Skip to main content

Who Supports Global Economic Engagement? The Sources of Preferences in American Foreign Economic Policy

  • Helen V. Milner (a1) and Dustin H. Tingley (a2)

In this article we bring together opposing international relations theories to better understand U.S. foreign policy, in particular foreign trade and aid. Using votes in the U.S. House of Representatives from 1979–2004, we explore different theoretical predictions about preferences for foreign economic policy. We assess the impact of domestic factors, namely political economy and ideological preferences, versus foreign policy pressures. Our three main results highlight the differential effect of these factors in the two issue areas. First, aid preferences are as affected by domestic political economy factors as are trade preferences. Second, trade preferences, but not economic aid ones, are shaped by the president's foreign policy concerns; for economic aid, domestic political economy factors matter more than foreign policy ones. Third, aid preferences are shaped more by ideological factors than are trade ones, but ideology plays a different substantive role in each. Different constituencies support aid and trade. This finding has implications for foreign policy substitutability, “the internationalist coalition” in U.S. foreign policy, “statist” theories of foreign policy, and the connection between public opinion and legislative voting.

Hide All
Alden Chris. 2000. From Neglect to ‘Virtual Engagement’: The United States and Its New Paradigm for Africa. African Affairs 99 (396):355–71.
Alesina Alberto, and Dollar David. 2000. Who Gives Foreign Aid to Whom and Why? Journal of Economic Growth 5 (1):3363.
Arnold Douglas R. 1992. The Logic of Congressional Action. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.
Asher Herbert B., and Weisberg Herbert F.. 1978. Voting Change in Congress: Some Dynamic Perspectives on an Evolutionary Process. American Journal of Political Science 22 (2):391425.
Avery William P. 1998. Domestic Interests in NAFTA Bargaining. Political Science Quarterly 113 (2):281305.
Bailey Michael A. 2001. Quiet Influence: The Representation of Diffuse Interests on Trade Policy, 1983–1994. Legislative Studies Quarterly 26 (1):4580.
Bailey Michael A., Goldstein Judith, and Weingast Barry R.. 1997. The Institutional Roots of American Trade Policy: Politics, Coalitions, and International Trade. World Politics 49 (3):309–38.
Baldwin Robert E., and Magee Christopher S.. 2000. Is Trade Policy for Sale? Congressional Voting on Recent Trade Bills. Public Choice 105 (1-2):79101.
Bates Robert H. 1997. Open-Economy Politics: The Political Economy of the World Coffee Trade. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Beaulieu Eugene. 2002a. Factor or Industry Cleavages in Trade Policy? An Empirical Analysis of the Stopler-Samuelson Theorem. Economics and Politics 14 (2):99131.
Beaulieu Eugene. 2002b. The Stolper-Samuelson Theorem Faces Congress. Review of International Economics 10 (2):343–60.
Bhagwati Jagdish N., Brecher Richard A., and Hatta Tatsuo. 1983. The Generalized Theory of Transfers and Welfare: Bilateral Transfers in a Multilateral World. American Economic Review 73 (4):606–18.
Bhagwati Jagdish N., Brecher Richard A., and Hatta Tatsuo. 1984. The Paradoxes of Immiserizing Growth and Donor-Enriching ‘Recipient-Immiserizing’ Transfers: a Tale of Two Literatures. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv 110:228–43.
Bobbio Norberto. 1996. Left and Right: The Significance of a Political Distinction. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Brakman Steven, and van Marrewijk Charles. 1998. The Economics of International Transfers. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Broz J. Lawrence. 2005. Congressional Politics of International Financial Rescues. American Journal of Political Science 49 (3):479–96.
Broz J. Lawrence, and Hawes Michael Brewster. 2006. Congressional Politics of Financing the International Monetary Fund. International Organization 60 (2):367–99.
Busby Joshua W., and Monten Jonathan. 2008. Without Heirs? Assessing the Decline of Establishment Internationalism in U.S. Foreign Policy. Perspectives on Politics 6 (3):451–72.
Cameron David R. 1978. The Expansion of the Public Economy: A Comparative Analysis. American Political Science Review 72 (4):1243–61.
Canes-Wrone Brandice. 2006. Who Leads Whom? Presidents, Policy, and the Public. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Canes-Wrone Brandice, Howell William G., and Lewis David E.. 2008. Toward a Broader Understanding of Presidential Power: A Re-Evaluation of the Two Presidencies Thesis. Journal of Politics 70 (1):116.
Carter Ralph. 1999. Congressional Trade Politics, 1985–1995. Congress & the Presidency 26 (1):6176.
Chaudoin Stephen, Milner Helen, and Tingley Dustin. 2010. The Center Holds: Liberal Internationalism Survives. International Security 35 (1):7594.
Citrin Jack, Green Donald P., Muste Christopher, and Wong Cara. 1997. Public Opinion Toward Immigration Reform: The Role of Economic Motivations. Journal of Politics 59 (3):858–81.
Clark David H. 2001. Trading Butter for Guns: Domestic Imperatives for Foreign Policy Substitution. Journal of Conflict Resolution 45 (5):636–60.
Clark David H., and Reed William. 2005. The Strategic Sources of Foreign Policy Substitution. American Journal of Political Science 49 (3):609–24.
Clinton William. 2000. The Trade and Development Act of 2000: Strengthening Our Economic Partnership with Sub-Saharan Africa and the Caribbean Basin. Available at ⟨⟩. Accessed 30 March 2010.
Collier Kenneth, and Munger Michael. 1994. A Comparison of Incumbent Security in the House and Senate. Public Choice 78 (2):145–54.
Congressional Record. 1984. Congressional Record of the House. 98th Cong., 2d sess., 5 September.
Danahy Patrick. 1998. Testimony of the President of American Textile Manufacturers Institute to the U.S. Senate Finance Committee. 105th Cong., 2d sess., 17 June.
Denzau Arthur T., and Munger Michael C.. 1986. Legislators and Interest Groups: How Unorganized Interests Get Represented. American Political Science Review 80 (1):89106.
Destler I. M. 1995. American Trade Politics. 3d ed.Washington, D.C.: Institute for International Economics.
Diehl Paul F. 1994. Substitutes or Complements? The Effects of Alliances on Military Spending in Major Power Rivalries. International Interactions 19 (3):159–76.
Divine Robert A. 1967. Second Chance: The Triumph of Internationalism in America during World War II. New York: Atheneum.
Dutt Pushan, and Mitra Devashish. 2005. Political Ideology and Endogenous Trade Policy: An Empirical Investigation. Review of Economics and Statistics 87 (1):5972.
Edwards George C. III 1989. At the Margins: Presidential Leadership in Congress. New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.
Fleck Robert K., and Kilby Christopher. 2001. Foreign Aid and Domestic Politics: Voting in Congress and the Allocation of USAID Contracts Across Congressional Districts. Southern Economic Journal 67 (3):598617.
Fleisher Richard, and Bond Jon R.. 1988. Are There Two Presidencies? Yes, But Only for Republicans. Journal of Politics 50 (3):747–67.
Fleisher Richard, Krutz Glen S., and Hanna Stephen. 2000. The Demise of the Two Presidencies. American Politics Research 28 (1):325.
Fordham Benjamin O. 2008. Economic Interests and Public Support for American Global Activism. International Organization 62 (1):163–82.
Fordham Benjamin O., and McKeown Timothy J.. 2003. Selection and Influence: Interest Groups and Congressional Voting on Trade Policy. International Organization 57 (3):519–49.
Friman H. Richard. 1993. Side-Payments Versus Security Cards: Domestic Bargaining Tactics in International Economic Negotiations. International Organization 47 (3):387410.
Government Printing Office (GPO). 2004. Table B-97—Farm Income, 1945–2003. Available at ⟨⟩. Accessed 30 March 2010.
Grossman Gene M., and Helpman Elhanan. 2002. Interest Groups and Trade Policy. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Guisinger Alexandra. 2009. Determining Trade Policy: Do Voters Hold Politicians Accountable? International Organization 63 (3):533–57.
Haggard Stephen. 1988. The Institutional Foundations of Hegemony: Explaining the Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act of 1934. International Organization 42 (1):91119.
Hainmueller Jens, and Hiscox Michael J.. 2006. Learning to Love Globalization: Education and Individual Attitudes Toward International Trade. International Organization 60 (2):469–98.
Hainmueller Jens, and Hiscox Michael J.. 2007. Educated Preferences: Explaining Individual Attitudes Toward Immigration in Europe. International Organization 61 (2):399442.
Hansen John Mark. 1991. Gaining Access: Congress and the Farm Lobby, 1919–1981. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Hanson Gordon H., Scheve Kenneth F., and Slaughter Matthew. 2007. Public Finance and Individual Preferences Over Globalization Strategies. Economics and Politics 19 (1):133.
Hays Jude C., Ehrlich Sean D., and Peinhardt Clint. 2005. Government Spending and Public Support for Trade in the OECD: An Empirical Test of the Embedded Liberalism Thesis. International Organization 59 (2):473–94.
Hinckley Barbara. 1994. Less Than Meets the Eye: Foreign Policy Making and the Myth of the Assertive Congress. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Hiscox Michael J. 2002a. Commerce, Coalitions, and Factor Mobility: Evidence from Congressional Votes on Trade Legislation. American Political Science Review 96 (3):593608.
Hiscox Michael J. 2002b. International Trade and Political Conflict : Commerce, Coalitions, and Mobility. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Holsti Ole R. 1979. The Three-Headed Eagle: The United States and System Change. International Studies Quarterly 23 (3):339–59.
Howell William G., and Pevehouse Jon C.. 2007. While Dangers Gather: Congressional Checks on Presidential War Powers. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Ikenberry David, Lake David A., and Mastanduno Michael. 1988. The State and American Foreign Economic Policy. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.
Johnson Robert David. 2006. Congress and the Cold War. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Jones Ronald W. 1984. The Transfer Problem in a Three Agent Setting. Canadian Journal of Economics 17 (1):114.
Kalt Joseph P., and Zupan Mark A.. 1993. Capture and Ideology in the Economic Theory of Politics. Public Choice Theory. Vol. 2, The Characteristics of Political Equilibrium. International Library of Critical Writings in Economics, Vol. 24, 238–59.
Karol David. 2007. Does Constituency Size Affect Elected Officials' Trade Policy Preferences? Journal of Politics 69 (2):483–94.
Katzenstein Peter J. 1978. Between Power and Plenty: Foreign Economic Policies of Advanced Industrial States. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Kemp Murray C. 1995. The Gains from Trade and the Gains from Aid: Essays in International Trade Theory. New York: Routledge.
Kesselman Mark. 1961. Presidential Leadership in Congress on Foreign Policy. Midwest Journal of Political Science 5 (3):284–89.
Krasner Stephen D. 1978. Defending the National Interest: Raw Materials Investments and U.S. Foreign Policy. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Krugman Paul. 1993. The Uncomfortable Truth About NAFTA: It's Foreign Policy, Stupid. Foreign Affairs 72 (5):1319.
Kupchan Charles A., and Trubowitz Peter L.. 2007. Dead Center: The Demise of Liberal Internationalism in the United States. International Security 32 (2):744.
Ladewig Jeffrey W. 2006. Domestic Influences on International Trade Policy: Factor Mobility in the United States, 1963–1992. International Organization 60 (1):69103.
Legro Jeffrey W. 2000. Whence American Internationalism. International Organization 54 (2):253–89.
Liang Kung-Yee, and Zeger Scott L.. 1993. Regression Analysis for Correlated Data. Annual Review of Public Health 14:4358.
Lindsay James. 1994. Congress and the Politics of U.S. Foreign Policy. Baltimore. Md.: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Lohmann Susanne, and O'Halloran Sharyn. 1994. Divided Government and U.S. Trade Policy: Theory and Evidence. International Organization 48 (4):595632.
Lumsdaine David H. 1993. Moral Vision in International Politics: The Foreign Aid Regime 1949–1989. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Magee Christopher. 2010. Would NAFTA Have Been Approved by the House of Representatives Under President Bush? Presidents, Parties, and Trade Policy. Review of International Economics 18 (2):382–95
Magee Stephen P., Brock William A., and Young Leslie. 1989. Black Hole Tariffs and Endogenous Policy Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Manning Bayless. 1977. The Congress, the Executive and Intermestic Affairs: Three Proposals. Foreign Affairs 55 (2):306–24.
Mansfield Edward D., and Mutz Diana C.. 2009. Support for Free Trade: Self-Interest, Sociotropic Politics, and Out-Group Anxiety. International Organization 63 (3):425–57.
Marshall Bryan W. 2005. Explaining Congressional-Executive Rivalry in International Affairs: The Changing Role of Parties, Committees, and the Issue Agenda. In Divided Power: The Presidency, Congress, and the Formation of American Economic Policy, edited by Kelly Donald R., 111–32. Fayetteville: University of Arkansas Press.
Marshall Bryan W., and Prins Brandon C.. 2002. The Pendulum of Congressional Power: Agenda Change, Partisanship, and the Demise of the Post–World War II Foreign Policy Consensus. Congress and the Presidency 29 (2):195212.
Mayda Anna Maria, and Rodrik Dani. 2005. Why Are Some People (and Countries) More Protectionist Than Others? European Economic Review 49 (6):1393–430.
Mayer Wolfgang, and Raimondos-Møller Pascalis. 2003. The Politics of Foreign Aid: A Median Voter Perspective. Review of Development Economics 7 (2):165–78.
McCarty Nolan, Poole Keith T., and Rosenthal Howard. 2006. Polarized America: The Dance of Ideology and Unequal Riches. Cambridge. Mass.: MIT Press.
McCormick James M., and Wittkopf Eugene R.. 1990. Bipartisanship, Partisanship, and Ideology in Congressional-Executive Foreign Policy Relations, 1947–1988. Journal of Politics 52 (4):1077–100.
McCormick Ryan. 2006. The African Growth and Opportunity Act: The Perils of Pursuing African Development Through U.S. Trade Law. Texas International Law Journal 41 (2):339–84.
McGinnis Michael D. 1990. A Rational Model of Regional Rivalry. International Studies Quarterly 34 (1):111–35.
McKinlay Robert D., and Little Richard. 1977. A Foreign Policy Model of U.S. Bilateral Aid Allocations. World Politics 30 (1):5886.
McKinlay Robert D., and Little Richard. 1978. A Foreign-Policy Model of the Distribution of British Bilateral Aid, 1960–70. British Journal of Political Science 8 (3):313–31.
McKinlay Robert D., and Little Richard. 1979. The U.S. Aid Relationship: A Test of the Recipient Need and the Donor Interest Models. Political Studies 27 (2):236–50.
Meernik James. 1993. Presidential Support in Congress: Conflict and Consensus on Foreign and Defense Policy. Journal of Politics 55 (3):569–87.
Meernik James, and Oldmixon Elizabeth. 2008. The President, the Senate, and the Costs of Internationalism. Foreign Policy Analysis 4 (2):187206.
Milner Helen, and Tingley Dustin. 2010. The Domestic Politics of Foreign Aid: American Legislators and the Politics of Donor Countries. Economics and Politics 22 (2):200–32
Most Benjamin A., and Starr Harvey. 1984. International Relations Theory, Foreign Policy Substitutability, and ‘Nice’ Laws. World Politics 36 (3):383406.
Nelson Douglas R., and Greenaway David. 2006. The Distinct Political Economies of Trade and Migration Policy: Through the Window of Endogenous Policy Models, with a Focus on North America. In Labor Mobility and the World Economy, edited by Foders Federico and Langhammer Rolf J., 295327. Heidelberg, Germany: Springer.
Neuhaus J. M., Kalbfleisch J. D., and Hauck W. W.. 1991. A Comparison of Cluster-Specific and Population-Averaged Approaches for Analyzing Correlated Binary Data. International Statistical Review 59 (1):2535.
Noël Alain, and Thérien Jean-Philippe. 1995. From Domestic to International Justice: The Welfare State and Foreign Aid. International Organization 49 (3):523–53.
Noël Alain, and Thérien Jean-Philippe. 2008. Left and Right in Global Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). 2007. Table 2a: Disbursements. Available at ⟨⟩. Accessed 30 March 2010.
O'Rourke Kevin H., and Sinnott Richard. 2001. The Determinants of Individual Trade Policy Preferences: International Survey Evidence. Brookings Trade Forum, 157206.
Palmer Glenn., and Morgan T. Clifton. 2006. A Theory of Foreign Policy. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Palmer Glenn, Wohlander Scott B., and Morgan T. Clifton. 2002. Give or Take: Foreign Aid and Foreign Policy Substitutability. Journal of Peace Research 39 (1):526.
Poole Keith T., and Daniels R. Steven. 1985. Ideology, Party, and Voting in the U.S. Congress, 1959–1980. American Political Science Review 97 (2):373–99.
Regan Patrick M. 2000. Substituting Policies During U.S. Interventions in Internal Conflicts: A Little of This, a Little of That. Journal of Conflict Resolution 44 (1):90106.
Rodrik Dani. 1998. Why Do More Open Economies Have Bigger Governments? Journal of Political Economy 106 (5):9971032.
Rogowski Ronald. 1989. Commerce and Coalitions: How Trade Affects Domestic Political Alignments. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Rohde David W. 2004. Roll Call Voting Data for the United States House of Representatives, 1953–2004. Compiled by the Political Institutions and Public Choice Program, East Lansing, Michigan State University.
Roscoe Douglas D., and Jenkins Shannon. 2005. A Meta-Analysis of Campaign Contributions' Impact on Roll Call Voting. Social Science Quarterly 86 (1):5268.
Rosendorff B. Peter, and Milner Helen. 1996. Trade Negotiations, Information and Domestic Politics. Economics and Politics 8 (2):145–89.
Ruggie John. 1982. International Regimes, Transactions, and Change: Embedded Liberalism in the Postwar Economic Order. International Organization 36 (2):379417.
Russett Bruce. 1990. Controlling the Sword: The Democratic Governance of National Security. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
Scheve Kenneth F., and Slaughter Matthew J.. 2001a. Labor Market Competition and Individual Preferences Over Immigration Policy. Review of Economics and Statistics 83 (1):133–45.
Scheve Kenneth F., and Slaughter Matthew J.. 2001b. What Determines Individual Trade-Policy Preferences? Journal of International Economics 54 (2):267–92.
Schraeder Peter J., Hook Stephen W., and Taylor Bruce. 1998. Clarifying the Foreign Aid Puzzle: A Comparison of American, Japanese, French, and Swedish Aid Flows. World Politics 50 (2):294323.
Scott James M., and Carter Ralph G.. 2002. Acting on the Hill: Congressional Assertiveness in U.S. Foreign Policy. Congress & the Presidency 29 (2):151–69.
Sigelman Lee. 1979. A Reassessment of the Two Presidencies Thesis. Journal of Politics 44 (4):1195–205.
Thérien Jean-Philippe, and Noël Alain. 2000. Political Parties and Foreign Aid. American Political Science Review 94 (1):151–62.
Thompson Carol B. 2004. U.S. Trade with Africa: African Growth & Opportunity? Review of African Political Economy 31 (101):457–74.
Tilton Douglas. 1998. U.S.-Africa Economic Initiatives. Washington, D.C.: Foreign Policy in Focus, 1 May.
Tingley Dustin. 2010. Donors and Domestic Politics: Political Influences on Foreign Aid Commitments. Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 50 (1):4049.
Trubowitz Peter. 1998. Defining the National Interest: Conflict and Change in American Foreign Policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Trubowitz Peter, and Mellow Nicole. 2005. ‘Going Bipartisan’: Politics by Other Means. Political Science Quarterly 120 (3):433–53.
Uslaner Eric M. 1998. Let the Chits Fall Where They May? Executive and Constituency Influences on Congressional Voting on NAFTA. Legislative Studies Quarterly 23 (3):347–71.
Walters Ronald. 2004. The African Growth and Opportunity Act: Changing Foreign Policy Priorities Toward Africa in a Conservative Political Culture. In Diversity and U.S. Foreign Policy: A Reader, edited by III Ernest J. Wilson, 288306. New York: Routledge.
Weissman Stephen R. 1996. Culture of Deference: Congress's Failure of Leadership in Foreign Policy. New York: Basic Books.
Wildavsky Aaron. 1966. The Two Presidencies. Trans-Action 4:714.
Wittkopf Eugene R. 1990. Faces of Internationalism: Public Opinion and American Foreign Policy. Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press.
Wolfowitz Paul D. 1994. Clinton's First Year. Foreign Affairs 73 (1):2843.
World Trade Organization (WTO). 2006. “International Trade Statistics.” Geneva.
Younas Javed. 2008. Motivation for Bilateral Aid Allocation: Altruism or Trade Benefits. European Journal of Political Economy 24 (3):661–74.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

International Organization
  • ISSN: 0020-8183
  • EISSN: 1531-5088
  • URL: /core/journals/international-organization
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 25
Total number of PDF views: 291 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 828 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between September 2016 - 22nd November 2017. This data will be updated every 24 hours.