Skip to main content
×
×
Home

NEUROECONOMICS: A CRITICAL RECONSIDERATION

  • Glenn W. Harrison (a1)
Abstract

Understanding more about how the brain functions should help us understand economic behaviour. But some would have us believe that it has done this already, and that insights from neuroscience have already provided insights in economics that we would not otherwise have. Much of this is just academic marketing hype, and to get down to substantive issues we need to identify that fluff for what it is. After we clear away the distractions, what is left? The answer is that a lot is left, but it is still all potential. That is not a bad thing, or a reason to stop the effort, but it does point to the need for a serious reconsideration of what neuroeconomics is and what passes for explanation in this literature. I argue that neuroeconomics can be a valuable field, but not the way it is being developed and “sold” now. The same is true more generally of behavioural economics, which shares many of the methodological flaws of neuroeconomics.

Copyright
Corresponding author
*Department of Economics, College of Business Administration, University of Central Florida, USA, and Durham Business School, Durham University, UK (part-time). Email contact: gharrison@research.bus.ucf.edu.
References
Hide All
Allgower E. L. and Georg K.. 2003. Introduction to numerical continuation methods. Phildaelphia: Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics.
Andersen S., Harrison G. W., Lau M. I. and Rutström E. E.. 2007. Behavioral econometrics for psychologists. Working Paper 07-04. Department of Economics, College of Business Administration, University of Central Florida; Journal of Economic Psychology, forthcoming.
Andersen S., Harrison G. W., Lau M. I. and Rutström E. E.. 2008a. Eliciting risk and time preferences. Econometrica 76: 583618.
Andersen S., Harrison G. W., Lau M. I. and Rutström E. E.. 2008b. Lost in state space: are preferences stable? International Economic Review 49: 10911112.
Anderson J. R. 2000. Cognitive psychology and its implications, 5th edn. New York: Worth.
Andreasen N. C., Arndt S., Swayze V., Cizadlo T., Flaum M., O'Leary D., Ehrhardt J. C. and Yuh W. T. C.. 1994. Thalamic abnormalities in schizophrenia visualized through magnetic resonance image averaging. Science 266: 294–8.
Bacharach M. 2006. Beyond individual choices: teams and frames in game theory. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Barrett L. F., Tugade M. M. and Engle R. W.. 2004. Individual differences in working memory capacity and dual-process theories of the mind. Psychological Bulletin 130: 553–73.
Benhabib J. and Bisin A.. 2005. Modeling internal commitment mechanisms and self-control: A neuroeconomics approach to consumption-saving decisions. Games and Economic Behavior 52: 460–92.
Becker G. M., DeGroot M. H., Morris H. and Marschak J.. 1963. Stochastic models of choice behavior. Behavioral Science 8: 4155.
Berridge K. C. 1996. Food reward: brain substrates of wanting and liking. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 20: 125.
Bhatt M. and Camerer C. F.. 2005. Self-referential thinking and equilibrium as states of mind in games: fMRI evidence. Games and Economic Behavior 52: 424–59.
Binmore K. 2007a. Playing for real. A text on game theory. New York: Oxford University Press.
Binmore K. 2007b. Does game theory work? The bargaining challenge. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Bolton P. and Dewatripont M.. 2005. Contract Theory. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Bowman F. D., Caffo B., Bassett S. S. and Kilts C.. 2008. A Bayesian hierarchical framework for spatial modeling of fMRI data. NeuroImage 39: 146–56.
Bronars S. G. 1987. The power of nonparametric tests of preference maximization. Econometrica 55: 693–8.
Bullmore E., Brammer M., Williams S. C. R., Rabe-Hesketh S., Janot N., David A., Mellers J., Howard R. and Sham P.. 1995. Statistical methods of estimation and inference for functional MR image analysis. Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 35: 261–77.
Camerer C. F. and Ho T.-H.. 1994. Violations of the betweeness axiom and nonlinearity in probability. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 8: 167–96.
Camerer C. 2003. Behavioral game theory: Experiments in strategic interaction. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Camerer C. 2008. The case for mindful economics. In Foundations of positive and normative economics, ed. Caplin A. and Schotter A.. New York: Oxford University Press.
Camerer C., Loewenstein G. and Prelec D.. 2004. Neuroeconomics: why economics needs brains. Scandinavian Journal of Economics 106: 555–79.
Camerer C., Loewenstein G. and Prelec D.. 2005. Neuroeconomics: how neuroscience can inform economics. Journal of Economic Literature 43: 964.
Caplin A. and Schotter A., Andrew , eds. 2008. Foundations of positive and normative economics. New York: Oxford University Press.
Chambers R. G. and Quiggin J.. 2000. Uncertainty, production, choice, and agency: The state-contingent approach. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Chandrasekhar P. V. S., Capra C. M., Moore S., Noussair C. and Berns G.. 2008. Neurobiological regret and rejoice functions for aversive outcomes. NeuroImage 39: 1472–84.
Cohen J. D. 2005. The vulcanization of the human brain: A neural perspective on interactions between cognition and emotion. Journal of Economic Perspectives 19 (4): 324.
Coller M. and Williams M. B.. 1999. Eliciting individual discount rates. Experimental Economics 2: 107–27.
Cox J. C. 2004. How to identify trust and reciprocity. Games and Economic Behavior 46: 260–81.
Crum W. R., Griffin L. D., Hill D. L. G. and Hawkes D. J.. 2003. Zen and the art of medical image registration: correspondence, homology, and quality. NeuroImage 20: 1425–37.
Deaton A. S. 1974. The analysis of consumer demand in the United Kingdom, 1900–1970. Econometrica 42: 341–67.
Dehaene S. and Changeux J.-P.. 1997. A hierarchical neuronal network for planning behavior. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 94: 1329313298.
Dehaene S., E. Spelke, P. Pinel, R. Stanescu and Tsivkin S.. 1999. Sources of mathematical thinking: Behavioral and brain-imaging evidence. Science 284: 970974.
Delgado M. R., Nystrom L. E., Fissell C., Noll D. C. and Fiez J. A.. 2000. Tracking the hemodynamic responses to reward and punishment in the striatum. Journal of Neurophysiology 84: 3072–7.
DeQuervain D., Fischbacher U., Treyer V., Schellhammer M., Schnyder U., Buck A. and Fehr E.. 2004. The neural basis of altruistic punishment. Science 305: 1254–8.
Dickhaut J., McCabe K., Nagode J. C., Rustichini A., Smith K. and Pardo J. V.. 2003. The impact of the certainty context on the process of choice. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 100 (6): 3536–41.
Elliott R., Friston K. J. and Dolan R. J.. 2000. Dissociable neural responses in human reward systems. Journal of Neuroscience 20 (16): 6159–65.
Friedman D., Harrison G. W. and Salmon J.. 1984. The Informational Efficiency of Experimental Asset Markets. Journal of Political Economy 92: 349408.
Friston K. J., Ashburner J., Frith C. D., Poline J. B., Heather J. D. and Frackowiak R. S. J.. 1995. Spatial registration and normalization of images. Human Brain Mapping 2: 165–89.
Gallagher H. L. and Frith C. D.. 2003. Functional imaging of ‘Theory of Mind’. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 7: 7783.
Garcia C. B. and Zangwill W. I.. 1981. Pathways to solutions, fixed points, and equilibria. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Gigerenzer G. 1996. On narrow norms and vague heuristics: A reply to Kahneman and Tversky (1996). Psychological Review 103: 592–6.
Gilhooly K. J. and Falconer W. A.. 1974. Concrete and abstract terms and relations in testing a rule. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 26: 355–9.
Glimcher P. W. 2003. Decisions, uncertainty, and the brain: The science of neuroeconomics. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Goeree J. K., Holt C. A. and Palfrey T. R.. 2005. Regular quantal response equilibrium. Experimental Economics 8: 347–67.
Grether D. M., Plott C. R., Rowe D. B., Sereno M. and Allman J. M.. 2007. Mental processes and strategic equilibration: An fMRI study of selling strategies in second price auctions. Experimental Economics 10: 105–22.
Gul F. and Pesendorfer W.. 2006. Random expected utility. Econometrica 74: 121–46.
Gul F. and Pesendorfer W.. 2008. The case for mindless economics. In Foundations of positive and normative economics, ed. Caplin A. and Schotter A.. New York: Oxford University Press.
Haile P. A., Hortaçsu A. and Kosenok G.. 2008. On the empirical content of quantal response equilibria. American Economic Review 98: 180200.
Harbaugh W. T., Mayr U. and Burghart D. R.. 2007. Neural responses to taxation and voluntary giving reveal motives for charitable donations. Science 316: 1622–5.
Harrison G. W. 1989. Theory and misbehavior of first-price auctions. American Economic Review 79: 749–62.
Harrison G. W. 1992. Theory and misbehavior of first-price auctions: Reply. American Economic Review 82: 1426–43.
Harrison G. W. and List J. A.. 2004. Field experiments. Journal of Economic Literature 42: 1013–59.
Harrison G. W. and Rutström E. E.. 2005. Expected utility theory and prospect theory: one wedding and a decent funeral. Working Paper 05-18. Department of Economics, College of Business Administration, University of Central Florida; Experimental Economics, forthcoming.
Harrison G. W. and Rutström E. E.. 2008. Risk aversion in the laboratory. In Risk aversion in experiments, ed. Cox J. C. and Harrison G. W.. Bingley, UK: Emerald.
Harsanyi J. C. 1975. The tracing procedure: A Bayesian approach to defining a solution for n-person non-cooperative games. International Journal of Game Theory 4: 6194.
Hayes J. R. and Simon H. A.. 1974. Understanding written problem instructions. In Knowledge and cognition, ed. Gregg L. W.. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Hey J. D. 2005. Why we should not be silent about noise. Experimental Economics 8: 325–45.
Hey J. D. and Orme C.. 1994. Investigating generalizations of expected utility theory using experimental data. Econometrica 62: 1291–326.
Hirshleifer J. and Riley J. G.. 1992. The analytics of uncertainty and information. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Hsu M., Bhatt M., Adolphs R., Tranel D. and Camerer C. F.. 2005. Neural systems responding to degrees of uncertainty in human decision-making. Science 310: 1680–3.
Johnson E. J., Camerer C. F., Sankar S. and Tymon T. T.. 2002. Detecting failures of backward induction: monitoring information search in sequential bargaining. Journal of Economic Theory 104: 1647.
Johnson-Laird P. N., Legrenzi P. and Sonino Legrenzi M.. 1972. Reasoning and sense of reality. British Journal of Psychology 63: 394400.
Jones L. S. 2007. The ethics of transcranial magnetic stimulation. Science 315: 1663.
Judd K. L. 1998. Numerical methods in economics. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Kahneman D. and Tversky A.. 1979. Prospect theory: An analysis of decision under risk. Econometrica 47: 263–91.
Kahneman D. and Tversky A.. 1996. On the reality of cognitive illusions. Psychological Review 103: 582–91.
Keller L., ed. 1999. Levels of selection in evolution. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Knoch D., Pascual-Leone A., Meyer K., Treyer V. and Fehr E.. 2006. Diminishing reciprocal fairness by disrupting the right prefontal cortex. Science 314: 829–32.
Knoch D., Pascual-Leone A. and Fehr E.. 2007. The ethics of transcranial magnetic stimulation: Response. Science 315: 1663–4.
Knutson B., Westdorp A., Kaiser E. and Hommer D.. 2000. FMRI visualization of brain activity during a monetary incentive delay task. NeuroImage 12: 20–7.
Kosfeld M., Heinrichs M., Zak P., Fischbacher U. and Fehr E.. 2005. Oxytocin increases trust in humans. Nature 435: 673–6.
Leland W. J. 1994. Generalized similarity judgements: An alternative explanation for choice anomalies. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 9: 151–72.
Linden D. J. 2007. The accidental mind. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Lohrenz T., McCabe K., Camerer C. F. and Montague P. R.. 2007. Neural signature of fictive learning signals in a sequential investment task. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 104: 9494–8.
Loomes G. 2005. Modelling the stochastic component of behavior in experiments: some issues for the interpretation of data. Experimental Economics 8: 301–23.
Loomes G. and Sugden R.. 1998. Testing different stochastic specifications of risky choice. Economica 65: 581–98.
Lopes L. L. 1995. Algebra and process in the modeling of risky choice. In Decision Making from a Cognitive Perspective, ed. Busemeyer J. R., Hastie R. and Medin D. L.. San Diego: Academic Press.
Luce R. D. 1986. Response times: Their role in inferring elementary mental organization. New York: Oxford University Press.
Marr D. 1982. Vision: A computational investigation into the human representation and processing of visual information. New York: W. H. Freeman & Company.
Marr D. and Poggio T.. 1976. Cooperative computation of stereo disparity. Science 194: 283–7.
McCabe K., Houser D., Ryan L., Smith V. L. and Trouard T.. 2001. A functional imaging study of cooperation in two-person reciprocal exchange. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 98: 11832–5.
McClure S. M., Laibson D. I., Loewenstein G. and Cohen J. D.. 2004. Separate neural systems value immediate and delayed monetary rewards. Science 306: 503–7.
McClure S. M., Ericson K. M., Laibson D. I., Loewenstein G. and Cohen J. D.. 2007. Time discounting for primary rewards. Journal of Neuroscience 27: 5796–804.
McDaniel T. M. and Rutström E. E.. 2001. Decision making costs and problem solving performance. Experimental Economics 4: 145–61.
Mehta J., Starmer C. and Sugden R.. 1994. The nature of salience: An experimental investigation of pure coordination games. American Economic Review 84: 658673.
Merlo A. and Schotter A.. 1992. Experimentation and learning in laboratory experiments: Harrison's criticism revisited. American Economic Review 82: 1413–25.
Montague P. R. and Berns G. S.. 2002. Neural economics and the biological substrates of valuation. Neuron 36: 265–85.
Paris Q. and Caputo M. R.. 2002. Comparative statics of money-goods specifications of the utility function. Journal of Economics (Zeitschrift für Nationalökonomie) 77: 5371.
Pratt J. W. 1964. Risk aversion in the small and in the large. Econometrica 32: 122–36.
Rabe-Hesketh S., Bullmore E. T. and Brammer M. J.. 1997. The analysis of functional magnetic resonance images. Statistical Methods in Medical Research 6: 215–37.
Rabin M. 1998. Psychology and economics. Journal of Economic Literature 36: 1146.
Rilling J. K., Sanfey A. G., Aronson J. A., Nystrom L. E. and Cohen J. D.. 2004. The neural correlates of theory of mind within interpersonal interactions. NeuroImage 22: 1694–703.
Ross D. 2005. Economic Theory and Cognitive Science: Microexplanation. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Rubinstein A. 1988. Similarity and decision-making under risk (is there a utility theory resolution to the Allais paradox?) Journal of Economic Theory 46: 145–53.
Rubinstein A. 2006. Discussion of ‘Behavioral Economics’. In Advances in Economics and Econometric Theory, ed. Blundell R., Newey W. K. and Persson T., vol II, 246–54. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Rubinstein A. 2007. Instinctive and cognitive reasoning: a study of response times. Economic Journal 117: 1243–59.
Samuelson L. 2005. Foundations of human sociality: a review essay. Journal of Economic Literature 43: 488–97.
Samuelson P. 1938. A note on the pure theory of consumer's behaviour. Economica 5: 6171.
Sanfey A. G., Rilling J. K., Aronson J. A., Nystrom L. E. and Cohen J. D.. 2003. The neural basis of economic decision-making in the ultimatum game. Science 300: 1755–8.
Simon H. A. 1996. The sciences of the artificial, 3rd edn. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Smith V. L. 1991. Rational choice: the contrast between economics and psychology. Journal of Political Economy 99: 877–97.
Smith V. L. 2003. Constructivist and ecological rationality in economics. American Economic Review 93: 465508.
Smith V. L. 2007. Rationality in economics: Constructivist and ecological forms. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Sorenson R. A. 1992. Thought experiments. New York: Oxford University Press.
Starmer C. 2000. Developments in non-expected utility theory: The hunt for a descriptive theory of choice under risk. Journal of Economic Literature 38: 332–82.
Stigler G. J. and Becker G. S.. 1977. De Gustibus Non Est Disputandum. American Economic Review 67: 7690.
Sugden R. 2003. The logic of team reasoning. Philosophical Explorations 6: 165–81.
Sunder S. 2006. Economic theory: structural abstraction or behavioral reduction? History of Political Economy 38: 322–42.
Tisserand D. J., Pruessner J. C., Sanz Arigita E. J., Boxtel M. P. J., Evans A. C., Jolles J. and Uylings H. B. M.. 2002. Regional frontal cortical volumes decrease differentially in aging: an MRI study to compare volumetric approaches and voxel-based morphometry. NeuroImage 17: 657–9.
Tversky A. 1969. Intransitivity of preferences. Psychological Review 76: 3148.
Tversky A. 1977. Features of similarity. Psychological Review 84: 327–52.
Varian H. R. 1985. Non-parametric analysis of optimizing behavior with measurement error. Journal of Econometrics 30: 445–58.
Varian H. R. 1988. Revealed preference with a subset of goods. Journal of Economic Theory 46: 179–85.
von Winterfeldt D. and Edwards W.. 1982. Costs and payoffs in perceptual research. Psychological Bulletin 19: 609–22.
von Winterfeldt D. and Edwards W.. 1986. Decision analysis and behavioral research. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Wason P. C. and Johnson-Laird P. N.. 1972. Psychology of reasoning: structure and content. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Wason P. C. and Shapiro D.. 1971. Natural and contrived experience in a reasoning problem. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 23: 6371.
White N. M. and Gaskin S.. 2006. Dorsal hippocampus function in learning and expressing a spatial discrimination. Learning and Memory 13: 119–22.
Wilcox N. T. 1993. Lottery choice: incentives, complexity and decision time. Economic Journal 103: 1397–417.
Wilcox N. T. 2006. Theories of learning in games and heterogeneity bias. Econometrica 74: 1271–92.
Wilcox N. T. 2008a. Stochastic models for binary discrete choice under risk: a critical primer and econometric comparison. In Risk Aversion in Experiments, ed. Cox J. and Harrison G. W.. Bingley, UK: Emerald.
Wilcox N. T. 2008b. Stochastically more risk averse: a contextual theory of stochastic discrete choice under risk. Journal of Econometrics 142: forthcoming.
Wong D. K., Grosenick L., Uy E. T., Guimaraes M. P., Carvalhaes C. G., Desain P. and Suppes P.. 2008. Quantifying inter-subject agreement in brain-imaging analyses. NeuroImage 39: 1051–63.
Zak P. J., Kurzban R. and Matzner W. T.. 2005. Oxytocin is associated with human trustworthiness. Hormones and Behavior 48: 522–7.
Zak P. J., Stanton A. A. and Ahmadi S.. 2007. Oxytocin increases generosity in humans. PloS ONE, 11: e1128, 15.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Economics & Philosophy
  • ISSN: 0266-2671
  • EISSN: 1474-0028
  • URL: /core/journals/economics-and-philosophy
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 11
Total number of PDF views: 116 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 518 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 23rd January 2018. This data will be updated every 24 hours.