Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 February 2015
The Irish workhouse has had a troubled history, attracting mostly negative commentary from the inception of the national poor law system after 1838 to the final abolition of the poor law in Northern Ireland in 1948. The popular historian of the institution opens his account with the bald statement that ‘the workhouse was the most feared and hated institution ever established in Ireland’. While one might quibble with this (the penitentiaries and asylums of the nineteenth century were surely as much feared, and perhaps with more reason; the record of the industrial schools and Magdalene asylums has more recently attracted the appalled attention of Irish society), the statement contains a kernel of truth. Designed with the deterrent principle of ‘less eligibility’ to the forefront, and irrevocably associated with the horrors of mass mortality during the Great Famine, the workhouses became in Irish popular memory (and in the bulk of historical commentary) associated with the suffering and degradation of their inmates. Nevertheless, the early history of the poor law and its associated workhouses is more complex than this suggests and deserves closer attention.
1 O’Connor, John, The workhouses of Ireland: the fate of Ireland’s poor (Dublin, 1995), p. 13.Google Scholar
3 Foucault, Michel, Discipline and punish: the birth of the prison (London, 1977);Google ScholarIgnatieff, Michael, A just measure of pain: the penitentiary in the industrial revolution (London, 1978);Google ScholarDriver, Felix, Power and pauperism: the workhouse system 1834–84 (Cambridge, 1993).Google Scholar
7 Tenth annual report of the Poor Law Commissioners, H.C. 1844 , xix.9, p. 35.
8 See Gray, Peter, The making of the Irish poor law, 1815–43 (Manchester, 2009), passim.Google Scholar
10 Although the building was completed after Nicholls had left Southwell, its design influenced the ‘model’ workhouse plans approved by the Poor Law Commissioners in 1835 and disseminated to boards of guardians: Higginbotham, Peter, ‘Southwell Union (Thurgarton Hundred Incorporation), Nottinghamshire’, (accessed 3 Nov. 2011).Google Scholar
11 For Nicholls’s shifting position on the applicability of the workhouse principle in Ireland, see Gray, , Making of the Irish poor law, pp 130–4, 158–68.Google Scholar
12 Nicholls memo, 20 Jan. 1837 (T.N.A., HO100/247, fols 340-1); Report of Geo. Nicholls, esq. … on poor laws, Ireland, H.C. 1837 , li.201.
13 Revans, John, Evils of the state of Ireland: their cause and their remedy — a poor law (London, 1836). For its reception see Gray, Making of the Irish poor law, pp 230–1.Google Scholar
15 See for example the positive referencing of Revans by the liberal-Catholic writer McMahon, Patrick in Monthly Chronicle, 4 (Oct. 1839), p. 443.Google Scholar
16 Board memo, Poor Law, 9 Oct. 1838, in Fifth annual report of the Poor Law Commissioners, H.C. 1839  xx.1, p. 26.Google Scholar
17 Chadwick to Nicholls, 10 Dec. 1838 (U.C.L. Archives, London, Chadwick Papers, 1486/14-20); Poor Law Commissioner to Treasury, 8 Feb. 1839, in Fifth annual report, pp 33–4.
18 O’Dwyer, Frederick, ‘Building empires: architecture, politics and the Board of Works, 1760–1860’ in Irish Architectural and Decorative Studies, 5 (2002), pp 108–75.Google Scholar
19 Jackson’s Oxford Journal, 6 Feb. 1836.
20 Cooper, Nicholas and Morrison, Kathryn, ‘The English and Welsh workhouses of George Wilkinson’ in The Georgian Group Journal, 14 (2004), pp 105–6.Google Scholar
21 Ibid., p. 122.
22 Poor Law Commissioner to Treasury, 8 Feb. 1839, in Fifth annual report, p. 34.
24 Cooper and Morrison, ‘Wilkinson’, p. 123.
26 Nicholls, George, A history of the Irish poor law, in connexion with the condition of the people (London, 1856), p. 244.Google Scholar
28 Wilkinson, George, Practical geology and ancient architecture of Ireland (London, 1845).Google Scholar
29 For its part, the Irish Penny Journal featured Wilkinson’s workhouse plans in its issue of 27 February 1841, and, in an article probably penned by Samuel Ferguson, praised both the aims of the poor law and the commission’s ‘intelligent and skilful architect’.
30 The Literary Gazette, 10 May 1845.
32 Pugin, A. W. N., Contrasts, or a parallel between the noble edifices of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries and similar buildings of the present day; shewing the present decay of taste (London, 1836);Google Scholar for the illustrative contrast between friary and the panopticon-workhouse added in the 1841 edition, see Driver, Power, pp 61–2.
34 Fifth annual report, pp 81–3.
35 For the stylistic variations in front buildings within the ‘Elizabethan’ template, see Gould, ‘George Wilkinson and the Irish workhouse’, p. 137.
36 Hansard’s parliamentary debates, 3rd ser., lxvii, col. 1352 (23 Mar. 1843).
38 Mr and MrsHall, S. C., Ireland: its scenery, character, etc., vol. iii (London, 1843), pp 344–8.Google Scholar
39 Forbes, John, Memorandums made in Ireland in the autumn of 1852 (2 vols, London, 1853), i, 144–5, 275, 279–80; ii, 228.Google Scholar
40 Nicholls was inclined to blame poor weather for the delays, while asserting that most had been completed in reasonable time and to a high standard of finish (Irish poor law, pp 259–60, 271–2, 284–5).
41 Northern Star, 5 Oct. 1839.
42 Copies or extracts of correspondence between the chief secretary to the lord lieutenant of Ireland and the commissioners of public works, relative to the workhouses at Londonderry, Strabane, and Castlederg: also, copies of reports made by Jacob Owen, esq., architect to the Board of Public Works, on the state of these buildings, and the cost of their erection, H.C. 1843 (244) xlvi.659.
43 Report from the select committee on union workhouses, Ireland, H.C. 1844 (441), xiv.495; Report of the commission for inquiring into the execution of the contracts for certain union workhouses in Ireland, H.C. 1844 , xxx.387.
44 Appendix D. to the eighth annual report of the Poor Law Commissioners, H.C. 1842  xix.119, pp 196–202; Appendix to the report of the commissioner appointed to inquire into the execution of the contracts for certain union workhouses in Ireland, H.C. 1844  xxx.551.
45 Tenth annual report, pp 36–7; Gould, , ‘George Wilkinson and the Irish workhouse’, pp 65–6.Google Scholar Balrothery was one of a number of workhouses identified by the inspectors as suffering from poor location as well as shoddy worksmanship: Collins, Sinéad, Balrothery poor law union, County Dublin, 1839–1851 (Dublin, 2005), pp 25–7.Google Scholar
47 Gould, Michael and Cox, Ronald, ‘The railway stations of George Wilkinson’ in Irish architectural and decorative studies, 6 (2003), pp 183–201.Google Scholar
48 Connaught Journal, 29 June, 30 Oct. 1840.