Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-p2v8j Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-30T22:16:09.834Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Ireland and the Black Atlantic in the eighteenth century

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  21 March 2016

Nini Rodgers
Nini Rodgers*
Affiliation:
School of Modern History, Queen’s University of Belfast
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In the second half of the twentieth century few subjects have excited more extensive historical debate in the western world than black slavery. American investigation has centred upon the actual operation of the institution. An impressively wide range of historical techniques, cliometrics, comparative history, cultural studies, the imagination of the novelist, have all been employed in a vigorous attempt to recover and evaluate the slave past. In Britain, the first great power to abolish the Atlantic trade and emancipate her slaves, the emphasis has been on the development of the anti-slavery movement, described by W. E. H. Lecky in 1869 as ‘a crusade’ to be rated ‘amongst the three or four perfectly virtuous pages comprised in the history of nations’, and therefore an obvious candidate for twentieth-century revision. Any discussion of black slavery in the New World immediately involves the historian in economic matters. Here the nineteenth-century orthodoxy launched by Adam Smith and developed by J. S. Mill and his friend J. E. Cairnes, author of The slave power (1862) and professor of political economy and jurisprudence in Queen’s College, Galway, saw slavery as both morally wrong and economically unsound, an anachronism in the modern world. Since the 1970s this view has been challenged head-on by American historians arguing that, however morally repugnant, slavery was a dynamic system, an engine of economic progress in the U.S.A. Such a thesis inevitably revives some of the arguments used by the nineteenth-century defenders of slavery and has equally inevitably attracted bitter anti-revisionist denunciation.

Type
Research Article
Information
Irish Historical Studies , Volume 32 , Issue 126 , November 2000 , pp. 174 - 192
Copyright
Copyright © Irish Historical Studies Publications Ltd 2000

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1 Lecky, W.E.H., A history of European morals (6th ed., 2 vols, London, 1884), ii, 153Google Scholar.

2 Cairnes, J.E., The slave power: its character, career and probable designs (London, 1862)Google Scholar; Davis, D.B., Slavery and human progress (Oxford, 1984), p. 244Google Scholar.

3 Fogel, R.W. and Engerman, S.L., Time on the cross (2 vols, Boston, 1974)Google Scholar.

4 Parish, P.J., Slavery, history and the historians (New York, 1989)Google Scholar.

5 Williams, Eric, Capitalism and slavery (London, 1964), pp 178-96, 98-106Google Scholar; Anstey, R.T., ‘Capitalism and slavery: a critique’ in Econ. Hist. Rev., xxi (1968), pp 307-20CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Drescher, Seymour, Capitalism and antislavery (Basingstoke, 1986), pp 67–88,111-34CrossRefGoogle Scholar; O’Brien, P.K., ‘European economic development and the contribution of the periphery’ in Econ. Hist. Rev., xxxv (1982), p. 7Google Scholar; Blackburn, Robin, The making of New World slavery: from the baroque to the modern, 1492-1800 (London, 1997), pp 510-73Google Scholar.

6 Richardson, David, ‘The British Empire and the Atlantic slave trade, 1660-1807’ in Marshall, P.J. (ed.), The Oxford history of the British Empire, ii: The eighteenth century (Oxford, 1998), p. 446Google Scholar.

7 Gross, Izhak, ‘The abolition of negro slavery and British parliamentary politics, 1832-3’ in Hist. Jn., xxiii (1980), pp 77-8Google Scholar; Riach, D.C., ‘Daniel O’Connell and American anti-slavery’ in I.H.S., xx, no. 77 (Mar. 1976), pp 3–25Google Scholar; idem, O’Connell and slavery’ in Donal McCartney (ed.), The world of Daniel O’Connell (Dublin, 1980), pp 175-85.

8 Williams, J.J., Whence the ‘black Irish’ of Jamaica? (New York, 1932)Google Scholar; Gwynn, Aubrey, ‘Early Irish emigration to the West Indies, 1612-43’ in Studies, xviii (1929), pp 377-93, 648-63Google Scholar; idem, ‘Indentured servants and negro slaves in the Barbadoes, 1642-1650’ in Studies, xix (1930), pp 279-94; idem, ‘Documents relating to the Irish in the West Indies, 1612-1752’ in Anal. Hib., iv (1932), pp 139-286; Beckles, H.McD., ‘A “riotous and unruly lot”: Irish indentured servants and freemen in the English West Indies, 1644-1713’ in William & Mary Quart, xlvii (1990), pp 503-22CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Cullen, L.M., ‘Galway merchants in the outside world, 1650-1800’ in Cearbhaill, Diarmuid Ó (ed.), Galway: town and gown, 1484-1984 (Galway, 1984), pp 63–89Google Scholar; Akenson, D.H., If the Irish ran the world: Montserrat, 1630-1730 (Liverpool, 1997)Google Scholar; Harvey, Karen, The Bellews of Mount Bellew (Dublin, 1998), pp 115-22Google Scholar; Ignatiev, Noel, How the Irish became white (New York, 1996)Google Scholar; Man, A.P. jr, ‘The Irish in New York in the early eighteen-sixties’ in I.H.S., vii, no. 26 (Sept. 1950), pp 87–108Google Scholar; Wilson, D.A., United Irishmen, United States: immigrant radicals in the early republic (Dublin, 1998), pp 133-41Google Scholar: Clark, Dennis, The Irish relations: trials of an immigrant tradition (London, 1982), pp 143-58Google Scholar; Kelly, Brian, ‘Ambiguous loyalties: the Boston Irish, slavery and the American Civil War’ in Historical Journal of Massachusetts, xxiv (1996), pp 165–204Google Scholar.

9 Truxes, T.M., Irish-American trade, 1660-1783 (Cambridge, 1988), app. 11. A. 1: ‘Exports of Irish beef (in barrels)’, pp 262-3Google Scholar. Truxes’s figures are taken from the import and export ledgers of the Irish Customs Revenue Commissioners (P.R.O., CUST 15). In 1730 France took 67, 730 barrels of beef, while Britain’s American colonies took 57,053. (West Indies and mainland colonies are not recorded separately, but the mainland colonies produced their own foodstuffs and had little interest in Irish imports.) The next most important customer was Spain with 11,420 barrels. In 1750 France took 77,884 barrels, British American colonies 43,155, and Spain 14,607.

10 Truxes, Irish-American trade, p. 154.

11 Dickson, David, ‘Butter comes to the market: the origins of commercial dairying in County Cork’ in O’Flanagan, Patrick and Buttimer, C.G. (eds), Cork: history and society (Dublin, 1993), pp 368, 371Google Scholar.

12 Thomas Mark to Charles O’Hara, 13 Mar., 1778 (P.R.O.N.I., O’Hara papers, T/2812/17/5); Parl. reg. Ire., i (1781), p. 81.

13 Maxwell, Constantia, Country and town in Ireland under the Georges (London, 1940), p. 235Google Scholar, quoted in Wall, Maureen, ‘The rise of the Catholic middle class in eighteenth-century Ireland’ in I.H.S., xi, no. 42 (Sept. 1958), p. 102Google Scholar.

14 Faulkner’s Dublin Journal, 27-30 Nov. 1784.

15 Rodgers, Nini, ‘Equiano in Belfast: a study of the anti-slavery ethos in a northern town’ in Slavery and Abolition, xviii (1997), pp 82-4Google Scholar.

16 [Wall], Maureen MacGeehin, ‘The Catholics in the towns and the quarterage dispute in eighteenth-century Ireland’ in I.H.S., viii, no. 30 (Sept. 1952), pp 101-3Google Scholar.

17 Lenihan, Maurice, Limerick: its history and antiquities (Dublin, 1866), pp 398-9Google Scholar; Edwards, Robin Dudley (ed.), ‘The minute book of the Catholic Committee, 1773-93’ in Archiv. Hib., ix (1942), p. 45Google Scholar.

18 Rodgers, ‘Equiano in Belfast’, p. 81.

19 Truxes, Irish-American trade, p. 228

20 Tuama, Seán Ó (ed.) and Kinsella, Thomas (trans.), An duanaire, 1600-1900: poems of the dispossessed (Mountrath, Portlaoise, 1981), p. 235Google Scholar.

21 Foy, Michael, The sugar industry in Ireland (Dublin, 1976), p. 8Google Scholar; Strain, R.M.W., Belfast and its Charitable Society: a study of urban social development (London, 1961), p. 63Google Scholar.

22 Truxes, Irish-American trade, p. 228.

23 Bartlett, Thomas, ‘Viscount Townshend and the Irish Revenue Board, 1767-73’ in R.I.A. Proc., lxxix (1979), sect. C, pp 153-75Google Scholar.

24 Lammey, David, ‘A study of Anglo-Irish relations between 1772 and 1782, with particular reference to the “free trade” movement’ (unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Queen’s University Belfast, 1984), pp 151-2Google Scholar.

25 Ibid., p. 204.

26 Cullen, L.M., ‘Economic development, 1750-1800’ in Moody, T.W. and Vaughan, W.E. (eds), A new history of Ireland, iv: Eighteenth-century Ireland, 1691-1800 (Oxford, 1986), p. 182Google Scholar; Cullen, L.M., ‘The Dublin merchant community’ in Butel, Paul and Cullen, L.M. (eds), Cities and merchants: French and Irish perspectives on urban development, 1500-1800 (Dublin, 1986), p. 197Google Scholar.

27 Petition of the merchants and traders of the city of Dublin concerned with the importation and refining of sugars, 30 Nov. 1765 (P.R.O.N.I., T/1060/9/3868).

28 Edward Byrne and John Sutton to John Foster, 11 Jan. 1780 (ibid., Foster-Massereene papers, D/562/8398); Messrs Stewart, Thompson, Bateson, Cunningham, Sinclair and Lewis to Foster, 19 Jan. 1780 (ibid., D/562/8440).

29 Lammey, ‘Free trade’, p. 272.

30 Petition from the sugar refiners of the city of Dublin, [May?] 1780 (P.R.O.N.I., D/562/8416A); allegations of the merchants and refiners of Ireland relative to the sugar business, 1780 (ibid., D/562/8420).

31 Advice on the sugar business (Dublin, 1780), repr. in Jebb, Frederick, Thoughts of the discontents of the people last year respecting the sugar duties (Dublin, 1781), app. vi, pp 51–61Google Scholar.

32 Lammey, ‘Free trade’, p. 274.

33 Ibid., pp 275-8; Callen, R.V., ‘The structure of Anglo-Irish politics during the American Revolution: Sir Henry Cavendish’s diary of the Irish parliament, October 12, 1779 to September 2, 1780; edition of the partial text and critical essay’ (2 vols, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Notre Dame, 1973), ii, 193–200Google Scholar.

34 Lammey, ‘Free trade’, pp 79-80.

35 Jebb, Sugar duties, app. i, pp 43-5.

36 Ibid., apps ii-iii, pp 46-7.

37 Ibid., app. iv, p. 48.

38 Hibernian Magazine, 1781, p. 99; Callen, ‘Cavendish diary’, ii, 283.

39 Jebb, Sugar duties, app. v, pp 49-51.

40 Callen, ‘Cavendish diary’, ii, 281.

41 Jebb, Sugar duties, pp 30-32.

42 Ibid., pp 6-7.

43 The pamphlet condemns ‘the licentious practice of publishing the opinions and resolutions of private men, in direct and seditious contradiction of the judgement of parliament on the same subject’ (ibid., p. 11). But curiously in apps i-v, pp 43-51, Jebb goes on to do this himself, producing in full the resolutions published by the Dublin merchants and traders, the three Volunteer companies and the refiners in August 1780.

44 Parl. reg. Ire., i (1781), pp 15, 18.

45 Ibid., pp 34-7.

46 Ibid., p. 81.

47 Between 9 October and 23 November 1781 there were five divisions over sugar, in all of which the administration recorded substantial, but varying, majorities: 111 to 43 (ibid., p. 37), 155 to 49 (ibid., p. 44), 105 to 54 (ibid., p. 70), 79 to 47 (ibid., p. 76), and 144 to 63 (ibid., p. 105). The attempt to repeal the mutiny act caused two divisions within the same period: 117 to 44 (ibid., p. 30) and 133 to 71 (ibid., p. 68). The number of divisions reflects the fact that a great deal more time was spent on debating sugar. The same pattern emerges if a comparison is made with the other important issue aired in this period, the trade problem with Portugal over the export of Irish wool.

48 Ibid., pp 105-25.

49 Ibid., iii (1783), p. 83; Lammey, ‘Free trade’, p. 282.

50 Parl. reg. Ire., i (1781), pp 15, 100-5, 111; Callen, ‘Cavendish diary’, ii, 194-6.

51 Parl. reg. Ire., i (1781), pp 83, 87; Callen, ‘Cavendish diary’, ii, 193, 270.

52 Parl. reg. Ire., i (1781), p. 7; ibid., iii (1783), p. 138.

53 Ibid., i (1781), p. 92; Faulkner’s Dublin Journal, 1-3 Sept. 1791.

54 Hibernian Magazine, 1781, p. 112.

55 Belfast News-Letter, 11 Jan., 1 Feb., 16 Sept. 1785.

56 Hibernian Magazine, 1781, pp 55, 168; Parl. reg. Ire., iii (1783), p. 74.

57 Petition of the merchants and traders of the city of Dublin concerned with the importation and refining of sugars, 30 Nov. 1765 (P.R.O.N.I., T/1060/9/3868); Watson’s Dublin directory, or the gentleman’s and citizen’s almanack, 1765 (Dublin, 1765).

58 Petition from the sugar refiners of the city of Dublin, [May?] 1780 (P.R.O.N.I., D/562/8416A). The names listed in order were Edward Byrne, Thomas Sherlock, Patrick Long, Joseph Green, John Maquay, John Sutton, Peter Galan, Andrew Maziere, Peter Canier, Patrick Sweetman, Garrett Geoghan, John Taurow, Samuel Collins, John Green, George Maquay, John Nairic, John Canier, John Maryland, John Byrne, Bartholomew Maziere, Patrick Kavanagh, John McMahon, John Morain, William Field, Samuel Canier, William Sweetman, Thomas Nowlan, Elias Tardy (Edwards, ‘Catholic Committee minute book’, pp 3-89).

59 Gilbert, J.T., A history of the city of Dublin (3 vols, Dublin, 1854-9), i, 354-5Google Scholar; Wall, ‘Catholic middle class’, pp 107-8.

60 The life of Theobald Wolfe Tone, compiled and arranged by William Theobald Wolfe Tone, ed. Bartlett, Thomas (Dublin, 1998), p. 235Google Scholar.

61 Edwards (ed.), ‘Catholic Committee minute book’, p. 45.

62 Ibid., pp 137-40; Bartlett, Thomas, The fall and rise of the Irish nation: the Catholic question, 1690-1830 (Dublin, 1992), p. 129Google Scholar.

63 Edwards (ed), ‘Catholic Committee minute book’, p. 144.

64 Tone, Life, ed. Bartlett, pp 47, 52.

65 Ibid., pp 65,71.

66 Bartlett, Fall & rise, p. 203.

67 Tone, Life, ed. Bartlett, pp 205-6.

68 Ibid., pp 152, 157.

69 Ibid., pp 173, 200.

70 Harvey, Bellews, pp 129, 169-70.

71 Ibid., pp 119-21.

72 Ibid., p. 169. Cf. ‘The crisis is arrived when we must assert our rights or submit to every imposition that can be heaped upon us, till custom and use shall make us as tame and abject slaves, as the blacks we rule over with such arbitrary sway’ (Washington, George, 1774, quoted in Christie, I.R., Crisis of Empire: Great Britain and the American colonies, 1754-83 (London, 1966), p. 91Google Scholar).

73 Truxes, Irish-American trade, pp 18, 98; Harvey, Bellews, pp 116-19.

74 Jebb, Sugar duties, pp 29-31.

75 Faulkner’s Dublin Journal, 27-30 Nov. 1784.

76 Riach, D.C., ‘Ireland and the campaign against American slavery, 1830-1860’ (unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Edinburgh, 1975), p. 17Google Scholar.

77 Harrison, R.S., Cork city Quakers, 1655-1939 (Cork, 1991), p. 17Google Scholar.

78 Riach, ‘Ireland & the campaign against American slavery’, pp 12-14.

79 Chart, D.A. (ed.), The Drennan letters: being a selection from the correspondence which passed between William Drennan and his brother-in-law and sister, Samuel and Martha McTier, during the years 1776-1819 (Belfast, 1931), p. 361Google Scholar; Cullen, L.M., Princes and pirates: the Dublin Chamber of Commerce, 1783-1983 (Dublin, 1983), p. 54Google Scholar.

80 Dublin Chronicle, 16-18 June 1789.

81 S.K., A short but particular and impartial account of the treatment of slaves in the island of Antigua (Cork, 1789), pp v-viGoogle Scholar. The pamphlet is dedicated to ‘the nobility and gentry and the liberal minded in general of the county and city of Cork’.

82 Ibid., pp vii, 47, 49, 52, 62.

83 Equiano, O1audah, The interesting narrative and other writings, ed. Carretta, Vincent (London & New York, 1995), p. 345Google Scholar; Tillyard, Stella, Citizen lord: Edward Fitzgerald, 1763-1798 (London, 1998), p. 131Google Scholar.

84 Equiano, Interesting narrative, ed. Carretta, pp 25-6.

85 O’Neill, Kevin, ‘Mary Shackleton Leadbeater: peaceful rebel’ in Keogh, Dáire and Furlong, Nicholas (eds), The women of 1798 (Dublin, 1998), pp 150-52Google Scholar; An address to the people of Great Britain, on the propriety of abstaining from West India sugar and rum (London, 1791; repr., Dublin, 1792).

86 Considerations addressed to the professors of Christianity of every denomination on the impropriety of consuming West Indian sugar and rum as produced by the oppressive labour of slaves (Dublin, 1792); An essay on the slave trade: enumerating its horrors, and stressing the vice of encouraging it by the consumption of West Indian productions, and also showing the certainty of its abolition by the disuse of them (Cork, 1792).

87 Midgley, Clare, Women against slavery: the British campaign, 1780-1870 (London, 1995), p. 34Google Scholar; Kitson, Peter J. and Lee, Debbie (eds), Slavery, abolition and emancipation (8 vols, London, 1999), iv, 196Google Scholar.

88 Rodgers, Nini, ‘Two Quakers and a utilitarian: the reaction of three Irish women writers to the problem of slavery, 1789-1807’ in R.I.A. Proc., c (2000), sect. C, pp 137-57Google Scholar.

89 The purrings of the city mowzers of Napper, escaped from the man-trap: a civic eclogue exhibiting a choice scrap of tea-table scandal between Tabby, a Cherokee, and other illustrious individuals (Dublin, 1792), pp 3-4.

90 Mullalla, James, Compilation on the slave trade, respectfully addressed to the people of Ireland (Dublin, 1792), p. 17Google Scholar.

91 Ibid., pp 26-7.

92 Chart (ed.), Drennan letters, p. 51.

93 Rodgers, , ‘Equiano in Belfast’, p. 79; An English country gentleman’s advice to the Irish members of the imperial parliament on the subject of the slave trade (London, 1802), p. 75Google Scholar.

94 Clarkson, Thomas, The history of the rise, progress and accomplishment of the abolition of the African slave trade by the British parliament (2 vols, London, 1808), ii, 490Google Scholar.

95 Riach, ‘Ireland & the campaign against American slavery’, pp 34, 36, 56.

96 Ibid., p.35.

97 Truxes, Irish-American trade, p. 72.

98 Lenihan, Limerick, p. 399.

99 Lammey, ‘Free trade’, p. 174; Stephen Roche to Charles O’Hara, 13 Mar. 1778 (P.R.O.N.I., T/2812/17/7).