We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 February 2009
A decade ago there appeared a volume of twelve essays on Lloyd George, written by a dozen young historians and edited by A. J. P. Taylor. These pieces, of varying merit and degree of interest, ranged widely from pre-1914 social reform to the Greek question and even to the Second World War.1 Yet strangely enough one of the most colourful patches of the huge canvas that was Lloyd George's life did not receive so much as a passing glance - namely his relations with the press. Taylor had hinted at the possibilities in that sphere when preparing a volume of his own essays a few years earlier. There he placed in sequence two entertaining chapters of quite unequal length and importance, one entitled ‘Lloyd George: rise and fall’ and the other ‘The Chief’.2 The latter requires a little explanation, for ‘ Chief was the style of address beloved of Alfred Harmsworth, Viscount Northcliffe, the man who owned The Times, Daily Mail, Evening News, and a host of other newspapers and journals. Quite simply he was the greatest press lord of them all, and Fleet Street has known many. While it is manifestly impossible in a few pages to explore in detail the full story of Lloyd George and the press, we can profitably follow his relations with Lord Northcliffe during the years 1914 to 1918 when these two giants were at the peak of their power and their fortunes were intertwined in many and strange ways. During the war Northcliffe was frequently called (and with utmost seriousness) ‘The Most Powerful Man in the Country’, while at the end Lloyd George was ‘The Man Who Won the War’. Often it seemed that the stage was not big enough for both and the British people must choose between them. Not until 1918 did two events - the ‘Maurice debate’ and the ‘Coupon election’ - prove conclusively that in the final analysis Lloyd George's power was real while Northcliffe's was largely illusory. Perhaps none was more surprised at this outcome, certainly none was more relieved, than Lloyd George himself. The reasons will become apparent as the history of their wartime relationship unfolds.
1 A.J.P., Taylor, ed., Lloyd George: twelve essays (London, 1971).Google Scholar
2 Taylor, A.J.P., Politics in wartime and other essays (London, 1964).Google Scholar
3 One quip ran: ‘The Cabinet has resigned and Lord Northcliffe has sent for the King’.
4 Reginald, Pound and Geoffrey, Harmsworth, Northcliffe (London, 1959), pp. 376–7.Google Scholar
5 Taylor, , Politics in wartime, p. 125.Google Scholar
6 Owen, Frank, Tempestuous journey: Lloyd George, his life and times (London, 1954), p. 286.Google Scholar
7 Lord Riddell's war diary 1914–1918 (London, 1933), p. 78.Google Scholar
8 Northcliffe, to George, Lloyd, 29 May 1915. Lloyd George papers, D/18/1/4, House of Lords Record Office.Google Scholar
9 Pound, and Harmsworth, , Northcliffe, p. 481.Google Scholar
10 See, for example, the many items of Northcliffe correspondence for the period 24 May to 9 September 1915, in the Lloyd George papers, D/18/1.
11 Pound, and Harmswort, , Northcliffe, p. 493.Google Scholar
12 Taylor, A.J.P., ed., Lloyd George. A diary by Frances Stevenson (1971), p. 90.Google Scholar
13 ibid.. p. 98.
14 Riddell's war diary, p. 153.Google Scholar
15 Pound, and Harmsworth, , Northcliffe, p. 498.Google Scholar
16 ibid..
17 The history of The Times, iv: The 150th anniversary and beyond,1912–1948, part 1 (London, 1952), 316.Google Scholar
18 Riddell's war diary, p. 185.Google Scholar
19 Pound, and Harmsworth, , Northcliffe, p. 500.Google Scholar
20 Taylor, A.J.P., English history, 1914–1945(London, 1965), p. 58.Google Scholar
21 History of The Times, iv, part 1, 285.Google Scholar
22 Hankey papers, Diary, HNKY 1/1, Churchill College, Cambridge.
23 Blake, Robert (ed.), The private papers of Douglas Haig (London, 1953), p. 155. Sir Philip Sassoon was a wealthy young Unionist M.P. serving as private secretary to Haig.Google Scholar
24 Pound, and Harmsworth, , Northcliffe, p. 503.Google Scholar
25 Private papers of Douglas Haig, p. 157.Google Scholar
26 Pound and Harmsworth, Northcliffe, p. 503. This does not appear to be in the Lloyd George papers.
27 Riddell's war diary, p. 208. Lee (later Lord Lee of Fareham) was a wealthy Unionist M.P. on Lloyd George's staff at the War Office.Google Scholar
28 Private papers of Douglas Haig, p. 166.Google Scholar
29 Pound, and Harmsworth, , Northcliffe, pp. 506–7.Google Scholar
30 C.à Repington, C., The First Word War (2 vols., London, 1920), 1, 354.Google Scholar
31 Owen, , Tempestuous journey, p. 325.Google Scholar
32 Gilbert, Martin, Winston Churchill, III (London, 1971). 811.Google Scholar
33 ibid..
34 Pound and Harmsworth, Northcliffe, p. 508.Google Scholar
35 Clarke, Tom, My Northcliffe diary (London, 1931), p. 102.Google Scholar
36 Beavcrbrook, Lord, Politicians and the War (one-volume edition, London, 1960), p. 323.Google Scholar The story in this form, frequently repeated, seems to have originated with Beaverbrook, but Pound and Harmsworth doubt that Northcliffe used those precise words. Certainly Northcliffe passed on a warning to Lloyd George about interfering with strategy, and told both Cecil Harmsworth and Sassoon that he had done so.
37 Repington, , First World War, 1, 374.Google Scholar
38 Riddell's war diary, p. 216.Google Scholar
39 Lloyd George. A diary by Frances Stevenson, pp. 122, 125.Google Scholar
40 McEwen, J.M., ‘The Pressand the fall of Asquith’, The Historical Journal, xxi, 4 (1978), 863–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
41 Beaverbrook's draft ‘History of the Crisis’. Beaverbrook papers, deed box 4, folder xxi. House of Lords Record Office. London.
42 Lloyd George. A diary by Frances Stevenson, p. 130.Google Scholar
43 See Spectator, 30 June 1933.Google Scholar
44 Beaverbrook, Politicians and the War, p. 512.Google Scholar
45 ibid.. p. 544, where Beaverbrook says that at Lloyd George's request he rang up Northcliffe, only to receive the cold reply: ‘Lord Northcliffe sees no advantage in any interview between him and the Prime Minister at the present juncture’. But see Taylor, A.J.P., Beaverbrook (London, 1972), pp. 120–7Google Scholar, where the evidence points to the unlikelihood of Beaverbrook having been with Lloyd George at any time during the first few days of the new administration. Probably Beaverbrook sought to improve upon the story in the Daily Chronicle of 8 December 1916 where Northcliffe was quoted as saying: ‘I prefer to sit in Printing House Square and Carmelite House’.
46 George, David Lloyd, War memoirs (6 vols., London, 1933–1936), iv, 2228.Google Scholar
47 Private papers of Douglas Haig, p. 190.Google Scholar
48 Lord Beaverbrook, Men and power, 1917–1918 (London, 1956), p. 47.Google Scholar
49 Pound and Harmsworth, Northcliffe, p. 520.
50 Riddell's war diary, p. 238.Google Scholar
51 Lloyd George. A diary by Frances Stevenson, p. 157.Google Scholar
52 Roskill, Stephen, Hankey, Man of secrets (3 vols., London, 1970–1974), 1, 390–1.Google Scholar
53 Wilson, Trevor (ed.), The political diaries of C. P. Scott, 1911–1928 (London, 1970), p. 296.Google Scholar
54 Beaverbrook, , Men and power, p. 172.Google Scholar
55 Churchill, Winston, The world crisis (6 vols., London, 1923–1931), ii, 293.Google Scholar
56 Pound, and Harmsworth, , Northcliffe, pp. 580, 585.Google Scholar
57 Beaverbrook, Men and power, p. 84Google Scholar; George, Lloyd, War memoirs, iv, 1871.Google Scholar
58 Beaverbrook, Men and power, p. 86.Google Scholar
59 Pound, and Harmsworth, , Northclife, p. 598.Google Scholar
60 Hankey, Lord, The Supreme Command 2 vols., London, 1961), (11, 777.Google Scholar
61 Political diaries of C. P. Scott, p. 336.Google Scholar
62 Pound, and Harmsworth, , Northcliffe, p. 613.Google Scholar
63 History of The Times, iv, part 1, 357.Google Scholar
64 Pound, and Harmsworth, , Northcliffe, p. 634.Google Scholar
65 Riddell's war diary, p. 366.Google Scholar
66 Pound, and Harmsworth, , Northcliffe, p. 682.Google Scholar
67 Roch, Walter, Life of David Lloyd George (4 vols., London, 1920), iv, 164.Google Scholar
