review 105: 3976.

A. Voorhoeve 2014. Book review (M.D. Adler, Well-Being and Fair Distribution). Social Choice and Welfare 42: 245254.

J. A. Weymark 1991. A reconsideration of the Harsanyi–Sen debate on utilitarianism. In Interpersonal Comparisons of Well-Being, ed. J. Elster and J. E. Roemer , 255320. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

J. A. Weymark 2005. Measurement theory and the foundations of utilitarianism. Social Choice and Welfare 25: 527555.

B. Williams 1973. Problems of the Self: Philosophical Papers 1956–1972. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Economics & Philosophy
  • ISSN: 0266-2671
  • EISSN: 1474-0028
  • URL: /core/journals/economics-and-philosophy
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *