Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-2xdlg Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-06-15T20:46:59.008Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Sir Nicholas Bacon and the Elizabethan via media*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 February 2009

Patrick Collinson
Patrick Collinson
Affiliation:
University of Kent
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

There exists in the British Museum a copy of the prayer book of 1559 bearing the signature of Sir Nicholas Bacon. It would be reasonable to infer that the book was once the lord keeper's property, but a pleasing fancy to pretend that he autographed it for a friend and well-wisher. He was not the author of this all but final recension of the Anglican liturgy but he was one of its principal sponsors. For in the words of Ralph Churton,’the business of that important parliament… in which the acts of uniformity and supremacy for the settlement of religion were passed was principally managed by the Lord Keeper Bacon’. It was Bacon who presided, not only in the House of Lords but over the theological disputation in Westminster Hall which was staged as a public signal that the English Church was to be once more reformed according to the protestant model. In a speech at the conclusion of the 1559 parliament he defended the newly made settlement against opponents and detractors, and in so doing scratched in the sand, as it were, the line of the Anglican via media:’Amongst thease I meane to comprehende aswell those that be to swifte as those that be to slowe, those I say that goe before the lawe or beyond the lawe as those that will not followe.’

Type
Articles
Information
The Historical Journal , Volume 23 , Issue 2 , June 1980 , pp. 255 - 273
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1980

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Press-mark c.25.m.7.

2 Ralph, Churton, The life of Alexander Nowell (Oxford, 1809), pp. 39–40.Google Scholar

3 British Library, MS Harley 5176, fo. 113v. I am grateful to the History of Parliament Trust and specifically to the general editor of the History of Parliament, Mr P. W. Hasler, for enabling me to employ transcripts of Sir Nicholas Bacon's parliamentary speeches made by Sir John Neale. Some of these transcripts I checked against the originals when I was employed as Professor Neale's research assistant in 1955–6.

4 Zceveld, W. Gordon, Foundations of Tudor policy (Cambridge, Mass., 1948), pp. 119–22, 128–56, 163CrossRefGoogle Scholar. Cf. Verkamp, Bernard J., The indifferent mean: adiaphorism in the English Reformation to 1554, Studies in the Reformation, 1 (Athens, Ohio, 1977).Google Scholar

5 John, Foxe, Acts and monuments, ed. Cattley, S. R., vi (London, 1838), 30.Google Scholar

6 The two liturgies of Edward VI, ed. Ketley, J., Parker Society (Cambridge, 1844), p. 197.Google Scholar

7 The works of George Herbert, ed. Hutchinson, F. E. (Oxford, 1941), p. 109.Google Scholar

8 James, Brogden, Illustrations of the liturgy and ritual of the United Church of England and Ireland: being sermons and discourses selected from the works of eminent divines who lived during the seventeenth century (London, 1842), III, 473.Google Scholar

9 Dixon, R. W., History of the Church of England from the abolition of the Roman jurisdiction, v (Oxford, 1950), 57.Google Scholar

10 Neale, J. E., ‘The Elizabethan Acts of Supremacy and Uniformity’, English Historical Review, LXV (1950), 304–32CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Neale, J. E., Elizabeth I and her parliaments 1559–1581 (London, 1953), pp. 51–84.Google Scholar

11 Jones, Norman L., ‘Faith by statute: the politics of religion in the parliament of 1559’, unpublished Cambridge Ph.D. thesis (1978)Google Scholar. See also Dr Jones's article,’Profiting from religious reform: the land rush of 1559’, Historical Journal, XXII (1979), 279–94.Google Scholar

12 Zeeveld, Foundations of Tudor policy.

13 British Library, MS Harley 5176, fo. 106.

14 Correspondence between Bacon, Cecil and Parker, December 1558-September 1559, Correspondence of Matthew Parker, ed. Bruce, J. & Perowne, T. T., Parker Society (Cambridge, 1853), PP.49–63, 67–71, 76.Google Scholar

15 John Jewel to Peter Martyr, n.d., The Zurich letters, ed. Robinson, H., Parker Society (Cambridge, 1842), p. 23.Google Scholar

16 Correspondence of Matthew Parker, p. 173.

17 More, P. E., 'the spirit of Anglicanism’, in Anglicanism: the thought and practice of the Church of England, illustrated from the religious literature of the seventeenth century, ed. More, P. E. & Cross, F. L. (London, 1935), p. xxii.Google Scholar

18 R. J. Schoek,’Rhetoric and law in sixteenth-century England’, Studies in Philology, I (1957), 110–27.

19 Sir Robert, Naunton, Fragmenta regalia, English Reprints ed. Arber, E. (London, 1870), p. 38.Google Scholar

20 Earl, Miner, ’Patterns of Stoicism in thought and prose styles, 1530–1700’, P.M.L.A., LXXXV (1970), 1023–40Google Scholar. But see George Williamson, The Senecan amble: a study in prose from Bacon to Collier (Chicago, 1951).Google Scholar

21 John Earle, The autograph manuscript of microcosmographie, Scolar Press Facsimile (Leeds, 1966), p. 47. Cf. Williamson, The Senecan amble, p. 121.

22 British Library, MS Harley 5176, fo. 93v.

23 Ibid. fo. 89v.

24 The remains of Edmund Grindal, ed. Nicholson, W., Parker Society (Cambridge, 1843), p. 471.Google Scholar

25 See my article’If Constantine, then also Theodosius: St Ambrose and the integrity of the Elizabethan Ecclesia Anglicana’, Journal of Ecclesiastical History, xxx (1979), 205–29.Google Scholar

26 Quintilian, , x. i. 125–31, XII. i. 19. On Quintilian's criticism of Seneca, see George Kennedy, Quintilian (New York, 1969), pp. 112–13.Google Scholar

27 George, Puttenham, The art of English poesie (1589), ed. Willcox, G. D. and Alice, Walker (Cambridge, 1936), pp. 139–40Google Scholar. L. A. Sonnino remarks in A handbook to sixteenth-century rhetoric (1968) that’the influence particularly noticeable in this period is that of Quintilian’(p. 2). Dr Lisa Jardine has observed the value of the Institutio Oratorio for a training in the art of’arguing on one's feet’as a lawyer and politician. (‘Humanism and dialectic in sixteenth-century Cambridge: a preliminary investigation’, in Classical influences on European culture A.D. 1500–1700: proceedings of an international conference held at King's College Cambridge, April 1974, ed. Bolgar, R. R. (Cambridge, 1976), p. 145.)Google Scholar

28 Quintilian, xII. i. 3.

29 Moses, Hadas, The Stoic philosophy of Seneca (New York, 1958), esp. pp. 17–19.Google Scholar

30 Quoted, Elizabeth McCutcheon in her edition of Sir Nicholas Bacon's Great House Sententiae (see n. 33 below), p. 24.

31 Ibid. p. 58.

32 Robert, Tittler, Nicholas Bacon: the making of a Tudor statesman (London, 1976), p. 57.Google Scholar

33 Quoted, McCutcheon, Bacon's Great House Sententiae, p. 13. There is a University of Chicago doctoral dissertation by Ernest R. Sandeen,’The building activities of Sir Nicholas Bacon‘(1959).

34 British Library, MS Royal 17 A XXIII. Edited with English translation and introduction by Elizabeth McCutcheon, Sir Nicholas Bacon's Great House Sententiae, English Literary Renaissance Supplements, III (Amherst, 1977).

35 British Library, MS Harley 398, fo. 7r.

36 Privately printed 1903, issued (Oxford, 1919) as The recreations of his age, from a MS in the possession of the Rev. M. H. Marsden of Moreton, co. Dorset.

37 ‘It is really the Stoa that first recognized the full equality of husband and wife’(Ludwig Edelstein, The meaning of Stoicism (Cambridge Mass., 1966), p. 73).Google Scholar

38 F. E. More in Anglicanism, p. xxiii.

39 British Library, MS Harley 5176, fo. 89.

40 McCutcheon, Bacon's Great House Sententiae, p. 32.

41 Some were collected by his son Francis: see Apophthegmes: the works of Francis Bacon, ed. Spedding, J., Ellis, R. L. and Heath, D. D., vII (London, 1861).Google Scholar

42 Ibid. 171.

43 Sir Nicholas Bacon to Nicholas Bacon, 23 Aug. 1573; E. R. Sandeen,’Correspondence of Nicholas Bacon, Lord Keeper’, University of Chicago A.M. dissertation (1955), p. 149.

44 Quoted, Hurstfield, J., The Queen's wards: wardship and marriage under Elizabeth I (London, 1958), p. 26.Google Scholar

45 British Library, MS Add. 33271, fo. I5V.

46 Mortimer, Levine, The early Elizabethan succession question, 1558–1568 (Stanford, 1966), pp. 74–85.Google Scholar

47 Conyers Read, Mr Secretary Cecil and Queen Elizabeth (London, 1955), pp. 281–3.Google Scholar

48 Archbishop Parker to Lady Bacon, 6 Feb. 1568; Correspondence of Matthew Parker, pp. 309–16.

49 Preserved Smith, , The life and letters of Martin Luther (London, 1911), p. 206.Google Scholar

50 This perhaps prompted Professor Gordon Rupp to entitle his 1975 quatercentenary lecture on Parker’Matthew Parker, a Man’, and to give to the volume of’historical pieces’in which it appears the general title Just men (London, 1977).

51 The select works of Robert Crowley, ed. Cowper, J. M., Early English Test Society, xv (London, 1872), 156.Google Scholar

52 Naunton, Fragmenta regalia, p. 38.

53 Conyers Read, Mr Secretary Cecil, p. 283.

54 Nicholas Bacon to the earl of Leicester, n.d.; British Library, MS. Harley 1877, fo. 27.

55 Patrick, Collinson, Archbishop Grindal 1519–1583: the struggle for a reformed Church (London, 1979). P. 295.Google Scholar

56 Anthony Esler, The aspiring mind of the Elizabethan younger generation (Durham N.C., 1966), pp. 4–10.

57 Alan, Simpson, The wealth of the gentry 1540–1660: East Anglian studies (Cambridge, 1961)Google Scholar; E. R. Sandeen,’Correspondence of Nicholas Bacon’; Smith, A. H., County and Court: government and politics in Norfolk, 1558–1603 (Oxford, 1974); ed. Smith, A. H., The papers of Nathaniel Bacon of Stiffkey, 1 (1556–1577), Norfolk Record Society CLVI (Norwich, 1978 & 1979).Google Scholar

58 The recreations of his age, p. 38.

59 Simpson, Wealth of the gentry, pp. 45–52.

60 Ibid. p. 78.

61 Sandeen,’Correspondence of Nicholas Bacon‘, pp. 17–77.

62 Alan, Macfarlane, The origins of English individualism: the family, property and social transition (Oxford, 1978).Google Scholar

63 Simpson, Wealth of the gentry, p. 78.

64 Sir Nicholas Bacon: an address given by Dr J. P. T. Bury in St Bene't's Church at the Commemoration of Benefactors [of Corpus Christi College] on 5th December 1975.

65 The papers of Nathaniel Bacon, 1, 69.

66 Sandeen,’Correspondence of Nicholas Bacon’, p. 157.

67 Ibid. p. 162.

68 Ibid. p. 164.

69 The papers of Nathaniel Bacon, 1, 46.

70 Simpson, Wealth of the gentry, pp. 64, 79.

71 The papers of Nathaniel Bacon, 1, 143–4.

72 Nicholas Bacon: The Making of a Tudor statesman, esp. pp. 61–2, 92, 158–63, 168–71.

73 Neale, Elizabeth I and her parliaments, p. 81.

74 Collinson, Archbishop Grindal, pp. 259–63.

75 Historical Manuscripts Commission II th Report, appendix Iv (Marquis of Townshend MSS), 4–7.

76 Humphrey Tyndall to Lord Burghley, 19 Dec. 1595; Trinity College Cambridge MS B/14/9, fos. 127—8. I owe this reference to the kindness of Dr Peter Lake.

77 British Library, MS Harley 5176, fo. 89.

78 Inner Temple Library, MS Petyt 538/47, fo. 479.

79 British Library, MS Harley 5176, fos. 89–92. Simonds D’Ewes, The journals of all the parliaments (1682), misplaces this speech in the 1572 parliament (pp. 192–5). This has perhaps encouraged some historians to connect its burden with the radical puritan agitation which came to the surface in the parliaments of the early 1570s, and in the pamphlet of 1572, An admonition to the parliament.Google Scholar

80 Christopher Haigh,’Puritan evangelism in the reign of Elizabeth I’, English Historical Review, XCII (1977). 30–58.

81 Patrick Collinson,’Episcopacy and reform in England in the later sixteenth century’, Studies in Church History, III, ed. Cuming, G. J. (Leiden, 1966), 91–125.Google Scholar

82 Patrick Collinson,’Magistracy and ministry: A Suffolk miniature’, in Reformation conformity and dissent: essays in honour of Geoffrey Nuttall, ed. R. Buick Knox (London, 1977), pp. 70–91; Kenneth W. Shipps,’Lay patronage of East Anglian Puritan clerics in pre-revolutionary England’, unpublished Yale Ph.D. dissertation (1971).

83 Tittler, Nicholas Bacon, pp. 61–2, 154.

84 Printed in John Stubbs's Gaping Gulf with letters and other relevant documents, ed. Lloyd E. Berry, Folger documents of Tudor & Stuart civilization (Charlottesville, 1968).

85 Prest, Wilfrid R., The Inns of Court under Elizabeth I and the early Stuarts 1590–1640 (London, 1972), esp. chapter 9,’Preachers, puritans and the religion of lawyers’, pp. 187 219.Google Scholar

86 The papers of Nathaniel Bacon, 1, 90–1, 95–7, 122–3, 161, 174, 281–2.

87 Ibid. 73–4.

88 John Stubbs to William Davison, 30 April 1578, in John Stubbs's Gaping Gulf, pp. 106–7.

89 Rosemary O’Day,’The ecclesiastical patronage of the Lord Keeper, 1558–1642’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 5th ser., xxIII (1973), 89–109.

90 Quoted, Patrick, Collinson, The Elizabethan puritan movement (London, 1967), p. 27.Google Scholar

91 O’Day,’Ecclesiastical patronage’, pp. 101–2.

92 Lambeth Palace Library, MSS 648, no. 103, 649, no. 79, 650, no. 69.

93 Macaulay, T. B., Critical and historical essays, ed. Grieve, A. J. (London, ii. d.), II, 300.Google Scholar

94 John, Strype, Annals of the Reformation (Oxford, 1824), 11, ii, 605.Google Scholar

95 Neale, Elizabeth I and her parliaments, pp. 57, 59.

96 John Jewel to Peter Martyr, 28 April 1559; zurich letters, p. 21.

97 Philip McNair,’Ochino's apology: three gods or three wives?’, History, LX (1975), 353–73.

98 M. K. Mclntosh,’Sir Anthony Cooke: Tudor humanist, educator and religious reformer’, Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, cxIx (1975), 233–50.

99 Collinson, Elizabethan puritan movement, p. 257.

100 Lady Ann Bacon to Lord Burghley, 26 Feb. 1584(/5); British Library, MS Lansdowne 43, no. 48, fos. 119–20. This copy is holograph. There is a further copy in MS Lansdowne 115, no. 55. fo- 125.

101 Anthony Bacon to Lady Ann Bacon, 12 July 1594; British Library, MS Add. 4112, fo. 49r. See the Index to the papers of Anthony Bacon (1558–1601) in Lambeth Palace Library (MSS. 647–662) (1974).

102 Thomas, Birch, Memoirs of the reign of Queen Elizabeth (London, 1754), 1, 67–8.Google Scholar

103 Edward Spencer to Anthony Bacon, 16 Aug. 1594; Lambeth Palace Library, MS 650, nos. 169–70.

104 D.N.B., art. Lady Ann Bacon.

105 The papers of Nathaniel Bacon, 1, 89–90.

106 British Library, MS Lansdowne 43, no. 48, fo. 120.

107 British Library, MS Harley 398, fos. 8v-9r.

108 Peter Lake,’Laurence Chaderton and the Cambridge moderate puritan tradition, 1570–1604’, unpublished Cambridge Ph.D. thesis (1978).

109 ’The Via Media in politics: an historical parallel’, in Essays in Elizabethan history (London, 1958). For the cultural implications, see J. A. van Dorsten, The radical arts: first decade of an Elizabethan renaissance (Leiden & Oxford, 1970).Google Scholar

110 British Library, MS Harley 398, fos. I2v-I5v.

111 Ibid. fos. 44v-5.

112 British Library, MS Cotton Titus F. i, fos. 123–6.

113 Tittler, Nicholas Bacon, pp. 173–86. Three letters from Bacon to the queen on matters of foreign policy discharged his responsibility as a councillor in this respect in the last months of his life. Copies in British Library, MS Harley 168, nos. 6, 23, 24, fos. 52–3, 91–2, 97.

114 Bacon to Walsingham, 24 July 1578; ibid. no. 25, fo. 94.

115 Esler, The aspiring mind, pp. 69–70.

116 The letters and life of Francis Bacon, ed. Spedding, J. (London, 1861), 1, 75.Google Scholar