We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 04 February 2015
Since the late 1980s crusade historiography has shown increasing interest in the periphery of Europe and the less ‘traditional’ crusading areas of Scotland, Wales, Poland and Scandinavia. Consideration of Ireland has formed part of this spread of interest, but, like many other areas, it remains comparatively unstudied. In part, the paucity of Irish texts relating to all kinds of crusading discourages research, as does the comparatively low number of known Irish crucesignati.
1 Guettner, Darius von, ‘Crusading in medieval Europe: its idea, reception, and the experience in Poland (1102–1194)’ (Ph.D. thesis, University of Melbourne, 2007Google Scholar); Hurlock, Kathryn, Wales and the Crusades, c. 1095– c. 1291 (Cardiff, forthcomingGoogle Scholar); Jensen, Kurt Villads, ‘Denmark and the crusading movement: the integration of the Baltic region into medieval Europe’ in MacInnes, Allan I., Pederesen, F. and Riis, Thomas (eds), Ships, guns and Bibles in the North Sea and Baltic States, c. 1350–1700 (East Linton, 2000), pp 188–205Google Scholar; Macquarrie, Alan, Scotland and the Crusades, 1095–1560 (Edinburgh, 1985; reprinted 1997Google Scholar).
2 Matthew, Elizabeth, ‘Henry V and the proposal for an Irish Crusade’ in Smith, Brendan (ed.), Ireland and the English world in the late Middles Ages: essays in honour of Robin Frame (Basingstoke, 2009), pp 161-75CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Kostick, Conor, ‘Ireland and the First Crusade’ in History Ireland, xi, no. 1 (2003), pp 12–13Google Scholar; Nicholson, Helen, ‘Serving king and Crusade: the military orders in royal service in Ireland, 1220–1400’ in Bull, Marcus and Housley, Norman (eds), The experience of crusading, vol. 1: Western approaches (Cambridge, 2003), pp 233-52Google Scholar; Costello, Con, ‘Ireland and the Crusades’ in Ir. Sword, ix (1970), pp 263–77Google Scholar.
3 Caball, Marc, ‘The literature of later medieval Ireland, 1200–1600: from the Normans to the Tudors’ in Kelleher, Margaret and O’Leary, Philip (eds), The Cambridge history of Irish literature, volume I: to 1890 (Cambridge, 2006), p. 74CrossRefGoogle Scholar.
4 Néill, Padraig Ó, ‘The impact of the Norman invasion on Irish literature’ in Anglo-Norman Studies, xx (1997), pp 172, 175Google Scholar.
5 Mc Carthy, D. P., The Irish annals: their genesis, evolution and history (Dublin, 2008), p. 10Google Scholar; Mac Niocaill, Gearóid, The medieval Irish annals (Dublin, 1975), p. 25Google Scholar; Corráin, Donnchadh Ó, ‘Annals of Inisfallen’ in Koch, John (ed.), Celtic culture (Oxford, 2006), p. 71Google Scholar; Gwynn, Aubrey and Neville Hadcock, R., Medieval religious houses, Ireland (London, 1970), p. 180Google Scholar.
6 Charles-Edwards, T. M. (ed.), The chronicle of Ireland (2 vols, Liverpool, 2006), i, 1Google Scholar. Clonmacnoise was an early Irish monastery, but became a cathedral church in the early twelfth century: Gwynn, & Hadcock, , Med. relig. houses, Ire., p. 64Google Scholar.
7 See Welch, Robert and Stewart, Bruce (eds), Oxford companion to Irish literature (Oxford, 1996), pp 15–17Google Scholar.
8 Simms, Katharine, Medieval Gaelic sources (Dublin, 2009), p. 22Google Scholar; Corráin, Ó, ‘Annals of Inisfallen’ in Koch, (ed.), Celtic culture, p. 21Google Scholar.
9 Simms, , Med. Gaelic sources, p. 21Google Scholar; Ó Corráin, , ‘Annals of Loch Cé’ in Koch, (ed.), Celtic culture, p. 73Google Scholar.
10 Simms, , Med. Gaelic sources, p. 26Google Scholar.
11 The Ó Mael Chonaire family were ‘poets and historians’ at the court of the Ua Conchobair kings of Connacht. They appear to have fulfilled this role from the beginning of the thirteenth century: Simms, Katharine, ‘Bardic schools, learned families’ in Duffy, Seán, MacShamhráin, Ailbhe and Moynes, James (eds), Medieval Ireland: an encyclopaedia (London, 2004), p. 36Google Scholar; Simms, , Med. Gaelic sources, p. 25Google Scholar.
12 Corráin, Donnchadh Ó, ‘Chronicon Scottorum’ in Koch, (ed.), Celtic culture, p. 72Google Scholar; Evans, Nicholas, ‘Annals & chronicles’ in Duffy, , MacShamhráin, & Moynes, (eds), Med. Ire.: an encyclopaedia, p. 21Google Scholar.
13 Evans, , ‘Annales & chronicles’ in Duffy, , MacShamhráin, & Moynes, (eds), Med. Ire.: an encyclopaedia, p. 21Google Scholar; Martin Freeman, A. (ed.), Annála Connacht/The annals of Connacht (a.d. 1224–1544) (Dublin, 1983), p. xxGoogle Scholar; Gwynn, & Hadcock, , Med. relig. houses, Ire., p. 128Google Scholar; A. Martin Freeman (ed.), ‘The annals in Cotton MS Titus A. xxv’ in Rev. Celt., xli (1924)–xliv (1927) [Annals of Boyle]; MacCarthaigh’s book, which uses the Annals of Inisfallen and other works as a source, contains no references to crusades; Ó hInnse, Séamus (ed.), Miscellaneous Irish annals (Dublin, 1947).Google Scholar
14 Simms, , Med. Gaelic sources, p. 24;Google ScholarÓ Clabaigh, Colmán N., ‘Annals of the Four Masters’ in Duffy, , MacShamhráin, & Moynes, (eds), Med. Ire.: an encyclopaedia, p. 23Google Scholar.
15 Duffy, , MacShamhráin, & Moynes, (eds), Med. Ire.: an encyclopaedia, p. 24Google Scholar.
16 Ó Néill, , ‘Impact of the Norman invasion’, p. 179Google Scholar.
17 Niocaill, Mac, Med. Irish annals, p. 37Google Scholar.
18 Scott, A. B., ‘Latin learning and literature in Ireland, 1169-1500’, in Dáibhí Ó, Cróinín (ed.), A new history of Ireland, i: prehistoric and early Ireland (Oxford, 2005), p. 988Google Scholar; Gwynn, Aubrey, ‘Some unpublished texts in the Black Book of Christ Church’ in Anal. Hib., xvi (1946), p. 313Google Scholar; Mac, Niocaill, Med. Ir. annals, p. 38Google Scholar.
19 Evans, , ‘Annals & chronicles’ in Duffy, , MacShamhráin, & Moynes, (eds), Med. Ire.: an encyclopaedia, p. 22Google Scholar.
20 Gwynn, & Hadcock, , Med. relig. houses, Ire., p. 130Google Scholar.
21 Niocaill, Mac, Med. Ir. annals, p. 38Google Scholar.
22 Grace, Jacobi, Kilkenniensis, Annales Hiberniae, ed. Butler, Richard (Dublin, 1842).Google Scholar
23 Niocaill, Mac, Med. Ir. annals, p. 38.Google Scholar
24 Scott, , ‘Latin learning’, pp 991–2Google Scholar.
25 Ibid., p. 989; Clyn’s interest in recording crusade-related events continued into the fourteenth century. He noted that in 1335 fervent crusaders were ‘marked on the naked fesh with the sign of the cross, with a red hot iron, that they might go to the Holy Land’: Williams, Bernadette, The annals of Ireland by Friar John Clyn (Dublin, 2007), p. 217Google Scholar. No other sources discuss this event, but Clyn may have included it because it occurred at the time of the erection of a cross in the centre of the town; the reference was included in the context of municipal rather than crusading history: Prim, John G. A., ‘The market cross of Kilkenny’ in Trans. Kilkenny Arch. Soc., ii (1852–3), p. 220Google Scholar.
26 Niocaill, Mac, Med. Ir. annals, p. 38Google Scholar; the association with Kilkenny was attributed by Robin Flower in 1931: Flower, Robin, ‘Manuscripts of Irish interest in British Museum’ in Anal. Hib., ii (1931), pp 292–340Google Scholar; Williams, Bernadette, ‘The Kilkenny Chronicle’ in Barry, Terry, Frame, Robin and Simms, Katharine (eds), Colony and frontier in medieval Ireland: essays presented to Lydon, J. F. (London, 1995), pp 75–96Google Scholar.
27 Scott, , ‘Latin learning’, p. 990Google Scholar.
28 Airt, Seán Mac (ed. and trans.), The Annals of Inisfallen (MS Rawlinson B.503) (Dublin, 1951), p. xxviiiGoogle Scholar. It is possible that the folios for these years were removed: Simms, , Med. Gaelic sources, p. 29Google Scholar.
29 Ó, Néill, ‘Impact of the Norman invasion’, p. 172Google Scholar.
30 Ibid., p. 175.
31 Scott, , ‘Latin learning’, pp 938–9Google Scholar.
32 Smith, Aquilla (ed.), Annales de Monte Fernandi [Annals of Multyfarnham] (Dublin, 1843), p. 6Google Scholar; Gwynn, , ‘Black Book of Christ Church’, p. 328Google Scholar.
33 Ibid., p. 9.
34 Pembridge’s Annals, ed.Gilbert, J. T. (London, 1884), p. 303Google Scholar. The annals written by James Grace between 1537 and 1539, which largely copy Pembridge’s work for the period 1162–70, also include the capture of ‘Babylon’: Grace, , Kilkenniensis, Annales Hiberniae, pp. v, 11Google Scholar.
35 Smith, (ed.), Annales de Monte Fernandi, p. 10Google Scholar; Gilbert, (ed.), Pembridge’s Annals, p. 305Google Scholar.
36 Smith, (ed.), Annales de Monte Fernandi, p. 10Google Scholar.
37 Ibid.; Gilbert (ed.), Pembridge’s Annals, p. 306; Williams, Annals of Ire., p. 137.
38 Smith, (ed.), Annales de Monte Fernandi, pp 10–11Google Scholar.
39 Ibid., p. 306; Williams, Annals of Ire., pp 136–7; Gillingham, J., Richard I (New Haven & London, 1999), p. 248Google Scholar.
40 Smith, (ed.), Annals de Monte Fernandi, p. 10Google Scholar.
41 Airt, Seán Mac and Niocaill, Gearóid Mac(eds), Annals of Ulster (Dublin, 1983), pp 527, 529Google Scholar; A.F. M., ii, 949–51.
42 Robinson, James Harvey (ed.), Readings in European history (2 vols, Boston, 1904), i, 316–18Google Scholar; Costick, , ‘Ireland & the First Crusade’, p. 12Google Scholar.
43 Airt, Mac (ed.), Annals of Inisfallen, p. 263Google Scholar.
44 William of Malmesbury, Gesta Regum Anglorum: the history of the English kings, ed. Thomson, R. M. (2 vols, Oxford, 1999), ii, 310Google Scholar.
45 Flanagan, Marie Thérèse, ‘High-kings with opposition’ in Cróinín, Ó (ed.), A new history of Ireland, i: prehistoric and early Ireland, p. 918Google Scholar.
46 Flanagan, , ‘High-kings with opposition’, p. 917Google Scholar; Hennessey, William M. (ed. and trans.), Chronicon Scotorum: a chronicle of Irish affairs (London, 1866), p. 275Google Scholar; Stokes, Whitley (trans.), Annals of Tigernach (2 vols, Llanerch, 1993), i, 43Google Scholar.
47 Petrie, George, ‘On the Cross of Cong’ in R.I.A. Proc., iv (1850), p. 579Google Scholar.
48 Costello, Con, Ireland and the Holy Land: an account of Irish links with the Levant from the earliest times (Dublin, 1974), p. 33Google Scholar.
49 Stokes, (trans.), Annals of Tigernach, p. 169Google Scholar; Hennessey, (ed.), Chron. Scot., p. 345Google Scholar.
50 Moore, R. I., The formation of a persecuting society: power and deviance in Western Europe, 950–1250 (Oxford, 1988), p. 29Google Scholar.
51 Rhigyfarch, , Life of St. David, trans. James, J. W. (Cardiff, 1967), p. 43Google Scholar.
52 Hurlock, , Wales & the Crusades (forthcoming), pp 16–17Google Scholar.
53 Hennessy, W. M. and MacCarthy, Bartholomew (eds), Annals of Ulster, otherwise Annals of Senat, a chronicle of Irish affairs, 432–1131, 1155–1541 (4 vols, Dublin, 1887–1901), ii, 201Google Scholar.
54 Grace, , Kilkenniensis, Annales Hiberniae, p. 17Google Scholar.
55 Gilbert, (ed.), Pembridge’s Annals, p. 305Google Scholar.
56 Smith, (ed.), Annales de Monte Fernandi, p. 10Google Scholar.
57 Williams, , Annals of Ire., p. 137Google Scholar.
58 Airt, Mac (ed.), Annals of Inisfallen, p. 307Google Scholar.
59 Flower, , ‘Manuscripts’, p. 331Google Scholar.
60 Barber, Malcolm, The new knighthood: a history of the Order of the Temple (Cambridge, 1994), pp 8–9Google Scholar.
61 Williams, , Annals of Ire., p. 193Google Scholar; Barber, , The new knighthood, p. 280Google Scholar.
62 Matthew the Templar appears as a witness on a deed of Henry II together with Archbishop Laurence O’Toole (d. 1180). McEnery, M. J. and Refaussé, Raymond (eds), Christ Church deeds (Dublin, 2001), no. 468Google Scholar; Gwynn, & Hadcock, , Med. relig. houses, Ire., p. 327Google Scholar.
63 Lennox Barrow, G., ‘The Knights Hospitaller of St John of Jerusalem at Kilmainham’ in Dublin Hist. Rec., xxxviii (1984–5), p. 109Google Scholar.
64 Lord, Evelyn, The Knights Templar in Britain (Harlow, 2001), p. 138Google Scholar; Nolan, Tom, ‘The Knights Templar and the houses of South East Ireland’ in Decies, xiv (1980), p. 52Google Scholar; Gwynn, & Hadcock, , Med. relig. houses, Ire., p. 330Google Scholar.
65 Matthew, Donald, Britain and the Continent, 1000–1300 (London, 2005), p. 204Google Scholar.
66 A.U., ii, 279; despite sharing a common core, the Annals of Loch Cé does not include this information.
67 Cotton, Henry (ed.), Fasti Ecclesiae Hibernicae: the succession of prelates and members of the cathedral bodies in Ireland (5 vols, Dublin, 1845–78), i, 118Google Scholar.
68 A.F. M., iii, 215.
69 Freeman, (ed.), Annals of Connacht, p. 43Google Scholar; A.L.C., p. 309.
70 Hurlock, Kathryn, ‘Crusades and crusading in the Welsh annalistic chronicles’ in Trivium Occasional Series, no. 5 (2009), pp 14–16Google Scholar.
71 Gilbert, (ed.), Pembridge’s Annals, p. 312Google Scholar.
72 Gwynn, , ‘Black Book of Christ Church’, p. 331Google Scholar.
73 Smith, (ed.), Annales de Monte Fernandi, p. 12Google Scholar.
74 Williams, , Annals of Ire., p. 141Google Scholar.
75 Smith, (ed.), Annales de Monte Fernandi, p. 14Google Scholar.
76 Airt, Mac (ed.), Annals of Inisfallen, p. 353Google Scholar.
77 Freeman, (ed.), Annals of Connacht, pp 97, 111Google Scholar.
78 Murphy, Denis (ed.), The Annals of Clonmacnoise (Dublin, 1896), p. 249Google Scholar; A.U., vol. ii, p. 347; Airt, Mac (ed.), Annals of Inisfallen, p. 371Google Scholar (which dates his death to 1271, but are the only annals to say, incorrectly, that he died in the Holy Land); Freeman, (ed.), Annals of Connacht, p. 157Google Scholar; Gwynn, , ‘Black Book of Christ Church’, p. 332Google Scholar.
79 Meek, Christine, ‘Beyond the frontier: Irish men and Irish goods in Lucca in the later Middle Ages’ in Barry, Frame & Simms (eds), Colony & frontier in med. Ire., pp 229–30Google Scholar; Sheehy, Maurice P. (ed.), Pontificia Hibernica: medieval papal chancery documents concerning Ireland, 640–1261 (2 vols, Dublin, 1965), i, 243Google Scholar; Lloyd, Simon, English society and the crusade, 1216–1307 (Oxford, 1988), p. 92Google Scholar.
80 Sheehy, (ed.), Pontificia Hib., ii, 253Google Scholar.
81 Ithel, John Williams ab (ed.), Annales Cambriae (London, 1860), p. 88Google Scholar; a chronicle from the Cistercian abbey of Neath, NRA E.164.1, published as ‘Chronicle of the thirteenth century’ in Archæologia Cambrensis, 8 (1862), p. 282.
82 Murray, Denis (ed.), The Annales of Clonmacnoise, being Annals of Ireland from the earliest period to a.d. 1408 (Dublin, 1896), p. 249Google Scholar.
83 Airt, Mac (ed.), Annals of Inisfallen, p. 371Google Scholar.
84 Grace, , Kilkenniensis, Annales Hiberniae, p. 37Google Scholar; Hartland, Beth, ‘Vaucouleurs, Ludlow and Trim: the role of Ireland in the career of Geoffrey de Geneville (c. 1226–1314)’ in I.H.S., xxxii, no. 128 (2001), pp 457–77Google Scholar.
85 Gilbert, (ed.), Pembridge’s Annals, p. 317Google Scholar.
86 Williams, , Annals of Ire., p. 207Google Scholar; Smith, (ed.), Annales de Monte Fernandi, pp 15–16Google Scholar.
87 Irish landholders who joined the crusading force of 1270–2 included Rolly, Hubert de, Alditeleg, James de, Baskerville, John de, Fifhide, John de, Verdun, John de, Crok, Nicholas, Afton, Richard de, Rokele, Richard de la, Ufford, Robert de, Clare, Thomas de and FitzWarin, William: Lloyd, English society, pp 262–77Google Scholar.
88 Hurlock, , ‘Crusades & crusading’, pp 17–18, 25Google Scholar.
89 Lydon, James, ‘The years of crisis, 1254–1315’ in Cosgrove, A. (ed.), A new history of Ireland, ii: medieval Ireland, 1169–1534 (Oxford, 1987), pp 181–2Google Scholar.
90 The chronicle of Walter of Guisborough, ed. Harry Rothwell, Camden Society, 3rd series, lxxxix (1957), pp 272, 279.
91 Gilbert, (ed.), Pembridge’s Annals, pp 319–21Google Scholar.
92 Hartland, Beth, ‘The household knights of Edward I in Ireland’ in Historical Research, xxii (2004), p. 165Google Scholar.
93 Williams, , Annals of Ire., pp 152–3Google Scholar.
94 Flower, , ‘Manuscripts’, p. 332Google Scholar.
95 Williams, , Annals of Ire., pp 142–3Google Scholar; Flower, , ‘Manuscripts’, p. 332.Google Scholar
96 Smith, (ed.), Annales de Monte Fernandi, pp 11, 14Google Scholar; Williams, , Annals of Ire., pp 146–8Google Scholar; A.U., ii, 339.
97 For a discussion of the crusading nature of these wars, see Lloyd, Simon, ‘“Political Crusades” in England, c. 1215–17 and c.1263–5’ in Edbury, P. W. (ed.), Crusade and settlement: papers read at the first conference of the Society for the Study of the Crusades and the Latin East and presented to R.C. Smail (Cardiff, 1985), pp 113-17Google Scholar.
98 Frame, Robin, ‘Ireland and the Barons’ Wars’ in Coss, P. R. and Lloyd, S. D. (eds), Thirteenth-century England: I: proceedings of the Newcastle upon Tyne conference 1985 (Woodbridge, 1986), p. 159Google Scholar; Luard, H. L. (ed.), Annales Monastici (5 vols, London, 1864–9), ii, 365Google Scholar.
99 Maddicott, J. R., Simon de Montfort (Cambridge, 1994), pp 91–3Google Scholar.
100 For the Welsh example, see Hurlock, , ‘Crusades & crusading’, pp 18–20Google Scholar.
101 Grace, , Kilkenniensis, Annales Hiberniae, p. 41Google Scholar; Gilbert, (ed.), Pembridge’s Annals, p. 320Google Scholar.
102 Sheehy, (ed.), Pontificia Hib., ii, 52, 65Google Scholar.
103 Ibid., ii, 106, 149.
104 Ibid., i, 201.
105 Dowling, Thadeus, Annales Breves Hiberniae (Short annals of Ireland) (Dublin, 1849), p. 15Google Scholar.
106 Pipard, Gilbert and Bertram, III de Verdon died on the Third Crusade; see B. Smith, Colonisation and conquest in medieval Ireland: the English in Louth, 1170–1330 (Cambridge, 1999), pp 30–1Google Scholar; Hagger, M. S., The fortunes of a Norman family: the de Verduns in England, Ireland and Wales, 1066–1316 (Oxford, 1987), pp 56–7Google Scholar.
107 Sheehy, (ed.), Pontificia Hib., i, 158–9Google Scholar.
108 Gransden, Antonia, Historical writing in England c. 550 to c. 1307 (London, 1996), p. 329Google Scholar.
109 For an attempt to reconstruct these lost annals, and a comparison of common elements in the texts that used it as a source, see Gywnn, , ‘Black Book of Christ Church Dublin’, pp 329–33Google Scholar.
110 Ibid., pp 52, 65; FitzMaurice, E. B. and Little, A. G. (ed.), Materials for the history of the Franciscan province of Ireland, a.d. 1230–1450 (Manchester, 1920), p. 39Google Scholar.
111 Cole, Penny J., The preaching of the Crusades to the Holy Land, 1095–1270 (Cambridge, 1991), pp 161–2Google Scholar.
112 Sheehy, (ed.), Pontificia Hib., ii, 151; Christopher T. Maier, Preaching the Crusades: mendicant friars and the Cross in the thirteenth century (Cambridge, 1994), p. 71Google Scholar.
113 Maier, , Preaching the Crusades, p. 94Google Scholar.
114 FitzMaurice, & Little, (eds.), Materials for the history of the Franciscan province, p. 23Google Scholar.
115 Stephenson, Joseph (ed.), Chronicon de Lanercost MCCI–MCCCXLVI (Edinburgh, 1839), p. 48Google Scholar; B. L. Cott. MS Claudius D VIII, f. 123v.
116 Triveti, Nicholas, Annales Sex Regum Angliae, ed. Thomas Hog (London, 1845), pp 88, 92, 103, 109, 111, 147, 176, 234, 272, 413.Google Scholar
117 Costello, , ‘Ireland & the Holy Land’, p. 271Google Scholar.
118 B. W., O’Dwyer, ‘The impact of the native Irish on the Cistercians in the thirteenth century’ in Jn. of Religious History, iv (1967), pp 290–2Google Scholar; Néill, Ó, ‘Impact’, p. 179Google Scholar.
119 Taylor, Claire, ‘The letter of Héribert of Périgord as a source for dualist heresy in the society of early eleventh-century Aquitaine’ in Jn. of Medieval History, xxvi (2000), pp 313–49CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Vincent, Nicholas, ‘England and the Albigensian Crusade’ in Weiler, B. with Rowland, I. W. (eds), England and Europe in the reign of Henry III (Aldershot, 2002), p. 68Google Scholar.
120 Gwynn, , ‘Black Book of Christ Church Dublin’, p. 315Google Scholar.
121 Williams, , ‘Kilkenny Chronicle’, p. 81Google Scholar.
122 Flower, , ‘Manuscripts’, pp 334–5Google Scholar;Williams, , ‘Kilkenny Chronicle’, p. 80, n. 31.Google Scholar
123 Hurlock, , ‘Crusades & crusading’, pp 14–16, 25–6Google Scholar.
124 Murphy, Gerard, ‘Two Irish poems written from the Mediterranean in the thirteenth century’ in Éigse, vii (1953–5), p. 71Google Scholar.
125 Thomson, Derick S., ‘The Macmhuirich bardic family’ in Trans. Gaelic Society of Inverness, xliii (1960–3), p. 278Google Scholar.
126 Clanchy, Thomas Owen (ed.), The triumph tree: Scotland’s earliest poetry, ad 550–1350 (Edinburgh, 1998), pp 268-70Google Scholar.
127 Ibid., pp 271–4.
128 Joinville, Jean de, The Life of St. Louis, ed. Rene Hague (New York, 1958).Google Scholar
129 Tyerman, Christopher, England and the Crusades, 1095–1588 (Chicago, 1988), pp 246-52Google Scholar.
130 Cardini, Franco, Europe and Islam (Oxford, 2001), pp 117-31Google Scholar.
131 Ekin, Des, The stolen village: Baltimore and the Barbary pirates (Dublin, 2006)Google Scholar; Appleby, J. C., ‘Settlers and pirates in early seventeenth-century Ireland: a profile of Sir William Hill’ in Studia Hib., xxv (1990), pp 76–104Google Scholar.
132 Hyde, Douglas (ed.), Gabháltais Shéarluis Mhóir: the conquests of Charlemagne (Irish Texts Society, Dublin, 1919), pp v–vi.Google Scholar
133 Costello, , Ireland, p. 58Google Scholar; [Fitzgerald, C. W.], marquis of Kildare [duke of Leinster], The earls of Kildare and their ancestors: from 1053 to 1773 (Dublin, 1858), pp 327-30Google Scholar.
134 Constable, Giles, ‘The historiography of the Crusades’ in Laiou, Angeliki E. and Mottahedah, Roy Parviz, The Crusades from the perspective of Byzantium and the Muslim world (Washington D.C., 2001), p. 6Google Scholar.
135 A.F. M., v, 1632.
136 Ibid., pp 1870–71; Boyle, Alexander, ‘Fearghal Ó Gadhra and the Four Masters’ in I.E.R., 5th series, C (July–Dec. 1963), pp 100–14Google Scholar.
137 Simms, , Med. Gaelic sources, p. 31Google Scholar.
138 Duffy, Seán, ‘Ireland and Scotland, 1014–1169: contacts and caveats’ in Smyth, Alfred P. (ed.), Seanchas: studies in early and medieval Irish archaeology, history and literature in honour of Francis Byrne, J. (Dublin, 2000), p. 348Google Scholar.
139 Simms, , Med. Gaelic sources, p. 32Google Scholar.
140 Duffy, , ‘Ireland & Scotland’, pp 348, 351Google Scholar.
141 Richter, Michael, ‘The European dimension in Irish history in the eleventh and twelfth centuries’ in Peritia, iv (1985), p. 330Google Scholar.
You have
Access
