Skip to main content
×
Home
    • Aa
    • Aa

Making the Real: Rhetorical Adduction and the Bangladesh Liberation War

Abstract
Abstract

Do normative arguments change what political actors do and if so, how? Rather than using the pure force of abstract moral reasoning, states often try to move the locus of contestation to an arena where they can make practical progress—the evidence or the empirical facts in support of their argument. This paper analyzes how states try to bolster their position first by constructing an argument in which an action represents part of their argument and then by performing that action to make the argument seem more convincing. I call this mechanism rhetorical adduction. The paper challenges theories of communication that deny a causal role to the content of normative arguments and diverges from a leading view on argumentation that arguments have their effects through persuasion. Integrating strategic argumentation theory with theory from psychology about how people make choices based on compelling reasons rather than cost-benefit analysis, I also use theory from sociology on how people resolve morally complex situations through the performance of “reality tests.” I illustrate the mechanism using a case from the Indo-Pakistani war of 1971 when initial resistance to recognizing the putative state of Bangladesh after India's invasion of East Pakistan was reversed as a result of an argument that Indian troop withdrawal meant that international norms were not violated.

Copyright
References
Hide All
AdlerEmanuel, and Pouliot Vincent. 2011. International Practices. International Theory 3 (1):136.
ArielyDan, and Norton Michael I.. 2008. How Actions Create—Not Just Reveal—Preferences. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 12 (1):1316.
BassGary J. 2013. The Blood Telegram: Nixon, Kissinger, and a Forgotten Genocide. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
BeachDerek, and Pedersen Rasmus Brun. 2013. Process-Tracing Methods: Foundations and Guidelines. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
BenfordRobert D. 2011. Framing Global Governance from Below: Discursive Opportunities and Challenges in the Transnational Social Movement Arena. In Arguing Global Governance: Agency, Lifeworld, and Shared Reasoning, edited by Bjola Corneliu and Kornprobst Markus, 6784. New York: Routledge.
BenfordRobert D., and Snow David A.. 2000. Framing Processes and Social Movements: An Overview and Assessment. Annual Review of Sociology 26 (1):611–39.
BjolaCorneliu, and Kornprobst Markus, eds. 2011. Arguing Global Governance: Agency, Lifeworld, and Shared Reasoning. New York: Routledge.
BoltanskiLuc, and Thevenot Laurent. 1999. The Sociology of Critical Capacity. European Journal of Social Theory 2 (3):359–77.
BoltanskiLuc, and Thevenot Laurent. 2006. On Justification: Economies of Worth. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
BusbyJoshua W. 2007. Bono Made Jesse Helms Cry: Jubilee 2000, Debt Relief, and Moral Action in International Politics. International Studies Quarterly 51 (2):247–75.
CogginsBridget. 2014. Power Politics and State Formation in the Twentieth Century: The Dynamics of Recognition. New York: Cambridge University Press.
CrawfordNeta. 2002. Argument and Change in World Politics: Ethics, Decolonization, and Humanitarian Intervention. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
CrawfordJames. 2007. The Creation of States in International Law. 2nd ed. Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press.
DebnathAngela. 2011. British Perceptions of the East Pakistan Crisis 1971: “Hideous Atrocities on Both Sides”? Journal of Genocide Research 13 (4):421–50.
DeitelhoffNicole. 2009. The Discursive Process of Legalization: Charting Islands of Persuasion in the ICC Case. International Organization 63 (1):3365.
DietrichFranz, and List Christian. 2011. A Model of Non-Informational Preference Change. Journal of Theoretical Politics 23 (2):145–64.
DietrichFranz, and List Christian. 2013. A Reason-Based Theory of Rational Choice. Nous 47 (1):104–34.
ElsterJon. 1998. Deliberation and Constitution Making. In Deliberative Democracy, edited by Elster Jon, 97122. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
FabryMikulas. 2010. Recognizing States: International Society and the Establishment of New States Since 1776. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
FearonJames D. 1997. Signaling Foreign Policy Interests: Tying Hands Versus Sinking Costs. Journal of Conflict Resolution 41 (1):6890.
FinnemoreMartha, and Sikkink Kathryn. 1998. International Norm Dynamics and Political Change. International Organization 52 (4):887917.
GoldgeierJames M., and Tetlock Philip E.. 2001. Psychology and International Relations Theory. Annual Review of Political Science 4 (1):6792.
GoldsmithJack, and Posner Eric. 2002. Moral and Legal Rhetoric in International Relations: A Rational Choice Perspective. Journal of Legal Studies 31 (S1):S115S139.
GrantThomas D. 2015. Aggression Against Ukraine: Territory, Responsibility, and International Law. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
HanriederTine. 2011. The False Promise of the Better Argument. International Theory 3 (3):390415.
HartH.L.A. 1994. The Concept of Law. Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press.
JervisRobert. 1970. The Logic of Images in International Relations. New York: Columbia University Press.
JohnstoneIan. 2003. Security Council Deliberations: The Power of the Better Argument. European Journal of International Law 14 (3):437–80.
KornprobstMarkus. 2014. From Political Judgments to Public Justifications (and Vice Versa): How Communities Generate Reasons Upon Which to Act. European Journal of International Relations 20 (1):192216.
KrebsRonald R., and Jackson Patrick T.. 2007. Twisting Tongues and Twisting Arms: The Power of Political Rhetoric. European Journal of International Relations 13 (1):3566.
KuhnDeanna. 1991. The Skills of Argument. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
KuxDennis. 1994. Estranged Democracies: India and the United States 1941–1991. New Delhi: Sage.
McDermottRose. 2001. The Psychological Ideas of Amos Tversky and Their Relevance For Political Science. Journal of Theoretical Politics. 13 (1):533.
MearsheimerJohn. 2011. Why Leaders Lie: The Truth About Lying in International Politics. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
MercierHugo, and Sperber Dan. 2011. Why Do Humans Reason? Arguments For an Argumentative Theory. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 34 (2):5774.
MorBen D. 2012. Credibility Talk in Public Diplomacy. Review of International Studies 38 (2):393422.
MüllerHarald. 2004. Arguing, Bargaining and All That: Communicative Action, Rationalist Theory and the Logic of Appropriateness in International Relations. European Journal of International Relations 10 (3):395435.
MussonJanice. 2008. Britain and the Recognition of Bangladesh in 1972. Diplomacy and Statecraft 19 (1):125–44.
NyhanBrendan, and Reifler Jason. 2010. When Corrections Fail: The Persistence of Political Misperceptions. Political Behavior 32 (2):303–30.
RaghavanSrinath. 2013. 1971: A Global History of the Creation of Bangladesh. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
ReiterDan. 2012. Democracy, Deception, and Entry into War. Security Studies 21 (4):594623.
RisseThomas. 2000. “Let's Argue!” Communicative Action in World Politics. International Organization 54 (1):140.
RisseThomas. 2004. Global Governance and Communicative Action. Government and Opposition 39 (2):288313.
RisseThomas, Ropp Stephen C., and Sikkink Kathryn, eds. 1999. The Power of Human Rights: International Norms and Domestic Change. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
SalzbergJohn. 1973. UN Prevention of Human Rights Violations: The Bangladesh Case. International Organization 27 (1):115–27.
SartoriAnne. 2005. Deterrence by Diplomacy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
SchellingThomas C. 1960. The Strategy of Conflict. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
SchimmelfennigFrank. 2001. The Community Trap: Liberal Norms, Rhetorical Action, and the Eastern Enlargement of the European Union. International Organization 55 (1):4780.
SearleJohn. 2010. Making the Social World. New York: Oxford University Press.
SellSusan K., and Prakash Aseem. 2004. Using Ideas Strategically: The Contest Between Business and NGO Networks in Intellectual Property Rights. International Studies Quarterly 48 (1):143–75.
SeymourLee. 2014. Let's Bullshit! Arguing, Bargaining and Dissembling Over Darfur. European Journal of International Relations 20 (3):571–95.
ShafirEldar, Simonson Itamar, and Tversky Amos. 1993. Reason-based Choice. Cognition 49 (1):1136.
ShannonVaughn P. 2000. Norms Are What States Make of Them: The Political Psychology of Norm Violation. International Studies Quarterly 44 (2):293316.
ShannonVaughan P., and Kowert Paul A., eds. 2011. Psychology and Constructivism in International Relations: An Ideational Alliance. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
ShawMalcolm. 2003. The Role of Recognition and Non-Recognition with Respect to Secession: Notes on Some Relevant Issues. In Secession and International Law: Conflict Avoidance— Regional Appraisals, edited by Dahlitz Julie, 243–58. New York: United Nations.
SimonsonItamar. 1989. Choice Based on Reasons: The Case of Attraction and Compromise Effects. Journal of Consumer Research 16 (2):158–74.
SissonRichard, and Rose Leo E.. 1990. War and Secession: Pakistan, India, and the Creation of Bangladesh. Berkeley: University of California Press.
SlovicPaul. 1995. The Construction of Preference. American Psychologist 50 (5):364–71.
SnowDavid A., Rochford R. BurkeJr., Worden Steven K., and Benford Robert D.. 1986. Frame Alignment Processes, Micromobilization, and Movement Participation. American Sociological Review 51 (4):464–81.
ToulminStephen. 2003. The Uses of Argument. UK: Cambridge University Press.
TverskyAmos, Sattath Shmuel, and Slovic Paul. 1988. Contingent Weighting in Judgment and Choice. Psychological Review 95 (3):371–84.
UlbertCornelia, and Risse Thomas. 2005. Deliberately Changing the Discourse: What Does Make Arguing Effective? Acta Política 40 (3):351–67.
United Nations Security Council. 1971. Official Record 1971. New York: United Nations.
US Department of State. 2005. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1969–1976, Vol. 11, South Asia Crisis, 1971. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
US Department of State. 2005. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1969–1976, Vol. E-7, Documents on South Asia 1969–1972. Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.
Vlaev IvoNick Chater, Stewart Neil, and Brown Gordon D.A.. 2011. Does the Brain Calculate Value? Trends in Cognitive Sciences 15 (11):546–54.
WatsonScott D. 2012. “Framing” the Copenhagen School: Integrating the Literature on Threat Construction. Millennium 40 (2):279301.
WheelerNicholas. 2000. Saving Strangers: Humanitarian Intervention in International Society. New York: Oxford University Press.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

International Organization
  • ISSN: 0020-8183
  • EISSN: 1531-5088
  • URL: /core/journals/international-organization
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 3
Total number of PDF views: 184 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 424 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between 16th March 2017 - 21st October 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.