Skip to main content
×
×
Home

The (In)compatibility of Peace and Justice? The International Criminal Court and Civil Conflict Termination

Abstract
Abstract

Does the International Criminal Court's (ICC) pursuit of justice facilitate peace or prolong conflict? This paper addresses the “peace versus justice” debate by examining the ICC's impact on civil conflict termination. Active ICC involvement in a conflict increases the threat of punishment for rebel and state leaders, which, under certain conditions, generates incentives for these leaders to continue the conflict as a way to avoid capture, transfer to the Hague, and prosecution. The impact of ICC involvement is conditional upon the threat of domestic punishment that leaders face; as the risk of domestic punishment increases, the conflict-prolonging effects of ICC involvement diminish. I test these theoretical expectations on a data set of all civil conflict dyads from 2002 to 2013. Findings support the hypothesized relationship. Even after addressing potential selection and endogeneity concerns, I find that active involvement by the ICC significantly decreases the likelihood of conflict termination when the threat of domestic punishment is relatively low.

Copyright
References
Hide All
Ai Chunrong, and Norton Edward C.. 2003. Interaction Terms in Logit and Probit Models. Economics Letters 80 (1):123–29.
Akhavan Payam. 2001. Beyond Impunity: Can International Criminal Justice Prevent Future Atrocities? The American Journal of International Law 95 (1):731.
Angrist Joshua D., and Pischke Jörn-Steffen. 2008. Mostly Harmless Econometrics: An Empiricist's Companion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Anonymous. 1996. Human Rights in Peace Negotiations. Human Rights Quarterly 18 (2):249–58.
Appel Benjamin J. 2016. In the Shadow of the International Criminal Court: Can the ICC Deter Human Rights Violations? Journal of Conflict Resolution. Published electronically 25 April. doi:10.1177/0022002716639101
Appel Benjamin J., and Prorok Alyssa K.. 2014. Does the ICC Have an Africa Problem? Understanding the Determinants of ICC Involvement. Paper presented at the American Political Science Association Annual Meeting, Washington, DC.
Arsanjani Mahnoush H. 1999. The International Criminal Court and National Amnesty Laws. Proceedings of the Annual Meeting (American Society of International Law) 93:6568.
Bailey Michael, Strezhnev Anton, and Voeten Erik. 2015. Estimating Dynamic State Preferences from UN Voting Data. Journal of Conflict Resolution 61 (2):430–56.
Balch-Lindsay Dylan, Enterline Andrew J., and Joyce Kyle A.. 2008. Third-Party Intervention and the Civil War Process. Journal of Peace Research 45 (3):345–63.
Baum Christopher F. 2006. An Introduction to Modern Econometrics Using Stata. College Station, TX: Stata Press.
Beardsley Kyle, and Schmidt Holger. 2012. Following the Flag or Following the Charter? Examining the Determinants of UN Involvement in International Crises, 1945–2002. International Studies Quarterly 56 (1):3349.
Bosco David. 2014. Rough Justice: The International Criminal Court in a World of Power Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Bosco David, and Rudolph Christopher. 2013. Principles and Pragmatism: Explaining Why the ICC Investigates Some Cases but Not Others. Paper presented at the American Political Science Association Annual Meeting, Chicago, IL.
Broache Michael. 2014. The International Criminal Court and Atrocities in DRC: A Case Study of the RCD-Goma (Nkunda Faction)/CNDP/M23 Rebel Group. Available at <http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2434703>. Accessed 21 June 2015.
Bueno De Mesquita Bruce, Morrow James D., Siverson Randolph M., and Smith Alastair. 1999. Policy Failure and Political Survival: The Contribution of Political Institutions. Journal of Conflict Resolution 43 (2):147–61.
Buhaug Halvard, and Gleditsch Kristian Skrede. 2008. Contagion or Confusion? Why Conflicts Cluster in Space. International Studies Quarterly 52 (2):215–33.
Carter David B., and Signorino Curtis S.. 2010. Back to the Future: Modeling Time Dependence in Binary Data. Political Analysis 18 (3):271–92.
Chapman Terrence L., and Chaudoin Stephen. 2013. Ratification Patterns and the International Criminal Court. International Studies Quarterly 57 (2):400409.
Cingranelli David L., and Richards David L.. 2010. The Cingranelli and Richards (CIRI) Human Rights Data Project. Human Rights Quarterly 32 (2):401–24. doi:10.1353/hrq.0.0141.
Clark Thomas Hethe. 2005. The Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Amnesties, and the “Interests of Justice”: Striking a Delicate Balance. Washington University Global Studies Law Review 4 (2):389414.
Collier Paul, Hoeffler Anke, and Söderbom Mans. 2004. On the Duration of Civil War. Journal of Peace Research 41 (3):253–73.
Croco Sarah E. 2011. The Decider's Dilemma: Leader Culpability, War Outcomes, and Domestic Punishment. American Political Science Review 105 (3):457–77.
Cunningham David. 2010. Blocking Resolution: How External States Can Prolong Civil Wars. Journal of Peace Research 47 (2):115–27.
Cunningham David, Gleditsch Kristian Skrede, and Salehyan Idean. 2009. It Takes Two: A Dyadic Analysis of Civil War Duration and Outcome. Journal of Conflict Resolution 53 (4):570–97.
Cunningham David, Gleditsch Kristian Skrede, and Salehyan Idean. 2013. Non-State Actors in Civil Wars: A New Dataset. Conflict Management and Peace Science 30 (5):516–31.
Cunningham Kathleen. 2011. Divide and Conquer or Divide and Concede: How Do States Respond to Internally Divided Separatists? American Political Science Review 105 (2):275–97.
Danner Allison Marston. 2003. Enhancing the Legitimacy and Accountability of Prosecutorial Discretion at the International Criminal Court. The American Journal of International Law 97 (3):510–52.
Deephouse David L., and Suchman Mark. 2008. Legitimacy in Organizational Institutionalism. In The Sage Handbook of Organizational Institutionalism, edited by Greenwood Royston, Oliver Christine, Suddaby Roy, and Sahlin-Andersson Kerstin, 4977. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Deitelhoff Nicole. 2009. The Discursive Process of Legalization: Charting Islands of Persuasion in the ICC Case. International Organization 63 (1):3365.
DeRouen Karl, and Sobek David. 2004. The Dynamics of Civil War Duration and Outcome. Journal of Peace Research 41 (3):303–20.
Doob Anthony N., and Webster Cheryl Marie. 2003. Sentence Severity and Crime: Accepting the Null Hypothesis. Crime and Justice 30:143–95.
Downs George W., and Rocke David M.. 1994. Conflict, Agency, and Gambling for Resurrection: The Principal-Agent Problem Goes to War. American Journal of Political Science 38 (2):362–80.
Drago Francesco, Galbiati Roberto, and Vertova Pietro. 2009. The Deterrent Effects of Prison: Evidence from a Natural Experiment. Journal of Political Economy 117 (2):257–80.
Eck Kristine, and Hultman Lisa. 2007. One-Sided Violence Against Civilians in War: Insights from New Fatality Data. Journal of Peace Research 44 (2):233–46.
Fearon James D. 2004. Why Do Some Civil Wars Last so Much Longer than Others? Journal of Peace Research 41 (3):275301.
Fehl Caroline. 2004. Explaining the International Criminal Court: A “Practice Test” for Rationalist and Constructivist Approaches. European Journal of International Relations 10 (3):357–94.
Fein Helen. 1995. More Murder in the Middle: Life-Integrity Violations and Democracy in the World, 1987. Human Rights Quarterly 17 (1):170–91.
Finnemore Martha, and Sikkink Kathryn. 1998. International Norm Dynamics and Political Change. International Organization 52 (4):887917.
Gilligan Michael J. 2006. Is Enforcement Necessary for Effectiveness? A Model of the International Criminal Regime. International Organization 60 (4):935–67.
Goemans H.E. 2000. War and Punishment: The Causes of War Termination and the First World War. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Goemans H.E. 2008. Which Way Out? The Manner and Consequences of Losing Office. Journal of Conflict Resolution 52 (6):771–94.
Goldsmith Jack. 2003. The Self-Defeating International Criminal Court. The University of Chicago Law Review 70 (1):89104.
Goldsmith Jack, and Krasner Stephen D.. 2003. The Limits of Idealism. Daedalus 132 (1):4763.
Goldstone Richard. 1995. Justice as a Tool for Peace-Making: Truth Commissions and International Criminal Tribunals. NYU Journal of International Law and Politics 28 (3):485504.
Goodliffe Jay, and Hawkins Darren. 2009. A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Rome: Explaining International Criminal Court Negotiations. Journal of Politics 71 (3):977–97.
Gurses Mehmet. 2015. Transnational Ethnic Kin and Civil War Outcomes. Political Research Quarterly 68 (1):142–53.
Hanmer Michael J., and Kalkan Kerem Ozan. 2013. Behind the Curve: Clarifying the Best Approach to Calculating Predicted Probabilities and Marginal Effects from Limited Dependent Variable Models. American Journal of Political Science 57 (1):263–77.
Hillebrecht Courtney. 2012. Trying the Perpetrators and Fueling the War: The (Perverse) Effects of the International Criminal Court? Paper presented at the APSA 2012 Annual Meeting, New Orleans.
Howe Edmund S., and Loftus Thomas C.. 1996. Integration of Certainty, Severity, and Celerity Information in Judged Deterrence Value: Further Evidence and Methodological Equivalence. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 26 (3):226–42.
International Criminal Court. Office of the Prosecutor. 2003. Paper on Some Policy Issues before the Office of the Prosecutor. <http://www.icc-cpi.int/NR/rdonlyres/1FA7C4C6-DE5F-42B7-8B25-60AA962ED8B6/143594/030905_Policy_Paper.pdf>. Accessed 21 January 2014.
Jalloh Charles Chernor. 2009. Regionalizing International Criminal Law? International Criminal Law Review 9 (3):445–99.
Jo Hyeran, and Simmons Beth A.. 2014. Can the International Criminal Court Deter Atrocity? SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 2552820. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network. <http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2552820>. Accessed 21 June 2015.
Keller Linda. 2007. Achieving Peace with Justice: The International Criminal Court and Ugandan Alternative Justice Mechanisms. Connecticut Journal of International Law 23 (2):209–81.
Kleiman Mark. 2009. When Brute Force Fails: How to Have Less Crime and Less Punishment. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Ku Julian, and Nzelibe Jide. 2006. Do International Criminal Tribunals Deter or Exacerbate Humanitarian Atrocities? Washington University Law Review 84 (4):777833.
Levitt Steven D. 1998. Why Do Increased Arrest Rates Appear to Reduce Crime: Deterrence, Incapacitation, or Measurement Error? Economic Inquiry 36 (3):353–72.
Majzub Diba. 2002. Peace or Justice? Amnesties and the International Criminal Court. Melbourne Journal of International Law 3 (2):247–79.
Marshall Monty G., and Jaggers Keith. 2010. Polity IV Project: Political Regime Characteristics and Transitions, 1800–2010. University of Maryland. Available at <http://www.systemicpeace.org/inscrdata.html>. Accessed 21 June 2013.
Meernik James, Nichols Angela, and King Kimi L.. 2010. The Impact of International Tribunals and Domestic Trials on Peace and Human Rights After Civil War. International Studies Perspectives 11 (4):309–34.
Meernik James, and Shairick Jamie. 2011. Promoting International Humanitarian Law: Strong States and the Ratification of the ICC Treaty. International Area Studies Review 14 (2):2348.
Nagin Daniel S. 1998. Criminal Deterrence Research at the Outset of the Twenty-First Century. Crime and Justice 23:142.
Nalepa Monika. 2010. Skeletons in the Closet: Transitional Justice in Post-Communist Europe. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Nalepa Monika, and Powell Emilia Justyna. 2016. The Role of Domestic Opposition and International Justice Regimes in Peaceful Transitions of Power. Journal of Conflict Resolution 60 (7):11911218.
Nilsson Desirée. 2010. Turning Weakness into Strength: Military Capabilities, Multiple Rebel Groups and Negotiated Settlements. Conflict Management and Peace Science 27 (3):253–71.
Paternoster Raymond. 1987. The Deterrent Effect of the Perceived Certainty and Severity of Punishment: A Review of the Evidence and Issues. Justice Quarterly 4 (2):173217.
Powell Emilia Justyna, and Staton Jeffrey K.. 2009. Domestic Judicial Institutions and Human Rights Treaty Violation. International Studies Quarterly 53 (1):149–74. doi:10.1111/j.1468-2478.2008.01527.x.
Powell Jonathan. 2012. Determinants of the Attempting and Outcome of Coups d’état. Journal of Conflict Resolution 56 (6):1017–40.
Prorok Alyssa K. 2016. Leader Incentives and Civil War Outcomes. American Journal of Political Science 60 (1):7084.
Robinson Darryl. 2003. Serving the Interests of Justice: Amnesties, Truth Commissions and the International Criminal Court. European Journal of International Law 14 (3):481505.
Schabas William. 2008. Prosecutorial Discretion v. Judicial Activism at the International Criminal Court. Journal of International Criminal Justice 6 (4):731–61.
Schabas William. 2011. An Introduction to the International Criminal Court. 4th ed. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Scharf Michael. 1999. The Amnesty Exception to the Jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court. Cornell International Law Journal 32 (3):507–27.
Simmons Beth A., and Danner Allison. 2010. Credible Commitments and the International Criminal Court. International Organization 64 (2):225–56.
Souare Issaka K. 2009. The International Criminal Court and African Conflicts: The Case of Uganda. Review of African Political Economy 36 (121):369–88.
Stahn Carsten. 2009. Judicial Review of Prosecutorial Discretion: Five Years On. In The Emerging Practice of the International Criminal Court, edited by Stahn Carsten and Sluiter Goran, 247–79. Leiden, Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
Staiger Douglas O., and Stock James H.. 1997. Instrumental Variables Regression with Weak Instruments. Econometrica 65 (3):557–86.
Stock James H., and Yogo Motohiro. 2005. Testing for Weak Instruments in Linear IV Regression. In Identification and Inference for Econometric Models: Essays in Honor of Thomas Rothenberg, edited by Andrews Donald, and Stock James, 80108. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Themnér Lotta, and Wallensteen Peter. 2014. Armed Conflicts, 1946–2013. Journal of Peace Research 51 (4):541–54.
Thyne Clayton L. 2012. Information, Commitment, and Intra-War Bargaining: The Effect of Governmental Constraints on Civil War Duration. International Studies Quarterly 56 (2):307–21.
Villa-Vicencio Charles. 2000. Why Perpetrators Should Not Always Be Prosecuted: Where the International Criminal Court and Truth Commissions Meet. Emory Law Journal 49 (1):205–22.
Wippman David. 1999. Atrocities, Deterrence, and the Limits of International Justice. Fordham International Law Journal 23 (2):473–88.
Wooldridge Jeffrey M. 2002. Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

International Organization
  • ISSN: 0020-8183
  • EISSN: 1531-5088
  • URL: /core/journals/international-organization
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×
Type Description Title
PDF
Supplementary materials

Prorok supplementary material
Prorok supplementary material

 PDF (1.4 MB)
1.4 MB

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 36
Total number of PDF views: 564 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 1779 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 3rd April 2017 - 15th December 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.